Comparison of soil nitrogen mineralization and nitrification in a mixed grassland and forested ecosystem in central Taiwan

We used the buried bag incubation method to study temporal patterns of net N mineralization and net nitrification in soils at Ta-Ta-Chia forest in central Taiwan. The site included a grassland zone, (dominant vegetation consists of Yushania niitakayamensis and Miscanthus transmorrisonensis Hayata) and a forest zone (Tsuga chinensis var. formosana and Yushania niitakamensis). In the grassland, soil concentration NH₄ ⁺ in the organic horizon (0.1–0.2 m) ranged from 1.0 to 12.4 mg N kg^–1 soil and that of NO₃ ^– varied from 0.2 to 2.1 mg N kg^–1 soil. In the forest zone, NH₄ ⁺ concentration was between 2.8 and 25.0 mg N kg^–1 soil and NO₃ ^–varied from 0.2 to 1.3 mg N kg^–1 soil. There were lower soil NH₄ ⁺ concentrations during the summer than other seasons. Net N mineralization was higher during the summer while net nitrification rates did not show a distinct seasonal pattern. In the grassland, net N mineralization and net nitrification rates were between –0.1 and 0.24 and from –0.04 to 0.04 mg N kg^–1 soil day^–1, respectively. In the forest zone, net N mineralization rates were between –0.03 and 0.45 mg N kg^–1 soil day^–1 and net nitrification rates were between –0.01 and 0.03 mg N kg^–1 soil day^–1. These differences likely result from differing vegetation communities (C₃ versus C₄ plant type) and soil characteristics.     

火烧对草地土壤氮总矿化、硝化及无机氮消耗速率的影响

采用同位素^15N库稀释技术结合扰动较小的管型取样法,测定了羊草草地火烧区与未烧区不同季节土壤氮的总矿化速率、总硝化速率、无机氮消耗速率．结果表明,火烧地的氮总矿化与硝化速率在牧草返青后的4、5月份均高于未烧地,7月份差异不显著,到生长季末的9月份又低于未烧地;火烧地NH^4-N的消耗速率7月份以前均高于未烧地,9月份低于未烧地,N03^--N的消耗4、5份火烧地要高于未烧地,7、9月份又低于未烧地;火烧地土壤NH4^ -N含量在4、5和7月份均高于未烧地,9月份基本没有差别,而N03^--N在4、5月份无大差别,7、9月份高于未烧地．     

Multi-trait genomic prediction for nitrogen response indices in tropical maize hybrids

In maize breeding, genomic prediction may be an efficient tool for selecting single-crosses evaluated under abiotic stress conditions. In addition, a promising strategy is applying multiple-trait genomic prediction using selection indices (SIs), increasing genetics gains and reducing time per cycles. In this study, we aimed (i) to compare accuracy of single- and multi-trait genomic prediction (STGP; MTGP) in two maize datasets, (ii) to evaluate prediction of four selection indices that could contribute to the selection of tropical maize hybrids under contrasting nitrogen conditions, and (iii) to compare the use of linear (GBLUP) and nonlinear (RKHS/GK) kernels in STGP and MTGP analyses. For either single-trait GBLUP and RKHS analyses, the highest values obtained for accuracy were 0.40 and 0.41 using harmonic mean (HM), respectively. From multi-trait GBLUP and GK, using the combination of selection indices in MTGP seems to be suitable, increasing the accuracy. Adding grain yield and plant height in MTGP showed a slight improvement in accuracy compared to STGP. In general, there was a modest benefit of using single-trait RKHS and GK multi-trait, rather than GBLUP.     

Nitrogen retention efficiency and nitrogen losses of a managed and phytodiverse temperate grassland

Maintaining nitrogen retention efficiency (NRE) is crucial in minimizing N losses when intensifying management of temperate grasslands. Our aim was to evaluate how grassland management practices and sward compositions affect NRE (1 − N losses/soil available N), defined as the efficiency with which soil available N is retained in an ecosystem. A three-factorial grassland management experiment was established with two fertilization treatments (without and combined N, phosphorus and potassium fertilization), two mowing frequencies (cut once and thrice per year) and three sward compositions (control, monocot- and dicot-enhanced swards). We measured N losses as leaching and nitrous oxide emissions, and soil available N as gross N mineralization rates. Fertilization increased N losses due to increased nitrification and decreased microbial N immobilization, and consequently decreased NRE. Intensive mowing partly dampened high N losses following fertilization. Sward compositions influenced NRE but not N losses: control swards that developed for decades under extensive management had the highest NRE, whereas monocot-enhanced sward had the lowest NRE. NRE was highly correlated with microbial NH₄⁺ immobilization and microbial biomass and only marginally correlated with plant N uptake, underlining the importance of microbial N retention in the soil-plant system. Microbial N retention is reflected in NRE but not in indices commonly used to reflect plant response. NRE was able to capture the effects of sward composition and fertilization whereas N losses were only sensitive to fertilization; thus, NRE is a better index when evaluating environmental sustainability of sward compositions and management practices of grasslands.     

Simulation of the decomposition and nitrogen mineralization of aboveground plant material in two unfertilized grassland ecosystems

A simple model of the decomposition and nitrogen mineralization of plant material from two unfertilized grassland ecosystems has been developed, with only the proportion of leaves and stems in the original material, the initial nitrogen contents of these plant parts and temperature as input data. The model simulates carbon losses from stems and leaves, using a double exponential decay function, with the temperature sum as independent variable. Mineralization of nitrogen is not calculated via microbial growth rates, but simulated on the basis of the carbon utilization efficiency of the microorganisms and the critical C/N ratio, i.e. the C/N ratio of the litter at which the microbial demand for nitrogen is met exactly. The parameter values for leaching fractions of carbon and nitrogen, relative decay rates, microbial carbon utilization efficiencies and critical C/N ratios were derived from a litter bag experiment with 12 litter types (species) including both green and dead materials, carried out in two unfertilized grassland ecosystems differing in production level. The model was evaluated using a cross-validation method, in which one species was omitted from the parametrization procedure, and its decomposition and mineralization were predicted by the resulting model. In general there was good agreement between the observed and predicted amounts of carbon and nitrogen remaining for all green litter types/species, but carbon and nitrogen dynamics in the dead material of Festuca rubra were poorly predicted. This disparity has been attributed to the proportion of leaves in the material of Festuca rubra (95%) being far beyond the range of leaf proportions in the three litter types the calibration set consisted of (8–35%). When the data of all litter types were used to determine the model parameters, good agreement was obtained between measured and simulated values for the changes in nitrogen and carbon in all litter types of both the green and dead material series. Optimization yielded parameter values for microbial carbon utilization efficiencies of 0.30 for microorganisms associated with green litter and 0.35 for those associated with dead litter. The critical C/N ratios for green and dead material were found to be 29 and 36, respectively.     

华北盐渍化草地土壤净氮矿化速率对不同水平氮添加的响应

对于养分贫瘠的盐渍化草地生态系统, 大气氮沉降如何影响土壤氮循环过程是一个目前尚未解决的问题。该研究在位于华北地区山西省右玉县境内的盐渍化草地建立了一个模拟氮沉降的试验平台, 设置8个氮添加水平, 分别为0、1、2、4、8、16、24、32 g·m^-2·a^-1 (N0、N1、N2、N4、N8、N16、N24、N32), 生长季5-9月, 每月月初以喷施的方式等量添加NH₄NO₃。从2017年5月到2019年10月, 运用顶盖PVC管法每月一次进行净氮矿化速率的测定同时计算了净氮矿化速率对不同水平氮添加的敏感性。主要结果表明: (1)高水平氮添加(N16、N24、N32)显著增加土壤无机氮库; (2)该盐渍化草地土壤氮矿化以硝化作用为主, 经过3年氮添加以后, 高氮添加(N24、N32)显著促进了土壤净硝化速率, 并且不同氮添加水平在不同的月份和年份中表现出差异性响应; (3)不同氮添加水平对土壤净氮矿化敏感性的影响在不同降水年份差异显著, 短期低水平氮添加提高了土壤净氮矿化的敏感性, 而高水平氮添加降低土壤净氮矿化敏感性; (4)盐渍化草地土壤净氮矿化速率与土壤温度和水分呈正相关关系, 与土壤pH呈负相关关系。因此, 在当前氮沉降增加的背景下, 北方盐渍化草地土壤氮矿化速率对低氮添加的敏感性较高, 结合氮沉降的特点, 未来模型预测应该同时考虑氮沉降对盐渍化草地的可能影响。     

Seasonal variations in nitrogen mineralization under three land use types in a grassland landscape

Soil nitrogen (N) mineralization is an important component of the N cycling process in ecosystems. In this study, we assessed the seasonal patterns of net soil N mineralization and nitrification using an intact soil core incubation method in the upper 0–10 cm soil layer in three representative land use types. These included a fenced steppe, an abandoned field and a crop field in a grassland landscape of Inner Mongolia, China. The study was conducted from September 2004 to August 2005. Our results demonstrate marked seasonal variations in inorganic N pools, net nitrogen mineralization and net nitrification. Net N mineralization was higher in the crop field than in the fenced steppe and the abandoned field. Daily rates of N mineralization and nitrification during the growing season were approximately twice their corresponding mean annual rates. Accumulative mineralization and nitrification of N during the growing season accounted for about 90 and 85% of that measured for the entire year. Rates of mineralization and nitrification were positively correlated with soil bulk density, but negatively correlated with soil pH. Net N mineralization and nitrification were strongly regulated by land use, precipitation, soil water and temperature.     

Microbial contributions to the increased nitrogen mineralization after air-drying of soils

The amounts of mineral-nitrogen (NH₄−N+NO₃−N) extracted by 2MKCL and the net amounts of N mineralized (δ Min-N) during a 10-day incubation of field-moist soils, air-dried then rewetted samples, and chloroform-fumigated samples, were measured in a range of 20 topsoils from grasslands. Air-drying generally increased extractable-N and the δ Min-N of the remoistened soils, but decreased the Min-N flush after fumigation. The C∶N ratios (CO₂−C production: net Min-N production) over 10 days decreased significantly from an average of 25 to 12 after initial air-drying, suggesting that substrates of low C∶N ratio, such as microbial cells, were contributiong to the extra N mineralized after the air-drying treatment. A procedure to quantify the contribution from microbial-N to the increased δ Min-N after air-drying was only partially successful, but indicated a large proportion of this increase was derived from microbial cells killed by desccation.     

冬小麦／夏玉米轮作体系中土壤氮素矿化及预测

应用田间试验结果研究了冬小麦和夏玉米生长期的土壤氮素矿化量,并用间隙淋洗好气培养试验结合一级动力学模型对田间氮素矿化量进行了预测。结果表明,土壤氮素矿化量在年际间和作物间的变异很大,夏玉米季一般高于冬小麦季,从而导致夏玉米季施用氮肥的增产作用不明显,冬小麦季矿化量占当季作物最高吸氮量的31％～60％,夏玉米季占62％～108％,加上起始Nmin的供氮,造成了作物产量尤其是夏玉米产量对施入氮肥反应不明显,土壤氮素净矿化量均随土壤供氮量的增加而显著减少,在一般供氮量范围内(0～300kgN·hm^-2)均表现为净矿化,一级动力学模型只能预测作物整个生育期土壤氮素矿化总的趋势,并不能反映某一阶段矿化量的变化,但模型能在种植作物以前估计出土壤氮素净矿化量,从这个意义上说,模型的预测作用仍是不可低估的。     

Emission of gaseous nitrogen oxides from an extensively managed grassland in NE Bavaria, Germany.

We analysed the stable isotope composition of emitted N₂O in a one-year field experiment (June 1998 to April 1999) in unfertilized controls, and after adding nitrogen by applying slurry or mineral N (calcium ammonium nitrate). Emitted N₂O was analysed every 2–4 weeks, with additional daily sampling for 10 days after each fertilizer application. In supplementary soil incubations, the isotopic composition of N₂O was measured under defined conditions, favouring either denitrification or nitrification. Soil incubated for 48 h under conditions favouring nitrification emitted very little N₂O (0.024 mol g_dw ^–1) and still produced N₂O from denitrification. Under denitrifying incubation conditions, much more N₂O was formed (0.91 mol g_dw ^–1 after 48 h). The isotope ratios of N₂O emitted from denitrification stabilized at ¹⁵N = –40.8 ± 5.7 and ¹⁸O = 2.7 ± 6.3. In the field experiment, the N₂O isotope data showed no clear seasonal trends or treatment effects. Annual means weighted by time and emission rate were ¹⁵N = –8.6 and ¹⁸O = 34.7 after slurry application, ¹⁵N = –4.6 and ¹⁸O = 24.0 after mineral fertilizer application and ¹⁵N = –6.4 and ¹⁸O = 35.6 in the control plots, respectively. So, in all treatments the emitted N₂O was ¹⁵N-depleted compared to ambient air N₂O (¹⁵N = 11.4 ± 11.6, ¹⁸O = 36.9 ± 10.7). Isotope analyses of the emitted N₂O under field conditions per se allowed no unequivocal identification of the main N₂O producing process. However, additional data on soil conditions and from laboratory experiments point to denitrification as the predominant N₂O source. We concluded (1) that the isotope ratios of N₂O emitted from the field soil were not only influenced by the source processes, but also by microbial reduction of N₂O to N₂ and (2) that N₂O emission rates had to exceed 3.4 mol N₂O m^–2 h^–1 to obtain reliable N₂O isotope data.     

Herbivore influence on soil microbial biomass and nitrogen mineralization in a northern grassland ecosystem: Yellowstone National Park

Microorganisms are largely responsible for soil nutrient cycling and energy flow in terrestrial ecosystems. Although soil microorganisms are affected by topography and grazing, little is known about how these two variables may interact to influence microbial processes. Even less is known about how these variables influence microorganisms in systems that contain large populations of free-roaming ungulates. In this study, we compared microbial biomass size and activity, as measured by in situ net N mineralization, inside and outside 35- to 40-year exclosures across a topographic gradient in northern Yellowstone National Park. The objective was to determine the relative effect of topography and large grazers on microbial biomass and nitrogen mineralization. Microbial C and N varied by almost an order of magnitude across sites. Topographic depressions that contained high plant biomass and fine-textured soils supported the greatest microbial biomass. We found that plant biomass accurately predicted microbial biomass across our sites suggesting that carbon inputs from plants constrained microbial biomass. Chronic grazing neither depleted soil C nor reduced microbial biomass. We hypothesize that microbial populations in grazed grasslands are sustained mainly by inputs of labile C from dung deposition and increased root turnover or root exudation beneath grazed plants. Mineral N fluxes were affected more by grazing than topography. Net N mineralization rates were highest in grazed grassland and increased from dry, unproductive to mesic, highly productive communities. Overall, our results indicate that topography mainly influences microbial biomass size, while mineral N fluxes (microbial activity) are affected more by grazing in this grassland ecosystem. Received: 4 June 1997 / Accepted: 16 December 1997     

Effects of precipitation intensity and temporal pattern on soil nitrogen mineralization in a typical steppe of Nei Mongol grassland

Aims Our objective is to: 1) explore the dynamics of soil nitrogen (N) mineralization in a grassland ecosystem in response to the changes in precipitation intensity and temporal distribution, and 2) identify the controlling factors.Methods The two study sites located in a typical steppe of the Nei Mongol grassland were fenced in 2013 and 1999, respectively. Our field experiment includes manipulations of three levels of precipitation intensity (increased 50%, decreased 50%, control) in three temporal patterns (increased or decreased precipitation for three years; increased or decreased precipitation for two years and no manipulation for one year; increased or decreased precipitation for one year and no manipulation for one year).Important findings 1) The soil net N mineralization and net nitrification rates decreased with changes in the temporal distributions of precipitation from one year to three years, with the maximum values of soil net N mineralization and nitrification rates observed in the treatments of increased or decreased precipitation for one year and no manipulation for one year (+PY1 or -PY1). This indicates that the high precipitation intensity and longer precipitation may have negative effects on soil net N mineralization and nitrification rates, while the moderate soilmoisture and temperature may stimulate soil mineralization. 2) The soil net N mineralization and nitrification rates, soil cumulative N mineralization, and nitrification in the fenced site in 1999 were higher than those in the site fenced in 2013, implying that a long-term enclosure may have promoted nutrient storage and soil quality restoration. 3) The long-term treatments of increased or decreased precipitation had significant effects on soil water content and temperature, whereas the short-term, discontinuous precipitation produced minor effects on soil moisture and temperature. Moreover, the controlling factors for soil N mineralization were different between the two fields. Soil moisture had a major effect on soil inorganic N content and net N mineralization rate in the site fenced in 2013, while soil temperature played a dominant role in the site fenced in 1999, with the net N mineralization rate depressed by higher soil moisture. Our findings suggest that the precipitation intensity and temporal distribution had important impacts on soil N mineralization in the Inner Mongolia grassland; these effects was site-dependent and particularly related to soil texture, community composition, and disturbance, and other factors.     

放牧草地健康管理的生理指标

依据草地对席子和牧的生理响应,用牧草生理低限（PLL）,生理上限（PUL）和再生长期（R期）长度/放牧期（G期）长度的比值（R/G）等指标。构建了放牧草地健康评价的生理阈限双因子法,并以光合作用及其相关参数分析了多年生黑麦草轮牧草地的健康指标。维持草地适宜的双因子生理阈限的R/G比值,旨在放牧后草地功能与健康的完全恢复,是放牧草地可持续经营的目标。     

Nitrogen response efficiency of a managed and phytodiverse temperate grassland

Aims

Our goal was to assess how management and sward functional diversity affect nitrogen response efficiency (NRE), the ratio of plant biomass production to supply of available nitrogen (N) in temperate grassland.

Methods

A three-factorial design was employed: three sward compositions, two mowing frequencies, and two fertilization treatments.

Results

NRE was largely influenced by fertilization followed by mowing frequency and sward composition. NRE was larger in unfertilized than fertilized plots, in plots cut thrice than plots cut once per year, and in control swards than in monocot- or dicot-enhanced swards. Fertilization decreased NRE through decreases in both N uptake efficiency (plant N uptake per supply of available N) and N use efficiency (NUE, biomass produced per plant N uptake) whereas mowing frequency and sward composition affected NRE through N uptake efficiency rather than NUE. The largest NRE in the control sward with 70 % monocots and 30 % dicots attests that these proportions of functional groups were best adapted in this grassland ecosystem.

Conclusions

Optimum NRE may not be a target of most farmers, but it is an appropriate tool to evaluate the consequences of grassland management practices, which farmers may employ to maximize profit, on environmental quality.     

Components of the nitrogen cycle measured for cropped and grassland soil-plant systems

Summary Inputs and outputs to the N balance of a clay soil catchment (Evesham and Kingston series) under grassland and cereals at Wytham near Oxford were measured over 2 years. Soil mineral N (NH₄+NO₃) was measured to 1 m depth at intervals of 2 to 8 weeks. The frequency distribution of these values was approximately log-normal and the geometric mean was used as an estimate of central tendency. Overall, soil mineral N tended to decrease during the study period, but marked fluctuations were observed in autumn (October–November) and early spring (February–March) in the grassland due to mineralization of soil organic N, and in the arable soil in April–May following the application of N fertilizer to the spring barley and winter wheat.N lost by leaching, including a little surface runoff, was calculated from the NO₃ concentration of the catchment drainage and the volume of drainage. The estimate of N leached using concentrations unweighted for flow rate was only 14 per cent less than that based on flow-weighted concentrations. The differences in the uptake of N by cereals and grass between fields were explicable partly in terms of soil type and partly in terms of the timing and amounts of fertilizer added. The results are discussed in the context of steady-state equilibrium of N in the soil-plant system. However, an N balance could not be struck because N input due to mineralization, and N outputs due to gaseous losses and immobilization of N in the soil and root biomasses, were not measured and could not be accurately estimated.     

温度和湿度对我国内蒙古羊草草原土壤净氮矿化的影响

土壤氮素的矿化是反映土壤供氮能力的重要因素之一 ,也是目前国内外研究的热点。通过测定内蒙古典型羊草草原自由放牧地土壤净氮矿化量和净氮矿化速率 ,揭示影响草地生态系统土壤氮循环过程的有关机理 ,为草地生态系统建模提供理论依据。在实验室条件下 ,运用恒温恒湿培养箱控制土壤的温度与湿度 ,测定羊草草原长期自由放牧地土壤氮素矿化量的积累。将不同水分含量的土柱分别放在温度为 - 10℃、0℃、5℃、15℃、2 5℃和 35℃的恒温恒湿培养箱中培养 ,培养 1、2、3、5周后取出 ,分析培养前后的 NH 4- N和 NO- 3- N含量 ,以确定土壤净氮矿化 (NH 4- N NO- 3- N)的累积和不同时间段内的矿化速率。结果表明 :不同处理温度和水分之间的差异均达到显著水平 (p<0 .0 0 0 1)。温度和水分之间具有显著的交互作用 (p<0 .0 0 0 1)。随着培养时间的延长 ,矿化氮累积量增加 ,但是矿化速率下降     

Ungulate and topographic control of nitrogen: phosphorus stoichiometry in a temperate grassland; soils, plants and mineralization rates

Although the link between the nitrogen (N): phosphorus (P) stoichiometry of biota and availability has received considerable attention in aquatic systems, there has been relatively little effort to compare the elemental composition of biota and supply in terrestrial habitats. In this study, I explored the effects of a prominent topo-edaphic gradient, from dry hilltop to wet slope-base, and native ungulates on N and P of soils, plants, and rates of in situ net mineralization in grasslands of Yellowstone National Park. Nitrogen and P measurements were made May–September, 2000, in paired, grazed and 38–42 year fenced, ungrazed grassland at five topographically variable sites. Similar to findings from other grassland ecosystems, several site factors associated with organic activity, including soil moisture, C, and plant biomass, covaried with soil N concentration and/or net N mineralization. Soil P concentration and net P mineralization, however, were unrelated to those factors. Instead, net P mineralization was negatively related to soil pH, which is known to control the form of inorganic P and its availability, and soil P was uncorrelated with any soil or plant variable measured in the study. Because of being influenced by different soil properties, N and P net mineralization were unrelated among grasslands. Furthermore, supply and plant N:P ratios were uncorrelated in this grassland system. Based on critical N:P ratios reflecting nutritional limitation of plants, Yellowstone grassland vegetation ranged from being N limited to N-P co-limited. Grazers increased N-P co-limitation by enhancing plant N concentrations and the soil pH gradient across grassland sites regulated plant nutritional limitation by affecting plant-available P. These findings showed how ungulates and a landscape factor, i.e. soil pH, determined plant nutrient status among YNP grasslands differently by influencing plant N concentration versus plant P concentration, respectively.     

Prediction of nitrogen responses of corn by soil nitrogen mineralization indicators

Soil nitrogen mineralization potential (N min) has to be spatially quantified to enable farmers to vary N fertilizer rates, optimize crop yields, and minimize N transfer from soils to the environment. The study objectives were to assess the spatial variability in soil N min potential based on clay and organic matter (OM) contents and the impact of grouping soils using these criteria on corn grain (Zea mays L.) yield, N uptake response curves to N fertilizer, and soil residual N. Four indicators were used: OM content and three equations involving OM and clay content. The study was conducted on a 15-ha field near Montreal, Quebec, Canada. In the spring 2000, soil samples (n = 150) were collected on a 30- x 30-m grid and six rates of N fertilizer (0 to 250 kg N ha(-1)) were applied. Kriged maps of particle size showed areas of clay, clay loam, and fine sandy loam soils. The N min indicators were spatially structured but soil nitrate (NO3-) was not. The N fertilizer rate to reach maximum grain yield (N max), as estimated by a quadratic model, varied among textural classes and Nmin indicators, and ranged from 159 to 250 kg N ha(-1). The proportion of variability (R2) and the standard error of the estimate (SE) varied among textural groups and N min indicators. The R2 ranged from 0.53 to 0.91 and the SE from 0.13 to 1.62. Corn grain N uptake was significantly affected by N fertilizer and the pattern of response differed with soil texture. For the 50 kg N ha(-1) rate, the apparent N min potential (ANM) was significantly larger in the clay loam (122 kg ha(-1)) than in the fine sandy loam (80 kg ha(-1)) or clay (64 kg ha(-1)) soils. The fall soil residual N was not affected by N fertlizer inputs. Textural classes can be used to predict N max. The N min indicators may also assist the variable rate N fertilizer inputs for corn production.     

Comparison of survey methods for wintering grassland birds

ABSTRACT Although investigators have evaluated the efficacy of survey methods for assessing densities of breeding birds, few comparisons have been made of survey methods for wintering birds, especially in grasslands. In winter, social behavior and spatial distributions often differ from those in the breeding season. We evaluated the degree of correspondence between density estimates based on different survey methods. Surveys were conducted during two winters (2001–2002 and 2002–2003) on 16 grassland sites in southwestern Oklahoma. Line‐transect (using a detection function to account for birds present but not detected) and area‐search (where density was based on the total count within a given area) methods were employed. Observations on line transects were also analyzed as strip transects, where density was based on total count within a given strip width and no detection function was used. Savannah Sparrows (Passerculus sandwichensis), LeConte's Sparrows (Ammodramus leconteii), Song Sparrows (Melospiza melodia), Smith's Longspurs (Calcarius pictus), Chestnut‐collared Longspurs (C. ornatus), and Eastern Meadowlarks (Sturnella magna) were sufficiently abundant to allow comparison. Area‐search density estimates tended to be higher than line‐transect estimates for Savannah Sparrows, Song Sparrows, and Eastern Meadowlarks, suggesting that some individuals initially located close to the transect line were not detected on line transects. The area‐search and line‐transect methods gave similar density estimates for Chestnut‐collared and Smith's longspurs. Area‐search estimates of Eastern Meadowlarks were significantly higher in the second year of the study only. For this species, area‐search estimates did not differ from those of strip transects covering an equal area, so the reason for the differing meadowlark estimates is not clear. Higher density estimates using the area‐search method likely resulted from: (1) birds that might escape detection by hiding were more likely detected (flushed) during area searches because of the repeated passes through the area, and (2) birds close to the line in line transects escape detection by hiding, biasing those estimates low. We also evaluated the correspondence of density rankings for the six species as determined by the different survey methods and for the same species across survey sites. Correlations among the six species of the area‐search results with those of line transects and strip transects generally were high, increasing in 2002–2003 when densities of birds were greater. All three methods provided similar density rankings among species. Density rankings within species across sites for the four non‐longspur species generally were concordant for the three methods, suggesting that any of them will adequately reflect among‐site differences, especially when densities vary greatly across sites. Further research is needed to determine the extent to which grassland birds are missed on line transects. We suggest that workers using line transects to study these species give careful consideration and make additional efforts to satisfy the distance‐sampling assumption that all birds on or near the line are detected. If density is measured as a total count in a fixed area, we recommend that observers pass within <10 m of all points in the area.