Programmed cell death in the ascidian embryo: modulation by FoxA5 and Manx and roles in the evolution of larval development

Programmed cell death (PCD) has been discounted in the ascidian embryo because the descendants of every embryonic cell appear to be present in the tadpole larva. Here we show that apoptotic PCD is initiated in the epidermis and central nervous system (CNS) but not in the endoderm, mesenchyme, muscle, and notochord cells during embryogenesis in molgulid ascidians. However, the affected cells do not actually die until the beginning of metamorphosis. Although specific patterns of PCD were different in distantly related ascidian species, the results suggest that removal of CNS cells by apoptosis is a urchordate feature predating the origin of the vertebrates. Certain molgulid ascidian species have evolved an anural (tailless) larva in which notochord cells fail to undergo the morphogenetic movements culminating in tail development. These anural species include Molgula occulta, the sister species of the urodele (tailed) species Molgula oculata. We show that PCD in the notochord cell lineage precedes the arrest of tail development in M. occulta and other independently evolved anural species. The notochord cells are rescued from PCD and a tail develops in hybrid embryos produced by fertilizing M. occulta eggs with M. oculata sperm, implying that apoptosis is controlled zygotically. Antisense inhibition experiments show that zygotic expression of the FoxA5 and Manx genes is required to prevent notochord PCD in urodele species and hybrids with restored tails. The results provide the first indication of PCD in the ascidian embryo and suggest that apoptosis modulated by FoxA5 and Manx is involved in notochord and tail regression during anural development. Differences in PCD that occur between ascidian species suggest that diversity in programming apoptosis may explain differences in larval form.     

Evolution of the ascidian anural larva: evidence from embryos and molecules.

Most ascidians pass through a tadpole (urodele) larval stage, although some species have derived a tailless (anural) larva. New insights into the evolution of anural larvae in the Roscovita clade of molgulid ascidians were obtained from studing embryonic development of the transitional anural species Molgula bleizi and from phylogenetic analysis based on muscle and cytoskeletal actin gene sequences. By observing in vitro fertilized eggs, we found that M. bleizi, previously described as a typical anural developer, actually forms a short immotile tail during embryogenesis. The short tail contains notochord lineage cells, which undergo abbreviated morphogenetic movements but eventually arrest in development. Molgula bleizi tail muscle lineage cells produce the muscle enzyme acetylcholinesterase (AChE) but do not express muscle actin genes. The presence of a short tail, a vestigial notochord, and AChE-positive muscle cells suggest that M. bleizi is a recently derived anural species. An M. bleizi larval muscle actin gene (MbMA1) was isolated, sequenced, and shown to be a pseudogene based on critical deletions in its coding region that would result in a nonfunctional actin protein. The mutations in MbMA1 are distinct from and have evolved independent of the larval muscle actin pseudogenes MoccMA1a and MoccMA1b in Molgula occulta, another anural developer in the Roscovita clade. Pseudogene formation explains the absence of muscle actin mRNA in M. bleizi embryos. The 3' untranslated region of an M. bleizi cytoskeletal actin gene was also isolated and sequenced. Phylogenetic trees reconstructed using muscle and cytoskeletal actin sequences suggest that the anural developer M. bleizi evolved prior to the divergence of the urodele developer Molgula oculata and the anural developer M. occulta in the Roscovita clade. Since M. bleizi lives attached to hard substrata in the tidal zone, whereas M. oculata and M. occulta live buried in subtidal sand flats, our results suggest that the anural larva evolved at least twice in the Roscovita clade of molgulid ascidians as an adaptation to different habitats.     

Tail morphogenesis in the ascidian, Ciona intestinalis, requires cooperation between notochord and muscle

We present evidence that notochord and muscle differentiation are crucial for morphogenesis of the ascidian tail. We developed a novel approach for embryological manipulation of the developing larval tissues using a simple method to introduce DNA into Ciona intestinalis and the several available tissue-specific promoters. With such promoters, we misexpressed the Xenopus homeobox gene bix in notochord or muscle of Ciona embryos as a means of interfering with development of these tissues. Ciona embryos expressing bix in the notochord from the 64-cell stage develop into larvae with very short tails, in which the notochord precursors fail to intercalate and differentiate. Larvae with mosaic expression of bix have intermediate phenotypes, in which a partial notochord is formed by the precursor cells that did not receive the transgene while the precursors that express the transgene cluster together and fail to undergo any of the cell-shape changes associated with notochord differentiation. Muscle cells adjacent to differentiated notochord cells are properly patterned, while those next to the notochord precursor cells transformed by bix exhibit various patterning defects. In these embryos, the neural tube extends in the tail to form a nerve cord, while the endodermal strand fails to enter the tail region. Similarly, expression of bix in muscle progenitors impairs differentiation of muscle cells, and as a result, notochord cells fail to undergo normal extension movements. Hence, these larvae have a shorter tail, due to a block in the elongation of the notochord. Taken together, these observations suggest that tail formation in ascidian larvae requires not only signaling from notochord to muscle cells, but also a "retrograde" signal from muscle cells to notochord.     

Expressions and localizations of Bax/Bcl-2 proteins during metamorphosis of Pelophylax ridibundus

Bcl-2 and Bax proteins are expressed in cells of the tails of Pelophylax ridibundus larvae. We investigated the levels of these proteins in tails undergoing apoptosis. Apoptotic cells were observed in the epidermis, muscle and notochord of tails of different lengths. The apoptotic cells in epidermis exhibited the typical features of apoptosis. Amorphous masses and irregularities in striated muscle tissue undergoing apoptosis and apoptotic remnants in the notochord also were observed. In general, Bax staining in the epidermis, subepidermal fibroblast layer, muscle and notochord cells increased, while Bcl-2 staining decreased as the tail regressed. Our results suggest that during tail regression due to metamorphosis, Bcl-2 and Bax proteins play key roles in the apoptosis of tail epidermis, subepidermal fibroblast layer, muscle and notochord cells.     

Interspecific hybridization between an anural and urodele ascidian: differential expression of urodele features suggests multiple mechanisms control anural development

Anural development in the ascidian Molgula occulta was examined using tissue-specific markers and interspecific hybridization. Unlike most ascidians, which develop into a swimming tadpole larva (urodele development), M. occulta eggs develop into a tailless slug-like larva (anural development) which metamorphoses into an adult. M. occulta embryos show conventional early cleavage patterns, gastrulation, and neurulation, but then diverge from the urodele developmental mode during larval morphogenesis. M. occulta larvae do not contain a pigmented sensory cell in their brain or form a tail with differentiated notochord and muscle cells. As shown by in situ hybridization with cloned probes and analysis of in vitro translation products, M. occulta embryos do not accumulate high levels of alpha actin or myosin heavy chain mRNA. In contrast, acetylcholinesterase is expressed in muscle lineage cells, indicating that various muscle cell features are differentially suppressed. M. occulta embryos also lack tyrosinase activity, suggesting that suppression of brain pigment cell differentiation occurs at an early step in development. M. occulta eggs fertilized with sperm from Molgula oculata (a closely related urodele species) develop into hybrid larvae exhibiting some of the missing urodele features. Some hybrid embryos develop tyrosinase activity and differentiate a brain pigment cell and a short row of notochord cells, and form a short tail. These urodele features appeared together or separately in different hybrid embryos suggesting that they develop by independent mechanisms. In contrast, alpha actin and myosin heavy chain mRNA accumulation was not enhanced in hybrid embryos. These results suggest that multiple mechanisms control anural development.     

Mutations affecting tail and notochord development in the ascidian Ciona savignyi.

Ascidians are among the most distant chordate relatives of the vertebrates. However, ascidians share many features with vertebrates including a notochord and hollow dorsal nerve cord. A screen for N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea (ENU)-induced mutations affecting early development in the ascidian Ciona savignyi resulted in the isolation of a number of mutants including the complementing notochord mutants chongmague and chobi. In chongmague embryos the notochord fails to develop, and the notochord cells instead adopt a mesenchyme-like fate. The failure of notochord development in chongmague embryos results in a severe truncation of tail, although development of the tail muscles and caudal nerve tracts appears largely normal. Chobi embryos also have a truncation of the tail stemming from a disruption of the notochord. However, in chobi embryos the early development of the notochord appears normal and defects occur later as the notochord attempts to extend and direct elongation of the tail. We find in chobi tailbud embryos that the notochord is often bent, with cells clumped together, rather than extended as a column. These results provide new information on the function and development of the ascidian notochord. In addition, the results demonstrate how the unique features of ascidians can be used in genetic analysis of morphogenesis.     

Evolutionary reorganizations of ontogenesis in ascidians of the genus Molgula

The data on comparative, experimental, and molecular embryology of ascidians (genus Molgula) published during the last 15 years have been reviewed. Some representatives of this genus evolved from development with a tailed larva (tadpole) to direct development associated with the loss of larval structures, such as tail, notochord, sensory organs, and differentiated muscles. The data on evolutionary reorganizations of ontogenesis in ascidians of the genus Molgula have been compared with those in sea urchins, anuran amphibians, and some other organisms.     

Factors necessary for restoring an evolutionary change in an anural ascidian embryo.

The ascidian Molgula oculata has a tailed (or urodele) larva, whereas Molgula occulta develops directly via a tailless (or anural) embryo. Interspecific hybrid embryos produced by fertilizing M. occulta eggs with M. oculata sperm (M. occulta x M. oculata hybrids) can develop urodele larval structures, including a brain pigment cell and a short tail containing a small notochord. Development of larval features differs in individual M. occulta clutches: some eggs develop into hybrids with both a brain pigment cell and a tail, some into hybrids with either a brain pigment cell or a tail, and others into hybrids without urodele features. The expression of a 58-kDa protein (p58), which is present in eggs and embryos of urodele ascidians but lacking in those of most anural species, also varies in expression between different clutches of M. occulta eggs. Western blot and immunofluorescence studies show that p58 expression is correlated with the ability of hybrid embryos to express urodele features. For example, clutches of M. occulta eggs containing relatively high levels of p58 produce many hybrids with both a brain pigment cell and a tail. Differential expression of p58 occurs during oogenesis in M. occulta individuals: p58 is found at similar levels in previtellogenic oocytes, but in some animals it disappears during vitellogenesis, while in others it persists throughout oogenesis and is present in mature eggs. When M. occulta eggs are extracted with Triton X-100, p58 remains in the detergent-insoluble fraction, suggesting that it is associated with the cytoskeleton. In most unfertilized M. occulta eggs, p58 is uniformly distributed, but after fertilization it is localized in the uncleaved zygote and then concentrated in embryonic ectoderm, notochord, and muscle lineage cells. Despite containing high levels of p58, gynogenetic hybrid embryos, produced by fertilizing M. occulta eggs with uv-irradiated M. oculata sperm, develop into hybrids without a brain pigment cell or a tail. The results suggest that both a functional paternal genome and p58 are necessary for restoration of larval features in M. occulta x M. oculata hybrids. The cytoskeletal complex containing p58 may mediate the localization of key maternal factors in the egg or may be involved in cellular interactions during embryogenesis which are responsible for development of urodele cell fates.     

Ascidian larva reveals ancient origin of vertebrate-skeletal-muscle troponin I characteristics in chordate locomotory muscle

Ascidians are protochordates related to vertebrate ancestors. The ascidian larval tail, with its notochord, dorsal nerve cord, and flanking rows of sarcomeric muscle cells, exhibits the basic chordate body plan. Molecular characterization of ascidian larval tail muscle may provide insight into molecular aspects of vertebrate skeletal muscle evolution. We report studies of the Ci-TnI gene of the ascidian Ciona intestinalis, which encodes the muscle contractile regulatory protein troponin I (TnI). Previous studies of a distantly related ascidian, Halocynthia roretzi, showed that different TnI genes were expressed in larval and adult muscles, the larval TnI isoforms having an unusual C-terminal truncation not seen in any vertebrate TnI. Here we show that, in contrast with Halocynthia, Ciona does not have a specialized larval TnI; the same TnI gene that is expressed in the heart and body-wall muscle of the sessile adult is also expressed in embryonic/larval tail muscle cells. Moreover the TnI isoform produced in embryonic/larval muscle is identical to that produced in adult body-wall muscle, i.e., a 182-residue protein with the characteristic chain length and overall structure of vertebrate skeletal muscle TnI isoforms. Phylogenetic analyses indicate that the unique features of Halocynthia larval TnI likely represent derived features, and hence that the vertebrate-skeletal-muscle -like TnI of Ciona is a closer reflection of the ancestral ascidian larval TnI. Our results indicate that characteristics of vertebrate skeletal muscle TnI emerged early in the evolution of chordate locomotory muscle, before the ascidian/vertebrate divergence. These features could be related to a basal chordate locomotory innovation-e.g., swimming by oscillation of an internal notochord skeleton-or they may be of even greater antiquity within the deuterostomes.     

Ultrastructural and histochemical study of anural development in the ascidian Molgula pacifica (Huntsman)

Summary Tadpole development is eliminated in the life cycle of the ascidian Molgula pacifica. The elimination of a tailed larva is termed anural development, in contrast to urodele development which is exhibited by most ascidian species. In the present study, transmission electron microscopy and histochemistry were used to gain a better understanding of anural development in M. pacifica. The fine structure of M. pacifica oocytes and fertilized eggs was similar to urodele oocytes and eggs, except that a perivitelline space and test cells were absent. M. pacifica embryos exhibited the typical cleavage pattern of urodele embryos. Gastrulation was initiated at the vegetal pole, as in urodeles, and occurred at the same time as in two urodele species (Molgula manhattensis and Pyura haustor). However, changes in cell shapes and cell movements of the vegetal pole cells that participate in gastrulation were highly modified compared to commonly studied ascidians. The changes in shapes and movements of the vegetal pole cells were minimal and resulted in embryos having a very small archenteron and blastopore. The presence of large, yolky cells in the interior of the embryo likely restricted vegetal cell movements. Two ultrastructurally distinct types of epidermal cells were evident at the gastrula stage. When gastrulae were manually dechorionated from their surrounding mucous-follicular envelope layers, the embryos were already surrounded by a thin tunic. When day 1 juveniles in the process of hatching were sectioned along the anterior-posterior axis, regional differences in cell types were evident. Differentiated muscle cells in the posterior region were not evident. Day 1 M. pacifica juveniles, anural-developing M. provisionalis juveniles and tadpoles from three urodele species were tested for their abilities to express AchE activity. The highest levels of AchE activity were detected in the larval tail muscle cells of urodeles, low levels of activity were detected in the posterior region of M. provisionalis juveniles, whereas M. pacifica juveniles did not exhibit AchE activity. The results are discussed in terms of evolutionary mechanisms responsible for anural development in ascidians. Offprint requests to: W.R. Bates     

Evolutionary reorganizations of ontogenesis in ascidians of the genus Molgula

The data on comparative, experimental, and molecular embryology of ascidians (genus Molgula) published during the last 15 years have been reviewed. Some representatives of this genus evolved from development with a tailed larva (tadpole) to direct development associated with the loss of larval structures, such as tail, notochord, sensory organs, and differentiated muscles. The data on evolutionary reorganizations of ontogenesis in ascidians of the genus Molgula have been compared with those in sea urchins, anuran amphibians, and some other organisms.     

ABCA1-dependent but apoA-I-independent cholesterol efflux mediated by fatty acid-bile acid conjugates (FABACs)

PCD (programmed cell death) in plants presents important morphological and biochemical differences compared with apoptosis in animal cells. This raises the question of whether PCD arose independently or from a common ancestor in plants and animals. In the present study we describe a cell-free system, using wheat grain nucellar cells undergoing PCD, to analyse nucleus dismantling, the final stage of PCD. We have identified a Ca2+/Mg2+ nuclease and a serine protease localized to the nucleus of dying nucellar cells. Nuclear extracts from nucellar cells undergoing PCD triggered DNA fragmentation and other apoptotic morphology in nuclei from different plant tissues. Inhibition of the serine protease did not affect DNA laddering. Furthermore, we show that the nuclear extracts from plant cells triggered DNA fragmentation and apoptotic morphology in nuclei from human cells. The inhibition of the nucleolytic activity with Zn2+ or EDTA blocked the morphological changes of the nucleus. Moreover, nuclear extracts from apoptotic human cells triggered DNA fragmentation and apoptotic morphology in nuclei from plant cells. These results show that degradation of the nucleus is morphologically and biochemically similar in plant and animal cells. The implication of this finding on the origin of PCD in plants and animals is discussed.     

The forkhead gene FH1 is involved in evolutionary modification of the ascidian tadpole larva.

The forkhead gene FH1 encodes a HNF-3beta protein required for gastrulation and development of chordate features in the ascidian tadpole larva. Although most ascidian species develop via a tadpole larva, the conventional larva has regressed into an anural (tailless) larva in some species. Molgula oculata (the tailed species) exhibits a tadpole larva with chordate features (a dorsal neural sensory organ or otolith, a notochord, striated muscle cells, and a tail), whereas its sister species Molgula occulta (the tailless species) has evolved an anural larva, which has lost these features. Here we examine the role of FH1 in modifying the larval body plan in the tailless species. We also examine FH1 function in tailless speciesxtailed species hybrids, in which the otolith, notochord, and tail are restored. The FH1 gene is expressed primarily in the presumptive endoderm and notochord cells during gastrulation, neurulation, and larval axis formation in both species and hybrids. In the tailless species, FH1 expression is down-regulated after neurulation in concert with arrested otolith, notochord, and tail development. The FH1 expression pattern characteristic of the tailed species is restored in hybrid embryos prior to the development of chordate larval features. Antisense oligodeoxynucleotides (ODNs) shown previously to disrupt FH1 function were used to compare the developmental roles of this gene in both species and hybrids. As described previously, antisense FH1 ODNs inhibited endoderm invagination during gastrulation, notochord extension, and larval tail formation in the tailed species. Antisense FH1 ODNs also affected gastrulation in the tailless species, although the effects were less severe than in the tailed species, and an anural larva was formed. In hybrid embryos, antisense FH1 ODNs blocked restoration of the otolith, notochord, and tail, reverting the larva back to the anural state. The results suggest that changes in FH1 expression are involved in re-organizing the tadpole larva during the evolution of anural development.     

Spatio-temporal pattern of MAP kinase activation in embryos of the ascidian Halocynthia roretzi

To understand developmental mechanisms, it is important to know when and where signaling pathways are activated. The spatio-temporal pattern of activation of mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK/ERK) was investigated during embryogenesis of the ascidian Halocynthia roretzi, using an antibody specific to the activated form of MAPK. During cleavage stages, activated MAPK was transiently observed in nuclei of the precursor blastomeres of endoderm, notochord, mesenchyme, brain, secondary muscle, trunk lateral cells and trunk ventral cells. These sites of MAPK activation are consistent with results of previous studies that have analyzed the embryonic induction of various tissues, and with results of inhibition of MAPK kinase (MEK) in ascidians. Activation of MAPK in notochord and mesenchyme blastomeres was observed in a short period in a single cell cycle. In contrast, in brain and secondary muscle lineages, MAPK activation spanned two or three cell cycles, and upon each cleavage, MAPK was asymmetrically activated in only one of the two daughter cells that remained brain or secondary muscle lineages. During later stages, MAPK activation was predominantly observed in the central nervous system. A conspicuous feature at this stage was that activation appeared to alternate between positive and negative along the anterior-posterior axis of the neural tube. During the tail elongation stage, MAPK was quiescent.