Karyometric marker features in fine needle aspirates of follicular adenoma of the thyroid

Karyometric measurements were performed on fine needle aspirates of clearly identifiable adenomatous areas and adjacent normal-appearing areas in the surgical specimens from ten patients with follicular adenomas of the thyroid. Similar measurements were made on aspirates from nine patients free of thyroid disease. A total of 95 karyometric features were evaluated for each nucleus. Analysis of variance of optical density values did not show a significant difference between the three types of nuclei. Discriminant analysis selected seven karyometric features that produced a statistically highly significant separation of adenoma nuclei from control nuclei. A similar analysis selected six features that produced a statistically highly significant discrimination of normal-appearing nuclei from control nuclei. The validity of these markers for distinguishing control nuclei from adenoma nuclei and normal-appearing nuclei adjacent to adenomas was demonstrated by analysis in further training and test sets. These findings parallel those previously demonstrated for invasive and microinvasive follicular carcinomas of the thyroid.     

Karyometric marker features in fine needle aspirates of invasive follicular carcinoma of the thyroid.

Karyometric measurements were performed on fine needle aspirates of clearly identifiable tumor areas and adjacent normal-appearing areas in the surgical specimens from ten patients with invasive follicular carcinoma of the thyroid. Similar measurements were performed on aspirates from nine patients free of thyroid disease (controls). A total of 95 karyometric features were evaluated for each nucleus. Analysis of variance of optical density values indicated (1) a similarity between tumor and normal-appearing nuclei from carcinoma cases, (2) a significant difference between those nuclei and control nuclei and (3) that most of the differences were due to the differences of tissue origin. Stepwise linear discriminant analysis selected ten features that produced a statistically highly significant separation of tumor nuclei from control nuclei. A similar analysis selected six features that produced a statistically highly significant discrimination of normal-appearing nuclei from control nuclei; the validity of those karyometric features as markers of malignancy in normal-appearing nuclei from tissues adjacent to invasive follicular carcinomas of the thyroid was demonstrated by analysis in further training and control sets of nuclei. This analysis in thyroid aspirates identified more marker features than did a previous similar analysis using tissue sections.     

Markers for malignancy in the nuclear texture of histologically normal tissue from patients with thyroid tumors

The chromatin of nuclei from histologically normal-appearing glands in tissue sections from patients with follicular adenoma, papillary carcinoma and follicular carcinoma of the thyroid exhibited changes that were statistically significant when compared to the nuclear chromatin in tissue sections of thyroid from normal individuals. Certain chromatin texture features assumed values approximating those found in tumor cell nuclei. Staining was affected only slightly, and morphometric features, such as nuclear area, roundness and ellipticity, were statistically not different from those in normal controls. In patients with Hürthle-cell tumors, such marker features could not be found. Results from measurements on 30 patients (approximately 1,000 nuclei) are reported.     

Chromatin texture analysis of cortical adrenal gland adenomas, including incidentalomas, and adjacent normal-appearing cortical tissue

OBJECTIVE: To describe, by morphometric and chromatin texture analysis, a series of adrenal gland lesions, including Cushing's and Conn's adenomas and incidentalomas. STUDY DESIGN: The material for the study consisted of five consecutive cases of incidentaloma, three cases of Conn's adenoma and three cases of Cushing's adenoma. Also included were five cases of adrenal carcinoma. Sections were stained according to the Feulgen procedure. Measurements were taken from the nodules and from two different zones, identified as outer and inner parts, of the normal-appearing adrenal cortex adjacent to the tumor. Data on approximately 50 nuclei were recorded for each of these three sites (tumor and outer and inner normal-appearing adrenal cortex). The nuclei were subjected to feature extraction and were analyzed by identification procedures--i.e., establishing nuclear and lesion signatures. RESULTS: The total optical density (OD) distributions of the nuclei from the normal-appearing adrenal cortex pointed to their diploid or near-diploid nature. In incidentalomas there was a very small increase in the number of nuclei, with increased total OD. In Conn's adenoma there was a noticeable but modest extension of the total OD distribution into the higher OD range. This trend continued for Cushing's adenoma. The pixel OD histograms for nuclei from normal-appearing tissue and from incidentalomas were hardly distinguishable. Starting with nuclei from Conn's adenoma, a shift toward lower pixel OD values began. The trend continued for nuclei from Cushing's adenoma and was very pronounced for nuclei from carcinoma. The nuclear signatures showed no appreciable difference between nuclei from normal-appearing cortex and from incidentaloma. Nuclei from Conn's adenoma were more similar to those from normal tissue in their signatures than nuclei from Cushing's adenoma. In fact, the nuclear signatures from Cushing's adenoma were almost identical to those of carcinoma. The lesion signatures for normal tissue, incidentaloma and Conn's adenoma confirmed the results seen in the nuclear signatures. There was a very modest increase in the number of nuclei with greater deviation from normal in incidentalomas, and the trend was more obvious in Conn's adenoma. However, in Cushing's adenoma there was a very substantial increase in the number of nuclei, with large deviations of their nuclear chromatin texture from normal. CONCLUSION: Computer-assisted analysis of nuclear characteristics proved useful in identifying and describing differences between groups of tumors arising in the adrenal cortex and highlighted the similarity between incidentalomas and adjacent normal-appearing cortex and between Cushing's adenoma and adrenal carcinoma.     

Planimetric studies on fine needle aspirates from follicular adenoma and follicular carcinoma of the thyroid

A planimetric study was performed on fine needle aspiration biopsy smears from 21 follicular thyroid adenomas, 13 follicular thyroid carcinomas and 7 nontoxic goiters. The nuclear and the cytoplasmic projected areas were measured in each smear on 50 cells with intact nuclei. The nuclear-cytoplasmic area was calculated. Significant differences in mean nuclear area were found between benign and malignant follicular neoplasms and between neoplastic cells and cells from nontoxic goiter. Planimetry of cells aspirated from follicular neoplasms permitted differentiation between carcinomas and adenomas with a high degree of statistical probability.     

Fine needle aspiration diagnosis of hyperplastic and neoplastic follicular nodules of the thyroid. A morphometric study.

The differentiation of hyperplastic nodules, follicular adenomas and follicular carcinomas from fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology smears may be difficult. To better define the diagnostic criteria, we studied the morphometric parameters of nuclear area (NA), nuclear:cytoplasmic ratio and nuclear roundness (NR) in single cells and cell aggregates. In addition, we quantitated the percentage of touching or overlapping nuclei (NO) and the percentage of extent of nuclear area of overlap (NAO) in cellular aggregates. We measured cellular samples from FNA aspirates obtained from 20 hyperplastic nodules, 21 follicular adenomas, 5 encapsulated follicular carcinomas and 22 invasive follicular carcinomas, all of which were subsequently confirmed by histologic examination. Cellular aggregates provided the maximum diagnostic information. Stepwise discriminant analysis revealed that nuclear size, nuclear roundness and the percentage NAO allow optimum differentiation of hyperplasia, adenomas and carcinomas. Clearly, all of the poorly differentiated carcinomas (large NA, low NR, high NO and NAO) could be reliably diagnosed. Discriminant analysis allowed the differentiation of carcinoma from adenoma in 20/22 carcinomas (91%) and all 21 adenomas (although 2 adenomas were called hyperplasias and 3 hyperplasias were called adenomas).     

Distinguishing cortical adrenal gland adenomas from carcinomas by their quantitative nuclear features

OBJECTIVE: To explore data from a set of cases of adrenal cortical adenomas with different endocrine syndromes and carcinomas to determine whether quantitative image analysis of nuclear features might be used to separate the groups. STUDY DESIGN: Fifteen adrenal cortical tumors in which clinical information and optimally preserved, paraffin-embedded tissue were available were used. There were 10 adenomas and 5 carcinomas. Among the adenomas, five were associated with primary hyperaldosteronism (Conn's syndrome) and five with Cushing's syndrome. Five-micrometer-thick sections were stained with hematoxylin and eosin. In each case 50 nuclei were measured, and a number of morphometric and densitometric features were extracted. The data were subjected to multivariate analysis. RESULTS: Quantitative analysis showed that nuclei from adrenal carcinomas are larger than those from adenomas. Total optical density (OD) had a near-diploid distribution in the adenomas, while it was clearly aneuploid in the carcinomas. The pixel OD histograms were almost identical for all groups. Differences in nuclear chromatin texture were found between adenomas and carcinomas and also between the two adenoma categories. Multivariate analysis showed good discrimination between carcinomas and adenomas (Wilks lambda = .628, P < .0001) and between adenomas. However, based on Bayesian decision boundaries, 20-25% of carcinoma nuclei could be expected to be in the range of adenoma, and about 12% of Cushing's adenoma nuclei and 15% of Conn's adenoma nuclei would be classified as carcinoma. CONCLUSION: Computer-assisted analysis of nuclear characteristics proved useful in identifying and describing differences between groups of tumors arising in the adrenal cortex.     

Morphometric image analysis of follicular lesions of the thyroid

OBJECTIVE: To determine the role of image morphometry in distinguishing various follicular lesions of the thyroid in cytologic smears. STUDY DESIGN: Archival fine needle aspiration smears of 10 cases each of follicular hyperplasia, follicular adenoma, follicular carcinoma and follicular variant of papillary carcinoma were used for the study. All cases were histopathologically proven. At least 100 random nuclei from each case were subjected to analysis with an image cytometer. Area, convex area, length, width, perimeter, convex perimeter and roundness of nuclei were measured using a 40 x objective (1 pixel = 0.446 micron). RESULTS: ANOVA showed that all the nuclear variables studied were significantly different (P < .05) in follicular hyperplasia as compared to follicular carcinoma and papillary carcinoma. All nuclear variables except roundness were also significantly different (P < .05) between follicular hyperplasia and follicular adenoma. However, between follicular adenoma, follicular carcinoma and papillary carcinoma there was considerable overlap of nuclear morphometric parameters. CONCLUSION: Image morphometry may help to distinguish nonneoplastic follicular lesions (hyperplasia) from neoplastic lesions (adenomas and carcinomas). However, to distinguish benign from malignant follicular lesions, image morphometry might not improve the accuracy of standard cytologic examination.     

Computerized morphometric study on fine needle aspirates of cellular follicular lesions of the thyroid

OBJECTIVE: To investigate the value of computerized nuclear morphometry in the differential diagnosis of cellular follicular lesions of the thyroid cytologically diagnosed on fine needle aspiration (FNA) smears. STUDY DESIGN: Sixty cases of FNA thyroid smears were cytologically diagnosed and classified as follows: 30 cases of follicular carcinoma, 20 cases of cellular hyperplastic nodules and 10 cases of follicular adenoma. Using an image analysis system, two morphometric variables, nuclear area and major axis length of the nucleus, were measured for each case. RESULTS: For both nuclear morphometric variables, statistical differences were found between carcinomas and hyperplastic nodules as well as between carcinomas and adenomas. No statistical differences were found between the nuclear variables in either hyperplastic nodules or adenomas. CONCLUSION: The results confirm the aim of our study, to establish nuclear morphometry by computerized image analysis as an additional tool in the differential diagnosis of thyroid follicular lesions cytologically diagnosed on FNA smears.     

Computer analysis of chromatin arrangement and nuclear texture in follicular thyroid tumours

The differentiation of the thyroid glands follicular neoplasias into adenomas and carcinomas is currently done using the histological criteria recommended by WHO. This pilot study of 10 human follicular carcinomas and 10 folliculars adenomas demonstrates the possibility of a cytological classification using digital picture processing of high resolution cell images. Giemsa stained paraplast sections were scanned with a Colour-TV-camera, different channels were used with respect to staining and analyzing methods and computed with an image processing system. The computer aided cytophotometric methods detected significant differences in the chromatin arrangement and structure.     

Diagnostic value of qualitative and quantitative variables in thyroid lesions

Two hundred and thirty-three thyroid lesions were studied by fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology using standard cytologic criteria available in the literature. These included 114 cases of nodular colloid goitre (NCG), 47 cases of Hashimoto's thyroiditis (HT), 12 follicular adenomas (FAd), five cases of subacute thyroiditis and three cases of thyrotoxicosis among the benign lesions. The malignant lesions seen were 30 cases of papillary carcinoma (PCa), 16 follicular carcinomas (FCa), three cases with double lesions, e.g. papillary carcinoma with coexisting NCG, and three of papillary carcinoma with HT. Emphasis was given to eight qualitative and quantitative (morphometric) variables in these various thyroid lesions. Cell measurements were done using a Visopan Lux projection microscope. The three qualitative variables included type of nuclear membrane (regular/irregular), type of nuclear chromatin and the presence or absence of conspicuous nucleoli. The quantitative variables studied were nuclear diameter, nuclear area, cytoplasmic diameter, cytoplasmic area & N/C ratio. Statistical analysis was performed in order to know whether the standard cytologic criteria used at FNA cytology in the literature (increased cellularity, microfollicles, increased N/C ratio, absence of significant haemosiderin-laden macrophages and scanty colloid) could differentiate a follicular adenoma from a follicular carcinoma. A statistical analysis was also performed to establish the utility of the qualitative and quantitative variables. The results showed that none of the standard cytologic criteria applied could differentiate follicular adenoma from a follicular carcinoma. With regard to qualitative variables, irregularity of nuclear membrane and presence of conspicuous nucleoli were most significant in papillary carcinoma, followed by follicular carcinoma, then by follicular adenoma; these features being hardly evident in nodular colloid goitre and Hashimoto's thyroiditis. A coarse nuclear chromatin was most significant in follicular carcinomas followed by follicular adenomas. It was less obvious in the benign conditions, but more prominent in Hashimoto's thyroiditis compared with a goitre. It was also not obvious in a papillary carcinoma. Of the quantitative variables, all measurements were greatest in PCa > FCa > FAd > NCG = HT. When differentiating follicular adenoma from follicular carcinoma the qualitative variables of significance were the presence or absence of nucleoli, the chromatin pattern and regularity/irregularity of nuclear membrane; the nuclear area was the most important feature among quantitative variables.     

Application of artificial neural network for classification of thyroid follicular tumors

OBJECTIVE: To analyze smears of 197 thyroid follicular tumors (adenoma and carcinoma). STUDY DESIGN: Several types of artificial neural networks (ANN) of various designs were used for diagnosis of thyroid follicular tumors. The typical complex of cytologic features, some nuclear morphometric parameters (area, perimeter, shape factor) and density features of chromatin texture (mean value and SD of gray levels) were defined for each tumor. RESULTS: The ANN was trained by means of cytologic features characteristic for a thyroid follicular adenoma and a follicular carcinoma. At subsequent testing, the correct cytologic diagnosis was established in 93% (25 of 27) of cases. The morphometry increased the accuracy of diagnosis for follicular tumors in up to 97% (75 of 78) of cases. ANN correctly distinguished an adenoma or a carcinoma in 87% (73 of 84) of cases when using color microscopic images of tumors. CONCLUSION: The usage of ANN has raised sensitivity of cytologic diagnosis of follicular tumors to 90%, compared with a usual cytologic method (sensitivity of 56%). The automatic classification of thyroid follicular tumors by means of ANN is prospective.     

The number of nucleoli in benign and malignant thyroid lesions: a useful diagnostic sign in cytological preparations

The slides of fine needle aspiration cytology specimens from 99 cases of cold thyroid nodules with known histology were reviewed and the number of nucleoli per nucleus counted and correlated with the different histopathological groups. Significant differences were observed between benign and malignant thyroid lesions in the number of nucleoli in the cytological material. Lower values were present in nodular goitres and follicular adenomas compared to carcinomas. In benign lesions the majority of nuclei contained one nucleolus and nuclei with two, three or more nucleoli were less frequent than in follicular, papillary, medullary and anaplastic carcinomas. Only one case of follicular adenoma had cells containing three or more nucleoli compared to more than half the cases of follicular carcinoma.     

Necrotic Debris In Thyroid Aspirates: A Feature of Follicular Carcinoma of the Thyroid

Fine needle aspirates from 44 follicular thyroid tumours (30 adenomas, 14 carcinomas) have been studied. All aspirates contained neoplastic cells in follicular and trabecular arrangements. The individual tumour cells showed varying degrees of anisonucleosis and nuclear pleomorphism. Colloid was scanty or absent from all smears. Granular or filamentous necrotic material was observed in both biopsies and smears from one moderately and two poorly differentiated follicular carcinomas, but in none of the adenomas. This suggests that necrotic debris may be a feature of follicular carcinoma of the thyroid.     

Karyometric features in nuclei near colonic adenocarcinoma. Statistical analysis.

The normal mucosa adjacent to colonic adenocarcinoma (marginal or transitional mucosa) has been shown to have subtle alterations of architecture, surface glycoproteins and proliferative activity. To evaluate possible changes in nuclear configurations in this marginal mucosa, a large set of cytometric features was evaluated using a computer-assisted video analysis system. Preliminary statistical analysis of the measurements identified six nuclear features useful for discriminating marginal mucosa nuclei from normal (control) mucosa nuclei: total optical density (OD), nuclear area, chromatin texture (from gray value cooccurrence matrix), chromatin coarseness, average OD of nuclear staining and peripheral tendency of the chromatin in the nucleus. An analysis of variance revealed that both patient-to-patient and gland-to-gland variation would limit the usefulness of any one feature as a screening tool. As a group, however, these six features should be investigated further as markers of preneoplastic changes in histologically normal-appearing mucosa.     

Detection of underlying characteristics of nuclear chromatin patterns of thyroid tumor cells using texture and factor analyses

BACKGROUND: Aspiration biopsy cytology of thyroid tumors has been used more frequently in recent times to differentiate between malignant and benign lesions. Chromatin patterns of the tumor cell nuclei are one of most important factors for cytologic diagnosis. The interpretation of nuclear chromatin patterns is subjective and more difficult than that of nuclear size or shape. In the present report, we investigated how to detect underlying chromatin characteristics of benign and malignant thyroid tumor cells by means of texture and factor analyses. METHODS: We employed a computer-aided system in which light microscopy was combined with an image processor and monochrome camera. Using this system, 100 randomly selected cells in a Papanicolaou stained, aspiration biopsy cytologic smear in each case of 39 benign and malignant thyroid tumor cases were digitized. We applied two-dimensional and higher texture analyses with the use of co-occurrence and run-length matrices to analyze the chromatin patterns. Factor analysis was used to determine whether a large number of independent variables actually measured one or more underlying common variables. RESULTS: According to parameters with high factor-loading values, the morphologic chromatin characters were classified into three categories according to heterogeneity, contrast, and homogeneity of chromatin patterns. On the basis of analyses with these morphologic categories, nuclei of papillary carcinoma showed higher contrast of chromatin patterns than did those of the benign group. Moreover, there was a variety of contrasting chromatin patterns among cells in each papillary carcinoma case in comparison with the benign group. In contrast, follicular carcinomas showed a significant difference in the standard deviation of factor 3, which indicated more monotonous chromatin patterns among cells in each follicular carcinoma case than in each benign case. CONCLUSION: We believe that this technique, using texture and factor analyses, is useful in the detection of underlying characteristics of nuclear chromatin patterns in aspiration biopsy cytology.     

Renal cell carcinoma metastatic to follicular adenoma of the thyroid gland. A case report

BACKGROUND: Renal cell carcinoma is an unpredictable tumor that can recur many years after the original diagnosis and metastasize to uncommon sites, including the thyroid gland. Differential diagnosis from primary thyroid tumor is often difficult both clinically and pathologically. We report a case of metastatic renal cell carcinoma in follicular adenoma of the thyroid gland. CASE: A 48-year-old woman presented with a 3-cm-diameter, palpable mass in the left lobe of the thyroid gland. The patient's history included removal of a left renal mass, which was conventional renal cell carcinoma. Fine needle aspiration cytology smears contained a few small clusters of polygonal cells with abundant, clear cytoplasm and irregular, hyperchromatic nuclei as well as bland-looking thyroid follicle cells and stromal cells. A papillary or follicular growth pattern was not detected. A cell block made from the aspirated sample was composed mainly of clear cells. By immunohistochemical stains, the clear cells were completely negative for TTF-1, thyroglobulin, calcitonin and inhibin while equivocally staining for cytokeratin, CD10 and galectin-3. The histologic diagnosis was renal cell carcinoma metastatic to follicular adenoma of the thyroid gland. CONCLUSION: Renal cell carcinoma metastatic to the thyroid may masquerade as a primary thyroid neoplasm. A history of prior nephrectomy, the presence of unremarkable thyroid follicle cells, the absence of a papillary or follicular growth pattern and immunohistochemical study can help differentiating metastatic renal cell carcinoma from a primary thyroid lesion with clear cell change.     

The significance of paravacuolar granules of the thyroid. A histologic, cytologic and ultrastructural study

The presence of the so-called "paravacuolar granules" in thyroid follicular cells has been associated with increased metabolic activity of the gland, regressive changes, degeneration, phagocytic activity and benign papillary hyperplasia. During the course of a review of the intraoperative cytologic preparations and corresponding histologic sections from 73 thyroid cases, the presence of granules within follicular cells was noted in 25 cases (18 adenomatous or colloid goiters, 3 follicular adenomas, 2 papillary carcinomas, 1 follicular carcinoma and in thyroid tissue surrounding a follicular adenoma in 1 case). Histochemical and ultrastructural studies showed the granules to consist of lysosomes containing hemosiderin or lipofuscin pigments. These findings indicate that the presence of paravacuolar granules in thyroid cells is a common nonspecific finding that simply reflects: (1) the erythrophagocytic capability of the follicular epithelial cells, which results in the accumulation of iron within lysosomes, and (2) the accumulation of lipofuscin pigments within lysosomes as a result of degradation of endogenous cellular material.     

Ultrastructural pathology of the thyroid folliculo-papillary and follicular carcinoma

Twenty cases of thyroid carcinoma (10 follicular and 10 folliculo-papillary) were ultrastructurally studied. In the follicular carcinoma the most striking features were: microfollicular cavities with microvilli from the apical surface of the tumorous cells, intracellular microlumens, swollen mitochondria sometimes containing electrondense bodies and tightly packed filaments. In the solid sheaths light and dark cells were present. Golgi complexes were disposed in small dense cristae. The nuclei were large, round, oval or with a folded appearance. In the folliculo-papillary carcinoma were found nuclei with an irregular shape containing stage I and stage II inclusions, dilated endoplasmic sacks, closely packed, sometimes dystrophic mitochondria, dense bodies or tightly packed parallel filaments and numerous phagolysosomes. The peroxidase activity wa present as black precipitates in the nuclear envelope or around colloid droplets. The acid phosphatase activity was found as unhomogeneous precipitates inside the lysosomes. From this study it could be concluded that the follicular and folliculo-papillary carcinomas have some common ultrastructural features; the ultrastructural and cytoenzymological patterns suggest marked alteration of the synthesis, storage and secretion of thyroid hormones.