The selection of marginal zone B cells differs from that of B-1a cells

Transgenic (Tg) L2 mice expressing high levels of the lambda2 (315) L chain contain only B cell populations involved in the first line of defense, i.e., B-1 and marginal zone (MZ) B cells. The strongly oligoclonal IgH chain repertoire of Tg B-1a cells in such mice was attributed to strong positive selection by autoantigens. In this study, we show that the MZ B cells of L2 mice correspond very closely to MZ B cells of normal mice, as revealed by surface marker expression and gene expression profiling. We demonstrate that the IgH chain repertoire of these Tg MZ B cells is extremely heterogeneous. This is in sharp contrast to the oligoclonality found in B-1a cells of the same mice, which was attributed to strong positive selection mediated by autoantigens. Therefore, the strong positive selection of the IgH chain repertoire in L2 mice is B-1a specific. Thus, our data demonstrate that despite common functional properties, MZ B and B-1a cells exhibit striking differences in their selection and/or maintenance requirements.     

Antibody repertoire and gene expression profile: implications for different developmental and functional traits of splenic and peritoneal B-1 lymphocytes

In L2 mice, a high expression level of the transgenic lambda2(315) L chain results in nearly complete exclusion of endogenous L chains and a predominance of B-1a cells. In this study, we show that splenic and peritoneal B-1a cells differ considerably in their Ab repertoire and gene expression profile. Splenic B-1a cells exhibit a more diversified repertoire under L chain limitation. Despite oligoclonal overlaps between both B-1a compartments, some B cell receptor specificities are clearly restricted to the peritoneum. The capacity of peritoneal B-1a cells to enter the splenic B-1a compartment was found to be very limited. Gene expression profiling revealed genes up-regulated in splenic B-1a cells that are involved in mediating specialized first-line-of-defense effector functions and interaction with T cells. Thus, splenic and peritoneal B-1a cells differ not only in their developmental program but also in functional properties.     

Functional activity of natural antibody is altered in Cr2-deficient mice

The major source of natural IgM Abs are B-1 cells, which differ from conventional B cells in their anatomic location, cell surface phenotype, restricted usage of particular V(H) genes and limited use of N-region addition during V-D-J rearrangement. The origin of B-1 cells is unclear. However, they are capable of self-renewal and their development is sensitive to signaling via the B cell receptor, as genetic defects that impair the strength of the signal often result in limited development. These findings suggest that B-1 cells require either an intrinsic signal, or contact with Ag, for positive selection and expansion and/or maintenance in the periphery. In support of interaction with cognate Ag, deficiency in the complement receptors CD21/CD35 results in a 30-40% decrease in the CD5(+) B-1 population. To determine whether this reduction reflects a loss of certain specificities or simply a proportional decline in the repertoire, we examined peritoneal B cells isolated from Cr2(+) and Cr2(def) mice for recognition of a B-1 cell Ag, i.e., phosphatidylcholine, and assayed for injury in an IgM natural Ab-dependent model of reperfusion injury. We found a similar frequency of phosphatidylcholine-specific CD5(+) B-1 cells in the two strains of mice. By contrast, the Cr2(def) mice have reduced injury in the IgM-dependent model of reperfusion injury. Reconstitution of the deficient mice with pooled IgM or adoptive transfer of Cr2(+) peritoneal B cells restored injury. These results suggest that complement receptors CD21/CD35 are important in maintenance of the B-1 cell repertoire to some, but not all, specificities.     

IL-9-induced expansion of B-1b cells restores numbers but not function of B-1 lymphocytes in xid mice

Mice expressing the X-linked immunodeficiency (xid) mutation lack functional Bruton's tyrosine kinase and were shown to be specifically deficient in peritoneal B-1 lymphocytes. We have previously shown that IL-9, a cytokine produced by TH2 lymphocytes, promotes B-1 cell expansion in vivo. To determine whether IL-9 overexpression might compensate the xid mutation for B-1 lymphocyte development, we crossed xid mice with IL-9-transgenic mice. In this model, IL-9 restored normal numbers of mature peritoneal B-1 cells that all belonged to the CD5(-) B-1b subset. Despite this normal B-1 lymphocyte number, IL-9 failed to restore classical functions of B-1 cells, namely, the production of natural IgM Abs, the T15 Id Ab response to phosphorylcholine immunization, and the antipolysaccharide humoral response against Streptococcus pneumoniae. By using bromelain-treated RBC, we showed that the antigenic repertoire of these IL-9-induced B-1b lymphocytes was different from the repertoire of classical CD5(+) B-1a cells, indicating that the lack of B-1 function by B-1b cells is associated with distinct Ag specificities. Taken together, our data show that B-1b cell development can restore the peritoneal B-1 population in xid mice but that these B-1b cells are functionally distinct from CD5(+) B-1a lymphocytes.     

A single DH gene segment creates its own unique CDR-H3 repertoire and is sufficient for B cell development and immune function

To test the contribution of individual D gene segments to B cell development and function, we used gene targeting to create mice that contain only DFL16.1 in the DH locus. We term this D-limited IgH allele DeltaD-DFL. Although the absolute number of IgM+IgD- B cells in the bone marrow was decreased, homozygous DeltaD-DFL BALB/c mice contained normal numbers of IgM+IgD+ B cells in bone marrow and spleen and normal numbers of B1a, B1b, and B2 cells in the peritoneal cavity. Bone marrow IgM+IgD+ B cells express a CDR-H3 repertoire similar in length and amino acid composition to the DFL16.1 subset of the wild-type BALB/c repertoire but divergent from sequences that do not contain DFL16.1. This similarity in content is the product of both germline bias and somatic selection, especially in the transition to the mature IgM+IgD+ stage of development. Serum Ig concentrations and the humoral immune response to a T-dependent Ag ([4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl]acetyl hapten) were nearly identical to wild-type littermate controls. A greater variance in the immune response to the T-independent Ag (alpha(1-->3)-dextran) was observed in DeltaD-DFL homozygotes, with half of the mice exhibiting levels below the range exhibited by controls. Although limited to a repertoire specific to DFL16.1, the presence of a single DH gene segment of normal sequence was sufficient for development of normal numbers of mature B cells and for robust humoral immune function.     

Negative selection by IgM superantigen defines a B cell central tolerance compartment and reveals mutations allowing escape

To analyze B lymphocyte central tolerance in a polyclonal immune system, mice were engineered to express a superantigen reactive to IgM of allotype b (IgM(b)). IgM(b/b) mice carrying superantigen were severely B cell lymphopenic, but small numbers of B cells matured. Their sera contained low levels of IgG and occasionally high levels of IgA. In bone marrow, immature B cells were normal in number, but internalized IgM and had a unique gene expression profile, compared with those expressing high levels of surface IgM, including elevated recombinase activator gene expression. A comparable B cell population was defined in wild-type bone marrows, with an abundance suggesting that at steady state ～20% of normal developing B cells are constantly encountering autoantigens in situ. In superantigen-expressing mice, as well as in mice carrying the 3H9 anti-DNA IgH transgene, or 3H9 H along with mutation in the murine κ-deleting element RS, IgM internalization was correlated with CD19 downmodulation. CD19(low) bone marrow cells from 3H9;RS(-/-) mice were enriched in L chains that promote DNA binding. Our results suggest that central tolerance and attendant L chain receptor editing affect a large fraction of normal developing B cells. IgH(a/b) mice carrying the superantigen had a ～50% loss in follicular B cell numbers, suggesting that escape from central tolerance by receptor editing from one IgH allele to another was not a major mechanism. IgM(b) superantigen hosts reconstituted with experimental bone marrow were demonstrated to be useful in revealing pathways involved in central tolerance.     

B-1a, B-1b and B-2 B cells display unique VHDJH repertoires formed at different stages of ontogeny and under different selection pressures.

Analyses of VHDJH rearrangements isolated from murine peritoneal B-1a cells (CD5+, IgMhi, B220lo), peritoneal B-1b cells (CD5-, IgMhi, B220lo), and conventional splenic B cells provide evidence that a unique repertoire of VH regions is displayed by each of these B-cell subsets. The B-1a subset is characterized by a low N-region diversity, by a high frequency of sequence homologies in the VH-D and D-JH junctions, and by a limited exonuclease nibbling of the terminals of the joining gene segments. Through expansion in ageing mice, B-1a clones with these properties are favoured. B-1b cells are similar to conventional B-2 cells with respect to N-region diversity, but are unique in terms of D gene expression. Thus, while most murine pre-B and B cells preferentially use DSP and DFL gene segments in a given reading frame (RF1), B-1b cells frequently express D genes in another reading frame (RF2). Together, these findings provide structural evidence for a model where B-1a, B-1b and B-2 cells are produced by separate progenitors that are active at different stages of ontogeny.     

Peritoneal cavity B cells are precursors of splenic IgM natural antibody-producing cells

Peritoneal cavity B-1 cells are believed to produce IgM natural Abs. We have used alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase-deficient (GalT(-/-)) mice, which, like humans, produce IgM natural Abs against the carbohydrate epitope Galalpha1,3Gal (Gal), to demonstrate that peritoneal cavity B-1b cells with anti-Gal receptors produce anti-Gal IgM Abs only after LPS stimulation. Likewise, peritoneal cavity cells of GalT(-/-) and wild-type mice do not produce IgM Abs of other specificities without LPS stimulation. Development of Ab-secreting capacity is associated with loss of CD11b/CD18 (Mac-1) expression. In contrast, there are large numbers of cells producing anti-Gal and other IgM Abs in fresh splenocyte preparations from GalT(-/-) and (for non-Gal specificities) wild-type mice. These cells are Mac-1(-) but otherwise B-1b-like in their phenotype. We therefore hypothesized a pathway wherein peritoneal cavity B cells migrate into the spleen after activation in vivo and lose Mac-1 expression to become IgM Ab-producing cells. Consistent with this possibility, splenectomy reduced anti-Gal Ab production after immunization of GalT(-/-) mice with Gal-positive rabbit RBC. Furthermore, splenectomized B6 GalT(-/-), Ig micro -chain mutant ( micro (-/-)) (both Gal- and B cell-deficient) mice produced less anti-Gal IgM than nonsplenectomized controls after adoptive transfer of peritoneal cavity cells from B6 GalT(-/-) mice. When sorted GalT(-/-) Mac-1(+) peritoneal cavity B cells were adoptively transferred to B6 GalT(-/-), micro (-/-) mice, IgM Abs including anti-Gal appeared, and IgM-producing and Mac1(-) B cells were present in the spleen 5 wk after transfer. These findings demonstrate that peritoneal cavity Mac-1(+) B-1 cells are precursors of Mac-1(-) splenic IgM Ab-secreting cells.     

B-1 B cell development

CD5+ B cells have attracted considerable interest because of their association with self-reactivity, autoimmunity, and leukemia. In mice, CD5+ B cells are readily generated from fetal/neonatal precursors, but inefficiently from precursors in adult. One model proposed to explain this difference is that their production occurs through a distinctive developmental process, termed B-1, that enriches pre-B cells with novel germline VDJs and that requires positive selection of newly formed B cells by self-Ag. In contrast, follicular B cells are generated throughout adult life in a developmental process termed B-2, selecting VDJs that pair well with surrogate L chain, and whose maturation appears relatively independent of antigenic selection. In the present study, I focus on processes that shape the repertoire of mouse CD5+ B cells, describing the differences between B-1 and B-2 development, and propose a model encompassing both in the generation of functional B cell subpopulations.     

Mechanisms of peritoneal B-1a cells accumulation induced by murine lupus susceptibility locus Sle2

The abundance of B-1a cells found in the peritoneal cavity of mice is under genetic control. The lupus-prone mouse New Zealand Black and New Zealand White (NZB x NZW)F(1) and its derivative NZM2410 are among the strains with the highest numbers of peritoneal B1-a cells. We have previously identified an NZM2410 genetic locus, Sle2, which is associated with the production of large numbers of B-1a cells. In this paper, we examined the mechanisms responsible for this phenotype by comparing congenic C57BL/6 mice with or without Sle2. Fetal livers generated more B-1a cells in B6.Sle2 mice, providing them with a greater starting number of B-1a cells early in life. Sle2-expressing B1-a cells proliferated significantly more in vivo than their B6 counterparts, and reciprocal adoptive transfers showed that this phenotype is intrinsic to Sle2 peritoneal B cells. The rate of apoptosis detected was significantly lower in B6.Sle2 peritoneal cavity B-1a cells than in B6, with or without exogenous B cell receptor cross-linking. Increased proliferation and decreased apoptosis did not affect Sle2 peritoneal B-2 cells. In addition, a significant number of peritoneal cavity B-1a cells were recovered in lethally irradiated B6.Sle2 mice reconstituted with B6.Igh(a) bone marrow, showing radiation resistance in Sle2 B-1a cells or its precursors. Finally, B6.Sle2 adult bone marrow and spleen were a significant source of peritoneal B-1a cells when transferred into B6.Rag2(-/-) mice. This suggests that peritoneal B-1a cells are replenished throughout the animal life span in B6.Sle2 mice. These results show that Sle2 regulates the size of the B-1a cell compartment at multiple developmental checkpoints.     

Transgenic overexpression of G5PR that is normally augmented in centrocytes impairs the enrichment of high-affinity antigen-specific B cells, increases peritoneal B-1a cells, and induces autoimmunity in aged female mice

To investigate signals that control B cell selection, we examined expression of G5PR, a regulatory subunit of the serine/threonine protein phosphatase 2A, which suppresses JNK phosphorylation. G5PR is upregulated in activated B cells, in Ki67-negative centrocytes at germinal centers (GCs), and in purified B220(+)Fas(+)GL7(+) mature GC B cells following Ag immunization. G5PR rescues transformed B cells from BCR-mediated activation-induced cell death by suppression of late-phase JNK activation. In G5PR-transgenic (G5PR(Tg)) mice, G5PR overexpression leads to an augmented generation of GC B cells via an increase in non-Ag-specific B cells and a consequent reduction in the proportion of Ag-specific B cells and high-affinity Ab production after immunization with nitrophenyl-conjugated chicken γ-globulin. G5PR overexpression impaired the affinity-maturation of Ag-specific B cells, presumably by diluting the numbers of high-affinity B cells. However, aged nonimmunized female G5PR(Tg) mice showed an increase in the numbers of peritoneal B-1a cells and the generation of autoantibodies. G5PR overexpression did not affect the proliferation of B-1a and B-2 cells but rescued B-1a cells from activation-induced cell death in vitro. G5PR might play a pivotal role in B cell selection not only for B-2 cells but also for B-1 cells in peripheral lymphoid organs.     

The pre-B-cell receptor: selector of fitting immunoglobulin heavy chains for the B-cell repertoire

In this Opinion article, I address the role of the pre-B-cell receptor (pre-BCR) in the development of antigen-specific B cells in terms of immunoglobulin heavy chain (IgH) variable-region repertoire selection, precursor B-cell differentiation and proliferation, and IgH allelic exclusion. Comparisons with the role of the pre-T-cell receptor (pre-TCR) in T-cell development raise provocative questions. Why do B- and T-cell lineages both use a surrogate chain - the surrogate light chain and the pre-TCR alpha-chain, respectively - as a step to develop their repertoires of antigen-recognizing cells? What are the functions of the pre-BCR and pre-TCR in lymphocyte differentiation and antigen-receptor allelic exclusion? This article, together with the accompanying article by Harald von Boehmer, hopes to answer some of these questions.     

In Situ IgM Production and Clonal Expansion of B-1 Cells in Peritoneal Cavity Promote Elimination of C. albicans Infection in IgH Transgenic Mice with VH Derived from a Natural Antibody

B-1 cells are innate-like cells that play important roles in host defense against infection. However, the function of B-1 cells in fungi infection remains unclear. Previously we produced IgH transgenic mice TgV_H3B4 with V_H derived from a natural antibody 3B4 that can identify C. albicans, and found that TgV_H3B4 mice were resistant to intraperitoneal (i. p.) and intravenous C. albicans infection. Most of the peritoneal cavity (PEC) B-1 cells in TgV_H3B4 mice express transgenic BCR that binds C. albicans. In the present study, we explored the response of B-1 cells to C. albicans infection by applying i. p. inoculation of fungi in TgV_H3B4 mice. We found that C. albicans was cleared more efficiently in TgV_H3B4 mice after i. p. inoculation than that of littermate control. The level of C. albicans-reactive IgM in PEC of TgV_H3B4 mice was much higher than that of control, and the number of B-1a B cells was also elevated in TgV_H3B4 mice, which was mainly due to enhanced proliferation of B-1 cells. Additionally, numbers of C. albicans-specific B cells increased greatly in TgV_H3B4 mice after C. albicans inoculation. Our data suggested that in situ IgM production and clonal expansion of B-1 cells in PEC participate in host defense against C. albicans infection.     

Association of B-1 B cells with follicular dendritic cells in spleen

Although CD5(+) B-1 B cells have been recognized as an infrequent B cell subset in mice for many years, attempts to identify their histologic location in normal mouse spleen have proven difficult due to both their paucity and low level expression of CD5. In this study we have studied V(H)11/D(H)/J(H) gene-targeted mice, V(H)11t, that develop elevated numbers of CD5(+) V(H)11/V(k)9 B cells with an anti-phosphatidylcholine (anti-PtC) autoreactive specificity, allowing B-1 B cell detection by anti-PtC Id-specific Abs in spleen section staining. Using this approach we found that anti-PtC B-1 cells first appear within the white pulp in neonates, expand in association with follicular dendritic cells (FDC), and localize more centrally than other (non-B-1) IgD(high) follicular B cells in adults. Among neonatal B cells, CD5(+) B-1 cells in both normal and V(H)11t mouse spleen and peritoneal cavity express the highest levels of CXCR5, which is important for FDC development. Injection of purified spleen or peritoneal B-1 cells into RAG knockout mice resulted in B-1 cell follicle formation in spleen, inducing FDC development and plasma cell generation. These results indicate that B-1 B cells are the first B cells to express fully mature levels of CXCR5, thereby promoting the development of FDC.     

Preferential autoantibody reactivity of the preimmune B cell repertoire in normal mice

Naturally occurring autoantibodies are frequently found in the sera of healthy individuals. They usually exhibit low binding affinities for autoantigens and often react with multiple antigenic determinants. To determine whether their frequencies have been overestimated by sensitive testing procedures, the germ-line B cell repertoire of strain A mice was examined for reactivity with a panel of auto- and foreign Ag. If the high frequencies of autoantibodies result from testing procedures, equally high frequencies would be expected for foreign Ag specificities detected in the same manner. The presence of specific autoantibodies was confirmed in this study by the disparate frequencies observed for antibodies reactive with individual Ag. The frequencies were highest for autoantigens associated with SLE, indicating a bias toward autoreactivity in the preimmune repertoire. Analysis of VH gene usage did not indicate any selection in V gene expression with autoreactivity.     

Impaired clearance of apoptotic cells induces the activation of autoreactive anti-Sm marginal zone and B-1 B cells

Since apoptotic cell Ags are thought to be a source of self-Ag in systemic lupus erythematosus, we have examined the role of apoptotic cells in the regulation and activation of B cells specific for Sm, a ribonucleoprotein targeted in human and murine lupus. Using Ig-transgenic mice that have a high frequency of anti-Sm B cells, we find that apoptotic cell injection induces a transient splenic B cell response, while simultaneously causing extensive splenic and peritoneal anti-Sm B cell death. In contrast, mice deficient in the clearance of apoptotic cells develop a chronic anti-Sm response beginning at 1-2 mo of age. These mice have expanded marginal zone and B-1 B cell populations and anti-Sm B cells of both types are activated to form Ab-secreting cells. This activation appears to be Ag-specific, suggesting that activation is due to increased availability of apoptotic cell Ags. Since marginal zone and B-1 cells are positively selected, these data suggest a loss of ignorance rather than a loss of tolerance.     

Lupus-specific antiribonucleoprotein B cell tolerance in nonautoimmune mice is maintained by differentiation to B-1 and governed by B cell receptor signaling thresholds

Systemic lupus erythematosus is an autoimmune disease characterized by the presence of autoantibodies. One of the unique targets of the immune system in systemic lupus erythematosus is Sm, a ribonucleoprotein present in all cells. To understand the regulation of B cells specific to the Sm Ag in normal mice, we have generated an Ig H chain transgenic mouse (2-12H Tg). 2-12H Tg mice produce B cells specific for the Sm that remain tolerant due to ignorance. We demonstrate here that anti-Sm B cells of 2-12H Tg mice can differentiate into Sm-specific peritoneal B-1 cells that remain tolerant. Differentiation to B-1 and tolerance are governed by the strength of B cell receptor signaling, since manipulations of the B cell receptor coreceptors CD19 and CD22 affect anti-Sm B cell differentiation and autoantibody production. These results suggest a differentiation scheme in which peripheral ignorance to Sm is maintained in mice by the differentiation of anti-Sm B cells to B-1 cells that have increased activation thresholds.     

Correlation between the avidity maturation of anti-HSP70 IgG autoantibody and recombination activating gene expressions in peripheral lymphoid tissues of Toxoplasma gondii-infected mice

The avidity maturation of anti-TgHSP70 IgG antibody produced by B-2 cells of BALB/c mice (a resistant strain) and that of anti-mHSP70 IgG autoantibody produced by B-1 cells of C57BL/6 mice (B6; a susceptible strain) was observed after Toxoplasma gondii infection. Recombination-activating genes (RAGs) were predominantly expressed in B-1 cells from peritoneal exudate cells (PECs) of T. gondii-infected B6 mice, while RAGs were expressed in B-2 cells from PECs of BALB/c mice. These results suggest that the involvement of RAG gene activations in the peripheral lymphoid tissues in the avidity maturation of anti-TgHSP70 IgG antibody and anti-mHSP70 IgG autoantibody in T. gondii-infected mice.