Lactose repressor hinge domain independently binds DNA

The short 8–10 amino acid “hinge” sequence in lactose repressor (LacI), present in other LacI/GalR family members, links DNA and inducer‐binding domains. Structural studies of full‐length or truncated LacI‐operator DNA complexes demonstrate insertion of the dimeric helical “hinge” structure at the center of the operator sequence. This association bends the DNA ～40° and aligns flanking semi‐symmetric DNA sites for optimal contact by the N‐terminal helix‐turn‐helix (HtH) sequences within each dimer. In contrast, the hinge region remains unfolded when bound to nonspecific DNA sequences. To determine ability of the hinge helix alone to mediate DNA binding, we examined (i) binding of LacI variants with deletion of residues 1–50 to remove the HtH DNA binding domain or residues 1–58 to remove both HtH and hinge domains and (ii) binding of a synthetic peptide corresponding to the hinge sequence with a Val52Cys substitution that allows reversible dimer formation via a disulfide linkage. Binding affinity for DNA is orders of magnitude lower in the absence of the helix‐turn‐helix domain with its highly positive charge. LacI missing residues 1–50 binds to DNA with ～4‐fold greater affinity for operator than for nonspecific sequences with minimal impact of inducer presence; in contrast, LacI missing residues 1–58 exhibits no detectable affinity for DNA. In oxidized form, the dimeric hinge peptide alone binds to O1 and nonspecific DNA with similarly small difference in affinity; reduction to monomer diminished binding to both O1 and nonspecific targets. These results comport with recent reports regarding LacI hinge interaction with DNA sequences.     

Engineered disulfide linking the hinge regions within lactose repressor dimer increases operator affinity, decreases sequence selectivity, and alters allostery.

The hinge domain encompasses amino acids 51-60 of lactose repressor (LacI) and plays an important role in its regulatory interaction with operator DNA. This segment makes both hinge-DNA and hinge-hinge' contacts that are critical to DNA binding. Furthermore, this small region serves as a central element in communicating the allosteric response to inducer. Introducing a disulfide bond between partner hinges within a dimer via the mutation V52C results in a protein that has increased affinity for O(1) operator DNA compared to wild-type LacI and abolishes allosteric response to inducer [Falcon, C. M., Swint-Kruse, L., and Matthews, K. S. (1997) J. Biol. Chem. 272, 26818]. We have established that this high affinity is maintained for the disulfide-linked protein even when symmetry and half-site spacing within the operator region are altered, whereas binding by the reduced protein, as for wild-type LacI, is severely diminished by these alterations. Interestingly, the allosteric response to inducer for V52C-oxidized remains intact for a small group of operator variants. Temperature studies demonstrate that the presence of the disulfide alters the thermodynamics of the protein-DNA interaction, with a DeltaC(p) of significantly smaller magnitude compared to wild-type LacI. The results presented here establish the hinge region as an important element not only for LacI high-affinity operator binding but also for the essential communication between ligand binding domains. Moreover, the results confirm that DNA sequence/conformation can profoundly influence allostery for this prototypic regulatory protein.     

Extrinsic interactions dominate helical propensity in coupled binding and folding of the lactose repressor protein hinge helix

A significant number of eukaryotic regulatory proteins are predicted to have disordered regions. Many of these proteins bind DNA, which may serve as a template for protein folding. Similar behavior is seen in the prokaryotic LacI/GalR family of proteins that couple hinge-helix folding with DNA binding. These hinge regions form short alpha-helices when bound to DNA but appear to be disordered in other states. An intriguing question is whether and to what degree intrinsic helix propensity contributes to the function of these proteins. In addition to its interaction with operator DNA, the LacI hinge helix interacts with the hinge helix of the homodimer partner as well as to the surface of the inducer-binding domain. To explore the hierarchy of these interactions, we made a series of substitutions in the LacI hinge helix at position 52, the only site in the helix that does not interact with DNA and/or the inducer-binding domain. The substitutions at V52 have significant effects on operator binding affinity and specificity, and several substitutions also impair functional communication with the inducer-binding domain. Results suggest that helical propensity of amino acids in the hinge region alone does not dominate function; helix-helix packing interactions appear to also contribute. Further, the data demonstrate that variation in operator sequence can overcome side chain effects on hinge-helix folding and/or hinge-hinge interactions. Thus, this system provides a direct example whereby an extrinsic interaction (DNA binding) guides internal events that influence folding and functionality.     

Fine-tuning function: correlation of hinge domain interactions with functional distinctions between LacI and PurR

LacI and PurR are highly homologous proteins. Their functional units are homodimers, with an N-terminal DNA binding domain that comprises the helix-turn-helix (HTH), N-linker, and hinge regions from both monomers. Hinge structural changes are known to occur upon DNA dissociation but are difficult to monitor experimentally. The initial steps of hinge unfolding were therefore examined using molecular dynamics simulations, utilizing a truncated, chimeric protein comprising the LacI HTH/N-linker and PurR hinge. A terminal Gly-Cys-Gly was added to allow "dimerization" through disulfide bond formation. Simulations indicate that differences in LacI and PurR hinge primary sequence affect the quaternary structure of the hinge x hinge' interface. However, these alternate hinge orientations would be sterically restricted by the core domain. These results prompted detailed comparison of recently available DNA-bound structures for LacI and truncated LacI(1-62) with the PurR structure. Examination revealed that different N-linker and hinge contacts to the core domain of the partner monomer (which binds effector molecule) affect the juxtapositions of the HTH, N-linker, and hinge regions in the DNA binding domain. In addition, the two full-length repressors exhibit significant differences in the interactions between the core and the C-linker connection to the DNA binding domain. Both linkers and the hinge have been implicated in the allosteric response of these repressors. Intriguingly, one functional difference between these two proteins is that they exhibit opposite allosteric response to effector. Simulations and observed structural distinctions are correlated with mutational analysis and sequence information from the LacI/GalR family to formulate a mechanism for fine-tuning individual repressor function.     

Ion concentration and temperature dependence of DNA binding: comparison of PurR and LacI repressor proteins.

Purine repressor (PurR) binding to specific DNA is enhanced by complexing with purines, whereas lactose repressor (LacI) binding is diminished by interaction with inducer sugars despite 30% identity in their protein sequences and highly homologous tertiary structures. Nonetheless, in switching from low- to high-affinity DNA binding, these proteins undergo a similar structural change in which the hinge region connecting the DNA and effector binding domains folds into an alpha-helix and contacts the DNA minor groove. The differences in response to effector for these proteins should be manifest in the polyelectrolyte effect which arises from cations displaced from DNA by interaction with positively charged side chains on a protein and is quantitated by measurement of DNA binding affinity as a function of ion concentration. Consistent with structural data for these proteins, high-affinity operator DNA binding by the PurR-purine complex involved approximately 15 ion pairs, a value significantly greater than that for the corresponding state of LacI (approximately 6 ion pairs). For both proteins, however, conversion to the low-affinity state results in a decrease of approximately 2-fold in the number of cations released per dimeric DNA binding site. Heat capacity changes (DeltaC(p)) that accompany DNA binding, derived from buried apolar surface area, coupled folding, and restriction of motional freedom of polar groups in the interface, also reflect the differences between these homologous repressor proteins. DNA binding of the PurR-guanine complex is accompanied by a DeltaC(p) (-2.8 kcal mol(-1) K(-1)) more negative than that observed previously for LacI (-0.9 to -1.5 kcal mol(-1) K(-1)), suggesting that more extensive protein folding and/or enhanced structural rigidity may occur upon DNA binding for PurR compared to DNA binding for LacI. The differences between these proteins illustrate plasticity of function despite high-level sequence and structural homology and undermine efforts to predict protein behavior on the basis of such similarities.     

Energetic and structural considerations for the mechanism of protein sliding along DNA in the nonspecific BamHI-DNA complex

The molecular mechanism by which DNA-binding proteins find their specific binding sites is still unclear. To gain insights into structural and energetic elements of this mechanism, we used the crystal structure of the nonspecific BamHI-DNA complex as a template to study the dominant electrostatic interaction in the nonspecific association of protein with DNA, and the possible sliding pathways that could be sustained by such an interaction. Based on calculations using the nonlinear Poisson-Boltzmann method and Brownian dynamics, a model is proposed for the initial nonspecific binding of BamHI to B-form DNA that differs from that seen in the crystal structure of the nonspecific complex. The model is electrostatically favorable, and the salt dependence as well as other thermodynamic parameters calculated for this model are in good agreement with experimental results. Several residues in BamHI are identified for their important contribution to the energy in the nonspecific binding model, and specific mutagenesis experiments are proposed to test the model on this basis. We show that a favorable sliding pathway of the protein along DNA is helical.     

The lac repressor hinge helix in context: The effect of the DNA binding domain and symmetry

The Lac system of genes has been an important model system in understanding gene regulation. When the dimer lac repressor protein binds to the correct DNA sequence, the hinge region of the protein goes through a disorder to order transition. The hinge region is disordered when binding to nonoperator sequences. This region of the protein must pay a conformational entropic penalty to order when it is bound to operator DNA. Structural studies show that this region is flexible. Previous simulations showed that this region is disordered when free in solution without the DNA binding domain present. Our simulations corroborate that this region is extremely flexible in solution, but we find that the presence of the DNA binding domain proximal to the hinge helix and salt make the ordered conformation more favorable even without DNA present.     

Operator DNA sequence variation enhances high affinity binding by hinge helix mutants of lactose repressor protein

The mechanism by which genetic regulatory proteins discern specific target DNA sequences remains a major area of inquiry. To explore in more detail the interplay between DNA and protein sequence, we have examined binding of variant lac operator DNA sequences to a series of mutant lactose repressor proteins (LacI). These proteins were altered in the C-terminus of the hinge region that links the N-terminal DNA binding and core sugar binding domains. Variant operators differed from the wild-type operator, O(1), in spacing and/or symmetry of the half-sites that contact the LacI N-terminal DNA binding domain. Binding of wild-type and mutant proteins was affected differentially by variations in operator sequence and symmetry. While the mutant series exhibits a 10(4)-fold range in binding affinity for O(1) operator, only a approximately 20-fold difference in affinity is observed for a completely symmetric operator, O(sym), used widely in studies of the LacI protein. Further, DNA sequence influenced allosteric response for these proteins. Binding of this LacI mutant series to other variant operator DNA sequences indicated the importance of symmetry-related bases, spacing, and the central base pair sequence in high affinity complex formation. Conformational flexibility in the DNA and other aspects of the structure influenced by the sequence may establish the binding environment for protein and determine both affinity and potential for allostery.     

How to Arm a Supervillin: Designing F-Actin Binding Activity into Supervillin Headpiece

Villin-type headpiece domains are compact motifs that have been used extensively as model systems for protein folding. Although the majority of headpiece domains bind actin, there are some that lack this activity. Here, we present the first NMR solution structure and ¹⁵N-relaxation analysis of a villin-type headpiece domain natively devoid of F-actin binding activity, that of supervillin headpiece (SVHP). The structure was found to be similar to that of other headpiece domains that bind F-actin. Our NMR analysis demonstrates that SVHP lacks a conformationally flexible region (V-loop) present in all other villin-type headpiece domains and which is essential to the phosphoryl regulation of dematin headpiece. In comparing the electrostatic surface potential map of SVHP to that of other villin-type headpiece domains with significant affinity for F-actin, we identified a positive surface potential conserved among headpiece domains that bind F-actin but absent from SVHP. A single point mutation (L38K) in SVHP, which creates a similar positive surface potential, endowed SVHP with specific affinity for F-actin that is within an order of magnitude of the tightest binding headpiece domains. We propose that this effect is likely conferred by a specific buried salt bridge between headpiece and actin. As no high-resolution structural information exists for the villin-type headpiece F-actin complex, our results demonstrate that through positive mutagenesis, it is possible to design binding activity into homologous proteins without structural information of the counterpart's binding surface.     

Cooperative and Anticooperative Effects in Binding of the First and Second Plasmid OsymOperators to a LacI Tetramer: Evidence for Contributions of Non-operator DNA Binding by Wrapping and Looping

The interaction oflacoperator DNA withlacrepressor (LacI) is a classic example of a genetic regulatory switch. To dissect the role of stoichiometry, subunit association, and effects of DNA length in positioning this switch, we have determined binding isotherms for the interaction of LacI with a high affinity (O^sym) operator on linearized plasmid (2500 bp) DNA over a wide range of macromolecular concentrations (10⁻¹⁴to 10⁻⁸M). Binding data were analyzed using a thermodynamic model involving four equilibria: dissociation of tetramers (T) into dimers (D), and binding of operator-containing plasmid DNA (O) to dimers and tetramers to form three distinct complexes, DO, TO, and TO₂. Over the range of con- centrations of repressor, operator, and salt (0.075 M K⁺to 0.40 M K⁺) investigated, we find no evidence for any significant thermodynamic effect of LacI dimers. Instead, all isotherms can be interpreted in terms of just two equilibria, involving only T and the TO and TO₂complexes. As a reference binding equilibrium, which we propose must approximate the DO binding interaction, we compare the plasmid O^symresults with our extensive studies of the binding of a 40 bp O^symDNA fragment to LacI. On this basis, we obtain a lower bound on the LacI dimer – tetramer equilibrium constant and values of the equilibrium constants for formation of TO and TO₂complexes.At a salt concentration of 0.40 M, the O^symplasmid binding data are consistent with a model with two independent and identical binding sites for operator per LacI tetramer, in which the binding to a site on the tetramer is only slightly more favorable than the reference binding interaction. Increasingly large deviations from the independent-site model are observed as the salt concentration is reduced; binding of a second operator to form TO₂becomes strongly disfavored relative to formation of TO at low salt concentrations (0.075 to 0.125 M). In addition, binding of both the first and second plasmid operator DNA molecules to the tetramer becomes increasingly more favorable than the reference binding interaction as [K⁺] is reduced from 0.40 M to 0.125 M. At 0.075 M K⁺, however, the strength of binding of the second plasmid operator DNA to the LacI tetramer is dramatically reduced; this interaction is much less favorable than binding the first plasmid operator DNA, and becomes much less favorable than the reference binding interaction. We propose that these differences arise from changes in the nature of the TO and TO₂complexes with decreasing salt concentration. At low salt concentration, we suggest the hypothesis that flanking non-operator sequences bind non-specifically (coulombically) by local wrapping, and that distant regions of non-operator DNA occupy the second operator-binding site by looping. We propose that wrapping stabilizes both 1:1 and 2:1 complexes at low salt concentration, and that looping stabilizes the 1:1 complex but competitively destabilizes the 2:1 TO₂complex at low salt concentration. These effects must play a role in adjusting the stability and structure of the LacI-lac operator repression complex as the cytoplasmic [K⁺] varies in response to changes in extracellular osmolarity.     

Electrostatic contributions to the binding free energy of the lambdacI repressor to DNA.

A model based on the nonlinear Poisson-Boltzmann (NLPB) equation is used to study the electrostatic contribution to the binding free energy of the lambdacI repressor to its operator DNA. In particular, we use the Poisson-Boltzmann model to calculate the pKa shift of individual ionizable amino acids upon binding. We find that three residues on each monomer, Glu34, Glu83, and the amino terminus, have significant changes in their pKa and titrate between pH 4 and 9. This information is then used to calculate the pH dependence of the binding free energy. We find that the calculated pH dependence of binding accurately reproduces the available experimental data over a range of physiological pH values. The NLPB equation is then used to develop an overall picture of the electrostatics of the lambdacI repressor-operator interaction. We find that long-range Coulombic forces associated with the highly charged nucleic acid provide a strong driving force for the interaction of the protein with the DNA. These favorable electrostatic interactions are opposed, however, by unfavorable changes in the solvation of both the protein and the DNA upon binding. Specifically, the formation of a protein-DNA complex removes both charged and polar groups at the binding interface from solvent while it displaces salt from around the nucleic acid. As a result, the electrostatic contribution to the lambdacI repressor-operator interaction opposes binding by approximately 73 kcal/mol at physiological salt concentrations and neutral pH. A variety of entropic terms also oppose binding. The major force driving the binding process appears to be release of interfacial water from the protein and DNA surfaces upon complexation and, possibly, enhanced packing interactions between the protein and DNA in the interface. When the various nonelectrostatic terms are described with simple models that have been applied previously to other binding processes, a general picture of protein/DNA association emerges in which binding is driven by the nonpolar interactions, whereas specificity results from electrostatic interactions that weaken binding but are necessary components of any protein/DNA complex.     

DNA binding to protein-gold nanocrystal conjugates

The E. coli DNA binding protein lac repressor (LacI) and a derivative with a designed thiol (T334C) were developed as gold nanocrystal conjugates to assess the effects of conjugation on DNA binding function. The designed derivative was engineered with a solvent-accessible thiol to promote oriented conjugation, avoiding obstruction of the DNA-binding domain by the nanocrystal. Analytical ultracentrifugation (AU) and electrophoretic mobility shift assays (EMSA) were used to evaluate the ability of conjugated repressors to bind the natural operator DNA sequence O(1). The results show that LacI does not retain significant DNA binding function when conjugated to gold nanocrystals, presumably because the basic DNA-binding domain is the site for nonspecific conjugation. T334C, with the potential for both directed and nonspecific conjugation, shows enhanced interaction with O(1) when conjugated. Interestingly, the order of component addition is a key factor in producing functional lac repressor conjugates.     

Comparison of simulated and experimentally determined dynamics for a variant of the Lacl DNA-binding domain, Nlac-P.

Recent advances in the experimentally determined structures and dynamics of the domains within LacI provide a rare context for evaluating dynamics calculations. A 1500-ps trajectory was simulated for a variant of the LacI DNA-binding domain, which consists of the first three helices in LacI and the hinge helix of the homologous PurR. Order parameters derived from dynamics simulations are compared to those obtained for the LacI DNA-binding domain with 15N relaxation NMR spectroscopy (Slijper et al., 1997. Biochemistry. 36:249-254). The MD simulations suggest that the unstructured loop between helices II and III does not exist in a discrete state under the conditions of no salt and neutral pH, but occupies a continuum of states between the DNA-bound and free structures. Simulations also indicate that the unstructured region between helix III and the hinge helix is very mobile, rendering motions of the hinge helix essentially independent of the rest of the protein. Finally, the alpha-helical hydrogen bonds in the hinge helix are broken after 1250 ps, perhaps as a prelude to helix unfolding.     

Subdividing repressor function: DNA binding affinity, selectivity, and allostery can be altered by amino acid substitution of nonconserved residues in a LacI/GalR homologue

Many mutations that impact protein function occur at residues that do not directly contact ligand. To understand the functional contributions from the sequence that links the DNA-binding and regulatory domains of the LacI/GalR homologues, we have created a chimeric protein (LLhP), which comprises the LacI DNA-binding domain, the LacI linker, and the PurR regulatory domain. Although DNA binding site residues are identical in LLhP and LacI, thermodynamic measurements of DNA binding affinity show that LLhP does not discriminate between alternative DNA ligands as well as LacI. In addition, small-angle scattering experiments show that LLhP is more compact than LacI. When DNA is released, LacI shows a 20 A increase in length that was previously attributed to unfolding of the linker. This change is not seen in apo-LLhP, even though the linker sequences of the two proteins are identical. Together, results indicate that long-range functional and structural changes are propagated across the interface that forms between the linker and regulatory domain. These changes could be mediated via the side chains of several linker residues that contact the regulatory domains of the naturally occurring proteins, LacI and PurR. Substitution of these residues in LLhP leads to a range of functional effects. Four variants exhibit altered affinity for DNA, with no changes in selectivity or allosteric response. Another two result in proteins that bind operator DNA with very low affinity and no allosteric response, similar to LacI binding nonspecific DNA sequences. Two more substitutions simultaneously diminish affinity, enhance allostery, and profoundly alter DNA ligand selectivity. Thus, positions within the linker can be varied to modulate different aspects of repressor function.     

lac Repressor headpiece binds specifically to half of the lac operator: a proton nuclear magnetic resonance study

The complex formation of the N-terminal domain (headpiece) of the Escherichia coli lac repressor and a synthetic 14-base-pair lac operator fragment has been investigated by 1H NMR. Titration shifts in the imino-proton region of the DNA spectrum and in the aromatic region of the headpiece spectrum are examined in detail and interpreted where possible. The assignment of the resonances in the complex follows in part from the titration data and is completed by nuclear Overhauser measurements. The shift of the His-29 C-2 resonance has been used to assess the binding strength of the complex. Evidence is presented for the presence of a high-affinity site on the lac operator fragment (KD less than or equal to 2 X 10(-5) M), which shows features in common with one of the specific binding sites on the complete lac operator, and for the presence of a second, nonspecific binding site with lower affinity. The influence of this second site on the interpretation of the binding data is discussed.     

DAPI binding to the DNA minor groove: a continuum solvent analysis

A continuum solvent model based on the generalized Born (GB) or finite-difference Poisson-Boltzmann (FDPB) approaches has been employed to compare the binding of 4'-6-diamidine-2-phenyl indole (DAPI) to the minor groove of various DNA sequences. Qualitative agreement between the results of GB and FDPB approaches as well as between calculated and experimentally observed trends regarding the sequence specificity of DAPI binding to B-DNA was obtained. Calculated binding energies were decomposed into various contributions to solvation and DNA-ligand interaction. DNA conformational adaptation was found to make a favorable contribution to the calculated total interaction energy but did not change the DAPI binding affinity ranking of different DNA sequences. The calculations indicate that closed complex formation is mainly driven by nonpolar contributions and was found to be disfavored electrostatically due to a desolvation penalty that outbalances the attractive Coulomb interaction. The calculated penalty was larger for DAPI binding to GC-rich sequences compared with AT-rich target sequences and generally larger for the FDPB vs the GB continuum model. A radial interaction profile for DAPI at different distances from the DNA minor groove revealed an electrostatic energy minimum a few Angstroms farther away from the closed binding geometry. The calculated electrostatic interaction up to this distance is attractive and it may stabilize a nonspecific binding arrangement.     

Linear diffusion of the restriction endonuclease EcoRV on DNA is essential for the in vivo function of the enzyme.

Linear diffusion along DNA is a mechanism of enhancing the association rates of proteins to their specific recognition sites on DNA. It has been demonstrated for several proteins in vitro, but to date in no case in vivo. Here we show that the restriction endonuclease EcoRV slides along the DNA, scanning approximately 1000 bp in one binding event. This process is critically dependent on contacts between amino acid residues of the protein and the backbone of the DNA. The disruption of single hydrogen bonds and, in particular, the alteration of electrostatic interactions between amino acid side chains of the protein and phosphate groups of the DNA interfere with or abolish effective sliding. The efficiency of linear diffusion is dependent on salt concentration, having a maximum at 50 mM NaCl. These results suggest that a nonspecific and mobile binding mode capable of linear diffusion is dependent on a subtle balance of forces governing the interaction of the enzyme and the DNA. A strong correlation between the ability of EcoRV mutants to slide along the DNA in vitro and to protect Escherichia coli cells from phage infection demonstrates that linear diffusion occurs in vivo and is essential for effective phage restriction.     

Structural homology between rbs repressor and ribose binding protein implies functional similarity.

The deduced amino acid sequence of the rbs repressor, RbsR, of Escherichia coli is homologous over its C-terminal 272 residues to the entire sequence of the periplasmic ribose binding protein. RbsR is also homologous to a family of bacterial repressor proteins including LacI. This implies that the structure of the repressor consists of a two-domain binding protein portion attached to a DNA-binding domain having the four-helix structure of the LacI headpiece. The implications of these relationships to the mechanism of this class of repressors are discussed.     

Glycine insertion in the hinge region of lactose repressor protein alters DNA binding.

Amino acid alterations were designed at the C terminus of the hinge segment (amino acids approximately 51-59) that links two functional domains within lactose repressor protein (LacI). Gly was introduced between Gly(58) and Lys(59) to generate Gly(58+1); Gln(60) was changed to Gly or Pro, and up to three additional glycines were inserted following Gln(60) --> Gly. All mutant proteins exhibited purification behavior, CD spectra, assembly state, and inducer binding properties similar to wild-type LacI and only small differences in trypsin proteolysis patterns. In contrast, significant differences were observed in DNA binding properties. Gly(58+1) exhibited a decrease of approximately 100-fold in affinity for O(1) operator, and sequential Gly insertion C-terminal to Gln(60) --> Gly resulted in progressively decreased affinity for O(1) operator, approaching nonspecific levels for insertion of >/=2 glycines. Where sufficient affinity for O(1) operator existed, decreased binding to O(1) in the presence of inducer indicated no disruption in the allosteric response for these proteins. Collectively, these results indicate that flexibility and/or spacing between the core and N-terminal domains did not significantly affect folding or assembly, but these alterations in the hinge domain profoundly altered affinity of the lactose repressor protein for its wild-type target sequence.