Field test of an automated radio‐telemetry system: tracking local space use of aerial insectivores

Documenting local space use of birds that move rapidly, but are too small to carry GPS tags, such as swallows and swifts, can be challenging. For these species, tracking methods such as manual radio‐telemetry and visual observation are either inadequate or labor‐ and time‐intensive. Another option is use of an automated telemetry system, but equipment for such systems can be costly when many receivers are used. Our objective, therefore, was to determine if an automated radio‐telemetry system, consisting of just two receivers, could provide an alternative to manual tracking for gathering data on local space use of six individuals of three species of aerial insectivores, including one Cliff Swallow (Petrochelidon pyrrhonota), one Eastern Phoebe (Sayornis phoebe), and four Barn Swallows (Hirundo rustica). We established automated radio‐telemetry systems at three sites near the city of Peterborough in eastern Ontario, Canada, from May to August 2015. We evaluated the location error of our two‐receiver system using data from moving and stationary test transmitters at known locations, and used telemetry data from the aerial insectivores as a test of the system's ability to track rapidly moving birds under field conditions. Median location error was ~250 m for automated telemetry test locations after filtering. More than 90% of estimated locations had large location errors and were removed from analysis, including all locations > 1 km from receiver stations. Our automated telemetry receivers recorded 17,634 detections of the six radio‐tagged birds. However, filtering removed an average of 89% of bird location estimates, leaving only the Cliff Swallow with enough locations for analysis of space use. Our results demonstrate that a minimal automated radio‐telemetry system can be used to assess local space use by small, highly mobile birds, but the resolution of the data collected using only two receiver stations was coarse and had a limited range. To improve both location accuracy and increase the percentage of usable location estimates collected, we suggest that, in future studies, investigators use receivers that simultaneously record signals detected by all antennas, and use of a minimum of three receiver stations with more antennas at each station.     

Detection range of songbirds using a stopover site by automated radio‐telemetry

A major uncertainty in automated radio‐telemetry studies of small birds is the detection range of receiving antennas. We compared simultaneous daytime detections (± 30 s) by automated and manual radio‐telemetry to assess detection probability and the proportion of transmissions detected for birds on migratory stopover as a function of distance, foraging guild (Black‐throated Blue Warblers, Setophaga caerulescens, and Yellow‐rumped Warblers, Dendroica coronata coronata, represented mid‐canopy foliage gleaners and White‐throated Sparrows, Zonotrichia albicollis, represented a ground forager), habitat type, meteorological variables, tower antenna number (1–4), and the position of a bird relative to the receiving antenna's bearing (offset angle). Our study was conducted at a migratory stopover site in southern Ontario, Canada. Most detections were in dense to sparse forest, and all individuals were within 1.03 km of the automated receiving station. Daily detection probability was near 100% for both foraging guilds. However, within 30 s before and after a manual radio‐telemetry location was made, detection probability and the proportion of transmissions detected by automated radio‐telemetry declined with distance, was higher for warblers than sparrows, and was lowest for 90° offset angles. Our results suggest that when research goals do not require detections with high temporal frequency, e.g., estimation of departure date or daily departure probability, our study design had an effective detection range of at least 1 km. However, where temporal precision is required, e.g., to investigate movements and changes in activity levels during stopover, detection range was ~300 m for ground‐foraging sparrows and 600 m for mid‐canopy foraging warblers, which is much lower than the presumed detection range of antennas under optimal conditions (15 km). This corresponds to a spatial area of coverage for forest‐dwelling birds of ~0.3–1.1 km². Our results suggest that to optimally configure an automated radio‐telemetry array at the regional scale, investigators should carefully consider detection range and its underlying covariates, including species type, the habitat matrix, and the orientation of antennas relative to preferred habitat.     

Substrate promiscuity of secondary metabolite enzymes: prenylation of hydroxynaphthalenes by fungal indole prenyltransferases

Fungal prenyltransferases of the dimethylallyltryptophan synthase (DMATS) superfamily share no sequence, but structure similarity with the prenyltransferases of the CloQ/NphB group. The members of the DMATS superfamily have been reported to catalyze different prenylations of diverse indole or tyrosine derivatives, while some members of the CloQ/NphB group used hydroxynaphthalenes as prenylation substrates. In this study, we report for the first time the prenylation of hydroxynaphthalenes by the members of the DMATS superfamily. Three tryptophan-containing cyclic dipeptide prenyltransferases (AnaPT, CdpNPT and CdpC3PT), one tryptophan C7-prenyltransferase and one tyrosine O-prenyltransferase (SirD) were incubated with naphthalene and 11 derivatives. The enzyme activity and preference of the tested prenyltransferases towards hydroxynaphthalenes differed clearly from each other. For an accepted substrate, however, different enzymes produced usually the same major prenylation product, i.e. with a regular C-prenyl moiety at para- or ortho-position to a hydroxyl group. Regularly, O-prenylated and diprenylated derivatives were also identified as enzyme products of substrates with low conversion rates and regioselectivity. This was unequivocally proven by mass spectrometry and nuclear magnetic resonance analyses. The K _M values and turnover numbers (k _cat) of the enzymes towards selected hydroxynaphthalenes were determined to be in the range of 0.064–2.8 mM and 0.038–1.30 s⁻¹, respectively. These data are comparable to those obtained using indole derivatives. The results presented in this study expanded the potential usage of the members of the DMATS superfamily for production of prenylated derivatives including hydroxynaphthalenes.     

Florida Panther Habitat Selection Analysis of Concurrent GPS and VHF Telemetry Data

Abstract: Florida panthers (Puma concolor coryi) are listed as an endangered subspecies in the United States and they exist in a single Florida population with <100 individuals; all known reproduction occurs south of Lake Okeechobee. Habitat loss is the biggest threat to this small population and previous studies of habitat selection have relied on very high frequency (VHF) telemetry data collected almost exclusively during diurnal periods. We investigated habitat selection of 12 panthers in the northern portion of the breeding range using 1) Global Positioning System (GPS) telemetry data collected during nocturnal and diurnal periods and 2) VHF telemetry data collected only during diurnal periods. Analysis of both types of telemetry data yielded similar results as panthers selected upland (P < 0.001) and wetland (P < 0.001) forested habitat types. Our results indicated that forests are the habitats selected by panthers and generally support the current United States Fish and Wildlife Service panther habitat ranking system. We suggest that future studies with greater numbers of panthers should investigate panther habitat selection using GPS telemetry data collected throughout the range of the Florida panther and with location attempts scheduled more evenly across the diel period. Global Positioning System radiocollars were effective at obtaining previously unavailable nocturnal telemetry data on panthers; however, we recommend that panther researchers continue to collect VHF telemetry data until acquisition rates and durability of GPS collars improve. (JOURNAL OF WILDLIFE MANAGEMENT 72(3):633–639; 2008)     

Alien and native plant seed dispersal by vehicles

Vehicles play a significant role in spreading plants, both in terms of quantity and quality (species). This study was conducted in Southeast Queensland to determine the role of utility vehicles in spreading seeds. These vehicles were found to carry up to 397 seeds per vehicle and in all four seasons of the year, with the majority of these species being alien to Australia and/or Queensland. The largest seed loads were found in autumn in this summer rainfall environment. Seeds were shown to attach to all parts of the vehicle, often in mud picked up from the ground, affixed directly to the engine or radiator, or carried into the cabin by the driver. Therefore, much of the seed load is to be found on the underside, on the back and front mudguards while smaller collections were found in the cabin, on the radiator and engine, and on the tyres. Fewer viable seeds were found on the engine, presumably as desiccation and heat contributed more to their death on this part of the vehicle. One method used to reduce weed seed spread by vehicles in Queensland is washing and vacuuming of vehicles. From the present study, these procedures would need to be applied to all parts of the vehicle and in all seasons of the year.     

An Integrated Vehicle-Mounted Telemetry System for VHF Telemetry Applications

Abstract: We designed and developed a vehicle-mounted very high frequency-based telemetry system that integrated an on-board antenna, receiver, electronic compass, Global Positioning System, computer, and Geographic Information System. The system allows users to accurately and quickly obtain fixes, estimate and confirm locations of radiomarked animals, and immediately record data into an electronic spreadsheet or database. The total cost of materials to build the system was $7,349 (United States currency). Mean error angle of 2.63 ± 12.1° (SD; range = −33.7–42.2°) and mean location error distance of 128 ± 91.3 m (SD; range = 0–408 m) suggested precision and accuracy of our system were comparable to other reported systems. Mean time to record 5 bearings/test transmitter was 6.28 ± 0.24 minutes (SE), which is the most efficient system reported to locate animals in the field. Vehicle-mounted telemetry systems like ours provide additional value to studies that involve tracking highly mobile species because investigators need not take bearings from established receiving stations and because investigators can immediately recognize bounced signals and take additional bearings and optimize accuracy of location estimates.     

Assessing the spatial ecology and resource use of a mobile and endangered species in an urbanized landscape using satellite telemetry and DNA faecal metabarcoding

The conservation of highly mobile species presents challenges to managers for assessment of threats to survival, given the difficulties in locating and observing such species. Here we evaluate satellite telemetry, DNA faecal metabarcoding and traditional field observations as three complementary techniques to acquire critical management information for an endangered species, Carnaby's Cockatoo Calyptorhynchus latirostris. Satellite telemetry of 23 birds resulted in 6026 location fixes accurate to within 500 m, and combined with extensive field observations and DNA faecal metabarcoding resulted in a more detailed understanding of how this species survives in an urbanized landscape. We identified 168 night roosts, 75% of which were previously unknown, which will contribute towards a more accurate population size estimate based on annual counts of roosting birds. We also determined the scale of daily movements (morning 5.4 ± 3.4 km from roost, afternoon 5.5 ± 3.3 km to roost; maximum distance between consecutive roosts 69.7 km) and the size of foraging areas around roosts (range 17–276 km²), and identified dependence on a variety of native and exotic food sources. Field observations identified 11 food‐plant families, but combined with DNA faecal metabarcoding this was extended to 21 food‐plant families. The three techniques were compared to assess their individual and collective values. By combining spatial ecology information from satellite telemetry with ecological knowledge from field observation and DNA faecal analysis, we gained deeper insights into the ecology of the species than would have been possible from any one technique alone. This information will lead to more strategic conservation planning to allow this species to persist within a rapidly expanding urban environment.     

Use of radio telemetry for studying upriver migration of adult Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar)

This paper describes and evaluates a 50 mHz radio telemetry system for studying river movements of adult Atlantic salmon ( Salmo salar ). In fresh water for most applications radio telemetry is preferable to ultrasonic telemetry, because the receiving element (antenna) can be above water, and radio signals are scarcely affected by turbulent, weedy or ice-covered water. Within the range of 10–200 mHz higher frequencies are preferred, since the efficient antenna size is inversely proportional to frequency, and attenuation of signals is independent of frequency. Transmitters were cylindrical (6.5–9.6 cm long * 1.9 cm diam) with a 0.5 wavelength antenna trailing from one end. Each emitted pulsed signals on one of 20 crystal-controlled channels between 49.100 and 49.385 mHz. Transmitters were placed in the stomachs of salmon and the antenna trailed out the last gill slit. Receivers were portable 20-channel manual or automatic scan models, and antennas were 48 cm diam capacitor tuned loops. Some salmon regurgitated transmitters. Two salmon were recaptured and showed no ill effects from carrying transmitters for 32 and 42 days. Pulse rate had little effect on known transmitter life under natural conditions. Known tag life was variable, but averaged 70 days for transmitters with 1000 mah batteries. The range of transmission of transmitters to a receiving system in an airplane at 410 m altitude was about 10 km, and to a boat about 1 km. Range to a land vehicle was variable depending on obstructions. From the airplane transmitters can be located within a radius of about 50 m.     

Migration and distribution of adult hatchery reared Yangtze sturgeons (Acipenser dabryanus) after releasing in the upper Yangtze River and its implications for stock enhancement

The Yangtze sturgeon (Acipenser dabryanus) is a most important aquatic animal at the national level. Influenced by human activities such as dam constructions and overfishing, its natural population in the wild has almost disappeared. Since 2000, its natural reproduction has not been detected. In May 2018, in the Yibin reaches of the upper Yangtze River, 40 adult hatchery reared Yangtze sturgeons with their gonads at or above stage III, body length ranging from 92 to 146 cm were ultrasonically labeled and released. Results of fixed station and mobile surveys showed that only one individual did not receive ultrasonic signals. Our study indicated that: (a) In terms of longitudinal migration along the river, most individuals were mainly distributed in the main section of the downstream Jinsha River below Xiangjiaba Dam after releasing, except one individual conducting a relatively long-distance migration; (b) Compared with the released juvenile fish which performed a descending migration, adult Yangtze sturgeons preferred an anadromous migration and a settled life in the wild; (c) The habitat water depth of the released Yangtze sturgeons ranged from 0.61m to 27.74 m with the mean value of 8.65 ± 3.89m (mean ± standard deviation). There was a significant difference in daytime and nighttime habitat water depths (p < .01), and the average habitat water depth in daytime was significantly lower than that at night. In this study, ultrasonic telemetry was used to quantitatively assess the migration and spatial distribution of the released adult Yangtze sturgeons for the first time. Our results would provide a scientific basis for the subsequent reconstruction and restoration of the wild populations and future stock enhancement.     

Evaluating how hunters see and react to telemetry collars on white-tailed deer

Fates of individuals outfitted with radiotransmitters commonly are used for estimating survival rates in populations of large animals that are hunted. Despite precautions, this practice may be subject to complex biases associated with hunter reaction to presence of radiotransmitters. To assess this potential bias we conducted an experiment using artificial deer (i.e., decoys) to measure hunters' abilities to see deer and determine if deer seen were wearing radiocollars. We used logistic regression to quantify probabilities that seeing deer and subsequently seeing radiocollars might be influenced by distance, percent visual obstruction, body orientation, hunter experience, and antler characteristics of deer. Additionally, we evaluated how experience and antler characteristics of deer might influence a hunter's decision to harvest a radiocollared deer. We found that 25.8% of the potentially observable collared deer (n = 663) were subsequently observed by hunters. Odds of observing deer and radiocollars increased 95% and 230%, respectively, for each additional log(yr) of hunting experience. Willingness to harvest radiocollared deer increased 89% for each additional log(yr) of hunting experience and 144% for large-antlered deer relative to antlerless deer. When hunting is an important source of mortality, analysts need to understand how potential biases associated with observing deer are associated with hunters' reactions to and subsequent decisions to harvest radiocollared animals. Our study suggested that presence of radiocollars may influence a deer's potential risk of being harvested and in turn bias telemetry-based estimates of survival, given that hunting mortality is the largest component of total mortality in hunted deer populations. Collar-based telemetry is used nearly universally by wildlife managers and researchers throughout North America and elsewhere to estimate and monitor the survival of big game populations that are managed through hunting. Our findings demonstrate that these estimates are likely subject to complex and systematic biases that managers should consider when evaluating future population-level effects of managed hunting. © 2011 The Wildlife Society     

Avoiding investment in fossil fuel assets

Reducing greenhouse gas emissions requires a transformation of capital assets in the economy, especially those for energy supply. This paper explores the hypothesis that economically efficient decarbonization occurs when the demand for fossil fuels declines at the same rate as their capital assets depreciate. In theory this means that new investments in fossil fuel assets are avoided, but without incurring stranded assets. We examine the practicality of this hypothesis using a biophysical economic model of the US energy supply system, with an example focused on impacts of electric vehicles on the petroleum supply chain. We specifically address two questions: (1) What rate of market penetration for electric vehicles is necessary to avoid investments in the petroleum-related assets? (2) How do the costs of upstream capital assets change with the transformation to electric vehicles? High annual depreciation rates for oil refineries (δ = 9.47%) and assets for crude oil extraction (δ = 8.23%) have important impacts on results. To avoid new investment in oil refining assets through widespread electrification of light-duty vehicles, the vehicle stock would need to be transformed in just 4 or 5 years. Under most scenarios, some petroleum pipelines will likely become stranded assets due to their low rate of depreciation (δ = 2.48%). In some scenarios, additional investments in wind and solar power generation surpass oil and gas extraction for about 5 years during the transformation to electric vehicles. Once built, however, wind and solar capital assets last longer, as shown by their low rate of depreciation (δ = 3.26%).     

Implications of Woodrats and Other Scavengers for Avian Telemetry Studies

Abstract: During 2 years of radiotelemetry research on chukars (Alectoris chukar) in western Utah, USA, we found 28% of retrieved radios (n = 78) in rubbish nests of woodrats (Neotoma spp.). Such movement and disturbance of carcasses and radios by woodrats and other species has implications for radiotelemetry studies. We evaluated spatio-temporal movement of 51 radiocollars attached to chukar carcasses in western Utah. Most (80%) carcasses were scavenged within one week and by the end of 3 weeks 25 (50%) had been retrieved from woodrat middens. Scavenging activity can both obscure important clues needed to identify causes of mortality and bias telemetry studies by delaying onset of mortality signals.     

Development of a novel probiotic delivery system based on microencapsulation with protectants

The establishment of the health-promoting benefits of probiotics is challenged by the antimicrobial bio-barriers throughout the host’s gastrointestinal (GI) tract after oral administration. Although microencapsulation has been frequently utilised to enhance the delivery of probiotics, microcapsules of sub-100 μm were found to be ineffective and therefore questioned as an effective delivery vehicle for viable probiotics despite the sensory advantage. In this study, four probiotics strains were encapsulated in chitosan-coated alginate microcapsules of sub-100 μm. Only a minor protective effect was observed from this original type of microcapsule. In order to enhance the survival of these probiotics, sucrose, a metabolisable sugar, and lecithin vesicles were added to the wall material. Both of the ingredients could be readily encapsulated with the probiotics, and protected them from stresses in the simulated GI fluids. The metabolisable sugar effectively increased the survival of the probiotics in gastric acid, mainly through energizing the membrane-bound F₁F₀-ATPases. The lecithin vesicles proved to alleviate the bile salt stress, and hence notably reduced the viability loss at the elevated bile salt concentrations. Overall, three out of the total four probiotics in the reinforced sub-100 μm microencapsules could significantly survive through an 8-h sequential treatment of the simulated GI fluids, giving less than 1-log drop in viable count. The most vulnerable strain of bifidobacteria also yielded a viability increase of 3-logs from this protection. In conclusion, the sub-100 μm microcapsules can be a useful vehicle for the delivery of probiotics, as long as suitable protectants are incorporated in the wall matrix.     

Off‐road vehicles affect nesting behaviour and reproductive success of American Oystercatchers Haematopus palliatus

As human populations and associated development increase, interactions between humans and wildlife are occurring with greater frequency. The effects of these interactions, particularly on species whose populations are declining, are of great interest to ecologists, conservationists, land managers and natural resource policy‐makers. The American Oystercatcher Haematopus palliatus, a species of conservation concern in the USA, nests on coastal beaches subject to various forms of anthropogenic disturbance, including aircraft overflights, off‐road vehicles and pedestrians. This study assessed the effects of these human disturbances on the incubation behaviour and reproductive success of nesting American Oystercatchers at Cape Lookout National Seashore, on the Atlantic coast of the USA. We expanded on‐going monitoring of Oystercatchers at Cape Lookout National Seashore by supplementing periodic visual observations with continuous 24‐h video and audio recording at nests. Aircraft overflights were not associated with changes in Oystercatcher incubation behaviour, and we found no evidence that aircraft overflights influenced Oystercatcher reproductive success. However, Oystercatchers were on their nests significantly less often during off‐road vehicle and pedestrian events than they were during control periods before the events, and an increase in the number of off‐road vehicles passing a nest during incubation was consistently associated with significant reductions in daily nest survival (6% decrease in daily nest survival for a one‐vehicle increase in the average number of vehicles passing a nest each day; odds ratio = 0.94; 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.90, 0.98) and hatching success (12% decrease in hatching success for a one‐vehicle increase in the average number of vehicles passing a nest each day; odds ratio = 0.88; 95% CI 0.76, 0.97). Management of vehicles and pedestrians in areas of Oystercatcher breeding is important for the conservation of American Oystercatchers.     

Chronic allergen challenge induces bronchial mast cell accumulation in BALB/c but not C57BL/6 mice and is independent of IL-9

As genetically engineered mutant mice deficient in single genes are usually generated on a C57BL/6 background, to study mast cell trafficking in mutant mice, we initially investigated whether mast cells accumulated in bronchi in C57BL/6 mice challenged with OVA allergen acutely or chronically for 1 to 3 months. The total number of bronchial mast cells were quantitated using toluidine blue staining in airways of different sizes, i.e. , small (<90 μm), medium (90–155 μm), or large (>150 μm) airways. Non-OVA challenged and acute OVA challenged mice (C57BL/6 and BALB/c) had no detectable bronchial mast cells. Chronic OVA challenge in BALB/c mice for 1 or 3 months induced a significant increase in the number of bronchial mast cells in small-, medium-, and large-sized airways but minimal change in the number of bronchial mast cells in C57BL/6 mice. Both BALB/c and C57BL/6 mice developed significant lung eosinophilia following acute or chronic OVA challenge. Studies of IL-9-deficient mice on a BALB/c background demonstrated a significant increase in the number of bronchial mast cells in IL-9-deficient mice suggesting that IL-9 was not required for the bronchial accumulation of mast cells. Overall, these studies demonstrate that the chronic OVA challenge protocol we have utilized in BALB/c mice provides a model to study the mechanism of bronchial mast cell accumulation and that bronchial mast cell accumulation in chronic OVA challenged mice is independent of IL-9 in this model.     

Delayed Treatment with Carboxy-PTIO Permits a 4-h Therapeutic Window of Opportunity and Prevents Against Ischemia-Induced Energy Depletion Following Permanent Focal Cerebral Ischemia in Mice

We examined whether a nitric oxide scavenger, 2-(4-carboxyphenyl)-4,4,5,5-tetramethyl-imidazoline-l-oxyl-3-oxide (carboxy-PTIO), could offer neuroprotective actions and improve cerebral energy metabolism in a model of stroke. Sixty C57BL/10J mice were given either carboxy-PTIO (0.3–1.2 mg/kg) or vehicle intraperitoneally, 0.5 h after permanent middle cerebral artery occlusion, to evaluate the dose–response effects. An additional 70 animals received carboxy-PTIO (0.6 mg/kg) or vehicle, 2–6 h post-ischemia, for establishing the therapeutic window. Subgroups of animals, treated with carboxy-PTIO (0.6 mg/kg) or vehicle, were used for measuring cerebral bioenergetic metabolites (ATP, ADP, AMP, adenosine). Mice treated with carboxy-PTIO (0.6 mg/kg) had dose-specifically reduced brain infarction, significantly by 27–30% (P < 0.05), even when therapy was delayed up to 4 h after the ischemic insult (P < 0.05). Four hour post-ischemia, ATP depleted in the ischemic hemisphere (P < 0.05). Administration with carboxy-PTIO not only improved the recovery of ATP in the ischemic hemisphere (P < 0.05), but also enhanced adenosine content across the ischemic and non-ischemic hemispheres (P < 0.05). The neuroprotection of carboxy-PTIO may be partly attributed to the beneficial effects of improving cerebral energy metabolism.     

Response to human presence during nocturnal line transect surveys in fallow deer (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Dama dama</Emphasis>) and wild boar (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Sus scrofa</Emphasis>)

The use of line transect methodology and portable thermal imaging for ground survey of wildlife should require a good knowledge of the behavioural response of the animals to the presence of an observer, in order to take into account the potential bias in density estimate caused by deviation from the assumption that distances are recorded at the initial position. We used ten fallow deer and eight wild boar fitted with radiocollars to investigate animals’ response during simulated nocturnal line transect surveys, carried out in a Mediterranean plain forest. The experiment consisted in radiolocating a focal animal before and after an observer walked a transect nearby (<100 m). Each transect line was followed using a Global Positioning System (GPS) navigator. We carried out a total of 64 trials on fallow deer and 57 on wild boar. Results showed that despite most of the animals moved significantly in response to the observer (mean ± standard error, wild boar—95.3 ± 10.0 m; fallow deer—149.6 ± 14.2 m), the flying patterns were different in the two species: the reaction of fallow deer turned out to be more intense and directional with respect to that showed by wild boar. Although these results sound explorative, the experiment attempted here, for the first time, is relevant for an appropriate design of nocturnal distance-sampling surveys and gives information about potential bias arising from animal’s behavioural response. We believe that these first results may foster more in-deep analyses which are now made possible with the adoption of GPS technology for animal location.     

Temporal and spatial relationships in the movements of loch dwelling brown trout, Salmo trutta L., recorded by ultrasonic tracking for 24 hours

Ultrasonic telemetry was used to record simultaneously, over one complete April day, the movements of four adult brown trout, Salmo trutta , which were residents of a shallow Scottish loch. The daily movements were generally along linear tracks. The home ranges are described as standard and 95% confidence ellipses. The area of standard ellipses ranged from 330 to 633 m² while 95% confidence ellipses were larger, ranging from 513 to 979 m². The distances separating individuals, which ranged from 1 to 70 m, were greatest during peaks of activity. Although there was considerable spatial overlap of individual home ranges, the trout were not within visual range for most of the tracking period. Close encounters (proximity <2.5m) occurred most frequently and lasted longest at night. It is concluded, from this study, that brown trout in small productive lochs are solitary but may hold temporary station within widely overlapping home ranges.     

Can We Accurately Characterize Wildlife Resource Use When Telemetry Data Are Imprecise?

ABSTRACT Telemetry data have been widely used to quantify wildlife habitat relationships despite the fact that these data are inherently imprecise. All telemetry data have positional error, and failure to account for that error can lead to incorrect predictions of wildlife resource use. Several techniques have been used to account for positional error in wildlife studies. These techniques have been described in the literature, but their ability to accurately characterize wildlife resource use has never been tested. We evaluated the performance of techniques commonly used for incorporating telemetry error into studies of wildlife resource use. Our evaluation was based on imprecise telemetry data (mean telemetry error = 174 m, SD = 130 m) typical of field-based studies. We tested 5 techniques in 10 virtual environments and in one real-world environment for categorical (i.e., habitat types) and continuous (i.e., distances or elevations) rasters. Technique accuracy varied by patch size for the categorical rasters, with higher accuracy as patch size increased. At the smallest patch size (1 ha), the technique that ignores error performed best on categorical data (0.31 and 0.30 accuracy for virtual and real data, respectively); however, as patch size increased the bivariate-weighted technique performed better (0.56 accuracy at patch sizes >31 ha) and achieved complete accuracy (i.e., 1.00 accuracy) at smaller patch sizes (472 ha and 1,522 ha for virtual and real data, respectively) than any other technique. We quantified the accuracy of the continuous covariates using the mean absolute difference (MAD) in covariate value between true and estimated locations. We found that average MAD varied between 104 m (ignore telemetry error) and 140 m (rescale the covariate data) for our continuous covariate surfaces across virtual and real data sets. Techniques that rescale continuous covariate data or use a zonal mean on values within a telemetry error polygon were significantly less accurate than other techniques. Although the technique that ignored telemetry error performed best on categorical rasters with smaller average patch sizes (i.e., ≤31 ha) and on continuous rasters in our study, accuracy was so low that the utility of using point-based approaches for quantifying resource use is questionable when telemetry data are imprecise, particularly for small-patch habitat relationships.     

Implications of ignoring telemetry error on inference in wildlife resource use models

Global Positioning System (GPS) and very high frequency (VHF) telemetry data redefined the examination of wildlife resource use. Researchers collar animals, relocate those animals over time, and utilize the estimated locations to infer resource use and build predictive models. Precision of these estimated wildlife locations, however, influences the reliability of point-based models with accuracy depending on the interaction between mean telemetry error and how habitat characteristics are mapped (categorical raster resolution and patch size). Telemetry data often foster the assumption that locational error can be ignored without biasing study results. We evaluated the effects of mean telemetry error and categorical raster resolution on the correct characterization of patch use when locational error is ignored. We found that our ability to accurately attribute patch type to an estimated telemetry location improved nonlinearly as patch size increased and mean telemetry error decreased. Furthermore, the exact shape of these relationships was directly influenced by categorical raster resolution. Accuracy ranged from 100% (200-ha patch size, 1- to 5-m telemetry error) to 46% (0.5-ha patch size, 56- to 60-m telemetry error) for 10 m resolution rasters. Accuracy ranged from 99% (200-ha patch size, 1- to 5-m telemetry error) to 57% (0.5-ha patch size, 56- to 60-m telemetry error) for 30-m resolution rasters. When covariate rasters were less resolute (30 m vs. 10 m) estimates for the ignore technique were more accurate at smaller patch sizes. Hence, both fine resolution (10 m) covariate rasters and small patch sizes increased probability of patch misidentification. Our results help frame the scope of ecological inference made from point-based wildlife resource use models. For instance, to make ecological inferences with 90% accuracy at small patch sizes (≤5 ha) mean telemetry error ≤5 m is required for 10-m resolution categorical rasters. To achieve the same inference on 30-m resolution categorical rasters, mean telemetry error ≤10 m is required. We encourage wildlife professionals creating point-based models to assess whether reasonable estimates of resource use can be expected given their telemetry error, covariate raster resolution, and range of patch sizes. © 2011 The Wildlife Society.