Vagotomy and Pyloroplasty for Gastric Ulcer

In a series of 68 patients with gastric ulcer who were treated by vagotomy and pyloroplasty there were no operative deaths, though one patient who received massive transfusions died 14 weeks later from hepatic necrosis probably associated with serum hepatitis. Four patients developed recurrent peptic ulceration requiring further surgical treatment. The clinical condition of all but three of the remainder was satisfactory after an average follow-up period of three years and two months. Of the 14 patients who presented with an acutely bleeding gastric ulcer, one subsequently required gastrectomy for continued bleeding; in all the others the immediate and long-term results were satisfactory. Of 21 patients with a “high” ulcer and 29 with combined gastric and duodenal ulceration one (4·8%) and three (10%) respectively suffered recurrences. We conclude that vagotomy and pyloroplasty is a satisfactory form of treatment for a high or bleeding gastric ulcer, but that for all other gastric ulcers some form of gastric resection is preferable.     

Five- to Eight-year Results of Truncal Vagotomy and Pyloroplasty for Duodenal Ulcer

From January 1963 to December 1965 inclusive 192 men with duodenal ulcer were treated by elective truncal vagotomy and pyloroplasty with one death. Ten subsequent deaths were due to causes unrelated to the ulcer or operation, and 17 patients became untraceable. The remaining 164 patients have been followed up for five to eight years. The late results have been compared with those obtained in a previous study of patients five to eight years after truncal vagotomy and gastroenterostomy, truncal vagotomy and antrectomy, and subtotal gastrectomy respectively for duodenal ulcer.Of the various postgastric operation syndromes early dumping, late dumping, bilious vomiting, and diarrhoea were all less frequent, but not significantly so, after vagotomy and pyloroplasty than after vagotomy and gastroenterostomy.Recurrent ulceration was commoner after vagotomy and pyloroplasty than after all the other operations, the incidence of proved and suspected recurrent ulcers being respectively 6·7 and 7·3% after vagotomy and pyloroplasty, but only 2·5 and 5·9% after vagotomy and gastroenterostomy, 0 and 5·2% after vagotomy and antrectomy, and 0·9 and 3·7% after subtotal gastrectomy. The differences between vagotomy and pyloroplasty and vagotomy and antrectomy or subtotal gastrectomy are statistically significant, but those between vagotomy and pyloroplasty and vagotomy and gastroenterostomy are not.Overall assessment (Visick grading) of the outcome gave poorer results after vagotomy and pyloroplasty than after any other operation, with 14% of category IV cases after vagotomy and pyloroplasty, 11% after vagotomy and gastroenterostomy, 8% after vagotomy and antrectomy, and 6% after subtotal gastrectomy—differences that are significant between vagotomy and pyloroplasty and vagotomy and antrectomy or subtotal gastrectomy but not between vagotomy and pyloroplasty and vagotomy and gastroenterostomy.In the light of these findings it is suggested that truncal vagotomy and pyloroplasty has not lived up to expectations and its place as the currently most popular procedure in the elective surgical treatment of duodenal ulcer should be reconsidered.     

Effect of Posture on Glucose Tolerance after Gastric Surgery

Oral glucose tolerance after either partial gastrectomy or vagotomy and pyloroplasty for duodenal ulcer was markedly affected by posture. Peak blood glucoses and the degree of reactive hypoglycaemia were greater in the erect than in the supine position. This is probably due to positional changes in gastric emptying, and our findings support the view that after gastric surgery alteration in gastric emptying rate is the main factor responsible for the change in oral glucose tolerance.     

Effects of truncal,selective, and highly selective vagotomy on glucose tolerance and insulin secretion in patients with duodenal ulcer. Part I-Effect of vagotomy on response to oral glucose.

An oral glucose tolerance test was performed in patients who had undergone truncal vagotomy and pyloroplasty, bilateral selective vagotomy and pyloroplasty, or highly selective vagotomy without a drainage procedure at least six months earlier. The results were compared with those from patients with chronic duodenal ulcer before operation. In all three groups of patients after vagotomy more rapid rates of rise of blood glucose and higher peak concentrations were observed than in patients who were tested before operation. These differences were statistically significant only in patients who had undergone truncal or selective vagotomy with pyloroplasty and were probably due to more rapid rates of gastric emptying after these operations. Plasma insulin concentrations were lower after truncal vagotomy than after selective or highly selective vagotomy, the difference between truncal vagotomy and highly selective vagotomy being statistically significant. Truncal vagotomy resulted in a diminished insulin response to oral glucose, which could have been due to vagal denervation of the pancreas or, more probably, impaired release of small-bowel hormones which normally augment the pancreatic insulin response.     

Emergency Vagotomy and Pyloroplasty for Perforated Duodenal Ulcer: Study of 73 Cases

Seventy-three unselected patients with perforated duodenal ulcer were treated by vagotomy and pyloroplasty in a six-year period. Postoperative complications were commoner when the operation was carried out after more than six hours after perforation. The follow-up results were similar to those for elective vagotomy and pyloroplasty carried out in the hospital during the past nine years.     

What is the Best Elective Operation for Duodenal Ulcer?

During the past 40 years, after gastroenterostomy and pyloroplasty for duodenal ulcer had been replaced by partial gastrectomy in many centres, partial gastrectomy itself gave way to combinations of vagotomy with gastroenterostomy, pyloroplasty or antrectomy. Opinions differ concerning the procedure of choice and in this paper the author examines the causes of this diversity of opinion and assesses the reliability of conclusions that can be drawn about the elective treatment of duodenal ulcer today. Most reports of results from various operations have come from retrospective studies, and the causes of variability among such reports are analyzed to point out the great difficulty in making a valid judgment about the relative worth of the various operations used to treat duodenal ulcer. Results of some of the few prospective studies with randomized operations assessed blindly are then presented and note is taken of the surprising observation that greatly different operations appear to give remarkably similar results. From the data available the author develops a logical way of approaching the choice of operation for the various problems related to duodenal ulcer that require elective surgical treatment.     

Incidence of Dumping after Truncal and Selective Vagotomy with Pyloroplasty and Highly Selective Vagotomy without Drainage Procedure

The incidence of dumping after truncal or selective vagotomy with pyloroplasty and highly selective vagotomy without a drainage procedure was assessed both clinically and experimentally. At a gastric follow-up clinic dumping was found to be significantly less frequent in patients who had undergone highly selective vagotomy without a drainage procedure than in patients who had undergone truncal or selective vagotomy with pyloroplasty (P < 0·05 or < 0·001, respectively). Hypertonic glucose given by mouth provoked the onset of dumping in 20% of patients with duodenal ulcer before operation, in 73% after truncal vagotomy and pyloroplasty, in 80% after selective vagotomy and pyloroplasty, and in 47% after highly selective vagotomy. The test meal also produced significantly greater decreases in blood pressure and increases in pulse rate in patients who had undergone vagotomy with pyloroplasty than in patients who had undergone highly selective vagotomy.     

Vagotomy without Diarrhoea

The incidence of diarrhoea after three types of vagotomy was assessed “blind” at a gastric follow-up clinic one year after operation. Diarrhoea was recorded in 24% of patients after truncal vagotomy and pyloroplasty, in 18% after selective vagotomy and pyloroplasty, but in only 2% of patients after highly selective vagotomy without a drainage procedure. The incidence of diarrhoea was significantly less (P < 0·01) after highly selective vagotomy than after either of the other procedures.Hypertonic glucose solution given by mouth to 15 representative patients from each group and to 15 patients before operation provoked the onset of diarrhoea in 67% of the patients who had undergone truncal vagotomy and pyloroplasty, in 60% of those who had undergone selective vagotomy and pyloroplasty, in 13% of those who had undergone highly selective vagotomy without a drainage procedure, and in none of the preoperative patients. Again the difference between the “highly selective” group and the other two groups of vagotomized patients was statistically significant.It is suggested that postvagotomy diarrhoea is attributable both to unregulated gastric emptying after truncal or selective vagotomy with a drainage procedure and to the extragastric denervation produced by truncal vagotomy. “Postvagotomy” diarrhoea can be virtually eliminated by using highly selective vagotomy without a drainage procedure.     

VAGOTOMY—Clinical Results,with a Note on Temporary Gastrostomy

Sixty replies to questionnaires sent to more than 100 patients who had had vagotomy for peptic ulcer showed that 93 per cent had satisfactory results. There were no deaths in this series. Three times as many unsatisfactory results occurred in a group of patients who had had gastrectomy. There were no proved recurrent or marginal ulcers in either group.Vagotomy plus a complementary procedure has proved, in the author''s experience, to be the operation of choice in chronic duodenal ulcer. At present gastrectomy plus vagotomy appears to be less desirable than vagotomy plus pyloroplasty or gastroenterostomy.     

DUODENAL ULCER—Gastrectomy Versus Vagotomy with Accessory Procedures

Vagotomy should be added to whatever other surgical procedure is used in the treatment of duodenal ulcer. Vagotomy with pyloroplasty is the procedure of choice in most patients with duodenal ulcer. Gastroenterostomy and gastrectomy with vagotomy are procedures of necessity in certain clinical situations.     

Vagotomy for Gastric Ulcer

Out of a series of 75 patients who were treated by vagotomy and drainage for gastric ulcer 66 have been followed up for one to seven years (average three-and-a-half years). Four recurrent gastric ulcers occurred among the 33 cases of ulcer of the lesser curve or body with no antral or duodenal lesion (type I). Among the 42 patients with an antral ulcer or an associated active or healed pyloric or duodenal lesion (type II or III) there was only one recurrence. The recurrence rate for men was 5% and for women 12%. One patient died two years after operation from cancer which may have originated in the stomach. The clinical results in patients without recurrences were generally satisfactory.Vagotomy, preferably selective, with drainage is a satisfactory operation in gastric ulcers of types II and III. For ulcers of type I, gastrectomy is to be preferred except in selected cases.     

The Immediate Results of Operations for Duodenal Ulcer: A Comparative Study of the Morbidity and Mortality of Vagotomy and Pyloroplasty versus Subtotal Gastrectomy

Immediate postoperative results of vagotomy and pyloroplasty were compared with those of subtotal gastrectomy. Ulcer recurrence rate and the long-term complications of the two procedures were not studied. Age and sex distribution, and preoperative indications in the two groups of patients were almost identical. Vagotomy and pyloroplasty has gradually superseded subtotal gastrectomy at St. Michael''s Hospital, Toronto. One hundred and seventy vagotomy and drainage procedures were compared with 173 subtotal gastric resections performed over a five-year period. There were 39 postoperative complications and five deaths in the subtotal gastrectomy group, an overall mortality of 2.8% and an elective mortality of 2.4%. In the vagotomy and pyloroplasty group there were 31 postoperative complications and two deaths, an overall mortality of 1.2% and an elective mortality of zero. Vagotomy and pyloroplasty is a relatively safe procedure, associated with fewer complications, shorter hospital stay and a lower mortality than subtotal gastrectomy.     

Duodenal ulcer; gastrectomy versus vagotomy with accessory procedures

Vagotomy should be added to whatever other surgical procedure is used in the treatment of duodenal ulcer. Vagotomy with pyloroplasty is the procedure of choice in most patients with duodenal ulcer. Gastroenterostomy and gastrectomy with vagotomy are procedures of necessity in certain clinical situations.     

Endometriosis; a review

The Billroth I gastric resection, with and without vagotomy, was used in 20 selected cases of peptic ulcer. Vagotomy and pyloroplasty is considered the operation of first choice for duodenal ulcer. The cases for Billroth I resections were selected from cases not suitable for pyloroplasty. Operations for peptic ulcer which preserve the gastrointestinal continuity are considered to be physiologically superior. Vagotomy and pyloroplasty, and Billroth I gastric resection both qualify in this regard. The postoperative digestive symptoms after Billroth I gastric resection in the present series were minimal, which tends to confirm this theoretical superiority.     

Prospectively randomised trial of proximal gastric vagotomy either with or without pyloroplasty in treatment of uncomplicated duodenal ulcer.

A consecutive series of 100 men with uncomplicated duodenal ulcer was randomly divided into two groups: one group of 52 underwent proximal gastric vagotomy (PGV), the other group (48) underwent PGV with pyloroplasty (PGVP). Preoperative peak acid output (PAOP) was measured in all patients. Those with a higher preoperative PAOP were significantly more likely to develop recurrent ulceration. Three patients developed recurrent ulceration after PGV and seven after PGVP. Dumping was both more common and more severe after PGVP than PGV. An overall satisfactory result was achieved in 92% after PGV and 81% after PGVP. We conclude that combining pyloroplasty with PGV has no appreciable advantages.     

Pattern of Gastric Emptying after Vagotomy and Pyloroplasty

The pattern and rate of gastric emptying have been studied in 16 patients before and after vagotomy and pyloroplasty. The rate of emptying, expressed as half life in minutes, was not greatly changed by operation. After operation, however, there was a rapid initial phase of emptying, particularly marked in patients who had post-vagotomy diarrhoea.     

Use of Gastric Function Tests by British Gastroenterologists

A questionnaire was used to study the choice and use of gastric function tests by members of the British Society of Gastroenterology.Pentagastrin has largely replaced older drugs as the stimulant of choice for evoking maximal acid secretion. Insulin tests are being used in situations where they are unlikely to provide useful clinical information. Fewer physicians than surgeons measure gastric secretion, and they use tests less often. The reluctance of physicians to test patients with uninvestigated dyspepsia or gastric ulcer seems justified, but in patients having dyspepsia with negative x-ray films, or after gastrectomy or vagotomy, the greater investigative keenness of surgeons seems commendable. Only half the surgeons ever try to assess the completeness of their vagotomies, and in only one-third of this half is it their usual practice. Criticism is made of the practice of routine measurement of acid in patients with duodenal ulcer, and of the use of acid measurements to decide whether a patient should have surgery or which type of operation should be performed.     

Changes in gastric mucosa after vagotomy and gastrojejunostomy for duodenal ulcer.

Gastric mucosa was studied histologically in 141 patients. Eighty two had undergone vagotomy and gastrojejunostomy between 15 and 25 years previously for duodenal ulcer, and 59 control patients had a long history (minimum 15 years) of duodenal ulcer treated medically. No carcinoma was found in either group. Two patients with severe dysplasia and 13 patients with moderate dysplasia were found in the study group, compared with none in the control group (p less than 0.01). Intestinal metaplasia was seen in 44 (53%) of the study group and 16 (27%) of the control group (p less than 0.01). Atrophy and gastritis were more severe (p less than 0.01 for atrophy; p = 0.05 for gastritis) in the study group. Gastric mucosal changes were more severe after surgical treatment for duodenal ulcer than after medical treatment, and possibly a high incidence of gastric carcinoma may occur 25 years after vagotomy and gastrojejunostomy.     

Treatment of severe side effects after vagotomy and gastroenterostomy by closure of gastroenterostomy without pyloroplasty.

We describe nine patients who had severe, persistent abdominal pain, vomiting, dumping, or diarrhoea several years after truncal vagotomy and gastroenterostomy had been performed for duodenal ulceration. Each patient was judged to have a bad clinical result (Visick grade 4). There was no evidence of recurrent ulceration in any of the patients, and in each the patency of the pyloric canal was confirmed radiologically or endoscopically. Each patient was treated by simply dismantling the gastroenterostomy without addition for a pyloroplasty. In one patient the surgeon suspected that a vagal trunk might have been left intact, and a revagotomy was performed by the "highly selective" technique. Postoperatively, none of the patients developed gastric retention. Symptomatic improvement occurred in eight patients, and four of them achieved perfect results (Visick grade 1). Side effects are common after vagotomy and gastroenterostomy, and are largely attributable to the presence of the gastroenterostomy stoma. Our results show that the symptoms may be alleviated by closing the gastroenterostomy, without precipitating gastric retention.     

Selective Vagotomy without Drainage. An Interim Report

The results of surgical treatment for duodenal ulcer were compared in two groups of patients—51 who had undergone selective vagotomy without drainage and 17 who had had selective vagotomy and pyloroplasty. It is suggested that in the absence of organic pyloric or duodenal stenosis the former method seems both preferable and desirable, since postoperativley dumping does not occur and there is a steady improvement in gastric emptying.