Combinatorial chemical reengineering of the alpha class glutathione transferases

Previously, we discovered that human glutathione transferases (hGSTs) from the alpha class can be rapidly and quantitatively modified on a single tyrosine residue (Y9) using thioesters of glutathione (GS-thioesters) as acylating reagents. The current work was aimed at exploring the potential of this site-directed acylation using a combinatorial approach, and for this purpose a panel of 17 GS-thioesters were synthesized in parallel and used in screening experiments with the isoforms hGSTs A1-1, A2-2, A3-3, and A4-4. Through analytical HPLC and MALDI-MS experiments, we found that between 70 and 80% of the reagents are accepted and this is thus a very versatile reaction. The range of ligands that can be used to covalently reprogram these proteins is now expanded to include functionalities such as fluorescent groups, a photochemical probe, and an aldehyde as a handle for further chemical derivatization. This site-specific modification reaction thus allows us to create novel functional proteins with a great variety of artificial chemical groups in order to, for example, specifically tag GSTs in biological samples or create novel enzymatic function using appropriate GS-thioesters.     

Cytosolic glutathione transferases from rat liver. Primary structure of class alpha glutathione transferase 8-8 and characterization of low-abundance class Mu glutathione transferases.

Six GSH transferases with neutral/acidic isoelectric points were purified from the cytosol fraction of rat liver. Four transferases are class Mu enzymes related to the previously characterized GSH transferases 3-3, 4-4 and 6-6, as judged by structural and enzymic properties. Two additional GSH transferases are distinguished by high specific activities with 4-hydroxyalk-2-enals, toxic products of lipid peroxidation. The most abundant of these two enzymes, GSH transferase 8-8, a class Alpha enzyme, has earlier been identified in rat lung and kidney. The amino acid sequence of subunit 8 was determined and showed a typical class Alpha GSH transferase structure including an N-acetylated N-terminal methionine residue.     

Structural determinants of glutathione transferases with azathioprine activity identified by DNA shuffling of alpha class members

A library of alpha class glutathione transferases (GSTs), composed of chimeric enzymes derived from human (A1-1, A2-2 and A3-3), bovine (A1-1) and rat (A2-2 and A3-3) cDNA sequences was constructed by the method of DNA shuffling. The GST variants were screened in bacterial lysates for activity with the immunosuppressive agent azathioprine, a prodrug that is transformed into its active form, 6-mercaptopurine, by reaction with the tripeptide glutathione catalyzed by GSTs. Important structural determinants for activity with azathioprine were recognized by means of primary structure analysis and activities of purified enzymes chosen from the screening. The amino acid sequences could be divided into 23 exchangeable segments on the basis of the primary structures of 45 chosen clones. Segments 2, 20, 21, and 22 were identified as primary determinants of the azathioprine activity representing two of the regions forming the substrate-binding H-site. Segments 21 and 22 are situated in the C-terminal helix characterizing alpha class GSTs, which is instrumental in their catalytic function. The study demonstrates the power of DNA shuffling in identifying segments of primary structure that are important for catalytic activity with a targeted substrate. GSTs in combination with azathioprine have potential as selectable markers for use in gene therapy. Knowledge of activity-determining segments in the structure is valuable in the protein engineering of glutathione transferase for enhanced or suppressed activity.     

Experimental conditions affecting functional comparison of highly active glutathione transferases

Glutathione transferases (GSTs, EC 2.5.1.18) possess multiple functions and have potential applications in biotechnology. Direct evidence of underestimation of activity of human GST A3-3 and porcine GST A2-2 measured at submicromolar enzyme concentrations is reported here for the first time. The combination of time-dependent and enzyme concentration-dependent loss of activity and the choice of the organic solvent for substrates were found to cause irreproducibility of activity measurements of GSTs. These effects contribute to high variability of activity values of porcine GST A2-2 and human Alpha-class GSTs reported in the literature. Adsorption of GSTs to surfaces was found to be the main explanation of the observed phenomena. Several approaches to improved functional comparison of highly active GSTs are proposed.     

Identification, characterization, and crystal structure of the Omega class glutathione transferases

A new class of glutathione transferases has been discovered by analysis of the expressed sequence tag data base and sequence alignment. Glutathione S-transferases (GSTs) of the new class, named Omega, exist in several mammalian species and Caenorhabditis elegans. In humans, GSTO 1-1 is expressed in most tissues and exhibits glutathione-dependent thiol transferase and dehydroascorbate reductase activities characteristic of the glutaredoxins. The structure of GSTO 1-1 has been determined at 2.0-A resolution and has a characteristic GST fold (Protein Data Bank entry code ). The Omega class GSTs exhibit an unusual N-terminal extension that abuts the C terminus to form a novel structural unit. Unlike other mammalian GSTs, GSTO 1-1 appears to have an active site cysteine that can form a disulfide bond with glutathione.     

Activation of rat glutathione transferases in class mu by active oxygen species

The activities of rat glutathione transferases (GSTs) 3-3, 3-4, 4-4 in Class mu towards 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene (CDNB) but not 1,2-dichloro-4-nitrobenzene were increased up to 5-fold during preincubation with 0.4 mM xanthine and xanthine oxidase in 50 mM potassium phosphate, pH 7.8, containing 0.1 mM EDTA. The activated GST 3-4, purified by S-hexylglutathione affinity chromatography after the treatment, had a higher specific activity (130 units/mg) than that of the nontreated (35 units/mg), the Km and Vmax values for glutathione or CDNB also were increased. Other rat GSTs in Class alpha and pi were inactivated by the same treatment. In the presence of superoxide dismutase, the activation of GST 3-4 did not occur.     

Structural evidence for conformational changes of Delta class glutathione transferases after ligand binding

We report four new crystal structures for Delta class glutathione transferases from insects. We compare these new structures as well as several previously reported structures to determine that structural transitions can be observed with ligand binding. These transitions occurred in the regions around the active site entrance, including alpha helix 2, C-terminus of alpha helix 4 including the loop to helix 5 and the C-terminus of helix 8. These structural movements have been reported or postulated to occur for several other glutathione transferase classes; however, this is the first report showing structural evidence of all these movements occurring, in this case in Delta class glutathione transferases. These fluctuations also can be observed occurring within a single structure as there is ligand bound in only one subunit and each subunit is undergoing different conformational transitions. The structural comparisons show reorganizations occur both pre- and post-GSH ligand binding communicated through the subunit interface of the quaternary assembly. Movements of these positions would allow 'breathing' of the active site for substrate entrance, topological rearrangement for varying substrate specificity and final product release.     

Equilibrium folding of dimeric class mu glutathione transferases involves a stable monomeric intermediate

The conformational stabilities of two homodimeric class mu glutathione transferases (GSTM1-1 and GSTM2-2) were studied by urea- and guanidinium chloride-induced denaturation. Unfolding is reversible and structural changes were followed with far-ultraviolet circular dichroism, tryptophan fluorescence, enzyme activity, chemical cross-linking, and size-exclusion chromatography. Disruption of secondary structure occurs as a monophasic transition and is independent of protein concentration. Changes in tertiary structure occur as two transitions; the first is protein concentration dependent, while the second is weakly dependent (GSTM1-1) or independent (GSTM2-2). The second transition corresponds with the secondary structure transition. Loss in catalytic activity occurs as two transitions for GSTM1-1 and as one transition for GSTM2-2. These transitions are dependent upon protein concentration. The first deactivation transition coincides with the first tertiary structure transition. Dimer dissociation occurs prior to disruption of secondary structure. The data suggest that the equilibrium unfolding/refolding of the class mu glutathione transferases M1-1 and M2-2 proceed via a three-state process: N(2) <--> 2I <--> 2U. Although GSTM1-1 and GSTM2-2 are homologous (78% identity/94% homology), their N(2) tertiary structures are not identical. Dissociation of the GSTM1-1 dimer to structured monomers (I) occurs at lower denaturant concentrations than for GSTM2-2. The monomeric intermediate for GSTM1-1 is, however, more stable than the intermediate for GSTM2-2. The intermediates are catalytically inactive and display nativelike secondary structure. Guanidinium chloride-induced denaturation yields monomeric intermediates, which have a more loosely packed tertiary structure displaying enhanced solvent exposure of its tryptophans and enhanced ANS binding. The three-state model for the class mu enzymes is in contrast to the equilibrium two-state models previously proposed for representatives of classes alpha/pi/Sj26 GSTs. Class mu subunits appear to be intrinsically more stable than those of the other GST classes.     

An ensemble of theta class glutathione transferases with novel catalytic properties generated by stochastic recombination of fragments of two mammalian enzymes

The correlation between sequence diversity and enzymatic function was studied in a library of Theta class glutathione transferases (GSTs) obtained by stochastic recombination of fragments of cDNA encoding human GST T1-1 and rat GST T2-2. In all, 94 randomly picked clones were characterized with respect to sequence, expression level, and catalytic activity in the conjugation reactions between glutathione and six alternative electrophilic substrates. Out of these six different compounds, dichloromethane is a selective substrate for human GST T1-1, whereas 1-menaphthyl sulfate and 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene are substrates for rat GST T2-2. The other three substances serve as substrates for both enzymes. Through this broad characterization, we have identified enzyme variants that have acquired novel activity profiles that differ substantially from those of the original GSTs. In addition, the expression levels of many clones were improved in comparison to the parental enzyme. A library of mutants can thus display a distribution of properties from which highly divergent evolutionary pathways may emerge, resembling natural evolutionary processes. From the GST library, a clone was identified that, by the point mutation N49D in the rat GST T2-2 sequence, has a 1700% increased activity with 1-menaphthyl sulfate and a 60% decreased activity with 4-nitrophenethyl bromide. Through the N49D mutation, the ratio of these activities has thus been altered 40-fold. An extensive characterization of a population of stochastically mutated enzymes can accordingly be used to find variants with novel substrate-activity profiles and altered catalytic properties. Recursive recombination of selected sequences displaying optimized properties is a strategy for the engineering of proteins for medical and biochemical applications. Such sequential design is combinatorial protein chemistry based on remodeling of existing structural scaffolds and has similarities to evolutionary processes in nature.     

Evolution of differential substrate specificities in Mu class glutathione transferases probed by DNA shuffling

A library of variant enzymes was created by combined shuffling of the DNA encoding the human Mu class glutathione transferases GST M1-1 and GST M2-2. The parental GSTs are 84 % sequence identical at the protein level, but their specific activities with the substrates aminochrome and 2-cyano-1,3-dimethyl-1-nitrosoguanidine (cyanoDMNG) differ by more than 100-fold. Aminochrome is of particular interest as an oxidation product of dopamine and of possible significance in the etiology of Parkinson's disease, and cyanoDMNG is a model for genotoxic and potentially carcinogenic nitroso compounds. GST M2-2 has at least two orders of magnitude higher catalytic activity with both of the substrates than any of the other known GSTs, including GST M1-1. The DNA library of variant Mu class GST sequences contained "mosaic" structures composed of alternating segments of both parental sequences. All clones contained the 5'-end of a GST M1-1 clone optimized for high-level expression in Escherichia coli. The remainder of the sequences derived from segments of GST M2-2 and GST M1-1 DNA. All of the clones analyzed contained between two and seven distinct DNA segments. In addition, each clone contained an average of approximately one point mutation. None of the library clones analyzed was identical with either of the two parental structures. Variant GST sequences were expressed in E. coli, and their enzymatic activities with aminochrome, cyanoDMNG, and 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene (CDNB) were determined in bacterial lysates. Such screening of more than 70 clones demonstrated a continuous range of activities covering at least two orders of magnitude for each of the substrates. For a given clone, the activities with aminochrome and cyanoDMNG, in spite of their different chemistries, were clearly correlated, whereas no strong correlation was found with CDNB. This functional correlation suggests a common structural basis for the enzymatic mechanisms for conjugation of aminochrome and denitrosation of cyanoDMNG. From an evolutionary perspective, the results show that recombination of segments from homologous proteins gives rise to a large proportion of functionally competent proteins with a range of activities. The data support the proposal that natural evolution of protein functions may involve recombination of DNA segments followed by selection for advantageous functional properties of the resulting proteins. Clearly, the same approach can be utilized in the engineering of proteins displaying novel functions by in vitro evolution.     

Binding and glutathione conjugation of porphyrinogens by plant glutathione transferases

Overexpression in Escherichia coli of a tau (U) class glutathione transferase (GST) from maize (Zea mays L.), termed ZmGSTU1, caused a reduction in heme levels and an accumulation of porphyrin precursors. This disruption was highly specific, with the expression of the closely related ZmGSTU2 or other maize GSTs having little effect. Expression in E. coli of a series of chimeric ZmGSTU1/ZmGSTU2 proteins identified domains responsible for disrupting porphyrin metabolism. In addition to known heme precursors, expression of ZmGSTU1 led to the accumulation of a novel glutathione conjugate of harderoporphyrin(ogen) (2,7,12,18-tetramethyl-3-vinylporphyrin-8,13,17-tripropionic acid). Using the related protoporphyrinogen as a substrate, conjugation could be shown to occur on one vinyl group and was actively catalyzed by the ZmGSTU. In plant transgenesis studies, the ZmGSTUs did not perturb porphyrin metabolism when expressed in the cytosol of Arabidopsis or tobacco. However, expression of a ZmGSTU1-ZmGSTU2 chimera in the chloroplasts of tobacco resulted in the accumulation of the harderoporphyrin(ogen)-glutathione conjugate observed in the expression studies in bacteria. Our results show that the well known ability of GSTs to act as ligand binding (ligandin) proteins of porphyrins in vitro results in highly specific interactions with porphyrinogen intermediates, which can be demonstrated in both plants and bacteria in vivo.     

Detoxification of DNA hydroperoxide by glutathione transferases and the purification and characterization of glutathione transferases of the rat liver nucleus.

DNA peroxidized by exposure to ionizing radiation in the presence of oxygen is a substrate for the Se-independent GSH peroxidase activity of several GSH transferases, GSH transferases 5-5, 3-3 and 4-4 being the most active in the rat liver soluble supernatant fraction (500, 35 and 20 nmol/min per mg of protein respectively) and GSH transferases mu and pi the most active, so far found, in the human liver soluble supernatant fraction (80 and 10 nmol/min per mg respectively). Although the GSH transferase content of the rat nucleus was found to be much lower than that of the soluble supernatant, nuclear GSH transferases are likely to be more important in the detoxification of DNA hydroperoxide produced in vivo. Two nuclear fractions were studied, one extracted with 0.075 M-saline/0.025 M-EDTA, pH 8.0, and the other extracted from the residue with 8.5 M-urea. The saline/EDTA fraction contained subunits 1, 2, 3, 4 and a novel subunit, similar but not identical to 5, provisionally referred to as 5*, in the proportions 40:25:5:5:25 respectively. The 8.5 M-urea-extracted fraction contained principally subunit 5* together with a small amount of subunit 6 in the proportion 95:5 respectively. GSH transferase 5*-5* purified from the 8.5 M-urea extract has the highest activity towards DNA hydroperoxide of any GSH transferase so far studied (1.5 mumol/min per mg). A Se-dependent GSH peroxidase fraction from rat liver was also active towards DNA hydroperoxide; however, since this enzyme accounts for only 14% of the GSH peroxidase activity detectable in the nucleus, GSH transferases may be the more important source of this activity. The possible role of GSH transferases, in particular GSH transferase 5*-5*, in DNA repair is discussed.     

An alpha class glutathione S-transferase from pike liver

Glutathione S-transferase (GST) was isolated from the Esox lucius liver and purified to the homogenous state by SDS-PAGE and isoelectrofocusing. It was found to be a homodimer with a subunit molecular weight of 25235.36 Da (HPLC-MS/MS data) and pI of about 6.4. Its substrate specificity, thermal stability, some kinetic characteristics, and optimum pH were studied. The enzyme was identified as Alpha class GST.     

Identification of a novel glutathione transferase in human skin homologous with class alpha glutathione transferase 2-2 in the rat.

Six forms of glutathione transferase with pI values of 4.6, 5.9, 6.8, 7.1, 8.5 and 9.9 have been isolated from the cytosol fraction of normal skin from three human subjects. The three most abundant enzymes were an acidic Class Pi transferase (pI 4.6; apparent subunit Mr 23,000), a basic Class Alpha transferase (pI 8.5; apparent subunit Mr 24,000) and an even more basic glutathione transferase of Class Alpha (pI 9.9; apparent subunit Mr 26,500). The last enzyme, which was previously unknown, accounts for 10-20% of the glutathione transferase in human skin. The novel transferase showed greater similarities with rat glutathione transferase 2-2, another Class Alpha enzyme, than with any other known transferase irrespective of species. The most striking similarities included reactions with antibodies, amino acid compositions and identical N-terminal amino acid sequences (16 residues). The close relationship between the human most basic and the rat glutathione transferase 2-2 supports the classification of the transferases previously proposed and indicates that the similarities between enzymes isolated from different species are more extensive than had been assumed previously.     

Cloning,characterization and regulation of a family of phi class glutathione transferases from wheat

Six phi (F) class glutathione transferases (GSTs) were cloned from bread wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) treated with the herbicide safener fenchlorazole ethyl and named TaGSTF1–6. Recombinant TaGSTFs were assayed for glutathione conjugating activity towards xenobiotics including herbicides and for glutathione peroxidase (GPOX) activity. TaGSTF1, which resembled ZmGSTF1, the dominant GST in maize (Zea mays), was highly active in conjugating 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenezene (CDNB) but had low activities towards chloroacetanilide, diphenyl ether and aryloxphenoxypropionate herbicides. TaGSTF2, TaGSTF3 and TaGSTF4 all resembled the safener-inducible ZmGSTF2, with TaGSTF2 and TaGSTF3 being highly active GPOXs and rapidly detoxifying chloroacetanilides. TaGSTF5 resembled ZmGSTF3, having limited conjugating and GPOX activity. TaGSTF6 contained both ZmGSTF1- and ZmGSTF2-like sequences but was most similar to ZmGSTF1 in detoxifying activity. The expression of TaGSTFs in wheat seedlings was enhanced upon exposure to fenchlorazole ethyl, herbicides or other chemical inducing treatments. TaGSTFs were also enhanced by treatment with the natural products caffeic acid, 7,4-dihydroxyflavone and naringenin. The CDNB-conjugating activity of TaGSTF1, and to a lesser extent TaGSTF6, was highly sensitive to inhibition by flavonoids, particularly the chalcone isoliquiritigenin. The other TaGSTFs were much less sensitive to such inhibition. It was subsequently determined that isoliquiritigenin underwent glutathione conjugation, though this reversible reaction did not require the intervention of any TaGSTF. The potential importance of GSTFs and glutathione conjugation in flavonoid metabolism is discussed.     

Novel class of glutathione transferases from cyanobacteria exhibit high catalytic activities towards naturally occurring isothiocyanates

In the present paper, we report a novel class of GSTs (glutathione transferases), called the Chi class, originating from cyanobacteria and with properties not observed previously in prokaryotic enzymes. GSTs constitute a widespread multifunctional group of proteins, of which mammalian enzymes are the best characterized. Although GSTs have their origin in prokaryotes, few bacterial representatives have been characterized in detail, and the catalytic activities and substrate specificities observed have generally been very modest. The few well-studied bacterial GSTs have largely unknown physiological functions. Genome databases reveal that cyanobacteria have an extensive arsenal of glutathione-associated proteins. We have studied two cyanobacterial GSTs which are the first examples of bacterial enzymes that are as catalytically efficient as the best mammalian enzymes. GSTs from the thermophile Thermosynechococcus elongatus BP-1 and from Synechococcus elongatus PCC 6301 were found to catalyse the conjugation of naturally occurring plant-derived isothiocyanates to glutathione at high rates. The cyanobacterial GSTs studied are smaller than previously described members of this enzyme family, but display many of the typical structural features that are characteristics of GSTs. They are also active towards several classical substrates, but at the same moderate rates that have been observed for other GSTs derived from prokaryotes. The cloning, expression and characterization of two cyanobacterial GSTs are described. The possible significance of the observed catalytic properties is discussed in the context of physiological relevance and GST evolution.     

Protective role of glutathione and glutathione transferases in mutagenesis and carcinogenesis

Glutathione (GSH) alone detoxifies electrophiles with an effectiveness which depends on the rate of the reaction and the concentration of GSH. If electrophiles are substrates for GSH transferase isoenzymes, the effectiveness of detoxication is much enhanced due to the increased rate of reaction and it is also independent of GSH concentration to low levels of GSH depletion, since the Km for GSH is approximately 0.1 mM. In this paper detoxication of electrophilic metabolites of the hepatocarcinogen N-methyl-4-aminoazobenzene which are not substrates for GSH transferases and the carcinogenic electrophile derived from the hepatocarcinogen aflatoxin B1 which is a poor substrate is compared with detoxication of electrophiles which are good substrates and which although bacterial mutagens are not carcinogenic in organs containing the appropriate GSH transferases. GSH transferases detoxify not only electrophiles derived from xenobiotics, but also endogenous electrophiles which are usually the consequence of free radical damage in the presence of oxygen to lipids and DNA and include lipid and DNA hydroperoxides and alkenals arising from the decomposition of lipid hydroperoxides. Studies in the rat and other mammals show the GSH transferases to be dimers in which the subunits are members of a gene super-family. There are three, perhaps four multigene families namely, alpha containing subunits 1, 2, 8 and 10; mu containing subunits 3, 4, 6 and 9; pi containing subunit 7 and subunits 5 and 5* which are so far unassigned. Subunit 5* is apparently restricted to the nucleus and is noteworthy for its activity towards DNA hydroperoxides. Studies in the human are not as advanced as in the rat but so far reveal close similarities. The ability of GSH transferases to detoxify electrophiles is important in carcinogenesis at a number of points. They may inhibit initiation and tumour proportion, but they may be advantageous to the developing tumour cell, and may be acquired in increased amounts during malignant progression. In many tumour cells the development of lines resistant to anticancer drugs is associated with an increased expression of GSH transferases, particularly GSH transferase pi in human cells.     

Non-inducibility of the glutathione transferases of the earthworm Eisenia andrei

1. Earthworms were exposed to solutions of potential biotransformation enzyme inducers, i.e. trans-stilbene oxide (0.1 mM), 3-methylcholanthrene (50 μM) or 1,4-bis[2-(3,5-dichloropyridoxyl)]benzene (30 μM) for 1 hr each day in three successive days.2. Glutathione transferase (GST) was determined in cytosolic extracts of the worms the day after the last treatment, with chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene, l,2-dichloro-4-nitrobenzene and ethacrynic acid as electrophilic substrates. Activity toward 1,2-epoxy-3-[p-nitro-fenoxy]propane was not detected.3. With all three substrates, the specific activity in the cytosol was similar in treated animals and controls.4. Ion exchange chromatography was performed on a NeoBar AQ^TMcolumn (The “Low Pressure High Performance” technique), and GST eluted in four distinct peaks.5. The elution profiles of GST activity were almost identical for exposed earthworms and controls.6. The results suggest that earthworms may not have inducible GST, perhaps because they are detritus eaters, and do not need to detoxicate poisonous secondary plant metabolites.