The evolutionary potential of paramutation: A population-epigenetic model

Paramutation involves an interaction between homologous alleles resulting in a heritable change in gene expression without altering the DNA sequence. Initially believed to be restricted to plants, paramutation has recently been observed in animal models, and a paramutation-like event has been noted in humans. Despite the accumulating evidence suggesting that trans-acting epigenetic effects can be inherited transgenerationally and therefore generate non-genomic phenotypic variation, these effects have been largely ignored in the context of evolutionary theory. The model presented here incorporates paramutation into the standard model of viability selection at one locus and demonstrates that paramutation can create long-term biological diversity in the absence of genetic change, and even in the absence of the original paramutagenic allele. Therefore, if paramutation is present, attributing evolution to only a traditional genetic model may fail to encompass the broad scope of phenotypic differences observed in nature. Moreover, we show also that an unusual mathematical behaviour, analogous to “Ewens’ gap” of the two-locus two-allele symmetric-selection model, occurs: when the rate of one parameter–for example, the rate of paramutation–is increased, a pair of equilibria may disappear only to reappear as this parameter increases further. In summary, by incorporating even the simplest epigenetic parameters into the standard population-genetic model of selection, we show how this type of inheritance system can profoundly alter the course of evolution.     

Paramutation in maize

Paramutation is a heritable change in gene expression induced by allele interactions. This review summarizes key experiments on three maize loci, which undergo paramutation. Similarities and differences between the phenomenology at the three loci are described. In spite of many differences with respect to the stability of the reduced expression states at each locus or whether paramutation correlates with DNA methylation and repeated sequences within the loci, recent experiments are consistent with a common mechanism underlying paramutation at all three loci. Most strikingly, trans-acting mutants have been isolated that prevent paramutation at all three loci and lead to the activation of silenced Mutator transposable elements. Models consistent with the hypothesis that paramutation involves heritable changes in chromatin structure are presented. Several potential roles for paramutation are discussed. These include localizing recombination to low-copy sequences within the genome, establishing and maintaining chromatin domain boundaries, and providing a mechanism for plants to transmit an environmentally influenced expression state to progeny.     

Hérédité et épigénétique: un rôle inattendu pour l’ARN

Although Mendel’s first laws explain the transmission of most characteristics, there has recently been a renewed interest in the notion that DNA is not the sole determinant of our inherited phenotype. Human epidemiology studies and animal and plant genetic studies have provided evidence that epigenetic information (“epigenetic” describes an inherited effect on chromosome or gene function that is not accompanied by any alteration of the nucleotide sequence) can be inherited from parents to offspring. Most of the mechanisms involved in epigenetic “memory” are paramutation events, which are heritable epigenetic changes in the phenotype of a “paramutable” allele. Initially demonstrated in plants, paramutation is defined as an interaction between two alleles of a single locus that results in heritable changes of one allele that is induced by the other. The authors describe an unexpected example of paramutation in the mouse revealed by a recent analysis of an epigenetic variation modulating expression of theKit locus. The progeny of hétérozygote intercrosses (carrying one mutant and one wild-type allele) showed persistence of the white patches (characteristic of hétérozygotes) in the homozygous Kit^+/+ progeny. The DNA sequences of the two wild-type alleles were structurally normal, revealing an epigenetic modification. Further investigations showed that RNA and microRNA, released by sperm, mediate this epigenetic inheritance. The molecular mechanisms involved in this unexpected mode of inheritance and the role of RNA molecules in the spermatozoon head as possible vectors for the hereditary transfer of such modifications — implying that paternal inheritance is not limited to just one haploid copy of the genome — are still a matter of debate. Paramutations may be considered to be one possibility of epigenetic modification in the case of familial disease predispositions not fully explained by Mendelian analysis.     

Structural features and methylation patterns associated with paramutation at the r1 locus of Zea mays.

In paramutation, two alleles of a gene interact and, during the interaction, one of them becomes epigenetically silenced. The various paramutation systems that have been studied to date exhibit intriguing differences in the physical complexity of the loci involved. B and Pl alleles that participate in paramutation are simple, single genes, while the R haplotypes that participate in paramutation contain multiple gene copies and often include rearrangements. The number and arrangement of the sequences in particular complex R haplotypes have been correlated with paramutation behavior. Here, the physical structures of 28 additional haplotypes of R were examined. A specific set of physical features is associated with paramutability (the ability to be silenced). However, no physical features were strongly correlated with paramutagenicity (the ability to cause silencing) or neutrality (the inability to participate in paramutation). Instead, paramutagenic haplotypes were distinguished by high levels of cytosine methylation over certain regions of the genes while neutral haplotypes were distinguished by lack of C-methylation over these regions. These findings suggest that paramutability of r1 is determined by the genetic structure of particular haplotypes, while paramutagenicity is determined by the epigenetic state.     

玉米副突变及其分子机制

副突变是一种表观遗传现象,通过同源基因间染色质状态信息的转移建立新的基因表达状态,这种表达状态能够通过减数分裂而传递到后代。玉米是研究副突变及其机制的模式植物,目前已经发现有5个基因位点能够发生副突变。对玉米b1副突变系统的广泛研究发现DNA重复序列、siRNA途径、DNA结合蛋白等在副突变状态的建立和维持过程中可能起着重要的作用。     

Passing the message on: inheritance of epigenetic traits

Epigenetic modifiers play an important role in genome organization, stability and the control of gene expression. Three research groups that are exploring the transfer of epigenetic information between generations have recently published papers. Mary Alleman et al. have shown that RNA-directed chromatin changes mediate paramutation in maize, and Minoo Rassoulzadegan et al. have demonstrated that RNA also plays a role in paramutation in mice. A new aspect of epigenetic regulation has been revealed by Jean Molinier et al. - they have demonstrated that the memory of exposure to stress is transferred through several generations.     

The maize b1 paramutation control region causes epigenetic silencing in Drosophila melanogaster

Paramutation is an epigenetic process in which a combination of alleles in a heterozygous organism results in a meiotically stable change in expression of one of the alleles. The mechanisms underlying paramutation are being actively investigated, and examples have been described in both plants and mammals, suggesting that it may utilize epigenetic mechanisms that are widespread and evolutionarily conserved. Paramutation at the well-studied maize b1 locus requires a control region consisting of seven 853 bp tandem repeats. To study the conservation of the epigenetic mechanisms underlying seemingly unique epigenetic processes such as paramutation, we created transgenic Drosophila melanogaster carrying the maize b1 control region adjacent to the Drosophila white reporter gene. We show that the b1 tandem repeats cause silencing of the white reporter in Drosophila. A single copy of the tandem repeat sequence is sufficient to cause silencing, and silencing strength increases as the number of tandem repeats increases. Additionally, transgenic lines with the full seven tandem repeats demonstrate evidence of either pairing-sensitive silencing and silencing in trans, or epigenetic activation in trans. These trans-interactions are dependent on repeat number, similar to maize b1 paramutation. Also, as in maize, the tandem repeats are bidirectionally transcribed in Drosophila. These results indicate that the maize b1 tandem repeats function as an epigenetic silencer and mediate trans-interactions in Drosophila, and support the hypothesis that the mechanisms underlying such epigenetic processes are conserved.     

副突变及其表观遗传机制的研究进展

经典遗传学的研究方法为许多遗传性疾病和遗传相关性疾病的预防、诊断和治疗提供了在分子水平上的直接线索,然而人类疾病的遗传表现始终存在着经典遗传学法则所不能解释的现象。副突变(paramutation)是上世纪50年代首次在玉米中发现的一种非孟氏遗传模式,其传递的等位基因不存在核苷酸序列的差异,提示了表观遗传机制可能参与了基因表达和表型的可遗传变化。近期的研究发现关于副突变现象的解释可能涉及一种新的表观遗传学调控机制,即由RNA(特别是非编码RNA)引发的基因组改变参与了副突变的发生和维持。其中DNA甲基转移酶II所介导的RNA甲基化发挥了极其重要的作用。对副突变及其机制的研究不仅能够深化人类对遗传和生命本质的认识,还有助于开拓在生物工程和疾病诊疗等应用领域的新思路。本文综述了副突变的分子机制和研究进展,并且探讨了副突变在疾病研究和基因治疗中的应用前景。     

Inherited variation at the epigenetic level: paramutation from the plant to the mouse

In contrast with a wide definition of the 'epigenetic variation', including all changes in gene expression that do not result from the alteration of the gene structure, a more restricted class had been defined, initially in plants, under the name 'paramutation'. It corresponds to epigenetic modifications distinct from the regulatory interactions of the cell differentiation pathways, mitotically stable and sexually transmitted with non-Mendelian patterns. This class of epigenetic changes appeared for some time restricted to the plant world, but examples progressively accumulated of epigenetic inheritance in organisms ranging from mice to humans. Occurrence of paramutation in the mouse and possible mechanisms were then established in the paradigmatic case of a mutant phenotype maintained and hereditarily transmitted by wild-type homozygotes. Together with the recent findings in plants indicative of a necessary step of RNA amplification in the reference maize paramutation, the mouse studies point to a new role of RNA, as an inducer and hereditary determinant of epigenetic variation. Given the known presence of a wide range of RNAs in human spermatozoa, as well as a number of unexplained cases of familial disease predisposition and transgenerational maintenance, speculations can be extended to possible roles of RNA-mediated inheritance in human biology and pathology.     

Locus-specific paramutation in Zea mays is maintained by a PICKLE-like chromodomain helicase DNA-binding 3 protein controlling development and male gametophyte function

Paramutations represent directed and meiotically-heritable changes in gene regulation leading to apparent violations of Mendelian inheritance. Although the mechanism and evolutionary importance of paramutation behaviors remain largely unknown, genetic screens in maize (Zea mays) identify five components affecting 24 nucleotide RNA biogenesis as required to maintain repression of a paramutant purple plant1 (pl1) allele. Currently, the RNA polymerase IV largest subunit represents the only component also specifying proper development. Here we identify a chromodomain helicase DNA-binding 3 (CHD3) protein orthologous to Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) PICKLE as another component maintaining both pl1 paramutation and normal somatic development but without affecting overall small RNA biogenesis. In addition, genetic tests show this protein contributes to proper male gametophyte function. The similar mutant phenotypes documented in Arabidopsis and maize implicate some evolutionarily-conserved gene regulation while developmental defects associated with the two paramutation mutants are largely distinct. Our results show that a CHD3 protein responsible for normal plant ontogeny and sperm transmission also helps maintain meiotically-heritable epigenetic regulatory variation for specific alleles. This finding implicates an intersection of RNA polymerase IV function and nucleosome positioning in the paramutation process.     

Molecular analysis of paramutant plants of Antirrhinum majus and the involvement of transposable elements

Paramutation is observed when the Antirrhinum majus lines 44 and 53 are crossed. These two lines both have insertions at the nivea locus, which encodes chalcone synthase (chs). The allele niv-53 carries the transposable element Tam1 in the promoter region of the chs gene; niv-44 carries the element Tam2 within the gene. The Tam1 element has previously been extensively characterised. Here the Tam2 element is further characterised, and the arrangement of the nivea locus in paramutant plants is analysed. The complete sequence of Tam2, and that of a partial cDNA complementary to it, have been determined. The cDNA is probably transcribed from a different copy of Tam2 from that present at the nivea locus, and does not encode a functional protein. Genomic Southerns of F1 plants from the 53/44 cross show that no major rearrangements are consistently associated with paramutation at the nivea locus of A. majus. The isolation from a paramutant plant arising from a 53/44 cross of an allele (niv-4432) resulting from the excision of Tam2 is reported. The excision of Tam2 resulted in a 32 bp deletion of chs gene sequences. Plants homozygous for the new niv-4432 allele have white flowers and are still paramutagenic, demonstrating that Tam2 need not be present at the nivea locus for paramutation to occur. Different interactions between Tam1 and Tam2 are discussed, and a possible model for paramutation is presented.