Rapid authentication of animal cell lines using pyrolysis mass spectrometry and auto-associative artificial neural networks

Summary Pyrolysis mass spectrometry (PyMS) was used to produce biochemical fingerprints from replicate frozen cell cultures of mouse macrophage hybridoma 2C11-12, human leukaemia K562, baby hamster kidney BHK 21/C13, and mouse tumour BW-O, and a fresh culture of Chinese hamster ovary CHO cells. The dimensionality of these data was reduced by the unsupervised feature extraction pattern recognition technique of auto-associative neural networks. The clusters observed were compared with the groups obtained from the more conventional statistical approaches of hierarchical cluster analysis. It was observed that frozen and fresh cell line cultures gave very different pyrolysis mass spectra. When only the frozen animal cells were analysed by PyMS, auto-associative artificial neural networks (ANNs) were employed to discriminate between them successfully. Furthermore, very similar classifications were observed when the same spectral data were analysed using hierarchical cluster analysis. We demonstrate that this approach can detect the contamination of cell lines with low numbers of bacteria and fungi; this approach could plausibly be extended for the rapid detection of mycoplasma infection in animal cell lines. The major advantages that PyMS offers over more conventional methods used to type cell lines and to screen for microbial infection, such as DNA fingerprinting, are its speed, sensitivity and the ability to analyse hundreds of samples per day. We conclude that the combination of PyMS and ANNs can provide a rapid and accurate discriminatory technique for the authentication of animal cell line cultures.     

DNA fingerprinting—a valuable new technique for the characterisation of cell lines

DNA fingerprinting is an important new development for the authentication of cell lines. Multilocus methods such as those developed by Alec Jeffreys provide information on a wide range of genetic loci throughout the human genome and thus give a useful genetic “snap-shot” of a cell culture. Our work has shown that Jeffreys multilocus fingerprinting method can be applied to cell lines from a wide range of animals including reptiles, birds, fish and diverse mammals. It can also differentiate very closely related cell lines including those from the same mouse strain. Routine fingerprint analysis has enabled an unprecedented level of confidence in the consistency of cell stocks. Our results demonstrate that this straightforward method represents a powerful and readily interpreted system for cell authentication and exclusion of cross-contamination.     

DNA fingerprinting of human cell lines using PCR amplification of fragment length polymorphisms

Summary Methods for monitoring cell line identification and authentication include species-specific immunofluorescence, isoenzyme phenotyping, chromosome analysis, and DNA fingerprinting. Most previous studies of DNA fingerprinting of cell lines have used restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis. In this study, we examined the utility of an alternative and simpler method of cell line DNA fingerprinting—polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification of fragment length polymorphisms. Fourteen human cell lines previously found by other methods to be either related or disparate were subjected to DNA fingerprinting by PCR amplification of selected fragment length polymorphism loci. Cell identification patterns by this method were concordant with those obtained by isoenzyme phenotyping and restriction fragment length polymorphism-DNA fingerprinting, and were reproducible within and between assays on different DNA extracts of the same cell line. High precision was achieved with electrophoretic separation of amplified DNA products on high resolution agarose or polyacrylamide gels, and with fragment length polymorphism (FLP) loci-specific “allelic ladders” to identify individual FLP alleles. Determination of the composite fingerprint of a cell line at six appropriately chosen fragment length polymorphism loci should achieve a minimum discrimination power of 0.999. The ability of PCR-based fragment length polymorphism DNA fingerprinting to precisely and accurately identify the alleles of different human cell lines at multiple polymorphic fragment length polymorphism loci demonstrates the feasibility of developing a cell line DNA fingerprint reference database as a powerful additional tool for future cell line identification and authentication.     

Multilocus DNA fingerprint analysis of cellbanks: Stability studies and culture identification in human B-lymphoblastoid and mammalian cell lines

The technique of multilocus DNA fingerprinting has great potential for the authentication of animal cell cultures and in identification of cross-contamination. The Alec Jeffreys probes 33.6 and 33.15 were used as multilocus probes to demonstrate the consistent DNA fingerprint profiles in human peripheral blood and its derivative Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) transformed B-lymphoblastoid cultures maintained by repeated subculture for six months. However, fingerprint analysis of EBV transformed cultures generated from small numbers of cells showed that the majority (seven of eight cultures) had anomalous profiles. Some of these altered profiles shared common features not seen in the peripheral blood pattern. Analysis of seven murine hybridoma clones from a single fusion experiment revealed only two clones which could not be distinguished using probe 33.15. Further studies of master and distribution cell banks for eleven cell lines demonstrated consistent fingerprint profiles in all cases except one (U937). However, this cell line showed only minor differences in the master and distribution bank profiles. These data indicate that, while changes in fingerprint profile may be identified in exceptional instances, the multilocus fingerprinting method using probes 33.6 and 33.15 is a powerful and reliable tool in the quality control of animal cell cultures.     

Profiling and authentication of human cell lines using short tandem repeat (STR) loci: Report from the National Cell Bank of Iran.

Assurance of cell line homogeneity and capability of cell contamination detection are among the most essential steps of cell based research. Due to high discriminatory efficiency, low cost and reliability, analysis of short tandem repeats (STR) has been introduced as a method of choice for human cell line authentication. In the present study 13 Combined DNA Index System (CODIS) based STRs along with the gender determination (Amelogenin) gene were utilized to establish a reproducible approach for the authentication of 100 human cell lines deposited in the National Cell Bank of Iran (NCBI), using the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) method. PCR products were subsequently analyzed by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) and visualized by silver staining followed by gel documentation and software analysis. STR profiles obtained were compared with those of the American Type Culture Collection (ATCC) and the Japanese Collection of Research Bioresource (JCRB) as STR references. We detected 18.8% cross contamination among the NCBI human cell lines. To our knowledge, this is the first report of authentication of human cell lines using the 13 CODIS core STRs combined with Amelogenin.     

Efficient DNA fingerprinting method for the identification of cross-culture contamination of cell lines

In order to identify cross-culture contamination of cell lines, we applied DNA fingerprinting using variable number of tandem repeat (VNTR) loci and short tandem repeat (STR) loci amplified by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) instead of a radioisotope labeled multilocus probe. Eleven cell lines were used for the Apo B and D1S80 loci detection, and twelve cell lines were examined in the Y-chromosome analysis. The data obtained from the sister cell lines NALM-6 and B85, two MOLM-1 cultures from two cryopreserved tubes, and four subclones of BALM-9 and its sister cell line BALM-10, displayed clear and distinct bands of each PCR product for both Apo B and D1S80. Detection of a Y-chromosome DNA sequence is another very informative marker for the identification of cell lines, if the Y-chromosome is present. We examined eight cell lines for the expression of four STR loci; the data thus generated were compared with the results previously reported from other laboratories. The resulting electrophoretic banding patterns showed that our "home-made" STR detection system is a useful and efficient tool for the authentication of cell lines. PCR detection of VNTR and STR loci represents a simple, rapid and powerful DNA fingerprinting technique to authenticate human cell lines and to detect cross-culture contamination. This PCR technique may be used in lieu of the more time-consuming, labor-intensive and radioactive Southern blot multilocus method.     

Rapid identification and authentication of closely related animal cell culture by polymerase chain reaction

Animal cell lines are important resources for research and diagnostic applications. Cross-contamination and misidentification of cell lines, however, can cause major problems for research (for example, false results that come from contamination cells may mislead the science). Hence, it is imperative to routinely monitor cell lines for identity and authenticity. Here, we extend our previous work on identification and authentication of animal cell culture by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification and DNA sequencing. A PCR-based method for rapid identification and authentication of closely related cell lines was described. In this method, two new primers were designed based on high homology in the aldolase gene family. Used together with our previous primers, the combinations of primers were able to differentiate closely related species, including human from monkey and mouse from rat. This PCR assay provides a rapid, simple, sensitive, and cost-effective method for authentication of closely related cell lines. The findings and conclusions in this report are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the views of the funding agency.     

SNP array profiling of mouse cell lines identifies their strains of origin and reveals cross-contamination and widespread aneuploidy

Background

The crisis of Misidentified and contaminated cell lines have plagued the biological research community for decades. Some repositories and journals have heeded calls for mandatory authentication of human cell lines, yet misidentification of mouse cell lines has received little publicity despite their importance in sponsored research. Short tandem repeat (STR) profiling is the standard authentication method, but it may fail to distinguish cell lines derived from the same inbred strain of mice. Additionally, STR profiling does not reveal karyotypic changes that occur in some high-passage lines and may have functional consequences. Single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) profiling has been suggested as a more accurate and versatile alternative to STR profiling; however, a high-throughput method for SNP-based authentication of mouse cell lines has not been described.

Results

We have developed computational methods (Cell Line Authentication by SNP Profiling, CLASP) for cell line authentication and copy number analysis based on a cost-efficient SNP array, and we provide a reference database of commonly used mouse strains and cell lines. We show that CLASP readily discriminates among cell lines of diverse taxonomic origins, including multiple cell lines derived from a single inbred strain, intercross or wild caught mouse. CLASP is also capable of detecting contaminants present at concentrations as low as 5%. Of the 99 cell lines we tested, 15 exhibited substantial divergence from the reported genetic background. In all cases, we were able to distinguish whether the authentication failure was due to misidentification (one cell line, Ba/F3), the presence of multiple strain backgrounds (five cell lines), contamination by other cells and/or the presence of aneuploid chromosomes (nine cell lines).

Conclusions

Misidentification and contamination of mouse cell lines is potentially as widespread as it is in human cell culture. This may have substantial implications for studies that are dependent on the expected background of their cell cultures. Laboratories can mitigate these risks by regular authentication of their cell cultures. Our results demonstrate that SNP array profiling is an effective method to combat cell line misidentification.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/1471-2164-15-847) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

竹亚科叶绿体DNA条形码筛选

竹亚科是一个形态上鉴定困难且易于混淆的类群。DNA条形码技术为这一类群的鉴定提供了一个辅助手段。核心条形码（rbcL＋matK）在竹亚科中的鉴别率很低,因此．有必要针对竹亚科筛选有效的DNA条形码片段。本研究根据已发表的竹亚科叶绿体基因组序列,筛选出16个片段,包括1个基因片段和15个基因间隔区,选取青篱竹族和莉竹族的10属22种30个个体,进行引物通用性、测序成功率和变异位点分析。研究结果表明：（1）引物具有较高的扩增成功率,但部分片段中由于存在poly结构造成测序失败;（2）片段中的插入／缺失可以编码,作为信息位点;（3）trnG—trnT（t）具有最多变异位点,建议可作为竹亚科优先选择的DNA条形码;（4）在开展不同类群的DNA条形码和分子系统学研究时,可以按照“trnG—trnT（t）＋x”的方式选择合适的叶绿体DNA片段。     

Identification of newly established <Emphasis Type="Italic">Spodoptera littoralis</Emphasis> cell lines by two DNA barcoding markers

Cell line authentication is crucial in determining the identity of cell lines and detecting any cross-contamination. The identity of three newly established Spodoptera littoralis cell lines (Spli-C, Spli-B, and Spli-S) was confirmed by DNA fingerprinting. In this study, we used two universal primers sets to amplify two DNA fragments in different positions in the mitochondrial cytochrome C oxidase 1 gene (COI). The PCR reaction succeeded in amplifying two target DNA amplicons. The first amplicon had ~650 bp, while the second had ~410 bp. By comparing the obtained informative sequences with those in the GenBank sequence database, the results showed 100% similarity between the S. littoralis cell lines and their host. The same similarity ratio was observed between the Sf21, Tni, and Cp cell lines, which are used widely, and their hosts. The informative sequences were then used for phylogenetic analyses. In addition to the high efficiency of this technique, it showed high reproducibility in two different laboratories. DNA barcoding using the two sets of the universal primers used in this study can be a fast and a reliable method for insect cell line identification.     

Characterization and authentication of insect cell lines using RAPD markers

Random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) analysis was used to characterize 11 insect cell lines, including six from lepidoptera (five species), one from diptera and four from coleoptera (one species: Leptinotarsa decemlineata). Whatever the order and even when comparing two closely related species from the same genus (Spodoptera), the DNA fingerprints are very different from one species or from one primer to the other. On the other hand, two independently isolated cell lines from the lepidopteran Phthorimaea operculella produce nearly identical profiles with only minor differences. Finally, a statistical analysis based on Nei's similarity coefficient was performed on the fingerprints of four independent cell lines from the Colorado potato beetle, L. decemlineata. Each possesses a common recognizable pattern also found in field-collected insects, while also showing a series of polymorphic markers which allow one to distinguish each cell line from the three others. RAPD fingerprinting, together with the use of appropriate statistics, thus constitutes a highly specific method both for the authentication of the species from which a cell line was developed and for the individual characterization of each cell line from a given species.     

Polymorphism analysis of Haemophilus influenzae strains isolated from healthy children with respect to amplification reaction

The random-amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) assay was used to generate DNA fingerprints for 44 isolates H. influenzae obtained from healthy children. Problems with reproducibility and discriminatory power, frequently cited in the literature, were overcome by optimization procedure allowing to achieve reliable conditions for H. influenzae analysed. Particular parameters of RAPD fingerprinting were evaluated with respect to selection of best working primer, DNA polymerase and DNA concentration for amplification pattern. This study proved high sensitivity and efficiency of optimized RAPD profiling applicable for searching the epidemiology traces.     

Assessment of discriminatory power of three different fingerprinting methods based on killer toxin sensitivity for the differentiation of Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains

AIMS: A panel composed of 44 taxonomically certified strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae of different origin was used to evaluate the discriminatory power of three different fingerprinting methods based on sensitivity towards 24 killer toxins. METHODS AND RESULTS: Binary data matrix (BDM), triplet data matrix (TDM) and numerical data matrix (NDM) were used as fingerprinting methods. NDM possessed the highest discriminatory power, assessed through the Simpson's, and Hunter and Gaston's indices for the measurement of diversity. The upper limits of fingerprinting ability expressed by the three above methods have been also discussed. CONCLUSIONS: NDM determined a significant increase of discriminatory power than the use of BDM or TDM, in terms of an effective amplification of their fingerprinting efficacy. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: The NDM fingerprinting method could find application in control laboratories for the discrimination of yeast strains of industrial importance or covered by patent.     

Reducing amplification artifacts in high multiplex amplicon sequencing by using molecular barcodes

Background

PCR amplicon sequencing has been widely used as a targeted approach for both DNA and RNA sequence analysis. High multiplex PCR has further enabled the enrichment of hundreds of amplicons in one simple reaction. At the same time, the performance of PCR amplicon sequencing can be negatively affected by issues such as high duplicate reads, polymerase artifacts and PCR amplification bias. Recently researchers have made some good progress in addressing these shortcomings by incorporating molecular barcodes into PCR primer design. So far, most work has been demonstrated using one to a few pairs of primers, which limits the size of the region one can analyze.

Results

We developed a simple protocol, which enables the use of molecular barcodes in high multiplex PCR with hundreds of amplicons. Using this protocol and reference materials, we demonstrated the applications in accurate variant calling at very low fraction over a large region and in targeted RNA quantification. We also evaluated the protocol’s utility in profiling FFPE samples.

Conclusions

We demonstrated the successful implementation of molecular barcodes in high multiplex PCR, with multiplex scale many times higher than earlier work. We showed that the new protocol combines the benefits of both high multiplex PCR and molecular barcodes, i.e. the analysis of a very large region, low DNA input requirement, very good reproducibility and the ability to detect as low as 1 % mutations with minimal false positives (FP).

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12864-015-1806-8) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Comparison of Pre-Analytical FFPE Sample Preparation Methods and Their Impact on Massively Parallel Sequencing in Routine Diagnostics

Over the last years, massively parallel sequencing has rapidly evolved and has now transitioned into molecular pathology routine laboratories. It is an attractive platform for analysing multiple genes at the same time with very little input material. Therefore, the need for high quality DNA obtained from automated DNA extraction systems has increased, especially to those laboratories which are dealing with formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) material and high sample throughput. This study evaluated five automated FFPE DNA extraction systems as well as five DNA quantification systems using the three most common techniques, UV spectrophotometry, fluorescent dye-based quantification and quantitative PCR, on 26 FFPE tissue samples. Additionally, the effects on downstream applications were analysed to find the most suitable pre-analytical methods for massively parallel sequencing in routine diagnostics. The results revealed that the Maxwell 16 from Promega (Mannheim, Germany) seems to be the superior system for DNA extraction from FFPE material. The extracts had a 1.3–24.6-fold higher DNA concentration in comparison to the other extraction systems, a higher quality and were most suitable for downstream applications. The comparison of the five quantification methods showed intermethod variations but all methods could be used to estimate the right amount for PCR amplification and for massively parallel sequencing. Interestingly, the best results in massively parallel sequencing were obtained with a DNA input of 15 ng determined by the NanoDrop 2000c spectrophotometer (Thermo Fisher Scientific, Waltham, MA, USA). No difference could be detected in mutation analysis based on the results of the quantification methods. These findings emphasise, that it is particularly important to choose the most reliable and constant DNA extraction system, especially when using small biopsies and low elution volumes, and that all common DNA quantification techniques can be used for downstream applications like massively parallel sequencing.     

Value of morphotyping for the characterization of Candida albicans clinical isolates

Until recently, morphotyping, a method evaluating fringe and surface characteristics of streak colonies grown on malt agar, has been recommended as a simple and unexpensive typing method for Candida albicans isolates. The discriminatory power and reproducibility of Hunter's modified scheme of Phongpaichit's morphotyping has been evaluated on 28 C. albicans isolates recovered from the oral cavity of asymptomatic human immunodeficiency virus-positive subjects, and compared to two molecular typing methods: randomly amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) fingerprinting, and contour clamped homogeneous electric field (CHEF) electrophoretic karyotyping. Morphological features of streak colonies allowed to distinguish 11 different morphotypes while RAPD fingerprinting yielded 25 different patterns and CHEF electrophoresis recognized 9 karyotypes. The discriminatory power calculated with the formula of Hunter and Gaston was 0.780 for morphotyping, 0.984 for RAPD fingerprinting, and 0.630 for karyotyping. Reproducibility was tested using 43 serial isolates from 15 subjects (2 to 6 isolates per subject) and by repeating the test after one year storage of the isolates. While genetic methods generally recognized a single type for all serial isolates from each of the subjects studied, morphotyping detected strain variations in five subjects in the absence of genetic confirmation. Poor reproducibility was demonstrated repeating morphotyping after one year storage of the isolates since differences in at least one character were detected in 92.9% of the strains.     

Descriptive parameter evaluation in mammalian cell culture

Several methods exist for assessing population growth and protein productivity in mammalian cell culture. These methods were critically examined here, based on experiments with two hybridoma cell lines. It is shown that mammalian cell culture parameters must be evaluated on the same basis. In batch culture mode most data is obtained on a cumulative basis (protein product titre, substrate concentration, metabolic byproduct concentration). A simple numerical integration technique can be employed to convert cell concentration data to a cumulative basis (cell-hours). The hybridoma lines used in this study included a nutritionally non-fastidious line producing low levels of MAb and a nutritionally fastidious hybridoma with high productivity. In both cases the cell-hour approach was the most appropriate means of expressing the relationship between protein productivity and cell population dynamics. The cell-hour approach could be used as the basis for all metabolic population parameter evaluations. This method has the potential to be used successfully for both prediction and optimization purposes. This revised version was published online in August 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Reconstructing A/B compartments as revealed by Hi-C using long-range correlations in epigenetic data

Analysis of Hi-C data has shown that the genome can be divided into two compartments called A/B compartments. These compartments are cell-type specific and are associated with open and closed chromatin. We show that A/B compartments can reliably be estimated using epigenetic data from several different platforms: the Illumina 450 k DNA methylation microarray, DNase hypersensitivity sequencing, single-cell ATAC sequencing and single-cell whole-genome bisulfite sequencing. We do this by exploiting that the structure of long-range correlations differs between open and closed compartments. This work makes A/B compartment assignment readily available in a wide variety of cell types, including many human cancers.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s13059-015-0741-y) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

A proteomics approach to identifying fish cell lines

Fish cell lines are relatively easy to culture and most have simple growth requirements that make cross contamination a potential problem. Cell line contamination is not an uncommon incident in laboratories handling more than one cell line and many reports have been made on cross contamination of mammalian cell lines. Although problems of misidentification and cross-contamination of fish cell lines have rarely been reported, these are issues of concern for cell culturists that can make scientific results and their reproducibility unreliable. Proper identification of cell lines is thus crucial and protocols for routine and rapid screening are preferred. Cytogenetic evaluation, DNA fingerprinting, microsatellite analysis and PCR methods have been published for inter-species identification of many cell lines, but discerning intra-species contamination has been challenging. More complex DNA fingerprinting and hybridization techniques coupled with isoenzyme analysis have been developed to discriminate intra-species contamination, however, these require complex and time consuming procedures to enable cell identification thus are difficult to apply for routine use. A simple proteomic approach has been made to identify several fish cell lines derived from tissues of the same or differing species. Protein expression signatures (PES) of the evaluated fish cell lines have been developed using 2-DE and image analysis. A higher degree of concordance was seen among cell lines derived from rainbow trout, than from other fish species. Similar concordance was seen in cells derived from the same tissues than from other tissues within the same species. These profiles have been saved in an electronic databank and could be made available to be used for discerning the origins of the various cell lines evaluated. This proteomic approach could thus serve as an additional, valuable and reliable technique for the identification of fish cell lines.