ABRF ESRG 2006 Study: Edman Sequencing as a Method for Polypeptide Quantitation

The Edman Sequencing Research Group (ESRG) designs studies on the use of Edman degradation for protein and peptide analysis. These studies provide a means for participating laboratories to compare their analyses against a benchmark of those from other laboratories that provide this valuable service. The main purpose of the 2006 study was to determine how accurate Edman sequencing is for quantitative analysis of polypeptides. Secondarily, participants were asked to identify a modified amino acid residue, N-epsilon-acetyl lysine [Lys(Ac)], present within one of the peptides. The ESRG 2006 peptide mixture consisted of three synthetic peptides. The Peptide Standards Research Group (PSRG) provided two peptides, with the following sequences: KAQYARSVLLEKDAEPDILELATGYR (peptide B), and RQAKVLLYSGR (peptide C). The third peptide, peptide C*, synthesized and characterized by ESRG, was identical to peptide C but with acetyl lysine in position 4. The mixture consisted of 20% peptide B and 40% each of peptide C and its acetylated form, peptide C*. Participating laboratories were provided with two tubes, each containing 100 picomoles of the peptide mixture (as determined by quantitative amino acid analysis) and were asked to provide amino acid assignments, peak areas, retention times at each cycle, as well as initial and repetitive yield estimates for each peptide in the mixture. Details about instruments and parameters used in the analysis were also collected. Participants in the study with access to a mass spectrometer (MALDI-TOF or ESI) were asked to provide information about the relative peak areas of the peptides in the mixture as a comparison with the peptide quantitation results from Edman sequencing. Positive amino acid assignments were 88% correct for peptide C and 93% correct for peptide B. The absolute initial sequencing yields were an average of 67% for peptide (C+C*) and 65.6 % for peptide B. The relative molar ratios determined by Edman sequencing were an average of 4.27 (expected ratio of 4) for peptides (C+C*)/B, and 1.49 for peptide C*/C (expected ratio of 1); the seemingly high 49% error in quantification of Lys(Ac) in peptide C* can be attributed to commercial unavailability of its PTH standard. These values compare very favorably with the values obtained by mass spectrometry.     

The oligosaccharide units of rabbit immunoglobulin G. Asymmetric attachment of C2-oligosaccharide

Two populations of immunoglobulin G (IgG) molecules were isolated from pooled rabbit serum. The first was almost devoid of galactosamine and was obtained in a yield of 7% of the total IgG; the second contained on average a single residue of galactosamine per molecule and was obtained in a yield of 30% of the total IgG. The galactosamine, which is present solely in the C2-oligosaccharide, appeared to be present on one H-chain and not the other in the four-chain structure. Evidence was obtained by the isolation of a glycopeptide linked through a disulphide bridge to a second peptide of the same sequence; the oligosaccharide attached to the first peptide was absent from the complementary peptide. Further evidence was obtained by degradation and analysis of the 5S IgG fragment, which comprises an intact half-molecule coupled through a disulphide bridge to the Fc fragment derived from the opposing half molecule (Goodman, 1965); only the intact H-chain carried the C2-oligosaccharide.     

A fast and sensitive micromethod for the manual sequencing of peptides using O-phthalaldehyde as derivatizing reagent

A general procedure for the manual sequencing of peptides using the fluorogenic reagent O-phthalaldehyde (OPA) is described. The method can be applied in two different ways. One of them involves back hydrolysis of the anilinothiazolinones resulting from the Edman degradation of the peptide and subsequent detection of the free amino acids as OPA derivatives. The other is a subtractive analysis in which the amino acid composition of the remaining peptide is determined after each degradation cycle. The direct procedure can be coupled to the subtractive one in order to assure the accuracy of the sequence analysis. The method is fast and simple, and allows determination of 10 pmol of amino acid per cycle using standard reagents and instrumentation. Sensitivity can be greatly enhanced provided that ultrapure chemicals are employed. Small peptides (8-10 residues) were sequenced from 200 pmol sample, using a high-performance liquid chromatography assembly coupled to a fluorescence detector.     

Microsequence analysis of peptides and proteins. IX. Manual gas-phase microsequencing of multiple samples

A novel apparatus for performing manual gas-phase Edman chemistry on protein and peptide samples is described. Edman chemistry is performed in 6 to 10 Teflon continuous flow reactors (CFR), previously described by J.E. Shively et al. (1987) Anal. Biochem. 163, 517-529). The CFRs are packed with 10-15 mg of Polybrene-coated spherical silica (Porasil B, Waters Associates). The gas-phase coupling reagent and cleavage reagent are 5% aqueous triethylamine and anhydrous trifluoroacetic acid, respectively, delivered by a stream of argon gas. The delivery of the gas-phase reagents is manually controlled with Hamilton 3-way valves and 2-way valves, and that of the solvents, ethyl acetate and butyl chloride, by syringe pipetting. The average cycle time is 15-20 min for 6 to 10 samples run simultaneously. Conversion of the anilinothiazolinone to phenylthiohydantoin (PTH) amino acid derivatives is accomplished manually with 25% aqueous trifluoroacetic acid. The PTH amino acids are analyzed by reversed-phase HPLC using an autosampler for handling multiple samples. Excellent results were obtained in the 100-200 pmol range. Protein samples can be sequenced from 15-20 cycles, and peptide samples usually to the COOH terminus. Initial yields ranged from 30 to 60% and repetitive yields ranged from 90 to 96%. The sample washout and size of background peaks are significantly reduced, compared to older methods of manual sequence analysis. The yields and background signal to noise are comparable to automated gas-phase Edman chemistry. The improved manual Edman described represents a low cost alternative to automated sequence analysis, and has the advantage being able to process multiple samples simultaneously.     

Solid-phase sequencing on the gas-phase sequencer

Automated Edman degradation has been successfully used for determining the primary structure of numerous peptides and proteins. Quantitative solid-phase Edman degradation has great potential use for amino acid sequence analysis of synthetic peptides assembled on resin support by the Merrifield procedure. We report here the combined use of a modified gas-phase sequencer program and our improved reversed-phase HPLC analysis for PTH-amino acids to carry out the sequence analysis on synthesized peptide resins. This approach is far more sensitive than using glass beads on the conventional solid-phase sequencer. The peptide was assembled on copoly (styrene-1% divinylbenzene) resin beads at an initial substitution of 0.54 mmol/g. On a routine basis, 10-15 resin beads are used, and a repetitive yield of 94% is obtained: as few as 4 beads can be successfully sequenced. The HPLC PTH-amino acid analysis is sensitive down to subpicomole quantities. This procedure offers a sensitive and rapid analytical tool for checking the purity of peptides as they are being assembled on solid support.     

Solvent selection for solid-to-solid synthesis

Thermolysin catalyzed solid-to-solid synthesis of the model peptide Z-L-Phe-L-Leu-NH(2) is practically feasible in water and a range of organic solvents with different physicochemical properties. Excellent overall conversions were obtained in acetonitrile, ethyl acetate, n-hexane, methanol, 2-propanol, tert-amyl alcohol, tetrahydrofuran, toluene and water, while no product precipitation was observed in dichloromethane resulting in a much lower yield. In precipitation driven synthesis the product accumulates both in solution and in the solid phase. It was shown that the highest overall yields (yield in the liquid plus yield in the solid) can be expected in solvents where the substrate solubilities are minimized. The best yields of solid product can be expected in solvents where both product and substrate solubilities are lowest. This was in agreement with experimental observations and should be generally valid.     

Covalent attachment of peptides to cytochrome C for automated sequence determination.

Because small peptides are lost into the organic solvents used, it is virtually impossible to obtain the complete amino acid sequence of a small peptide using only an automated peptide sequencer of the spinning cup type. To overcome this problem we have extended peptides at the carboxy terminus by attachment to equine cytochrome c by a water soluble carbodiimide, relying on the acetylated N-terminus of the cytochrome to minimize its direct contribution to recovery of PTH-amino acids. The Model Peptide H-Leu-Trp-Met-Arg-phe-Ala-OH was used for most experiments. After reaction of 3H-peptide with cytochrome c, about one-third of the tritium counts migrated with cytochrome c during gel filtration. After attachment, the amino acid sequence of the hexapeptide was readily determined with a single cleavage Quadrol program in a Beckman 890B sequencer, whereas only the N-terminal residue was recovered without attachment. The repetitive yield after attachment was 95-96%, with 21-27+ overlap and an initial yield of 18-20%. Sequence data with other peptides illustrate applications and present limitations of our approach.     

Enzymatic peptide synthesis in organic media: a comparative study of water-miscible and water-immiscible solvent systems.

Peptide synthesis was carried out in a variety of organic solvents with low contents of water. The enzyme was deposited on the support material, celite, from an aqueous buffer solution. After evaporation of the water the biocatalyst was suspended in the reaction mixtures. The chymotrypsin-catalyzed reaction between Z-Phe-OMe and Leu-NH2 was used as a model reaction. Under the conditions used ([Z-Phe-OMe]0 less than or equal to 40 mM, [Leu-NH2]0/([Z-Phe-OMe]0 = 1.5) the reaction was first order with respect to Z-Phe-OMe. Tris buffer, pH 7.8, was the best buffer to use in the preparation of the biocatalyst. In water-miscible solvents the reaction rate increased with increasing water content, but the final yield of peptide decreased due to the competing hydrolysis of Z-Phe-OMe. Among the water-miscible solvents, acetonitrile was the most suitable, giving 91% yield with 4% (by vol.) water. In water-immiscible solvents the reaction rate and the product distribution were little affected by water additions in the range between 0% and 2% (vol. %) in excess of water saturation. The reaction rates correlated well with the log P values of the solvent. The highest yield (93%) was obtained in ethyl acetate; in this solvent the reaction was also fast. Under most reaction conditions used the reaction product was stable; secondary hydrolysis of the peptide formed was normally negligible. The method presented is a combination of kinetically controlled peptide synthesis (giving high reaction rates) and thermodynamically controlled peptide synthesis (giving stable reaction products).     

Covalent Attachment of Peptides to Cytochrome C for Automated Sequence Determination

Because small peptides are lost into the organic solvents used, it is virtually impossible to obtain the complete amino acid sequence of a small peptide using only an automated peptide sequencer of the spinning cup type. To overcome this problem we have extended peptides at the carboxy terminus by attachment to equine cytochrome c by a water soluble carbodiimide, relying on the acetylated N-terminus of the cytochrome to minimize its direct contribution to recovery of PTH-amino acids. The Model Peptide H-Leu-Trp-Met-Arg-Phe-Ala-OH was used for most experiments. After reac-tion of³H-peptide with cytochrome c, about one-third of the tritium counts migrated with cytochrome c during gel filtration. After attachment, the amino acid sequence of the hexapeptide was readily determined with a single cleavage Quadrol program in a Beckman 890B sequencer, whereas only the N-terminal residue was recovered without attachment. The repetitive yield after attachment was 95–96%, with 21–27% overlap and an initial yield of 18-20%. Sequence data with other peptides illustrate applications and present limitations of our approach.     

ABRF-ESRG’03: Analysis of a PVDF-Bound Known Protein with a Homogeneous Amino-Terminus

The Association of Biomolecular Resource Facilities 2003 Edman Sequencing Research Group (ABRF-ESRG’03) sample is the 15th in a series of studies designed to allow participating members to evaluate their abilities to analyze the N-terminus of a protein or peptide using automated Edman degradation chemistry. It is a follow-up study to the ESRG’02 sample, which was a single protein with a heterogeneous N-terminus. Both the 2002 and 2003 samples were obtained from the same protein complex and were resolved by SDS-PAGE followed by electrophoretic transfer to PVDF membrane. The ABRF-ESRG’03 sample had an apparent molecular weight of 49 kDa and a single N-terminus, with initial yields of approximately 2 pmol. Participants were asked to sequence 25 residues and return their results to the ESRG for analysis along with two completed surveys and an area/pmol table for repetitive and initial yield calculations. Data for 46 responses are presented which include initial yields, repetitive yields, sequencer performance, and ability to identify the protein.     

Photosynthetic Unit Size during the Synchronous Life Cycle of Scenedesmus

Apparent size of the photosynthetic unit (chlorophyll/O₂ per flash) was estimated by O₂ yield of repetitive short flashes on cell samples taken at various times from a synchronized culture (14-hour light, 10-hour dark) of Scenedesmus obliquus. Unit size was essentially invariant (< 10% variation) with a mean value of 1750 chlorophyll/O₂ per flash. In contrast, the light-saturated photosynthetic rate per unit chlorophyll, or turnover rate of the photosynthetic unit, varied with the life cycle, rising 40% in the first three hours of the light period and decaying slowly thereafter. The results are taken as evidence that the metabolic machinery is subject to far greater control and adjustment than is the photochemical machinery.     

The action of indophenols and nitrophenols on the deactivation reactions in the water-splitting system of photosynthesis

The dependence of the relative average oxygen yield per flash for repetitive excitation with single flashes as a function of the dark time, t_d, between the flashes has been investigated.

The decrease of = f(t_d) for long dark times (t_d) depends on the deactivation processes in the water-splitting system by which the number of precursors for photosynthetic oxygen evolution is diminished.

It is shown that the rate of the deactivation reactions can be either accelerated or retarded by indophenols and nitrophenols. These effects can be clearly correlated to the acidity of the hydroxyl group of these substances, but other factors have also to be considered in order to interpret completely the mode of action of these agents in the deactivation process. Possible mechanisms are discussed.     

Fluorescence detection of amino acids in the postcleavage conversions for manual sequencing of a peptide

A modified Edman degradation method where fluorescent derivatives of amino acids were generated from the postcleavage products of a peptide is described. In the method, the target peptide was applied onto double glass fiber membranes in a small filter disk (4 mm i.d.) and then treated with small amounts of reagents for the manual sequencing of the peptide. The anilinothiazolinone (ATZ) of N-terminus amino acid residue after the isolation from the solid-phase membranes was reacted with a primary amine, 4-(1′-cyanoisoindolyl)aniline (CIA), to form a more stable and sensitive fluorescent derivative, phenylthiocarbamoyl-CIA. An average yield of 85% was obtained in neutral pH conditions for the CIA reaction. The ATZ-CIA-amino acids were separated by reversed-phase liquid chromatography and detected by fluorometry. The lower limits of the detection for amino acids after the Edman degradation were 0.16 to 0.52 pmol (signal/noise ratio = 3) on the column. The sensitivity was approximately 10 times higher than ultraviolet absorbance detection of phenylthiohydantoin products in the conventional Edman degradation. The suitability of the method was demonstrated by the sensitive manual sequencing of insulin chain B composed of 30 amino acids.     

Expression and membrane assembly of a transmembrane region from Neu

Transmembrane domains of receptor tyrosine kinases are increasingly seen as key modulatory elements in signaling pathways. The present work addresses problems surrounding expression, isolation, secondary structure recovery, and assembly into membranes, of the relatively large quantities of transmembrane peptides needed to investigate these pathways by NMR spectroscopy. We demonstrate significant correspondence between SDS-PAGE behavior of such peptides and their (2)H NMR spectra in lipid bilayer membranes. A 50-residue peptide, Neu(exp), containing the transmembrane portion of the receptor tyrosine kinase, Neu, was designed for expression in Escherichia coli. The sequence also contained 11-12 amino acids from each side of the transmembrane domain. The common problem of low expressivity of transmembrane peptides was encountered-likely associated with membrane toxicity of the desired gene product. This difficulty was overcome by expressing the peptide as a TrpE fusion protein in a pATH vector to target expression products to inclusion bodies, and subsequently removing the TrpE portion by cyanogen bromide cleavage. Inclusion bodies offered the additional benefits of reduced proteolytic degradation and simplified purification. The presence of a hexa-His tag allowed excellent recovery of the final peptide, while permitting use of denaturing solvents and avoiding the need for HPLC with its attendant adsorption losses. Isolated expressed peptides were found to be pure, but existed as high oligomers rich in beta-structure as evidenced by CD spectroscopy and SDS-PAGE behavior. Dissolution in certain acidic organic solvents led to material with increased alpha-helix content, which behaved in detergent as mixtures of predominantly monomers and dimers-a situation often considered to exist in cell membranes. For purposes of NMR spectroscopy, peptide alanine residues were deuterated in high yield during expression. The same acidic organic solvents used to dissolve and dissociate expressed transmembrane peptides proved invaluable for their assembly into lipid bilayers. Analogous transmembrane peptides from the human receptor tyrosine kinase, ErbB-2, demonstrated related phenomena.     

Simultaneous synthesis of multiple oligonucleotides using nucleoside-H-phosphonate intermediates

A semimechanized simultaneous synthesis of multiple oligonucleotides using nucleoside-H-phosphonates as intermediates was developed and applied to the preparation of hybridization probes. The synthesis could be done with equivalent results (about 98% average yield per cycle) using regenerated H-phosphonates.     

The nitrogen fertilization of spring barley

Summary From 1971 to 1979 field trials with increasing rates of fertilizer nitrogen on spring barley with sugar beet as the preceding crop were conducted on a farm on sandy loam in the south western part of The Netherlands. Prior to sowing and fertilizing soil samples were taken and analysed for mineral nitrogen (N_min). The average yield increase through application of fertilizer nitrogen was only 750 kg of grain per ha per year, the maximum yield being about 5 tonnes per ha. In the case of a fixed rate of fertilizer nitrogen per annum it can be derived from the response curves that 60 kg of N would have given the smallest average yield deficit (170 kg grain per ha) in comparison with maximum yields. With an N-advisory system based on soil analysis the average yield deficit would be at a minimum (163 kg of grain per ha) with a value for mineral soil nitrogen+fertilizer nitrogen totalling 120 kg N per ha.No relationship was found between optimum rate of fertilizer nitrogen and the amount of mineral soil nitrogen at the end of the winter. This was ascribed to the relatively small variation in mineral soil nitrogen and the weak response of the crop to fertilizer nitrogen.Promising results from nitrogen fertilizing systems based on soil analysis can be expected from more responsive crops like winter wheat, sugar beets and potatoes.With the average yield deficit compared with maximum yield as a characteristic, the usefulness of any N-advisory system can be compared, taking a fixed rate of nitrogen system as a standard.Seconded by the Agricultural Bureau of the Netherlands Fertilizer Industry (LBNM).     

Internal chain cleavage and product heterogeneity during Edman degradation of isosteric peptide analogs lacking the alpha-carbonyl function

A synthetic peptide analog, with one peptide carbonyl group replaced by a methylene bridge, was submitted to structural analysis by Edman degradation. Multiple cleavages were obtained in the first cycle, due to phenylthiocarbamylation of the internal secondary amine as well as spontaneous alkaline cyclization and subsequent recoupling with the Edman reagent. Three fragments from cleavage of the peptide analog after a single Edman cycle were purified by reverse-phase high-performance liquid chromatography. The results support previous observations in a novel combination. The reactions may also be important with native polypeptides since non-quantitative alkaline cyclization now encountered can mimic apparent N-terminal heterogeneity in agreement with earlier data, while quantitative cyclization can mimic loss of N-terminal residues.     

Constrained Unfolding of a Helical Peptide: Implicit versus Explicit Solvents

Steered Molecular Dynamics (SMD) has been seen to provide the potential of mean force (PMF) along a peptide unfolding pathway effectively but at significant computational cost, particularly in all-atom solvents. Adaptive steered molecular dynamics (ASMD) has been seen to provide a significant computational advantage by limiting the spread of the trajectories in a staged approach. The contraction of the trajectories at the end of each stage can be performed by taking a structure whose nonequilibrium work is closest to the Jarzynski average (in naive ASMD) or by relaxing the trajectories under a no-work condition (in full-relaxation ASMD—namely, FR-ASMD). Both approaches have been used to determine the energetics and hydrogen-bonding structure along the pathway for unfolding of a benchmark peptide initially constrained as an α-helix in a water environment. The energetics are quite different to those in vacuum, but are found to be similar between implicit and explicit solvents. Surprisingly, the hydrogen-bonding pathways are also similar in the implicit and explicit solvents despite the fact that the solvent contact plays an important role in opening the helix.     

Sequence organization of the rat genome by electron microscopy.

The size and arrangement of repetitive and inverted repeat (foldback) sequences in rat DNA were studied by visualization of hybrid and heteroduplex structures in the electron microscope. The self-reassociation of repetitive sequence-bearing DNA strands often results in the formation of four-ended "H" structures, whose duplex regions equal the repetitive sequence length and can be measured in the electron microscope. In this way, it was determined that the average size of the class of numerous short repetitive sequences is 0.40 +/- 0.15 kbp. Heteroduplex structures were prepared between long whole DNA single strands and short repeat-sequence-bearing strands. The analysis of these structures confirms that the size of the repetitive sequences in 0.4 kbp on average. Length measurements between adjacent duplexes show that the average spacing between two interspersed repeats is at least 1.5-1.8 kbp. By examining 29.4-kbp single strands after brief renaturation, the size and distribution of foldback sequences were determined. There are 1.9 X 10(5) foldback apirs per rat genome, spaced an average of 9.7 kbp apart according to our measurement. Repetitive, inverted repeat and unique sequences are interspersed with each other in at least half the genome.     

Accelerated high-sensitivity microsequencing of proteins and peptides using a miniature reaction cartridge.

Greatly reduced automated protein sequencing degradation times of less than 25 min with concurrent on-line phenylthiohydantoin (PTH) derivative analysis times of less than 16 min have been achieved by using a miniaturized reaction cartridge with optimized chemical and analytical cycles. Using this method a wide range of standard and novel peptides and proteins have been sequenced with reproducibly high initial and repetitive cycle yields. In these accelerated analyses the recovery of the more labile PTH derivatives was markedly improved by using elevated pressure during cleavage steps and temperature programming throughout the Edman cycle.