Frequency and distribution of aneuploidy in human female gametes

Summary During the past 6 years, 14 cytogenetic studies on human oocytes recovered during in vitro fertilization procedures have been published; they report contradictory results. The present survey has pooled the more than 1500 oocyte chromosome complements examined to date, in order to determine generalized trends in chromosomal abnormalities of female gametes. The overall frequency of abnormalities in mature oocytes is 24.0% with a large majority of aneuploidies (22.8%) over structural aberrations (1.2%), which could be explained by the difficulty in the detection of structural abnormalities in oocyte chromosome sets. An analysis of the distribution of non-disjunction among all chromosomes was also performed. In the A, C, D, and especially in the G groups, there is a significant difference between the observed non-disjunction and the frequencies expected from an equal partitioning of non-disjunction among all chromosomes. These data are discussed with reference to the differences obtained from cytogenetic studies on human sperm and from investigations on spontaneous abortion.     

Elimination of X-ray-induced chromosomal aberrations in the progeny of female mice

Female NMRI mice were irradiated with various doses of X-rays and induced chromosome aberrations were scored in MII oocytes (Dosage: 0.222, 0.666, 2 and 6 Gy). After irradiation with 2 Gy, early zygotes were examined in the 2-cell stage; additional dominant lethals were counted and surviving embryos were examined after 13.5 days of pregnancy. 87.2% of the MII oocytes showed structural chromosomal aberrations after irradiation with 2 Gy. Surviving embryos, however, failed to show any increase in the aberration rate. This result points to (almost) complete elimination of genetically damaged oocytes and zygotes already before birth. In addition to the structural aberrations, aneuploidies were induced. Most of them, however, were hypoploidies. Hence, the study confirmed the well-known susceptibility of oocytes around the time of fertilization for induced chromosome loss. Induced hyperploidies, however, were very rare. Evidence for induction of meiotic non-disjunction was weak. In surviving embryos, no increase in numerical aberrations, either hypoploid or hyperploid was discovered. The significance of these data for the prediction of chromosomal damage due to to ionizing radiation in humans is discussed. Recent risk estimates of UNSCEAR and other agencies represent very cautious upper levels.     

Nondisjunction and chromosome breakage in mouse oocytes after various X-ray doses

Summary The effect of varying X-ray doses (0.05–0.80 Gy) on preovulatory mouse oocytes was studied by measuring nondisjunction during the first meiotic division, as well as structural chromosome anomalies in ovulated oocytes at metaphase stage II. The incidence of nondisjunction (0.1% hyperploid oocytes) found in oocytes from nonirradiated NMRI-Han female mice was in accordance with the results previously obtained with the same strain. Significantly (P<0.05) more hyperploid oocytes (0.9%) were ovulated following irradiation with 0.8 Gy. There was no statistically significant increase of nondisjunction after low doses. Structural chromosome anomalies occurred, however, even after an irradiation dose as low as 0.05 Gy. The dose response for structural chromosome anomalies is altogether different from that of radiation-induced hyperpoidy. We consider that irradiation of mature oocytes might well be less hazardous with regard to its potency for increasing nondisjunction during the first meiotic division when compared with the effect of chemical mutagens.     

Testing of 3 chemical compounds for aneuploidy induction in the female mouse

The 3 chemicals, 6 mercaptopurine (6-MCP), phenylalanine and para-fluorophenylalanine (pFPA) have been tested on mouse oocytes of the Swiss strain for possible aneuploidy-inducing effects. Tests were made at the dictyate stage in young and aged females and at the preovulatory (diakinesis/MI) stage in aged females only. Metaphase II chromosome complements were analysed for aneuploidy resulting from segregational errors arising at the first meiotic division. No evidence of non-disjunction was found either in treated or control groups up to the age of 40 weeks tested. The need to select for gametogenic stage and strain when using a mouse model system for aneuploidy testing, is considered.     

Repairs of X-ray induced sublethal damage in class B oocytes of Drosophila melanogaster.

Repair of X-ray-induced sublethal damage (Elkind-type recovery) in class B oocytes of Drosophila melanogaster was studied. Newly hatched females of two different stocks were treated with either acute or fractionated exposures. For the fractionation experiments a constant time interval of one hour between the dose fractions was used. As genetic endpoints dominant lethality, chromosome aberrations (detachments) and non-disjunction were studied. The repair of X-ray-induced sublethal damage in class B oocytes is expressed as a reappearance on the initial shoulder in the fractionation curve. For dominant lethality it could be shown that less sublethal damage is repaired in oocytes of Berlin wild females than in those of attached-X females (on the average 76 per cent and 101 per cent respectively). Complete repair (about 100 per cent) was observed for detachments in occytes of attached-X females. Within the dose ranges used no radiation effects on non-disjunction could be observed. The results are interpreted to show that in class B oocytes (1) sublethal damage is due to chromosome breaks and/or lesions leading to breaks and (2) X-ray-induced dominant lethality is the consequence of chromosome damage (true dominant lethals).     

Enhanced polarizing microscopy as a new tool in aneuploidy research in oocytes

Chromosomal non-disjunction in female meiosis gives rise to reduced fertility and trisomy in humans. Human oocytes, especially from aged women, appear especially susceptible to non-disjunction. The oocyte spindle is crucial for high fidelity of chromosome segregation at meiotic divisions, and alterations in spindle morphology are therefore indicators of adverse conditions during oocyte development that may result in meiotic aneuploidy. In the past, oocytes had to be fixed for spindle analysis, precluding direct non-invasive identification of aneugens and adverse maturation conditions that affect spindle integrity and chromosome behaviour. Aneuploidy research for detection of spindle aberrations was therefore mainly focused on in vivo or in vitro exposed, fixed animal oocytes or cytogenetic analysis of spread oocytes. Orientation independent enhanced polarizing microscopy with nearly circularly polarized light and electronically controlled liquid crystal compensator optics is a new tool to study spindle morphology non-invasively in vivo for qualitative as well as quantitative analysis. Image generation by polarization microscopy depends on the intrinsic optical properties of the spindle with its paracrystalline microtubule lattice. When polarized light passes through such a lattice it induces a splitting of the beam and shift in the plane of vibration and retardation of light (termed birefringence and retardance). Studies of animal oocytes and follicle-cell denuded human oocytes fertilized by intracytoplasmic sperm injection for assisted conception have demonstrated the safety and efficacy of enhanced polarization microscopy. The method can be employed in aneuploidy research for non-invasive dose-response studies to detect spindle aberrations, for instance, in combination with cytogenetic analysis. Due to the non-invasive nature of the technique it may be employed in routine analysis of human oocytes to assess risks by lifestyle factors, and occupational and adverse environmental exposures.     

Cytology of aberrations induced by X-rays in oocytes of Drosophila melanogaster.

200 first-division configurations were analyzed for cytological aberrations induced by X-rays in late meiotic prophase in oocytes of Drosophila melanogaster. For the 3000 and 6000 r doses, 38 and 66%, respectively, were classified as abnormal. The aberrant divisions included displacement of the chromosomes suggesting their non-disjunction, loss of a whole chromosome, fragments and heterologous exchanges and unidentifiable aberrations. Non-disjunctional chromosomes were free of heterologous exchanges. The concept that a majority of X-ray-induced dominant lethals is due to chromosomal breakage is supported by the findings of the present study.     

The influence of maternal age on radiation-induced chromosome aberrations in mouse oocytes

The relative sensitivities of dictyate oocytes from young and old female mice to radiation-induced chromosome damage were examined in 2 separate experiments. Firstly, females were given either 2 or 4 Gy of X-rays and metaphase I stage oocytes collected 16.5 days later. Analysis of these cells showed dose-related increases in chromosome aberrations in both age groups. The response was significantly greater in oocytes of older females. In the second experiment, females were given 4 Gy of X-rays and metaphase I stage oocytes collected 3.5 days later. Again, a significantly larger frequency of aberrations was present in cells from older animals. Overall, these 2 experiments provide unambiguous evidence that the radiosensitivity of mouse dictyate oocytes increases with advancing maternal age.     

Cytogenetic studies in mouse oocytes irradiated in vitro at different stages of maturation, by use of an early preantral follicle culture system

In vivo studies on X-irradiated mice have shown that structural chromosome aberrations can be induced in female germ cells and that the radiation-induced chromosomal damage strongly depends on the stage of maturation reached by the oocytes at the time of irradiation. In the present study, the sensitivity of oocytes to induction of chromosome damage by radiation was evaluated at two different stages, by use of a recently developed method of in vitro culture covering a crucial period of follicle/oocyte growth and maturation. A key feature of this system is that growth and development of all follicles is perfectly synchronized, due to the selection of a narrow class of follicles in the start-off culture. This allows irradiation of well-characterized and homogenous populations of follicles, in contrast to the situation prevailing in vivo. Follicles were X-irradiated with either 2 or 4 Gy, on day 0 of culture (early preantral follicles with one to two cell layers) or on day 12, 3h after hormonal stimulation of ovulation (antral Graafian follicles). Ovulated oocytes, blocked in metaphase I (MI) by colchicine, were fixed 16 h after hormonal stimulation and analyzed for chromosome aberrations. The results confirm the high radiosensitivity of oocytes at 2 weeks prior to ovulation and the even higher radiosensitivity of those irradiated a few hours before ovulation, underlining the suitability of the in vitro system for further studies on the genetic effects of ionising radiation in female mammals.     

Measurement of neutron-induced genetic damage in mouse immature oocytes

Recent experimental evidence concerning the nature of radiosensitive targets in mouse immature (resting) oocytes has led to new experimental designs that permit measurement of radiation-induced genetic damage in these important cells. We have previously reported initial results of the detection of genetic damage in mouse immature oocytes using monoenergetic 0.43-MeV neutrons. Here we provide a full report of our data and compare the genetic sensitivity of immature oocytes with those measured by others for maturing oocytes. Until recently, all attempts to detect radiation-induced genetic damage in mouse immature oocytes had failed. This appears to have been because the radiation types and modes of dose delivery used in those studies did not sufficiently spare the hypersensitive lethality target (the plasma membrane) while at the same time deposit enough dose in DNA to produce detectable mutation. Recoil protons from 0.43-MeV neutrons produce short ionization tracks (2.6 micron mean) and can therefore deposit energy in the DNA without simultaneously traversing the plasma membrane. Using these particles, we have obtained dose-response relationships for both chromosome aberrations and dominant lethal mutations in oocytes from females irradiated 8-12 weeks earlier, when oocytes were immature. Results suggest that the intrinsic mutational sensitivity of mouse immature oocytes is not very different from that of maturing oocytes.     

Meiotic non-disjunction induced by fission neutrons relative to X-rays observed in mouse secondary spermatocytes. II. Dose-effect relationships after treatment of pachytene cells

(C57B1/Cne X C3H/Cne)F1 male mice were irradiated with single acute doses of 0.4 MeV neutrons (from 0.11 to 0.72 Gy) or 250 kV X-rays (from 0.25 to 3 Gy) and sacrificed 5 days later. Chromosome preparations of secondary spermatocytes, irradiated at the stage of pachytene, were analysed and the incidence of hyper-haploidies and chromosome fragments was recorded. Data on numerical aberrations were fitted by highly significant linear relationships for both types of radiation. A relative biological effectiveness (RBE) value of 5.65 was estimated by the ratio between the slopes of the two regression lines. The same linear fitting was applied to frequencies of cells with fragments, even if in this case other types of functions could not be excluded. An RBE value was estimated in the same way as for numerical aberrations and yielded a comparable figure of 5.23. A significant correlation was also found between the incidence of numerical and structural aberrations, which points to the chromosome itself as the prevalent target for radiation-induced non-disjunction (ND). In addition, the highly significant linearity of the dose-effect relationship observed for the induction of aneuploidies suggests, as the simplest hypothesis, a single-hit mechanism of radiation action, possibly through pre-non-disjunctional damage to the centromeric region, rather than an indirect induction of segregational difficulties after primarily induced chromatid interchanges.     

Genetic tests for autosomal non-disjunction and chromosome loss in mice

Two new genetic methods for detecting autosomal non-disjunction and chromosome loss in mice are described. Both methods involve the use of marker genes and Robertsonian translocations, the latter present only in tester parents, to detect events in chromosomally normal mice. With the Rb method, the tester parent carries one or more Robertsonian translocations heterozygously; with the MBH method the tester parent carries two Robertsonian translocations showing monobrachial homology. The high rates of meiotic non-disjunction in the tester mice provide gametes with specific extra or missing chromosomes which, at fertilization, can allow the survival of a proportion of the zygotes lacking or carrying an extra specific chromosome from tested chromosomally normal parents. The Rb method has been assessed for X-ray-induced chromosome 1 loss and non-disjunction in mature oocytes and also for such chromosome 1 loss from the maternal pronuclei of 1-cell zygotes. The MBH method has been assessed for X-ray-induced chromosome 1 loss in male postmeiotic cells and for non-disjunction in spermatocytes. Both methods proved effective in detecting chromosome 1 loss. A single case of the much rarer non-disjunctional event was also found. As applied, both methods compared favourably with the numerical sex chromosome anomaly (NSA) method and have considerable potential for further development.     

Trichlorfon predisposes to aneuploidy and interferes with spindle formation in in vitro maturing mouse oocytes

The pesticide trichlorfon (TCF) has been implicated in human trisomy 21, and in errors in chromosome segregation at male meiosis II in the mouse. We previously provided evidence that TCF interferes with spindle integrity and cell-cycle control during murine oogenesis. To assess the aneugenic activity of TCF in oogenesis, we presently analysed maturation, spindle assembly, and chromosome constitution in mouse oocytes maturing in vitro in the presence of 50 or 100 microg/ml TCF for 16 h or in pulse-chase experiments. TCF stimulated maturation to meiosis II at 50 microg/ml, but arrested meiosis in some oocytes at 100 microg/ml. TCF at 100 microg/ml was aneugenic causing non-disjunction of homologous chromosomes at meiosis I, a significant increase of the hyperploidy rate at metaphase II, and a significant rise in the numbers of oocytes that contained a 'diploid' set of metaphase II chromosomes (dyads). TCF elevated the rate of precocious chromatid segregation (predivision) at 50 and 100 microg/ml. Pulse-chase experiments with 100 microg/ml TCF present during the first 7 h or the last 9 h of maturation in vitro did not affect meiotic progression and induced intermediate levels of hyperploidy at metaphase II. Exposure to > or =50 microg/ml TCF throughout maturation in vitro induced severe spindle aberrations at metaphase II, and over one-third of the oocytes failed to align all chromosomes at the spindle equator (congression failure). These observations suggest that exposure to high concentrations of TCF induces non-disjunction at meiosis I of oogenesis, while lower doses may preferentially cause errors in chromosome segregation at meiosis II due to disturbances in spindle function, and chromosome congression as well as precocious separation of chromatids prior to anaphase II. The data support evidence from other studies that TCF has to be regarded as a germ cell aneugen.     

Studies on non-disjunction of the major autosomes in Drosophila melanogaster. I. Methodology and rate of induction by x-rays for the compound second chromosome

The induction of non-disjunction by X-irradiation of the second chromosome in stage-7 oocytes of Drosophila melanogaster has been studied by employing isochromosome stocks. This makes the quantitative recovery possible of progeny resulting from disomic and nullosomic eggs. Determination of egg hatchability has been used to correct for varying degrees of segregation in males carrying different isochromosomes. Even at exposures as low as 250 R the frequency of non-disjunction is significantly higher than in the controls. No evidence has been obtained for the existence of a threshold. In the stage-7 oocytes, the induction of non-disjunction increased linearly with radiation exposure over a range of 250–3000 R and thus seems to reflect a single-hit event. These findings could be of significance for the evaluation of genetic radiation hazards in man. In slightly younger oocyte stages the induction of disomic eggs followed dose-square kinetics. The frequency of nullosomic eggs rises exponentially with radiation exposure, presumably as a consequence of increasing chromosome loss resulting from unrestituted breaks in each of the two maternal isochromosomes. Furthermore, it was observed that the late stage-7 oocytes were more sensitivie to the induction of non-disjunction than earlier stages.     

Meiotic stage-dependent induction of chromosome aberrations in Chinese hamster primary oocytes exposed to topoisomerase II inhibitor etoposide

To investigate the chromosomal effects of topoisomerase II (topo-II)-interactive drugs on mammalian primary oocytes, female Chinese hamsters were treated with etoposide (VP-16) at various intervals pre- and post-human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) injections. Chromosome analysis of oocytes at metaphase II (M II) showed that treatment with VP-16 at 50h pre-hCG had no effect, but the treatments between 24h pre-hCG and 2h post-hCG often caused structural chromosome aberrations. Although treatment at 4h post-hCG had no effect, subsequent treatments at 6 and 8h post-hCG produced a significant increase in structural chromosome aberrations. No effect was found following treatment at 10h post-hCG. The incidence of aneuploidy following exposure to VP-16 was also dependent on the time of hCG injection. Taking the time course of meiotic progression in primary oocytes following hCG injection and pharmacokinetics of VP-16 into consideration, it is likely that meiotic stages from late dictyate to diakinesis are highly sensitive to VP-16, while stages at dictyate and from metaphase I (M I) to telophase I (telo I) are relatively insensitive to the drug. Moreover, the effect of VP-16 on structural chromosome aberrations and aneuploidy was dose-dependent.Chromosome analysis at M I detected a frequent occurrence of structural chromosome aberrations in treated oocytes. This suggests that structural aberrations may be caused by disruption of cleavable complexes during chromosome condensation. Detection of chromosome bridges during anaphase I/telophase I (ana I/telo I) may support the hypothesis that induction of aneuploidy by VP-16 is due to failure in decatenation of recombinant homologous chromosomes.     

SKY and FISH analysis of radiation-induced chromosome aberrations: a comparison of whole and partial genome analysis

For a retrospective dose estimation of human exposure to ionising radiation, a partial genome analysis is routinely used to quantify radiation-induced chromosome aberrations. For this purpose, fluorescence in situ hybridisation (FISH) with whole chromosome painting probes for selected chromosomes is usually applied covering about 20% of the whole genome. Since genome-wide screening techniques like spectral karyotyping (SKY) and multiplex FISH (mFISH) have been developed the detection of radiation-induced aberrations within the whole genome has now become feasible. To determine the correspondence between partial and whole genome analysis of radiation-induced chromosome aberrations, they were measured comprehensively in this study using in vitro irradiated blood samples from three donors. We were able to demonstrate that comparable results can be detected with both approaches. However, complex aberrations might be misinterpreted by partial genome analysis. We therefore conclude that whole genome analysis by SKY is useful especially in the high dose range to correct aberration data for complex exchange aberrations.     

Analysis of structural and numerical chromosome abnormalities in sperm of normal men and carriers of constitutional chromosome aberrations. A review

Sperm chromosome analysis offers the opportunity to gather information about the origin of chromosome aberrations in human germ cells. Over the last 20 years more than 20 000 sperm chromosome complements from normal donors and almost 6000 spermatozoa from men with constitutional chromosome aberrations (inversions, translocations) have been analyzed for structural and numerical chromosome abnormalities, as well as for segregation of the constitutional chromosome aberrations after the sperm had penetrated hamster oocytes. On the other hand, it took only 6 years to screen more than 3 million mature spermatozoa from healthy probands for disomy rates of 20 autosomes (chromosomes 19 and 22 not evaluated) and the sex chromosomes, and for diploidy rates by in situ hybridization techniques. In the present paper the results arising from both methods are compiled and compared. Received: 29 January 1997 / Accepted: 5 March 1997     

Chromosome analysis of mouse zygotes after injecting oocytes with spermatozoa treated in vitro with green tea catechin, (-)-epigallocatechin gallate (EGCG)

The cytogenetic effects of (-)-epigallocatechin gallate (EGCG) on mouse spermatozoa were studied in vitro using an intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) technique. Spermatozoa were collected by the swim-up method and treated with EGCG at 1 microM and 10 microM. When motile, EGCG-treated spermatozoa were injected into oocytes, structural chromosome aberrations (SCAs) at the first cleavage metaphase did not increase significantly. However, a majority of immotile spermatozoa treated with 10 microM EGCG had the following abnormalities: pronuclear arrest (11% of activated oocytes), degenerated sperm chromatin (chromosome) mass (30% of activated oocytes) and occurrence of structural chromosome aberrations (57% of analyzed metaphases). The incidence of these abnormalities suggests that immotile spermatozoa were susceptible to EGCG, and that the damage of sperm chromatin was accelerated in immotile spermatozoa by 10 microM EGCG treatment.     

Chromosome aberrations in metaphase II-oocytes. Stage sensitivity in the mouse oogenesis to amethopterin and cyclophosphamide

The stage sensitivity in oogenesis of C₃H mice was investigated by transplacental treatment of embryonic oogonia and oocytes at meiotic prophase I. After birth the stages of early and late dictyotene as well as the preovulatory and ovulatory phases were treated. Chromosome analysis was performed in unfertilized metaphase II-oocytes after induced ovulation [pregnant mare's serum (PMS) and human chorionic gonadotrophin (HCG)]. As test compounds both the folic acid antagonist amethopterin (M) and the alkylating agent cyclophosphamide (C) were used.Embryonic oogonia as well as the preovulatory phase of oogenesis proved to be most sensitive for the induction of chromosomal aberrations. The investigation with graded doses during the preovulatory stage demonstrated the dose-dependent frequency of the induced types of chromosomal abnormalities.The high sensitivity of these stages where chromosome segregation takes place, e.g. oogonia, preovulatory stage, seems to be related to an additional induction of aneuploidies.     

Chromosome anomalies in mouse oocytes after irradiation.

We investigated the cytogenetic effects of X-rays on unfertilized mouse oocytes. NMRI females received an irradiation with 0,22.2,66.6,200, and 600 R during the preovulatory phase 3 hrs after HCG (human chorionic gonadotrophin). This is a stage during oogenesis in which the oocytes pass from late dictyotene to diakinesis. Chromosome analysis was performed after ovulation at metaphase II. From these experiments we can draw the following conclusions: 1) X-rays induced during the preovulatory phase a high number of chromosome anomalies. Among these, structural anomalies prevail. 7 out of 144 ovulated oocytes in matched controls carried such an abnormality, whereas after irradiation we observed with 22.2, 66.6, 200, and 600 R, 11 out of 72, 34 out of 108, 89 out of 102, and 122 out of 124, respectively. 2) Irradiation seems also to affect the chromosome segregation during the 1. meiotic division, as we observed after 22.2, 66.6, and 200 R a total of 6 oocytes out of 204 with a supernummary chromosome. In controls, however, no hyperploidy was found in 143 ova. This increase, however, was not significant. 3) Chromosome anomalies, e.g. breaks and deletions that go back to a one-break event increased linearly with increasing dose. Exchanges, however, going back to two-break events fittest best to the linear-quadratic dose-response model. 4) The dose of 600 R seems to represents a kind of borderline in this experiment, because nearly all (122 out 124) carried at least one structural chromosome anomaly. It is also this dose after which the highest frequency of reciprocal translocations was observed in a hump-shaped slope in spermatocytes after irradiation of spermatogonia (Preston and Brewen, 1973). With an increasing dosage up to 1200 R the frequency of translocations decrease again. The elimination of cells, crossing this borderline, might be due to genetic or non-genetic effects. 5) The frequency of radiation-induced translocations per oocyte agrees with the frequency of translocations in human lymphocytes (Dolphin and Lloyd, 1974) after in vitro irradiation. 6) Significant, lower frequencies of structural chromosome anomalies were observed irradiating earlier stages of mouse oogenesis. These stages are dictyotene from females at the age of 3, or 6 weeks and prophase I-stages in female embryos on the 17th day of gestation. This result may be due to a lower sensitivity of these stages or to modifying events during the interval between irradiation and preparations.