Developing with lethal RA levels: genetic ablation of Rarg can restore the viability of mice lacking Cyp26a1

We have previously reported that the retinoic acid (RA) catabolizing enzyme CYP26A1 plays an important role in protecting tail bud tissues from inappropriate exposure to RA generated in the adjacent trunk tissues by RALDH2, and that Cyp26a1-null animals exhibit spina bifida and caudal agenesis. We now show that, in the absence of Cyp26a1, retinoic acid receptor gamma (RARgamma) mediates ectopic RA-signaling in the tail bud. We also show that activated RARgamma results in downregulation of Wnt3a and Fgf8, which integrate highly conserved signaling pathways known for their role in specifying caudal morphogenesis. Ablation of the gene for RARgamma (Rarg) rescues Cyp26a1-null mutant animals from caudal regression and embryonic lethality, thus demonstrating that CYP26A1 suppresses the RA-mediated downregulation of WNT3A and FGF8 signaling pathways by eliminating ectopic RA in gastrulating tail bud mesoderm.     

Analysis of the origins and early fates of neural crest cells in caudal regions of avian embryos

Holmdahl divided vertebrate embryogenesis into two phases called primary and secondary body development. Three primary germ layers are delineated during primary body development and undergo morphogenesis to form primary organ rudiments. In contrast, during secondary body development, the tail bud (a mesenchymal mass of cells located at the caudal end of the embryo and derived principally from Hensen's node) directly forms secondary organ rudiments. We have been testing Holmdahl's concept of primary and secondary body development by mapping the embryonic structures that originate from the tail bud. In the present study, we examined the origins of neural crest cells in caudal regions of avian embryos and observed two populations: primary neural crest cells derived from ectoderm and secondary neural crest cells derived from tail bud. Both types of neural crest cells originate locally, and little or no displacement of these cells occurs along the longitudinal axis. Some secondary neural crest cells seem to colonize the surface epithelium, forming a mosaic derived from both ectoderm and tail bud. Other secondary neural crest cells form spinal ganglia, differentiating as sensory neurons, satellite cells, and Schwann cells. Despite their strikingly different origins and locations, primary and secondary neural crest cells give rise to similar structures.     

Engrailed defines the position of dorsal di-mesencephalic boundary by repressing diencephalic fate.

Regionalization of a simple neural tube is a fundamental event during the development of central nervous system. To analyze in vivo the molecular mechanisms underlying the development of mesencephalon, we ectopically expressed Engrailed, which is expressed in developing mesencephalon, in the brain of chick embryos by in ovo electroporation. Misexpression of Engrailed caused a rostral shift of the di-mesencephalic boundary, and caused transformation of dorsal diencephalon into tectum, a derivative of dorsal mesencephalon. Ectopic Engrailed rapidly repressed Pax-6, a marker for diencephalon, which preceded the induction of mesencephalon-related genes such as Pax-2, Pax-5, Fgf8, Wnt-1 and EphrinA2. In contrast, a mutant Engrailed, En-2(F51rE), bearing mutation in EH1 domain, which has been shown to interact with a co-repressor, Groucho, did not show the phenotype induced by wild-type Engrailed. Furthermore, VP16-Engrailed chimeric protein, the dominant positive form of Engrailed, caused caudal shift of di-mesencephalic boundary and ectopic Pax-6 expression in mesencephalon. These data suggest that (1) Engrailed defines the position of dorsal di-mesencephalic boundary by directly repressing diencephalic fate, and (2) Engrailed positively regulates the expression of mesencephalon-related genes by repressing the expression of their negative regulator(s).     

Direct effects of retinoic acid on the development of the tail bud in chick embryos

Retinoic acid (RA) has been reported to induce vascular lesions and haematoma formation in the vicinity of the tail bud during the critical period for inducing abnormalities of tail bud development in hamsters (Wiley, '83; Tibbles and Wiley, '88), mice (Tibbles and Wiley, '88) and chicken embryos (Jelinek and Kistler, '81). Experiments were conducted to determine whether or not these vascular lesions were the primary cause of the malformations which they accompanied. Chick embryos were exposed for varying lengths of time to several dosages of RA. Primitive streaks or tail buds from treated embryos were then excised prior to vascularization and transplanted to the coelomic walls of untreated host embryos. The grafts were harvested at 3 or 6 days after grafting and processed for histological examination. Observations of serial sections of controls showed that the primitive streak and early (stage 13-14) tail bud were able to form neural tubes and a variety of other structures including ganglia, nerve fibres, and kidney tubules. Treatment of donor embryos with RA prior to grafting, however, affected the frequency and characteristics of the neural tubes and other tissues developing in the grafts. The effects of RA on development were correlated with both the dosage and length of exposure to the teratogen prior to grafting. Since the grafts were made before the appearance of blood vessels in the tail buds, we have concluded that the effects of RA on the development of tail bud tissues, and especially the secondary neural tube, are direct and are not mediated solely through the disruptive effects of vascular lesions seen in intact embryos.     

A Novel Gain-Of-Function Mutation of the Proneural IRX1 and IRX2 Genes Disrupts Axis Elongation in the Araucana Rumpless Chicken

Axis elongation of the vertebrate embryo involves the generation of cell lineages from posterior progenitor populations. We investigated the molecular mechanism governing axis elongation in vertebrates using the Araucana rumpless chicken. Araucana embryos exhibit a defect in axis elongation, failing to form the terminal somites and concomitant free caudal vertebrae, pygostyle, and associated tissues of the tail. Through whole genome sequencing of six Araucana we have identified a critical 130 kb region, containing two candidate causative SNPs. Both SNPs are proximal to the IRX1 and IRX2 genes, which are required for neural specification. We show that IRX1 and IRX2 are both misexpressed within the bipotential chordoneural hinge progenitor population of Araucana embryos. Expression analysis of BRA and TBX6, required for specification of mesoderm, shows that both are downregulated, whereas SOX2, required for neural patterning, is expressed in ectopic epithelial tissue. Finally, we show downregulation of genes required for the protection and maintenance of the tailbud progenitor population from the effects of retinoic acid. Our results support a model where the disruption in balance of mesoderm and neural fate results in early depletion of the progenitor population as excess neural tissue forms at the expense of mesoderm, leading to too few mesoderm cells to form the terminal somites. Together this cascade of events leads to axis truncation.     

A developmental pathway controlling outgrowth of the Xenopus tail bud

We have developed a new assay to identify factors promoting formation and outgrowth of the tail bud. A piece of animal cap filled with the test mRNAs is grafted into the posterior region of the neural plate of a host embryo. With this assay we show that expression of a constitutively active Notch (Notch ICD) in the posterior neural plate is sufficient to produce an ectopic tail consisting of neural tube and fin. The ectopic tails express the evenskipped homologue Xhox3, a marker for the distal tail tip. Xhox3 will also induce formation of an ectopic tail in our assay. We show that an antimorphic version of Xhox3, Xhox3VP16, will prevent tail formation by Notch ICD, showing that Xhox3 is downstream of Notch signalling. An inducible version of this reagent, Xhox3VP16GR, specifically blocks tail formation when induced in tailbud stage embryos, comfirming the importance of Xhox3 for tail bud outgrowth in normal development. Grafts containing Notch ICD will only form tails if placed in the posterior part of the neural plate. However, if Xwnt3a is also present in the grafts they can form tails at any anteroposterior level. Since Xwnt3a expression is localised appropriately in the posterior at the time of tail bud formation it is likely to be responsible for restricting tail forming competence to the posterior neural plate in our assay. Combined expression of Xwnt3a and active Notch in animal cap explants is sufficient to induce Xhox3, provoke elongation and form neural tubes. Conservation of gene expression in the tail bud of other vertebrates suggests that this pathway may describe a general mechanism controlling tail outgrowth and secondary neurulation.     

Effects of retinoic acid on chick tail bud development

The present study describes the teratogenic effects of retinoic acid (RA) on the development of the chick tail bud. Chick embryos were recovered 48 hours after treatment at HH stages 11 to 16 with various dosages of RA by subblastodermal injection. At the gross level, RA treatment resulted in varying degrees of caudal regression, scoliosis, limb malformations, and open posterior neuropores among the survivors. Histological examination of tail buds from treated embryos revealed defects which included total dysplasia of caudal structures, the presence of accessory neural tube and notochord tissue, and abnormal fusions of the notochord to the neural tube and tailgut. The incidence, severity, and location of the defects were dependent on the dose of the teratogen, and the stage of development at the time of treatment. The defects resembled those induced in previous studies by treatment with sialic acid binding lectins such as wheat germ agglutinin and limulus polyphemus lectin (Griffith and Wiley, '90b).     

Frizzled-4 expression during chick kidney development

Wnts have been implicated in metanephric kidney development. To determine whether Frizzleds, the genes that encode Wnt receptors, are present at early stages of nephrogenesis, we examined the expression of several recently identified Frizzled genes in the chick by in situ hybridization. Here we report the cloning and characterization of chick Frizzled-4 (cFz-4), which we found to be expressed in the developing chick kidney. cFz-4 was first expressed in the pronephros caudal to the third somite at Hamburger and Hamilton stage 10. Its expression increased with maturation, becoming restricted to the newly induced glomeruli and tubules in the mesonephros and metanephros. Within the metanephros, cFz-4 and Wnt-4 expression patterns were similar, whereas Wnt-11 was expressed solely in the tips of the branching ureteric bud. cFz-4 expression was compared with that of known kidney markers. It preceded that of Lmx-1, but was similarly restricted to developing glomeruli and tubules. In contrast, Pax-2 expression and Lim 1/2 antibody labeling occurred in intermediate mesoderm caudal to the fifth somite in the early pronephros, and each persisted in both the tubules and nephric ducts throughout further development.     

Localised axial progenitor cell populations in the avian tail bud are not committed to a posterior Hox identity

The outgrowth of the vertebrate tail is thought to involve the proliferation of regionalised stem/progenitor cell populations formed during gastrulation. To follow these populations over extended periods, we used cells from GFP-positive transgenic chick embryos as a source for donor tissue in grafting experiments. We determined that resident progenitor cell populations are localised in the chicken tail bud. One population, which is located in the chordoneural hinge (CNH), contributes descendants to the paraxial mesoderm, notochord and neural tube, and is serially transplantable between embryos. A second population of mesodermal progenitor cells is located in a separate dorsoposterior region of the tail bud, and a corresponding population is present in the mouse tail bud. Using heterotopic transplantations, we show that the fate of CNH cells depends on their environment within the tail bud. Furthermore, we show that the anteroposterior identity of tail bud progenitor cells can be reset by heterochronic transplantation to the node region of gastrula-stage chicken embryos.     

Discontinuity of primary and secondary neural tube in spina bifida induced by retinoic acid in mice

This report shows by light microscopy the appearance of secondary neurulation separated from primary neurulation and its developmental fate in the spinal cord of mice exposed to retinoic acid in utero. The embryos and fetuses were derived from pregnant mice (ICR strain) given 60, 40, or 0 mg/kg of retinoic acid in olive oil on day 8 of gestation orally and killed 1, 2, or 10 days later. Separation of the primary neural fold from the secondary neural tube was seen in 9- and 10-day-old embryos: the caudal part of the neuroepithelium of the primary neural fold was disarranged with non-closed posterior neuropore, and underneath it the secondary neural tissue extended caudally with abnormal notochord. At term, fetuses showed spina bifida, including myeloschisis, myelocele, and diplomyelia (diastematomyelia) with abnormal distribution of ganglionic cells. These cord lesions were located between the third lumbar and second coccygeal levels. The former two cord anomalies were associated with diplomyelia and split the dorsal and ventral portions of the spinal cord with an overlapping zone between the third lumbar and third sacral levels. These findings suggest that the separation from primary neurulation is due to the lesions in both primary neural folds and notochord induced by retinoic acid and that the spinal cord caudal to the third lumbar level originates from both neuroectoderm and mesenchyme-like cells while that caudal to the third sacral level originates from mesenchyme-like cells only.     

Growth differentiation factor 11 signaling controls retinoic acid activity for axial vertebral development

Mice deficient in growth differentiation factor 11 (GDF11) signaling display anterior transformation of axial vertebrae and truncation of caudal vertebrae. However, the in vivo molecular mechanisms by which GDF11 signaling regulates the development of the vertebral column have yet to be determined. We found that Gdf11 and Acvr2b mutants are sensitive to exogenous RA treatment on vertebral specification and caudal vertebral development. We show that diminished expression of Cyp26a1, a retinoic acid inactivating enzyme, and concomitant elevation of retinoic acid activity in the caudal region of Gdf11^−/− embryos may account for this phenomenon. Reduced expression or function of Cyp26a1 enhanced anterior transformation of axial vertebrae in wild-type and Acvr2b mutants. Furthermore, a pan retinoic acid receptor antagonist (AGN193109) could lessen the anterior transformation phenotype and rescue the tail truncation phenotype of Gdf11^−/− mice. Taken together, these results suggest that GDF11 signaling regulates development of caudal vertebrae and is involved in specification of axial vertebrae in part by maintaining Cyp26a1 expression, which represses retinoic acid activity in the caudal region of embryos during the somitogenesis stage.     

Retinoic acid induces changes in the localization of homeobox proteins in the antero-posterior axis of Xenopus laevis embryos.

We have studied the localization of the proteins of Xeb1 and Xeb2, two homeobox (hbx)-containing genes that are expressed during the early development of Xenopus laevis. Both proteins are expressed in juxtaposed and partially overlapping domains along the antero-posterior axis of Xenopus laevis embryos, with clearly defined anterior boundaries. Xeb2 is predominantly expressed in the caudal region of the hindbrain, whereas the Xeb1 protein is located in the most rostral region of the spinal cord. Furthermore, both proteins are expressed in single cells dispersed in the lateral flanks of the embryo in positions that correlate with the expression domains in the neural tube. We suggest that these cells are migratory neural crest cells that have acquired positional information in the neural tube prior to migration. The Xeb2 protein was also detected in the most posterior branchial arches and the pronephros. In stage 45 embryos, nuclei of the IX-X cranial ganglia, the lung buds and cells spreading into the forelimb rudiment express the Xeb2 antigen. The Xeb1 protein was also detected in the lung buds and the forelimb rudiment. To examine the effect of retinoic acid on expression, gastrula embryos were treated with all-trans retinoic acid (RA). Increasing concentrations of RA caused progressive truncation of anterior structures. The most severely affected embryos lacked eyes, nasal pits, forebrain, midbrain and otic vesicles, and the anterior boundary of the hindbrain seemed to be displaced rostrally. This alteration correlates with a progressive displacement of the anterior boundary of the expression domain of Xeb2. On the other hand, 10(-6) M RA induces an ectopic site of Xeb1 expression at the anterior end of the central nervous system, located just anterior to the extended domain of Xeb2 whereas expression in the spinal cord remains unaffected.     

Relationship between Wnt-1 and En-2 expression domains during early development of normal and ectopic met-mesencephalon.

Grafting a met-mesencephalic portion of neural tube from a 9.5-day mouse embryo into the prosencephalon of a 2-day chick embryo results in the induction of chick En-2 (ChickEn) expression in cells in contact with the graft (Martinez et al., 1991). In this paper we investigate the possibility of Wnt-1 being one of the factors involved in En-2 induction. Since Wnt-1 and En-2 expression patterns have been described as diverging during development of the met-mesencephalic region, we first compared Wnt-1 and En-2 expression in this domain by in situ hybridization in mouse embryos after embryonic day 8.5. A ring of Wnt-1-expressing cells is detected encircling the neural tube in the met-mesencephalic region at least until day 12.5. This ring consistently overlapped with the En-2 expression domain, and corresponds to the position of this latter gene's maximal expression. We subsequently studied ChickEn ectopic induction in chick embryos grafted with various portions of met-mesencephalon. When the graft originated from the level of the Wnt-1-positive ring, ChickEn induction was observed in 71% of embryos, and in these cases correlated with Wnt-1 expression in the grafted tissue. In contrast, this percentage dropped significantly when the graft was taken from more rostral or caudal parts of the mesencephalic vesicle. Taken together, these results are compatible with a prolonged role of Wnt-1 in the specification and/or development of the met-mesencephalic region, and show that Wnt-1 could be directly or indirectly involved in the regulation of En-2 expression around the Wnt-1-positive ring during this time. We also provide data on the position of the Wnt-1-positive ring relative to anatomical boundaries in the neural tube, which suggest a more general role for the Wnt-1 protein as a positional signal involved in organizing the met-mesencephalic domain.     

Sialoconjugates and development of the tail bud

Using lectin histochemistry, we have previously shown that there are alterations in the distribution of glycoconjugates in the tail bud of chick embryos that parallel the developmental sequence of the caudal axis. If glycoconjugates or the cells bearing them play a role in caudal axial development, then, restriction of their availability by binding with lectins would be expected to produce abnormalities of caudal development. In the present study, we treated embryos at various stages of tail bud development by microinjection with a variety of lectins. Administration of WGA by sub-blastodermal injection resulted in high incidences of secondary neural tube and notochordal abnormalities in lectin-treated embryos. The incidence of malformations was dependent upon both the dose of WGA received and the stage of development at the time of treatment. Using an anti-WGA antibody, we have also shown binding of the lectin in regions where defects were found. The lectin WGA binds to the sialic acid residues of glycoconjugates and to N-acetylglucosamine. Treatment of embryos with Limulus polyphemus lectin (LPL), which also binds to sialic acid, produced results similar to those of WGA. Treatments using lectins with other sugar-binding specificities, including succinylated WGA (with N-acetylglucosamine specificity only) produced defects that differed from those produced by WGA and LPL, and only with the administration of much higher doses. The results suggest that glycoconjugates in general and sialoconjugates in particular, or the cells carrying them, may have a role in caudal axial development.     

Effects of retinoic acid on the distribution of glycoconjugates during mouse tail bud development

Retinoic acid (RA), a potent teratogen of caudal axial development in rodents, has been shown to alter glycoconjugates in a variety of embryonic tissues and teratocarcinomas. In this study, we examined its effects on the expression of cell surface and extracellular matrix glycoconjugates during tail bud development in mouse embryos by using lectin histochemistry. The lectins WGA, sWGA, and PNA showed striking differences in binding between RA-exposed and control embryos. Computer-assisted densitometry revealed a significant increase in binding of all three lectins to the extracellular material of the luminal and abluminal borders of the secondary neural tube and surrounding the notochord in RA-exposed embryos. RA-treated embryos also showed an increased binding affinity for the lectins sWGA and PNA to the cells of the notochord, while WGA showed increased binding to the neuroepithelial cells of the secondary neural tube. The results suggest that RA affects the expression of lectin binding sites during the early development of RA-induced caudal axial defects.