Pattern of polypeptide synthesis in myoblast hybrids

We have examined cell hybrids derived from L6J1 rat myoblasts and A9 mouse fibroblastic cells for expression of the myogenic phenotype. Initial results showed that hybrid cells were no longer able to form myotubes and hence showed extinction of the myogenic phenotype. We then proceeded to characterize the pattern of protein synthesis in these cells using two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. Although we did detect extinction of synthesis of a small number of myoblast polypeptides in the hybrids these did not appear to be rat myoblast specific. Instead they correlated well with polypeptides lost upon viral transformation in another rat cell line. Analysis of the ability of parental cells and hybrids to grow in soft agar confirmed that both A9 cells and hybrids were more transformed than the parental L6J1 cells. The results are consistent with the interpretation that extinction of the ability to form myotubes is due to either transformation and/or a disrupted cell organization but is unlikely to be due to specific extinction of myoblast specific polypeptides, at least at the level detectable by 2D gel electrophoresis.     

Analysis of myogenesis by somatic cell hybridization : I. Myogenic competence of homotypic hybrids derived from rat L6 myoblasts

Several authors have described the extinction of myogenic competence in hybrids produced by fusion of myogenic and non-myogenic cells. Interpretations of such experiments rest upon the assumption that extinction does not occur with any appreciable frequency as a non-specific consequence of the cell hybridization process itself. In order to test this assumption we have analyzed the myogenic competence of over 140 independent homotypic hybrid clones produced by PEG-mediated fusion of rat L6 myoblasts. Based upon an evaluation of myotube formation in hybrid colonies, we demonstrate that 99% of primary hybrid clones are myogenic. The fact that 97% of secondary hybrid colonies also differentiate indicates that myogenic competence is a stable characteristic of the hybrids. Four hybrid clones were isolated and expanded for analyses of chromosome numbers, myotube formation, creatine kinase activities, and microfluorimetric DNA determinations of myotube nuclei. Our results demonstrate that polyploid homotypic hybrid cells produced by fusion of non-neoplastic, developmentally determined rat myoblasts retain and express their program of differentiation. This work provides a foundation for future studies which will investigate the expression of myogenic properties in hybrids between myogenic and non-myogenic cells.     

Analysis of myogenesis by somatic cell hybridization: III. Myogenic competence of hybrids derived from rat L6 myoblasts and mouse primary fibroblasts and myoblasts

Hybrid cells derived from rat L6 myoblasts and mouse primary fibroblasts (M x F hybrids), as well as those derived from rat L6 myoblasts and mouse primary myoblasts (M x M hybrids), were examined for their ability to engage in myogenesis as judged by muscle fiber formation plus the expression of skeletal muscle myosin and creatine kinase (CK). Of 172 primary hybrid colonies scored, 59% were myogenic in the M x F fusion and 97% exhibited muscle fiber formation in the M x M fusion. Individual hybrid clones from each cross were isolated, expanded and analyzed for myogenic capabilities as well. All three M x M and all ten M x F isolated clones exhibited preferential elimination of mouse chromosomes. Nonetheless, all were capable of fusing spontaneously and of elaborating skeletal muscle myosin and CK. The three M x M hybrids expressed only MM-CK whereas nine out of ten M x F hybrids produced all three CK isoenzymes (MM, MB, BB). These results suggest that M X M hybrids express CK patterns reminiscent of the rat L6 parental cells while M X F hybrids apparently mimic mouse muscle fiber CK patterns. Various models are discussed which address these phenomena.     

Suppression of the transformed phenotype of hepatoma cells after hybridization with normal diploid fibroblasts

Hybrids were generated between mouse hepatoma cells which exhibit a transformed phenotype, and rat normal diploid fibroblasts. Most isolated hybrid clones contain a single set of chromosomes from each parent. Such clones grow to low saturation densities and are unable to grow or to form colonies in soft agar. The transformed phenotype of the parental hepatoma cells is thus suppressed in these hybrids. Suppression is very stable; however, subclones which have regained a transformed phenotype could be selected; these subclones show a significant reduction of their chromosome number. Amongst the hybrid clones isolated after fusion, a few are characterized by an excess of mouse chromosomes and a reduced number of rat chromosomes. Such clones exhibit a transformed phenotype. Our results show that, provided the hybrids contain an almost complete single set of chromosomes of each parent, spontaneous transformation behaves as a recessive trait in hybrids formed with normal diploid cells.     

Discrimination of myogenic and nonmyogenic cells from embryonic skeletal muscle by 90 degrees light scattering

A myogenic cell suspension was isolated from the breast muscles of 10-day-old chicken embryos by trypsin digestion. The cell preparation was subjected to Percoll density centrifugation to reduce the number of fibroblast-like cells present. The Percoll-isolated, predominantly myogenic cell population was then fractionated by flow cytometry using 90 degrees light scattering as the parameter for sorting. Cells exhibiting lower scatter, with a peak of 45 units, produced cultures containing myotubes and gave rise only to myogenic clones. Cells exhibiting higher scatter (120-200 units) produced nonmyogenic cultures and gave rise to nonmyogenic clones. Cells with intermediate light scatter were also detected. The latter produced both myogenic and nonmyogenic clones. The differences in light scatter presumably reflect higher cytoplasmic complexity of the nonmyogenic cells compared with the myogenic cells. Moreover, the differences in light scattering properties of the different cell types offer a means for the isolation of pure populations of myogenic cells directly from the intact muscle.     

Transfer of the human X chromosome to human--Chinese hamster cell hybrids via isolated HeLa metaphase chromosomes.

Evidence is presented for the uptake of the human X chromosome by human-Chinese hamster cell hybrids which lack H P R T activity, following incubation with isolated human HeLa S3 chromosomes. Sixteen independent clonal cell lines were isolated in H A T medium, all of which contained a human X chromosome as determined by trypsin-Giemsa staining. The frequency of H A T-resistant clones was 32 x 10(-6) when 10(7) cells were incubated with 10(8) HeLa chromosomes. Potential reversion of the hybrid cells in H A T medium was less than 5 x 10(-7). The 16 isolated cell lines all contained activity of the human X-linked marker enzymes H P R T, P G K,alpha-Gal A, and G6PD, as determined by electrophoresis. The phenotype of G6PD was G6PD A, corresponding to G6PD A in HeLa cells. The human parental cells used in the fusion to form the hybrids had the G6PD B phenotype. The recipient cells gave no evidence of containing human X chromosomes. These results indicate that incorporation and expression of HeLa X chromosomes is accomplished in human-Chinese hamster hybrids which lack a human X chromosome.     

The Ha-ras-induced transformed phenotype of rat-1 cells can be suppressed in hybrids with rat embryonic fibroblasts

Somatic cell hybrids were isolated from fusions of diploid embryonic rat fibroblasts with transformed Rat-1 cells which contained 4 to 5 copies of the transforming human Ha-ras 1 gene. In contrast to their transformed parental cells four hybrid clones showed normal morphology, long latency periods of tumorigenicity in newborn rats, anchorage requirement of proliferation, and an eightfold-reduced amount of secreted transforming growth factor activity. Thus these hybrids are called suppressed with regard to expression of the Ha-ras-induced transformed phenotype. Tumorigenic derivatives of the suppressed hybrids that had segregated chromosomes were isolated. Since two of the tumorigenic hybrid clones showed the similar low level of secreted transforming growth factors as the suppressed hybrids, decreased production of transforming growth factor activity is unlikely to be a sufficient criterion for suppression of malignancy. Whereas one of the suppressed hybrids expressed the transforming gene product p21 at a level similar to that of the transformed parental cells, other suppressed hybrids expressed less p21. This suggests that the suppressed phenotype can be regulated at the posttranslational level of p21 but that additional controls of expression of p21 are likely to exist. DNA of the suppressed hybrids transformed Rat-1 cells to proliferation in the presence of semisolid agar. Thus the activated human Ha-ras gene in the suppressed hybrids retained its biological activity even though it did not transform these cells to tumorigenicity.     

Expression and extinction of glial properties in glioma X neuroblastoma cell hybrids

Rat glioma cells (clone C₆TK⁻) were hybridized with mouse neuroblastoma cells (clone NA), and 18 primary and secondary hybrid clones containing one chromosome set from each parent were isolated. The hybrids were assayed for the glial marker enzymes 2′,3′-cyclic nucleotide 3′-phosphohydrolase (CNP) and glycerol-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GPDH). In many of the hybrid clones, the levels of CNP and GPDH were reduced to 5–20% of the activity of C₆TK⁻, as has been observed in other classes of glial X non-glial cell hybrids. In some hybrid clones, however, GPDH and CNP were expressed at high activity. Rat (glial) GPDH activity was not reduced in these clones, but mouse GPDH activity remained low, and was not “de-repressed” or “activated”. This suggests that the controls governing differentiation in neuroblastoma cells and extinction in hybrids may differ in some important details. There was a strong positive correlation between the specific activities of CNP and GPDH in the hybrid clones, suggesting that a mechanism regulates the activity of these two glial enzymes coordinately.     

Extinction of liver-specific functions in hybrids between differentiated and dedifferentiated rat hepatoma cells.

A cross has been performed between dedifferentiated rat hepatoma cells and the differentiated cells from which they were derived. 10 hybrid clones, containing the complete chromosome sets of both parents, show extinction of 4 liver-specific enzymes: tyrosine aminotransferase (E.C. 2.6.1.5), alanine aminotransferase (E.C. 2.6.1.2), and the liver-specific isozymes of alcohol dehydrogenase (E.C. 1.1.1.1) and aldolase (E.C. 4.1.2.13). Moreover, the 4 hybrid clones examined do not produce albumin . The only function of the differentiated parent which is not extinguished in the hybrid cells is inducibility of the aminotransferases. For 3 of the hybrid clones, extinction of 3 of the 4 enzymes is incomplete, but these clones do not differ in modal chromosome number from those which show more complete extinction of the enzymes. Subcloning of several of the hybrids revealed that the phenotype of the hybrids is very stable; 4 subclones showing reexpression of intermediate levels of the enzymes are characterized. These results show that dedifferentiation of the parental cells is not due to the simple loss of some factor required for the maintenance of expression of differentiated functions, and suggest that dedifferentiation is due to the activation of some control mechanism, whose final effect is negative, and which may be a part of the epigenotype of the embryonic hepatocyte.     

Evidence for suppression of cellular growth in vitro and selection against the indigenous mouse X chromosome in A9 cell hybrids after microcell-mediated transfer of an X from other mammalian species

Introduction of a human or Syrian hamster X chromosome (derived from BHK-191-5C cell hybrids) into tumorigenic mouse A9 cells via microcell fusion induced changes in cellular morphology and a retardation of cellular growth. The suppression of growth of the hybrids could be abolished, however, by daily changes of medium containing 20% serum. G-banding analysis showed the absence of a single, cytogenetically identifiable, indigenous X chromosome (marker Z) in two of four hybrid clones after an X chromosome was transferred from either hamster or human cells. All hybrids were tumorigenic when tested in nude mice. Together, these data suggest that the loss of the mouse X chromosome took place probably because of growth inhibitory effects imposed on hybrid cells due to the increase in X chromosome dosage. In addition, our results show a lack of association between the phenotype of cellular growth suppression in vitro and the phenotype of suppression of tumorigenicity in vivo.     

Preparation and characterization of cell clones from adult human dystrophic muscle

We have developed a single cell-cloning technique to isolate pure cell populations from human adult skeletal muscle. The procedure is based on plating single cells derived from dissociated muscle biopsies on glass shards. With this technique we have prepared four cell clones derived from the same biopsy which each yielded between 10⁶ and 2 × 10⁷ cells. Two of these clones proved to be myogenic and two nonmyogenic, by using morphological and biochemical criteria. These clones maintained their phenotype for up to 50 days in culture even after freezing and thawing.     

Transfection of a DNA locus that mediates the conversion of 10T1/2 fibroblasts to myoblasts

Stable myoblast cell lines were isolated after a brief exposure of mouse fibroblasts (10T1/2 cells) to 5-azacytidine. We show that transfection of 10T1/2 cells with DNA from these azacytidine-induced myoblasts (or from mouse C2C12 myoblasts) results in myogenic conversion of approximately 1 in 15,000 transfected colonies. In contrast, transfection of 10T1/2 cells with DNA from nonmyogenic cells (parental 10T1/2 cell DNA) does not give rise to myoblast colonies. These results indicate that an azacytidine-induced structural modification (presumably demethylation) in the DNA of a single locus is sufficient to convert 10T1/2 cells into determined myoblasts.     

Coexpression of myogenic functions in L6 rat × T984 mouse myoblast hybrids

L6 rat myoblasts differ from T984 mouse myoblasts in the expression of several myogenic functions. Simple hybrids between these myogenic lines contained mostly chromosomes and expressed the mouse phenotype. Hybrids containing an approximately balanced set of chromosomes from each parent were constructed by fusing tetraploid L6 cells to T984 myoblasts. These hybrids were allowed to differentiate and their expression of myogenic proteins was compared to the parental phenotypes. The synthesis of creatine phosphokinase isoenzymes is codominantly expressed in the hybrid cells. Myosin light chain synthesis and the levels of acetylcholine receptor are either regulated by the mouse genome or are codominantly expressed.     

Stability of the "two active X" phenotype in triploid somatic cells.

We examined triploid cells of XXY karyotype heterozygous for glucose 6 phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD) electrophoretic variants with regard to the stability of their X chromosome phenotype. Clonal populations of cells derived from these human fibroblasts maintained a precise 1:2:1 ratio of A:heteropolymer:B isozymes throughout their life span, indicating stability of the two active X chromosomes in these cells. To determine the influence of the autosomal complement on X chromosome expression, we attempted to perturb the relationship. Fusion of these triploid cells with human diploid fibroblasts carrying a novel G6PD variant (B') resulted in heterokaryons exprssing a novel heteropolymer, presumably indicating that all three parental X chromosomes were active. However, no derepression of the inactive X chromosome was observed. Analysis of interspecific hybrids derived from triploid cells and mouse fibroblasts confirmed that activity of parental X chromosomes is maintained. Some human mouse hybrid clones, however, expressed only a single human G6PD isozyme, probably attributable to segregation of the pertinent X chromosome, but elimination of a relevant autosome cannot be excluded. The triploid cells transformed by SV40 showed alterations in LDH pattern and an approximately 10-20% decrease in chromosome number, but maintained the precise G6PD phenotype of the untransformed cell. These studies provide evidence for the stability of the X chromosome phenotype in triploid cells.     

Limited lifespan in somatic cell hybrids and cybrids

The transformed phenotype is believed to be dominant in fusions between limited lifespan cells and transformed cells, based on heterokaryon experiments and on the isolation of transformed hybrids from mass cultures of fused cells. A series of fusions has been performed between limited lifespan Lesch-Nyhan fibroblast cells and a permanent HeLa cell line with a complementary genetic marker. The growth of independently isolated hybrid clones was followed in parallel with Lesch-Nyhan cells. In fusions involving Lesch-Nyhan cells which had completed about 50% of their lifespan, all hybrids initially show fibroblastic properties. Thirty-five hybrids had a limited lifespan slightly longer than Lesch-Nyhan controls. Three other hybrid clones, and all mass cultures of hybrids, showed the appearance of transformed colonies at a rate of approx. one transformant in 2 × 10₅ hybrid cells. These transformed cells showed anchorage independence, low serum requirement, chromosome loss, and have been maintained in culture for 50–100 population doublings with no signs of senescence. Fusions involving enucleated HeLa cells did not show transformation. Fusions with senescent Lesch-Nyhan cells yielded hybrids which grew beyond the normal Lesch-Nyhan cell lifespan, but which again showed limited lifespan and low frequency transformation. It is concluded that limited lifespan is expressed in a dominant manner in these fusions, and that transformation or “escape from senescence” is a low frequency event requiring the presence of the HeLa nucleus.     

Genetic control of tumorigenicity in interspecific mammalian cell hybrids.

The nature of genetic control of cellular malignancy was investigated by examining the tumorigenicity of a series of interspecific mouse-human cell hybrids in the athymic nude mouse. Two highly malignant but genetically distinct mouse cell lines, A9 and PG19, were hybridized with three normal human diploid fibroblast strains, and 19 independently arising hybrid clones were isolated. Each of these clones was capable of forming progressive lethal tumors in the nude mouse, and thus resembled the malignant parental mouse cells rather than the nonmalignant parental human cells. We failed to obtain any evidence for complete suppression of tumorigenicity in these cell hybrids. The absence of suppression was observed regardless of the extent and composition of the human chromosome complements retained in the hybrid clones; the results of detailed cytological and isoenzyme analyses would make it highly improbable that the observed lack of suppression was due to cellular selection in vivo for a more tumorigenic subpopulation in the injected hybrid cells. These data demonstrate that at least for the parental cell combinations used in this study, no human chromosome, when present singly in the mouse-human cell hybrids, can suppress the tumorigenic phenotype of the mouse cells. Our results are consistent with the view that the suppression of cellular malignancy previously demonstrated in intraspecific (mouse × mouse) somatic cell hybrids does not occur in interspecific (mouse-human) cell hybrids, or alternatively, genetic determinants located on two or more human chromosomes are required simultaneously to suppress the malignancy of the mouse cells in cell hybrids derived from malignant mouse cell and nonmalignant human cells.     

Coordinate expression of parietal endodermal functions in hybrids of embryonal carcinoma and endodermal cells.

A derivative, FOT5, of the F9 murine embryonal carcinoma cell line which is resistant to ouabain and thioguanine was fused with a near diploid parietal endodermal cell line, PFHR9, Hybrid clones (ENEC1 to ENEC5) were isolated in HAT Medium containing ouabain at a frequency of approximately 2 x 10(-4). The DNA contents and chromosome number of the ENEC hybrids were approximately the sum of those of the parents. Five hybrid cell lines examined in detail expressed the following parietal endodermal functions: plasminogen activator activity, basement membrane proteins, and endodermal cytoskeletal proteins. Embryonal carcinoma characteristic functions (tumorigenicity, a stage specific embryonic antigen, and high alkaline phosphatase activity) were extinguished in the hybrids. No hybrid clones with embryonal carcinoma morphology were observed among 1,358 hybrid clones examined. Hybrids, propagated for over 100 generations, continued to express endodermal functions and not embryonal carcinoma functions. The coordinate expression of endodermal functions and the extinction of embryonal carcinoma functions in the ENEC hybrids suggest that the parietal endodermal cells contain diffusible activities which extinguish embryonal carcinoma functions and possibly cause the embryonal carcinoma genome to express parietal endodermal characteristics.     

Paracrine control of myoblast proliferation and differentiation by fibroblasts

Double-muscling (DM) is a hereditary (apparently single-gene) skeletal muscle hyperplasia which occurs in beef cattle. In order to investigate the cellular basis of this phenotype, cell cultures from developing muscle tissue of normal and DM fetal calves were studied. In cultures composed of both myogenic cells and nonmyogenic, fibroblast-like cells, DM myoblasts exhibited a prolonged proliferative phase. This resulted in delayed, but increased production of fused myotubes in the DM cultures. "Conditioned" media experiments indicated that the fibroblast-like cells in the cultures produced soluble myoblast growth factor activity. Both normal and DM fibroblast-like cells produced the growth factor activity, but the mutant fibroblast-like cells produced a greater level of such activity. The conditioned media failed to increase proliferation of bovine muscle fibroblasts and did not stimulate quiescent Swiss 3T3 cells to divide, indicating that the myoblast trophic activity is distinct from bFGF or PDGF. Also, the myotrophic activity present in the conditioned media acted in an additive fashion with saturating doses of bFGF and of IGF-1, suggesting that the activity is not due to either of these known myogenic growth factors. Both normal and DM fibroblast-like cells produced myoblast trophic activity when the cells were proliferating, but did not produce myotrophic activity when the fibroblasts were mitotically quiescent. These findings indicate that the proliferative state of the connective tissue cells in muscle may have a controlling influence on myoblast proliferation and differentiation during development.     

Genotyping of somatic hybrids between <Emphasis Type="Italic">Festuca arundinacea</Emphasis> Schreb. and <Emphasis Type="Italic">Triticum aestivum</Emphasis> L.

In order to genotype hybrid genomes of distant asymmetric somatic hybrids, we synthesized hybrid calli and plants via PEG-mediated protoplast fusion between recipient tall fescue (Festuca. arundinacea Schreb.) and donor wheat (Triticum aestivum L.). Seventeen and 25 putative hybrid clones were produced from the fusion combinations I and II, each with the donor wheat protoplast treated by UV light for 30 s and 1 min, respectively. Isozyme and RAPD profiles confirmed that ten hybrid clones were obtained from combination I and 19 from combination II. Out of the 29 hybrids, 12 regenerated hybrid plants with tall fescue phenotype. Composition and methylation-variation of the nuclear and cytoplasmic genomes of some hybrids, either with or without regenerative ability, were compared by genomic in situ hybridization, restriction fragment length polymorphism, and DNA methylation-sensitive amplification polymorphism. Our results indicated that these selected hybrids all contained introgressed nuclear and cytoplasmic DNA as well as obvious methylation variations compared to both parents. However, there were no differences either in nuclear/cytoplasmic DNA or methylation degree between the regenerable and non-regenerable hybrid clones. We conclude that both regeneration complementation and genetic material balance are crucial for hybrid plant regeneration.