Nuclear—organelle interactions: the immutans variegation mutant of Arabidopsis is plastid autonomous and impaired in carotenoid biosynthesis

The immutans (im) variegation mutant of Arabidopsis thaliana contains green- and white-sectored leaves due to the action of a nuclear recessive gene. The mutation is somatically unstable, and the degree of sectoring is influenced by light and temperature. Whereas the cells in the green sectors contain normal chloroplasts, the cells in the white sectors are heteroplastidic and contain non-pigmented plastids that lack organized lamellar structures, as well as small pigmented plastids and/or rare normal chloroplasts. This indicates that the plastids in im white cells are not affected equally by the nuclear mutation and that the expression of immutans is ‘plastid autonomous’. In contrast to other variegation mutants with heteroplastidic cells, the defect in im is not maternally inherited. immutans thus represents a novel type of nuclear gene-induced variegation mutant. It has also been found that the white tissues of immutans accumulate phytoene, a non-colored C₄₀ carotenoid intermediate. This suggests that immutans controls, either directly or indirectly, the activity of phytoene desaturase (PDS), the enzyme that converts phytoene to zeta-carotene in higher plants. However, im is not the structural gene for PDS. A secondary effect of carotenoid deficiency, both in immutans and in wild-type plants treated with a herbicide that blocks carotenoid synthesis, is an increase in acid ribonuclease activity in white tissue. It is concluded that the novel variegation generated by the immutans mutation should offer great insight into the complex circuitry that regulates nuclear—organelle interactions.     

Complementary genes control biparental plastid inheritance in Pelargonium

Summary Zonal pelargoniums exhibit biparental plastid inheritance. After G x W plastid crosses the progeny are a mixture of green, variegated and white embryos corresponding to a maternal, biparental or paternal inheritance of plastids, respectively. There are two patterns of segregation: type-I females have families in which the majority of embryos are green, variegated are of intermediate frequency and white are the least frequent. Type-II females have families in which green and white embryos are present at about the same frequency and variegated are the least common. The results of many selfs and crosses made within and between 8 type-I and 8 type-II plants led us to conclude that the type of female was determined by its genotype with respect to a pair of complementary genes. Plants giving rise to the type-II pattern contained one or two copies of the dominant alleles of both genes, whereas in the absence of either one or both dominant alleles the plants were type I. The genes were called Pr1/pr1 and Pr2/pr2, an adaptation of symbolism used previously. All 8 type IIs were double heterozygotes Pr1pr1, Pr2pr2, whereas we found 3 genotypes among the type Is, Pr1Pr1, pr2pr2; pr1pr1, Pr2Pr2 and pr1pr1, Pr2pr2. In unrelated experiments we found type IIs of which some were again double heterozygotes and others single heterozygotes Pr1pr1, Pr2Pr2 or Pr1Pr1, Pr2pr2. The model displaces an earlier model based on the proposed operation of a gametophytic lethal or incompatibility system.     

High transmission of paternal plastid DNA in alfalfa plants demonstrated by restriction fragment polymorphic analysis

Summary A high frequency of paternal plastid transmission occurred in progeny from crosses among normal green alfalfa plants. Plastid transmission was analyzed by hybridization of radiolabeled alfalfa plastid DNA (cpDNA) probes to Southern blots of restriction digests of the progeny DNA. Each probe revealed a specific polymorphism differentiating the parental plastid genomes. Of 212 progeny, 34 were heteroplastidic, with their cpDNAs ranging from predominantly paternal to predominantly maternal. Regrowth of shoots from heteroplasmic plants following removal of top growth revealed the persistence of mixed plastids in a given plant. However, different shoots within a green heteroplasmic plant exhibited paternal, maternal, or mixed cpDNAs. Evidence of maternal nuclear genomic influence on the frequency of paternal plastid transmission was observed in some reciprocal crosses. A few tetraploid F₁ progeny were obtained from tetraploid (2n=4x=32) Medicago sativa ssp. sativa x diploid (2n=2x=16) M. sativa ssp. falcata crosses, and resulted from unreduced gametes. Here more than the maternal genome alone apparently functioned in controlling plastid transmission. Considering all crosses, only 5 of 212 progeny cpDNAs lacked evidence of a definitive paternal plastid fragment.Contribution No. 89-524-J from the Kansas Agricultural Experiment Station, Kansas State University, Manhattan     

The mechanism of the mixed inheritance of chloroplast genes in Pelargonium

Summary The distributions are given of gene frequencies among embryos after G X W and W X G plastid crosses within and between eight Pelargonium cultivars and some of their inbred or hybrid derivatives.Two distinct segregation patterns are recognized. Homozygous type I female parents (Pr₁Pr₁) have a high frequency of progeny with only maternal alleles, are intermediate for biparental and low for paternal offspring. Heterozygous type II female plants (Pr₁Pr₂) have an equally high frequency of maternal and paternal offspring and a generally low biparental frequency. These correspond to L-shaped and U-shaped gene frequency distributions respectively in which the only modes are at 0 per cent (maternal embryos) and 100 per cent (paternal embryos), with no mode corresponding to the population mean and no sign of a Gaussian distribution.The extremely variable plastid gene frequencies are strongly influenced by the maternal nuclear genotype and by the plastid genotype in which the wild-type allele is always more successful than the mutant in strict comparisons.The relative frequencies of maternal and paternal zygotes, and the mean gene frequency among all the zygotes in a cross, are explicable in terms of the input frequencies of genes from the two parents, their degree of mixing, and by some form of selective replication of plastids. This selection is controlled by nuclear and plastid genotypes which may act in the same direction, to increase the frequency of either the maternal or the paternal alleles, or in opposition. But selection alone is inadequate to explain the shapes of the gene frequency distributions. Instead, a model is proposed in which the segregation or replication of plastids appears to have a strong random element, which results in random drift of gene frequencies within a heteroplasmic zygote or embryo.     

A Search for the Rare Type II (G > V < W) Plastid Segregation Pattern among Cultivars of Pelargonium?Hortorum Bailey

The type II plastid segregation pattern, in which green andwhite offspring are approximately equally frequent and variegatedfew after G ? W plastid crosses, is produced by female genotypesheterozygous for a nuclear gene, Pr₁ Pr₃. As the Pr³ alleleis rarely passed on from mother to offspring, its maintenancein the population is likely to be difficult, and heterozygotescarrying the allele are expected to be uncommon. This is borneout by an analysis of Pelargonium cultivars.     

Polar lipid composition of a plastid ribosome-deficient barley mutant

Green and white leaves of the barley mutant line `albostrians' were compared for their polar lipid content and fatty acid composition. The mutant plastids of the white leaves have a double-layered envelope, but in contrast with the normal chloroplasts, lack 70 S ribosomes and thylakoids. In the green leaves, the amount of monogalactosyldiacylglycerol (MGDG) consistently exceeds the amount of digalactosyldiacylglycerol (DGDG) and the amount of galactolipids exceeds the amount of phospholipids. In contrast, in white leaves the amount of DGDG exceeds the amount of MGDG and the amount of phospholipids exceeds the amount of galactolipids. In white leaves, the galactolipid composition reflects the plastid envelope composition which is rich in DGDG, whereas in green leaves the galactolipid composition reflects the thylakoid composition which is rich in MGDG. These results demonstrate the likelihood that all the enzymes involved in galactolipid, sulfolipid and fatty acid synthesis are coded by the nuclear genome.     

Aspects of the biochemistry and ultrastructure of a cytoplasmically inherited plastid defect (Dp1) of tobacco

Dpl, a cytoplasmically inherited plastid defect of Nicotiana tabacum L., has been further characterized by pigment and ribulose diphosphate carboxylase (RuDPCase) assays and electron microscopy. RuDPCase activity was reduced in defective plastids to 20–67% of that in normal chloroplasts. The chlorophyll content was reduced to 5% or less of that in normal chloroplasts. Leaf areas with only defective plastids were very light green for several days after the leaf began to expand but eventually turned white. This loss of chlorophyll was correlated with a reduction in internal plastid lamellae, but there was much less reduction in RuDPCase activity. The presence of cells with both mutant and normal plastids indicate that the plastid and not some other cytoplasmic factor was the site of the controlling unit.Scientific Paper No. 3812, College of Agriculture, Washington State University, Pullman, Projects 1916 and 1920. Supported in part by funds provided for medical and biological research by Washington State Initiative Measure 171.     

Somatic instability of carotenoid biosynthesis in the tomato ghost mutant and its effect on plastid development

The tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum (L.) Mill.) ghost plant is a mutant of the San Marzano cultivar affected in carotenoid biosynthesis. ghost plants exhibit a variable pattern of pigment biosynthesis during development. Cotyledons are green but true leaves are white. Green sectors, which appear to be clonal in origin, are frequently observed in the white tissue. Because of the lack of photosynthesis ghost plants have a very low viability in soil. We have developed a strategy for propagating ghost plants that employs organ culture to generate variegated green-white plants which, supported by the photosynthetic green areas, develop in soil to almost wild-type size. These plants were used to analyze the pigment content of the different tissues observed during development and plastid ultrastructure. Cotyledons and green leaves contain both colored carotenoids and chlorophyll but only the colorless carotenoid phytoene accumulates in white leaves. the plastids in the white tissue of ghost leaves lack internal membrane structures but normal chloroplasts can be observed in the green areas. The chromoplasts of white fruits are also impaired in their ability to form thylakoid membranes.     

Influence of parental genotype on plastid inheritance in Medicago sativa

Research using chlorophyll-deficient mutants has shown that plastids are inherited biparentally in Medicago sativa L. (alfalfa). Variation in plastid transmission behavior was observed among crosses in earlier studies, but it was not determined whether this variation was under genetic control. In my research, genetic analyses of the frequencies of normal (G), chlorophyll-deficient (CD), and sectored (G and CD) progenies produced from G x CD crosses demonstrated that plastid inheritance patterns in alfalfa are influenced by both maternal and paternal genotypes. A strong paternal bias in plastid transmission existed in the majority of crosses despite the potential developmental disadvantages associated with paternally contributed CD plastids. The high frequencies of uniparental progenies suggest that genetic control of plastid inheritance in alfalfa may be exerted through effects on the number and distribution of maternal and paternal plastids early in embryo development.     

Early steps in plastid evolution: current ideas and controversies

Some nuclear‐encoded proteins are imported into higher plant plastids via the endomembrane (EM) system. Compared with multi‐protein Toc and Tic translocons required for most plastid protein import, the relatively uncomplicated nature of EM trafficking led to suggestions that it was the original transport mechanism for nuclear‐encoded endosymbiont proteins, and critical for the early stages of plastid evolution. Its apparent simplicity disappears, however, when EM transport is considered in light of selective constraints likely encountered during the conversion of stable endosymbionts into fully integrated organelles. From this perspective it is more parsimonious to presume the early evolution of post‐translational protein import via simpler, ancestral forms of modern Toc and Tic plastid translocons, with EM trafficking arising later to accommodate glycosylation and/or protein targeting to multiple cellular locations. This hypothesis is supported by both empirical and comparative data, and is consistent with the relative paucity of EM‐based transport to modern primary plastids.     

Control of plastid division by means of nuclear DNA amount

Summary For a given cell type and genotype a close positive correlation exists between the number of plastids in a cell and the amount of DNA in the nucleus. Comprehensive evidence is presented. The duplication of the DNA amount entails an increase of the plastid number in differentiating cells by about 70%. Exceptions reported in the literature are critically examined. The odds are in favour of the assumption that exceptions to the rule which are not due to special circumstances do not exist. In meristematic cells even a duplication of the plastid number will occur, for cells without plastids are not to be found. The plastids are always ready to divide, the interpretation goes, but the size of their populations is limited by the amount of nuclear DNA. Thus meristematic cells manage to control their plastid populations by releasing once in a cell cycle the brakes imposed upon plastid division, whereupon the plastids make use of their newly won freedom, dividing until the old ratio between plastid number and nuclear DNA amount is established again. As a shorter time is needed for plastid division than for mitosis, there is no danger of cells arising without plastids; no distributing mechanism is required if at least three to four plastids are present in a cell. The findings are consistent with and would appear to be best explained by the theory of the symbiotic origin of the plastids.     

Streptomycin and lincomycin resistances are selective plastid markers in cultured Nicotiana cells

Summary Resistance to streptomycin and lincomycin in plant cell culture is used as a color marker: resistant cells are green whereas sensitive cells are white on the selective medium. Streptomycin and lincomycin at appropriate concentrations do not kill sensitive Nicotiana cells. The selective value of plastid ribosomal DNA mutations, conferring resistance to streptomycin and lincomycin, was investigated by growing heteroplastidic cells on a selective medium. The heteroplastidic cells were obtained by protoplast fusion, and contained a mixed population of streptomycin resistant plastids from the N. tabacum line Nt-SR1-Kan2, and lincomycin resistant plastids from the N. plumbaginifolia line Np-LR400-Hyg1. Clones derived from protoplast fusion were selected by kanamycin and hygromycin resistance, transgenic nuclear markers. Somatic hybrids were then grown on a selective streptomycin or lincomycin medium, or in the absence of either drug to a 50 to 100 mg size callus. Southern analysis of a polymorphic region of plastid DNA (ptDNA) revealed that somatic hybrids grown on streptomycin contained almost exclusively ptDNA from the streptomycin resistant parent, somatic hybrids grown on lincomycin contained almost exclusively ptDNA from the lincomycin resistant parent whereas somatic hybrids grown in the absence of either drug contained mixed parental plastids. Sensitive ptDNA was below detection level in most clones on selective medium, but could be recovered upon subsequent culture in the presence of the appropriate drug. The drugs streptomycin and lincomycin provide a powerful selection pressure that should facilitate recovery of plastid transformants.     

Extreme variation in rates of evolution in the plastid Clp protease complex

Eukaryotic cells represent an intricate collaboration between multiple genomes, even down to the level of multi‐subunit complexes in mitochondria and plastids. One such complex in plants is the caseinolytic protease (Clp), which plays an essential role in plastid protein turnover. The proteolytic core of Clp comprises subunits from one plastid‐encoded gene ( clpP1 ) and multiple nuclear genes. The clpP1 gene is highly conserved across most green plants, but it is by far the fastest evolving plastid‐encoded gene in some angiosperms. To better understand these extreme and mysterious patterns of divergence, we investigated the history of clpP1 molecular evolution across green plants by extracting sequences from 988 published plastid genomes. We find that clpP1 has undergone remarkably frequent bouts of accelerated sequence evolution and architectural changes (e.g. a loss of introns and RNA ‐editing sites) within seed plants. Although clpP1 is often assumed to be a pseudogene in such cases, multiple lines of evidence suggest that this is rarely true. We applied comparative native gel electrophoresis of chloroplast protein complexes followed by protein mass spectrometry in two species within the angiosperm genus Silene , which has highly elevated and heterogeneous rates of clpP1 evolution. We confirmed that clpP1 is expressed as a stable protein and forms oligomeric complexes with the nuclear‐encoded Clp subunits, even in one of the most divergent Silene species. Additionally, there is a tight correlation between amino acid substitution rates in clpP1 and the nuclear‐encoded Clp subunits across a broad sampling of angiosperms, suggesting continuing selection on interactions within this complex.     

Genome-based reconstruction of the protein import machinery in the secondary plastid of a chlorarachniophyte alga

Most plastid proteins are encoded by their nuclear genomes and need to be targeted across multiple envelope membranes. In vascular plants, the translocons at the outer and inner envelope membranes of chloroplasts (TOC and TIC, respectively) facilitate transport across the two plastid membranes. In contrast, several algal groups harbor more complex plastids, the so-called secondary plastids, which are surrounded by three or four membranes, but the plastid protein import machinery (in particular, how proteins cross the membrane corresponding to the secondary endosymbiont plasma membrane) remains unexplored in many of these algae. To reconstruct the putative protein import machinery of a secondary plastid, we used the chlorarachniophyte alga Bigelowiella natans, whose plastid is bounded by four membranes and still possesses a relict nucleus of a green algal endosymbiont (the nucleomorph) in the intermembrane space. We identified nine homologs of plant-like TOC/TIC components in the recently sequenced B. natans nuclear genome, adding to the two that remain in the nucleomorph genome (B. natans TOC75 [BnTOC75] and BnTIC20). All of these proteins were predicted to be localized to the plastid and might function in the inner two membranes. We also show that the homologs of a protein, Der1, that is known to mediate transport across the second membrane in the several lineages with secondary plastids of red algal origin is not associated with plastid protein targeting in B. natans. How plastid proteins cross this membrane remains a mystery, but it is clear that the protein transport machinery of chlorarachniophyte plastids differs from that of red algal secondary plastids.