Mutational analysis of the pseudoknot structure of the S15 translational operator from Escherichia coli

Expression of rpsO, the gene encoding the small ribosomal protein S15, is autoregulated at the translational level by S15, which binds to its mRNA in a region overlapping the ribosome-binding site. By measuring the effect of mutations on the expression of a translational rpsO-lacZ fusion and the S15 binding affinity for the translational operator, the formation of a pseudoknot in the operator site in vivo is fully demonstrated and appears to be a prerequisite for S15 binding. The mutational analysis suggests also that specific determinants for S15 binding are located in very limited regions of the structure formed by the pseudoknot. It is deduced that a specific pseudoknot conformation is a key element for autoregulation.     

Structural elements of rps0 mRNA involved in the modulation of translational initiation and regulation of E. coli ribosomal protein S15.

Previous experiments showed that S15 inhibits its own translation by binding to its mRNA in a region overlapping the ribosome loading site. This binding was postulated to stabilize a pseudoknot structure that exists in equilibrium with two stem-loops and to trap the ribosome on its mRNA loading site in a transitory state. In this study, we investigated the effect of mutations in the translational operator on: the binding of protein S15, the formation of the 30S/mRNA/tRNA(fMet) ternary initiation complex, the ability of S15 to inhibit the formation of this ternary complex. The results were compared to in vivo expression and repression rates. The results show that (1) the pseudoknot is required for S15 recognition and translational control; (2) mRNA and 16S rRNA efficiently compete for S15 binding and 16S rRNA suppresses the ability of S15 to inhibit the formation of the active ternary complex; (3) the ribosome binds more efficiently to the pseudoknot than to the stem-loop; (4) sequences located between nucleotides 12 to 47 of the S15 coding phase enhances the efficiency of ribosome binding in vitro; this is correlated with enhanced in vivo expression and regulation rates.     

Molecular dissection of the pseudoknot governing the translational regulation of Escherichia coli ribosomal protein S15.

The ribosomal protein S15 controls its own translation by binding to a mRNA region overlapping the ribosome binding site. That region of the mRNA can fold in two mutually exclusive conformations that are in dynamic equilibrium: a structure with two hairpins and a pseudoknot. A mutational analysis provided evidence for the existence and requirement of the pseudoknot for translational control in vivo and S15 recognition in vitro. In this study, we used chemical probing to analyze the structural consequences of mutations and their effect on the stem-loop/pseudoknot equilibrium. Interactions between S15 and the pseudoknot structure were further investigated by footprinting experiments. These data, combined with computer modelling and the previously published data on S15 binding and in vivo control, provide important clues on pseudoknot formation and S15 recognition. An unexpected result is that the relevant control element, here the pseudoknot form, can exist in a variety of topologically equivalent structures recognizable and shapable by S15. S15 sits on the deep groove of the co-axial stack and makes contacts with both stems, shielding the bridging adenine. The only specific sequence determinants are found in the helix common to the pseudoknot and the hairpin structures.     

Do mRNA and rRNA binding sites of E.coli ribosomal protein S15 share common structural determinants?

Escherichia coli ribosomal protein S15 recognizes two RNA targets: a three-way junction in 16S rRNA and a pseudoknot structure on its own mRNA. Binding to mRNA occurs when S15 is expressed in excess over its rRNA target, resulting in an inhibition of translation start. The sole apparent similarity between the rRNA and mRNA targets is the presence of a G-U/G-C motif that contributes only modestly to rRNA binding but is essential for mRNA. To get more information on the structural determinants used by S15 to bind its mRNA target as compared to its rRNA site, we used site-directed mutagenesis, substitution by nucleotide analogs, footprinting experiments on both RNA and protein, and graphic modeling. The size of the mRNA-binding site could be reduced to 45 nucleotides, without loss of affinity. This short RNA preferentially folds into a pseudoknot, the formation of which depends on magnesium concentration and temperature. The size of the loop L2 that bridges the two stems of the pseudoknot through the minor groove could not be reduced below nine nucleotides. Then we showed that the pseudoknot recognizes the same side of S15 as 16S rRNA, although shielding a smaller surface area. It turned out that the G-U/G-C motif is recognized from the minor groove in both cases, and that the G-C pair is recognized in a very similar manner. However, the wobble G-U pair of the mRNA is not directly contacted by S15, as in rRNA, but is most likely involved in building a precise conformation of the RNA, essential for binding. Otherwise, unique specific features are utilized, such as the three-way junction in the case of 16S rRNA and the looped out A(-46) for the mRNA pseudoknot.     

The HCV IRES pseudoknot positions the initiation codon on the 40S ribosomal subunit

The hepatitis C virus (HCV) genomic RNA contains an internal ribosome entry site (IRES) in its 5′ untranslated region, the structure of which is essential for viral protein translation. The IRES includes a predicted pseudoknot interaction near the AUG start codon, but the results of previous studies of its structure have been conflicting. Using mutational analysis coupled with activity and functional assays, we verified the importance of pseudoknot base pairings for IRES-mediated translation and, using 35 mutants, conducted a comprehensive study of the structural tolerance and functional contributions of the pseudoknot. Ribosomal toeprinting experiments show that the entirety of the pseudoknot element positions the initiation codon in the mRNA binding cleft of the 40S ribosomal subunit. Optimal spacing between the pseudoknot and the start site AUG resembles that between the Shine–Dalgarno sequence and the initiation codon in bacterial mRNAs. Finally, we validated the HCV IRES pseudoknot as a potential drug target using antisense 2′-OMe oligonucleotides.     

Formation of the central pseudoknot in 16S rRNA is essential for initiation of translation.

The postulated central pseudoknot formed by regions 9-13/21-25 and 17-19/916-918 of 16S rRNA of Escherichia coli is phylogenetically conserved in prokaryotic as well eukaryotic species. This pseudoknot is located at the center of the secondary structure of the 16S rRNA and connects the three major domains of this molecule. We have introduced mutations into this pseudoknot by changing the base-paired residues C18 and G917, and the effect of such mutations on the ribosomal activity was studied in vivo, using a 'specialized' ribosome system. As compared with ribosomes having the wild-type pseudoknot, the translational activity of ribosomes containing an A, G or U residue at position 18 was dramatically reduced, while the activity of mutant ribosomes having complementary bases at positions 18 and 917 was at the wild-type level. The reduced translational activity of those mutants that are incapable of forming a pseudoknot was caused by their inability to form 70S ribosomal complexes. These results demonstrate that the potential formation of a central pseudoknot in 16S rRNA with any base-paired residues at positions 18 and 917 is essential to complete the initiation process.     

Specific recognition of rpsO mRNA and 16S rRNA by Escherichia coli ribosomal protein S15 relies on both mimicry and site differentiation

The ribosomal protein S15 binds to 16S rRNA, during ribosome assembly, and to its own mRNA (rpsO mRNA), affecting autocontrol of its expression. In both cases, the RNA binding site is bipartite with a common subsite consisting of a G*U/G-C motif. The second subsite is located in a three-way junction in 16S rRNA and in the distal part of a stem forming a pseudoknot in Escherichia coli rpsO mRNA. To determine the extent of mimicry between these two RNA targets, we determined which amino acids interact with rpsO mRNA. A plasmid carrying rpsO (the S15 gene) was mutagenized and introduced into a strain lacking S15 and harbouring an rpsO-lacZ translational fusion. Analysis of deregulated mutants shows that each subsite of rpsO mRNA is recognized by a set of amino acids known to interact with 16S rRNA. In addition to the G*U/G-C motif, which is recognized by the same amino acids in both targets, the other subsite interacts with amino acids also involved in contacts with helix H22 of 16S rRNA, in the region adjacent to the three-way junction. However, specific S15-rpsO mRNA interactions can also be found, probably with A(-46) in loop L1 of the pseudoknot, demonstrating that mimicry between the two targets is limited.     

Unusual mRNA pseudoknot structure is recognized by a protein translational repressor

Translation of ribosomal proteins in the alpha operon of E. coli is repressed by one of the encoded proteins, S4; it specifically recognizes an RNA fragment containing the translational initiation site for the first gene in the operon. RNA structure mapping experiments have suggested a pseudoknot structure for the S4 binding site: the loop of a hairpin is base paired to sequences downstream of the hairpin. Here, we systematically test this proposed structure by measuring S4 binding to an extensive set of site-directed mutations that create compensatory base pair changes in potential helices. The pseudoknot folding is confirmed, and two additional, unexpected interactions within the pseudoknot are also detected. The overall structure is an unusual "double pseudoknot" linking a hairpin upstream of the ribosome binding site with sequences 2-10 codons downstream of the initiation codon. Stabilization of this structure by S4 could account for translational repression.     

Structural requirements for efficient translational frameshifting in the synthesis of the putative viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase of potato leafroll virus.

The putative RNA-dependent RNA polymerase of potato leafroll luteovirus (PLRV) is expressed by -1 ribosomal frameshifting in the region where the open reading frames (ORF) of proteins 2a and 2b overlap. The signal responsible for efficient frameshift is composed of the slippery site UUUAAAU followed by a sequence that has the potential to adopt two alternative folding patterns, either a structure involving a pseudoknot, or a simple stem-loop structure. To investigate the structure requirements for efficient frameshifting, mutants in the stem-loop or in the potential pseudoknot regions of a Polish isolate of PLRV (PLRV-P) have been analyzed. Mutations that are located in the second stem (S2) of the potential pseudoknot structure, but are located in unpaired regions of the alternative stem-loop structure, reduce frameshift efficiency. Deletion of the 3' end sequence of the alternative stem-loop structure does not reduce frameshift efficiency. Our results confirm that -1 frameshift in the overlap region depends on the slippery site and on the downstream positioned sequence, and propose that in PLRV-P a pseudoknot is required for efficient frameshifting. These results are in agreement with those recently published for the closely related beet western yellows luteovirus (BWYV).     

A competition mechanism regulates the translation of the Escherichia coli operon encoding ribosomal proteins L35 and L20

Escherichia coli ribosomal protein (r-protein) L20 is essential for the assembly of the 50S ribosomal subunit and is also a translational regulator of its own rpmI-rplT operon, encoding r-proteins L35 and L20 in that order. L20 directly represses the translation of the first cistron and, through translational coupling, that of its own gene. The translational operator of the operon is 450 nt in length and includes a long-range pseudoknot interaction between two RNA sequences separated by 280 nt. L20 has the potential to bind both to this pseudoknot and to an irregular hairpin, although only one site is occupied at a time during regulation. This work shows that the rpmI-rplT operon is regulated by competition between L20 and the ribosome for binding to mRNA in vitro and in vivo. Detailed studies on the regulatory mechanisms of r-protein synthesis have only been performed on the rpsO gene, regulated by r-protein S15, and on the alpha operon, regulated by S4. Both are thought to be controlled by a trapping mechanism, whereby the 30S ribosomal subunit, the mRNA, and the initiator tRNA are blocked as a nonfunctional preternary complex. This alternative mode of regulation of the rpmI-rplT operon raises the possibility that control is kinetically and not thermodynamically limited in this case. We show that the pseudoknot, which is known to be essential for L20 binding and regulation, also enhances 30S binding to mRNA as if this structure is specifically recognised by the ribosome.     

An NMR and mutational analysis of an RNA pseudoknot of Escherichia coli tmRNA involved in trans-translation.

Transfer-messenger RNA (tmRNA) is a unique molecule that combines properties from both tRNA and mRNA, and facilitates a novel translation reaction termed trans -translation. According to phylogenetic sequence analysis among various bacteria and chemical probing analysis, the secondary structure of the 350-400 nt RNA is commonly characterized by a tRNA-like structure, and four pseudoknots with different sizes. A mutational analysis using a number of Escherichia coli tmRNA variants as well as a chemical probing analysis has recently demonstrated not only the presence of the smallest pseudoknot, PK1, upstream of the internal coding region, but also its direct implication in trans -translation. Here, NMR methods were used to investigate the structure of the 31 nt pseudoknot PK1 and its 11 mutants in which nucleotide substitutions are introduced into each of two stems or the linking loops. NMR results provide evidence that the PK1 RNA is folded into a pseudoknot structure in the presence of Mg(2+). Imino proton resonances were observed consistent with formation of two helical stem regions and these stems stacked to each other as often seen in pseudoknot structures, in spite of the existence of three intervening nucleo-tides, loop 3, between the stems. Structural instability of the pseudoknot structure, even in the presence of Mg(2+), was found in the PK1 mutants except in the loop 3 mutants which still maintained the pseudoknot folding. These results together with their biological activities indicate that trans -translation requires the pseudoknot structure stabilized by Mg(2+)and specific residues G61 and G62 in loop 3.     

Improved model of a LexA repressor dimer bound to recA operator

A complete three dimensional model for the LexA repressor dimer bound to the recA operator site consistent with relevant biochemical and biophysical data for the repressor was proposed from our laboratory when no crystal structure of LexA was available. Subsequently, the crystal structures of four LexA mutants Delta(1-67) S119A, S119A, G85D and Delta(1-67) quadruple mutant in the absence of operator were reported. It is examined in this paper to what extent our previous model was correct and how, using the crystal structure of the operator-free LexA dimer we can predict an improved model of LexA dimer bound to recA operator. In our improved model, the C-domain dimerization observed repeatedly in the mutant operator-free crystals is retained but the relative orientation between the two domains within a LexA molecule changes. The crystal structure of wild type LexA with or without the recA operator cannot be solved as it autocleaves itself. We argue that the 'cleavable' cleavage site region found in the crystal structures is actually the more relevant form of the region in wild-type LexA since it agrees with the value of the pre-exponential Arrhenius factor for its autocleavage, absence of various types of trans-cleavages, difficulty in modifying the catalytic serine by diisopropyl flourophosphate and lack of cleavage at Arg 81 by trypsin; hence the concept of a 'conformational switch' inferred from the crystal structures is meaningless.     

Evidence for allosteric coupling between the ribosome and repressor binding sites of a translationally regulated mRNA

Escherichia coli ribosomal protein S4 is a translational repressor regulating the expression of four ribosomal genes in the alpha operon. In vitro studies have shown that the protein specifically recognizes an unusual mRNA pseudoknot secondary structure which links sequences upstream and downstream of the ribosome binding site for rpsM (S13) [Tang, C. K., & Draper, D. E. (1989) Cell 57, 531]. We have prepared fusions of the rpsM translational initiation site and lacZ that allows us to detect repression in cells in which overproduction of S4 repressor can be induced. Twenty-five mRNA sequence variants have been introduced into the S13-lacZ fusions and the levels of translational repression measured. Sets of compensating base changes confirm the importance of the pseudoknot secondary structure for translational repression. An A residue in a looped, single-stranded sequence is also required for S4 recognition and may contact S4 directly. Comparison of translational repression levels and S4 binding constants for the set of mRNA mutations show that nine mutants are repressed much more weakly than predicted from their affinity for S4; in extreme cases no repression can be detected for variants with unchanged S4 binding. We suggest that the mRNA contains functionally distinct ribosome and repressor binding sites that are allosterically coupled. Mutations can relieve translational repression by disrupting the linkage between the two sites without altering S4 binding. This proposal assigns to the mRNA a more active role in mediating translational repression than found in other translational repression systems.     

Mutational analysis of the pseudoknot in the tRNA-like structure of turnip yellow mosaic virus RNA. Aminoacylation efficiency and RNA pseudoknot stability.

Site-directed mutations were introduced in the connecting loops and one of the two stem regions of the RNA pseudoknot in the tRNA-like structure of turnip yellow mosaic virus RNA. The kinetic parameters of valylation for each mutated RNA were determined in a cell-free extract from wheat germ. Structure mapping was performed on most mutants with enzymic probes, like RNase T1, nuclease S1 and cobra venom ribonuclease. An insertion of four A residues in the four-membered connecting loop L1 that crosses the deep groove of the pseudoknot reduces aminoacylation efficiency. Deletions up to three nucleotides do not affect aminoacylation or RNA pseudoknot formation. Deletion of the entire loop abolishes aminoacylation. Although elimination of the pseudoknot is presumed, this could not be demonstrated. Unlike the mutations in loop L1, all mutations in the three-membered connecting loop L2 that crosses the shallow groove of the RNA pseudoknot decrease the aminoacylation efficiency considerably. Nonetheless, the RNA pseudoknot is still present in most mutated RNAs. These results indicate that a number of mutations can be introduced in both loops without abolishing aminoacylation. Results obtained with the introduction of mismatches and A.U base-pairs in stem S1 of the pseudoknot, containing three G.C base-pairs in wild-type RNA, indicate that the pseudoknot is only marginally stable. Our estimation of the gain of free energy due to the pseudoknot formation is at most 2.0 kcal/mol. The pseudoknot structure can, however, be stabilized upon binding the valyl-tRNA synthetase.     

Multiple RNA interactions position Mrd1 at the site of the small subunit pseudoknot within the 90S pre-ribosome

Ribosomal subunit biogenesis in eukaryotes is a complex multistep process. Mrd1 is an essential and conserved small (40S) ribosomal subunit synthesis factor that is required for early cleavages in the 35S pre-ribosomal RNA (rRNA). Yeast Mrd1 contains five RNA-binding domains (RBDs), all of which are necessary for optimal function of the protein. Proteomic data showed that Mrd1 is part of the early pre-ribosomal complexes, and deletion of individual RBDs perturbs the pre-ribosomal structure. In vivo ultraviolet cross-linking showed that Mrd1 binds to the pre-rRNA at two sites within the 18S region, in helix 27 (h27) and helix 28. The major binding site lies in h27, and mutational analyses shows that this interaction requires the RBD1-3 region of Mrd1. RBD2 plays the dominant role in h27 binding, but other RBDs also contribute directly. h27 and helix 28 are located close to the sequences that form the central pseudoknot, a key structural feature of the mature 40S subunit. We speculate that the modular structure of Mrd1 coordinates pseudoknot formation with pre-rRNA processing and subunit assembly.     

Improved Model of a LexA Repressor Dimer Bound to recA Operator

Abstract

A complete three dimensional model for the LexA repressor dimer bound to the recA operator site consistent with relevant biochemical and biophysical data for the repressor was proposed from our laboratory when no crystal structure of LexA was available. Subsequently, the crystal structures of four LexA mutants Δ_1–67 S119A, S119A, G85D and Δ_1-67 quadruple mutant in the absence of operator were reported. It is examined in this paper to what extent our previous model was correct and how, using the crystal structure of the operator-free LexA dimer we can predict an improved model of LexA dimer bound to recA operator. In our improved model, the C-domain dimerization observed repeatedly in the mutant operator-free crystals is retained but the relative orientation between the two domains within a LexA molecule changes. The crystal structure of wild type LexA with or without the recA operator cannot be solved as it autocleaves itself. We argue that the ‘cleavable’ cleavage site region found in the crystal structures is actually the more relevant form of the region in wildtype LexA since it agrees with the value of the pre-exponential Arrhenius factor for its auto- cleavage, absence of various types of trans-cleavages, difficulty in modifying the catalytic serine by diisopropyl flourophosphate and lack of cleavage at Arg 81 by trypsin; hence the concept of a ‘conformational switch’ inferred from the crystal structures is meaningless.     

Conserved functional domains and a novel tertiary interaction near the pseudoknot drive translational activity of hepatitis C virus and hepatitis C virus-like internal ribosome entry sites

The translational activity of the hepatitis C virus (HCV) internal ribosome entry site (IRES) and other HCV-like IRES RNAs depends on structured RNA elements in domains II and III, which serve to recruit the ribosomal 40S subunit, eukaryotic initiation factor (eIF) 3 and the ternary eIF2/Met-tRNA_i^Met/GTP complex and subsequently domain II assists subunit joining. Porcine teschovirus-1 talfan (PTV-1) is a member of the Picornaviridae family, with a predicted HCV-like secondary structure, but only stem-loops IIId and IIIe in the 40S-binding domain display significant sequence conservation with the HCV IRES. Here, we use chemical probing to show that interaction sites with the 40S subunit and eIF3 are conserved between HCV and HCV-like IRESs. In addition, we reveal the functional role of a strictly conserved co-variation between a purine–purine mismatch near the pseudoknot (A–A/G) and the loop sequence of domain IIIe (GAU/CA). These nucleotides are involved in a tertiary interaction, which serves to stabilize the pseudoknot structure and correlates with translational efficiency in both the PTV-1 and HCV IRES. Our data demonstrate conservation of functional domains in HCV and HCV-like IRESs including a more complex structure surrounding the pseudoknot than previously assumed.     

Cap-independent translation of tobacco etch virus is conferred by an RNA pseudoknot in the 5'-leader

The tobacco etch virus (TEV) 5'-leader promotes cap-independent translation in a 5'-proximal position and promotes internal initiation when present in the intercistronic region of a dicistronic mRNA, indicating that the leader contains an internal ribosome entry site. The TEV 143-nucleotide 5'-leader folds into a structure that contains two domains, each of which contains an RNA pseudoknot. Mutational analysis of the TEV 5'-leader identified pseudoknot (PK) 1 within the 5'-proximal domain and an upstream single-stranded region flanking PK1 as necessary to promote cap-independent translation. Mutations to either stem or to loops 2 or 3 of PK1 substantially disrupted cap-independent translation. The sequence of loop 3 in PK1 is complementary to a region in 18 S rRNA that is conserved throughout eukaryotes. Mutations within L3 that disrupted its potential base pairing with 18 S rRNA reduced cap-independent translation, whereas mutations that maintained the potential for base pairing with 18 S rRNA had little effect. These results indicated that the TEV 5'-leader functionally substitutes for a 5'-cap and promotes cap-independent translation through a 45-nucleotide pseudoknot-containing domain.