Dosimetric evaluation of image based brachytherapy using tandem ovoid and tandem ring applicators

Aim

The aim of the study is to evaluate the differences in dosimetry between tandem-ovoid and tandem-ring gynaecologic brachytherapy applicators in image based brachytherapy.

Dosimetric characterization of 3D printed bolus at different infill percentage for external photon beam radiotherapy

Background and purpose3D printing is rapidly evolving and further assessment of materials and technique is required for clinical applications. We evaluated 3D printed boluses with acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS) and polylactide (PLA) at different infill percentage.Material and methodsA low-cost 3D printer was used. The influence of the air inclusion within the 3D printed boluses was assessed thoroughly both with treatment planning system (TPS) and with physical measurements. For each bolus, two treatment plans were calculated with Monte Carlo algorithm, considering the computed tomography (CT) scan of the 3D printed bolus or modelling the 3D printed bolus as a virtual bolus structure with a homogeneous density. Depth dose measurements were performed with Gafchromic films.ResultsHigh infill percentage corresponds to high density and high homogeneity within bolus material. The approximation of the bolus in the TPS as a homogeneous material is satisfying for infill percentages greater than 20%. Measurements performed with PLA boluses are more comparable to the TPS calculated profiles. For boluses printed at 40% and 60% infill, the discrepancies between calculated and measured dose distribution are within 5%.Conclusions3D printing technology allows modulating the shift of the build-up region by tuning the infill percentage of the 3D printed bolus in order to improve superficial target coverage.     

Dosimetric characterization of INTRABEAM® miniature accelerator flat and surface applicators for dermatologic applications

PurposeThis study aims at characterizing the dosimetric behavior of an INTRABEAM^® miniature accelerator equipped with flat and surface applicators, converting the spherical dose distribution into a flat one.MethodsDosimetric characterization was carried out in two steps. Firstly characterization was made in standard conditions for dermatologic applications, which is with the applicator directly on contact with the skin. Secondly, characterization was made in more clinical conditions, such as obliquities and heterogeneities.ResultsBehaviors of flat and surface applicators are different. Dose distribution for surface applicators is uniform at surface, whereas for flat applicator the maximum homogeneity is shown at a particular depth in water. Some results are different from previously published studies due to differences in the X-ray source design. The study showed that in the absence of a perfect contact between the applicator and the skin of the patient, there is a dose distribution spread on the edge of the irradiation field where the contact is not made. Dose loss due to lack of backscatter radiations is significant. By contrast, influence of a denser material behind the measurement point has no significant influence on the dose at this point. Thickness of tissue treated with flat and surface applicators is only a few millimeters, depending on the applicator's size, making these applicators ideal for superficial lesions, compared to high energy electrons and iridium brachytherapy.ConclusionsThe INTRABEAM^® miniature accelerator equipped with surface applicators is a reliable way of treating superficial cutaneous malignancies.     

Radiological properties of 3D printed materials in kilovoltage and megavoltage photon beams

PurposeThis study evaluates the radiological properties of different 3D printing materials for a range of photon energies, including kV and MV CT imaging and MV radiotherapy beams.MethodsThe CT values of a number of materials were measured on an Aquilion One CT scanner at 80 kVp, 120 kVp and a Tomotherapy Hi Art MVCT imaging beam. Attenuation of the materials in a 6 MV radiotherapy beam was investigated.ResultsPlastic filaments printed with various infill densities have CT values of −743 ± 4, −580 ± 1 and −113 ± 3 in 120 kVp CT images which approximate the CT values of low-density lung, high-density lung and soft tissue respectively. Metal-infused plastic filaments printed with a 90% infill density have CT values of 658 ± 1 and 739 ± 6 in MVCT images which approximate the attenuation of cortical bone. The effective relative electron density RED_eff is used to describe the attenuation of a megavoltage treatment beam, taking into account effects relating to the atomic number and mass density of the material. Plastic filaments printed with a 90% infill density have RED_eff values of 1.02 ± 0.03 and 0.94 ± 0.02 which approximate the relative electron density RED of soft tissue. Printed resins have RED_eff values of 1.11 ± 0.03 and 1.09 ± 0.03 which approximate the RED of bone mineral.Conclusions3D printers can model a variety of body tissues which can be used to create phantoms useful for both imaging and dosimetric studies.     

End-to-end dosimetric audit: A novel procedure developed for Irish HDR brachytherapy centres

PurposeA dosimetric audit of Ir-192 high dose rate (HDR) brachytherapy remote after-loading units was carried out in 2019. All six brachytherapy departments on the island of Ireland participated in an end-to-end test and in a review of local HDR dosimetry procedures.Materials and methodsA 3D-printed customised phantom was created to position the following detectors at known distances from the HDR source: a Farmer ionization chamber, GafChromic film and thermoluminescent dosimeters (TLDs). Dedicated HDR applicator needles were used to position an Ir-192 source at 2 cm distance from these detectors. The end-to-end dosimetry audit pathway was performed at each host site and included the stages of imaging, applicator reconstruction, treatment planning and delivery. Deviations between planned and measured dose distributions were quantified using gamma analysis methods. Local procedures were also discussed between auditors and hosts.ResultsThe mean difference between Reference Air Kerma Rate (RAKR) measured during the audit and RAKR specified by the vendor source certificate was 1.3%. The results of end-to-end tests showed a mean difference between calculated and measured dose of 2.5% with TLDs and less than 0.5% with Farmer chamber measurements. GafChromic films showed a mean gamma passing rates of >95% for plastic and metal applicators with 2%/1 mm global tolerance criteria.ConclusionsThe results of this audit indicate dosimetric consistency between centres. The ‘end to end’ dosimetry audit methodology for HDR brachytherapy has been successfully implemented in a multicentre environment, which included different models of Ir-192 sources and different treatment planning systems.The ability to create a 3D-printed water-equivalent phantom customised to accurately position all three detector types simultaneously at controlled distances from the Ir-192 source under evaluation gives good reproducibility for end-to-end methodology.     

Application of Monte Carlo calculations for validation of a treatment planning system in high dose rate brachytherapy

AimThe accuracy of treatment planning systems is of vital importance in treatment outcomes in brachytherapy. In the current study the accuracy of dose calculations of a high dose rate (HDR) brachytherapy treatment planning system (TPS) was validated using the Monte Carlo method.Materials and methodsThree ⁶⁰Co sources of the GZP6 afterloading brachytherapy system were modelled using MCNP4C Monte Carlo (MC) code. The dose distribution around all the sources was calculated by MC and a dedicated treatment planning system. The results of both methods were compared.ResultsThere was good agreement (<2%) between TPS and MC calculated dose distributions except at a point near the sources (<1 cm) and beyond the tip of the sources.ConclusionsOur study confirmed the accuracy of TPS calculated dose distributions for clinical use in HDR brachytherapy.     

Characterization of irregular electron beam for boost dose after whole breast irradiation

Irradiating a tumor bed with boost dose after whole breast irradiation helps reducing the probability of local recurrence. However, the success of electron beam treatment with a small area aiming to cover a superficial lesion is a dual challenge as it requires an adequate dosimetry beside a double check for dose coverage with an estimation of various combined uncertainty of tumor location and losing lateral electron equilibrium within small field dimensions.Aim of workthis work aims to measure the electron beam fluence within different field dimensions and the deviation from measurement performed in standard square electron applicator beam flatness and symmetry, then to calculate the average range of the correction factor required to overcome the loss of lateral electron equilibrium.Material and methodthe electron beam used in this work generated from the linear accelerator model ELEKTA Precise and dosimetry system used were a pair of PTW Pin Point ion chambers for electron beam dosimetry at standard conditions and assessment of beam quality at a reference depth of measurement, with an automatic water phantom, then a Roos ion chamber was used for absolute dose measurement, and PTW 2Darray to investigate the beam fluence of four applicators 6, 10, 14 and 20 cm² and 4 rectangular cutouts 6 × 14, 8 × 14, 6 × 17 and 8 × 17 cm², the second part was clinical application which was performed in a precise treatment planning system and examined boost dose after whole breast irradiation.Resultsrevealed that lower energy (6MeV and 8MeV) showed the loss of lateral electron equilibrium and deviation from measurements of a standard applicator more than the high energy (15 MeV) which indicated that the treatment of superficial dose with 6MeV required higher monitor unit to allow for the loss of lateral electron equilibrium and higher margin as well.     

Clinical application of MOSkin dosimeters to rectal wall in vivo dosimetry in gynecological HDR brachytherapy

PurposeThree MOSkins dosimeters were assembled over a rectal probe and used to perform in vivo dosimetry during HDR brachytherapy treatments of vaginal cancer. The purpose of this study was to verify the applicability of the developed tool to evaluate discrepancies between planned and measured doses to the rectal wall.Materials and methodsMOSkin dosimeters from the Centre for Medical Radiation Physics are particularly suitable for brachytherapy procedures for their ability to be easily incorporated into treatment instrumentation. In this study, 26 treatment sessions of HDR vaginal brachytherapy were monitored using three MOSkin mounted on a rectal probe. A total of 78 measurements were collected and compared to doses determined by the treatment planning system.ResultsMean dose discrepancy was determined as 2.2 ± 6.9%, with 44.6% of the measurements within ±5%, 89.2% within ±10% and 10.8% higher than ±10%. When dose discrepancies were grouped according to the time elapsed between imaging and treatment (i.e., group 1: ≤90 min; group 2: >90 min), mean discrepancies resulted in 4.7 ± 3.6% and 7.1 ± 5.0% for groups 1 and 2, respectively. Furthermore, the position of the dosimeter on the rectal catheter was found to affect uncertainty, where highest uncertainties were observed for the dosimeter furthest inside the rectum.ConclusionsThis study has verified MOSkin applicability to in-patient dose monitoring in gynecological brachytherapy procedures, demonstrating the dosimetric rectal probe setup as an accurate and convenient IVD instrument for rectal wall dose verification. Furthermore, the study demonstrates that the delivered dose discrepancy may be affected by the duration of treatment planning.     

Influence of different Fletcher–Suit applicator geometries on sagittal dose distribution

IntroductionOne of the brachytherapy treatment modality of cervix carcinomas is insertion with Fletcher–Suit (FS) applicator. Depending on the patient anatomy and pathology and on the construction of the FS applicator different geometrical arrangements in ovoid separation, in ovoids' sagittal level with respect to the tandem were experienced. The multiple insertions show minor differences in applicator geometries. The aim of the study is to evaluate the influence of main geometrical parameters: the ovoid separation, symmetry and the ovoids' sagittal shift on dose distribution in different FS applicator arrangements. We tested the effect of dwell time settings in improvement of dose distribution of less adequate insertions. We also investigated the effect of inter-fractional variation of applicator geometry.Materials and methodsWe considered 73 treatment fractions of 22 patients. All insertions were performed by the same gynaecologist with the same type of FS applicator, while the treatment plans were generated by the same physicist using the same treatment planning method. We compared the sagittal dose distribution of different FS applicator geometries with dose levels at two applicator points, defined 2 cm apart from the tandem towards the bladder and rectum. We computed the Pearson correlation coefficients between the dose levels at the applicator points and the ovoid separation, symmetry and the ovoids' sagittal shift. We also investigated the effect of dwell time settings in ovoids in order to decrease the dose to organs at risk. The inter-fractional variation of the FS applicator geometries and the influence on the dose levels at the two applicator points were also tested.Results and conclusionsStrong correlation was found between the ovoid separation and dose values to applicator points defined in sagittal direction of FS applicator arrangements. Also strong correlation was between the ovoids' sagittal position with respect to the tandem and the applicator point defined towards the rectum, while the ovoid symmetry had no influence on the sagittal dose distribution. The standard deviations of inter-fractional variation of the ovoid separation and the ovoids' sagittal position were within ±5.2 mm and ±10.2 mm respectively. The inter-fractional variations in FS applicator geometry resulted in variation in dose levels at the applicator points ±0.8 Gy typically, while the largest value was ±1.6 Gy.     

Verification in the water phantom of the irradiation time calculation done by the algorithm used in intraoperative radiotherapy

AimThe investigation of the irradiation time calculation accuracy of the GGPB algorithm used for IORT.BackgroundConventionally, breast conserving therapy consists of breast conserving surgery followed by postoperative whole breast irradiation and boost. The use of intraoperative radiotherapy (IORT) enables the boost to be delivered already during the surgery. In this case, the treatment dose for IORT can be calculated by use of General Gaussian Pencil Beam (GGPB) algorithm, which is implemented in TPS Eclipse.Materials and methodsPDDs and OFs for electron beams from Mobetron and all available applicators were measured in order to configure the GGPB algorithm. Afterwards, the irradiation times for the prescribed dose of 3 Gy were calculated by means of it. The results of calculations were verified in the water phantom using the Marcus ionization chamber.ResultsThe results differed between energies. For 6 MeV the irradiation times calculated by the GGPB algorithm were correct, for the energy of 9 MeV they were too small and for the energy of 4 MeV they were too large for applicators with smaller diameters, while acceptable for the remaining ones.ConclusionThe GGPB algorithm can be used in intraoperative radiotherapy for energy and applicator sets for which no significant difference between the measured and the prescribed dose was obtained. For the rest of energy-applicator sets the configuration should be verified and possibly repeated.     

Dosimetric comparison of MRI-based HDR brachytherapy and stereotactic radiotherapy in patients with advanced cervical cancer: A virtual brachytherapy study

AimTo evaluate the treatment plans of 3D image-guided brachytherapy (BT) and stereotactic robotic radiotherapy with online image guidance – CyberKnife (CK) in patients with locally advanced cervix cancer.Methods and materialsTen pairs of plans for patients with locally advanced inoperable cervical cancer were created using MR based 3D brachytherapy and stereotaxis CK. The dose that covers 98% of the target volume (HR CTV D98) was taken as a reference and other parameters were compared.ResultsOf the ten studied cases, the dose from D100 GTV was comparable for both devices, on average, the BT GTV D90 was 10–20% higher than for CK. The HR CTV D90 was higher for CK with an average difference of 10–20%, but only fifteen percent of HR CTV (the peripheral part) received a higher dose from CK, while 85% of the target volume received higher doses from BT. We found a significant organ-sparing effect of CK compared to brachytherapy (20–30% lower doses in 0.1 cm³, 1 cm³, and 2 cm³).ConclusionBT remains to be the best method for dose escalation. Due to the significant organ-sparing effect of CK, patients that are not candidates for BT could benefit from stereotaxis more than from classical external beam radiotherapy.     

Développement de l’appareil Papillon 50™ et de ses applicateurs pour la radiothérapie 50 kV des cancers du rectum et de la peau

ObjectiveContact X-Ray 50 kV (CXRT) has proven its efficiency to treat rectum and skin cancers. The goal of this technological research was to design and produce a new CXRT machine with dedicated applicators to replace the Philips unit not any more manufactured.Materials and methodsThe P50 was assembled in UK and the characteristics of the machine were evaluated with spectrometers, ions chambers, Gafchromic films and Monte Carlo code. The applicators were designed and manufactured in Nice. Dosimetric data were measured for each applicator. Validated protocols were used to treat patients.ResultsBetween September 2009 and November 2011, the performances of the P50 was judged satisfactory with a dose rate close to 15 Gy/min depending on the applicator. The dose distribution was according to objectives. Clinical results achieved in 62 patients treated in centre Antoine-Lacassagne for rectum, skin or eyelid cancers confirmed the efficiency and good tolerance of CXRT. Similar results in rectal cancer were observed in Clatterbridge with 120 rectal cancers treated with P50.DiscussionThese results are encouraging and should contribute to the international dissemination of CXRT. New machine (Papillon Plus) should be designed and produced for intraoperative irradiation and treatment of vaginal vault.ConclusionThis experience of research and development well structured within the frame of TecSan project should be encouraged further to facilitate technological innovation in the field of radiotherapy.     

The role of high-dose-rate brachytherapy boost in breast-conserving therapy: Long-term results of the Hungarian National Institute of Oncology

AimTo report the long-term results of high-dose-rate (HDR) brachytherapy (BT) boost for breast cancer patients treated with conservative surgery and radiotherapy.Materials and methodsBetween 1995 and 2007, 100 early-stage breast cancer patients received an HDR BT boost after conservative surgery and whole breast irradiation. Ten patients (10%) received a single-fraction HDR boost of 8–10.35 Gy using rigid needles, while 90 (90%) were treated with a fractionated multi-catheter HDR BT boost. The latter consisted of 3 × 4 Gy (n = 19), 3 × 4.75 Gy (n = 70), and 2 × 6.4 Gy (n = 1). Breast cancer related events, cosmetic results and side effects were assessed.ResultsAt a median follow-up time of 94 months (range: 8–152) only 7 (7%) ipsilateral breast failures were observed for a 5- and 8-year actuarial rate of 4.5 and 7.0%, respectively. The 8-year disease-free, cancer-specific, and overall survival was 76.1, 82.8, and 80.4%, respectively. Cosmetic outcome was rated excellent in 17%, good in 39%, fair in 33%, and poor in 11%. Data on late radiation side effects were available for 91 patients (91%). Grade 3 fibrosis and grade 3 telangiectasia occurred in 6 (6.6%) and 2 (2.2%) patients, respectively. In univariate analysis only positive margin status had a significant negative effect on local control.ConclusionsHDR BT boost using multi-catheter implants produce excellent long-term local tumour control with acceptable cosmetic outcome and low rate of grade 3 late radiation side effects.     

A dosimetric analysis comparing electron beam with the MammoSite brachytherapy applicator for intact breast boost

IntroductionElectron beam radiation is the modality most often used to deliver an operative bed boost to breast cancer patients after completing whole breast radiation. However, electrons can potentially provide inadequate coverage. The MammoSite breast brachytherapy applicator may provide dosimetric advantages in the delivery of an operative bed boost and its role in this setting is not yet defined.Materials and methodsThe study population consisted of 15 patients with early stage breast cancer treated with partial breast irradiation (PBI) using the MammoSite device. For each patient, a theoretical boost plan using electrons and a second theoretical boost plan using the MammoSite applicator were created. To assess the adequacy of each boost plan, the PTV V90, PTV V95, and PTV V100 were calculated. To assess dose to normal tissues, the ipsilateral breast V50, ipsilateral lung V30, and heart V20 were calculated.ResultsThe mean PTV V100 for the MammoSite boost was 95.5%, compared to 77.4% for the electron boost (p < 0.001). The mean PTV V95 was 97.8%, compared to 93.3% for the electron boost (p = 0.02). The mean PTV V90, mean breast V50, mean lung V30, and mean heart V20 were not statistically different for MammoSite compared to electrons.ConclusionsA tumor bed boost using the MammoSite breast brachytherapy applicator provides superior target coverage and delivers similar doses to the ipsilateral breast and lung compared to a boost delivered with electrons. More investigation into the role of balloon brachytherapy in the delivery of a breast boost is warranted.     

Dose to pelvic lymph nodes in image based high dose rate brachytherapy of carcinoma cervix

AimThe aim of this study is to analyse the dosimetry to the pelvic lymph nodes and its correlation to point B using CT based high dose rate brachytherapy of carcinoma cervix.BackgroundConventionally, dose to pelvic lymph nodes from intracavitary brachytherapy was reported by point B and by the reference points of the lymphatic trapezoid.Materials and methods30 consecutive CT based high dose rate applications were reviewed between February and March 2016. The high risk clinical target volume and the organs at risk and the pelvic nodal groups were contoured. DVH parameters for the right and left obturator nodal group, right and left external iliac nodal group and right and left internal iliac nodal group were recorded. Right and left point B doses were also recorded.ResultsOn analysis of the combined dose, it was found that all the DVH parameters were significantly different from point B, except the D100 obturator and D2cc internal iliac lymph node. There was a significant correlation between all DVH parameters and point B, except D2cc, D1cc and D0.1cc of external iliac. The obturator group received the highest dose contribution from brachytherapy. The mean D90 dose received per fraction for the obturator, external iliac and internal iliac nodes was 2.7 Gy, 1.17 Gy and 1.41 Gy, respectively.ConclusionsThere is a significant dose contribution to the pelvic lymph nodal groups during intracavitary brachytherapy. There is a low degree of correlation between point B dose and dosimetric parameters of the individual nodal groups. Hence, it is important to analyse the dose delivered to individual nodal groups during intracavitary brachytherapy, at least in patients with enlarged lymph nodes to calculate the cumulative dose delivered.     

Megavoltage 2D topographic imaging: An attractive alternative to megavoltage CT for the localization of breast cancer patients treated with TomoDirect

PurposeTo show the usefulness of topographic 2D megavoltage images (MV2D) for the localization of breast cancer patients treated with TomoDirect (TD), a radiotherapy treatment technique with fixed-angle beams performed on a TomoTherapy system.MethodsA method was developed to quickly localize breast cancer patients treated with TD by registering the MV2D images produced before a TD treatment with reference images reconstructed from a kilovoltage CT simulation scanner and by using the projection of the beam-eye-view TD treatment field. Dose and image quality measurements were performed to determine the optimal parameters for acquiring MV2D images. A TD treatment was simulated on a chest phantom equipped with a breast attachment. MVCT and MV2D images were performed for 7 different shifted positions of the phantom and registered by 10 different operators with the simulation kilovoltage CT images.ResultsCompared to MVCT, MV2D imaging reduces the dose by a factor of up to 45 and the acquisition time by a factor of up to 49. Comparing the registration shift values obtained for the phantom images obtained with MVCT in the coarse mode to those obtained with MV2D, the mean difference is 1.0 ± 1.1 mm, −1.1 mm ± 1.1, and −0.1 ± 2.2 mm, respectively, in the lateral, longitudinal, and vertical directions.ConclusionsWith dual advantages (very fast imaging and a potentially reduced dose to the heart and contralateral organs), MV2D topographic images may be an attractive alternative to MVCT for the localization of breast cancer patients treated with TomoDirect.     

Effect of patient positioning on carbon-ion therapy planned dose distribution to pancreatic tumors and organs at risk

PurposePancreatic tumor treatment dose distribution variations associated with supine and prone patient positioning were evaluated.MethodsA total of 33 patients with pancreatic tumors who underwent CT in the supine and prone positions were analyzed retrospectively. Gross tumor volume (GTV), planning target volume (PTV), and organs at risk (OARs) (duodenum and stomach) were contoured. The prescribed dose of 55.2 Gy (RBE) was planned from four beam angles (0°, 90°, 180°, and 270°). Patient collimator and compensating boli were designed for each field. Dose distributions were calculated for each field in the supine and prone positions. To improve dose distribution, patient positioning was selected from supine or prone for each beam field.ResultsCompared with conventional beam angle and patient positioning, D2cc of 1st-2nd portion of duodenum (D1-D2), 3rd-4th portion of duodenum (D3-D4), and stomach could be reduced to a maximum of 6.4 Gy (RBE), 3.5 Gy (RBE), and 4.5 Gy (RBE) by selection of patient positioning. V10 of D1-D2, D3-D4, and stomach could be reduced to a maximum of 7.2 cc, 11.3 cc, and 11.5 cc, respectively. D95 of GTV and PTV were improved to a maximum of 6.9% and 3.7% of the prescribed dose, respectively.ConclusionsOptimization of patient positioning for each beam angle in treatment planning has the potential to reduce OARs dose maintaining tumor dose in pancreatic treatment.     

Clinical examples of 3D dose distribution reconstruction,based on the actual MLC leaves movement,for dynamic treatment techniques

AimTo present practical examples of our new algorithm for reconstruction of 3D dose distribution, based on the actual MLC leaf movement.BackgroundDynaLog and RTplan files were used by DDcon software to prepare a new RTplan file for dose distribution reconstruction.Materials and methodsFour different clinically relevant scenarios were used to assess the feasibility of the proposed new approach: (1) Reconstruction of whole treatment sessions for prostate cancer; (2) Reconstruction of IMRT verification treatment plan; (3) Dose reconstruction in breast cancer; (4) Reconstruction of interrupted arc and complementary plan for an interrupted VMAT treatment session of prostate cancer. The applied reconstruction method was validated by comparing reconstructed and measured fluence maps. For all statistical analysis, the U Mann–Whitney test was used.ResultsIn the first two and the fourth cases, there were no statistically significant differences between the planned and reconstructed dose distribution (p = 0.910, p = 0.975, p = 0.893, respectively). In the third case the differences were statistically significant (p = 0.015). Treatment plan had to be reconstructed.ConclusionDeveloped dose distribution reconstruction algorithm presents a very useful QA tool. It provides means for 3D dose distribution verification in patient volume and allows to evaluate the influence of actual MLC leaf motion on the dose distribution.