To clone or not to clone plant QTLs: present and future challenges

Recent technical advancements and refinement of analytical methods have enabled the loci (quantitative trait loci, QTLs) responsible for the genetic control of quantitative traits to be dissected molecularly. To date, most plant QTLs have been cloned using a positional cloning approach following identification in experimental crosses. In some cases, an association between sequence variation at a candidate gene and a phenotype has been established by analysing existing genetic accessions. These strategies can be refined using appropriate genetic materials and the latest developments in genomics platforms. We foresee that although QTL analysis and cloning addressing naturally occurring genetic variation should shed light on mechanisms of plant adaptation, a greater emphasis on approaches relying on mutagenesis and candidate gene validation is likely to accelerate the pace of discovering the genes underlying QTLs.     

A new licence to clone

Many countries are still grappling with the issue of therapeutic cloning of human cells as the UN tackles this issue alongside reproductive cloning, but in the UK a new programme looking at the causes of motor neuron disease has recently been sanctioned. Michael Gross reports.     

Efficacy of clone fingerprinting methodologies

With the development of new high-information content fingerprinting techniques for constructing BAC-based physical maps, physical map construction is accelerating and it is important to determine which methodologies work best. In a recent publication (Z. Xu et al., 2004, Genomics 84:941-951), Xu et al. evaluated five different techniques (one agarose-based and four using multiple enzymes) and concluded that a two-enzyme technique was superior. In addition, they found that no benefit was gained from fingerprinting more than 10x coverage. In this paper we report our own extensive simulation results, which lead to contrasting conclusions. Our data indicate that the five-enzyme method known as SNaPshot is the most effective and that the assembly can in fact be significantly improved with greater than 10x coverage.     

Dolly,the so-called clone

The word 'clone' is in the forefront of scientific terms that are familiar to the general public. But what exactly does it mean? Suprisingly, there is no simple answer, for different scientists are using the term for different entities.     

Alloreactivity of an OVA-specific T-cell clone

A T-cell clone (Lyl-03) derived from BALB/cBy mice, though highly specific for OVA/A^d, reacted to allogeneic spleen cells of 6 of 12 H-2 haplotypes tested. The reactivity to each particular H-2 haplotype required the expression of a non-major histocompatibility complex (MHC) gene product present on the B cells of certain strains of mice. All the alloreactive responses were MHC restricted and were inhibited by class II-specific and L3T4-specific monoclonal antibodies. The non-MHC gene product, X, is a new lymphocyte-stimulating determinant that is not expressed in mice with the xid defect. We favor a model that proposes two independent sites (or receptors) for X and the class II molecule. Contrary to previous models for alloreactivity, the anti-MHC site is not directed to a polymorphic receptor for self-class II epitope on the foreign class II molecule, but rather to a conserved determinant present on both self- and allo-class II molecules. If there is only one antigen receptor on the T-cell clone Lyl-03, then anti-X receptor must bind to a cross-reactive determinant found on immunogenic OVA and the non-MHC coded gene product expressed on the cell surface membrane. We further postulate that class II plus X recognition may be a general rule for alloreactive as well as autoreactive responses. Thus, both allo-class II and allo-class I reactive T cells are similar in that both bind a non-MHC coded gene product prior to activation.Abbreviations used in this paper: APC antigen-presenting cell(s) - Con A concanavalin A - Cl. clone - DME Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium - FCS fetal calf serum - H-2 histocompatibility-2 - MHC major histocompatibility complex - MLR mixed lymphocyte response - Mls mixed lymphocyte stimulating - OVA chicken ovalbumin - X unknown cell-surface antigen - xid immunodeficiency mapped to the X chromosome     

A cDNA clone encoding Brassica calmodulin

A 834 bp cDNA encoding calmodulin (CaM) has been isolated from Brassica juncea. On Northern analysis this cDNA hybridises this cDNA to mRNAs of about 0.9 kb in leaf, silique and peduncle. Genomic Southern analysis indicates the presence of a CaM multigene family in Brassica juncea. Comparison of the predicted amino acid sequence of Brassica CaM with that of Arabidopsis CaM ACaM-2 and ACaM-3 showed 100% homology, which is not unusual, since both plants belong to the family Cruciferae. In situ hybridisation studies on Brassica seedlings using a digoxigenin-labelled RNA probe showed that high levels of CaM mRNA were detected in the leaf primordia and the shoot apical meristem, and to a lesser degree, in the zone of root elongation of the root tip. The occurrence of a higher rate of cell division and growth in these regions than its surrounding tissue may possibly be related to higher levels of CaM mRNA.     

Current methods for YAC clone characterization

Yeast artificial chromosome (YAC) cloning has allowed isolation of much longer DNA fragments than was previously possible. While this technology makes feasible the isolation of large regions of complex genomes in overlapping cloned segments, it has also required altered methods for manipulation of cloned DNAs. In particular, the isolation of insert sequences from YAC clones has been especially difficult. Methods for characterization of YAC inserts are described and compared.     

The biological improbability of a clone

Empirical evidence for intraclonal genetic variation is described here for clonal systems using a variety of molecular techniques and implicating a diversity of mechanisms. However, clonal systems are still generally perceived as having strict genetic fidelity. As concepts of genetic variability move from primary sequence data to include epigenetic and structural influences on genetic expression, the ability to detect changes in the genome at short intervals allows precedence to be given to inherent biological variation that is often analytically ignored. Therefore, the advent of powerful molecular techniques, like genome mapping, mean that our concepts of genetic fidelity within eukaryotic clones and the whole philosophy of the 'clone' needs to be re-evaluated and redefined to replace old unproven dogma in this aspect of science.     

A clone of Scenedesmus with Chodatella-stages

A clonal culture of an organism isolated as Chodatella quadriseta Lemm. developed coenobial stages resembling Scenedesmus quadricauda (Turp.) Bréb. The sequence of these changes was followed, the population being found to consist almost entirely of unicells when young, but with a regular increase in coenobia with increasing age. Definition of the coenobia was attempted by numerical analysis of shape and size. Another clone, from a different habitat, was found to behave similarly. Some of the taxonomic implications of this form of pleomorphism are discussed.     

BAC trimming: minimizing clone overlaps

Bacterial vectors containing large inserts of genomic DNA are now the standard substrates for large-scale genomic sequencing. Long overlaps between some clones lead to considerable redundant effort. A method for deleting defined regions from bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) inserts, using homologous recombination, was applied to minimize the overlap between successive BAC clones. This procedure, called trimming, was carried out in the recA(-) BAC host. We have precisely deleted up to 70 kb of DNA from BACs that were to be sequenced. This method requires minimal prior characterization of the clones: collections of BAC end sequences or STS-based maps will accelerate the process. BAC trimming will be useful in both small and large genome sequencing projects and will be of particular utility for gap closure in finishing phases.     

Diploid clone produces unreduced diploid gametes but tetraploid clone generates reduced diploid gametes in the Misgurnus loach

Most individuals of the loach Misgurnus anguillicaudatus reproduce bisexually, but cryptic clonal lineages reproduce by natural gynogenesis of unreduced diploid eggs that are genetically identical to maternal somatic cells. Triploid progeny often occur by the accidental incorporation of a sperm nucleus into diploid eggs. Sex reversal from a genetic female to a physiological male is easily induced in this species by androgen treatment and through environmental influences. Here, we produced clonal tetraploid individuals by two methods: 1) fertilization of diploid eggs from a clonal diploid female with diploid sperm of a hormonally sex-reversed clonal diploid male and 2) artificial inhibition of the release of the second polar body in eggs of clonal diploid females just after initiation of gynogenetic development. There is no genetic difference between the clonal diploid and tetraploid individuals except for the number of chromosome sets or genomes. Clonal tetraploid males never produced unreduced tetraploid sperm, only diploid sperm that were genetically identical to those of a clonal diploid. Likewise, clonal tetraploid females did not form unreduced tetraploid eggs, just diploid eggs. However, the eggs' genotypes were identical to those of the original clone, and almost all the eggs initiated natural gynogenesis. Thus, gametogenesis of the clonal tetraploid loach is controlled by the presence of two chromosome sets to pair, thereby preserving the normal meiotic process, i.e., the formation of bivalents and subsequently two successive divisions.     

The plant activation of m-phenylenediamine by Tradescantia clone 03 and clone 4430 cells in liquid suspension culture

In this study, we expanded the use of the genus Tradescantia to investigate the plant activation of promutagens and further refine the methodology of the plant cell/microbe coincubation assay. Liquid suspension cell cultures of Tradescantia clone 03 and Tradescantia clone 4430 were used to activate the promutagen m-phenylenediamine into a mutagenic compound which was detected by Salmonella typhimurium strain TA98 in the plant cell/microbe coincubation assay. Optimum treatment parameters were established for both plant cell lines. Optimum was defined as the lowest concentration or shortest time period that provided consistently positive results and high rates of revertants. Preliminary experiments with both cell lines defined 2.5 mumoles m-phenylenediamine per plate as the optimum concentration to be used in the determination of the optimal coincubation period and the optimal concentration of plant cells. These experiments also determined the optimal physiological stage at which both clones should be used in the coincubation assay. Differences were found in the optimal of coincubation (1h for clone 03, 2 h for clone 4430) and growth stage (mid-log for clone 03, mid- to late-log for clone 4430). Similar activation responses were seen for both clones when the concentration of plant cells (mg/ml) was varied. Under optimized conditions, clone 03 cells demonstrated an approximately 10% higher activation response than clone 4430.