Double labelling of cells with tritiated thymidine and bromodeoxyuridine reveals a circadian rhythm-dependent variation in duration of DNA synthesis and S phase flux rates in rodent oral epithelium

Abstract. We describe a double labelling method for estimating the duration of DNA synthesis (Ts) and the flux of cells into and from the S phase of the cell cycle, based on labelling with tritiated thymidine ([³H]TdR) followed by bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) and combining immunohistological detection of BrdU with conventional autoradiography. In practice, the change in size of a window of double labelled cells occurs as the time interval between the two labels increases. In mouse tongue epithelium there is a marked circadian variation in the number of cells in DNA synthesis. From 0900 to 1500 h this labelling index (LI) falls, but from 2100 to 0300 h it increases. Our results show that the circadian decrease in LI is associated with a short Ts (5·8 ± 0·3 h), a high S phase efflux and an initially low influx of cells from G_: into S. Conversely, the rising circadian LI is associated with a longer Ts (9.4 ± 0.1 h), an initially low efflux and a moderate to high influx. Two time-points exist on the circadian LI curve when influx and efflux rates change abruptly. At 0100 h the efflux rate rises from low (5 cells %/h) to high (15–16 cells %/h) and simultaneously the influx rate changes from high to low. Similarly at 1300–1400 h, efflux rate falls from high (19–20 cells %/h) to low (4–8 cells %/h) values and influx rates change from low to high. This double labelling method has revealed that the duration of DNA synthesis varies across the circadian cycle, as do influx and efflux values which generally fall within a discrete range of high or low values. The timing of the changes in flux suggests the presence of two 'control' points on the circadian LI cycle that were previously unrecognized.     

Circadian variation of DNA replication in hamster cheek pouch epithelium analysed by tritiated thymidine labelling, flow sorting and autoradiography: no resting S phase cells in the normal epithelium

In the normal hamster cheek pouch epithelium, cell proliferation takes place with a pronounced circadian rhythm. We tested our previous hypothesis that all cells having S phase DNA content are actively synthesizing DNA and thus participating in the daily cohort of proliferating cells. We found no evidence of resting S phase cells in the normal epithelium. Using labelling with tritiated thymidine followed by fluorescence activated cell sorting according to DNA content and by autoradiography of the sorted nuclei, it was demonstrated that during the 24 h period almost all cells with mid S phase DNA content were active in DNA synthesis.     

Double labelling of tissue combining tritiated thymidine autoradiography with immunodetection of bromodeoxyuridine: the autoradiographic significance of inhibition of thymidine incorporation into DNA by bromodeoxyuridine given simultaneously

We describe a reproducible method for combining tritiated thymidine ([H]TdR) autoradiography with immunoperoxidase detection of bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) in paraffin-embedded tissues. The technique has been used to examine, in mouse tongue epithelium, the inhibition of incorporation into DNA of [3H]TdR by a simultaneous injection of BrdU in the doses that both compounds are likely to be used in cell proliferation studies. The significance that this inhibition has on prolongation of autoradiograph exposure times, to ensure that all cells that incorporate [3H]TdR are scored as positive, in particular the most lightly labelled cells, has been quantified. The inhibition of uptake into DNA of [3H]TdR from 0.23 to 1.85 MBq (6.25 to 50 mu Ci) per animal, produced by a simultaneous injection of 2.5 mg BrdU shows a linear, dose-dependent relationship. Provided the injected dose (in mu Ci per animal) multiplied by the autoradiographic exposure time (in days) is greater than a value of 700, then all cells that are labelled after incorporation of [3H]TdR alone are also labelled after simultaneous double labelling, despite the latter producing a lower average grain count.     

Double labelling of tissue combining tritiated thymidine autoradiography with immunodetection of bromodeoxyuridine: the autoradiographic significance of inhibition of thymidine incorporation into DNA by bromodeoxyuridine given simultaneously

Abstract We describe a reproducible method for combining tritiated thymidine ([³H]TdR) autoradiography with immunoperoxidase detection of bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) in paraffin-embedded tissues. The technique has been used to examine, in mouse tongue epithelium, the inhibition of incorporation into DNA of [³H]TdR by a simultaneous injection of BrdU in the doses that both compounds are likely to be used in cell proliferation studies. The significance that this inhibition has on prolongation of autoradiograph exposure times, to ensure that all cells that incorporate [³H]TdR are scored as positive, in particular the most lightly labelled cells, has been quantified.
The inhibition of uptake into DNA of [³H]TdR from 0.23 to 1.85 MBq (6.25 to 50 μCi) per animal, produced by a simultaneous injection of 2.5 mg BrdU shows a linear, dose-dependent relationship. Provided the injected dose (in μCi per animal) multiplied by the autoradiographic exposure time (in days) is greater than a value of 700, then all cells that are labelled after incorporation of [³H]TdR alone are also labelled after simultaneous double labelling, despite the latter producing a lower average grain count.     

Circadian variations in the DNA synthesis of the rat corneal epithelium. A study using double labelling with tritiated thymidine

A prominent circadian rhythm was found in the labelling indices (LI) of the peripheral rat corneal epithelium and of the adjacent conjunctival epithelium, while almost no diurnal variation was found in the central area. Application of a double labelling technique indicated that there are rhythmic pulses of high and low influx of cells into the S phase and similar pulses of efflux of cells from the S phase. Results of the study indicate that there are different cohorts of cycling cells all over the rat corneal epithelium. Cells belonging to a rapidly proliferating cohort are observed in the peripheral cornea. There is a gradual reduction in the fraction of labelled DNA-synthesizing cells towards the centre. The considerably lower fraction of cells taking up tritiated thymidine (3H)TdR in the central cornea may be due to a higher fraction of basal cells having reached higher levels of differentiation. This may result in a shift from the salvage to the de novo pathway. The slowly proliferating cohort seems to have a prolonged S phase duration and displays practically no diurnal variation in the LI. The DNA-synthesizing cells belonging to this latter cohort probably use the salvage pathway for DNA synthesis resulting in uptake of (3H)TdR all over the cornea. The LI is thus not a reliable indicator of cell proliferation in the corneal epithelium, due both to the heterogeneity of the cell proliferation, and in particular due to the lack of labelling of the centrally located DNA-synthesizing cells. To what extent these properties may also be present in other proliferating tissues with different levels of differentiations, may be questioned.     

DNA-synthesizing cells in oral epithelium have a range of cell cycle durations: evidence from double-labelling studies using tritiated thymidine and bromodeoxyuridine

Mouse tongue epithelium is characterized by a circadian variation in the number of DNA-synthesizing cells (labelling index, LI). Cells undergoing DNA synthesis were labelled with tritiated thymidine [( 3H]TdR) at 0300 (peak LI) or 1200 h (low LI). The fate of these cells was assessed by injecting animals with bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) at intervals from 12-48 h after [3H]TdR, to follow them from one cell cycle to the next. Labelling was revealed by combining [3H]TdR autoradiography with immunoperoxidase detection of BrdU in the same sections. A single peak in the appearance of double-labelled cells was seen at 44 h, if [3H]TdR was given at 1200 h; following [3H]TdR at 0300 h, a peak of double labelling was seen at 48 h with the possibility of smaller peaks at 24 h and 36 h. These results show that the 24 h periodicity in LI in this tissue is associated with a predominant cell cycle duration of 44-48 h, but that a few cells cycle more quickly. Double labelling with [3H]TdR and BrdU provides a useful method for establishing cell cycle duration by labelling S-phase cells in successive cell cycles.     

DNA-synthesizing cells in oral epithelium have a range of cell cycle durations: evidence from double-labelling studies using tritiated thymidine and bromodeoxyuridine

Abstract Mouse tongue epithelium is characterized by a circadian variation in the number of DNA-synthesizing cells (labelling index, LI). Cells undergoing DNA synthesis were labelled with tritiated thymidine ([³H]TdR) at 0300 (peak LI) or 1200 h (low LI). The fate of these cells was assessed by injecting animals with bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) at intervals from 12–48 h after [³H]TdR, to follow them from one cell cycle to the next. Labelling was revealed by combining [³H]TdR autoradiography with immunoperoxidase detection of BrdU in the same sections.
A single peak in the appearance of double-labelled cells was seen at 44 h, if [³H]TdR was given at 1200 h; following [3H]TdR at 0300 h, a peak of double labelling was seen at 48 h with the possibility of smaller peaks at 24 h and 36 h.
These results show that the 24 h periodicity in LI in this tissue is associated with a predominant cell cycle duration of 44–48 h, but that a few cells cycle more quickly. Double labelling with [³H]TdR and BrdU provides a useful method for establishing cell cycle duration by labelling S-phase cells in successive cell cycles.     

Effects of pulse labelling with tritiated thymidine on the circadian rhythmicity in epidermal cell-cycle distribution in mice

The influence of pulse labelling with 50 microCi tritiated thymidine ( [3H]TdR) (2 microCi/g) on epidermal cell-cycle distribution in mice was investigated. Animals were injected intraperitoneally with the radioactive tracer or with saline at 08.00 hours, and groups of animals were sacrificed at intervals during the following 32 hr. Epidermal basal cells were isolated from the back skin of the animals and prepared for DNA flow cytometry, and the proportions of cells in the S and G2 phases of the cell cycle were estimated from the obtained DNA frequency distributions. The proportions of mitoses among basal cells were determined in histological sections from the same animals, as were the numbers of [3H]TdR-labelled cells per microscopic field by means of autoradiography. The results showed that the [3H]TdR activity did not affect the pattern of circadian rhythms in the proportions of cells in S, G2 and M phase during the first 32 hr after the injection. The number of labelled cells per vision field was approximately doubled between 8 and 12 hr after tracer injection, indicating an unperturbed cell-cycle progression of the labelled cohort. In agreement with previous reports, an increase in the mitotic index was seen during the first 2 hr. These data are in agreement with the assumption that 50 microCi [3H]TdR given as a pulse does not perturb cell-cycle progression in mouse epidermis in a way that invalidates percentage labelled mitosis (PLM) and double-labelling experiments.     

Double labelling with bromodeoxyuridine and [3H]-thymidine of proliferative cells in small intestinal epithelium in steady state and after irradiation

The simultaneous immunohistochemical detection of bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) and [3H]-thymidine ([3H]TdR), by conventional autoradiography, was performed on the mouse small intestine (ileum). Proliferation was studied under normal conditions as well as after 3 Gy of gamma-rays. The BrdU method in conjunction with [3H]TdR autoradiography appears to be reliable and useful for the study of cell kinetics especially in disturbed states, on condition that [3H]TdR is delivered to the animals before BrdU. It has been found that cells in the crypt are delayed by irradiation in their progression through the cell cycle predominantly in late S phase. The cells at the bottom of the crypt are more affected than the more differentiated but proliferating cells in the upper part of the crypt.     

DNA synthesis in Langerhans' cells of mouse ear epithelium revealed by tritiated thymidine autoradiography and histochemical staining for non-specific esterase and beta-glucuronidase activity

The proportion of Langerhans' cells in DNA synthesis in normal mouse skin was assessed by combining tritiated thymidine [3H]TdR autoradiography with enzyme histochemistry. After injection of [3H]TdR, ear skin was treated in two ways. Epithelial sheet preparations were stained for the presence of non-specific esterase and cytospin preparations of epithelial cell suspensions were stained for beta-glucuronidase activity. The labelling index (+/- SE mean) for cytospins, 40 min after injecting [3H]TdR, was 1.6 +/- 0.15%, doubling to 3-4% from 7-17 days after injection. The sheet preparations showed the proportion of label attributable to paired Langerhans' cells rising from 18% at 40 min after injection, to approximately 45%, on days 1-4 after injection. These results suggest that the proliferation of Langerhans' cells in normal mouse skin might be higher than was previously thought to be the case.     

Cyclin/PCNA immunostaining as an alternative to tritiated thymidine pulse labelling for marking S phase cells in paraffin sections from animal and human tissues

Abstract Paraffin sections from animal or human tissues fixed in different fixatives were submitted to immunostaining with the mouse monoclonal antibody 19A2, developed by Ogata et al. (1987a) against cyclin/PCNA. Detection of the bound antibody was performed by the indirect method with biotinylated sheep antibody and streptavidin-biotin-peroxidase complexes. No, or faint, nuclear staining was seen in material fixed in ethanol, Bouin, Bouin-Hollande, Carnoy or formaldehyde, whereas readily detectable immunocytochemical reaction was constantly observed over nuclei of methanol-fixed tissues. Hydrolysis with 2 N HCl prior to immunocytochemistry (as currently performed to render incorporated BrdU accessible to antibodies) somewhat improved the results with Bouin or Carnoy and markedly augmented the intensity of the peroxidase reactions in formaldehyde and in methanol-fixed tissues. The distribution of the positive nuclei in the two latter cases coincided with the proliferative compartment. On the other hand, double labelling with [³H]-thymidine and with the cyclin/PCNA antibody revealed that in methanol-fixed tissues the cyclin/PCNA labelling index did not differ by more than 6% from the [³H]-thymidine index. Besides the two labels overlapped in a proportion of labelled cells that was in reasonable agreement with expectation considering cells flow in and out of S phase since the time of [³H]-thymidine injection. This indicates that both labels recognize the same cells in this material. In contrast, in formaldehyde-fixed tissues, the cyclin/PCNA labelling index markedly exceeded the [³H]-thymidine labelling index. From this it is concluded that cyclin/PCNA immunostaining can be used:

• 1 In formaldehyde-fixed tissues (including existing material stored as paraffin blocks): for defining and mapping the proliferative (or germinative) compartment.
• 2 In methanol-fixed tissues as a substitute to the [³H]-thymidine autoradiographic labelling index.

From this, a method is proposed (derived from classical ‘double-labelling’technique) for measuring S phase duration in tissues fixed at a known interval time after a single labelling with [³H]-thymidine (or BrdU) and submitted to cyclin/PCNA immunocytochemical detection and to autoradiography (or to BrdU immunostaining).     

Cyclin/PCNA immunostaining as an alternative to tritiated thymidine pulse labelling for marking S phase cells in paraffin sections from animal and human tissues

Paraffin sections from animal or human tissues fixed in different fixatives were submitted to immunostaining with the mouse monoclonal antibody 19A2, developed by Ogata et al. (1987a) against cyclin/PCNA. Detection of the bound antibody was performed by the indirect method with biotinylated sheep antibody and streptavidin-biotin-peroxidase complexes. No, or faint, nuclear staining was seen in material fixed in ethanol, Bouin, Bouin-Hollande, Carnoy or formaldehyde, whereas readily detectable immunocytochemical reaction was constantly observed over nuclei of methanol-fixed tissues. Hydrolysis with 2 N HCl prior to immunocytochemistry (as currently performed to render incorporated BrdU accessible to antibodies) somewhat improved the results with Bouin or Carnoy and markedly augmented the intensity of the peroxidase reactions in formaldehyde and in methanol-fixed tissues. The distribution of the positive nuclei in the two latter cases coincided with the proliferative compartment. On the other hand, double labelling with [3H]-thymidine and with the cyclin/PCNA antibody revealed that in methanol-fixed tissues the cyclin/PCNA labelling index did not differ by more than 6% from the [3H]-thymidine index. Besides the two labels overlapped in a proportion of labelled cells that was in reasonable agreement with expectation considering cells flow in and out of S phase since the time of [3H]-thymidine injection. This indicates that both labels recognize the same cells in this material. In contrast, in formaldehyde-fixed tissues, the cyclin/PCNA labelling index markedly exceeded the [3H]-thymidine labelling index. From this it is concluded that cyclin/PCNA immunostaining can be used: (1) In formaldehyde-fixed tissues (including existing material stored as paraffin blocks): for defining and mapping the proliferative (or germinative) compartment. (2) In methanol-fixed tissues as a substitute to the [3H]-thymidine autoradiographic labelling index. From this, a method is proposed (derived from classical 'double-labelling' technique) for measuring S phase duration in tissues fixed at a known interval time after a single labelling with [3H]-thymidine (or BrdU) and submitted to cyclin/PCNA immunocytochemical detection and to autoradiography (or to BrdU immunostaining).     

A reproducible technique combining tritiated thymidine autoradiography with immunodetection of bromodeoxyuridine for double labelling studies of cell proliferation in paraffin sections of tissues

Abstract. A method is described to combine tritiated thymidine autoradiography with immunoperoxidase detection of bromodeoxyuridine on the same paraffin sections. It overcomes the varied technical artefacts we encountered when first attempting to combine these techniques and results in preparations with extremely low peroxidase and autoradiographic backgrounds. In particular, we find it is important to avoid the use of detergents during immunostaining, otherwise grain counts are reduced and autoradiograph exposures need to be greatly increased, and to avoid excessive peroxidase staining which makes it difficult to visualize silver grains in the overlying emulsion. The advantages of a method to remove emulsion films using acid-alcohol, allowing the same sections to be dipped twice with a long and a short autoradiographic exposure, are presented. The routine combination of high quality tritiated thymidine autoradiography with clean immunoperoxidase staining of bromodeoxyuridine-positive nuclei provides a new and powerful cell kinetic, double-labelling method to augment existing techniques e.g. by labelling the same cells undergoing DNA synthesis in successive cell cycles.     

A reproducible technique combining tritiated thymidine autoradiography with immunodetection of bromodeoxyuridine for double labelling studies of cell proliferation in paraffin sections of tissues

A method is described to combine tritiated thymidine autoradiography with immunoperoxidase detection of bromodeoxyuridine on the same paraffin sections. It overcomes the varied technical artefacts we encountered when first attempting to combine these techniques and results in preparations with extremely low peroxidase and autoradiographic backgrounds. In particular, we find it is important to avoid the use of detergents during immunostaining, otherwise grain counts are reduced and autoradiograph exposures need to be greatly increased, and to avoid excessive peroxidase staining which makes it difficult to visualize silver grains in the overlying emulsion. The advantages of a method to remove emulsion films using acid-alcohol, allowing the same sections to be dipped twice with a long and a short autoradiographic exposure, are presented. The routine combination of high quality tritiated thymidine autoradiography with clean immunoperoxidase staining of bromodeoxyuridine-positive nuclei provides a new and powerful cell kinetic, double-labelling method to augment existing techniques e.g. by labelling the same cells undergoing DNA synthesis in successive cell cycles.     

Validation of bromodeoxyuridine immunohistochemistry for localization of S-phase cells in decalcified tissues. A comparative study with tritiated thymidine autoradiography

Summary Immunohistochemical detection of the thymidine analogue 5-bromo-2-deoxyuridine (BrdUrd), which is incorporated by S-phase cells, offers a convenient way of studying the proliferation kinetics of cells in normal skeletal tissues and in bone containing/derived tumours. To assess the validity of using this approach on decalcified, paraffin embedded tissues, the BrdUrd method was compared with tritiated thymidine (³H-TdR) autoradiography, using rat tibiae labelled with both³H-TdR and BrdUrd, fixed in Carnoy's fluid and decalcified in EDTA, prior to routine paraffin embedding. The distribution of BrdUrd-labelled cells correlated with the sites of cell proliferation in the growing rat tibia.Independent studies with each method on paired serial sections of double-labelled tissue, showed a highly significant correlation (r=0.81, p<0.0003) in the numbers of labelled cells seen in autoradiographs and immunostained sections from the proximal tibial growth plate. Combined BrdUrd immunohistochemistry and³H-TdR autoradiography showed that the majority of labelled cells in cartilage, bone marrow, and fibrous perichondrium and periosteum had incorporated both labels. These results show that BrdUrd immunohistochemistry is a valid technique for the study of dividing cells in mineralized tissues after decalcification.     

DNA synthesis in Langerhans'cells of mouse ear epithelium revealed by tritiated thymidine autoradiography and histochemical staining for non-specific esterase and beta-glucuronidase activity

Abstract The proportion of Langerhans'cells in DNA synthesis in normal mouse skin was assessed by combining tritiated thymidine [³H]TdR autoradiography with enzyme histochemistry. After injection of [³H]TdR, ear skin was treated in two ways. Epithelial sheet preparations were stained for the presence of non-specific esterase and cytospin preparations of epithelial cell suspensions were stained for beta-glucuronidase activity. The labelling index (p± SE mean) for cytospins, 40 min after injecting [³H]TdR, was 1.6 ± 0.15%, doubling to 3–4% from 7–17 days after injection. The sheet preparations showed the proportion of label attributable to paired Langerhans'cells rising from 18% at 40 min after injection, to approximately 45%, on days 1–4 after injection. These results suggest that the proliferation of Langerhans'cells in normal mouse skin might be higher than was previously thought to be the case.