Exposure of mammalian cells to 60-Hz magnetic or electric fields: analysis of DNA repair of induced, single-strand breaks

DNA damage was induced in isolated human peripheral lymphocytes by exposure at 5 Gy to 60Co radiation. Cells were permitted to repair the DNA damage while exposed to 60-Hz fields or while sham-exposed. Exposed cells were subjected to magnetic (B) or electric (E) fields, alone or in combination, throughout their allotted repair time. Repair was stopped at specific times, and the cells were immediately lysed and then analyzed for the presence of DNA single-strand breaks (SSB) by the alkaline-elution technique. Fifty to 75 percent of the induced SSB were repaired 20 min after exposure, and most of the remaining damage was repaired after 180 min. Cells were exposed to a 60-Hz ac B field of 1 mT; an E field of 1 or 20 V/m; or combined E and B fields of 0.2 V/m and 0.05 mT, 6 V/m and 0.6 mT, or 20 V/m and 1 mT. None of the exposures was observed to affect significantly the repair of DNA SSB.     

Sinusoidal 60 Hz electromagnetic fields failed to induce changes in protein synthesis in Escherichia coli

Escherichia coli JM83 {F^? ara Δ(lac-proAB) rpsL [?80dΔ(lacZ)M15]} in midlog growth phase at 30 °C were exposed to 60 Hz sinusoidal magnetic field of 3 mT of nonuniform diverging flux, inducing a nonuniform electric field with a maximum intensity of 32 μV/cm using an inductor coil. Exposed and unexposed control cells were maintained at 30.8 ± 0.1 °C and 30.5 ± 0.1 °C, respectively. Quadruplicate samples of exposed and unexposed E. coli cells were simultaneously radiolabeled with ³⁵S-L-methionine at 10 min intervals over 2 hr. Radiochemical incorporation into proteins was analyzed via liquid scintillation counting and by denaturing 12.5% polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The results showed that E. coli exposed to a 60 Hz magnetic field of 3 mT exhibited no qualitative or quantitative changes in protein synthesis compared to unexposed cells. Thus small prokaryotic cells (less than 2 μm × 0.5 μm) under constant-temperature conditions do not alter their protein synthesis following exposure to 60 Hz magnetic fields at levels at 3 mT. © 1994 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Effects of 50 Hz electric currents and magnetic fields on the prokaryote Propionibacterium acnes

The effects of 50 Hz sinusoidal electric currents and magnetic fields on the Gram-positive skin bacterium Propionibacterium acnes were investigated. Intracellular free calcium ([Ca(2+)](i)), intracellular pH (pH(i)), and cell viability were examined, based on their relevance to ELF field studies and on previous studies conducted on P. acnes (UVA irradiation, photosensitization using porphyrin-based sensitizers, and broad-band red light). The [Ca(2+)](i) and the pH(i) were measured spectrofluorimetrically using the fluorescent probes fura-2 and BCECF, respectively. Sham-exposed controls were used to assess the field exposed samples. Cell suspensions were exposed to 50 Hz, 0.2 mT sinusoidal magnetic fields generated by using Helmholtz coils for up to 30 min. The estimated maximum induced electric field was 0.2 mV/m. Changes in [Ca(2+)](i) and cell viability were not detected. Ag/AgCl electrodes were used to expose cell suspensions to 50 Hz sinusoidal electric currents. The current densities were in the range 0.015-1500 A/m(2) (corresponding electric fields congruent with0.01-1000 V/m). Changes in [Ca(2+)](i) were not observed after current exposure. Current densities of 800 A/m(2) (electric field E congruent with550 V/m) were required for a 50% reduction in cell viability. Current densities greater than 800 A/m(2) were required for a reduction in pH(i). However, a pH gradient across the cell membrane (inside alkaline) was maintained even when exposure resulted in less than 0. 2% survival (1400 A/m(2), E congruent with950 V/m). Thus, dissipation of the pH gradient across the cell membrane and changes in [Ca(2+)](i) were not a consequence of cell inactivation by 50 Hz electric currents. This is in contrast to inactivation of P. acnes by UVA irradiation or photosensitization, where such changes have been obtained.     

No Evidence of Persisting Unrepaired Nuclear DNA Single Strand Breaks in Distinct Types of Cells in the Brain,Kidney, and Liver of Adult Mice after Continuous Eight-Week 50 Hz Magnetic Field Exposure with Flux Density of 0.1 mT or 1.0 mT

Background

It has been hypothesized in the literature that exposure to extremely low frequency electromagnetic fields (50 or 60 Hz) may lead to human health effects such as childhood leukemia or brain tumors. In a previous study investigating multiple types of cells from brain and kidney of the mouse (Acta Neuropathologica 2004; 107: 257–264), we found increased unrepaired nuclear DNA single strand breaks (nDNA SSB) only in epithelial cells of the choroid plexus in the brain using autoradiographic methods after a continuous eight-week 50 Hz magnetic field (MF) exposure of adult mice with flux density of 1.5 mT.

Methods

In the present study we tested the hypothesis that MF exposure with lower flux densities (0.1 mT, i.e., the actual exposure limit for the population in most European countries, and 1.0 mT) shows similar results to those in the previous study. Experiments and data analysis were carried out in a similar way as in our previous study.

Results

Continuous eight-week 50 Hz MF exposure with 0.1 mT or 1.0 mT did not result in increased persisting unrepaired nDNA SSB in distinct types of cells in the brain, kidney, and liver of adult mice. MF exposure with 1.0 mT led to reduced unscheduled DNA synthesis (UDS) in epithelial cells in the choroid plexus of the fourth ventricle in the brain (EC-CP) and epithelial cells of the cortical collecting duct in the kidney, as well as to reduced mtDNA synthesis in neurons of the caudate nucleus in the brain and in EC-CP.

Conclusion

No evidence was found for increased persisting unrepaired nDNA SSB in distinct types of cells in the brain, kidney, and liver of adult mice after continuous eight-week 50 Hz magnetic field exposure with flux density of 0.1 mT or 1.0 mT.     

Effects of Electromagnetic Fields on the Bioactivities of an Osteoblast-Like Cell Line (UMR-106)

In the present study, we first investigated the effects of various types of low-energy, low-frequency electromagnetic fields (EMFs) on DNA synthesis in UMR-106 osteoblast-like cells. The experimental groups were exposed to EMFs for 2 days (twice/day, 30 min/time), and DNA synthesis was measured. The results showed that the cells responded most sensitively to EMFs of some specific combinations of the parameters by an increase in DNA synthesis, implying that EMFs with a specific waveform rather than a complex one can be used in clinical electrotherapy. The parameters were as follows: pulsed electric field (PEF) with pulse width 0.2 ms, field strength 10 V/cm, frequency 125 Hz; sinusoidal electric field (SEF) with field strength 1 V/cm, frequency 10 Hz; and alternating magnetic field (AMF) with field density 0.5 mT, frequency 5 Hz. In addition to frequency, the field strength or field density within a suitable intensity scale played a dominant role in causing the DNA synthesis response. We then compared the effects of two kinds of fields, PEF and AMF, with the optimum parameters identified by the experiments, on alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity, protein and collagen synthesis, and intracellular levels of cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP). The results indicated that both fields could not only affect UMR-106 cells proliferation but could particularly affect a series of characteristic bioactivities of UMR-106 such as ALP activity and collagen synthesis. The intracellular cAMP levels were increased rapidly and greatly with exposure to both PEF and AMF, implying that the action of low-frequency EMFs proceeds via second messenger-dependent processes originating from signals at the cell membrane. The difference in action between PEF and AMF suggests that they may couple to the cell membrane in a partially different way.     

60 Hz magnetic field exposure induces DNA crosslinks in rat brain cells

In previous research, we found an increase in DNA strand breaks in brain cells of rats acutely exposed to a 60 Hz magnetic field (for 2 h at an intensity of 0.5 mT). DNA strand breaks were measured with a microgel electrophoresis assay using the length of DNA migration as an index. In the present experiment, we found that most of the magnetic field-induced increase in DNA migration was observed only after proteinase-K treatment, suggesting that the field caused DNA-protein crosslinks. In addition, when brain cells from control rats were exposed to X-rays, an increase in DNA migration was observed, the extent of which was independent of proteinase-K treatment. However, the X-ray-induced increase in DNA migration was retarded in cells from animals exposed to magnetic fields even after proteinase-K treatment, suggesting that DNA-DNA crosslinks were also induced by the magnetic field. The effects of magnetic fields were also compared with those of a known DNA crosslink-inducing agent mitomycin C. The pattern of effects is similar between the two agents. These data suggest that both DNA-protein and DNA-DNA crosslinks are formed in brain cells of rats after acute exposure to a 60 Hz magnetic field.     

Rats are not aversive when exposed to 60-Hz magnetic fields at 3.03 mT.

Thirty-two male rats were tested in two replicates of an experiment to determine whether body currents induced by 60-Hz magnetic fields might lead to avoidance behavior comparable to that which results from exposure to strong 60-Hz electric fields. The test apparatus was a two-compartment Plexiglas shuttlebox enclosed in a sound-attenuating plywood chamber, which in turn was encompassed by two copper bus bars that, when energized, served as a source of 60-Hz magnetic fields. Location of the rat, and traverse activity in the shuttlebox were monitored by nine infra-red photo detectors equally spaced along the length of the apparatus. Rats were divided into 2 groups: 1 group of rats (n = 8 per group per replicate) was sham exposed while rats in the other group (n = 8 per group per replicate) were exposed to a 3.03 mT (30.3 G), 60-Hz magnetic field whenever they traversed to or were located on the side (L or R) predetermined as the exposed side. To control artifact incident to side preference, the side exposed (L or R) was alternated over the exposed rats. Each rat was tested individually in a 1-h session. A 2-factor ANOVA (exposed vs. control, replicate 1 vs. replicate 2) failed to reveal any significant effects due to either factor or to an interaction between factors. These data demonstrate that rats do not avoid exposure to 60-Hz magnetic fields at a flux density of 3.03 mT and further imply that the avoidance by rats of high level 60-Hz electric fields is mediated by something other than the internal body currents induced by the exposure.     

Currents induced in anatomic models of the human for uniform and nonuniform power frequency magnetic fields

We have used the quasi-static impedance method to calculate the currents induced in the nominal 2 x 2 x 3 and 6 mm resolution anatomically based models of the human body for exposure to magnetic fields at 60 Hz. Uniform magnetic fields of various orientations and magnitudes 1 or 0.417 mT suggested in the ACGIH and ICNIRP safety guidelines are used to calculate induced electric fields or current densities for the various glands and organs of the body including the pineal gland. The maximum 1 cm(2) area-averaged induced current densities for the central nervous system tissues, such as the brain and the spinal cord, were within the reference level of 10 mA/m(2) as suggested in the ICNIRP guidelines for magnetic fields (0.417 mT at 60 Hz). Tissue conductivities were found to play an important role and higher assumed tissue conductivities gave higher induced current densities. We have also determined the induced current density distributions for nonuniform magnetic fields associated with two commonly used electrical appliances, namely a hair dryer and a hair clipper. Because of considerably higher magnetic fields for the latter device, higher induced electric fields and current densities were calculated.     

Effects of sinusoidal 60-Hz electric and magnetic fields on ATP and oxygen levels in the slime mold, Physarum polycephalum

We have previously reported that exposing the vegetative plasmodia stage of Physarum polycephalum to either individual or simultaneously applied electric and magnetic fields (45-75 Hz, 0.14-2.0 G, and 0.035-0.7 V/m) lengthens their mitotic cycle, depresses their rate of reversible shuttle streaming, and lowers their respiration rate. In this article we report the effects of simultaneously applied electromagnetic fields (60 Hz, 1.0 G, 1.0 V/m), electric fields only (60 Hz, 1.0 V/m), magnetic fields only (60 Hz, 1.0 G) on the haploid amoeba of Physarum exposed for 120-180 days. Statistically significant depressions (about 8-11%) in ATP levels were observed with all field conditions; however, respiration was significantly decreased only when amoebae were subjected to either combined fields or electric fields alone. Magnetic fields alone failed to induce a significant decrease in respiration.     

No influence of magnetic fields on cell cycle progression using conditions relevant for patients during MRI

The purpose of this study was to examine whether exposure to magnetic fields (MFs) relevant for magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in clinical routine influences cell cycle progression in two tumor cell lines in vitro. HL60 and EA2 cells were exposed to four types of MFs: (i) static MF of 1.5 and 7.05 T, (ii) extremely low frequency magnetic gradient fields (ELFMGFs) with +/- 10 mT/m and 100 Hz, as well as +/- 100 mT/m and 100 Hz, (iii) pulsed high frequency MF in the radiofrequency (RF) range (63.6 MHz, 5.8 microT), and (iv) a combination of (i-iii). Exposure periods ranged from 1 to 24 h. Cell cycle distribution (G(0)/G(1), S, and G(2)/M phases) was analyzed by flow cytometry. Cell cycle analysis did not reveal differences between the exposed and the control cells. As expected, positive controls with irradiated (8 Gy) HL60 and EA2 cells showed a strong G(2)/M arrest. Using conditions that are relevant for patients during MRI, no influence of MFs on cell cycle progression was observed in these cell lines. Care was taken to control secondary parameters of influence, such as vibration by the MR scanner or temperature to avoid false positive results.     

Increase in X-ray-induced mutations by exposure to magnetic field (60 Hz, 5 mT) in NF-kappaB-inhibited cells

It is established that extremely low frequency magnetic fields (ELFMF) at the flux densities, i.e., 5 mT and less, are not mutagenic. However, exposure to ELFMF enhances mutations induced by X-rays. In this study, we examined the effects of long-term exposure to 5 mT ELFMF on mutation induction and X-ray-induced mutations in human malignant glioma cells (MO54) with different mutant IkappaB-alpha (a critical inhibitor of NF-kappaB) genes. Cells were exposed or sham-exposed to 5 mT ELFMF for up to 8 days with or without initial X-rays (4 Gy), and the mutant frequency of hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyl transferase (HPRT) gene was analyzed. An obvious increase in X-ray-induced mutations was observed after treatment with ELFMF in combination with X-irradiation in MO54 cells with tyrosine mutant IkappaB-alpha gene other than with serine mutant IkappaB-alpha gene or vector alone. Exposure to ELFMF alone increased mutations significantly in MO54 cells with tyrosine mutant IkappaB-alpha gene. In addition, X-ray-induced apoptoic cells were increased in MO54-V cells after exposure to ELFMF, while an anti-apoptotic effect of magnetic field was found in MO54-SY4 cells. Our data suggest that exposure to 5 mT ELFMF may induce mutations and enhance X-ray-induced mutations, resulting from the inactivation of NF-kappaB through the inhibition of tyrosine phosphorylation.     

Absence of DNA damage after 60-Hz electromagnetic field exposure combined with ionizing radiation,hydrogen peroxide,or c-Myc overexpression

The principal objective of this study was to assess the DNA damage in a normal cell line system after exposure to 60 Hz of extremely low frequency magnetic field (ELF-MF) and particularly in combination with various external factors, via comet assays. NIH3T3 mouse fibroblast cells, WI-38 human lung fibroblast cells, L132 human lung epithelial cells, and MCF10A human mammary gland epithelial cells were exposed for 4 or 16 h to a 60-Hz, 1 mT uniform magnetic field in the presence or absence of ionizing radiation (IR, 1 Gy), H₂O₂ (50 μM), or c-Myc oncogenic activation. The results obtained showed no significant differences between the cells exposed to ELF-MF alone and the unexposed cells. Moreover, no synergistic or additive effects were observed after 4 or 16 h of pre-exposure to 1 mT ELF-MF or simultaneous exposure to ELF-MF combined with IR, H₂O₂, or c-Myc activation.     

Increase in hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyl transferase gene mutations by exposure to electric field

Previously, we reported that exposure to extremely low frequency magnetic field (400 mT) increased in hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyl transferase (HPRT) gene mutations. However, it is unclear these mutations were induced by magnetic field (MF), electric field (EF), or both. To explore this question, a new exposure apparatus for EF was manufactured. We observed an increase in HPRT gene mutations in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells after exposure to EF (10 V/m, 60 Hz) for 10 h. The mutant frequency by EF-exposure was an approximate 2-fold of that by sham-exposure. Our data suggest that the mutations induced by exposure of cells to the variable magnetic field at 400 mT may be, in part, due to the induced EF.     

Increase in radiation-induced HPRT gene mutation frequency after nonthermal exposure to nonionizing 60 Hz electromagnetic fields

It is widely accepted that moderate levels of nonionizing electric or magnetic fields, for example 50/60 Hz magnetic fields of about 1 mT, are not mutagenic. However, it is not known whether such fields can enhance the action of known mutagens. To explore this question, a stringent experimental protocol, which included blinding and systematic negative controls, was implemented, minimizing the possibility of observer bias or experimental artifacts. As a model system, we chose to measure mutation frequencies induced by 2 Gy gamma rays in the redox-sensitive hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyl transferase (HPRT) gene in Chinese hamster ovary cells. We tested whether a 12-h exposure to a 60 Hz sinusoidally oscillating magnetic-flux density (Brms = 0.7 mT) could affect the mutagenic effects of ionizing radiation on the HPRT gene locus. We determined that the magnetic-field exposure induced an approximate 1.8-fold increase in HPRT mutation frequency. Additional experiments at Brms = 0.23 and 0.47 mT revealed that the effect was reduced at lower flux densities. The field exposure did not enhance radiation-induced cytotoxicity or mutation frequencies in cells not exposed to ionizing radiation. These results suggest that moderate-strength, oscillating magnetic fields may act as an enhancer of mutagenesis in mammalian cells.     

Effect of high-density extremely low frequency magnetic field on sister chromatid exchanges in mouse m5S cells

The induction of sister chromatid exchanges (SCEs) was evaluated in the cultured mouse m5S cells after exposure to extremely low frequency magnetic field (ELFMF; 5, 50 and 400 mT). Exposure to 5 mT and 50 mT ELFMF led to a very small increase in the frequency of SCEs, but no significant difference was observed between exposed and unexposed control cells. The cells exposed to 400 mT ELFMF exhibited a significant elevation of the SCE frequencies. There was no significant difference between data from treatments with mitomycin-C (MMC) alone and from combined treatments of MMC plus ELFMF (400 mT) at any MMC concentrations from 4 to 40 nM. These results suggest that exposure to highest-density ELFMF of 400 mT may induce DNA damage, resulting in an elevation of the SCE frequencies. We suppose that there may be a threshold for the elevation of the SCE frequencies, that is at least over the magnetic density of 50 mT.     

Morphologic responses of osteoblast-like cells in monolayer culture to ELF electromagnetic fields

Osteoblast-like cells (MC 3T3-E1) were exposed for 24 h, immediately after plating, to a 60 Hz, 0.7 mT rms magnetic flux density, sufficient to induce an electric field of 0.5 mV/m rms, in order to investigate the influence of ELF field exposure on cell morphology. Using phase contrast images of the live cells, computerized image-analysis permitted rapid and objective quantification of cell length, width, area, perimeter, circularity and angular orientation. While the field-exposed cells were consistently smaller than sham treated cells, the morphologic alterations were not significantly different in the exposed cell population when cell orientation was not considered. When analyzed with respect to cell orientation, cells oriented parallel to the induced electric field (orthogonal to the applied magnetic field) demonstrated a significant decrease in cell length and an increase in roundness. These results confirm and extend previous studies on the morphologic adaptation of cells to low level ELF electromagnetic fields. The results suggest that the observed responses most likely depend on the induced electric field, with a field intensity threshold well below 1 mV/m. Further, these results provide important clues to the specific mechanism by which such low level fields may be capable of influencing cell behavior, and help to explain some of the difficulties in obtaining robust responses in in vitro EMF experiments.     

No effect of exposure to static and sinusoidal magnetic fields on nitric oxide production by macrophages

The effects of exposure to static (1–100 mT) or sinusoidal (1 Hz, 1.6 mT) magnetic fields on the production of nitric oxide (NO) by murine BCG-activated macrophages were investigated. In these cells, the inducible isoform of NO synthase is present. No significant differences were observed in nitrite levels among exposed, sham-exposed, or control macrophages after exposure for 14 h to static fields of 1, 10, 50, and 100 mT and to sinusoidal 1.6 mT, 1 Hz magnetic fields. © 1996 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

In vitro effects of low-level, low-frequency electromagnetic fields on DNA damage in human leucocytes by comet assay

The sources for the effects of electromagnetic fields (EMFs) have been traced to time-varying as well as steady electric and magnetic fields, both at low and high to ultra high frequencies. Of these, the effects of low-frequency (50/60 HZ) magnetic fields, directly related to time-varying currents, are of particular interest as exposure to some fields may be commonly experienced. In the present study, investigations have been carried out at low-level (mT) and low-frequency (50 Hz) electromagnetic fields in healthy human volunteers. Their peripheral blood samples were exposed to 5 doses of electromagnetic fields (2,3,5,7 and 10mT at 50 Hz) and analysed by comet assay. The results were compared to those obtained from unexposed samples from the same subjects. 50 cells per treatment per individual were scored for comet-tail length which is an estimate of DNA damage. Data from observations among males were pooled for each flux density for analysis. At each flux density, with one exception, there was a significant increase in the DNA damage from the control value. When compared with a similar study on females carried out by us earlier, the DNA damage level was significantly higher in the females as compared to the males for each flux density.     

Thresholds for 60 Hz magnetic field stimulation of peripheral nerves in human subjects

The goal of the research reported here is to narrow the range of uncertainty about peripheral nerve stimulation (PNS) thresholds associated with whole body magnetic field exposures at 50/60 Hz. This involved combining PNS thresholds measured in human subjects exposed to pulsed magnetic gradient fields with calculations of electric fields induced in detailed anatomical models of the body by that same exposure system. PNS thresholds at power frequencies (50/60 Hz) can be predicted from these data due to the wide range of pulse durations (70 mus to 1 ms), the length of the pulse trains (several tens of ms), and the exposure of a large part of the body to the magnetic field. These data together with the calculations of the rheobase electric field exceeded in 1% (E(1%)) of two anatomical body models, lead to a median PNS detection threshold of 47.9 +/- 4.4 mT for a uniform 60 Hz magnetic field exposure coronal to the body. The threshold for the most sensitive 1% of the population is about 27.8 mT. These values are lower than PNS thresholds produced by magnetic fields with sagittal and vertical orientations or nonuniform exposures.     

The Effect of ELF Magnetic Field on Tumor Growth after Electrochemotherapy

From a fundamental point of view, chemotherapy is the most widely used treatment for cancers despite its side effects on normal cells and tissues. Electrochemotherapy (ECT) is a method for increasing the permeability of cancer cells to drugs and, hence, decreasing their dosage. It apparently creates electropores on the cell membrane using electric pulses. ECT can decrease tumor volume; but this effect is not permanent, and partial regrowth has been reported. The aim of this study was to investigate the potential of magnetic fields in preventing the regrowth of tumors after ECT. Tumoral Balb/c mice were exposed to a magnetic field (15 mT, 50 Hz) for 12 days after treating additionally with 70 V/cm electric pulses and bleomycin at the first day. The magnetic field caused a significant reduction in tumor volumes, while there was no significant difference between the ECT and the electroporation with ECT and magnetic field groups. The exploited magnetic field (15 mT, 50 Hz) could decrease the tumor growth rate significantly, without any effect on ECT efficiency.