Formation of native-like mammalian sperm cell chromatin with folded bull protamine

The DNA of most vertebrate sperm cells is packaged by protamines. The primary structure of mammalian protamine I can be divided into three domains, a central DNA binding domain that is arginine-rich and amino- and carboxyl-terminal domains that are rich in cysteine residues. In native bull sperm chromatin, intramolecular disulfide bonds hold the terminal domains of bull protamine folded back onto the central DNA binding domain, whereas intermolecular disulfide bonds between DNA-bound protamines help stabilize the chromatin of mature mammalian sperm cells. Folded bull protamine was used to condense DNA in vitro under various solution conditions. Using transmission electron microscopy and light scattering, we show that bull protamine forms particles with DNA that are morphologically similar to the subunits of native bull sperm chromatin. In addition, the stability provided by intermolecular disulfide bonds formed between bull protamine molecules within in vitro DNA condensates is comparable with that observed for native bull sperm chromatin. The importance of the bull protamine terminal domains in controlling the bull sperm chromatin morphology is indicated by our observation that DNA condensates formed under identical conditions with a fish protamine, which lacks cysteine-rich terminal domains, do not produce as uniform structures as bull protamine. A model is also presented for the bull protamine.DNA complex in native sperm cell chromatin that provides an explanation for the positions of the cysteine residues in bull protamine that form intermolecular disulfide bonds.     

Sperm chromatin structure: Insights from in vitro to in situ experiments

The sperm genome is tightly packed into a minimal volume of sperm nuclei. Sperm chromatin is highly condensed by protamines (PRMs) after histone–protamine replacement, and the majority of the sperm genome forms a nucleo-protamine structure, namely, the PRM–DNA complex. The outline of sperm chromatin structure was proposed 30 years ago, and the details have been explored by approaches from several independent research fields including male reproduction and infertility, DNA biopolymer, and most recently, genome-wide sequence-based approaches. In this review, the history of research on sperm chromatin structure is briefly described, and the progress of recent related studies is summarized to obtain a more integrated view for the sperm chromatin, an extremely compacted “black box.”     

The protamine family of sperm nuclear proteins

The protamines are a diverse family of small arginine-rich proteins that are synthesized in the late-stage spermatids of many animals and plants and bind to DNA, condensing the spermatid genome into a genetically inactive state. Vertebrates have from one to 15 protamine genes per haploid genome, which are clustered together on the same chromosome. Comparison of protamine gene and amino-acid sequences suggests that the family evolved from specialized histones through protamine-like proteins to the true protamines. Structural elements present in all true protamines are a series of arginine-rich DNA-anchoring domains (often containing a mixture of arginine and lysine residues in non-mammalian protamines) and multiple phosphorylation sites. The two protamines found in mammals, P1 and P2, are the most widely studied. P1 packages sperm DNA in all mammals, whereas protamine P2 is present only in the sperm of primates, many rodents and a subset of other placental mammals. P2, but not P1, is synthesized as a precursor that undergoes proteolytic processing after binding to DNA and also binds a zinc atom, the function of which is not known. P1 and P2 are phosphorylated soon after their synthesis, but after binding to DNA most of the phosphate groups are removed and cysteine residues are oxidized, forming disulfide bridges that link the protamines together. Both P1 and P2 have been shown to be required for normal sperm function in primates and many rodents.     

Loss of the cleaved-protamine 2 domain leads to incomplete histone-to-protamine exchange and infertility in mice

Protamines are unique sperm-specific proteins that package and protect paternal chromatin until fertilization. A subset of mammalian species expresses two protamines (PRM1 and PRM2), while in others PRM1 is sufficient for sperm chromatin packaging. Alterations of the species-specific ratio between PRM1 and PRM2 are associated with infertility. Unlike PRM1, PRM2 is generated as a precursor protein consisting of a highly conserved N-terminal domain, termed cleaved PRM2 (cP2), which is consecutively trimmed off during chromatin condensation. The carboxyterminal part, called mature PRM2 (mP2), interacts with DNA and together with PRM1, mediates chromatin-hypercondensation. The removal of the cP2 domain is believed to be imperative for proper chromatin condensation, yet, the role of cP2 is not yet understood. We generated mice lacking the cP2 domain while the mP2 is still expressed. We show that the cP2 domain is indispensable for complete sperm chromatin protamination and male mouse fertility. cP2 deficient sperm show incomplete protamine incorporation and a severely altered protamine ratio, retention of transition proteins and aberrant retention of the testis specific histone variant H2A.L.2. During epididymal transit, cP2 deficient sperm seem to undergo ROS mediated degradation leading to complete DNA fragmentation. The cP2 domain therefore seems to be a key aspect in the complex crosstalk between histones, transition proteins and protamines during sperm chromatin condensation. Overall, we present the first step towards understanding the role of the cP2 domain in paternal chromatin packaging and open up avenues for further research.     

Ability of hamster spermatozoa to digest their own DNA

Mammalian sperm chromatin is bound by protamines into highly condensed toroids with approximately 50 kilobases (kb) of DNA. It is also organized into loop domains of about the same size that are attached at their bases to the proteinaceous nuclear matrix. In this work, we test our model that each sperm DNA-loop domain is condensed into a single protamine toroid. Our model predicts that the protamine toroids are linked by chromatin that is more sensitive to nucleases than the DNA within the toroids. To test this model, we treated hamster sperm nuclei with DNase I and found that the sperm chromatin was digested into fragments with an average size of about 50 kb, by pulse-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE). Surprisingly, we also found that spermatozoa treated with 0.25% Triton X-100 (TX) and 20 mM MgCl2 overnight resulted in the same type of degradation, suggesting that sperm nuclei have a mechanism for digesting their own DNA at the bases of the loop domains. We extracted the nuclei with 2 M NaCl and 10 mM dithiothreitol (DTT) to make nuclear halos. Nuclear matrices prepared from DNase I-treated spermatozoa had no DNA attached, suggesting that DNase I digested the DNA at the bases of the loop domains. TX-treated spermatozoa still had their entire DNA associated with the nuclear matrix, even though the DNA was digested into 50-kb fragments as revealed by PFGE. The data support our donut-loop model for sperm chromatin structure and suggest a functional role for this type of organization in that sperm can digest its own DNA at the sites of attachment to the nuclear matrix.     

Nucleoplasmin interaction with protamines. Involvement of the polyglutamic tract

Different recombinant forms of nucleoplasmin including truncations at the carboxyl-terminal end of the molecule (r-NP121, r-NP142) have been expressed and purified. All of them were found to oligomerize, forming pentameric complexes which, according to their hydrodynamic properties, can be modeled by oblate ellipsoids of constant width. In this model, the highly charged carboxyl ends appear to be arranged around a pentameric core along the plane defined by the major axes of the ellipsoid. Importantly, all the recombinant forms appear to be able to decondense protamine-containing sperm nuclei. However, although the stoichiometry with which protamines bind to these forms appears to be constant (2.5 mol of protamine/mol of nucleoplasmin pentamer), the efficiency with which they remove protamines from the sperm DNA decreases in the following order: o-NP > r-NP142 > or = r-NP > r-NP121. Therefore, the main polyglutamic tract of nucleoplasmin (which is absent in r-NP121), while enhancing the efficiency of protamine removal, is not indispensable for sperm chromatin decondensation in the biological model we have used.     

Scrotal heat stress induces altered sperm chromatin structure associated with a decrease in protamine disulfide bonding in the stallion

A variety of testicular insults can induce changes in the structure of spermatozoal chromatin, resulting in spermatozoal DNA that is more susceptible to acid-induced denaturation. The degree of change in the DNA can be measured using the sperm chromatin structure assay (SCSA). The SCSA measures the relative amounts of single- and double-stranded DNA after staining with the metachromatic dye, acridine orange. Here we used a stallion model (n = 4) to study the effects of scrotal heat stress on spermatozoal DNA. This model was created by insulating stallion testes for 48 h and collecting sperm daily thereafter for 60 days. Changes in the SCSA were then correlated with protamine disulfide content and protamine types and levels. Results of the SCSA indicated that the susceptibility of spermatozoal DNA to denaturation was dependent on the spermatogenic cell stage that the ejaculated sperm was in at the time of the heat stress. Spermatozoa with altered DNA had a decrease in the extent of disulfide bonding that was associated with an increase in the susceptibility of DNA to denaturation. However, there were no detectable changes in either the protamine type or level. Thus, in this model, decreased disulfide bonding is associated with an increased susceptibility of spermatozoal DNA to denaturation in the absence of protamine changes.     

Convergent evolution of cysteine residues in sperm protamines of one genus of marsupials, the Planigales

A characteristic feature of the sperm P1 protamines of eutherian mammals is the constant presence of six to nine cysteine residues per molecule. During spermiogenesis these residues become oxidized to form a three-dimensional network of disulfide bridges between, and within, protamine molecules in the sperm chromatin. This covalent cross linking strongly stabilizes eutherian sperm nuclei. In contrast, protamines sequenced from teleost fish, birds, monotremes, and marsupials all lack cysteine residues and their sperm nuclei, without the stabilizing cross links, are easily decondensed in vitro. We have now found that one genus of tiny, shrewlike dasyurid marsupials, the Planigales, possess P1 protamines containing five to six cysteine residues. These residues appear to have evolved since the divergence of Planigales from other members of the family Dasyuridae, such as the marsupial mouse, Sminthopsis crassicaudata. We believe this constitutes a case of convergent evolution in a subfamily of dasyurid marsupials toward the cysteine-rich eutherian form of sperm protamine P1.      

Marked differences in the ability of distinct protamines to disassemble nucleosomal core particles in vitro

In accordance with the results of classical experiments performed in vitro with calf thymus chromatin and the fish protamine salmine, we have observed that this highly basic, small molecular weight protamine cannot cause major displacement of histones from nucleosomal core particles at concentrations several times higher than physiological (arginine/nucleotide ratios 1-8) and that hyperacetylation of histones facilitates nucleosome disassembly. However, the avian protamine galline, with molecular weight and number of arginine residues almost twice those of common fish protamines, is able to displace the nucleosomal core histones from DNA in vitro at concentrations (arginine/nucleotide ratios 0.6-1.2) within the physiological range (0.8). Our results suggest that the binding of the avian protamine galline to chromatin could be directly involved in the rapid disassembly of nucleosomes that takes place during the nucleohistone nucleoprotamine transition in chicken spermiogenesis.     

Protamine-DNA association in mammalian spermatozoa

We have previously identified two subsets of basic nuclear proteins of mouse sperm: the protamines and a group of less basic proteins and, with the aid of a polyvalent antiserum, we have demonstrated their differential extractibility by NaCl in reducing solution (Rodman et al., J cell sci 53 (1982) 227) [9]. By affinity purification with isolated mouse sperm protamines we have obtained a protamine-specific fraction of that antiserum and a fraction that contains antibodies to the subset of less basic proteins. With those immunochemical probes we have shown the following The antigenic sites recognized by the protamine-specific antibodies are accessible, intranuclearly, only after the DNA has been removed by DNase I. The antibodies and DNA compete for binding sites on the protamines. DNA removal and consequent availability of the antigenic sites of the protamine molecules to the antibodies are possible only after displacement of the less basic proteins and chromatin decondensation have been induced. Immunoreactivity by the less basic proteins takes place without intervention of DNase. Those data indicate that the protamines are DNA-bound but that the less basic proteins are not or, alternatively, their putative DNA-binding sites do not coincide with their immuno-reactive sites. Those data also suggest that a function of the subset of less basic proteins may be to provide a shield for the protamine-DNA complex. The mouse protamine-affinity-bound antibodies are highly cross-reactive with protamines of other mammalian sperm suggesting that, despite considerable molecular diversity among mammalian protamines, the DNA-binding sites are conserved.     

Phosphorylated protamines. II. Circular dichroism of complexes with DNA, dependency on ionic strength.

The influence of protamine phosphorylation upon the conformation of nucleoprotamine complexes was studied at different ionic strengths using circular dichroism. The sharp onset of CD spectral changes upon decreasing the NaC1 concentrationwas correlated with the beginning of complex formation and can be used to determine apparent binding affinities in terms of a critical ionic strength. It is show that phosphorylation strongly reduces the binding strength of protamines towards DNA. Directly mixed and reconstituted complexes reveal differences in their CD spectra, which decrease with increasing ionic strength. Spectra of complexes between threefold phosphorylated clupeine Z and DNA obtained by reconstitution or direct mixing at higher ionic strength resemble the phi-type spectra of DNA and are unique for the phosphorylated species. The implications of protamine phosphorylation for chromatin or DNA condensation havebeen discussed.     

Characterization of chromatin-condensing proteins during spermiogenesis in a neogastropod mollusc (Murex brandaris)

During the process of chromatin cndensation in the spermiogenesis of the neogastropod mollusc Murex brandaris, the nuclear protein complement undergoes a complex series of changes. These changes lead to the appearance of three small protamines in the ripe sperm nuclei. We have characterized this system electrophoretically and at the compositions with antibodies elicited against a specific spermatozoan protamine. Our results indicate that the complex pattern of chromatin condensation during spermiogenesis in this species (M. brandaris) may be modulated by a series of post-translational (and intranuclear) modifications of DNA-interacting proteins, such as precursors to the sperm protamines. The amino acid composition of each sperm protamine is remarkably simple (lys + arg + gly ≥96 mol%). This system of spermiogenic/spermatozoal proteins in the neogastropod M. brandaris clearly differs from that in patellogastropods and archaeogastropods, and it may be helpful in understanding evolutionary changes in the chromatin condensation pattern during the spermiogenesis of gastropod molluscs. © 1994 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Identification of bull protamine disulfides

We have identified the disulfide cross-links in bull protamine by titrating intact bull sperm with dithiothreitol (DTT) and following the modification of each cysteine residue with tritiated iodoacetate. The derivatization of each cysteine was monitored by a combination of HPLC, peptide mapping, and protein sequencing. Analyses of total free sulfhydryls show that all seven of the bull protamine cysteines are cross-linked as disulfides in mature sperm. The first disulfide is reduced at a DTT:protamine cysteine (DTT:Cys) ratio of 0.3 and the last at a ratio of 2.0. Intra- and intermolecular disulfides were identified by correlating the reduction of specific disulfides with the dissociation of protamine from DNA in partially reduced sperm and sperm treated with N,N'-ethylenedimaleimide, a bifunctional disulfide cross-linking agent. Three intermolecular and two intramolecular disulfides were identified. The results of these experiments demonstrate that the amino- and carboxy-terminal ends of the bull protamine molecule are folded inward toward the center of the molecule and are locked in place, each by a single intramolecular disulfide bridge. Three intermolecular disulfides cross-link neighboring protamine molecules around the DNA helix in such a manner that the protamines cannot be dissociated from DNA without first reducing the interprotamine disulfides.     

Chromatin organization during spermiogenesis in Octopus vulgaris. II: DNA-interacting proteins

In this article we study the proteins responsible for chromatin condensation during spermiogenesis in the cephalopod Octopus vulgaris. The DNA of ripe sperm nuclei in this species is condensed by a set of five different proteins. Four of these proteins are protamines. The main protamine (Po2), a protein of 44 amino acid residues, is extraordinarily simple (composed of only three different amino acid types: arginine (R), serine (S), and glycine (G). It is a basic molecule consisting of 79.5 mol% arginine residues. The rest of the protamines (Po3, Po4, Po5) are smaller molecules (33, 28, and 30 amino acid residues, respectively) that are homologous among themselves and probably with the main Po2 protamine. The ripe sperm nucleus of O. vulgaris also contains a small quantity of a molecule (Po1) that is similar to Po2 protamine. This protein could represent a Po2 protamine-precursor in a very advanced step of its processing. We discuss the characteristics of these proteins, as well as the relation between the complexity of chromatin condensation and the transitions of nuclear proteins during spermiogenesis in O. vulgaris.     

Sperm nuclei glutathione peroxidases and their occurrence in animal species with cysteine-containing protamines

The selenoenzyme sperm nuclei glutathione peroxidase (snGPx), also called the nuclear form of phospholipid hydroperoxide glutathione peroxidase (n-PHGPx), was found to be involved in the stabilization of condensed sperm chromatin, most likely by thiol to disulfide oxidation of the cysteine residues of the mammalian protamines, small nuclear basic proteins in the nuclei of sperm cells. By applying Acidic Urea-PAGE in combination with SDS-PAGE, snGPx with an apparent molecular mass of 34 kDa and a 24-kDa protein were purified from rat sperm nuclei. The 24-kDa protein was identified by means of mass spectrometry as a truncated form of snGPx produced by cleavage at the N-terminal end. After defined processing of spermatozoa and detergent treatment of the sperm nuclei fraction, snGPx and its truncated form were shown to be the only selenoproteins present in mature mammalian sperm nuclei. Both forms were found in mature rat and horse sperm nuclei but in man only snGPx was detected. In trout and chicken, species with sperm cells which likewise undergo chromatin condensation but do not contain cysteine in their protamines, the snGPx proteins were missing. This can be taken as an indirect proof of the function of snGPx to act as protamine cysteine thiol peroxidase in the mammalian species with cysteine-containing protamines.     

Histone- and Protamine-DNA Association: Conservation of Different Patterns within the β-Globin Domain in Human Sperm

Most DNA in human sperm is bound to highly basic proteins called protamines, but a small proportion is complexed with histones similar to those found in active chromatin. This raises the intriguing possibility that histones in sperm are marking sets of genes that will be preferentially activated during early development. We have examined the chromatin structure of members of the β-globin gene family, which are expressed at different times in development, and the protamine 2 gene, which is expressed in spermatids prior to the widespread displacement of histones by transition proteins. The genes coding for and γ globin, which are active in the embryonic yolk sac, contain regions which are histone associated in the sperm. No histone-associated regions are present at the sites tested within the β- and δ-globin genes which are silent in the embryonic yolk sac. The trends of histone or protamine association are consistent for samples from the same person, and no significant between-subject variations in these trends are found for 13 of the 15 fragments analyzed in the two donors. The results suggest that sperm chromatin structures are generally similar in different men but that the length of the histone-associated regions can vary. The association of sperm DNA with histones or protamines sometimes changes within as little as 400 bp of DNA, suggesting that there is fine control over the retention of histones.     

Processing of the precursor of protamine P2 in mouse. Identification of intermediates by their insolubility in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate

Two basic proteins, protamines P1 and P2, are present in chromatin of mouse spermatozoa. Protamine P1, the less abundant protein in mouse, has a homolog in most mammals, and its synthesis follows a conventional route. In contrast, protamine P2 has been found only in certain other mammals, including humans, and it is synthesized as a precursor nearly twice as long as the mature protein. Processing of this precursor is not yet understood, although it necessarily takes place in elongating spermatids and is likely to play a role in the chromatin condensation occurring in these haploid cells. We have fractionated basic proteins from mouse testis chromatin and have identified six proteins on electrophoretic gels which, like protamines, are insoluble in SDS. All six were also soluble at the same trichloroacetic acid concentration as protamine P2 and were present in chromatin of elongating spermatids. Radioactive labelling patterns acquired by these SDS-insoluble proteins during translation in vitro of testis RNA indicate that the largest represents the precursor of protamine P2, and suggest that the others represent intermediates generated by proteolytic cleavage of the precursor. Results from pulse 3H labelling in vivo were also consistent with the conclusion that a precursor/product relationship exists between these proteins and protamine P2. Conclusions concerning the kinetics of processing have, in addition, been drawn from this data. Hypotheses concerning possible functional roles played by the precursor are presented.     

Hyperacetylation of histone H4 promotes chromatin decondensation prior to histone replacement by protamines during spermatogenesis in rainbow trout

During the final stages of spermatogenesis in rainbow trout a dramatic increase in the level of histone H4 hyperacetylation is observed which is closely correlated with the replacement of histones by protamines. In order to understand further how H4 hyperacetylation might assist in protamine replacement of the histones, we have investigated the effect of H4 hyperacetylation on chromatin structure in trout testes actively undergoing the replacement process. Long chromatin fragments enriched in hyperacetylated H4 have been isolated and characterized. Evidence is presented that hyperacetylated H4 is clustered in certain regions (domains) of late stage testis chromatin and within these domains the chromatin exhibits an altered, highly relaxed structure which is believed to be the result of the extensive hyperacetylation. These domains, which are nearly devoid of protamine, are postulated to represent an initial structural transition which is necessary for the proper histone removal and protamine replacement process to take place.     

Phosphorylation state of protamines 1 and 2 in human spermatids and spermatozoa

The basic nuclear proteins of a fraction of elongating spermatids from human tests and of a fraction of motile spermatozoa from the ejaculate, separated by ion-exchange chromatography, were compared. Analysis by acetic acid-urea polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) showed that, in both fractions, four proteins of lower mobility were coeluted with protamine 1 by 23% guanidinium chloride (GuCI) while protamine 2 alone was eluted by 50% GuCI. Treatment with alkaline phosphatase identified those four proteins as phosphorylated protamines, and cyanogen bromide (CNBr) treatment of the dephosphorylated protamines distinguished them as variants of protamine 2 and not of protamine 1. Thus far, phosphorylated forms of protamine 1 have not been detected in either spermatids or spermatozoa. Those observations indicate that protamine 2 functions in the cycle of phosphorylation-dephosphorylation, which is essential to the process of sperm chromatin condensation, while the role of protamine 1 in human spermiogenesis is not yet defined. The presence of phosphorylated protamine in motile, presumably mature spermatozoa appears to be characteristic of human sperm but not of the sperm of other mammals and is probably the basis for the heterogeneity of chromatin condensation frequently observed in human spermatozoa.