Mammalian Male Mutation Bias: Impacts of Generation Time and Regional Variation in Substitution Rates

In mammals, males undergo a greater number of germline cell divisions compared with females. Thus, the male germline accumulates more DNA replication errors, which result in male mutation bias—a higher mutation rate for males than for females. The phenomenon of male mutation bias has been investigated mostly for rodents and primates, however, it has not been studied in detail for other mammalian orders. Here we sequenced and analyzed five introns of three genes (DBX/DBY, UTX/UTY, and ZFX/ZFY) homologous between X and Y chromosomes in several species of perissodactyls (horses and rhinos) and of primates. Male mutation bias was evident: substitution rate was higher for a Y chromosome intron than for its X chromosome homologue for all five intron pairs studied. Substitution rates varied regionally among introns sequenced on the same chromosome and this variation influenced male mutation bias inferred from each intron pair. Interestingly, we observed a positive correlation in substitution rates between homologous X and homologous Y introns as well as between orthologous primate and perissodactyl introns. The male-to-female mutation rate ratio estimated from concatenated sequences of five perissodactyl introns was 3.88 (95% CI = 2.90–6.07). Using the data generated here and estimates available in the literature, we compared male mutation bias among several mammalian orders. We conclude that male mutation bias is significantly higher for organisms with long generation times (primates, perissodactyls, and felids) than for organisms with short generation times (e.g., rodents) since the former undergo a greater number of male germline cell divisions. Electronic Supplementary Material Electronic Supplementary material is available for this article at and accessible for authorised users. [Reviewing Editor: Dr. Deborah Charlesworth]     

Sex Differences in Mutation Rate in Higher Primates Estimated from AMG Intron Sequences

To study sex differences in mutation rate in primates, we sequenced the third introns of the AMGX and AMGY genes from humans, orangutans, and squirrel monkeys and estimated that the male-to-female ratio of mutation rate is α= 5.14 with the 95% confidence interval (2.42, 16.6). Combining this data set and the data sets from ZFX/ZFY and SMCX/SMCY introns, we obtained an estimate of α= 5.06 with the 95% confidence interval reduced to (3.24, 8.79). The α value is significantly higher in higher primates than in rodents. Received: 19 August 1996 / Accepted: 22 November 1996     

Variable Substitution Rates of the 18 Domain Sequences in Artemia Hemoglobin

The Artemia hemoglobin is a dimer comprising two nine-domain covalent polymers in quaternary association. Each polymer is encoded by a gene representing nine successive globin domains which have different sequences and are presumed to have been copied originally from a single-domain gene. Two different polymers exist as the result of a complete duplication of the nine-domain gene, allowing the formation of either homodimers or the heterodimer. The total population size of 18 domains comprising nine corresponding pairs, coupled with the probability that they reflect several hundred million years of evolution in the same lineage, provides a unique model in which the process of gene multiplication can be analyzed. The outcome has important implications for the reliability of local molecular clocks. The two polymers differ from each other at 11.7% of amino acid sites; however when corresponding individual domains are compared between polymers, amino acid substitution fluctuates by a factor of 2.7-fold from lowest to highest. This variation is not obvious at the DNA level: Domain pair identity values fluctuate by 1.3-fold. Identity values are, however, uncorrected for multiple substitutions, and both silent and nonsilent changes are pooled. Therefore, to determine the variability in relative substitution rates at the DNA level, we have used the method of Li (1993, J Mol Evol 36:96–99) to determine estimates of nonsynonymous (K _A ) and synonymous (K _S ) substitutions per site for the nine pairs of domains. As expected, the overall level of silent substitutions (K _S of 56.9%) far exceeded nonsilent substitutions (K _A of 6.7%); however, for corresponding domain pairs, K _A fluctuates by 2.3-fold and K _S by 1.7-fold. The large discrepancies reflected in the expressed protein have accrued within a single lineage and the implication is that divergence dates of different genera based on amino acid sequences, even with well-studied proteins of reasonable size, can be wrong by a factor well in excess of 2. Received: 4 June 1997 / Accepted: 17 December 1997     

Synonymous and Nonsynonymous Substitution Rates in Diatoms: A Comparison Between Chloroplast and Nuclear Genes

Rates of synonymous and nonsynonymous nucleotide substitutions and codon usage bias (ENC) were estimated for a number of nuclear and chloroplast genes in a sample of centric and pennate diatoms. The results suggest that DNA evolution has taken place, on an average, at a slower rate in the chloroplast genes than in the nuclear genes: a rate variation pattern similar to that observed in land plants. Synonymous substitution rates in the chloroplast genes show a negative association with the degree of codon usage bias, suggesting that genes with a higher degree of codon usage bias have evolved at a slower rate. While this relationship has been shown in both prokaryotes and multicellular eukaryotes, it has not been demonstrated before in diatoms. Received: 3 June 1998 / Accepted: 11 August 1998     

Rates of Nucleotide Substitution in Angiosperm Mitochondrial DNA Sequences and Dates of Divergence Between Brassica and Other Angiosperm Lineages

We obtained 16 nucleotide sequences (∼1400 bp each) of the first intron of the mitochondrial (mt) gene for NADH subunit 4 (nad4) from 10 species of Brassicaceae. Using these new sequences and five published sequences from GenBank, we constructed a phylogenetic tree of the Brassicaceae species under study and showed that the rate of nucleotide substitution in the first intron of nad4 is very low, about 0.16–0.23 × 10⁻⁹ substitution per site per year, which is about half of the silent rate in exons of nad4. The ratios of substitution rates in this intron, ITS, and IGS are approximately 1:23:73, where ITS is the nuclear intergenic spacer between 18S and 25S rRNA genes and IGS is the intergenic spacer of 5S rRNA genes. A segment (335 bp) in the first intron of nad4 in Brassicaceae species that is absent in wheat was considered as a nonfunctional sequence and used to estimate the neutral rate (the rate of mutation) in mtDNA to be 0.5–0.7 × 10⁻⁹ substitution per site per year, which is about three times higher than the substitution rate in the rest of the first intron of nad4. We estimated that the dates of divergence are 170–235 million years (Myr) for the monocot–dicot split, 112–156 Myr for the Brassicaceae–Lettuce split, 14.5–20.4 Myr for the Brassica–Arabidopsis split, and 14.5–20.4 Myr for the Arabidopsis–Arabideae split. Received: 14 July 1998 / Accepted: 1 October 1998     

Implications of Fluctuations in Substitution Rates: Impact on the Uncertainty of Branch Lengths and on Relative-Rate Tests

Many tests of the lineage dependence of substitution rates, computations of the error of evolutionary distances, and simulations of molecular evolution assume that the rate of evolution is constant in time within each lineage descended from a common ancestor. However, estimates of the index of dispersion of numbers of mammalian substitutions suggest that the rate has time-dependent variations consistent with a fractal-Gaussian-rate Poisson process, which assumes common descent without assuming rate constancy. While this model does not affect certain relative-rate tests, it substantially increases the uncertainty of branch lengths. Thus, fluctuations in the rate of substitution cannot be neglected in calculations that rely on evolutionary distances, such as the confidence intervals of divergence times and certain phylogenetic reconstructions. The fractal-Gaussian-rate Poisson process is compared and contrasted with previous models of molecular evolution, including other Poisson processes, the fractal renewal process, a Lévy-stable process, a fractional-difference process, and a log-Brownian process. The fractal models are more compatible with mammalian data than the nonfractal models considered, and they may also be better supported by Darwinian theory. Although the fractal-Gaussian-rate Poisson process has not been proven to have better agreement with data or theory than the other fractal models, its Gaussian nature simplifies the exploration of its impact on evolutionary distance errors and relative-rate tests. Received: 29 September 1999 / Accepted: 20 January 2000     

Intragenic Variation of Synonymous Substitution Rates Is Caused by Nonrandom Mutations at Methylated CpG

It has been observed that synonymous substitution rates vary among genes in various organisms, although the cause of the variation is unresolved. At the intragenic level, however, the variation of synonymous substitutions is somewhat controversial. By developing a rigorous statistical test and applying the test to 418 homologous gene pairs between mouse and rat, we found that more than 90% of gene pairs showed a statistical significance in intragenic variation of synonymous substitution rates. Moreover, by examining all conceivable possibilities for the cause of the variation, we successfully found that intragenic variation of synonymous substitutions in mammalian genes is caused mainly by a nonrandom mutation due to the methylation of CpG dinucleotides rather than by functional constraints. Received: 12 January 2001 / Accepted: 28 February 2001     

Synonymous Nucleotide Divergence and Saturation: Effects of Site-Specific Variations in Codon Bias and Mutation Rates

The synonymous divergence between Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium is explained in a model where there is a large variation between mutation rates at different nucleotide sites in the genome. The model is based on the experimental observation that spontaneous mutation rates can vary over several orders of magnitude at different sites in a gene. Such site-specific variation must be taken into account when studying synonymous divergence and will result in an apparent saturation below the level expected from an assumption of uniform rates. Recently, it has been suggested that codon preference in enterobacteria has a very large site-specific variation and that the synonymous divergence between different species, e.g., E. coli and Salmonella, is saturated. In the present communication it is shown that when site-specific variation in mutation rates is introduced, there is no need to invoke assumptions of saturation and a large variability in codon preference. The same rate variation will also bring average mutation rates as estimated from synonymous sequence divergence into numerical agreement with experimental values. Received: 10 July 1998 / Accepted: 20 August 1998     

Variation in the Pattern of Nucleotide Substitution Across Sites

A model of nucleotide substitution that allows the transition/transversion rate bias to vary across sites was constructed. We examined the fit of this model using likelihood-ratio tests by analyzing 13 protein coding genes and 1 pseudogene. Likelihood-ratio testing indicated that a model that allows variation in the transition/transversion rate bias across sites provided a significant improvement in fit for most protein coding genes but not for the pseudogene. When the analysis was repeated with parameters estimated separately for first, second, and third codon positions, strong heterogeneity was uncovered for the first and second codon positions; the variation in the transition/transversion rate was generally weaker at the third codon position. The transition rate bias and branch lengths are underestimated when variation in the transition/transversion rate was not accommodated, suggesting that it may be important to accommodate variation in the pattern of nucleotide substitution for accurate estimation of evolutionary parameters. Received: 4 November 1997 / Accepted: 19 May 1998     

Disparate Evolution of Paralogous Introns in the Xdh Gene of Drosophila

Drosophila nuclear introns are commonly assumed to change according to a single rate of substitution, yet little is known about the evolution of these non-coding sequences. The hypothesis of a uniform substitution rate for introns seems to be at odds with recent findings that the nucleotide composition of introns varies at a scale unknown before, and that their base content variation is correlated with that of the adjacent exons. However, no direct attempt at comparing substitution rates in introns seems to have been addressed so far. We have studied the rate of nucleotide substitution over a region of the Xdh gene containing two adjacent short, constitutively spliced introns, in several species of Drosophila and related genera. The two introns differ significantly in base composition and substitution rate, with one intron evolving at least twice as fast as the other. In addition, the substitution pattern of the introns is positively associated with that of the surrounding coding regions, evidencing that the molecular evolution of these introns is impacted by the region in which they are embedded. The observed differences cannot be attributed to selection acting differently at the level of the secondary structure of the pre-mRNA. Rather, they are better accounted for by locally heterogeneous patterns of mutation. Received: 26 July 1999 / Accepted: 21 August 1999     

The Complete Mitochondrial DNA Sequence of the Domestic Sheep (Ovis aries) and Comparison with the Other Major Ovine Haplotype

The complete mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) molecule of the domestic sheep, Ovis aries, was sequenced, together with part of the mtDNA of a specimen representing the other major O. aries haplotype group. The length of the complete ovine mtDNA presented is 16,616 nucleotides (nt). This length is not absolute, however, due to heteroplasmy caused by the occurrence of different numbers of a 75-nt-long tandem repeat in the control region. The sequence data were included in analyses of intraspecific ovine molecular differences, molecular comparisons with bovine mtDNAs, and phylogenetic analyses based on complete mtDNAs. The comparisons with bovine mtDNAs were based on the central domains of the ovine control regions, representing both major ovine haplotype groups, and the corresponding domains of Bos taurus and B. indicus. The comparisons showed that the difference between the bovids was 1.4 times greater than the intraspecific ovine difference. These findings suggest that the strains of wild sheep from which domestic sheep originated were more closely related than were the B. primigenius subspecies which gave rise to B. indicus and B. taurus cattle. Datings based on complete mtDNAs suggest that the bovine and ovine lineages diverged about 30 million years before present. This dating is considerably earlier than that proposed previously. Received: 5 September 1997 / Accepted: 5 May 1998     

Evolution of the Larval Cuticle Proteins Coded by the Secondary Sex Chromosome Pair: X2 and Neo-Y of Drosophila miranda: I. Comparison at the DNA Sequence Level

The larval cuticle protein genes (Lcps) represent a multigene family located at the right arm of the metacentric autosome 2 (2R) in Drosophila melanogaster. Due to a chromosome fusion the Lcp locus of Drosophila miranda is situated on a pair of secondary sex chromosomes, the X2 and neo-Y chromosome. Comparing the DNA sequences from D. miranda and D. melanogaster organization and the gene arrangement of Lcp1–Lcp4 are similar, although the intergene distances vary considerably. The greatest difference between Lcp1 and Lcp2 is due to the occurrence of a pseudogene in D. melanogaster which is not present in D. miranda. Thus the cluster of the four Lcp genes existed already before the separation of the melanogaster and obscura group. Intraspecific homogenizations of different cluster units must have occurred repeatedly between the Lcp1/Lcp2 and Lcp3/Lcp4 sequence types. The most obvious example is exon 2 of the Lcp3 gene in D. miranda, which has been substituted by the corresponding section of the Lcp4 gene rather recently. The homogenization must have occurred before the translocation which generated the neo-Y chromosome. Lcp3 of D. melanogaster has therefore no orthologous partner in D. miranda. Rearrangements in the promoter regions of the D. miranda Lcp genes have generated new, potentially functional CAAT-box motifs. Since three of the Lcp alleles on the neo-Y are not expressed and Lcp3 is expressed only at a reduced level, it is suggestive to speculate that the rearrangements might be involved as cis-regulatory elements in the up-regulation of the X2-chromosomal Lcp alleles, in Drosophila an essential process for dosage compensation. The Lcp genes on the neo-Y chromosome have accumulated more base substitutions than the corresponding alleles on the X2. Received: 27 December 1995 / Accepted: 30 April 1996     

Regular Spliceosomal Introns Are Invasive in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii: 15 Introns in the Recently Relocated Mitochondrial cox2 and cox3 Genes

In the unicellular green alga, Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, cytochrome oxidase subunit 2 (cox2) and 3 (cox3) genes are missing from the mitochondrial genome. We isolated and sequenced a BAC clone that carries the whole cox3 gene and its corresponding cDNA. Almost the entire cox2 gene and its cDNA were also determined. Comparison of the genomic and the corresponding cDNA sequences revealed that the cox3 gene contains as many as nine spliceosomal introns and that cox2 bears six introns. Putative mitochondria targeting signals were predicted at each N terminal of the cox genes. These spliceosomal introns were typical GT–AG-type introns, which are very common not only in Chlamydomonas nuclear genes but also in diverse eukaryotic taxa. We found no particular distinguishing features in the cox introns. Comparative analysis of these genes with the various mitochondrial genes showed that 8 of the 15 introns were interrupting the conserved mature protein coding segments, while the other 7 introns were located in the N-terminal target peptide regions. Phylogenetic analysis of the evolutionary position of C. reinhardtii in Chlorophyta was carried out and the existence of the cox2 and cox3 genes in the mitochondrial genome was superimposed in the tree. This analysis clearly shows that these cox genes were relocated during the evolution of Chlorophyceae. It is apparent that long before the estimated period of relocation of these mitochondrial genes, the cytosol had lost the splicing ability for group II introns. Therefore, at least eight introns located in the mature protein coding region cannot be the direct descendant of group II introns. Here, we conclude that the presence of these introns is due to the invasion of spliceosomal introns, which occurred during the evolution of Chlorophyceae. This finding provides concrete evidence supporting the ``intron-late' model, which rests largely on the mobility of spliceosomal introns. Received: 22 August 2000 / Accepted: 28 February 2001     

Evolution of Microsatellite Alleles in Four Species of Mice (Genus Apodemus)

Microsatellite length variation was investigated at a highly variable microsatellite locus in four species of Apodemus. Information obtained from microsatellite allele sequences was contrasted with allele sizes, which included 18 electromorphs. Additional analysis of a 400-bp unique sequence in the flanking region identified 26 different haplotype sequences or ``true' alleles in the sample. Three molecular mechanisms, namely, (1) addition/deletion of repeats, (2) substitutions and indels in the flanking region, and (3) mutations interrupting the repeat, contributed to the generation of allelic variation. Size homoplasy can be inferred for alleles within populations, from different populations of the same species, and from different species. We propose that microsatellite flanking sequences may be informative markers for investigating mutation processes in microsatellite repeats as well as phylogenetic relationships among alleles, populations, and species. Received: 3 November 1999 / Accepted: 2 May 2000     

Evolution of the Larval Cuticle Proteins Coded by the Secondary Sex Chromosome Pair: X2 and Neo-Y of Drosophila miranda: II. Comparison at the Amino Acid Sequence Level

The larval cuticle proteins (LCPs) are encoded by a multigene family, Lcp1–4, located at the right arm of the metacentric autosome 2 (2R) in Drosophila melanogaster. Due to a chromosome fusion the Lcp locus of Drosophila miranda is situated on a pair of secondary sex chromosomes, the X2 and neo-Y chromosomes. Comparing the deduced amino acid sequences of the autosomal D. melanogaster loci with the sex-chromosomal loci of D. miranda, we were able to trace the evolution of the Lcp loci with respect to their different chromosomal inheritance. The length of the signal peptide is conserved in all four LCPs, while the size of the mature LCPs varies. Conserved protein motifs became obvious from the alignment, indicating regions of structural and functional importance. Analyzing intra- and interspecific sequence similarities of the Lcp gene families allowed us to reconstruct the phylogeny of the gene cluster. Alignment with cuticle amino acid sequences originating from divergent insect species reveals motifs already present in the primordial insect LCPs. These motifs indicate different levels of constraint acting during the evolution of the LCPs. Received: 27 December 1995 / Accepted: 30 April 1996     

Mutation and Recombination in Cattle Satellite DNA: A Feedback Model for the Evolution of Satellite DNA Repeats

The cattle genome contains several distinct centromeric satellites with interrelated evolutionary histories. We compared these satellites in Bovini species that diverged 0.2 to about 5 Myr ago. Quantification of hybridization signals by phosphor imaging revealed a large variation in the relative amounts of the major satellites. In the genome of water buffalo this has led to the complete deletion of satellite III. Comparative sequencing and PCR-RFLP analysis of satellites IV, 1.711a, and 1.711b from the related Bos and Bison species revealed heterogeneities in 0.5 to 2% of the positions, again with variations in the relative amounts of sequence variants. Restriction patterns generated by double digestions suggested a recombination of sequence variants. Our results are compatible with a model of the life history of satellites during which homogeneity of interacting repeat units is both cause and consequence of the rapid turnover of satellite DNA. Initially, a positive feedback loop leads to a rapid saltatory amplification of homogeneous repeat units. In the second phase, mutations inhibit the interaction of repeat units and coexisting sequence variants amplify independently. Homogenization by the spreading of one of the variants is prevented by recombination and the satellite is eventually outcompeted by another, more homogeneous tandem repeat sequence. Received: 21 July 2000 / Accepted: 30 October 2000     

High Evolutionary Rates in Nuclear Genes of Squamates

We compared nonsynonymous substitution rates (Ka) of nuclear coding genes between four major groups of living sauropsids (reptiles): birds, squamates, crocodiles, and turtles. Since only 9 orthologous genes are known in all the four taxonomic groups, we searched for orthologous genes known in chicken and at least one of any representative of poikilotherm sauropsids. Thus, we analyzed three additional data sets: 28 genes identified in chicken and various squamates, 24 genes identified in chicken and crocodilians, and 20 genes identified in chicken and turtles. To compare nonsynonymous substitution rates between all lineages of sauropsids, we used the relative-rate test with human genes as the outgroup. We show that 22/28 nuclear coding genes of squamates, especially snakes (15/16), have an higher evolutionary rate than those in chicken (in mean, 30–40% faster). However, no such difference is detected between crocodiles, turtles and chicken. Higher substitution rate in squamates nuclear coding genes than in chicken, and probably than in other sauropsids, could explain some of the difficulties in resolving the molecular phylogeny of reptiles. Received: 5 July 2000 / Accepted: 13 February 2001     

Evolution of Orthologous Intronless and Intron-Bearing Globin Genes in Two Insect Species

While globin genes ctt-2β and ctt-9.1 in Chironomus thummi thummi each have a single intron, all of the other insect globin genes reported so far are intronless. We analyzed four globin genes linked to the two intron-bearing genes in C. th. thummi. Three have a single intron at the same position as ctt-2β and ctt-9.1; the fourth is intronless and lies between intron bearing genes. Finally, in addition to its intron, one gene (ctt-13RT) was recently interrupted by retrotransposition. Phylogenetic analyses show that the six genes in C. th. thummi share common ancestry with five globin genes in the distantly related species C. tentans, and that a 5-gene ancestral cluster predates the divergence of the two species. One gene in the ancestral cluster gave rise to ctn-ORFB in C. tentans, and duplicated in C. th. thummi to create ctt-11 and ctt-12. From parsimonious calculations of evolutionary distances since speciation, ctt-11, ctt-12, and ctn-ORFB evolved rapidly, while ctn-ORFE in C. tentans evolved slowly compared to other globin genes in the clusters. While these four globins are under selective pressure, we suggest that most chironomid globin genes were not selected for their unique function. Instead, we propose that high gene copy number itself was selected because conditions favored organisms that could synthesize more hemoglobin. High gene copy number selection to produce more of a useful product may be the basis of forming multigene families, all of whose members initially accumulate neutral substitutions while retaining essential function. Maintenance of a large family of globin genes not only ensured high levels of hemoglobin production, but may have facilitated the extensive divergence of chironomids into as many as 5000 species. Received: 31 December 1996 / Accepted: 16 May 1997     

Clustering of Tissue-Specific Genes Underlies Much of the Similarity in Rates of Protein Evolution of Linked Genes

Are genes nonrandomly distributed around the genome and might this explain why it was found that, in the mouse genome, proteins of linked genes evolve at similar rates? Anecdotal evidence suggests that the similarity of expression of linked genes might, in part, explain the similarity in their rates of evolution. Immune system genes, for example, are known to evolve at a high rate and sometimes cluster in the genome. Here we develop methods for statistical tests of similarity of expression of linked genes and report that there is a significant tendency for genes of similar expression breadth to be linked. Significantly, when we exclude tissue specific genes from our sample, the similarity in rates of protein evolution of linked genes is greatly diminished, if not abolished. This diminution is not a sampling artifact. In contrast, while half of the immune genes in our sample reside in 1 of 10 immune clusters in the mouse genome, this clustering appears not to affect the extent of local similarity in rates of evolution. The distribution of placentally expressed genes, in contrast, does have an effect.