Cytotoxic T lymphocyte recognition of class I H-2 antigens after DNA-mediated gene transfer

Cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) recognition sites on class I major histocompatibility complex molecules have been investigated by several laboratories by using cloned genes expressed on mouse L cells by DNA-mediated gene transfer. Recombinant genes, constructed by restriction endonuclease treatment of cloned H-2Dd and Ld genes and exchange of the N and C1 exons (exon shuffling) have provided an additional tool. These hybrid H-2 molecules expressed on L cells have been used as targets to achieve more precise localization of site(s) recognized by allospecific and virus-specific CTLs. CTL systems were chosen that limit recognition to either the Dd or Ld alloantigen or to virus and Dd or Ld complexes. Using this approach, we were able to map essential restricting site(s) to the N and/or C1 domains. Additional evidence is presented that the cytoplasmic tail of H-2 may be involved in interactions with some viral antigens and effect the formation of an immunogenic complex.     

Analysis of hybrid H-2D and L antigens with reciprocally mismatched aminoterminal domains: functional T cell recognition requires preservation of fine structural determinants

Studies of immune recognition of hybrid class I antigens expressed on transfected cells have revealed an apparent general requirement that the N(alpha 1) and C1(alpha 2) domains be derived from the same gene in order to preserve recognition by virus-specific H-2-restricted and allospecific T cells. One exception has been the hybrid DL antigen in which the N domain of H-2Ld has been replaced by that of H-2Dd. Cells bearing this molecule serve as targets for some virus and allospecific CTL. Because cells expressing the reciprocal hybrid LD (N domain of H-2Dd replaced by that of H-2Ld) antigen have not been available, it has not been possible to evaluate whether this exception stemmed from the relatedness of H-2Ld and H-2Dd or whether the DL antigen fortuitously preserved some function of the parent molecule as a rare exception. To assess this question, and to evaluate the contribution of the N and C1 domains of H-2Ld and H-2Dd to serologic and T cell recognition, we have constructed the reciprocal chimeric gene pLD (the N exon of H-2Ld substituted for that of H-2Dd), introduced this into mouse L cells by DNA-mediated gene transfer, and analyzed the expressed product biochemically, serologically, and functionally. Transformant L cells expressing either LD or DL antigens were both reactive with a number of anti-H-2Ld or anti-H-2Dd N/C1-specific monoclonal antibodies, indicating the preservation in the hybrid molecules of determinants controlled by discrete domains. Mab binding was generally greater with cells expressing hybrid DL antigen than with those transformants expressing LD molecules. Moreover, the amount of beta 2M associated with DL antigens was more than that associated with LD. Cells expressing hybrid DL antigens were recognized as targets by bulk and cloned allospecific anti-H-2Dd and anti-H-2Ld CTL, whereas cells expressing LD molecules were not recognized by any of the T cells tested. VSV-specific H-2Ld-restricted CTL failed to lyse VSV-infected targets expressing either DL or LD. These results indicate that T cell reactivity of cells expressing the DL hybrid antigen is an exception to the observed general requirement for class I antigens to possess matched N and C1 domains for functional T cell recognition by T cells restricted to parental antigens.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Recognition of the alpha-1 and alpha-2 domains of H-2 molecules by allospecific cloned T cells

Previously we had shown that allospecific bulk cultures of cytolytic T lymphocytes lysed the products of cloned class I major histocompatibility genes expressed after DNA-mediated gene transfer. In these experiments, performed by using cloned allospecific T cell effectors, a T cell hybridoma, and recombinant DNA technology, we have been able to map determinants recognized by these T cell clones to the alpha-1 domain of H-2Dd and the alpha-2 domain of H-2Ld (four of eight clones). Target cells used were L cells (H-2k), expressing wild type or hybrid H-2 antigens of H-2d origin. Thus, for the first time determinants recognized by cloned T cells are found in the recombined alpha-1 and alpha-2 domains.     

Interaction of alpha 1 with alpha 2 region in class I MHC proteins contributes determinants recognized by antibodies and cytotoxic T cells

The structure-function relationship of individual coding regions of class I mouse major histocompatibility complex proteins was studied by a combination of recombinant DNA, gene transfer techniques, and serologic and functional characterization. To examine the role of alpha 1 and alpha 2 regions in antibody and CTL recognition, the third exon of H-2Dd, Kd, and Ld transplantation antigen genes was replaced by the homologous coding region of the Qa-2-coded class I gene, Q6. We have chosen to carry out the exon shuffling experiments between these two different types of class I genes, because they are structurally similar and did not evolve to carry out identical functions. Therefore, it is less likely that the hybrid proteins will fortuitously recreate alpha 1-alpha 2 controlled functionally important determinants. The replacement of H-2 alpha 2 coding region with its Q6 counterpart had different effects on the expression of the three genes. The mutant H-2Dd gene transfected into L cells was expressed at high levels and retained several of the serologic determinants found on parental H-2Dd and Q6 domains. The serologic epitopes on the mutant H-2Kd-transfected cells were detectable at very low levels, whereas the product of the mutant H-2Ld gene could not be identified at all. Analysis of cells transfected with mutant H-2Dd gene with alloreactive and minor antigen(s)-restricted cytotoxic T cells indicated that the hybrid proteins lost the ability to be recognized by T cells. Our data suggest that cytotoxic T cells recognize conformational determinants composed of amino acids from alpha 1 and alpha 2 regions. Alternatively, it could be proposed that T cell recognition sites located in a single alpha 1 or alpha 2 protein region are susceptible to distortion upon alpha 1-alpha 2 interactions. Such susceptibility to conformational changes of the amino-terminal domain of transplantation antigens could be of functional importance for H-2-restricted antigen presentation.     

Biochemical and functional analyses of a secreted H-2Ld molecule.

A truncated H-2Ld gene was constructed by deleting the transmembrane and cytoplasmic exons. The truncated H-2Ld gene was introduced into mouse L cells using the thymidine kinase gene as a selectable marker. Transformants were isolated and screened for the presence of truncated H-2Ld antigen. The truncated H-2Ld gene product was present in both the cytoplasm and culture medium, but not on the cell surface. The truncated H-2Ld antigen was stable in culture medium for at least 9 h and was secreted into the medium at a rate similar to the kinetics with which complete H-2 antigens reach the cell surface. Transformants expressing the truncated H-2Ld molecule were not recognized by cytotoxic T lymphocytes specific for the H-2Ld antigen.     

The products of transferred H-2 genes express determinants that restrict hapten-specific cytotoxic T cells

Cell lines into which cloned H-2 genes had been introduced (i.e., transformants) were used to correlate the genes and their products that are capable of functioning as H-2 restriction elements for hapten-self-(AED and TNP) specific cytotoxic T cells (CTL). These transformants provided a unique system in which major histocompatibility restricted (MHC) T cell recognition could be examined by using cells that express only H-2Ld or only H-2Dd gene products. BALB/c (H-2d) anti AED-self CTL lysed both the H-2Ld and Dd transformants, but not parental, i.e., untransformed, cells. The AED-self lysis of the Ld and Dd transformants was shown to be specifically inhibited by anti-H-2Ld and anti H-2Dd monoclonal antibody, respectively. In contrast to these results, BALB/c anti TNP-self CTL were found to lyse readily the Dd but not Ld transformed lines, supporting reports indicating that H-2Ld-restricted TNP-self CTL could not be detected. The results of this study thus demonstrate that the cell surface products encoded by these transferred MHC class I genes contain self determinants recognized by CTL.     

Structural relationships among the H-2 D-regions of murine MHC haplotypes

The number of genes encoding functional Ag-presenting molecules in the D region of the murine MHC differs among haplotypes. For example, the H-2b D region contains a single "D/L" gene, H-2Db, whereas the d-haplotype encodes two, H-2Dd and Ld. Using D/L specific oligonucleotide probes, we have found that, as with H-2d, the q- and v-haplotypes contain two D/L genes, whereas the other haplotype examined have one. Hybridization analysis using cloned probes that map between H-2Dd and Ld revealed similar structures in each of the three haplotypes (d, q, and v) which have "duplicated" D regions. Two approaches were used to examine allelic relationships among the D/L genes. First, the 5' region of the H-2Db gene was sequenced, and found to be more similar to H-2Ld than to H-2Dd. Second, oligonucleotide probes that distinguish H-2Ld from H-2Dd revealed H-2Ld-related genes in several haplotypes, including the duplicated haplotypes H-2q and H-2v. Analogous probes specific for H-2Dd, however, did not detect similar sequences in the other haplotypes. We interpret these results to mean that the three duplicated D regions arose from a common duplication event, and share the five gene structure of the D region cluster defined in H-2d. However, subsequent events have generated sequence divergence at the D-locus.     

Differential lack of class I H-2d antigen expression by sublines of the BALB/c S49 T cell lymphoma

Five different sublines of the BALB/c murine S49.1 T cell lymphoma were found to exhibit distinct patterns of absence of detectable H-2d class I major histocompatibility antigen expression. The results were demonstrated and verified by a) the generation of H-2Kd-, H-2Dd,Ld-, and H-2Ld-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes that were assayed on S49.1 target cell lines, b) antibody-mediated cytotoxicity with the use of anti-H-2d monoclonal reagents, and c) flow microfluorometry. The five lines investigated were S49.1, T-25, T-25ADH, Thy-1-, and 100/0. None of these lines expressed detectable levels of Ld. S49.1 expressed both Kd and Dd, T-25 and T-25ADH expressed Dd but not Kd or Ld, Thy-1- expressed Kd but not Dd or Ld, and 100.0 did not express any detectable amounts of Kd, Dd, or Ld. These results indicate that K and D (and L) antigens can be expressed independently of each other and suggest that expression of class I antigens is controlled in a locus-specific manner.     

In vitro mutagenesis of a mouse MHC class I gene for the examination of structure-function relationships

Oligonucleotide-directed, site-specific mutagenesis has been employed to elucidate the role of individual amino acids on the expression and function of a MHC class I antigen. Two oligonucleotides were synthesized to introduce single amino acid substitutions in the murine H-2Ld gene. The highly conserved glycosylation site at amino acid position 86 was changed from asparagine to lysine to remove the carbohydrate moiety from the first external domain of the H-2 molecule, and the phenylalanine at position 116 was changed to tyrosine, replacing the Ld residue with the Kb type amino acid analogous to Kb mutants: bm5 and bm16 mutants derived from the Kb antigen have the Ld-type residue at this position. The mutant genes were constructed by annealing the mutagenic oligomers to the single stranded H-2Ld gene, followed by chain elongation reaction. The expected mutations were confirmed by DNA sequence determination. The mutant genes were introduced into mouse L cells by DNA-mediated gene transfer. Both mutant genes expressed the antigens on the cell surface, as detected by antibody binding; these antigens were reactive with the cytotoxic T cells specific for the H-2Ld antigen. Detailed examination with 16 monoclonal anti-H-2Ld antibodies revealed that the binding of some antibodies was significantly reduced in the glycosylation mutant, implying a certain contribution of the carbohydrates to the antigenic activity of some determinants. No detectable changes have been observed in the mutant of the substitution at position 116 by the parameters we tested.     

Properties of H-2L locus products in allogeneic and H-2 restricted, trinitrophenyl-specific cytotoxic responses.

The role of the recently defined L antigen (a second D region product) in allogeneic and TNP-specific syngeneic primary CML responses has been investigated. The lysis by anti-L specific cytotoxic effector cells was not inhibited when the target cells were pretreated with an antiserum directed against K and D, whereas an antiserum against L completely abrogated this response. Therefore, H-2L products are recognized on the target cell independently of H-2K and H-2D locus products. Both A.SW cells as well as B10 cells were found to respond to Ld alloantigens, in addition to Dd alloantigens when stimulated by cells differing only in the D region. The results of cold target blocking and antiserum inhibition experiments failed to detect cytotoxic cells with specificity of L antigens in association with TNP, under conditions in which TNP-specific effectors to K and D antigens were demonstrable. These findings suggest that there is a more limited involvement of H-2L locus products than the H-2K or H-2D locus products in the induction and specificity of these responses.     

Interaction of monoclonal antibodies with MHC class I antigens on mouse spleen cells. II. Levels of expression of H-2K, H-2D, and H-2L in different mouse strains

The numbers of MHC class I molecules expressed by spleen cells from various mouse strains were determined by using MHC-specific monoclonal antibodies and a radioactive binding assay. Although small differences were found to exist in some cases, our general conclusion is that different mice of the same strain, congenic mice of different haplotypes, and syngeneic mice of varying background all express similar numbers of class I antigens. B10.A mice (8 to 10 wk old), for example, express 5.3 X 10(4) Kk molecules/cell, 5.4 X 10(4) Dd molecules/cell, and 2.2 X 10(4) Ld molecules/cell. Some of the differences observed in class I antigen expression included: 1) the level of Kk expression increased to a small but significant extent with age in B10.A mice; 2) female B10.A mice expressed slightly higher amounts of Kk than male mice; and 3) B10.A(2R) and B10.A(4R) recombinant strains expressed elevated levels of K-end antigens and slightly decreased levels of D-end antigens when compared with the unrecombinant B10.A strain. In several strains, F1 mice express approximately 50% as many copies of each parental antigen as do the homozygous parents. B10 mice, which are negative for the L antigen, nevertheless express the same total number of D-end molecules as do B10.A mice. The data suggest that the levels of expression of MHC class I molecules are controlled by at least two factors: gene dosage and another factor(s) that gives rise to the small variations in class I antigen expression seen with age, sex, and strain, and to the low expression of Ld relative to Dd and Kk.     

Flow microfluorometric analysis of H-2L expression

The cell surface expression of H-2L, a major transplantation antigen, was compared by flow microfluorometry to the expression of products of H-2K and H-2D loci, using monoclonal antibodies. By this methodology, the ontogeny and tissue distribution of Ld antigens were found to be indistinguishable from those of the K and D antigens. In a reciprocal blocking assay, using fluorescein-labeled test reagents, it was shown that monoclonals anti-H-2.65 and anti-H-2.64 did not inhibit the binding of each other. These results suggest that the alloantigenic determinants H-2.64 and H-2.65 are located at distinct sites on Ld molecules. Quantitative comparisons using the fluorescein-labeled monoclonal reagents indicated that Ld molecules are expressed at 2- to 3-fold lower levels on the cell surface compared with K and D molecules. These findings give new credence to a "3-locus" model for the major histocompatibility complex of man and mouse, where H-2L and HLA-C share several homologies that are unique and distinguish them from the other histocompatibility loci.     

The nucleotide sequence and comparative analysis of the H-2Dp class I H-2 gene

We present the complete nucleotide sequence and the deduced amino acid sequence of the H-2Dp class I gene. This gene, which was cloned from a B10.P genomic DNA library, encodes and intact, functional H-2Dp molecule. Comparative analysis of the Dp sequence with other class I sequences reveals both similarities and differences. This analysis also shows that these genes exhibit D region-specific, locus-specific, as well as allele-specific sequences. The H-2Dp nucleotide sequence is greater than 90% homologous to the H-2Ld and H-2Db genes and only approximately 85% homologous to the H-2Dd gene. The K region and Qa region genes are less homologous. The 3' noncoding sequences appear to be region-specific. All of the previously described D region genes, Db, Ld, and Dd, possess the B2-SINE Alu-like repetitive sequence, as does Dp. Thus, this B2 repeat is a region-specific marker present in all D region genes studied so far. The additional polyadenylation site found in the H-2Dp gene starting at nucleotide 4671, which is homologous to non-D region sequences, as well as unique protein Dp coding sequences, make this gene an interesting model for studying the evolution of polymorphism and structure/function relationships in the class I gene family.     

Construction of novel class I histocompatibility antigens by interspecies exon shuffling

Human and mouse class I histocompatibility antigens share considerable structural homology at both the protein and DNA sequence level. This homology has allowed the production of hybrid class I molecules by the reciprocal exchange of DNA sequences corresponding to equivalent domains of HLA-B7 and either H-2Ld or H-2Dd. It is shown that these genes give rise to protein products that are stably expressed on the surface of murine L cells after DNA-mediated gene transfer. These proteins express only those monoclonal antibody-defined H-2 determinants that are expected based on their genetic construction. The molecules have allowed the localization of a number of polymorphic and monomorphic HLA-specific epitopes. In all but one case, expression of an epitope on a domain does not appear to be influenced by the replacement of adjacent human domains with their murine equivalents, suggesting a considerable degree of structural independence of the domains. Cells expressing the hybrid molecules have also been tested as targets for a panel of HLA-B7-specific cytotoxic T cell clones. The results show that the polymorphic determinants recognized by these clones map to the alpha 1 and alpha 2 domains of the HLA-B7 molecule. No evidence for an influence of species-related amino acid sequence differences in the third extracellular domain on T cell recognition was seen. The results are discussed in light of the proposed domain structure of the class I proteins and the potential use of such molecules for further functional studies.     

Clonal variation in cell surface display of an H-2 protein lacking a cytoplasmic tail

Truncated variants of the gene encoding H-2Ld, an integral membrane protein encoded by the major histocompatibility complex, were constructed by in vitro mutagenesis to elucidate the function of charged amino acids found on the cytoplasmic side of the transmembrane (TM) region. Analysis of cloned L cells transfected with these genes shows that the seven amino acids following the TM segment, four of which are basic, enhance the cell surface expression of H-2Ld protein but are not required for it. However, some clones do not express a tailless H-2Ld protein on the cell surface but express it intracellularly where it has a long half-life. Turnover measurements on cell surface H-2Ld proteins suggest that the basic residues following the TM segment are not a "stop transfer" sequence (Blobel, G., 1980, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA., 77:1496-1500) which anchors the H-2Ld protein in the membrane. Pulse-chase and endoglycosidase H sensitivity studies show that H-2Ld proteins lacking some or all of the basic residues and H-2Ld proteins which have a full-length cytoplasmic tail are processed with different kinetics. These results suggest an involvement of the membrane-proximal region of the cytoplasmic tail in the intracellular transport of H-2Ld. We further suggest that the L cell clones which do and do not express a tailless H-2Ld protein on the cell surface differ in the ability to transport a tailless integral membrane protein to the cell surface.     

Genetic analysis of the H-2D region using a new intra-D-region recombinant mouse strain

A rare D-region recombination event which gave rise to the B10.RQDB major histocompatibility complex haplotype has been examined to ascertain the nature of the crossover and to determine which class I genes are present in the new alignment of D-region genes. Serologic analysis have shown that the B10 . RQDB major histocompatibility complex recombinant mouse inherited the H-2Dd gene from the B10.T(6R) parental line and the H-2Db gene from the B10.A(2R) parental line, representing the first example of an intra-D-region crossover resulting from an intercross. Previous molecular genetic analyses of the d and b haplotypes revealed structural diversity in the organization of their D-region gene clusters. Hence, the D region is comprised of five class I genes in the d haplotype and only one in the b haplotype. Because allelic relationships among the various D-region genes are not defined, either a homologous or nonhomologous alignment of genes has generated the RQDB crossover. Therefore, the possibility that all three D-region antigen-presenting molecules (Dd, Ld, and Db) might be encoded by the RQDB haplotype was examined. Fluorescence-activated cell sorter and cytotoxic T lymphocyte analyses revealed no detectable levels of H-2Ld cell-surface expression, confirming earlier studies with antibody-mediated cytotoxicity and immunoprecipitation. Southern blot analysis localized the recombination point to within a 1-kb region at the centromeric end of the H-2Ld gene on the B10 . T(6R) chromosome in a region of high homology to the H-2Db gene on the B10 . A(2R) chromosome. Together, these studies define the D region of the RQDB haplotype as containing the five class I genes: Dd, D2d, D3d, D4d, and Db. In addition to providing insight into rare recombination events in the D region, the B10.RQDB mouse should be a useful tool for exploring the function of D-region genes.