Studies on the mechanism of retinoid-induced pattern duplications in the early chick limb bud: temporal and spatial aspects

All-trans-retinoic acid causes striking digit pattern changes when it is continuously released from a bead implanted in the anterior margin of an early chick wing bud. In addition to the normal set of digits (234), extra digits form in a mirror-symmetrical arrangement, creating digit patterns such as a 432234. These retinoic acid-induced pattern duplications closely mimic those found after grafts of polarizing region cells to the same positions with regard to dose-response, timing, and positional effects. To elucidate the mechanism by which retinoic acid induces these pattern duplications, we have studied the temporal and spatial distribution of all-trans-retinoic acid and its potent analogue TTNPB in these limb buds. We find that the induction process is biphasic: there is an 8-h lag phase followed by a 6-h duplication phase, during which additional digits are irreversibly specified in the sequence digit 2, digit 3, digit 4. On average, formation of each digit seems to require between 1 and 2 h. The tissue concentrations, metabolic pattern, and spatial distribution of all- trans-retinoic acid and TTNPB in the limb rapidly reach a steady state, in which the continuous release of the retinoid is balanced by loss from metabolism and blood circulation. Pulse-chase experiments reveal that the half-time of clearance from the bud is 20 min for all-trans- retinoic acid and 80 min for TTNPB. Manipulations that change the experimentally induced steep concentration gradient of TTNPB suggest that a graded distribution of retinoid concentrations across the limb is required during the duplication phase to induce changes in the digit pattern. The extensive similarities between results obtained with retinoids and with polarizing region grafts raise the possibility that retinoic acid serves as a natural "morphogen" in the limb.     

Distribution of Retinoids Applied Exogenously to Chick Limb Buds: an Autoradiographic Analysis

An autoradiographic analysis was undertaken to examine the localization of retinoids applied exogenously to chick limb buds. Ion-exchange beads (AGI-X2) containing a tritium-labeled synthetic retinoid, Am80, were implanted to various regions of chick wing buds. This synthetic retinoid is known to induce a duplicated limb pattern as retinoic acid (RA) does. One to 24 hours after the application, wing buds were fixed, sectioned, and prepared for autoradiography. Heavy labeling was observed in the peripheral region of the wing mesoderm, but no gradient along the antero-posterior axis was found.
These results suggest that the peripheral region of the limb bud may be important for the morphogenetic function of RA. Tissue-bound retinoids may not form an antero-posterior concentration gradient when retinoids are added to the anterior margin of the chick limb bud.     

Retinoic acid application to chick wing buds leads to a dose-dependent reorganization of the apical ectodermal ridge that is mediated by the mesenchyme

Local application of retinoic acid to wing buds of chick embryos leads to dose- and position-dependent changes in the pattern of cellular differentiation. Early effects of retinoid treatment on the apical ectodermal ridge coordinate pattern changes and morphogenesis. The length of the apical ridge increases when additional digits will form but decreases when digits are lost. These changes in length can be understood in terms of a threshold response to the local retinoid concentration that results in either disappearance or maintenance of the ridge (Lee & Tickle, J. Embryol. exp. Morph. 90, 139-169 (1985)). Here, we have analysed the mechanisms involved in ridge disappearance by locally applying retinoic acid to the apex of stage 20 chick wing buds. With this treatment regime, low doses give duplicated digit patterns and higher doses truncations. The height of the apical ridge is progressively reduced with increasing doses of retinoid and the time course of ridge flattening indicates that the height of the ridge is correlated with bud outgrowth. With high doses of retinoic acid, the typical ridge, a pseudostratified epithelium in which the columnar cells are tightly packed, disappears and the epithelium at the tip of the bud consists of loosely packed cuboidal cells. Shortly after treatment, there is a decrease in the number of gap junctions between ridge cells. This early change in cell contacts suggests that gap junctions may be involved in maintaining epithelial morphology. When treated epithelium is recombined with untreated mesenchyme, an apical ridge is reestablished and distal structures can be generated. In contrast, when treated mesenchyme is recombined with the epithelium from normal buds, only proximal structures are formed. Therefore, retinoids can lead to a reorganization of the apical ectodermal ridge which is mediated and maintained by the mesenchyme.     

Characterization of concentration gradients of a morphogenetically active retinoid in the chick limb bud

It has long been suggested that the generation of biological patterns depends in part on gradients of diffusible substances. In an attempt to bridge the gap between this largely theoretical concept and experimental embryology, we have examined the physiology of diffusion gradients in an actual embryonic field. In particular, we have generated in the chick wing bud concentration gradients of the morphogenetically active retinoid TTNPB, (E)-4-[2-(5,6,7,8-tetrahydro-5,5,8,8-tetramethyl-2-naphthalenyl)-1-prope nyl] benzoic acid, a synthetic vitamin A compound. Upon local application of TTNPB the normal 234 digit pattern is duplicated in a way that correlates with the geometry of the underlying TTNPB gradient; low doses of TTNPB lead to a shallow gradient and an additional digit 2, whereas higher doses result in a steep, far-reaching gradient and patterns with additional digits 3 and 4. The experimentally measured TTNPB distribution along the anteroposterior axis, can be modeled by a local source and a dispersed sink. This model correctly predicts the site of specification of digit 2, and provides an empirical estimate of the diffusion coefficient (D) of retinoids in embryonic limb tissue. The numerical value of approximately 10(-7) cm2s-1 for D suggests that retinoids are not freely diffusible in the limb rudiment, but interact with the previously identified cellular retinoic acid binding protein. In addition, D affords an estimate of the time required to establish a diffusion gradient as 3 to 4 h. This time span is in a range compatible with the time scale of pattern specification in developing vertebrate limbs. Our studies support the view that diffusion of morphogenetic substances is a plausible mechanism of pattern formation in secondary embryonic fields.     

Spatial analysis of limb bud myogenesis: Elaboration of the proximodistal gradient of myoblasts requires the continuing presence of apical ectodermal ridge

Myogenic tissue from embryonic chick wing and leg buds is composed of several subpopulations of myoblasts. These clonally distinct subpopulations first appear at different developmental stages, and are distributed differently along the proximo-distal axis of the buds, giving the appearance of a gradient of myoblast cell types. This myoblast distribution pattern has been utilized to investigate the dependence of muscle tissue outgrowth and development on the presence of the apical ectodermal ridge (AER). Wing buds which have had the AER removed at stages 17–18 (2 days) subsequently develop normal proximal regions, but fail to elaborate skeletal structures distal to the humerus. The myoblast pattern of operated buds is also normal proximally, but distal portions of the pattern are not observed. Removal of the AER at stage 20 (3 days) results in buds which develop slightly more distal skeletal structures and the coinciding portions of the myoblast pattern, but in which the more distal portions of the normal myoblast gradient are truncated. These data suggest that elaboration of the myogenic pattern in early limb buds is dependent on the continuing presence of the AER, and that early removal of the AER leads to the subsequent cessation of myoblast pattern specification.     

Evaluation of the sensitive step of inhibition of chondrogenesis by retinoids in limb mesenchymal cells in vitro

The sensitive step of inhibition of chondrogenesis in vitro by retinoids was investigated in modified micromass cultures of limb bud mesenchymal cells from mouse embryos of day 11 and 12. Evaluation of chondrogenesis was performed after alcian blue staining, using a simple random hit counting of cartilage nodules. All-trans-retinoic acid, 13-cis-retinoic acid, and a newly developed arotinoid, RO 13-6298, were tested for their ability to inhibit chondrogenesis. We found that inhibition of chondrogenesis depended on the dosage and the duration of treatment with the different retinoids. Further analysis showed that chondrogenesis in limb bud mesenchymal cells from the proximal part was irreversibly inhibited after one hour of treatment, whereas distal cells showed a reduction of cartilage development only after a treatment period of 12 and more hours. In respect to the doses of the retinoids, proximal cells were about one magnitude more vulnerable than distal cells. These proximo-distal differences were obtained with 13-cis-retinoic acid at 10 micrograms/ml, with all-trans-retinoic acid at 1 microgram/ml and with arotinoid RO 13-6298 with 10 ng/ml. It is supposed that the late blastemal stage of chondrogenic differentiation before the onset of matrix synthesis is the step which is most vulnerable to retinoid treatment.     

Effects of localized application of transforming growth factor beta 1 on developing chick limbs

The effects of exogenous transforming growth factor beta (TGF-beta) on chick limb development in vivo were studied by implanting carriers of TGF-beta 1 into developing wing buds. Agarose beads were soaked in solutions containing TGF-beta 1 and implanted into wing buds at stages 18 to 27. Localized application of TGF-beta 1 to distal regions of the wing bud caused specific skeletal elements in the limb to be reduced or absent. The particular proximal-distal limb element affected depended on the stage at which the bead was implanted. Position of the bead in the anterior-posterior axis also influenced the pattern of affected structures. Experiments in which TGF-beta 1 beads were implanted and then removed at 24- and 48-hr intervals indicate that there are specific periods during which a skeletal element appears to be sensitive to the effects of exogenous TGF-beta 1. In a few cases, beads placed in proximal positions in later staged limbs resulted in formation of ectopic cartilage near the bead. These results suggest that exposure to exogenous TGF-beta 1 in vivo influences the development of skeletal elements in the chick limb in a stage- and position-dependent manner.     

Characterization of retinoid metabolism in the developing chick limb bud

Retinoids (vitamin A derivatives) have been shown to have striking effects on developing and regenerating vertebrate limbs. In the developing chick limb, retinoic acid is a candidate morphogen that may coordinate the pattern of cellular differentiation along the anteroposterior limb axis. We describe a series of investigations of the metabolic pathway of retinoids in the chick limb bud system. To study retinoid metabolism in the bud, all-trans-[3H]retinol, all-trans-[3H]retinal and all-trans-[3H]retinoic acid were released into the posterior region of the limb anlage, the area that contains the zone of polarizing activity, a tissue possibly involved in limb pattern formation. We found that the locally applied [3H]retinol is primarily converted to [3H]retinal, [3H]retinoic acid and a yet unidentified metabolite. When [3H]retinal is locally applied, it is either oxidized to [3H]retinoic acid or reduced to [3H]retinol. In contrast, local delivery of retinoic acid to the bud yields neither retinal nor retinol nor the unknown metabolite. This flow of metabolites agrees with the biochemical pathway of retinoids that has previously been elucidated in a number of other animal systems. To find out whether metabolism takes place directly in the treated limb bud, we have compared the amount of [3H]retinoid present in each of the four limb anlagen following local treatment of the right wing bud. The data suggest that retinoid metabolism takes place mostly in the treated limb bud. This local metabolism could provide a simple mechanism to generate in a controlled fashion the biologically active all-trans-retinoic acid from its abundant biosynthetic precursor retinol. In addition, local metabolism supports the hypothesis that retinoids are local chemical mediators involved in pattern formation.     

Expression of the short stature homeobox gene Shox is restricted by proximal and distal signals in chick limb buds and affects the length of skeletal elements

SHOX is a homeobox-containing gene, highly conserved among species as diverse as fish, chicken and humans. SHOX gene mutations have been shown to cause idiopathic short stature and skeletal malformations frequently observed in human patients with Turner, Leri-Weill and Langer syndromes. We cloned the chicken orthologue of SHOX, studied its expression pattern and compared this with expression of the highly related Shox2. Shox is expressed in central regions of early chick limb buds and proximal two thirds of later limbs, whereas Shox2 is expressed more posteriorly in the proximal third of the limb bud. Shox expression is inhibited distally by signals from the apical ectodermal ridge, both Fgfs and Bmps, and proximally by retinoic acid signaling. We tested Shox functions by overexpression in embryos and micromass cultures. Shox-infected chick limbs had normal proximo-distal patterning but the length of skeletal elements was consistently increased. Primary chick limb bud cell cultures infected with Shox showed an initial increase in cartilage nodules but these did not enlarge. These results fit well with the proposed role of Shox in cartilage and bone differentiation and suggest chick embryos as a useful model to study further the role of Shox in limb development.     

5-Aza-2'-deoxycytidine-induced cytotoxicity and limb reduction defects in the mouse

BACKGROUND: 5-Aza-2'-deoxycytidine (dAZA), causes hindlimb phocomelia in CD-1 mice. Studies in our laboratory have examined the hypothesis that compound- induced changes in gene expression may uniquely affect hindlimb pattern formation. The present study tests the hypothesis that dAZA causes limb dysplasia by inducing cytotoxicity among rapidly proliferating cells in the limb bud mesenchyme. METHODS: Pregnant CD-1 mice were given a teratogenic dose of dAZA (i.p.) at different times on GD 10 and fetuses evaluated for skeletal development in both sets of limbs by standard methods. Using general histology and BrdU immunohistochemistry, limb mesenchymal cell death and cell proliferation were then assessed in embryos at various times post dosing, shortly after initial limb bud outgrowth. The effect of dAZA on early limb chondrogenesis was also studied using Northern analysis of scleraxis and Alcian blue staining of whole mount limb buds. RESULTS: Compound related hindlimb defects were not restricted to a specific set of skeletal elements but consisted of a range of temporally related limb anomalies. Modest defects of the radius were observed as well. These results are consistent with a general insult to the limb mesenchyme. Mesenchymal cell death and reduced cell proliferation were also observed in both sets of limbs. The timing and location of these effects indicate a role for cytotoxicity in the etiology of dAZA induced limb defects. These effects also agree with the greater teratogenicity of dAZA in the hindlimb because they were more pronounced in that limb. The expression of scleraxis, a marker of early chondrogenesis, was reduced 12 hr after dAZA exposure, a time coincident with maximal cell death, as was the subsequent emergence of Alcian blue stained long bone anlagen. CONCLUSIONS: These findings support the hypothesis that cytotoxic changes in the limb bud mesenchyme during early limb outgrowth can induce the proximal limb truncations characteristic of phocomelia after dAZA administration.     

Behavior of cells in artificially made cell aggregates and tissue fragments after grafting to developing hind limb buds in Xenopus laevis

During vertebrate limb development, the limb bud grows along the proximo-distal (P-D) direction, with the cells changing their adhesiveness. To know whether the position-related differences in cell adhesiveness are actually utilized by morphogenesis to constitute limb structures, we grafted cell aggregates made of dissociated cells derived from different positions and stages of developing hind limb buds into developing hind limb buds and observed the behavior of the cells. Cell aggregates made of dissociated mesenchymal cells from two different origins were implanted in different positions and stages of limb buds or grafted on limb stumps made by cutting. The two grafted cell populations in the aggregate always sorted out from each other, but their patterning of sorting-out was quite different according to the transplanted regions. In summary, cells in the aggregate that have closer positional identity to the transplanted site were always situated at the boundary between host and donor cells. The pattern of sorting-out seemed to be determined by the relative adhesiveness of surrounding cells to the constituent cells of the aggregates. We also transplanted fragments dissected out from different regions along the P-D axis into st. 50 limb buds. The descendants of grafted cells moved distally to the region corresponding to their positional identity and participated in the formation of more distal structures from that point. These results suggest that the difference in cell adhesiveness may probably play a role in arranging cells along the P-D axis of a developing limb bud.     

The occurrence of supernumerary limbs following blastemal transplantation in the regenerating forelimb of the axolotl, Ambystoma mexicanum

Regeneration blastemas at the stages of medium bud and palette were transplanted to contralateral limb stumps so that either their anterior and posterior positions or their dorsal and ventral positions were apposed to those of the stumps. Grafts were shifted from distal levels to proximal levels, or from proximal levels to distal levels, or remained at either a proximal or a distal level. When anterior and posterior positions of graft and stump were apposed, supernumerary limbs were produced at the graft-stump junction in anterior and posterior positions relative to the stump. All analyzable supernumerary limbs were of stump handedness. Apposition of dorsal and ventral positions of graft and stump led to the formation of supernumerary limbs at dorsal and ventral positions relative to stump tissues. All analyzable supernumerary limbs were once again of stump handedness. Shifts from distal levels to proximal levels never resulted in skeletal deletions, as potential deletions in the proximal-distal axis were always filled in. Shifts from proximal levels to distal levels resulted in a low frequency of serial duplications. The results are discussed in view of a recently presented formal model for pattern regulation in epimorphic fields.     

Elevations in the endogenous levels of the putative morphogen retinoic acid in embryonic mouse limb-buds associated with limb dysmorphogenesis

Retinoic acid, an endogenous metabolite of vitamin A (retinol), possesses striking biological activity akin to a morphogen in developing and regenerating vertebrate limbs. Systemic administration of retinoic acid (RA) to pregnant mammals during the period of limb organogenesis invariably results in dose-dependent dysmorphogenesis. In an attempt to uncover the mode of action of RA in the developing limb bud we analyzed, by HPLC methods, the levels of RA and its metabolic precursor, retinol, in embryonic mouse tissues prior to and following maternal exposure to a teratogenic dose of RA. Detectable levels of both RA and its isomer 13-cis-retinoic acid were found in the limb buds of Day 11 mouse embryos (40 +/- 2 somites). Although retinol was the major retinoid found in ethanolic extracts of either whole embryo or the limb buds, the latter is enriched in RA compared to the whole embryo. This indicated either a higher degree of retinol metabolism or a sequestration of RA in the limb bud compared to the rest of the embryo at this stage of development. A study of the time course of retinoid levels in treated embryos showed that changes occur rapidly, are stable for several hours, and then begin to return to pretreatment levels. After a maternal dose of 10 mg/kg RA, which resulted in a mild degree of limb anomalies, peak RA levels in the limb bud increased 50-fold over the endogenous level; a full 300-fold increase was found after a 100 mg/kg dose which results in 100% incidence of phocomelia. Interestingly, a dose-dependent depression in retinol levels was observed after RA treatment both in maternal plasma as well as the embryo. Studies are in progress to trace the intracellular disposition of both retinol and RA as well as any further active metabolite of RA in the limb buds and other embryonic tissues.     

Hox-4 gene expression in mouse/chicken heterospecific grafts of signalling regions to limb buds reveals similarities in patterning mechanisms.

The products of Hox-4 genes appear to encode position in developing vertebrate limbs. In chick embryos, a number of different signalling regions when grafted to wing buds lead to duplicated digit patterns. We grafted tissue from the equivalent regions in mouse embryos to chick wing buds and assayed expression of Hox-4 genes in both the mouse cells in the grafts and in the chick cells in the responding limb bud using species specific probes. Tissue from the mouse limb polarizing region and anterior primitive streak respecify anterior chick limb bud cells to give posterior structures and lead to activation of all the genes in the complex. Mouse neural tube and genital tubercle grafts, which give much less extensive changes in pattern, do not activate 5'-located Hox-4 genes. Analysis of expression of Hox-4 genes in mouse cells in the grafted signalling regions reveals no relationship between expression of these genes and strength of their signalling activity. Endogenous signals in the chick limb bud activate Hox-4 genes in grafts of mouse anterior limb cells when placed posteriorly and in grafts of mouse anterior primitive streak tissue. The activation of the same gene network by different signalling regions points to a similarity in patterning mechanisms along the axes of the vertebrate body.     

The differentiation of normal and muscle-free distal chick limb bud mesenchyme in micromass culture

Distal chick wing bud mesenchyme from stages 19 to 27 embryos has been grown in micromass culture. The behavior of cultures comprising mesenchyme located within 350 microns of the apical ectodermal ridge (distal zone mesenchyme) was compared to that of cultures of the immediately proximal mesenchyme (subdistal zone cultures). In cultures of the distal mesenchyme from stages 21-24 limbs, all of the cells stained immunocytochemically for type II collagen within 3 days, indicating ubiquitous chondrogenic differentiation. At stage 19 and 20, this behavior was only observed in cultures of the distal most 50-100 microns of the limb bud mesenchyme. Between stages 25 and 27, distal zone cultures failed to become entirely chondrogenic. At all stages, subdistal zone cultures always contained substantial areas of nonchondrogenic cells. The different behavior observed between distal zone and corresponding subdistal zone cultures appears to be a consequence of the presence of somite-derived presumptive muscle cells in the latter, since no such difference was observed in analagous cultures prepared from muscle-free wing buds. The high capacity of the distal zone for cartilage differentiation supports a view of pattern formation in which inhibition of cartilage is an important component. However, its consistent behavior in vitro indicates that micromass cultures do not reflect the in vivo differences between the distal zones at different stages. The subdistal region retains a high capacity of cartilage differentiation and the observed behavior in micromass reflects interactions with a different cell population.     

Existence of gradient in cell adhesiveness along the developing Xenopus hind limb bud, shown by a cellular sorting-out experiment in vitro

To examine the possibility of a difference in cell adhesiveness along the developing Xenopus hind limb bud axes, single mesenchymal cells from developing hind limb buds were cultured, allowing them to form an aggregate in a gyratory culture system. By observing the distribution of cells within aggregates, it was found that sorting-out occurred between cells from different positions and different stages. Cells derived from more distal positions tended to be situated interiorly in the aggregates. According to Steinberg's differential adhesion hypothesis, these results support the idea that there is a graded difference in cell adhesiveness along the proximo-distal axis of the developing limb, with adhesiveness increasing distally. Although similar sorting-out was observed between anterior and posterior cell populations, it could not be determined which cell populations were definitely more cohesive. These properties may be correlated with the experimentally demonstrated 'positional value', which should be different among cells located at different positions along the axes of the developing vertebrate limb bud.     

The spatial and temporal distribution of polarizing activity in the flank of the pre-limb-bud stages in the chick embryo

The presence of polarizing activity in the limb buds of developing avian embryos determines the pattern of the anteroposterior axis of the limbs in the adult. Maps of the spatial distribution and the strength of the signal within limb buds of different stages are well documented. Polarizing activity can also be found in Hensen's node in the early embryo. We have mapped the distribution of polarizing activity as it emerges from Hensen's node and spreads into the flank tissue of the embryo. There is a clear change in the local pattern of expression of polarizing activity between stage 8 and 18. Almost no activity is measured for stages 8 and 9. More or less uniform levels of around 10% are spread along the flank lateral to the unsegmented somitic mesoderm from somite position 12 to 22 in stage 10 embryos. Some 6 to 8 h later at stage 12, there is a distinct peak of activity at somite position 18, the middle of the wing field. This peak increases at stages 13 to 15 and its position traverses to the posterior edge of the wing field. Full strength of activity is reached shortly before the onset of limb bud formation at stage 16 to 17. Stages 16 to 18 were investigated for polarizing activity in the wing and the leg field. Low levels of polarizing activity are present in the anterior leg field at stages 16 and 17 but have disappeared by stage 18 and all activity is confined to the posterior part of the leg bud.     

Formation of supernumerary structures by the embryonic chick wing depends on the position and orientation of a graft in a host limb bud

The relationship between the position transplanted in a host limb bud, the orientation of a graft in a host limb bud, and the extra limb structures formed was studied by juxtaposing normally nonadjacent embryonic chick wing bud tissue. In one series of transplantation operations, two different wedges (ectoderm and mesoderm) of stage 21 right donor posterior wing bud tissue were transplanted to the middle of a host stage 20 to 22 right wing bud such that the dorsal-ventral polarity of the graft and host were the same or reversed. The results of these transplantation operations show that the formation of supernumerary limb structures depends on the position of origin of the donor tissue, the anterior-posterior position transplanted in a host limb bud, and the orientation of the graft in the host limb bud. In a second series of transplantation operations, the relationship between the proximodistal position where posterior donor tissue is transplanted in an anterior host site and the extra structures formed was studied. A wedge of posterior stage 21 right wing bud tissue was transplanted to an anterior proximal or anterior distal site of a stage 22 to 24 host right wing bud. The results of these transplantation operations show that when the donor tissue is transplanted to an anterior proximal position in a host wing bud, then limbs with only a duplicated humerus result, whereas, when transplanted to an anterior distal position, then limbs with a duplicated forearm element and extra digits result.     

A comparative study of myogenic cell invasion of the avian wing and leg bud.

The borders of myogenic cell invasion of avian wing and leg buds were determined using the interspecific grafting technique between quail and chick embryos. Distal parts of quail limb buds were grafted ectopically into the coelomic cavity of chick embryos. The presence or absence of skeletal muscle was investigated in histological sections of the reincubated grafts. A comparison between the borders of myogenic cell invasion of the wing and leg buds showed that the differences in the position of the distal most muscles in the adult avian limbs could be a consequence of the cranio-caudal sequence of development.     

Retinoic acid induces a pattern of digits in anterior half wing buds that lack the zone of polarizing activity

Wing buds whose posterior half is excised, develop into wings lacking distal structures. However, such experimentally generated preaxial half wing buds can be rescued by implanting a retinoic-acid-releasing bead at their anterior margin. The polarity of the pattern that originates from preaxial half wing buds is reversed. For example, instead of a 234 digit pattern typical for normal wings, the order of digits is 432. This result implies that retinoic acid has the capacity to reprogram anterior limb bud tissue, and that the resulting change in cell fate does not depend on the presence of posterior tissue regions such as the zone of polarizing activity (ZPA).