Embryo sex selection by a rat male-specific antibody and the cytogenetic and developmental confirmation in cattle embryos

Embryos of mouse, rabbit, goat, sheep, and cattle were separated into 2 groups on the basis of their morphology when incubated with a male-specific antibody (qualified here as the H-Y antibody) prepared from newborn rat testis. When morula-stage embryos were cultured in the presence of this H-Y antibody, the development of roughly one half of the embryos was arrested at that stage, whereas the other half continued to develop to the blastocyst stage. The developmentaly arrested group of embryos resumed their development into blastocysts when cultured in antibody-free medium. Eighty to 90% of cattle embryos whose development was unaffected by the antibody were shown to possess a female karyotype (XX), and close to 80% of those embryos whose development was arrested possessed a male karyotype (XY). Cattle embryos whose sex had been presumptively identified by development in the presence of the H-Y antibody were cryopreserved and transferred, and the sex of the calves was examined. The overt sex of the young born from sexed embryos was found to be the same as that determined by chromosomal analysis. © 1993 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Sexing in vitro produced bovine embryos, at different stages of development, using rat H-Y antiserum

The male-specific H-Y antigen is present on mammalian cell membranes and has been identified by various methods, including antiserum cytotoxicity. The objective of the present study was to determine the sex of in vitro produced (IVP) bovine embryos, at varying stages of development, by culturing in the presence of rat monoclonal H-Y antibodies. Embryos derived from IVM/IVF were classified according to the interval after IVF (48, 96 or 120 h) as Category 1, 2 or 3 if they had 4 to 8, <32, and >32 cells, respectively. Embryos of each category were cultured for 24h in TCM-199 supplemented with bovine oviductal epithelial cells, fetal calf serum (FCS), and antibiotics (Control group), to which the following had been added: guinea pig serum (GPS; C' group); H-Y antiserum (HY group); or GPS and H-Y antiserum (C' + HY group). After culture, embryos were designated as "affected" when development was arrested or one or more blastomeres was degenerate; embryos lacking these changes were designated "unaffected." The sex of each embryo was subsequently determined by chromosome analysis. After 48h of IVF (Category 1), within each of the four treatments, the proportion of unaffected embryos was higher than the proportion of unaffected embryos (81% versus 19%, P < 0.05). Similarly, the Control, C' and HY groups of Categories 2 and 3 embryos had different proportions of unaffected versus affected embryos (75% versus 25%, P < 0.05). In all these groups, the male:female ratio did not significantly differ from 1:1. In contrast, in the C' + HY group of Categories 2 and 3 embryos, the ratio of unaffected versus affected embryos was 41% versus 59% (P < 0.05) and the male:female ratio differed (P < 0.05) from the expected 1:1 ratio (approximately 0.3:1 and 4.5:1 for unaffected versus affected, respectively). In conclusion, when bovine embryos were cultured in the presence of rat monoclonal H-Y antibodies and compliment, alterations occurred in embryos that were beyond the 8-cell stage; we inferred that the antibodies cross-reacted with H-Y antigens.     

Survival after transfer of “sexed” mouse embryos exposed to H-Y antisera

Immunological means were used to determine the sex of mouse embryos prior to transfer to pseudopregnant recipients. Antisera to histocompatibility-Y (H-Y) antigen were prepared in adult C57BL/6 female mice by repeated intraperitoneal injections of spleen cells from males of the same strain. Eight-to 16-cell embryos were cultured in BMOC-3 alone or BMOC-3 without bovine serum albumin to which one of the following had been added: H-Y antiserum and normal guinea pig serum (NGPS), NGPS alone, normal mouse serum alone or normal mouse serum and NGPS. After 24 hr of culture, embryos were classified as either affected or unaffected. An embryo was classified as affected if degeneration of the embryo or breakdown of one or more cells was observed. A total of 1000 embryos were cultured in BMOC-3 with H-Y antiserum and NGPS (treated embryos). Two hundred and fifty embryos were cultured in each of the other four media (control embryos). Eighty-seven (9%) of the control embryos and 479 (48%) of the treated embryos were classified as affected after culture. Unaffected embryos, approximately 12 each, were transferred to pseudopregnant recipients. One-hundred forty control embryos (17%) survived to term with 67 females (48%) and 73 males (52%) born. Fifty-eight treated embryos (14%) survived to term, producing 50 females (86%) and 8 males (14%). Percentage of females from embryos cultured in antiserum was greater than for embryos cultured in any other media (P<0.001). These results demonstrate that detection of H-Y antigen on preimplantation embryos may be a useful and effective method of determining sex of an embryo prior to transfer.     

Identification of a male-specific histocompatibility protein on preimplantation porcine embryos

An indirect immunofluorescence assay was used to detect the presence of male-specific protein(s) on various stages of preimplantation porcine embryos. Embryos were collected at slaughter from the reproductive tracts of day?2.5, ?4, ?5, ?6, and ?8 (day 0 = first day of estrus) sows and gilts. Embryos were placed in medium containing an anti-male primary antibody, washed, and transferred to culture drops containing a fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC)-labeled secondary antibody. Embryos were classified as either fluorescent (H-Y positive) or nonfluorescent (H-Y negative), transferred to coded drops, and karyotyped to examine sex chromosomes. A total of 91 eight-cell to blastocyst stage embryos were evaluated; of these, 46% were classified as fluorescent and 54% as nonfluorescent. Of readable metaphase spreads (65%) from these embryos, 81% (48 of 59, P < 0.005) were correctly sexed by immunological detection of the male-specific antigen. Although 13 % (2/15)of four-cell embryos evaluated were classified as fluorescent, the accuracy with which embryos at this stage were sexed by detection of H-Y antigen was not different from 50%. Fifty percent of eight-cell embryos were classified as H-Y positive with 78% of embryos correctly sexed. It was concluded that the eight-cell embryo is the earliest stage of development for which there is evidence for expression of H-Y antigen. Detection of the male-specific protein was difficult at the expanded blastocyst stage.     

Evaluation of the presence of a specific histocompatibility protein on equine embryonic cells

An indirect immunofluorescence assay was used to detect the presence of H-Y antigen on equine blastocysts. A total of 33 blastocyst stage horse embryos were collected 6 to 7 days post-ovulation by trans-cervical flush and were immediately evaluated for the presence of H-Y antigen. Additionally, 17 embryos, were collected and cultured for 72 h to the expanded blastocyst stage and similarly evaluated. Embryos were placed in medium containing monoclonal antibodies to H-Y antigen followed by incubation in medium containing 1/10 (v/v) fluorescein isothiocyanate conjugated goat anti-mouse IgM Fc specific antiserum. Embryos were individually evaluated at 400X to identify cell specific fluorescence. Following evaluation, embryonic sex was independently verified with karyotypes to identify sex chromosomes. Of the 50 embryos evaluated, 29 were evaluated as non-fluorescent and 21 fluorescent. Expression of H-Y antigen was determined to be uniform in those embryos classified as fluorescent. Twenty-three of 28 (82%) readable karyotypes corresponded to the predicted sex. These results indicate a specific histocompatibility antigen is expressed and maintained at the blastocyst stage of development. In addition, no segregation of this protein on specific cell types occurs in this species.     

Investigation of sperm cytotoxicity as an indicator of ability of antisera to detect male-specific antigen on preimplantation mouse embryos

H-Y antisera were produced in C57BL/6 female mice by repeated intraperitoneal injections of syngeneic male spleen cells. Epididymal spermatozoa were incubated in the presence of H-Y antisera and guinea-pig serum as a complement source. Levels of ATP remaining after treatment were used to calculate the amount of specific killing. Sera of different cytotoxic titres were used in an indirect immunofluorescent assay with a fluorescein isothiocyanate-conjugated IgG fraction of goat anti-mouse IgG (Fc fragment specific) as second antibody. Embryos were classified as fluorescent or nonfluorescent, transferred to pseudopregnant recipients, and allowed to develop to term. Of 12 sera tested for sperm cytotoxicity, 5 were different from a nonimmunized control serum (P less than 0.05). Percentage specific killing in each of these sera was 7.8 +/- 4.2, 11.7 +/- 3.0, 26.0 +/- 2.2, 27.7 +/- 3.7 and 39.2 +/- 4.8, respectively (mean +/- s.e.m. with three replicates). The 5 sera and an additional one (4.9 +/- 1.3% specific killing) were used in the embryo sexing experiment. The accuracy with which these sera correctly identified sex of preimplantation embryos was 60, 46, 74, 73, 74 and 48%, respectively. Correlation coefficients were 0.86 (P less than 0.05) for specific sperm cytotoxicity and percentage of nonfluorescent embryos that were female and 0.78 (n.s.) for specific sperm cytotoxicity and percentage of fluorescent embryos that were male. Therefore, although the sperm cytotoxicity test is useful for screening antisera for the study of H-Y antigen expression on preimplantation embryos, nonfluorescent embryos are more accurately classified as females than are fluorescent embryos as male.     

Expression of a male-specific factor on various stages of preimplantation bovine embryos

Four-cell to blastocyst stage bovine embryos were collected from superovulated donors and cultured for 90 min in Ham's F-10 medium (HF-10) containing 10% (V/V) absorbed anti-histocompatibility (H)-Y antiserum. Embryos were then washed 3 times and placed in HF-10 supplemented with 10% (V/V) fluorescein isothiocynate (FITC)-conjugated goat anti-mouse gamma globulin. After an additional wash, embryos were placed in fresh drops of HF-10, individually evaluated at 200 X magnification, and classified as either fluorescent (H-Y-positive) or nonfluorescent (H-Y-negative). Embryos were then placed in drops of HF-10 containing 14% vinblastin and cultured for 4-6 h. Embryos were coded and individually karotyped, and the sex chromosomes were identified. H-Y antigen was detected as early as the eight-cell stage, but not at the four-cell stage. Seventy-nine percent of fluorescent embryos and 89% of nonfluorescent embryos were XY and XX, respectively. Another experiment was carried out in which H-Y antigen was detected on intact inner cell masses (ICM) isolated by immunosurgery from expanded blastocysts that also had been assayed for H-Y antigen. Eighty-eight and 92%, respectively, of ICM classified as fluorescent or nonfluorescent had been scored the same as intact blastocysts. It is concluded from these data that H-Y antigen can be detected on eight-cell to blastocyst stage bovine embryos. There appears to be a localization of detectable antigen in the area of the ICM at the expanded blastocyst stage. Detection of H-Y antigen is an effective, noninvasive method for identification of the sex of preimplantation bovine embryos.     

A technique for sexing mouse embryos by a visual colorimetric assay of the X-linked enzyme, glucose 6-phosphate dehydrogenase

Described is a simple visual, colorimetric assay for the X-linked enzyme, glucose 6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD), in mouse embryos. Included is a demonstration of the effectiveness of the assay in predicting the sex of embryos prior to transfer. Scoring of embryos according to G6PD content resulted in an apparent bimodal distribution with 50% scoring as females, i.e., double dosage of G6PD, and 50% scoring as males, i.e., single dosage of G6PD. Transfer of "sexed" embryos to surrogate mothers resulted in an overall birth rate of 35% (181 516 ) compared to 46% (39 84 ) for controls. Embryos predicted as females resulted in a birth rate of 35% (86 247 ), and 72% (62 86 ) of pups born were female. Embryos predicted as males resulted in a birth rate of 35% (95 269 ), and 57% (54 95 ) of pups born were male. Overall, the accuracy of the assay was 64% (116 181 ) in predicting sex, i.e., about two-thirds of the embryos were correctly sexed prior to transfer.     

Birth of rats following nuclear exchange at the 2-cell stage

We report full-term development of nuclear transfer embryos following nuclear exchange at the 2-cell stage. Nuclei from 2-cell rat embryos were transferred into enucleated 2-cell embryos and developed to term after transfer to recipients (NT2). Pronuclear exchange in zygotes was used for comparison (NT1). Zygotes and 2-cell embryos were harvested from 4-week-old female Sprague-Dawley rats. Nuclear transfer was performed by transferring the pronuclei or karyoplasts into the perivitelline space of recipient embryos followed by electrofusion to reconstruct embryos. Fused couplets were cultured for 4 or 24 h before being transferred into day 1 pseudopregnant recipients (Hooded Wistar) at the 1- or 2-cell stage. In vitro culture was also carried out to check the developmental competence of the embryos. In vitro development to the blastocyst stage was not significantly different between the two groups (NT1, 34.3%; NT2, 45.0%). Two of three recipients from NT1 and two of five recipients from NT2 became pregnant. Six pups (3 from NT1, 3 from NT2) were delivered from the four foster mothers. Three female pups survived; 2 from NT1 and 1 from NT2. At 2 months of age these pups appeared healthy, and were mated with Sprague-Dawley males. One rat derived from NT1 delivered 15 pups (5 males, 10 females) as did the rat from NT2 (7 males, 8 females). Our results show that by using karyoplasts from 2-cell stage embryos as nuclear donors and reconstructing them with enucleated 2-cell embryos, healthy rats can be produced.     

Sexing of rat embryos with antisera specific for male rats.

Male-specific antigenicity (H-Y antigen) of rat embryos has been examined, and the feasibility of sexing rat embryos by use of H-Y antibodies has been studied. Rat H-Y antisera were produced by immunization of female Wistar rats with a homogenate of testes from male Wistar neonates. Male specificity of the antiserum (H-Y antibody) was determined by retention of cytotoxicity to male epidermal cells after absorption with female cells. After cultivation of rat embryos for 5 to 6 hr in the presence of antibody, half of the embryos were arrested at the morula stage. However, these embryos developed into blastocysts after removal of the antiserum, and then they grew into male young in recipient foster mothers. Eighty percent of the embryos that developed to blastocysts in the presence of the antiserum grew into female young.     

Superovulation treatments and embryo transfer in Angora goats

A high incidence of early luteal regression after PMSG superovulation was associated with low recovery of embryos from reproductive tracts of Angora goats flushed later than Day 5 after onset of oestrus. Embryos were successfully recovered (mean 7.9/female) by flushing on Days 2-5. Mean ovulation rate after an FSH regimen (16.1 +/- 0.8) was significantly higher than that after a single injection of PMSG (10.8 +/- 1.2). Fertilization rate and survival of embryos following transfer to naturally synchronized recipient feral goats did not differ between the two gonadotrophin regimens: the mean number of kids born to 47 donors treated with FSH (7.5 +/- 0.6) was significantly greater than that to 28 donors treated with PMSG (4.8 +/- 0.6). Irrespective of hormonal treatment, the numbers of embryos recovered and of kids born were correlated with ovulation rate (r = 0.82, P less than 0.001 for both). Embryo survival was influenced by ovulation rate in recipients, with 52%, 63% and 75% of transferred embryos being carried to term by recipients with 1,2 and 3 CL, respectively (P less than 0.01). More embryos survived (65%) when 2 embryos were transferred to each recipient than when 1 (51%) or 3 (48%) were transferred. In recipients receiving 2 embryos, survival was significantly improved by transfer of both embryos to the same oviduct (70%) than when one was transferred to each oviduct (62%). The percentage survival of embryos was optimal when oestrus of recipients was synchronized within +/- 1 day of oestrus in donors.     

Viability of blastocysts produced by aggregation of two half-embryos in the mouse

Although methods for production of chimeras from early cleavage stages have been well established, little research has been directed toward production of genetically identical chimeric offspring. This study was designed to examine survival of blastocysts produced by aggregation of two halved eight-cell stage embryos from two different mouse strains. Four blastomeres of an eight-cell embryo from a pigmented strain were aggregated with four blastomeres of an eight-cell embryo from a nonpigmented strain. Aggregates were cultured for 48 h and transferred as blastocysts to synchronized recipients of three treatment groups. Viability was determined by examining the number of offspring produced relative to the number of blastocysts transferred. Thirty-nine pups were born from 375 transferred blastocysts (10%), with 16 pups displaying coat-color chimerism. Both nonmanipulated eight-cell embryos cultured for 48 h (P < 0.05) and chimeric blastocysts (P < 0.001) displayed lower embryo survival after transfer to recipients than noncultured, nonmanipulated blastocysts used as controls. Viability of chimeric blastocysts was also lower than that of nonmanipulated embryos cultured for the same period and transferred to the same recipients (P < 0.001). Although posttransfer survival of chimeric blastocysts was low, the birth of morphologically normal offspring demonstrated that production of chimeras from half embryos was compatible with survival. Improvements in this procedure may be useful for production of tenetically identical chimeras from outbred populations, such as those commonly found in domestic livestock species.     

Influence of beta-carotene on fertility in rabbits when using embryo transfer programs

The effect of beta-carotene on reproduction traits in rabbits was studied in 509 (superovulated and normally ovulated) donors and 239 recipients by using embryo/gene transfer performed at 2 different locations. All of the bucks and the half of the females were fed a diet supplemented with 40 mg synthetic beta-carotene (Rovimix((R)))/kg feed. Embryos at the pronucleus stage were collected 19 to 21 hours after induction of ovulation with human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG); they were then microinjected into the male pronucleus and transferred to synchronized recipients. Data were obtained from the time when the donors and recipients were caged, until the pups resulting from the embryo transfers were weaned. Supplemented beta-carotene did not affect most of the 30 traits that were analyzed. However superovulated donors in Project 2 that received the beta-carotene enriched diet had a 14% lighter ovary weight (P<0.05) and less than half of the oocytes were unfertilized (P<0.05). In Project 1 (beta-carotene group) there was a greater number of pups born (36%, P<0.05) and more of these pups were born alive (53%, P<0.05).     

H-Y antigen in the study of sex determination and control of sex ratio

It has been proposed, on the basis of widespread phylogenetic conservation, that H-Y antigen is the inducer of primary sex, causing the undifferentiated XY gonad to become a testis in male heterogametic species such as the human and bovine. That proposition has withstood extensive testing in vivo and in vitro. Freemartin gonads are H-Y⁺, for example, and masculinization of the freemartin gonad has been attributed to soluble H-Y, borne and transmitted in the serum of the bull twin, and bound in ovarian receptors of the female. We have applied monoclonal H-Y antibodies to the identification of gender in embryos of the bovine. Our preliminary results imply presence of H-Y in bovine embryos of the morula and blastocyst stages recovered at about 6–12 days of gestation. Assignment of H-Y phenotype -- positive in males and negative in females -- allows selective implantation of male and female during embryo transfer. Thus in an early study, we correctly identified gender in 6 of 7 calves born healthy at term, after transfer of 8 blastocysts.     

First birth of an animal from an extinct subspecies (Capra pyrenaica pyrenaica) by cloning

Two experiments have been performed to clone the bucardo, an extinct wild goat. The karyoplasts were thawed fibroblasts derived from skin biopsies, obtained and cryopreserved in 1999 from the last living specimen, a female, which died in 2000. Cytoplasts were mature oocytes collected from the oviducts of superovulated domestic goats. Oocytes were enucleated and coupled to bucardo's fibroblasts by electrofusion. Reconstructed embryos were cultured for 36 h or 7 d and transferred to either Spanish ibex or hybrid (Spanish ibex male ×  domestic goat) synchronized recipients. Embryos were placed, according to their developmental stage, into the oviduct or into the uterine horn ipsilateral to an ovulated ovary. Pregnancy was monitored through their plasmatic PAG levels. In Experiment 1, 285 embryos were reconstructed and 30 of them were transferred at the 3- to 6-cells stage to 5 recipients. The remaining embryos were further cultured to day 7, and 24 of them transferred at compact morula/blastocyst stage to 8 recipients. In Experiment 2, 154 reconstructed embryos were transferred to 44 recipients at the 3- to 6-cells stage. Pregnancies were attained in 0/8 and 7/49 of the uterine and oviduct-transferred recipients, respectively. One recipient maintained pregnancy to term, displaying very high PAG levels. One morphologically normal bucardo female was obtained by caesarean section. The newborn died some minutes after birth due to physical defects in lungs. Nuclear DNA confirmed that the clone was genetically identical to the bucardo's donor cells. To our knowledge, this is the first animal born from an extinct subspecies.     

Mouse interferon produced in vivo does not inhibit the development of preimplantation mouse embryos

Mouse embryos were cultured in vitro in medium with serum containing interferon which had been induced in vivo by intravenous administration of polyinosine-polycytidylic acid. Two-cell and blastocyst-stage embryos were incubated for 72 and 24 h respectively before embryo transfer, or fixation to determine cell number. Further, blastocysts were outgrown on coverslips in embryo culture medium with fetal calf serum and interferon. Expression of an intermediate filament protein (Mr 55 000) in blastocyst outgrowths was examined with a monoclonal antibody. Embryos appeared morphologically normal and after treatment the mean cell number did not differ from that of controls. Implantation was unaffected by any of the treatments, but culture before transfer in medium containing mouse serum reduced the number of normal fetuses recovered on Day 14 of gestation compared to those cultured in medium without serum. Exposure to interferon did not modify the expression of filaments in the outgrown blastocyst. It is therefore unlikely that interferon induced by viral infection during pregnancy is responsible for preimplantation embryonic loss.     

Successful implantation of in vitro cultured rabbit embryos after uterine transfer: A role for mucin

The functional role of the mucin layer for development of rabbit embryos was examined by uterine transfer of embryos with different thicknesses of mucin. Embryos collected at various intervals after human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) injection were cultured until 90 hr post-coitum (p.c.) and transferred to the uterus of synchronized recipients. When embryos collected at 20 or 25 hr p.c. were used for transfer, no implantation occurred. By contrast, embryos collected at 35 or 40 hr p.c. developed to term at high rates (53 and 80%, respectively). The thickness of the mucin layer on the embryos was different between these two groups. Embryos collected before 25 hr p.c. have less than 11.2 ± 0.2 μm of thickness of mucin and embryos collected after 35 hr p.c. have more than 34.3 ± 5.5 μm. To examine whether mucin deposition is required for in vitro cultured rabbit blastocysts to continue development after uterine transfer, embryos were collected at 20 hr p.c., cultured for 60 or 70 hr in vitro, and then temporarily transferred to the oviducts of recipient does to add mucin. These embryos were recovered from the oviducts at 24 hr after transfer, classified according to the thickness of mucin deposition, and transferred again to the uterus of synchronized recipients. Twenty live young were obtained from 67 embryos with a 20–40 μm thick mucin layer. No live young were obtained from 57 embryos with less than a 20 μm thick mucin. The thickness of the mucin layer appears to be an important factor for successful implantation of rabbit embryos. © 1996 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Efficient selection of transgenic mouse embryos using EGFP as a marker gene

We have established a reliable method that uses the EGFP (Enhanced Green Fluorescent Protein) gene as a marker for selecting transgenic embryos from preimplantation embryos. Embryos that were subjected to the pronuclear microinjection of the CMV/β‐actin/EGFP fusion gene were cultured in vitro until they developed into the morulae‐ or blastocyst‐stage. The expression of EGFP was easily observed by a fluorescent microscopy. There appeared to be no damage to the in vivo developmental ability of the embryos in response to the EGFP excitation light, which utilized an IB filter for a period of 30 min. Modified PCR analysis using Dpn I and Bal 31 digestion of the embryonic DNA showed that all of the embryos expressing EGFP in all their cells were transgenic, while more than half with mosaic expression of EGFP were not transgenic. Approximately 77% of pups born from the embryos that uniformly expressed the EGFP gene were transgenic, while 21.4% of pups from the embryos with mosaic expression were transgenics. The results showed that the use of EGFP as a marker is very useful and reliable for selecting transgenic embryos, and that it is important to transfer the embryos expressing EGFP in all their cells to obtain truly transgenic animals. Mol. Reprod. Dev. 54:43–48, 1999. © 1999 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Enzyme immunoassay of H–Y antigen: Experimental and clinical applications

A newly developed enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) was applied for studying H-Y antigen in buffaloes, cattle, horses and humans. A monoclonal H-Y antibody was absorbed with cells from males or females and was then tested against fluid samples known to contain soluble H-Y antigen. In this system, positive absorption manifested itself by a fall in optical density relative to the optical density scored using unabsorbed antibody; this finding signified the presence of H-Y in the absorbing cells. In each of the four species, the fall in optical density was pronounced after absorption with male cells, but some decrease was also evident after absorption with female cells, indicating a degree of nonspecific attachment of the antibody.     

Detection of H-Y in the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay

Summary We have developed a new enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for determination of H-Y phenotype in the human. This assay, which measures the inhibition of the reaction of a monoclonal anti-H-Y antibody and a mouse testis extract as a source of H-Y antigen, was applied to the supernatant of lymphocytes from ten normal male and ten normal female subjects. Introduction of supernatant from male cells gave reading of 69%–78% of those obtained with testis supernatant alone; female-cell supernatant did not inhibit the reaction (89%–102%).