The binding of 1,8 ANS congeners to I-FABP and comparison of some hypotheses about ANS' spectral sensitivity to environment

The ANS congeners 1-anilinonaphthalene and 1-amino,8-sulfonato naphthalene were investigated as analogs of 1,8 anilinonaphthalene sulfonate. Like 1,8 ANS, they also bind to I-FABP, and the fully-bound spectra reveal interesting similarities and differences with respect to ANS binding. The nature of these differences suggests that certain hypotheses in the literature about ANS photophysics ought to be revised. The conceptual decomposition of energetic effects in the thermodynamics of ANS binding proposed earlier [W. Kirk, E. Kurian, F. Prendergast, Characterization of the sources of protein-ligand affinity: 1-sulfonato-8-(1')anilinonaphthalene binding to intestinal fatty acid binding protein. Biophys. J. (1996) 70 69-83.] is extended further in this report.     

The binding of 1,8 ANS congeners to I-FABP and comparison of some hypotheses about ANS' spectral sensitivity to environment

The ANS congeners 1-anilinonaphthalene and 1-amino,8-sulfonato naphthalene were investigated as analogs of 1,8 anilinonaphthalene sulfonate. Like 1,8 ANS, they also bind to I-FABP, and the fully-bound spectra reveal interesting similarities and differences with respect to ANS binding. The nature of these differences suggests that certain hypotheses in the literature about ANS photophysics ought to be revised. The conceptual decomposition of energetic effects in the thermodynamics of ANS binding proposed earlier [1] [W. Kirk, E. Kurian, F. Prendergast, Characterization of the sources of protein–ligand affinity: 1-sulfonato-8-(1′)anilinonaphthalene binding to intestinal fatty acid binding protein. Biophys. J. (1996) 70 69–83.] is extended further in this report.     

Interaction of prostaglandins and fatty acids with native and acetaldehyde-alkylated proteins

Using intrinsic and probe fluorescence, microcalorimetry and isotopic methods, the interactions of prostaglandins (PG) E2 and F2 alpha and some fatty acids with native and alkylated proteins (human serum albumin (HSA) and rat liver plasma membrane PG receptors), were studied. The fatty acid and PG interactions with human serum albumin (HSA) resulted in effective quenching of fluorescence of the probe, 1.8-anilinonaphthalene sulfonate (ANS), bound to the protein. Fatty acids competed with ANS for the binding sites; the efficiency of this process increased with an increase in the number of double bonds in the fatty acid molecule. PG induced a weaker fluorescence quenching of HSA-bound ANS and stabilized the protein molecule in a lesser degree compared to fatty acids. The sites of PG E2 and F2 alpha binding did not overlap with the sites of fatty acid binding on the HSA molecule. Nonenzymatic alkylation of HSA by acetaldehyde resulted in the abnormalities of binding sites for fatty acids and PG. Modification of the plasma membrane proteins with acetaldehyde sharply diminished the density of PG E2 binding sites without changing the association constants. Alkylation did not interfere with the parameters of PG F2 alpha binding to liver membrane proteins.     

Characterization of the sources of protein-ligand affinity: 1-sulfonato-8-(1'')anilinonaphthalene binding to intestinal fatty acid binding protein.

1-Sulfonato-8-(1')anilinonaphthalene (1,8-ANS) was employed as a fluorescent probe of the fatty acid binding site of recombinant rat intestinal fatty acid binding protein (1-FABP). The enhancement of fluorescence upon binding allowed direct determination of binding affinity by fluorescence titration experiments, and measurement of the effects on that affinity of temperature, pH, and ionic strength. Solvent isotope effects were also determined. These data were compared to results from isothermal titration calorimetry. We obtained values for the enthalpy and entropy of this interaction at a variety of temperatures, and hence determined the change in heat capacity of the system consequent upon binding. The ANS-1-FABP is enthalpically driven; above approximately 14 degrees C it is entropically opposed, but below this temperature the entropy makes a positive contribution to the binding. The changes we observe in both enthalpy and entropy of binding with temperature can be derived from the change in heat capacity upon binding by integration, which demonstrates the internal consistency of our results. Bound ANS is displaced by fatty acids and can itself displace fatty acids bound to I-FABP. The binding site for ANS appears to be inside the solvent-containing cavity observed in the x-ray crystal structure, the same cavity occupied by fatty acid. From the fluorescence spectrum and from an inversion of the Debye-Hueckel formula for the activity coefficients as a function of added salt, we inferred that this cavity is fairly polar in character, which is in keeping with inferences drawn from the x-ray structure. The binding affinity of ANS is considered to be a consequence of both electrostatic and conditional hydrophobic effects. We speculate that the observed change in heat capacity is produced mainly by the displacement of strongly hydrogen-bonded waters from the protein cavity.     

Effect of free fatty acid anion on the in vitro binding of 1-anilino-8-naphthalene sulfonate to cytoplasmic proteins from rat liver.

The influence of oleate ion, a free fatty acid anion, on the binding characteristics of 1-anilino-8-naphthalene sulfonate (ANS) with the cytoplasmic proteins (Y and Z) from rat liver has been examined using fluorescence spectroscopy. ANS binds strongly with both ligandin (Y) and Z protein at a single binding site with dissociation constants of 0.6 and 1.4 micron respectively. Increasing concentrations of oleate ion decreased the ANS binding with either protein by competing with the ANS binding site. Relative binding constant of oleate ion for the hepatic ligandin or Z protein was about 2 micron as determined from the competitive inhibition of ANS binding. These results suggest that variations in the hepatic cytoplasmic free fatty acid concentration may be important in regulating the capacity of Y and Z proteins to transport other organic anions.     

Fluorescence study of lymphocyte plasma membranes]

ANS binding parameters--dissociation constant, number of binding sites, rotation freedom--are measured by fluorescence studies of a complex between ANS and lymph node cell plasma membranes. Divalent ions, Mg++ and Ca++, enhance the complex fluorescence intensity without shifting its maximum wavelength : this enhancement is induced by affinity and quantum yield increases, while the number of binding sites remains constant. The complex fluorescence quenching by ethacrynic acid shows the presence of free SH groups in the ANS binding site. An energy transfer takes place between membrane protein tryptophan residues and bound ANS ; the energy transfer yield is unaffected by Ca++ ions. A correlation of these results is postulated with the biological activity of the membrane.     

Modification of phospholipids in erythrocyte membranes by phospholipase D. A fluorescence and ESR spectroscopic study

The conversion of more than 65% of the phospholipids in human erythrocyte membranes to phosphatidyl-methanol and phosphatidic acid by incubation with phospholipase D and methanol increased the dissociation constant of the fluorescence probe ANS compared to untreated membranes, but did not affect the number of binding sites and the limiting fluorescence enhancement at maximal binding (Imax). On the contrary, the cationic fluorescence probe dansylcadaverin showed additional binding sites without a change in Kd and an increase of Imax upon incubation with phospholipase D treated erythrocyte membranes compared to incubations of membranes with the original phospholipid pattern. The characteristic temperature-dependence of the quenching of the membrane protein fluorescence by a membrane-bound nitroxide-labeled stearic acid was not influenced by the modification of the phospholipids. A slight reduction of the order parameter, S, determined by ESR-spectroscopy with the same nitroxide spin-labeled fatty acid incorporated into modified membranes compared to controls was found at 40 degrees C, but not at 25 degrees C. The results were interpreted as an indication of membrane domains that retained their physical properties and lipid composition during the incubation with phospholipase D.     

Detection of ligand-induced conformation changes in lactate dehydrogenase by using fluorescent probes

The binding of ANS to apolactate dehydrogenase (apo-LDH) is accompanied by a 300-fold increase in dye fluorescence with a shift of the emission maximum from 515 to 479 nm, as well as by quenching of intrinsic protein fluorescence. A tetrameric LDH molecule has 6.4 +/- 1.6 non-interacting dye-binding sites with an association constant equal to (4.3 +/- 1.6) X 10(3) M-1. NAD+ added at saturating concentrations does not alter the number of ANS binding sites or the association constant value. The formation of binary LDH.NAD+, LDH.NADH, LDH.AMP and LDH.pyruvate complexes causes the quenching of fluorescence of the enzyme-bound ANS. The extent of quenching observed at ligand saturating concentrations differs for each ligand. Pyruvate added to the binary LDH.AMP complex exerts no effect on the fluorescence of protein-bound ANS; this indicates that the binding of AMP causes some alterations in the microenvironment of the substrate-binding site. Nicotinamide mononucleotide (NMN) can act as a coenzyme in the LDH-catalyzed reaction. AMP added together with NMN displays an inhibitory effect. The cationic (auramine O) and anionic (ANS) fluorescent probes bound to LDH exhibit different responses to conformational changes accompanying the transition from the apoenzyme to the LDH X NAD-pyruvate complex.     

Polyene fatty acid interactions with recombinant intestinal and liver fatty acid-binding proteins. Spectroscopic studies

Binding and proximity relationships of fatty acids with recombinant rat liver fatty acid-binding protein (L-FABP) and intestinal fatty acid-binding protein (I-FABP) were studied with absorption and fluorescence spectroscopy. Protein aromatic amino acids were examined in the absence and presence of bound fatty acid. Second derivative absorbance spectroscopy of the apo- and holoproteins suggested that fatty acid binding altered the conformation of L-FABP, but not of I-FABP. Fatty acid binding also blocked the accessibility of L-FABP tyrosine and I-FABP tryptophan to Stern-Volmer quenching by acrylamide, indicating that these amino acids were present in the fatty acid-binding pocket. Forster energy transfer from I-FABP tryptophan to bound cis-parinaric acid resulted in quenching of tryptophan lifetime and appearance of sensitized lifetime of bound cis-parinaric acid. The calculated donor-acceptor distances were 16.9 +/- 0.6 and 19.2 +/- 0.3 A for I-FABP and L-FABP, respectively. Absorbance spectral shifts and ratios of fluorescence excitation maxima indicated that the parinaric acid microenvironment in the fatty acid-binding site of I-FABP was much less polar than that of L-FABP. Parinaric acids displayed similar rotational correlation time and limiting anisotropy when bound to I-FABP and to L-FABP. These results are consistent with a close proximity of bound fatty acids to the tyrosine and tryptophan residues and with immobilization of the polyene fatty acids in the fatty acid-binding site(s) of L-FABP and I-FABP. The two proteins differ in that only L-FABP has two fatty acid-binding sites and appears to undergo significant conformational change upon fatty acid binding.     

Comparative Study of the Fatty Acid Binding Process of a New FABP from Cherax quadricarinatus by Fluorescence Intensity,Lifetime and Anisotropy

Fatty acid-binding proteins (FABPs) are small cytosolic proteins, largely distributed in invertebrates and vertebrates, which accomplish uptake and intracellular transport of hydrophobic ligands such as fatty acids. Although long chain fatty acids play multiple crucial roles in cellular functions (structural, energy metabolism, regulation of gene expression), the precise functions of FABPs, especially those of invertebrate species, remain elusive. Here, we have identified and characterized a novel FABP family member, Cq-FABP, from the hepatopancreas of red claw crayfish Cherax quadricarinatus. We report the characterization of fatty acid-binding affinity of Cq-FABP by four different competitive fluorescence-based assays. In the two first approaches, the fluorescent probe 8-Anilino-1-naphthalenesulfonate (ANS), a binder of internal cavities of protein, was used either by directly monitoring its fluorescence emission or by monitoring the fluorescence resonance energy transfer occurring between the single tryptophan residue of Cq-FABP and ANS. The third and the fourth approaches were based on the measurement of the fluorescence emission intensity of the naturally fluorescent cis-parinaric acid probe or the steady-state fluorescence anisotropy measurements of a fluorescently labeled fatty acid (BODIPY-C16), respectively. The four methodologies displayed consistent equilibrium constants for a given fatty acid but were not equivalent in terms of analysis. Indeed, the two first methods were complicated by the existence of non specific binding modes of ANS while BODIPY-C16 and cis-parinaric acid specifically targeted the fatty acid binding site. We found a relationship between the affinity and the length of the carbon chain, with the highest affinity obtained for the shortest fatty acid, suggesting that steric effects primarily influence the interaction of fatty acids in the binding cavity of Cq-FABP. Moreover, our results show that the binding affinities of several fatty acids closely parallel their prevalences in the hepatopancreas of C. quadricarinatus as measured under specific diet conditions.     

Significant hydrogen exchange protection in GroEL-bound DHFR is maintained during iterative rounds of substrate cycling.

An unresolved key issue in the mechanism of protein folding assisted by the molecular chaperone GroEL is the nature of the substrate protein bound to the chaperonin at different stages of its reaction cycle. Here we describe the conformational properties of human dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) bound to GroEL at different stages of its ATP-driven folding reaction, determined by hydrogen exchange labeling and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry. Considerable protection involving about 20 hydrogens is observed in DHFR bound to GroEL in the absence of ATP. Analysis of the line width of peaks in the mass spectra, together with fluorescence quenching and ANS binding studies, suggest that the bound DHFR is partially folded, but contains stable structure in a small region of the polypeptide chain. DHFR rebound to GroEL 3 min after initiating its folding by the addition of MgATP was also examined by hydrogen exchange, fluorescence quenching, and ANS binding. The results indicate that the extent of protection of the substrate protein rebound to GroEL is indistinguishable from that of the initial bound state. Despite this, small differences in the quenching coefficient and ANS binding properties are observed in the rebound state. On the basis of these results, we suggest that GroEL-assisted folding of DHFR occurs by minor structural adjustments to the partially folded substrate protein during iterative cycling, rather than by complete unfolding of this protein substrate on the chaperonin surface.     

Mapping fatty acid binding to beta-lactoglobulin: Ligand binding is restricted by modification of Cys 121.

Native beta-lactoglobulin (Blg) binds 1 mole of palmitic acid per mole of protein with a dissociation constant of 0.6 microM for the primary fatty acid binding site. Chemical modification of Cys 121, which lies at the external putative hydrophobic binding site of Blg, does not affect retinol or 4,4'-bis 1-(phenylamino)-8-naphthalenesulfonate (bis-ANS) binding to the protein, indicating that the incorporated appendages do not perturb the internal hydrophobic site within the beta-barrel of Blg (i.e., the retinoid site is unaffected). On the other hand, methylation of Cys 121, reduces the affinity of Blg for palmitic acid by 10-fold as monitored by intrinsic fluorescence. Modification of the Cys 121 with methylmethanethiosulfonate or a thiol-specific spin label appears to either further weaken or totally eliminate fatty acid binding, respectively, due to steric hindrance. Furthermore, this binding pattern has been independently verified using a spin labeled fatty acid analog and monitoring ESR as well as by bis-ANS fluorescence when bound to the protein. These results suggest that fatty acids bind at the "external site" of beta-lactoglobulin, between the sole alpha-helix and the beta-barrel. In addition, structural stability studies of native and chemically modified Blg appear to confirm this observation as well.     

Interaction between protein kinase C and sphingomyelin/cholesterol

Physical characteristics of binding of protein kinase C with sphingomyelin/cholesterol lipid bilayers were analysed using three complementary approaches: acrylodan fluorescence, fluorescence energy transfer and quenching of tryptophan fluorescence. It was demonstrated that sphingomyelin/cholesterol lipid membranes were available for protein kinase C binding. The intensity of the binding was dependent on the sphingomyelin content. The results of quenching of intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence showed that the enzyme molecule penetrated the sphingomyelin/cholesterol lipid bilayer to the C-16 position of labeled fatty acid probes. Our results also showed sphingomyelin itself restrains protein kinase C activity. A possible explanation for our results is that caveolae function as signaling storage devices.     

Spectral studies on the interaction of iodine and anthracene sulfonate with bacterial phospholipids from different mutants of Salmonella minnesota.

Using spectrophotometric and spectrofluorometric techniques, the interaction of iodine and 2-anthracene sulfonate (ANS) with the phospholipids (PL) isolated from four genetically correlated Salmonella minnesota isolates viz., a smooth form (S), a deeply rough mutant (Rc) and two intermediate forms (Ra and Rb) were studied. Appearance of an isosbestic point and a new band in absorption spectra indicated charge-transfer (C-T) interaction of iodine with the PL through the formation of 1:1 complex. Stern-Volmer type fluorescence quenching of PL was observed with the addition of iodine to PL, while PL enhanced the fluorescence of anionic dye ANS. The values of the binding constants between iodine/PL and ANS/PL, measured by using suitable equations, showed a systematic gradation in the molecular properties of the PL in the membrane structure in smooth (S) and rough (Ra, Rb and Rc) mutants of Salmonella minnesota.     

Misconceptions over Förster resonance energy transfer between proteins and ANS/bis-ANS: Direct excitation dominates dye fluorescence

Our aim was to disprove the widespread misconception that Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) is the only explanation for observing fluorescence from ANS (8-anilino-1-naphthalenesulfonic acid) and bis-ANS (4,4′-dianilino-1,1′-binaphthyl-5,5′-disulfonic acid, dipotassium salt) following excitation at 280 nm in the presence of protein. From ultraviolet (UV) absorption spectra and fluorescence emission spectra of bis-ANS and ANS in buffer and ethanol, direct excitation at 280 nm was found to be the dominant mechanism for the resulting dye fluorescence. Furthermore, Tyr/Trp quenching studies were performed for solutions of N-acetyl-l-tryptophanamide, heat-stressed immunoglobulin G (IgG), and bovine serum albumin (BSA) by monitoring changes in steady state fluorescence spectra and time-resolved fluorescence decays as a function of dye concentration. Stronger quenching of the intrinsic BSA and IgG fluorescence in steady state than in time-resolved fluorescence by bis-ANS and ANS pointed toward static quenching being the dominant mechanism in addition to dynamic quenching and/or FRET. In conclusion, one should consider the role of direct excitation of ANS and bis-ANS at 280 nm to ensure a proper interpretation of fluorescence signals resulting from dye-protein interactions. When ANS or bis-ANS is to be used for protein characterization, we recommend selectively exciting the dyes at the higher absorption wavelength maximum (370 or 385 nm, respectively).     

8-anilino-1-naphthalene sulfonic acid (ANS) induces folding of acid unfolded cytochrome c to molten globule state as a result of electrostatic interactions.

Hydrophobic interaction of 8-anilino-1-naphthalene sulfonic acid (ANS) with proteins is one of the widely used methods for characterizing/detecting partially folded states of proteins. We have carried out a systematic investigation on the effect of ANS, a charged hydrophobic fluorescent dye, on structural properties of acid-unfolded horse heart cytochrome c at pH 2.0 by a combination of optical methods and electrospray ionization mass spectroscopy (ESI MS). ANS was found to induce, a secondary structure similar to native protein and quenching of fluorescence of tryptophan residue, in the acid-unfolded protein. However, the tertiary structure was found to be disrupted thus indicating that ANS stabilizes a molten globule state in acid-unfolded protein. To understand the mechanism of ANS-induced folding of acid-unfolded cytochrome c, comparative ESI MS, soret absorption, and tryptophan fluorescence studies using nile red, a neutral hydrophobic dye, and ANS were carried out. These studies suggested that, at low pH, electrostatic interactions between negatively charged ANS molecules and positively charged amino acid residues present in acid-unfolded cytochrome c are probably responsible for ANS-induced folding of acid-unfolded protein to partially folded compact state or molten globule state. This is the first experimental demonstration of ANS induced folding of unfolded protein and puts to question the usefulness of ANS for characterization/determination of partially folded intermediates of proteins observed under low pH conditions.     

Characterization of a partially folded intermediate of stem bromelain at low pH.

Equilibrium studies on the acid included denaturation of stem bromelain (EC 3.4.22.32) were performed by CD spectroscopy, fluorescence emission spectroscopy and binding of the hydrophobic dye, 1-anilino 8-naphthalene sulfonic acid (ANS). At pH 2.0, stem bromelain lacks a well defined tertiary structure as seen by fluorescence and near-UV CD spectra. Far-UV CD spectra show retention of some native like secondary structure at pH 2.0. The mean residue ellipticities at 208 nm plotted against pH showed a transition around pH 4.5 with loss of secondary structure leading to the formation of an acid-unfolded state. With further decrease in pH, this unfolded state regains most of its secondary structure. At pH 2.0, stem bromelain exists as a partially folded intermediate containing about 42.2% of the native state secondary structure Enhanced binding of ANS was observed in this state compared to the native folded state at neutral pH or completely unfolded state in the presence of 6 m GdnHCl indicating the exposure of hydrophobic regions on the protein molecule. Acrylamide quenching of the intrinsic tryptophan residues in the protein molecule showed that at pH 2.0 the protein is in an unfolded conformation with more tryptophan residues exposed to the solvent as compared to the native conformation at neutral pH. Interestingly, stem bromelain at pH 0.8 exhibits some characteristics of a molten globule, such as an enhanced ability to bind the fluorescent probe as well as considerable retention of secondary structure. All the above data taken together suggest the existence of a partially folded intermediate state under low pH conditions.     

A fluorescence study of the binding of cytochrome C to mixed-phospholipid microvesicles : evidence for a preferred orientation of the bound protein.

Kinetic and equilibrium experiments are reported on the binding of the fluorescent probe 1,8-anilino-naphtalene sulfonate (ANS) to microvesicles of natural lecithin containing 10 per cent of an anionic phospholipip (90 : 10 mixtures). Kinetics discriminated between fast binding to the outer leaflet of the bilayer and apparently slow binding to the inner leaflet controlled by the diffusion of the probe across the bilayer. The equilibrium distribution of ANS between the two leaflets was not dependent on the nature of the anionic species and the spectral properties of bound ANS were identical in all cases investigated. A hyperbolic saturation was observed allowing to propose an affinity scale for the binding of ANS to mixtures of lecithin with phosphatidic acid, phosphatidylinositol, and cardiolipin. The effects on binding of ionic strength and sodium dodecylsulfate were also considered. The binding of horse heart ferricytochrome c to ANS-labelled microvesicles was studied quantitatively making use of the quenching of the probes fluorescence by the heme. Perrin-F?rster energy transfer could be analysed on the basis of a simple model of the physical arrangement of the system which was elaborated from published data referring to ANS and cytochrome c binding to phospholipids. Experimental and theoretical computed values of the quenching efficiency were compared and led to conclude in favor of a preferred orientation of the heme crevice fully accessible from the external space at the lipid interface.     

Different conformation changes induced by calcium and terbium of the porcine intestinal calcium-binding protein

The fluorescence of 1-anilino-8-naphthalenesulfonate (ANS) is progressively enhanced with increasing concentration of it, showing a proportionate blue shift of the emission maximum, by the interaction with the porcine intestinal Ca2+-binding protein (CaBP) in the absence of Ca2+. The apo-CaBP has a single binding site for ANS as determined by the fluorescence change, the apparent dissociation constant (Kd) estimated at 49.1 microM. Addition of Ca2+ or Tb3+ to the ANS-apo-CaBP system is capable of enhancing its fluorescence up to about 2- or 5-fold, respectively, causing further blue shift of the emission maximum. These metal ions do not affect the capacity of ANS binding, but Ca2+ slightly increases the Kd value. Increase of the fluorescence of the ANS-CaBP complex by increasing binding of Ca2+ to it was monophasic, while that with Tb3+ was biphasic, both saturated at the same molar ratio, 2, of added cations to the complex. Biphasic change of response has also been observed in UV absorption of the CaBP with increasing concentration of Tb3+. With a half-saturating concentration of Tb3+, Ca2+ can induce a much higher enhancement of the ANS fluorescence than excess Ca2+ alone. All these results indicate that the CaBP molecule contains a single ANS binding site and the conformation and/or microenvironment surrounding bound ANS of the protein is altered reversibly with binding of Ca2+ or Tb3+ to it and that there are differences between Ca2+- and Tb3+-induced conformation changes around the ANS-binding site and the tyrosine residue of it.     

Dynamics of ANS binding to tuna apomyoglobin measured with fluorescence correlation spectroscopy.

The dynamics of the binding reaction of ANS to native and partly folded (molten globule) tuna and horse apomyoglobins has been investigated by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy and frequency domain fluorometry. The reaction rate has been measured as a function of apomyoglobin and ANS concentrations, pH, and temperature. Examination of the autocorrelation functions shows that the reaction rate is fast enough to be observed in tuna apomyoglobin, whereas the reaction rate in horse apomyoglobin is on the same time scale as diffusion through the volume or longer. Specifically, for tuna apomyoglobin at pH 7 and room temperature the on rate is 2200 microM(-1) s(-1) and the off rate is 5900 s(-1), in comparison with k(on) = 640 microM(-1) s(-1) and k(off) = 560 s(-1) for horse myoglobin as measured previously. The independence of the reaction rate from the ANS concentration indicates that the reaction rate is dominated by the off rate. The temperature dependence of the on-rate shows that this rate is diffusion limited. The temperature dependence of the off rates analyzed by Arrhenius and Ferry models indicates that the off rate depends on the dynamics of the protein. The differences between horse and tuna apomyoglobins in the ANS binding rate can be explained in terms of the three-dimensional apoprotein structures obtained by energy minimization after heme removal starting from crystallographic coordinates. The comparison of the calculated apomyoglobin surfaces shows a 15% smaller cavity for tuna apomyoglobin. Furthermore, a negative charge (D44) is present in the heme cavity of tuna apomyoglobin that could decrease the strength of ANS binding. At pH 5 the fluorescence lifetime distribution of ANS-apomyoglobin is bimodal, suggesting the presence of an additional binding site in the protein. The binding rates determined by FCS under these conditions show that the protein is either in the open configuration or is more flexible, making it much easier to bind. At pH 3, the protein is in a partially denatured state with multiple potential binding sites for ANS molecule, and the interpretation of the autocorrelation function is not possible by simple models. This conclusion is consistent with the broad distribution of ANS fluorescence lifetimes observed in frequency domain measurements.