Helper cells in the autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction. I. Generation of cytotoxic T cells recognizing modified self H-2

The autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction (AMLR) in mice measures the proliferative response of T cells to determinants on syngeneic non-T spleen cells. Normally, cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) are not generated in this reaction. However, the addition of trinitrophenyl-modified mitomycin C-treated syngeneic T cells (TNP-Tm) to the AMLR results in the generation of TNP-specific CTL but does not alter the proliferative response. Significant cytotoxic activity is not detectable against TNP in association with Ia unless TNP is present on cells bearing those determinants. Thus, if unselected spleen cells are TNP-modified and used as stimulators in the AMLR, the proliferative response is enhanced and CTL are generated that recognize TNP in association with K, D, and I region-encoded determinants. The CTL generated in the AMLR are H-2 restricted and dependent on the presence of adherent cells in the sensitization cultures. The experiments presented here suggest that the AMLR can provide the help necessary for generating cytotoxic T cells in vitro.     

Functional heterongeneity among the T-derived lymphocytes of the mouse. VI. Memory T cells stored in the T2 subpopulation.

Memory T cells were demonstrated in mice which were the precursors for cells causing sheep red blood cell-(SRBC) specific helper activity in the in vitro response of spleen cells to trinitrophenyl (TNP)-SRBC. These memory cells were distinguished from the effectors of helper activity generated during the primary response and were shown to belong to the T2 subpopulation of peripheral T cells on the basis of 1) their rapid response to a challenge with SRBC, 2) their long lifetime, and 3) their sensitivity to small in vivo doses of anti-thymocyte serum.     

Cellular interaction between cytotoxic and suppressor T cells against syngeneic tumors in the mouse.

Splenic T cells from animals bearing growing syngeneic tumors specifically inhibited the effector process of tumor cell lysis by the cytotoxic T cell which had been activated in vitro by mitomycin C treated homologous tumor. The suppression was strictly specific for the individual tumor by which suppressor cells were generated, whereas in some cases cytotoxic T cells generated by two closely related sarcomas showed a certain degree of crossreactivity. This suggests that suppressor and cytotoxic T cells recognize different antigenic moieties on tumor cells; one unique to the individual tumor and the other shared by related tumor cell lines.The suppressor T cell from tumor bearing animals possessed Ia antigen controlled by a gene in I-J subregion of H-2 major histocompatibility complex. Cytotoxic T cells generated by some but not all syngeneic tumors were also killed by anti-Ia and complement; however, the Ia antigen on such cytotoxic T cells was found to be controlled by a locus in I-A subregion. In general, the cytotoxic T cells generated by newly established tumor cell lines had Ia antigen, whereas some old cell lines, which were capable of growing across the H-2 barrier, activated the Ia negative cytotoxic T cell. These results collectively indicate that the immunological resistance against tumors is dependent on the balance of activations of the cytotoxic and suppressor T cells with different specificities and phenotypic expressions.     

Studies on the resistance to tolerance induction against human IgG in DDD mice. III. Development of the resistance with age and cellular events.

Three-week-old DDD mice were easily rendered tolerant to human IgG while 12-week-old mice were tolerized only partially. Mechanisms of the development of the resistance with age were investigated. It was shown by the cell transfer experiments that spleen T cells, purified on a Tetron wool column, from older mice were responsible for the resistance, which was not associated with the loss of suppressor cells with age. To elucidate the possibility of whether tolerogen-sensitive spleen T cells differentiate into resistant ones, cell transfer experiments were carried out in which thymectomized, lethally irradiated mice were reconstituted with spleen cells from 3-week-old mice and then treated with the tolerogen on various days afterward. The results indicated that tolerance was inducible in these hosts to the same degree, irrespective of the timing of the tolerogen injection, while age-matched intact mice gradually acquired the resistance. Then the possibility of whether age of thymus affected tolerance inducibility of the hosts or not was examined. The tolerogen was injected into irradiated, bone-marrow-reconstituted mice which bore either 4- or 7-week-old thymus. It was shown that helper T cells newly generated under younger thymus acquired higher susceptibility to the tolerogen. There was no difference in tolerance inducibility irrespective as to whether bone marrow cells were prepared from younger or older mice. From these observations it was suggested that the resistance to tolerance induction in DDD mice is acquired through the appearance of resistant T cells which are generated from T-cell precursors in bone marrow under the influence of a radioresistant thymic constitution and predominantly located in the spleen.     

Generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes in the autologous mixed lymphocyte culture.

We have studied the ability of purified B lymphocytes to generate cytotoxic T lymphocytes in autologous mixed leukocyte cultures (MLC). Cytotoxic lymphocytes were produced but only autologous mononuclear cells stimulated by lipopolysaccharide (LPS) were susceptible target cells. Unstimulated mononuclear cells and purified B cells were not susceptible to killing by cytotoxic cells generated in the autologous MLC. This suggests that the target antigen may be expressed on stimulated or dividing B lymphocytes in a way that renders the cells more susceptible to cytolysis. Autologously stimulated cytotoxic effector cells were found to exhibit specificity. Cy totoxicity for autologous LPS-stimulated target cells occurred but not for an allogeneic, B cell, histiocytic lymphoma cell line. It is postulated that cytotoxic T cells generated in the autologous MLC may play a role in immune surveillance or in regulation of the immune system.     

T lymphocyte-mediated suppression of myeloma function in vitro. I. Suppression by allogeneically activated T lymphocytes.

Alloreactive cells generated by in vitro stimulation of C57BL/6 (H-2b) spleen lymphocytes with irradiated MOPC 315 or MOPC 104E(H-2d) cells were shown to lyse 51Cr-labeled myeloma targets at high effector:target ratios under conditions of inefficient cell contact, the alloreactive cells cause variable and frequently minimal lysis of myeloma targets but markedly suppress antibody secretion even by viable myeloma cells. The suppressor cells are radioresistant T cells lacking I-J subregion-encoded surface determinants; their precursors are insensitive to cyclophosphamide; suppression is H-2 specific and not mediated by secreted factors; and the suppression is blocked by Cytochalasin B, a known inhibitor of T cell-mediated cytolysis. These properties are typical of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) and not of defined suppressor T cells, suggesting that inhibition of myeloma function probably represents a pre-lytic effect of the alloreactive CTL, although a CTL-like suppressor cell effect cannot be definitively excluded. These results are discussed with reference to the possible relationships between suppressor and cytolytic T lymphocytes.     

Comparison of the capacity of murine and human class I MHC molecules to stimulate T cell activation.

The mechanism underlying the apparent differences in the capacity of murine and human class I MHC molecules to function as signal transducing structures in T cells was examined. Cross-linking murine class I MHC molecules on splenic T cells did not stimulate an increase in intracellular calcium ([Ca2+]i) and failed to induce proliferation in the presence of IL-2 or PMA. In contrast, modest proliferation was induced by cross-linking class I MHC molecules on murine peripheral blood T cells or human class I MHC molecules on murine transgenic spleen cells, but only when costimulated with PMA. Moreover, cross-linking murine class I MHC molecules or the human HLA-B27 molecule on T cell lines generated from transgenic murine splenic T cells stimulated only modest proliferation in the presence of PMA, but not IL-2. On the other hand, cross-linking murine class I MHC molecules expressed by the human T cell leukemic line, Jurkat, transfected with genes for these molecules, generated a prompt increase in [Ca2+]i, and stimulated IL-2 production in the presence of PMA. The results demonstrate that both murine and human class I MHC molecules have the capacity to function as signal transducing structures, but that murine T cells are much less responsive to this signal.     

Generation of specific helper cells and suppressor cells in vitro for the IgE and IgG antibody responses.

Normal splenic lymphocytes from BDF1 mice were cultured on ovalbumin (OA)-bearing syngeneic peritoneal adherent cells for 5 days and their subsequent helper function was tested by an adoptive transfer technique. Lymphocytes harvested from the culture were mixed with DNP-KLH-primed spleen cells and transferred into irradiated syngeneic mice followed by challenge with DNP-OA. The results showed that the cultured lymphocytes has helper function for both IgE and IgG anti-DNP antibody responses. Depletion of mast cells and T cells in the peritoneal adherent cell preparations did not affect the generation of helper cells in the culture. The helper function of the cultured lymphocytes was abolished by the treatment with anti-theta antiserum and complement and was specific for ovalbumin. The OA-specific helper T cells were generated in vitro by the culture of a T cell-rich fraction of normal spleen on T cell-depleted OA-bearing peritoneal cells. If the normal splenic lymphocytes or T cell-rich fraction were cultured with 10 mug/ml of OA in the absence of macrophages, cultured lymphocytes lacked helper function. The transfer of splenic lymphocytes or splenic T cells cultured with soluble OA to normal non-irradiated mice, however, suppressed both IgG and IgE antibody responses of the recipients to subsequent immunization with DNP-OA. The suppressor cells were sensitive to anti-theta antiserum and complement and their activity was specific for OA. The cultured cells transferred into normal mice did not suppress anti-hapten antibody response to DNP-KLH. Normal lymphocytes cultured on OA-bearing macrophages and had helper function in adoptive transfer experiments failed to suppress antibody response of non-irradiated recipients to DNP-OA. The results indicate that OA-bearing macrophages primed T cells and generated helper T cells, whereas the culture of normal lymphocytes with soluble OA in the absence of macrophages generated suppressor T cells.     

Vaccinia virus-specific CD8+ cytotoxic T lymphocytes in humans.

Stimulation of human vaccinia virus immune peripheral blood mononuclear cells in vitro from vaccinia virus-immune donors with live vaccinia virus-infected autologous cells generated vaccinia virus-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) capable of lysing vaccinia virus-infected cells. We generated vaccinia virus-specific CD8+ clones and CD4+ CTL lines by limiting dilution from two donors by using peripheral blood mononuclear cells obtained 2 months or 4 years postrevaccination with vaccinia virus. These results demonstrate that vaccinia virus-specific CTL are generated as a result of immunization of humans with vaccinia virus and that both CD8(+)- and CD4(+)-specific T cells are maintained as memory cells.     

Induction of plasma cell differentiation of human fetal lymphocytes: evidence for functional immaturity of T and B cells.

Resembling the in vitro antibody response of the newborn cultures of cord blood lymphocytes stimulated with pokeweed mitogen (PWM) generated fewer plasma cells (PC) than comparable adult lymphocyte cultures and the response was almost exclusively of the IgM class. We investigated the cellular basis of this difference by preparing mixed cultures of newborn T or B lymphocytes with adult B or T cells. Substitution of adult for newborn T cells enhanced the response of newborn B cells, particularly of the IgG and IgA classes. The response of second trimester fetal spleen cells was also increased by adult T cells, although no IgA PC appeared. Conversely, adult B cells generated fewer PC particularly of the IgG and IgA classes when cultured with newborn T cells. The relatively poor IgA and IgG responses of newborn cells seems partially but not entirely due to deficiency of T cell helper function. Suppressor activity of newborn T cells was investigated by adding excess unrelated newborn or adult T cells to adult T + B cells: adult T cells improved the response whereas newborn T cells were variably suppressive. The results indicate that newborn T cells, although capable of helper function, are balanced toward suppression.     

Involvement of two distinct regulatory T cell populations in the antigen-specific suppression of cytolytic T cell generation.

Alloantigen-specific, radiation-resistant T cells generated in mixed-lymphocyte cultures inhibited the generation of allospecific CTL responses in vitro. This regulatory T cell population was studied using mAb generated to Ag-specific suppressor factors that regulate the response to the synthetic terpolymer L-glutamic acid60-L-alanine30-L-tyrosine10 (GAT). Both monoclonal 984 D4.6.5 and a pool of four mAb 2441, when added in the presence of complement, eliminated alloantigen-specific inhibition of the CTL response. When separate cell cultures treated with mAb 984 or 2441 plus complement were recombined, inhibition was reestablished, suggesting that two or more populations of cells are required for active inhibition. Furthermore, neither the mAb 984 nor the mAb 2441 plus complement had any effect on any stage of CTL development. This suggests that the inhibition of the CTL response was not the result of cytolytic activity via the regulatory T cells. Experiments in which these antibodies were added without complement treatment showed that the mAb 2441 neutralized the inhibitory activity, whereas mAb 984 augmented inhibition. It is concluded from these studies that regulatory T cells originally identified in humoral immune responses also regulate cell-mediated immune responses. Suppressor epitopes are displayed on the surface of these cells that allow them to be distinguished from other T cells. These data also show the utility of the mAb 984 and 2441 raised against specific suppressor T cell products in different experimental models of immunity. These studies suggest that phenotypically distinct Ts cell populations can play a normal regulatory role in both cell-mediated and humoral immunity.     

Tumor-specific idiotype vaccines. III. Induction of T helper cells by anti-idiotype and tumor cells

In a previous report, we have demonstrated the induction of tumor-specific immunity by monoclonal anti-idiotype antibodies generated against a monoclonal anti-tumor antibody, 11C1, that also cross-reacts with mouse mammary tumor virus envelope glycoprotein gp52. Also, we showed that whereas one anti-idiotype antibody, 2F10, could induce protective immunity, another anti-idiotype antibody, 3A4, induced nonprotective immunity. Here we demonstrated the existence of T helper cells which recognize anti-idiotypes that exert differential controls on tumor growth. The qualitative nature of idiotype recognizing T cells generated in response to 2F10, 3A4, irradiated tumor, and progressively growing tumor was compared. The reactivity pattern of idiotype recognizing T cells obtained from 2F10 and irradiated tumor immunized mice were similar in nature in the sense that Lyt-2- T cells obtained from these immunized mice responded to both 2F10 and 3A4 as antigen, although T cells from tumor immunized mice responded better to 3A4 antigen. On the other hand, the idiotype-recognizing T cells obtained from 3A4-immunized mice showed a similar reactivity pattern to T cells isolated from mice during the early phase of tumor growth (within day 4 to 5 after the inoculation of 10(4) live tumor cells). Lyt-2- T cells isolated from mice immunized with 3A4 or during the early phase of tumor growth responded only to 3A4 antigen. The inability of Lyt-2- T cells, isolated from 4- to 5-day-old tumor in mice, to cooperate with 2F10-TNP is not due to the absence of 2F10 idiotype recognizing T cells as 2F10 id recognizing T cells are present when examined at the precursor level. These data on the idiotype specificity of T helper cells show a correlation with the presence of anti-tumor immunity. This information will help in the design and application of idiotype vaccine in tumor immunotherapy.     

Role of endogenous peptides in murine allogenic cytotoxic T cell responses assessed using transfectants of the antigen-processing mutant 174xCEM.T2.

One model to explain the high frequency of alloreactive T cells proposes that allogeneic MHC molecules are recognized together with host cell-derived peptides. A model system was developed to investigate the relevance of this mechanism by expression of H-2Dd or H-2Ld in 174xCEM.T2 (T2) cells. This human cell line contains a mutation in its Ag-processing pathway that should restrict the association of endogenous peptides with cell surface class I molecules. CTL generated by stimulating C57BL/6 (H-2b) responder cells with H-2Dd or H-2Ld transfectants of the human B cell line C1R or the murine T cell lymphoma EL4 were assayed for their ability to recognize alloantigenic determinants on these transfectants. The major fraction of the H-2Dd-specific allogeneic CTL response, generated in a MLC or under clonal limiting dilution conditions, was composed of T cells that recognized H-2Dd expressed on C1R or EL4 cells, but failed to recognize this molecule on T2 cells. Clonal analysis indicated that approximately one-third of these CTL recognized determinants that were unique to H-2Dd expressed on C1R stimulator cells whereas the remainder recognized determinants that were also found on EL4 transfectants. Less than 10% of H-2Dd-reactive CTL recognized the T2 transfectant, and these clones also killed C1R-Dd and EL4-Dd. This result suggests that the great majority of H-2Dd-specific alloreactive CTL recognize determinants that are formed by a complex of H-2Dd with endogenous peptides that are absent or significantly reduced in T2 cells. Based on recognition of human or murine transfectants, these CTL exhibit some level of specificity for the structure or composition of the bound peptides. Examination of allogeneic CTL specific for H-2Ld revealed populations similar to those described for H-2Dd. In addition, a major new population was present that recognized determinants shared between C1R-Ld and T2-Ld but not present on EL4-Ld. These results are consistent with the idea that the alloreactive response to H-2Ld is also largely dependent on the presence of bound peptide. However, they also may indicate that the H-2Ld molecule expressed on T2 cells is occupied by one or more peptides that are shared with other human, but not murine, cells. The significance of these results to current models of alloreactivity is discussed.     

T cells in B cell chronic lymphocytic leukemia. II. Lack of antigen-specific T suppressor cells and their progenitors

Nylon wool-purified T cells (Tn) of two patients with chronic lymphocytic leukemia of the B cell type were phenotyped and tested in various assays for antigen-specific T helper (Th), T suppressor effector (Tse), T suppressor precursor (Tsp), and T suppressor inducer (Tsi) function. Antigen-specific Th as well as Tsi activity could be effectively generated. Although phenotypically CD8+ T cells, carrying the receptor for the Fc part of IgG, were present in mononuclear blood cells and Tn fractions, no antigen-specific Tse cell activity could be induced. In addition, Tsp cells were found to be functionally absent. These findings are discussed in relation to a tumor-induced limited heterogeneity within the T suppressor (Ts) cell compartment.     

In vitro T cell-mediated killing of Pseudomonas aeruginosa. V. Generation of bactericidal T cells in nonresponder mice

We have previously reported that BALB/c mice immunized with 10 micrograms of a Pseudomonas aeruginosa polysaccharide antigen (PS) and 100 micrograms vinblastine sulfate develop T cell-mediated protective immunity, but fail to generate an antibody response. Vinblastine functions in this system to remove a suppressor cell that normally inhibits expression of this form of immunity after PS immunization. T cells from CB.20 mice immunized with the 10 micrograms of PS and 100 micrograms vinblastine fail to kill P. aeruginosa in vitro. These mice are allotype congenic with BALB/c mice, differing at loci closely linked to the IgH-1 locus. Immunization of CB.20 mice with 10 micrograms PS and 100 micrograms vinblastine results in the appearance of T cells which suppress in vitro bactericidal activity of BALB/c T cells. In the current study we found that T cell-mediated bactericidal activity can be generated in CB.20 mice by increasing the dose of vinblastine given at the time of PS immunization. The phenotype of the CB.20 bactericidal T cell generated by high dose vinblastine is identical to that of the BALB/c bactericidal T cell, and the CB.20 bactericidal T cell can adoptively transfer protective immunity to granulocytopenic mice. After immunization of BALB/c and CB.20 mice with PS alone, approximately one log fewer CB.20 T cells than BALB/c T cells are required to suppress bacterial killing in vitro. Furthermore, the number of CB.20 T cells required to suppress in vitro bacterial killing is directly correlated with the dose of vinblastine administered at the time of immunization. Increasing the immunizing dose of PS overcomes suppressor activity and allows the generation of bactericidal T cells in BALB/c mice without a requirement for vinblastine. CB.20 mice fail to generate bactericidal T cells after immunization with high doses of PS. These results indicate that CB.20 and BALB/c mice both possess the full repertoire of T cells required to express bactericidal T cell activity and that the differences in their responses reflect only quantitative differences in suppressor cell activity.     

Effects of in vivo priming on in vitro induction of cytotoxicity. I. Non-specific augmentation by in vivo presensitization with allogeneic or xenogeneic cells.

In vivo presensitization of donor mice of responding cells with third party cellular antigens augmented in vitro generation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes in allogeneic and xenogeneic combinations. In vitro induction of detectable cytotoxicity in presensitized responding cells required the incubation period needed for in vitro primary response. However, such cytotoxic T lymphocytes were generated after in vitro stimulation with monolayers of methylcholanthrene-induced tumor cells, UV-irradiated or heated spleen cells which had proved to be effective in secondary but not in primary response. Presensitized responding cells exposed to 600R-irradiation did not augment in vitro induction of cytotoxicity in normal responding cells. The augmenting effect of presensitized responding cells may be attributable to radiosensitive T cells which are in a transitional state in differentiation from typical unprimed cells to typical primed cells.     

"Physiological interaction" does not explain the H-2 requirement for recognition of virus-infected cells by cytotoxic T cells.

B10.A (H-2Kk, H-2Dd) ectromelia-immune T cells from secondary responses in vitro were protent killers of both infected L929 (H-2Kk H-2Dk) and infected P-815 (H-2Kd, H-2Db) target cells. Specific competition with unlabelled targets showed that two separate T cell subsets were responsible for lysis of infected L929 and infected P-815 cells. One hypothesis to account for this (a form of "physiological interaction") is that T cells which kill one target e.g. infected L929) display only one out of two possible self-complementary recognition structures, in this example the H-2Kk alloantigen, not H-2Dd, whereas T cells that lyse infected P-815 targets display only H-2Dd, not H-2Kk. This hypothesis was tested and seems untenable because of the following results: A.TH (H-2Ks, H-2Dd) ectromelia-immune, secondary cytotoxic T cells which killed infected SJL/J (H-2Ks, H-2Ds) targets were themselves inactivated by pre-incubation with SJL/J cytotoxic T cells generated in one-way mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) against BALB/c (H-2Kd, H-2Dd). A.TL (H-2Ks, H-2Dd) ectromelia-immune secondary cytotoxic T cells which killed infected BALB/c targets were themselves inactivated by BALB/c cytotoxic T cells generated in MLR against SJL/J. Thus, virus-immune T cells which lyse infected targets by virtue of shared H-2K are also displaying H-2D alloantigen, and vice versa.     

Generation of immune memory by haptenated derivatives of thymus-independent antigens in C57BL/6 mice. I. The differentiation of memory B lymphocytes into antibody-secreting cells depends on the nature of the thymus-independent carrier used for memory induction and/or revelation

It has been previously reported that trinitrophenylated lipopolysaccharide (TNP-LPS), a thymus-independent (TI)-1 antigen, elicits an anamnestic response to TNP in C57BL/6 mice. The ability of these mice to mount a secondary response to TI-2 antigens was analyzed. Priming with DNP-Ficoll or DNP-Dextran, both TI-2 antigens, resulted in an increased frequency of TNP-binding B lymphocytes. Evidence is presented that memory cell-induction by DNP-Ficoll does not require functional T cells. The differentiation into antibody-forming cells (AFC) of memory cells generated by DNP-Dextran or DNP-Ficoll cannot be obtained by a challenge with either antigen. There was no indication that the lack of a secondary response to TI-2 antigens was related to suppressive T cells interfering with memory expression. Memory cells induced by DNP-Dextran or DNP-Ficoll can nevertheless be activated by TNP-LPS. In contrast to the restricted sensitivity of TNP-memory cells generated by TI-2 antigens, TNP-LPS-induced memory cells are indifferently susceptible to TI-1 or TI-2 antigenic stimulation. These results are discussed in terms of memory B-cell subpopulations.     

In vivo generation of pathogen-specific Th1 cells in the absence of the IFN-gamma receptor

The precise mechanisms that govern the commitment of CD4 T cells to become Th1 or Th2 cells in vivo are incompletely understood. Recent experiments demonstrate colocalization of the IFN-gammaR chains with the TCR during activation of naive CD4 T cells, suggesting that association of these molecules may be involved in determining lineage commitment. To test the role of IFN-gamma and its receptor in the generation of Th1 Ag-specific CD4 T cells, we analyzed mice after infection with Listeria monocytogenes or lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus. In the absence of IFN-gamma, Ag-specific CD4 T cells were generated in response to both these infections. In addition, IFN-gamma-producing (Th1) Ag-specific CD4 T cells were generated in mice lacking the ligand-binding chain of the IFN-gammaR (IFN-gammaR1-/-) or the signaling chain (IFN-gammaR2-/-). There was no increase in the number of IL-4-producing Ag-specific CD4 T cells, nor was there a decrease in the expression of T-bet in the absence of functional IFN-gamma signaling, indicating that the cells were committed Th1 cells. Thus, both chains of the IFN-gammaR are dispensable for the generation of Th1 Ag-specific CD4 T cells after infection in vivo.