Asymmetric electron transfer in cyanobacterial Photosystem I: charge separation and secondary electron transfer dynamics of mutations near the primary electron acceptor A0

Point mutations were introduced near the primary electron acceptor sites assigned to A0 in both the PsaA and PsaB branches of Photosystem I in the cyanobacterium Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803. The residues Met688PsaA and Met668PsaB, which provide the axial ligands to the Mg2+ of the eC-A3 and eC-B3 chlorophylls, were changed to leucine and asparagine (chlorophyll notation follows Jordan et al., 2001). The removal of the ligand is expected to alter the midpoint potential of the A0/A0- redox pair and result in a change in the intrinsic charge separation rate and secondary electron transfer kinetics from A0- to A1. The dynamics of primary charge separation and secondary electron transfer were studied at 690 nm and 390 nm in these mutants by ultrafast optical pump-probe spectroscopy. The data reveal that mutations in the PsaB branch do not alter electron transfer dynamics, whereas mutations in the PsaA branch have a distinct effect on electron transfer, slowing down both the primary charge separation and the secondary electron transfer step (the latter by a factor of 3-10). These results suggest that electron transfer in cyanobacterial Photosystem I is asymmetric and occurs primarily along the PsaA branch of cofactors.     

Replacement of the methionine axial ligand to the primary electron acceptor A0 slows the A0- reoxidation dynamics in photosystem I

The recent crystal structure of photosystem I (PSI) from Thermosynechococcus elongatus shows two nearly symmetric branches of electron transfer cofactors including the primary electron donor, P(700), and a sequence of electron acceptors, A, A(0) and A(1), bound to the PsaA and PsaB heterodimer. The central magnesium atoms of each of the putative primary electron acceptor chlorophylls, A(0), are unusually coordinated by the sulfur atom of methionine 688 of PsaA and 668 of PsaB, respectively. We [Ramesh et al. (2004a) Biochemistry 43:1369-1375] have shown that the replacement of either methionine with histidine in the PSI of the unicellular green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii resulted in accumulation of A(0)(-) (in 300-ps time scale), suggesting that both the PsaA and PsaB branches are active. This is in contrast to cyanobacterial PSI where studies with methionine-to-leucine mutants show that electron transfer occurs predominantly along the PsaA branch. In this contribution we report that the change of methionine to either leucine or serine leads to a similar accumulation of A(0)(-) on both the PsaA and the PsaB branch of PSI from C. reinhardtii, as we reported earlier for histidine mutants. More importantly, we further demonstrate that for all the mutants under study, accumulation of A(0)(-) is transient, and that reoxidation of A(0)(-) occurs within 1-2 ns, two orders of magnitude slower than in wild type PSI, most likely via slow electron transfer to A(1). This illustrates an indispensable role of methionine as an axial ligand to the primary acceptor A(0) in optimizing the rate of charge stabilization in PSI. A simple energetic model for this reaction is proposed. Our findings support the model of equivalent electron transfer along both cofactor branches in Photosystem I.     

Electron transfer in cyanobacterial photosystem I: II. Determination of forward electron transfer rates of site-directed mutants in a putative electron transfer pathway from A0 through A1 to FX

The directionality of electron transfer in Photosystem I (PS I) is investigated using site-directed mutations in the phylloquinone (QK) and FX binding regions of Synnechocystis sp. PCC 6803. The kinetics of forward electron transfer from the secondary acceptor A1 (phylloquinone) were measured in mutants using time-resolved optical difference spectroscopy and transient EPR spectroscopy. In whole cells and PS I complexes of the wild-type both techniques reveal a major, slow kinetic component of tau approximately 300 ns while optical data resolve an additional minor kinetic component of tau approximately 10 ns. Whole cells and PS I complexes from the W697FPsaA and S692CPsaA mutants show a significant slowing of the slow kinetic component, whereas the W677FPsaB and S672CPsaB mutants show a less significant slowing of the fast kinetic component. Transient EPR measurements at 260 K show that the slow phase is approximately 3 times slower than at room temperature. Simulations of the early time behavior of the spin polarization pattern of P700+A1-, in which the decay rate of the pattern is assumed to be negligibly small, reproduce the observed EPR spectra at 260 K during the first 100 ns following laser excitation. Thus any spin polarization from P700+FX- in this time window is very weak. From this it is concluded that the relative amplitude of the fast phase is negligible at 260 K or its rate is much less temperature-dependent than that of the slow component. Together, the results demonstrate that the slow kinetic phase results from electron transfer from QK-A to FX and that this accounts for at least 70% of the electrons. Although the assignment of the fast kinetic phase remains uncertain, it is not strongly temperature dependent and it represents a minor fraction of the electrons being transferred. All of the results point toward asymmetry in electron transfer, and indicate that forward transfer in cyanobacterial PS I is predominantly along the PsaA branch.     

Bidirectional electron transfer in photosystem I: accumulation of A0- in A-side or B-side mutants of the axial ligand to chlorophyll A0

Photosystem I contains two potential electron transfer pathways between P(700) and F(X). These branches are made up of the electron transfer chain components A, A(0), and A(1). The primary electron acceptor A(0) is a chlorophyll a monomer that could be one or both of the two chlorophyll molecules, eC-A(3)/eC-B(3), identified in the 2.5 A resolution structure. The eC-A(3)/eC-B(3) chlorophylls are both coordinated by the sulfur atom of a methionine. This coordination is highly unusual, as interactions between the acid Mg(2+) and the soft base sulfur are weak. The eC-A(3)/eC-B(3) chlorophylls also are located close to one of the connecting chlorophylls that may link the antenna and the electron transfer chain chlorophylls. Due to their location in the structure, the eC-A(3)/eC-B(3) chlorophylls may play a role in both excitation energy transfer and electron transfer. To test the role of the eC-A(3)/eC-B(3) chlorophylls in electron transfer, Met-684 of PsaA and Met-664 of PsaB have been changed to His, Ser, and Leu. Replacement of either M(A684) or M(B664) results in a significant alteration in growth phenotype. The His and Leu mutants are very light sensitive in the presence of oxygen. Growth is impaired to a greater extent in the B-side mutants. However, all of the mutants are able to grow anaerobically at comparable rates. The His and Ser mutants all accumulate PSI at a level similar to that of wild type, whereas the Leu mutants have reduced amounts of PSI. Ultrafast transient absorbance measurements show that the (A(0)(-) - A(0)) difference signal accumulates in the MH(A684) and MH(B664) mutants under neutral conditions, demonstrating that electron transfer between A(0)(-) and A(1) is blocked or significantly slowed. The results show that both the A-branch and the B-branch of the ETC are active in PSI from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii.     

Electron transfer in cyanobacterial photosystem I: I. Physiological and spectroscopic characterization of site-directed mutants in a putative electron transfer pathway from A0 through A1 to FX

The Photosystem I (PS I) reaction center contains two branches of nearly symmetric cofactors bound to the PsaA and PsaB heterodimer. From the x-ray crystal structure it is known that Trp697PsaA and Trp677PsaB are pi-stacked with the head group of the phylloquinones and are H-bonded to Ser692PsaA and Ser672PsaB, whereas Arg694PsaA and Arg674PsaB are involved in a H-bonded network of side groups that connects the binding environments of the phylloquinones and FX. The mutants W697FPsaA, W677FPsaB, S692CPsaA, S672CPsaB, R694APsaA, and R674APsaB were constructed and characterized. All mutants grew photoautotrophically, yet all showed diminished growth rates compared with the wild-type, especially at higher light intensities. EPR and electron nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) studies at both room temperature and in frozen solution showed that the PsaB mutants were virtually identical to the wild-type, whereas significant effects were observed in the PsaA mutants. Spin polarized transient EPR spectra of the P700+A1- radical pair show that none of the mutations causes a significant change in the orientation of the measured phylloquinone. Pulsed ENDOR spectra reveal that the W697FPsaA mutation leads to about a 5% increase in the hyperfine coupling of the methyl group on the phylloquinone ring, whereas the S692CPsaA mutation causes a similar decrease in this coupling. The changes in the methyl hyperfine coupling are also reflected in the transient EPR spectra of P700+A1- and the CW EPR spectra of photoaccumulated A1-. We conclude that: (i) the transient EPR spectra at room temperature are predominantly from radical pairs in the PsaA branch of cofactors; (ii) at low temperature the electron cycle involving P700 and A1 similarly occurs along the PsaA branch of cofactors; and (iii) mutation of amino acids in close contact with the PsaA side quinone leads to changes in the spin density distribution of the reduced quinone observed by EPR.     

Electrogenicity at the donor/acceptor sides of cyanobacterial photosystem I

To study electrogenesis the photosystem I particles fromSynechococcus elongatus were incorporated into asolectin liposomes, and fast kinetics of laser flash-induced electric potential difference generation has been measured by a direct electrometric method in proteoliposomes adsorbed on a phospholipid-impregnated collodion film. The photoelectric response has been found to involve three electrogenic stages associated with (i) iron-sulfur center F_x reduction by the primary electron donor P700, (ii) electron transfer between iron-sulfur centers F_x and F_A/F_B, and (iii) reduction of photo-oxidized P700⁺ by reduced cytochromec₅₅₃. The relative magnitudes of phases (ii) and (iii) comprised about 20% of phase (i).     

Extraction of electron acceptor A1 from pea photosystem I

Photosystem I particles were washed twice in either 0, 50 or 100% water-saturated diethyl ether. It was found that the characteristic electron spin resonance signal associated with electron acceptor A₁ was progressively lost with increasing percentage saturation of the ether. Light-induced electron flow to the terminal iron-sulphur acceptors was inhibited although these acceptors were still present and could be chemically reduced. The kinetics of optical measurements of P700⁺ re-reduction at 820 nm following ether washing were consistent with removal of electron acceptor A₁.     

Electrochemical and spectro-kinetic evidence for an intermediate electron acceptor in photosystem I

Absorption changes accompanying light-induced P-700 formation and its decay in the dark at 15 K in Photosystem-I particles poised at various redox potentials have been examined. In unpoised samples, the light-induced absorption change is practically irreversible. At increasingly negative potentials, an increasing fraction of the absorption change, proportional to the fraction of bound iron-sulfur protein chemically reduced, becomes reversible, and the titration curve has a midpoint potential of --530 mV (vs. normal hydrogen electrode). At --66 mV, the P-700 absorption change is 97% reversible. The total P-700-signal amplitude decreases over the same potential span and levels off at about 43% (to slightly over 50% at a substantially higher excitation intensity). These results provide additional support to previous suggestions of an existence of an intermediate electron acceptor located between the primary donor, P-700, and the more stable primary electron acceptor (P-430 or bound iron-sulfur protein).     

Identification of a 19-kDa polypeptide as an Fe-S center apoprotein in the photosystem I primary electron acceptor complex

Treatment of Photosystem I (PSI) with sodium thiocyanate, a chaotropic agent, results in the selective depletion of certain low-molecular-weight polypeptides. A PSI complex obtained following treatment with 0.5 M sodium thiocyanate is significantly depleted of polypeptides of approximately 8, 10, 14, and 16 kDa, relative to an untreated control, but retains approximately 90% of the EPR signal amplitude associated with the iron-sulfur Centers A and B. The only peptides remaining that could not be depleted without a parallel decrease in the signal amplitude of the Fe-S Centers A and B are the 62-kDa reaction center-containing polypeptide and a 19-kDa polypeptide. These results are considered in relation to the identity of the apoprotein of the Fe-S Centers A and B.     

Multiple pathways of charge recombination revealed by the temperature dependence of electron transfer kinetics in cyanobacterial photosystem I

The kinetics of charge recombination in Photosystem I P₇₀₀-F_A/F_B complexes and P₇₀₀-F_X cores lacking the terminal iron?sulfur clusters were studied over a temperatures range of 310 K to 4.2 K. Analysis of the charge recombination kinetics in this temperature range allowed the assignment of backward electron transfer from the different electron acceptors to P₇₀₀⁺. The kinetic and thermodynamic parameters of these recombination reactions were determined. The kinetics of all electron transfer reactions were activation-less below 170 K, the glass transition temperature of the water-glycerol solution. Above this temperature, recombination from [F_A/F_B]^? in P₇₀₀-F_A/F_B complexes was found to proceed along two pathways with different activation energies (E_a). The charge recombination via A_1A has an E_a of ~290 meV and is dominant at temperatures above ~280 K, whereas the direct recombination from F_X^? has an E_a of 22 meV and is prevalent in the 200 K to 270 K temperature range. Charge recombination from the F_X cluster becomes highly heterogeneous at temperatures below 200 K. The conformational mobility of Photosystem I was studied by molecular dynamics simulations. The F_X cluster was found to ‘swing’ by ~30° along the axis between the two sulfur atoms proximal to F_A/F_B. The partial rotation of F_X is accompanied by significant changes of electric potential within the iron?sulfur cluster, which may induce preferential electron localization at different atoms of the F_X cluster. These effects may account for the partial arrest of forward electron transfer and for the heterogeneity of charge recombination observed at the glass transition temperature.     

Properties of the primary electron acceptor complex of photosystem I in the blue green alga Chlorogloea fritschii.

Photooxidation of P700 at low temperatures in membrane fractions from the blue-green alga $\text{Chlorogloea fritschii}$ may be coupled irreversibly to the reduction of a bound ferredoxin. If this ferredoxin is reduced before freezing, P700 photooxidation at low temperatures becomes reversible. This reversible photooxidation is coupled to the reduction of a component with an EPR signal at g = 2.08, 1.88 and 1.78. A complete spectrum of this component has been obtained for the first time. We propose that as in higher plants this component is the primary electron acceptor of Photosystem I, the bound ferredoxin is a secondary electron acceptor. Using ⁵⁷Fe enriched preparations we have shown that the ERP signals attributed to the bound ferredoxin are due to iron containing centres. This experiment did not show the presence of iron in the primary electron acceptor.     

Replacement of the methionine axial ligand to the primary electron acceptor A0 slows the A0 reoxidation dynamics in Photosystem I

The recent crystal structure of photosystem I (PSI) from Thermosynechococcus elongatus shows two nearly symmetric branches of electron transfer cofactors including the primary electron donor, P₇₀₀, and a sequence of electron acceptors, A, A₀ and A₁, bound to the PsaA and PsaB heterodimer. The central magnesium atoms of each of the putative primary electron acceptor chlorophylls, A₀, are unusually coordinated by the sulfur atom of methionine 688 of PsaA and 668 of PsaB, respectively. We [Ramesh et al. (2004a) Biochemistry 43:1369-1375] have shown that the replacement of either methionine with histidine in the PSI of the unicellular green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii resulted in accumulation of A₀⁻ (in 300-ps time scale), suggesting that both the PsaA and PsaB branches are active. This is in contrast to cyanobacterial PSI where studies with methionine-to-leucine mutants show that electron transfer occurs predominantly along the PsaA branch. In this contribution we report that the change of methionine to either leucine or serine leads to a similar accumulation of A₀⁻ on both the PsaA and the PsaB branch of PSI from C. reinhardtii, as we reported earlier for histidine mutants. More importantly, we further demonstrate that for all the mutants under study, accumulation of A₀⁻ is transient, and that reoxidation of A₀⁻ occurs within 1-2 ns, two orders of magnitude slower than in wild type PSI, most likely via slow electron transfer to A₁. This illustrates an indispensable role of methionine as an axial ligand to the primary acceptor A₀ in optimizing the rate of charge stabilization in PSI. A simple energetic model for this reaction is proposed. Our findings support the model of equivalent electron transfer along both cofactor branches in Photosystem I.     

Characterization of a photosystem I core containing P700 and intermediate electron acceptor A1

A new photosystem I core has been isolated that is devoid of the bound iron-sulfur clusters but preserves electron flow from P700 to the intermediate electron acceptor A1. The particle is prepared by incubation of a Synechococcus sp. PCC 6301 photosystem I core protein (which contains electron acceptors A0, A1, and FX) with 3 M urea and 5 mM K3Fe(CN)6 to oxidatively denature the FX iron-sulfur cluster to the level of zero-valence sulfur. In this apo-FX preparation, over 90% of the flash-induced absorption change at 820 nm decays with a 10-microseconds half-time characteristic of the decay of the P700 triplet state formed from the backreaction of P700+ with an acceptor earlier than FX. Chemical reduction at high pH values with aminoiminomethanesulfinic acid results in kinetics identical with those seen in the P700 chlorophyll a protein prepared with sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS-CP1, which contains only electron acceptor A0); the flash-induced absorption change decays primarily with a 25-ns half-time characteristic of the backreaction between P700+ and A0-, and the magnitude of the total absorption change is larger than can be accounted for by the P700 content alone. Addition of oxygen results in a reversion to the 10-microseconds kinetic decay component attributed to the decay of the P700 triplet state. At 77 K, the optical transient in the apo-FX preparation decays with a 200-microseconds half-time characteristic of the backreaction between P700+ and A1-.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Characterization of a redox-active cross-linked complex between cyanobacterial photosystem I and its physiological acceptor flavodoxin.

A covalent complex between photosystem I and flavodoxin from the cyanobacterium Synechococcus sp. PCC 7002 was generated by chemical cross-linking. Laser flash-absorption spectroscopy indicates that the bound flavodoxin of this complex is stabilized in the semiquinone state and is photoreduced to the quinol form upon light excitation. The kinetics of this photoreduction process, which takes place in approximately 50% of the reaction centres, displays three exponential components with half-lives of 9 microsec, 70 microsec and 1 ms. The fully reduced flavodoxin subsequently recombines with P700+ with a t1/2 of 330 ms. A corresponding flavodoxin semiquinone radical signal is readily observed in the dark by room temperature electron paramagnetic resonance, which reversibly disappears upon illumination. In contrast, the light-induced reduction of oxidized flavodoxin can be observed only by first-flash experiments following excessive dark adaptation. In addition, the docking site of flavodoxin on photosystem I was determined by electron microscopy in combination with image analysis. Flavodoxin binds to the cytoplasmic side of photosystem I at a distance of 7 nm from the centre of the trimer and in close contact to a ridge formed by the subunits PsaC, PsaD and PsaE.     

Optical difference spectrum of the electron acceptor Ao in photosystem I

Optical measurements were made during low temperature photoreduction of photosystem I acceptors, A₁ and A₀. In the presence of a significant amount ofA₁ (detected by EPR), no absorbance changes occurred between 750-350 nm, indicating that this species is not a chlorophyll or pheophytin molecule. Spectral changes in this region that may be correlated with the appearance of A⁻₀, suggest that this component is a chlorophyll a anion monomer. The species is present in reaction centres in a ratio of 0.94 A_o/P700.

Photosystem I Primary acceptor Optical difference spectrum Chlorophyll a monomer     

Structure of the primary electron donor in photosystem I: a resonance Raman study

Low-temperature resonance Raman (RR) spectra have been obtained at resonance with the Soret transition of chlorophyll a in photosystem I particles containing large amounts either of the triplet state of P700 or of its radical cation state. Subtracting these spectra from those of resting reaction centers yielded RR spectra of P700 in its neutral, ground state. These spectra arise from two distinct chlorophyll a molecules differing by the strengths of the bonding interactions assumed by their keto carbonyl groups, the stretching frequencies of which are found at 1655 and 1675 cm-1. The present results rule out previous hypotheses that P700 might have consisted of a single, chemically modified chlorophyll a molecule. Neither of the bonding interactions assumed by the keto carbonyls of the P700 chlorophylls most probably involves chlorophyll-chlorophyll bridging through water molecules, as surmised in the so-called special pair models, but likely consists of H bonds with distinct protein sites. The magnesium atoms of the two P700 chlorophylls are 5-coordinated. Hence, the structural model of P700 provided by the present data is qualitatively the same, in terms of bonding interactions, as that currently accepted for the bacterial primary donor.     

Effect of exogenous glucose on electron flow to photosystem I and respiration in cyanobacterial cells

The effects of exogenous glucose on the rates of alternative pathways of photosystem II (PSII)-independent electron flow to PSI and of dark respiration in Synechocystis sp. 6803 cells were studied. The presence of glucose was shown to accelerate the electron flow to P700⁺, the PSI primary electron donor oxidized with Far-red light (FRL), which excites specifically only PSI. An increase in the glucose concentration was accompanied by a further activation of electron flow to PSI, which was supported by the dark donation of reducing equivalents to the electron transport chain. An increase in the external glucose concentration resulted also in the disappearance of lag-phase in the kinetics of P700⁺ reduction, which was observed in the cells incubated without glucose after FRL switching off. A similarity of nonphotochemical processes of electron transfer to PSI in cyanobacteria and higher plants was supposed, basing on the earlier observed fact of the occurrence of such lagphase in higher plants and its dependence on the exhausting of stromal reductants in the light. Acceleration of dark electron flow to PSI in the presence of glucose, a major respiratory substrate, may indicate the coupling between nonphotochemical processes in the photosynthetic and respiratory chains of electron transport in cyanobacterial cells. A close correlation between photosynthesis and respiration in cyanobacterial cells is also confirmed by a sharp acceleration of respiration with an increase in the glucose concentration in medium.     

P700: the primary electron donor of photosystem I.

The primary electron donor of photosystem I, P700, is a chlorophyll species that in its excited state has a potential of approximately -1.2 V. The precise chemical composition and electronic structure of P700 is still unknown. Recent evidence indicates that P700 is a dimer of one chlorophyll (Chl) a and one Chl a'. The Chl a' and Chl a are axially coordinated by His residues provided by protein subunits PsaA and PsaB, respectively. The Chl a', but not the Chl a, is also H-bonded to the protein. The H-bonding is likely responsible for selective insertion of Chl a' into the reaction center. EPR studies of P700(+*) in frozen solution and single crystals indicate a large asymmetry in the electron spin and charge distribution towards one Chl of the dimer. Molecular orbital calculations indicate that H-bonding will specifically stabilize the Chl a'-side of the dimer, suggesting that the unpaired electron would predominantly reside on the Chl a. This is supported by results of specific mutagenesis of the PsaA and PsaB axial His residues, which show that only mutations of the PsaB subunit significantly alter the hyperfine coupling constants associated with a single Chl molecule. The PsaB mutants also alter the microwave induced triplet-minus-singlet spectrum indicating that the triplet state is localized on the same Chl. Excitonic coupling between the two Chl a of P700 is weak due to the distance and overlap of the porphyrin planes. Evidence of excitonic coupling is found in PsaB mutants which show a new bleaching band at 665 nm that likely represents an increased intensity of the upper exciton band of P700. Additional properties of P700 that may give rise to its unusually low potential are discussed.