Oxidative stress-alleviating strategies to improve recombinant protein production in CHO cells

Large scale biopharmaceutical production of biologics relies on the overexpression of foreign proteins by cells cultivated in stirred tank bioreactors. It is well recognized and documented fact that protein overexpression may impact host cell metabolism and that factors associated with large scale culture, such as the hydrodynamic forces and inhomogeneities within the bioreactors, may promote cellular stress. The metabolic adaptations required to support the high-level expression of recombinant proteins include increased energy production and improved secretory capacity, which, in turn, can lead to a rise of reactive oxygen species (ROS) generated through the respiration metabolism and the interaction with media components. Oxidative stress is defined as the imbalance between the production of free radicals and the antioxidant response within the cells. Accumulation of intracellular ROS can interfere with the cellular activities and exert cytotoxic effects via the alternation of cellular components. In this context, strategies aiming to alleviate oxidative stress generated during the culture have been developed to improve cell growth, productivity, and reduce product microheterogeneity. In this review, we present a summary of the different approaches used to decrease the oxidative stress in Chinese hamster ovary cells and highlight media development and cell engineering as the main pathways through which ROS levels may be kept under control.     

Azadirachtin production in stirred tank reactors by Azadirachta indica suspension culture

Successful scale-up of Azadirachta indica suspension culture for azadirachtin production was done in stirred tank bioreactor with two different impellers. The kinetics of biomass accumulation, nutrient consumption and azadirachtin production of A. indica cell suspension culture were studied in a stirred tank bioreactor equipped with centrifugal impeller and compared with similar bioreactor with a setric impeller to investigate the role of O₂ transfer efficiency of centrifugal impeller bioreactor on overall culture metabolism. The maximum cell mass for centrifugal impeller bioreactor and stirred tank bioreactor (with setric impeller) were 18.7 and 15.5 g/L (by dry cell weight) and corresponding azadirachtin concentrations were 0.071 and 0.05 g/L, respectively. Glucose and phosphate were identified as the major growth-limiting nutrients during the bioreactor cultivation. The centrifugal impeller bioreactor demonstrated less shearing and improved O₂ transfer than the stirred tank bioreactor equipped with setric impeller with respect to biomass and azadirachtin production.     

Broth rheology, growth and metabolite production of Beta vulgaris suspension culture: a comparative study between cultures grown in shake flasks and in a stirred tank

Cells of Beta vulgaris have the ability to grow in a stirred tank under an impeller tip speed as high as 95.3 cm seg⁻¹. Comparing this system with cultures performing in shake flasks, a decrease of the cell concentration, betalains production, and growth rate was observed. However, the kinetic profiles of aggregates size and cellular viability were practically the same. The cultures carried out in the fermentor showed a major accumulation of extracellular arabinogalactoprotein and polysaccharide, which is an indication of the cell response to hydrodynamic stress. These extracellular molecules produced a considerable change in the rheology of cell-free medium. This change in the rheology can be playing an important role in the reduction of the actual hydrodynamic stress during cultivation.     

Monoterpenoid oxindole alkaloid production by Uncaria tomentosa (Willd) D.C. cell suspension cultures in a stirred tank bioreactor

Cell growth, monoterpenoid oxindole alkaloid (MOA) production, and morphological properties of Uncaria tomentosa cell suspension cultures in a 2-L stirred tank bioreactor were investigated. U. tomentosa (cell line green Uth-3) was able to grow in a stirred tank at an impeller tip speed of 95 cm/s (agitation speed of 400 rpm), showing a maximum biomass yield of 11.9 +/- 0.6 g DW/L and a specific growth rate of 0.102 d(-1). U. tomentosa cells growing in a stirred tank achieved maximum volumetric and specific MOA concentration (467.7 +/- 40.0 microg/L, 44.6 +/- 5.2 microg/g DW) at 16 days of culture. MOA chemical profile of cell suspension cultures growing in a stirred tank resembled that of the plant. Depending on culture time, from the total MOA produced, 37-100% was found in the medium in the bioreactor culture. MOA concentration achieved in a stirred tank was up to 10-fold higher than that obtained in Erlenmeyer flasks (agitated at 110 rpm). In a stirred tank, average area of the single cells of U. tomentosa increased up to 4-fold, and elliptical form factor increased from 1.40 to 2.55, indicating enlargement of U. tomentosa single cells. This work presents the first report of U. tomentosa green cell suspension cultures that grow and produce MOA in a stirred tank bioreactor.     

Effect of aggregate size in cell cultures of<Emphasis Type="Italic"> Saussurea medusa</Emphasis> on cell growth and jaceosidin production

Cell suspension cultures of Saussurea medusa were grown in shake flasks and a 5-l stirred tank bioreactor. Biomass and jaceosidin distribution in cell aggregates of different sizes were investigated during the cultivation period. The results showed that on day 10, jaceosidin accumulation showed an increase with increasing size of the cell aggregate to 4 mm in diameter, with the highest jaceosidin accumulation being 12.2 mg/g. An inverse tendency was observed with cell aggregates larger than 4 mm in diameter, with the lowest accumulation being 3.1 mg/g. However, all of the cell aggregates, despite their size, synthesized almost the same amount of jaceosidin at day 12. Oxygen diffusion limitation and cell-cell contact may explain this behavior. In comparison with cells cultivated in shake flasks, decreased biomass and decreased jaceosidin concentration were observed when the cells were cultivated in a stirred tank bioreactor. The sublytic effects caused by the hydrodynamic stress in combination with insufficient nutrients in the bioreactor may cause cell damage.     

Hydrodynamic effects on BHK cells grown as suspended natural aggregates

Baby hamster kidney (BHK) cell aggregates grown in stirred vessels with different working volumes and impeller sizes were characterized. Using batch cultures, the range of agitation rates studied (25-100 rpm) led to aggregates with maximum sizes of 150 mum. Necrotic centers were not observed and cell specific productivity was independent of aggregate size. High cell viability was found for both single and adherent cells without an increase in cell death when agitation rate was increased. The increase in agitation rate affected aggregates by reducing their size and increasing their concentration and cell concentration in aggregates, while increasing the fraction of free cells in suspension. The experimental relationship between aggregate size and power dissipation rate per unit of mass was close to -1/4, suggesting a correlation with a critical turbulence microscale; this was independent of vessel scale and impeller geometry over the range investigated. Viscous stresses in the viscous dissipation subrange (below Kolmogoroff eddies) appear to be responsible for aggregate breakage. Under intense agitation BHK cells grown in the absence of microcarriers existed as aggregates without cell damage, whereas cells grown on the surface of microcarriers were largely reduced. This is a clear advantage for scaleup purposes if aggregates are used as a natural immobilization system in stirred vessels. (c) 1995 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Induction of mammalian cell death by simple shear and extensional flows

In this work we investigated whether the type of shear flow, to which cells are exposed, influences the initiation of cell death. It is shown that mammalian cells, indeed, distinguish between discrete types of flow and respond differently. Two flow devices were employed to impose accurate hydrodynamic flow fields: uniform steady simple shear flow and oscillating extensional flow. To distinguish between necrotic and apoptotic cell death, fluorescence activated cell sorting and the release of DNA in the culture supernatant was used. Results show that Chinese Hamster Ovaries and Human Embryonic Kidney cells will enter the apoptotic pathway when subjected to low levels of hydrodynamic stress (around 2.0 Pa) in oscillating, extensional flow. In contrast, necrotic death prevails when the cells are exposed to hydrodynamic stresses around 1.0 Pa in simple shear flow or around 500 Pa in extensional flow. These threshold values at which cells enter the respective death pathway should be avoided when culturing cells for recombinant protein production to enhance culture longevity and productivity. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2009; 104: 360–370 © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Effect of shear stress on anthraquinones production by Rubia tinctorum suspension cultures

Suspension cultures of Rubia tinctorum, an anthraquinones (AQs) producer, were grown both in Erlenmeyer flasks at 100 rpm and in a 1.5 L mechanically stirred tank bioreactor operating at 450 rpm. The effect of hydrodynamic stress on cell viability, biomass, and AQs production was evaluated. Cell viability showed a transient decrease in the bioreactor during the first days, returning to the initial values toward the end of the culture time. The biomass obtained in the bioreactor was 29% lower than that attained in the Erlenmeyer flasks. The H2O2 production in the bioreactor (with peaks at 7 and 10 days) was about 15 times higher than that obtained in the flasks. A clear relationship exists between the maximum concentration of H2O2 generated and AQs produced. The AQs content in the bioreactor was 233% higher than that in the Erlenmeyer flasks. The AQs specific productivity in the stirred tank and in the Erlenmeyer flasks was 70.7 and 28.5 micromol/g FW/day, respectively. This production capability was maintained in the regrowth assays. On the other hand, the negative effects of hydrodynamic stress on viability and biomass concentration observed in the bioreactor culture were reverted in the regrowth cultures. It can be concluded that R. tinctorum suspension cultures are able to grow in stirred tanks at 450 rpm responding to the hydrodynamic stress with higher concentrations of AQs, which suggest the possibility of a technological approach taking advantage of this phenomenon.     

Comparison of manufacturing techniques for adenovirus production

We have compared three different production methods, which may be suitable for the large scale production of adenovirus vectors for human clinical trials. The procedures compared 293 cells adapted to suspension growth in serum-free medium in a stirred tank bioreactor, 293 cells on microcarriers in serum-containing medium in a stirred tank bioreactor, and 293 cells grown in standard tissue culture plasticware. With a given virus, yields varied between 2000 and 10,000 infectious units/cell. The stirred tank bioreactor routinely produced between 4000 and 7000 infectious units/cell when 293 cells were grown on microcarriers. The 293 cells adapted to suspension growth in serum-free medium in the same stirred tank bioreactor yielded between 2000 and 7000 infectious units/cell. Yields obtained from standard tissue culture plasticware were up to 10,000 infectious units/cell. Cell culture conditions were monitored for glucose consumption, lactate production, and ammonia accumulation. Glucose consumption and lactate accumulation correlated well with the cell growth parameters. Ammonia production does not appear to be significant. Based on virus yields, ease of operation and linear scalability, large-scale adenovirus production seems feasible using 293 cells (adapted to suspension/serum free medium or on microcarriers in serum containing medium) in a stirred tank bioreactor. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Influence of aeration–homogenization system in stirred tank bioreactors,dissolved oxygen concentration and pH control mode on BHK-21 cell growth and metabolism

This work focused on determining the effect of dissolved oxygen concentration (DO) on growth and metabolism of BHK-21 cell line (host cell for recombinant proteins manufacturing and viral vaccines) cultured in two stirred tank bioreactors with different aeration-homogenization systems, as well as pH control mode. BHK-21 cell line adapted to single-cell suspension was cultured in Celligen without aeration cage (rotating gas-sparger) and Bioflo 110, at 10, 30 and 50 % air saturation (impeller for gas dispersion from sparger-ring). The pH was controlled at 7.2 as far as it was possible with gas mixtures. In other runs, at 30 and 50 % (DO) in Bioflo 110, the cells grew at pH controlled with CO₂ and NaHCO₃ solution. Glucose, lactate, glutamine, and ammonium were quantified by enzymatic methods. Cell concentration, size and specific oxygen consumption were also determined. When NaHCO₃ solution was not used, the optimal DOs were 10 and 50 % air saturation for Celligen and Bioflo 110, respectively. In this condition maximum cell concentrations were higher than 4 × 10⁶ cell/mL. An increase in maximum cell concentration of 36 % was observed in batch carried out at 30 % air saturation in a classical stirred tank bioreactor (Bioflo 110) with base solution addition. The optimal parameters defined in this work allow for bioprocess developing of viral vaccines, transient protein expression and viral vector for gene therapy based on BHK-21 cell line in two stirred tank bioreactors with different agitation–aeration systems.     

Production of anti‐inflammatory compounds in Sphaeralcea angustifolia cell suspension cultivated in stirred tank bioreactor

Sphaeralcea angustifolia is a plant used for the treatment of inflammatory processes. Scopoletin, tomentin, and sphaeralcic acid were identified as the compounds with anti‐inflammatory and immunomodulatory effects. Successful establishment of the cell culture in Erlenmeyer flasks has been reported previously. The aim of this study was to evaluate the ability of cells in suspension from S. angustifolia grown in a stirred tank bioreactor and demonstrate their capacity to produce bioactive compounds. Cells in suspension grown at 200 rpm reached a maximal cell biomass in dry weight at 19.11 g/L and produced 3.47 mg/g of sphaeralcic acid. The mixture of scopoletin and tomentin was only detected at the beginning of the culture (12.13 μg/g). Considering that the profile of dissolved oxygen during the cultures was lesser than 15%, it is possible that the low growth at 100 rpm could be due to oxygen limitations or to cell sedimentation. At 400 rpm, a negative effect on cell viability could be caused by the increase in the hydrodynamic stress, including the impeller tip, average shear rate, and Reynolds number. The sphaeralcic acid content in the cell suspension of S. angustifolia obtained in the bioreactor was two orders of magnitude greater than that reported for the culture grown in Erlenmeyer flasks.     

A viscous pump bioreactor

The fluid dynamic design and characterization of a low mechanical stress agitator and bioreactor vessel for large-scale bioprocessing using anchorage dependent mammalian cells is considered. The complex and fragile nature of mammalian cells puts stringent constraints on the design of agitators for stirred tank bioreactors. Traditional agitators have difficulty meeting the competing requirements of fluidization and mixing while maintaining low enough mechanical stress levels to avoid cell damage. A rotating disc agitator design is proposed. Flow visualization and laser Doppler velocimeter measurements reveal fluidization of microcarriers with a gentle (low turbulence level), highly three-dimensional flow characterized by good mixing at low hydrodynamic shear stress levels.     

An analysis of organism lifelines in an industrial bioreactor using Lattice-Boltzmann CFD

Euler-Lagrange CFD simulations, where the biotic phase is represented by computational particles (parcels), provide information on environmental gradients inside bioreactors from the microbial perspective. Such information is highly relevant for reactor scale-down and process optimization. One of the major challenges is the computational intensity of CFD simulations, especially when resolution of dynamics in the flowfield is required. Lattice-Boltzmann large-eddy simulations (LB-LES) form a very promising approach for simulating accurate, dynamic flowfields in stirred reactors, at strongly reduced computation times compared to finite volume approaches. In this work, the performance of LB-LES in resolving substrate gradients in large-scale bioreactors is explored, combined with the inclusion of a Lagrangian biotic phase to provide the microbial perspective. In addition, the hydrodynamic performance of the simulations is confirmed by verification of hydrodynamic characteristics (radial velocity, turbulent kinetic energy, energy dissipation) in the impeller discharge stream of a 29 cm diameter stirred tank. The results are compared with prior finite volume simulation results, both in terms of hydrodynamic and biokinetic observations, and time requirements.     

New milliliter‐scale stirred tank bioreactors for the cultivation of mycelium forming microorganisms

A novel milliliter‐scale stirred tank bioreactor was developed for the cultivation of mycelium forming microorganisms on a 10 milliliter‐scale. A newly designed one‐sided paddle impeller is driven magnetically and rotates freely on an axis in an unbaffled reaction vessel made of polystyrene. A rotating lamella is formed which spreads out along the reactor wall. Thus an enhanced surface‐to‐volume ratio of the liquid phase is generated where oxygen is introduced via surface aeration. Volumetric oxygen transfer coefficients (k_La) > 0.15 s^?1 were measured. The fast moving liquid lamella efficiently prevents wall growth and foaming. Mean power consumption and maximum local energy dissipation were measured as function of operating conditions in the milliliter‐scale stirred tank bioreactor (V = 10 mL) and compared to a standard laboratory‐scale stirred tank bioreactor with six‐bladed Rushton turbines (V = 2,000 mL). Mean power consumption increases with increasing impeller speed and shows the same characteristics and values on both scales. The maximum local energy dissipation of the milliliter‐scale stirred tank bioreactor was reduced compared to the laboratory‐scale at the same mean volumetric power input. Hence the milliliter impeller distributes power more uniformly in the reaction medium. Based on these data a reliable and robust scale‐up of fermentation processes is possible. This was demonstrated with the cultivation of the actinomycete Streptomyces tendae on both scales. It was shown that the process performances were equivalent with regard to biomass concentration, mannitol consumption and production of the pharmaceutical relevant fungicide nikkomycin Z up to a process time of 120 h. A high parallel reproducibility was observed on the milliliter‐scale (standard deviation < 8%) with up to 48 stirred tank bioreactors operated in a magnetic inductive drive. Rheological behavior of the culture broth was measured and showed a highly viscous shear‐thinning non‐Newtonian behavior. The newly developed one‐sided paddle impellers operated in unbaffled reactors on a 10 milliliter‐scale with a magnetic inductive drive for up to 48 parallel bioreactors allows for the first time the parallel bioprocess development with mycelium forming microorganisms. This is especially important since these kinds of cultivations normally exhibit process times of 100 h and more. Thus the operation of parallel stirred tank reactors will have the potential to reduce process development times drastically. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2010; 106: 443–451. © 2010 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Power consumption and maximum energy dissipation in a milliliter‐scale bioreactor

Mean power consumption and maximum local energy dissipation were measured as function of operating conditions of a milliliter‐scale stirred tank bioreactor (V = 12 mL) with a gas‐inducing impeller. A standard laboratory‐scale stirred tank bioreactor (V = 1,200 mL) with Rushton turbines was used as reference. The measured power characteristics (Newton number as function of Reynolds number) were the same on both scales. The changeover between laminar and turbulent flow regime was observed at a Reynolds number of 3,000 with the gas‐inducing stirrer on a milliliter‐scale. The Newton number (power number) in the turbulent flow regime was 3.3 on a milliliter‐scale, which is close to values reported for six‐blade Rushton turbines of standard bioreactors. Maximum local energy dissipation (ε_max) was measured using a clay/polymer flocculation system. The maximum local energy dissipation in the milliliter‐scale stirred tank bioreactor was reduced compared with the laboratory‐scale stirred tank at the same mean power input per unit mass (ε_ø), yielding ε_max/ε_ø ≈ 10 compared with ε_max/ε_ø ≈ 16. Hence, the milliliter‐scale stirred tank reactor distributes power more uniformly in the reaction medium. These results are in good agreement with literature data, where a decreasing ε_max/ε_ø with increasing ratio of impeller diameter to reactor diameter is found (d/D = 0.7 compared with d/D = 0.4). Based on these data, impeller speeds can now be easily adjusted to achieve the same maximum local energy dissipation at different scales. This enables a more reliable and robust scale‐up of bioprocesses from milliliter‐scale to liter‐scale reactors. © 2009 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 2010     

The tubular loop batch fermentor: Basic concepts

A tubular loop batch fermentor has been designed and constructed, and was found to behave in a similar manner to a conventional stirred tank reactor. It appeared that foaming could be greatly reduced as no air ever encountered the impeller. The fluid mechanics of pipe flow are considerably simpler than tank flow patterns. On this basis a design procedure for a large scale tubular fermentor was outlined, which had considerable advantages over the more complex scale-up problems of a tank fermentor.     

The effect of particle morphology and concentration on the directly measured yield stress in filamentous suspensions

The influence of concentration (mass and volume fraction) and particle morphology on the yielding properties of filamentous broths ofAspergillus niger and Strepto-myces levoris was investigated using the rotating vane technique and compared with those of pulp suspensions. Two methods were applied to determine the volume fraction of the cells growing in filamentous form: the measurement of interstitial volume using a high molecular weight dye or dextran, and the measurement of dewatered broth filter cake volume by displacement using a pycnometer. The latter method provided the most reliable results. Cell concentrations ranging from 3 to 20 g dw/L, with corresponding volume fractions between 0.005 and 0.05, were obtained with broths generated in stirred tank and shake flask fermentations. The yield stress values obtained using the vane technique (0.1 相似文献   

A novel centrifugal impeller bioreactor. I. Fluid circulation, mixing, and liquid velocity profiles

A novel centrifugal impeller bioreactor for shear-sensitive biological systems was designed by installing a centrifugal-pumplike impeller in a stirred vessel. The fluid circulation, mixing, and liquid velocity profiles in the new bioreactor (5-L) were assessed as functions of the principal impeller designing and bioreactor operating parameters. The performances of the centrifugal impeller bioreactor were compared with those of a widely used cell-lift bioreactor. The newly developed bioreactor showed higher liquid lift capacity and shorter mixing time than the cell lift with comparable dimensions. Furthermore, the experiments of the liquid velocity profiles around an impeller region indicated that the centrifugal impeller bioreactor produced lower shear stress than the cell lift. This conclusion was also supported by evaluating the changes in size distributions of granulated agar particles that were sheared with those two types of impeller.     

Continuous alpha-amylase production using Bacillus amyloliquefaciens adsorbed on an ion exchange resin

Summary A method for the continuous production of extracellular alpha amylase by surface immobilized cells of Bacillus amyloliquefaciens NRC 2147 has been developed. A large-pore, macroreticular anionic exchange resin was capable of initially immobilizing an effective cell concentration of 17.5 g DW/1 (based on a total reactor volume of 160 ml). The reactor was operated continuously with a nutrient medium containing 15 g/l soluble starch, as well as yeast extract and salts. Aeration was achieved by sparging oxygen enriched air into the column inlet. Fermentor plugging by cells was avoided by periodically substituting the nutrient medium with medium lacking in both soluble starch and yeast extract. This fermentor was operated for over 200 h and obtained a steady state enzyme concentration of 18700 amylase activity units per litre (18.7 kU/l), and an enzyme volumetric productivity of 9700 amylase activity units per litre per hour (9.7 kU/l-h). Parallel fermentations were performed using a 2 l stirred vessel fermentor capable of operation in batch and continuous mode. All fermentation conditions employed were identical to those of the immobilized cell experiments in order to assess the performance of the immobilized cell reactor. Batch stirred tank operation yielded a maximum amylase activity of 150 kU/l and a volumetric productivity of 2.45 kU/l-h. The maximum cell concentration obtained was 5.85 g DW/l. Continuous stirred tank fermentation obtained a maximum effluent amylase activity of 6.9 kU/l and a maximum enzyme volumetric productivity of 2.73 kU/l-h. Both of these maximum values were observed at a dilution rate of 0.345 l/h. The immobilized cell reactor was observed to achieve larger volumetric productivities than either mode of stirred tank fermentation, but achieved an enzyme activity concentration lower than that of the batch stirred tank fermentor.     

Physiological responses of CHO cells to repetitive hydrodynamic stress

A majority of the previous investigations on the hydrodynamic sensitivity of mammalian cells have focused on lethal effects as determined by cell death or lysis. In this study, we investigated the effect of hydrodynamic stress on CHO cells in a fed‐batch process using a previously reported system which subjects cells to repetitive, high levels of hydrodynamic stress, quantified by energy dissipation rate (EDR). The results indicated that cell growth and monoclonal antibody production of the test cells were very resistant to the hydrodynamic stress. Compared to the control, no significant variation was observed at the highest EDR tested, 6.4 × 10⁶ W/m³. Most product quality attributes were not affected by intense hydrodynamic stress either. The only significant impact was on glycosylation. A shift of glycosylation pattern was observed at EDR levels at or higher than 6.0 × 10⁴ W/m³, which is two orders of magnitude lower than the EDR where physical cell damage, as measured by lactate dehydrogenase release, was observed. While not as extensively investigated, a second monoclonal antibody produced in a different CHO clone exhibited the same glycosylation change at an intensive EDR, 2.9 × 10⁵ W/m³. Conversely, a low EDR of 0.9 × 10² W/m³ had no effect on the glycosylation pattern. As 6.0 × 10⁴ W/m³, the lowest EDR that triggers the glycosylation shift, is about one order of magnitude higher than the estimated, maximum EDR in typically operated, large‐scale stirred tank bioreactors, further studies in a lower EDR range of 1 × 10³–6.0 × 10⁴ W/m³ are needed to assess the glycosylation shift effect under typical large‐scale bioreactor operation conditions. Follow‐up studies in stirred tanks are also needed to confirm the glycosylation shift effect and to validate the repetitive hydrodynamic stress model. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2009;103: 1103–1117. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.