Screening for resistance against Myzus persicae and Macrosiphum euphorbiae among wild Solanum

As a consequence of selection for productive traits, the genetic diversity of Solanum tuberosum cultivars has been drastically reduced. With the goal to develop aphid-resistant potato cultivars, our objective was to quantify the resistance of 14 accessions belonging to five wild potato species ( Solanum chomatophilum , Solanum stoloniferum stoloniferum , Solanum bukasovii , Solanum marinasense and Solanum medians ) against two aphid pests, Myzus persicae and Macrosiphum euphorbiae . Aphids were reared under controlled conditions in microcages clipped on the abaxial face of mature leaves of the Solanum species. The five wild Solanum species induced more than 90% of nymph mortality in M. persicae . The mortality rate of Ma. euphorbiae was also >90% on all S. chomatophilum , S. stoloniferum and S. medians accessions and on S. bukasovii -PI 414155. When enough adult aphids emerged, that is for Ma. euphorbiae on three S. bukasovii and three S. marinasense accessions, the prereproductive period, the adult survival and fecundity were assessed. These parameters allowed us to calculate the intrinsic rate of natural increase ( r_m ), the finite rate of increase and the population doubling time (DT). The r_m and the finite rate of increase were significantly reduced, whereas the population's DT was significantly enhanced for most (five out of six) wild Solanum accessions. All accessions of S. chomatophilum , S. stoloniferum and S. medians and S. bukasovii -PI 414155 were highly resistant to both M. persicae and Ma. euphorbiae . In conclusion, S. chomatophilum -PI 310943 and -PI 310990, and S. stoloniferum -PI 195167, -PI 201855 and -PI 275248, can be amenable for potato breeding programmes.     

温度对桃蚜和马铃薯长管蚜实验种群生命表参数的影响

【目的】桃蚜Myzus persicae (Sulzer)和马铃薯长管蚜Macrosiphum euphorbiae (Thomas)是2种主要的马铃薯害虫。本研究旨在明确温度对这两种马铃薯蚜虫生长发育、存活、繁殖及种群增长的影响。【方法】在室内测定了5个温度（10, 15, 20, 25和30℃）下桃蚜和马铃薯长管蚜的生长发育、存活和繁殖指标,并组建了4个恒温条件下（10,15,20和25℃）的实验种群生命表。【结果】在10~25℃范围内,2种蚜虫的若蚜期、世代历期、成蚜寿命和产蚜期等均随温度的升高而缩短,而30℃高温抑制了其发育、存活和繁殖。2种蚜虫的平均世代历期（T）随温度的升高而缩短,桃蚜和马铃薯长管蚜分别从10℃的30.08 d和35.35 d缩短至25℃的14.28 d和12.95 d。桃蚜的净增殖率（R₀）在15℃时最高（86.00）,其次为20℃（73.75）,再次为25℃（62.49）,最低为10℃（51.00）;马铃薯长管蚜的R0在15℃最高（58.97）,其次为10℃（51.98）,再次为20℃（48.94）,最低为25℃（12.36）。桃蚜的内禀增长率（r_m）随温度的升高而增大,从最小10℃的0.1307增大到25℃的0.2896;马铃薯长管蚜的r_m在20℃时最大（0.2182）,其次为25℃（0.1942）,再次为15℃（0.1485）,最小为10℃（0.1118）。在相同的温度下,桃蚜的发育速率、净增殖率和内禀增长率均高于马铃薯长管蚜。【结论】温度对2种马铃薯蚜虫的生长发育、存活、繁殖及种群增长有显著的影响,桃蚜在马铃薯上的种群增长能力强于马铃薯长管蚜。这一结果为马铃薯蚜虫预测模型的建立奠定了必要的基础,并解释了桃蚜在马铃薯上发生数量多于马铃薯长管蚜的原因。     

The resistance of three Solanum species to Myzus persicae, Macrosiphum euphorbiae and Aulacorthum solani (Aphididae: Homoptera)

A study was made of the resistance of three wild potato species, Solanum chacoense, S. stoloniferum and S. demissum, to three aphid species, namely Myzus persicae (Sulz.), Aulacorthum solani (Kalt.) and Macrosiphum euphorbiae (Thomas), which all commonly infest the cultivated potato, S. tuberosum. The resistance of each Solanum species differed with the species of aphid, with the part of the plant and with the physiological condition of the leaf. As a result, it may be difficult to utilize such resistance, since it is ineffective against some of the pest aphid species and may break down as the physiological condition of the plant changes.     

Characterization of polymorphic microsatellite loci in the aphid species Macrosiphum euphorbiae (Hemiptera: Aphididae)

Fourteen microsatellite loci were isolated and characterized in the potato aphid, Macrosiphum euphorbiae Thomas, by screening a genomic library with the oligonucleotide probes (GA)₁₀ (GT)₁₀ and (GATA)₄. Allelic diversity was estimated in samples collected from potato fields in Tunisia. Ten loci displayed polymorphism that ranged from two to four alleles per locus and the observed heterozygosity ranged from zero to one. These markers could be used to study the population genetic structure of this polyphagous aphid species.     

Studies on the morphometry of the green peach aphid, Myzus persicae (Sulzer) (Homoptera: Aphididae)

Aphids are one of the most important groups of phytophagous insects because of their polyphenism, host alternation, heteroecious behavior and reproductive habits. Laboratory culture of the aphid Myzus persicae on the host plant Brassica pekinensis Hubner was maintained seasonally for biometrical studies. The metric analysis revealed gradual developmental changes from the first instar nymph to the adult stage in size, shape, and a number of characters. The transitional changes were sufficiently distinct to allow differentiation of each of the life stages irrespective of the season. A key to the nymphal stages of the pest is provided.     

Role of host‐plant selection in resistance of wild Solanum species to Macrosiphum euphorbiae and Myzus persicae

Damage to potatoes by Macrosiphum euphorbiae (Thomas) and Myzus persicae (Sulzer) (both Hemiptera: Aphididae) can be controlled through plant resistance. We used ethological experiments and electric penetration graph (EPG) analysis to evaluate the role of host selection in the previously assessed resistance levels of Solanum accessions: Solanum circaeifolium Bitter subsp. capsicibaccatum (Cárdenas) (PI210036), S. chomatophilum Bitter (PI243340 and PI310990), S. okadae Hawkes & Hjert. (PI458367), S. oplocense Hawkes (PI473368), S. pinnatisectum Dunal (PI186553), S. polyadenium Greenm. (PI230463), S. tarijense Hawkes (PI414150), and S. trifidum Correll (PI255538), to M. euphorbiae and M. persicae. Through multivariate analysis, we grouped behavioural variables into factors, which we related to host selection behaviours, and then evaluated whether factors varied between each accession and the susceptible S. tuberosum. None of the factors obtained by ethological experiments differed among accessions. Four of six and three of five factors obtained through EPG varied among accessions for M. euphorbiae and M. persicae, respectively, and were used to suggest resistance characteristics. The resistance to M. persicae of both S. chomatophilum accessions was associated with pathway activity disturbance. Solanum tarijense and S. polyadenium resistance to M. persicae resulted from leaf surface characteristics, which may be trichomes. Solanum oplocense and S. trifidum resistance to M. euphorbiae resulted from the wound response system, whereas S. pinnatisectum resistance may stem from nutritionally unbalanced or toxic phloem sap. Solanum polyadenium resistance to M. euphorbiae was phloem‐based. Solanum circaeifolium ssp. capsicibaccatum resistance to M. persicae, and the resistance of PI243340 S. chomatophilum and S. tarijense to M. euphorbiae were not related to host selection and therefore were presumably due to physiologically active compounds.     

Effect of eggplant transformed with oryzacystatin gene on Myzus persicae and Macrosiphum euphorbiae

Abstract:  The effect of a genetically modified eggplant line expressing oryzacystatin on Myzus persicae (Sulzer) and Macrosiphum euphorbiae (Thomas) was examined. The transgenic eggplant reduced the net reproductive rate ( R ₀), the instantaneous rate of population increase ( r ), and the finite rate of population increase ( λ ) of both aphids species compared with a control eggplant line. The mean generation time ( T ) of the aphids was unaffected by the transgenic plants. Age-specific mortality rates of M. persicae and M. euphorbiae were higher on transgenic plants. These results indicate that expression of oryzacystatin in eggplant has a negative impact on population growth and mortality rates of M. persicae and M. euphorbiae and could be a source of plant resistance for pest management of these aphids.     

An interval timer controls the production of sexual morphs in Myzus persicae (Homoptera: Aphididae)

Abstract The interval timer mechanism was examined in two clones of Myzus persicae (Sulzer) originating from peach in Naousa, North Greece. Overwintering eggs were collected in April 1997 and after egg hatch the morphs of progeny were recorded at LD 10 : 14 h and 17 °C until the appearance of sexuals. In one clone, observations were continued until the 21st generation after egg hatch. In addition, the production of sexual morphs was examined in two other clones originating from Lehonia, Central Greece, when apterae (wingless females) were transferred from long to short days and 17 °C in the second and eighth generation of parthenogenetic rearing after their collection from peach trees. In clones from Naousa, the first gynoparae appear and comprise 10% of alate (winged) females in the second half of the third generation after egg hatch. The percentage of gynoparae increased in each consecutive generation, reaching 100% in fifth and seventh generations in clones Nb and Na, respectively. First males appeared later than gynoparae, in fifth and sixth generation in clones Nb and Na, respectively. In clone Nb, the number of males, after their appearance in fifth generation, was relatively constant from the sixth to the ninth generation (10.8–12.3). Then a significant increase was observed in the 10th generation, thereafter remaining relatively constant until the 21st generation (18.1–19.8). A similar trend in the number of males produced was observed in clones deriving from Lehonia.     

Comparative analysis of Solanum stoloniferum responses to probing by the green peach aphid Myzus persicae and the potato aphid Macrosiphum euphorbiae

Abstract Plants protect themselves against aphid attacks by species‐specific defense mechanisms. Previously, we have shown that Solanum stoloniferum Schlechtd has resistance factors to Myzus persicae Sulzer (Homoptera: Aphididae) at the epidermal/mesophyll level that are not effective against Macrosiphum euphorbiae Thomas (Homoptera: Aphididae). Here, we compare the nymphal mortality, the pre‐reproductive development time, and the probing behavior of M. persicae and M. euphorbiae on S. stoloniferum and Solanum tuberosum L. Furthermore, we analyze the changes in gene expression in S. stoloniferum 96 hours post infestation by either aphid species. Although the M. euphorbiae probing behavior shows that aphids encounter more probing constrains on phloem activities–longer probing and salivation time– on S. stoloniferum than on S. tuberosum, the aphids succeeded in reaching a sustained ingestion of phloem sap on both plants. Probing by M. persicae on S. stoloniferum plants resulted in limited feeding only. Survival of M. euphorbiae and M. persicae was affected on young leaves, but not on senescent leaves of S. stoloniferum. Infestation by M. euphorbiae changed the expression of more genes than M. persicae did. At the systemic level both aphids elicited a weak response. Infestation of S. stoloniferum plants with a large number of M. persicae induced morphological changes in the leaves, leading to the development of pustules that were caused by disrupted vascular parenchyma and surrounding tissue. In contrast, an infestation by M. euphorbiae had no morphological effects. Both plant species can be regarded as good host for M. euphorbiae, whereas only S. tuberosum is a good host for M. persicae and S. stoloniferum is not. Infestation of S. stoloniferum by M. persicae or M. euphorbiae changed the expression of a set of plant genes specific for each of the aphids as well as a set of common genes.     

矿物油处理对马铃薯长管蚜定向和取食行为的影响（英文）

大田和实验室研究均表明矿物油的施用可有效降低蚜虫对非持久性病毒的传播。我们分别于矿物油喷施马铃薯植株24 h和7 d后,调查其对马铃薯长管蚜Macrosiphum euphorbiae行为的影响;采用暗室生测法调查了蚜虫对处理的植物挥发性化合物的反应;采用刺探电位技术（EPG）评价了矿物油处理对蚜虫取食行为的影响。结果表明：矿物油处理导致植物对寄主的引诱作用失效,这种效果至少持续24 h。矿物油处理马铃薯植株24 h和7 d后,蚜虫对处理植株的取食行为发生改变。开始记录至第1次刺探所需时间降低,但只在处理7 d后显著降低,提示矿物油处理有助于蚜虫口针的穿刺。然而,流涎阶段以及韧皮部汁液吸食阶段（摄食阶段）显著缩短。本研究中观察到的蚜虫行为的改变不能充分解释施用矿物油的大田中为什么出现7 d 的保护作用,因此可能还存在其他的机制。     

B型烟粉虱取食诱导烟草对烟蚜防御反应的时间效应

为了明确B型烟粉虱Bemisia tabaci取食诱导烟草对烟蚜Myzus persicae的防御反应和时间效应,探讨外来入侵害虫B型烟粉虱取食诱导的烟草防御反应在其与桃蚜种间竞争中的作用,本研究采用小叶笼法和生化分析法,分别研究了B型烟粉虱取食诱导烟草对烟蚜生长发育的影响和烟草主要营养指标的变化。结果表明：B型烟粉虱取食诱导的烟草可对烟蚜产生明显的防御反应,对烟蚜的存活和生长发育有显著的抑制作用和时间效应。在烟粉虱若虫危害烟草至第5天,烟草系统白脉叶片上烟蚜的死亡率较对照叶片上烟蚜的死亡率升高36.13%;至第10天死亡率升高72.78%,且平均相对生长率较对照显著降低;至第15天死亡率升高仍达58.89%。在烟粉虱若虫危害至第10天时,将处理植株上的烟粉虱的若虫虫体去除,然后在烟草系统白脉叶片上接烟蚜1龄若蚜,在去虫后15 d内,烟草系统白脉叶片对烟蚜死亡率及相对生长率的影响较不去虫的对照间均有明显差异（P<0.05）。但至去虫后第20天,对烟蚜的不利影响即消失。研究表明B型烟粉虱取食诱导的烟草系统白脉叶片对烟蚜的抗性能持续表达15 d左右。烟粉虱危害后的局部带虫叶片与对照相比,对烟蚜的生长发育没有明显的不利影响。B型烟粉虱危害的烟草,其可溶性糖和可溶性蛋白的含量降低,这与烟蚜的死亡率表现出显著的负相关性。     

桃蚜对不同单色光趋性反应的测定

为了探讨蚜虫对不同色光选择反应的定量指标, 采用滤光片技术测定了有翅和无翅桃蚜Myzus persicae对不同波长单色光的趋性反应。结果表明: 有翅蚜对490~550 nm范围内的单色光表现出明显趋性, 其中对538.9和549.9 nm的绿偏黄色光趋性最强, 平均位移分别达25.29和22.97 cm, 其次为491.5 nm的蓝绿色光, 而对于波长576.0 nm的黄色光并没有表现出明显趋性。无翅蚜对不同单色光的趋性反应则没有明显的峰值, 最高相对平均位移仅1.41。行为测定结果与前人电生理测定的结果基本一致, 说明以位移作为小体昆虫趋光性强弱的指标是可靠的。     

Diurnal Patterns in Host Finding by Potato Aphids, Macrosiphum euphorbiae (Homoptera: Aphididae)

Potato aphid, Macrosiphum euphorbiae (Homoptera: Aphididae), is an abundant potato pest and vector of potato leaf-roll virus and potato virus Y in Maine and other potato growing areas. We investigated the circadian rhythmicity of its movement towards host plant odor. Effects of daily cycle (day or night) and illumination (light or dark) on the proportion of aphids colonizing potato leaflets were determined in a Petri plate arena and in a Y-tube olfactometer. In Petri dishes, both daily cycle and light had a highly significant effect on plant colonization. Increasing temperature reduced aphid colonization of the leaflets. In the olfactometer, light had a significant effect on the proportion of aphids walking towards the host plant. Interaction between time and light was also statistically significant, with the effect of illumination being smaller during the day than during the night. Our results suggest that circadian rhythm in host-finding behavior of the potato aphid is regulated by both exogenous and endogenous mechanisms.     

Mass Rearing of Aphidius gifuensis (Hymenoptera: Aphidiidae) for Biological Control of Myzus persicae (Homoptera: Aphididae)

The green peach aphid, Myzus persicae, is a major pest of tobacco, Nicotiana tabacum, in Yunnan province, China, where its control still depends on the use of insecticides. In recent years, the local government and farmers have sought to improve the biological control of this tobacco pest. In this paper, we present methods for mass rearing Aphidius gifuensis, a dominant endoparasitoid of M. persicae on tobacco plants in this region. The tobacco cultivar K326 (N. tabacum) was used as the host plant and M. persicae as the host insect. In the greenhouse, we collected tobacco seedlings for about 35 days (i.e., until the six-true-leaf stage), transferred them to 7.5-cm diameter pots, and kept these plants in the greenhouse for another 18 days. These pots were then transferred to an insectary-greenhouse, where the tobacco seedlings were inoculated with five to seven wingless adult M. persicae per pot. After 3 days, the infested seedlings were moved to a second greenhouse to allow the aphid population to increase, and after an additional 4±1 days when 182±4.25 aphid adults and nymphs were produced per pot, they were inoculated with A. gifuensis. With this rearing system, we were able to produce 256±8.8 aphid mummies per pot, with an emergence rate of 95.6±2.45%; 69% were females. The daily cost of parasite production (recurring costs only) was US$ 0.06 per 1000 aphid mummies. With this technique, we released 109 800 parasitoids in 1998, 196 000 in 1999, 780 000 in 2000, and 5 600 000 in 2001 during a 2-month period each year. This production method is discussed with respect to countrywide usage in biological control and integrated control of M. persicae.     

Inheritance of partial resistance to the leaf aphids Macrosiphum euphorbiae and Uroleucon sonchi in lettuce

The genetics of partial resistance (PR) of lettuce to the leaf aphid species Macrosiphum euphorbiae and Uroleucon sonchi was studied in F₁ and F₂ generations of six crosses between four cultivars. Partial resistance inherited mainly additively. With M. euphorbiae the estimates of broad-sense F₂ heritability were low and non-significant in crosses between parents of the same resistance level (S x S and PR x PR), and high (0.69-0.76) in crosses between parents of different resistance level (PR x S). The level of resistance in lettuce cultivars ‘Charan’ and ‘Marbello’ led to a marked reduction in percentage of plants with colonies of M. euphorbiae in a field experiment. With U. sonchi the highest estimates of F₂ heritability were found in ‘Charan x ‘Avoncrisp’ (0.51) and ‘Charan’ x ‘Chou de Naples' (0.48). In the cross ‘Charan’ x ‘Marbello’ (PR x PR) no significant segregation for resistance to M. euphorbiae was found, indicating that these cultivars may have the same genetic constitution for resistance to M. euphorbiae.‘Charan’ has additional genes for resistance to U. sonchi, that are not, or only weakly linked to the gene(s) for resistance to M. euphorbiae. The heritability estimates for the partial resistance to M. euphorbiae and U. sonchi indicate that it is possible to effectively select for these traits in plant breeding programmes.     

Factors affecting sporulation and germination of Pandora nouryi (Entomophthorales: Entomophthoraecae), a pathogen of Myzus persicae (Homoptera: Aphididae)

Pandora nouryi discharged large numbers of primary conidia between 8 and 25°C from cadavers on the surface of water-agar. At 8°C conidial discharge lasted for 120 h, but most conidia were produced within 48 h when temperature was >15°C. Saturated humidity alone was not enough to allow for sporulation to occur freely and where RH?<?95%, no conidia were discharged. Light did not affect the pattern of conidial production nor the total number of conidia. Germination percentages of conidia on the surface of water-agar were 40 and 66% at 8 and 30°C, respectively, and were significantly lower than that at 15–25°C where germination was >95%. Conidia on leaves germinated well when RH?>?74%, while no germination occurred when RH?<?100% on cover slips. All eight insecticides tested entirely inhibited conidial germination at recommended doses (R), in particular, both the organophosphorus pesticides Lorsben (chlorpyrifos) and the organochlorine pesticides Thiodan (endosulfan) completely inhibited conidial germination even at 0.2R dose.     

取食B型烟粉虱前侵染的烟草对B型烟粉虱和烟蚜体内保护酶和消化酶活性的影响

前期研究发现, 重要的外来入侵害虫B型烟粉虱Bemisia tabaci在烟草植株上对烟蚜Myzus persicae具有明显的种间竞争优势。为明确两种害虫的生理适应性差异对其种间竞争的影响, 用生化分析法研究了两种成虫取食B型烟粉虱为害的烟草植株后其体内主要保护酶和消化酶活性的影响。结果表明: B型烟粉虱取食其前侵染的烟草植株6, 12, 24, 48和72 h后, 其体内超氧化物歧化酶（SOD）和多酚氧化酶（PPO）的活性均显著增加（P<0.05）, 过氧化物酶（POD）活性在取食12和24 h后变化不明显, 但在取食6, 48和72 h后也显著增加（P<0.05）, B型烟粉虱体内的这3种酶活性的最高值较对照最高分别增加达1.62, 2.71和2.57倍。烟蚜取食B型烟粉虱前侵染的烟草植株在多数取食时间段内, 其体内PPO和SOD的活性仅略有增加, 但在取食12 h后SOD的活性受到明显的抑制。POD活性除在取食24 h后显著高于对照外, 在取食其他时间后均受到显著的抑制（P<0.05）。B型烟粉虱取食其前侵染的烟草植株不同时间后, 其体内蛋白酶和淀粉酶活性均显著增加, 最大值分别是对照的1.54倍和1.33倍; 烟蚜取食烟草植株6 h后, 其体内蛋白酶和淀粉酶活性与对照相比没有明显差异（P<0.05）, 但随着取食时间的延长, 这两种酶活性被显著抑制, 其最低值分别为对照的0.39和0.72倍。结果提示: 与烟蚜相比, B型烟粉虱取食经B型烟粉虱前侵染的烟草后其体内保护酶和消化酶的活性提高是其具有较高适应性的原因之一。     

寄主植物对烟蚜药剂敏感性及相关酶活性的影响

以甘蓝、烟草和桃树上的饲养的烟蚜Myzus persicae（Sulzer）种群为研究材料,分别测试了其对吡虫啉、丁硫克百威和氰戊菊酯这3种杀虫剂的敏感性。结果表明,桃树上的烟蚜种群敏感性最高,其次为烟草种群,甘蓝种群最低。测试了在3种不同寄主上饲养的烟蚜种群的羧酸酯酶、乙酰胆碱酯酶和谷光甘肽-s-转移酶的比活力,这3种酶均表现为甘蓝种群最高,其次为烟草种群,桃树种群最低。     

Performance of the tobacco aphid Myzus persicae (Hemiptera: Aphididae) on Oriental and Virginia tobacco varieties

Abstract 1 The life parameters of one red and one green clone of Myzus persicae reared on 11 Oriental tobacco type varieties (KP7, K63, KZ10/z, MA13/b, BX2/a, N34/4, KP14/a, Kolindros, S79, TA21 and BX81) and on five Virginia ones (VE9, VE3, SPG28‐VE2, Kleio‐KN1 and Niki‐NK3) at 20 °C and LD 16 : 8 h were examined. 2 In general, the clones, performed better on Oriental than on Virginia type varieties. The varieties TA21 and Kolindros could be considered as the most resistant among the Oriental ones. Aphids on Virginia varieties showed longer developmental time (9.1–9.6 days), a lower intrinsic rate of increase (0.2347–0.2647) and higher nymphal mortality (27.9–52.5%) than on Oriental varieties. The corresponding values in the latter were 7.3–9.0 days, 0.2784–0.3302 and 10.0–47.9%. 3 The leaves of Virginia type varieties (188–471 hairs/cm²) and one Oriental (K63) 273 hairs/cm² were more hairy than the other Oriental type varieties (61–150 hairs/cm²). The Virginia type varieties showed also a lower level of reducing sugars (3.5–7.2%) than the Oriental ones (7.0–9.8%). Trichome density and level of reducing sugars were significantly negatively correlated with developmental time and intrinsic rate of increase. 4 An interclonal variation in performance, possibly related to the colour of aphids, was observed. The red clone performed better than the green one. The same trend was observed when the results of the previous clones on the variety KP14/a were analysed with the data obtained on the same variety from two other clones (one red and one green).     

不同地理种群烟蚜形态特征差异分析

烟蚜Myzus persicae是一种世界性的重要农业害虫。为探讨我国不同地理种群烟蚜形态特征变异情况, 本研究测量了我国18个地理种群烟蚜的体长、 体宽、 头宽、 各足腿节长、 各足胫节长等18个形态性状度量特征和Q值, 并进行方差分析和基于欧氏距离与地理距离和海拔差距的Mantel Test, 利用各形态特征与体长的比值构成的比例特征进行系统聚类和主成分分析。结果表明： 部分地理种群烟蚜的形态性状差异显著。系统聚类和主成分分析表明, 18个烟蚜地理种群中贵州贞丰种群（ZF-GZ）与其他种群相比差异最大, 陕西南泥湾（NNW-SX）、 湖南慈利（CL-HN）、 安徽谯城（QC-AH）和重庆武隆（WL-CQ）种群差异最小, 其他种群间的差异程度介于这两者之间。Mantel Test显示欧氏距离与地理距离、 海拔高度差距都不具有相关性。烟蚜种群的形态分化不符合地理隔离模式, 地理气候条件对种群形态有一定影响, 种群形态差异的形成是多种因素综合作用的结果, 但具体作用机制尚不明确。