Unexpected anisotropy in substrate cleavage rates by asymmetric hammerhead ribozymes.

RNA substrates which form relatively short helices I and III with hammerhead ribozymes are generally cleaved more rapidly than substrates which create longer binding helices. We speculated that for optimum cleavage rates, one of the helices needed to be relatively weak. To identify this helix, a series of ribozymes and substrates of varying lengths were made such that in the complex, helices I and III consisted of 5 and 10 bp respectively or vice versa. In two independent systems, substrates in the complexes with the shorter helix I and longer helix III were cleaved one to two orders of magnitude more rapidly than those in the complexes with the longer helix I and shorter helix III. Similar results were obtained whether the numbers of base pairs in helices I and III were limited either by the length of the hybridizing arms of the ribozyme or the length of the substrate. The phenomenon was observed for both all-RNA and DNA armed ribozymes. Thus, a relatively short helix I is required for fast cleavage rates in pre-formed hammer-head ribozyme-substrate complexes. When helix III has 10 bp, the optimum length for helix I is approximately 5 bp.     

Determination of hammerhead ribozyme kinetic constants at high molar ratio ribozyme-substrate

 Hammerhead ribozymes provide valuable tools in the field of gene therapy due to their cleavage specificity and the broad range of RNA targets. A major prerequisite for the selection of suitable ribozymes for in vivo application is represented by in vitro determination of ribozyme cleavage kinetic constants. From the experimental cleavage data, kinetic constants are usually calculated under the assumption of rapid conversion of the substrate into the ribozyme-substrate complex. However, this condition is often not satisfied for ribozymes carrying additional RNA stretches, due to cloning strategies or necessary for ribozyme expression in the cell. To overcome this problem, we propose a mathematical model which is able to calculate ribozyme kinetic constants in the case of non-rapid conversion of substrate into ribozyme-substrate complex. In addition, our system gives the opportunity to evaluate the nature of the S conversion into ES through the determination of a model parameter. The validity of the proposed model is restricted to the hypothesis of a ribozyme excess over the substrate at the beginning of the cleavage reaction and to the absence of any mass exchange with the external environment. Received: 1 February 2001 / Revised version: 1 September 2001 / Published online: 23 August 2002     

Length variation of helix III in a hammerhead ribozyme and its influence on cleavage activity

The previously described HIV-1 directed hammerhead ribozyme 2as-Rz12 can form with its target RNA 2s helices I and III of 128 and 278 base pairs (bp). A series of derivatives was made in which helix III was truncated to 8, 5, 4, 3, and 2 nucleotides (nt). These asymmetric hammerhead ribozymes were tested for in vitro cleavage and for inhibition of HIV-1 replication in human cells. Truncation of helix III to 8 bp did not affect the in vitro cleavage potential of the parental catalytic antisense RNA 2as-Rz12. Further truncation of helix III led to decreased cleavage rates, with no measurable cleavage activity for the 2 bp construct. All catalytically active constructs showed complex cleavage kinetics. Three kinetic subpopulations of ribozyme-substrate complexes could be discriminated that were cleaved with fast or slow rates or not at all. Gel purification of preformed ribozyme-substrate complexes led to a significant increase in cleavage rates. However, the complex cleavage pattern remained. In mammalian cells, the helix III-truncated constructs showed the same but no increased inhibitory effect of the comparable antisense RNA on HIV-1 replication.     

Interaction between hammerhead ribozyme and RNA substrates measured by a surface plasmon resonance biosensor

Dynamic interactions between hammerhead ribozymes and RNA substrates were measured using the surface plasmon resonance (SPR) technology. Two in vitro transcribed substrates (non-cleavable and cleavable) were immobilised on streptavidin-coated dextran matrices and subsequently challenged with non-related yeast tRNA or two hammerhead ribozymes, both of which had previously been shown to exhibit functional binding and cleavage of complementary target RNAs. The target-binding domain of one of the ribozymes was fully complementary to a 16-ribonucleotide stretch on the immobilised substrates, while the other ribozyme had a nine-ribonucleotide complementarity. The two ribozymes could readily be differentiated with regard to affinity. Cleavage could be measured, using the ribozyme with full target complementarity to the cleavable substrate. In contrast, the ribozyme with lower affinity lacked cleavage activity. We suggest that SPR will be useful for investigations of ribozyme-substrate interactions.     

Energetic contribution of non-essential 5' sequence to catalysis in a hepatitis delta virus ribozyme

Hepatitis delta virus (HDV) ribozymes employ multiple catalytic strategies to achieve overall rate enhancement of RNA cleavage. These strategies include general acid-base catalysis by a cytosine side chain and involvement of divalent metal ions. Here we used a trans-acting form of the antigenomic ribozyme to examine the contribution of the 5' sequence in the substrate to HDV ribozyme catalysis. The cleavage rate constants increased for substrates with 5' sequence alterations that reduced ground-state binding to the ribozyme. Quantitatively, a plot of activation free energy of chemical conversion versus Gibb's free energy of substrate binding revealed a linear relationship with a slope of -1. This relationship is consistent with a model in which components of the substrate immediately 5' to the cleavage site in the HDV ribozyme-substrate complex destabilize ground-state binding. The intrinsic binding energy derived from the ground-state destabilization could contribute up to 2 kcal/mol toward the total 8.5 kcal/mol reduction in activation free energy for RNA cleavage catalyzed by the HDV ribozyme.     

A comparison of the in vitro activity of DNA-armed and all-RNA hammerhead ribozymes.

Hammerhead ribozymes targeted against two unrelated RNA substrates have been prepared. For each substrate, four ribozymes, differing in their hybridising arm length and composition (DNA or RNA), have been synthesised and kinetically characterised. The presence of DNA in the hybridising arms had little effect on the overall cleavage rate when the cleavage step was rate determining. Shortening each of the hybridising arms of ribozymes from 10 to 6 nucleotides generally resulted in modest changes in rate constants for cleavage of the same 13mer substrate. In one case the presence of long RNA hybridising arms significantly impeded the cleavage reaction. Cleavage rates displayed first order dependence on hydroxide ion concentration at low pHs. At higher pH, some ribozymes deviated from this first order dependence because of a change in the rate-determining step, possibly due to a requirement for a conformation change in the ribozyme-substrate complex prior to cleavage. Ribozyme cleavage was strongly dependent on temperature in the range 5-45 degrees C, with an activation energy for the reaction of approximately 60 kJ mol-1. The ribozymes displayed biphasic dependence on magnesium ion concentration; evidence of strong apparent binding (Kd approximately 10 mM) as well as a looser interaction was observed for all ribozymes.     

Essential nucleotide sequences and secondary structure elements of the hairpin ribozyme.

In vitro selection experiments have been used to isolate active variants of the 50 nt hairpin catalytic RNA motif following randomization of individual ribozyme domains and intensive mutagenesis of the ribozyme-substrate complex. Active and inactive variants were characterized by sequencing, analysis of RNA cleavage activity in cis and in trans, and by substrate binding studies. Results precisely define base-pairing requirements for ribozyme helices 3 and 4, and identify eight essential nucleotides (G8, A9, A10, G21, A22, A23, A24 and C25) within the catalytic core of the ribozyme. Activity and substrate binding assays show that point mutations at these eight sites eliminate cleavage activity but do not significantly decrease substrate binding, demonstrating that these bases contribute to catalytic function. The mutation U39C has been isolated from different selection experiments as a second-site suppressor of the down mutants G21U and A43G. Assays of the U39C mutation in the wild-type ribozyme and in a variety of mutant backgrounds show that this variant is a general up mutation. Results from selection experiments involving populations totaling more than 10(10) variants are summarized, and consensus sequences including 16 essential nucleotides and a secondary structure model of four short helices, encompassing 18 bp for the ribozyme-substrate complex are derived.     

Kinetics of hairpin ribozyme cleavage in yeast.

Hairpin ribozymes catalyze a self-cleavage reaction that provides a simple model for quantitative analyses of intracellular mechanisms of RNA catalysis. Decay rates of chimeric mRNAs containing self-cleaving ribozymes give a direct measure of intracellular cleavage kinetics in yeast. Intracellular ribozyme-mediated cleavage occurs at similar rates and shows similar inhibition by ribozyme mutations as ribozyme-mediated reactions in vitro, but only when ribozymes are located in a favorable mRNA sequence context. The impact of cleavage on mRNA abundance is shown to depend directly on intrinsic mRNA stability. Surprisingly, cleavage products are no more labile than uncleaved mRNAs despite the loss of terminal cap structures or poly (A).     

Design and specificity of hammerhead ribozymes against calretinin mRNA.

We obtained a partial sequence of mouse calretinin mRNA from cDNA clones, and designed hammerhead ribozymes to cleave positions within it. With a view to optimising hammerhead ribozymes for eliminating the mRNA in vivo, we varied the length and sequence of the three duplex 'arms' and measured the cleavage of long RNA substrates in vitro at 37 degrees C (as well as 50 degrees C). Precise cleavage occurred, but it could only go to completion with a large excess of ribozyme. The evidence suggests that the rate-limiting step with a large target is not the cleavage, but the formation of the active ribozyme: substrate complex. The efficiency varied unpredictably according to the target site, the length of the substrate RNA, and the length of the ribozyme; secondary structure in vitro may be responsible. We particularly investigated the degree of sequence-specificity. Some mismatches could be tolerated, but shortening of the total basepairing with the substrate to less than 14 bp drastically reduced activity, implying that interaction with weakly-matched RNAs is unlikely to be a serious problem in vivo. These results suggest that specific and complete cleavage of a mRNA in vivo should be possible, given high-level expression of a ribozyme against a favourable target site.     

A nested double pseudoknot is required for self-cleavage activity of both the genomic and antigenomic hepatitis delta virus ribozymes.

The crystal structure of a genomic hepatitis delta virus (HDV) ribozyme 3' cleavage product predicts the existence of a 2 bp duplex, P1.1, that had not been previously identified in the HDV ribozymes. P1.1 consists of two canonical C-G base pairs stacked beneath the G.U wobble pair at the cleavage site and would appear to pull together critical structural elements of the ribozyme. P1.1 is the second stem of a second pseudoknot in the ribozyme, making the overall fold of the ribozyme a nested double pseudoknot. Sequence comparison suggests the potential for P1.1 and a similar fold in the antigenomic ribozyme. In this study, the base pairing requirements of P1.1 for cleavage activity were tested in both the genomic and antigenomic HDV ribozymes by mutagenesis. In both sequences, cleavage activity was severely reduced when mismatches were introduced into P1.1, but restored when alternative base pairing combinations were incorporated. Thus, P1.1 is an essential structural element required for cleavage of both the genomic and antigenomic HDV ribozymes and the model for the antigenomic ribozyme secondary structure should also be modified to include P1.1.     

Design of hairpin ribozyme variants with improved activity for poorly processed substrates

Application of ribozymes for knockdown of RNA targets requires the identification of suitable target sites according to the consensus sequence. For the hairpin ribozyme, this was originally defined as Y?2 N?1 *G+1 U+2 Y+3 B+?, with Y = U or C, and B = U, C or G, and C being the preferred nucleobase at positions -2 and +4. In the context of development of ribozymes for destruction of an oncogenic mRNA, we have designed ribozyme variants that efficiently process RNA substrates at U?2 G?1 *G+1 U+2 A+3 A+? sites. Substrates with G?1 *G+1 U+2 A+3 sites were previously shown to be processed by the wild-type hairpin ribozyme. However, our study demonstrates that, in the specific sequence context of the substrate studied herein, compensatory base changes in the ribozyme improve activity for cleavage (eight-fold) and ligation (100-fold). In particular, we show that A+3 and A+? are well tolerated if compensatory mutations are made at positions 6 and 7 of the ribozyme strand. Adenine at position +4 is neutralized by G? →U, owing to restoration of a Watson-Crick base pair in helix 1. In this ribozyme-substrate complex, adenine at position +3 is also tolerated, with a slightly decreased cleavage rate. Additional substitution of A? with uracil doubled the cleavage rate and restored ligation, which was lost in variants with A?, C? and G?. The ability to cleave, in conjunction with the inability to ligate RNA, makes these ribozyme variants particularly suitable candidates for RNA destruction.     

Evidence for processivity and two-step binding of the RNA substrate from studies of J1/2 mutants of the Tetrahymena ribozyme.

J1/2 of the Tetrahymena ribozyme, a sequence of three A residues, connects the RNA-binding site to the catalytic core. Addition or deletion of bases from J1/2 improves turnover and substrate specificity in the site-specific endonuclease reaction catalyzed by this ribozyme: G2CCCUCUA5 (S) + G in-equilibrium G2CCCUCU (P) + GA5. These paradoxical enhancements are caused by decreased affinity of the ribozyme for S and P [Young, B., Herschlag, D., & Cech, T.R. (1991) Cell 67, 1007]. An additional property of these mutant ribozymes, decreased fidelity of RNA cleavage, is now analyzed. (Fidelity is the ability to cleave at the correct phosphodiester bond within a particular RNA substrate.) Introduction of deoxy residues to give "chimeric" ribo/deoxyribooligonucleotides changes the positions of incorrect cleavage. Previous work indicated that S is bound to the ribozyme by both base pairing and teritary interactions involving 2'-hydroxyl groups of S. The data herein strongly suggest that the P1 duplex, which consists of S base-paired with the 5' exon binding site of the ribozyme, can dock into tertiary interactions in different registers; different 2'-hydroxyl groups of S plug into tertiary contacts with the ribozyme in the different registers. It is concluded that the mutations decrease fidelity by increasing the probability of docking out of register relative to docking in the normal register, thereby giving cleavage at different positions along S. These data also show that the contribution of J1/2 to the teritiary interactions is indirect, not direct. Thus, a structural role of the nonconserved J1/2 is indicated: this sequence positions S to optimize tertiary binding interactions and to ensure cleavage at the phosphodiester bond corresponding to the 5' splice site. Substitution of sulfur for the nonbridging pro-RP oxygen atom at the normal cleavage site has no effect on (kcat/Km)S but decreases the fraction of cleavage at the normal site in reactions catalyzed by the -3A mutant ribozyme, which has all three A residues of J1/2 removed. Thus, the ribozyme chooses where to cleave S after rate-limiting binding of S, indicating that docking can change after binding and suggesting that the ribozyme could act processively. Indeed, it is shown that the +2A ribozyme cleaves at one position along an RNA substrate and then, before releasing that RNA product, cleaves it again.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Oligonucleotide facilitators may inhibit or activate a hammerhead ribozyme.

Facilitators are oligonucleotides capable of affecting hammerhead ribozyme activity by interacting with the substrate at the termini of the ribozyme. Facilitator effects were determined in vitro using a system consisting of a ribozyme with 7 nucleotides in every stem sequence and two substrates with inverted facilitator binding sequences. The effects of 9mer and 12mer RNA as well as DNA facilitators which bind either adjacent to the 3'- or 5'-end of the ribozyme were investigated. A kinetic model was developed which allows determination of the apparent dissociation constant of the ribozyme-substrate complex from single turnover reactions. We observed a decreased dissociation constant of the ribozyme-substrate complex due to facilitator addition corresponding to an additional stabilization energy of delta delta G=-1.7 kcal/mol with 3'-end facilitators. The cleavage rate constant was increased by 3'-end facilitators and decreased by 5'-end facilitators. Values for Km were slightly lowered by all facilitators and kcat was increased by 3'-end facilitators and decreased by 5'-end facilitators in our system. Generally the facilitator effects increased with the length of the facilitators and RNA provided greater effects than DNA of the same sequence. Results suggest facilitator influences on several steps of the hammerhead reaction, substrate association, cleavage and dissociation of products. Moreover, these effects are dependent in different manners on ribozyme and substrate concentration. This leads to the conclusion that there is a concentration dependence whether activation or inhibition is caused by facilitators. Conclusions are drawn with regard to the design of hammerhead ribozyme facilitator systems.     

Structural flexibility and the thermodynamics of helix exchange constrain attenuation and allosteric activation of hammerhead ribozyme TRAPs

Perturbations of precleavage equilibria in RNA-cleaving ribozymes can be exploited to control cleavage kinetics. In the targeted ribozyme-attenuated probes (TRAP) design, antisense and attenuator sequences are appended onto the catalytic core of a ribozyme or deoxyribozyme. The attenuator anneals to conserved bases in the catalytic core to form an inactive conformation, which is activated upon binding of a sense strand oligonucleotide to the antisense module. In this work, the apparent Michaelis-Menton constant (K'm) for the binding of the RNA substrate to the ribozyme is shown to be within a factor of 2 for a number of constructs whose observed cleavage rates varied by several 100-fold. These observations rule out models of allosteric regulation based on modulation of substrate binding affinity, instead favoring a model in which regulation arises from equilibration between the active and inactive conformations of the TRAP. Free energies of formation for isolated helices that are exchanged during this reequilibration were determined from the concentration dependence of optical melt data. These values established that the thermodynamic stabilities of sense-antisense duplexes and of the attenuator-core duplexes correlate with observed rates of cleavage. Notably reduced cleavage rates are observed for TRAP ribozymes with extended antisense sequences, suggesting that tight binding of attenuator to the core is assisted by a long antisense portion. A construct with a 25-nucleotide antisense showed greater than 730-fold activation upon annealing with a 20-nucleotide DNA sense strand oligo, representing the greatest activation observed to date for the TRAP design.     

Nucleic acid binding and chaperone properties of HIV-1 Gag and nucleocapsid proteins

The Gag polyprotein of HIV-1 is essential for retroviral replication and packaging. The nucleocapsid (NC) protein is the primary region for the interaction of Gag with nucleic acids. In this study, we examine the interactions of Gag and its NC cleavage products (NCp15, NCp9 and NCp7) with nucleic acids using solution and single molecule experiments. The NC cleavage products bound DNA with comparable affinity and strongly destabilized the DNA duplex. In contrast, the binding constant of Gag to DNA was found to be ~10-fold higher than that of the NC proteins, and its destabilizing effect on dsDNA was negligible. These findings are consistent with the primary function of Gag as a nucleic acid binding and packaging protein and the primary function of the NC proteins as nucleic acid chaperones. Also, our results suggest that NCp7's capability for fast sequence-nonspecific nucleic acid duplex destabilization, as well as its ability to facilitate nucleic acid strand annealing by inducing electrostatic attraction between strands, likely optimize the fully processed NC protein to facilitate complex nucleic acid secondary structure rearrangements. In contrast, Gag's stronger DNA binding and aggregation capabilities likely make it an effective chaperone for processes that do not require significant duplex destabilization.     

Detailed analysis of stem I and its 5' and 3' neighbor regions in the trans-acting HDV ribozyme.

To determine the stem I structure of the human hepatitis delta virus (HDV) ribozyme, which is related to the substrate sequence in the trans -acting system, we kinetically studied stem I length and sequences. Stem I extension from 7 to 8 or 9 bp caused a loss of activity and a low amount of active complex with 9 bp in the trans -acting system. In a previous report, we presented cleavage in a 6 bp stem I. The observed reaction rates indicate that the original 7 bp stem I is in the most favorable location for catalytic reaction among the possible 6-8 bp stems. To test base specificity, we replaced the original GC-rich sequence in stem I with AU-rich sequences containing six AU or UA base pairs with the natural +1G.U wobble base pair at the cleavage site. The cis -acting AU-rich molecules demonstrated similar catalytic activity to that of the wild-type. In trans -acting molecules, due to stem I instability, reaction efficiency strongly depended on the concentration of the ribozyme-substrate complex and reaction temperature. Multiple turnover was observed at 37 degreesC, strongly suggesting that stem I has no base specificity and more efficient activity can be expected under multiple turnover conditions by substituting several UA or AU base pairs into stem I. We also studied the substrate damaging sequences linked to both ends of stem I for its development in therapeutic applications and confirmed the functions of the unique structure.     

Trans-acting glmS catalytic riboswitch: locked and loaded

A recently discovered class of gene regulatory RNAs, coined riboswitches, are commonly found in noncoding segments of bacterial and some eukaryotic mRNAs. Gene up- or down-regulation is triggered by binding of a small organic metabolite, which typically induces an RNA conformational change. Unique among these noncoding RNAs is the glmS catalytic riboswitch, or ribozyme, found in the 5'-untranslated region of the glmS gene in Gram-positive bacteria. It is activated by glucosamine-6-phosphate (GlcN6P), leading to site-specific backbone cleavage of the mRNA and subsequent repression of the glmS gene, responsible for cellular GlcN6P production. Recent biochemical and structural evidence suggests that the GlcN6P ligand acts as a coenzyme and participates in the cleavage reaction without inducing a conformational change. To better understand the role of GlcN6P in solution structural dynamics and function, we have separated the glmS riboswitch core from Bacillus subtilis into a trans-cleaving ribozyme and an externally cleaved substrate. We find that trans cleavage is rapidly activated by nearly 5000-fold to a rate of 4.4 min(-1) upon addition of 10 mM GlcN6P, comparable to the cis-acting ribozyme. Fluorescence resonance energy transfer suggests that this ribozyme-substrate complex does not undergo a global conformational change upon ligand binding in solution. In addition, footprinting at nucleotide resolution using terbium(III) and RNase V1 indicates no significant changes in secondary and tertiary structure upon ligand binding. These findings suggest that the glmS ribozyme is fully folded in solution prior to binding its activating ligand, supporting recent observations in the crystalline state.     

Properties of antigenomic hepatitis delta virus ribozyme cis- and trans- analogs

A series of permuted variants of antigenomic HDV ribozyme and trans-acting variants were constructed. The catalytic activity study of the ribozymes has shown that all the variants were capable of self-cleaving with equally biphasic kinetics. Ribonuclease and Fe(II)-EDTA cleavage have provided evidence that all designed ribozymes fold according to the pseudoknot model and the conformations of the initial and cleaved ribozyme are different. A scheme of HDV ribozyme self-cleavage reaction was suggested. The role of hydrogen bonds in the reaction was evaluated by substitution of ribose in the ribozyme for deoxyribose. It was found that the 2'-OH group of U23 and C27 is critical for the reaction to occur; the 2'-OH group of U32 and U39 is important, while 2'-OH groups of other nucleotides of loop 3, stem 4 and stem 1 are unimportant for the cleavage activity.