Retrotransfer in Escherichia coli conjugation: bidirectional exchange or de novo mating?

DNA can be transferred among eubacteria and to plants and fungi by related, plasmid-mediated processes collectively referred to as bacterial conjugation. Conjugation occurs between cells in contact with one another and results in the unidirectional delivery of DNA from a bacterial donor to a recipient. Recent experiments that have reexamined the directionality of DNA flow during conjugation have come to different conclusions, some suggesting that genetic material also flows from recipient cells into the donor and that this process, termed retrotransfer, is likewise directed by donor-encoded functions. Given that bacteria are perhaps united with all living creatures by conjugation, the possibility of gene flow into donor bacteria during conjugation raises interesting evolutionary and biocontainment issues. Here we report that plasmid transmission from bacterial recipients to donors is not a donor-mediated event. Movement of genetic material from recipients to donors was inhibited by streptomycin, which does not inhibit the conjugative donor, indicating that retrotransfer requires gene expression in recipients. Furthermore, retrotransfer was reduced in matings mediated by plasmids that encode strong entry exclusion, to a similar degree as matings between two donors. Therefore we suggest that retrotransfer is in fact newly initiated conjugation between transconjugants and donors.     

Genetic construction of nisin-producing Lactococcus lactis subsp. cremoris and analysis of a rapid method for conjugation.

Conjugation was used to construct nisin-producing Lactococcus lactis subsp. cremoris strains. Recipients were obtained by electroporation of L. lactis subsp. cremoris strains with the drug resistance plasmid pGK13 or pGB301. A method, direct-plate conjugation, was developed in which donor and recipient cells were concentrated and then combined directly on selective media. This method facilitated transfer of the nisin-sucrose (Nip+ Suc+) phenotype from the donor strain, L. lactis subsp. lactis 11454, to three L. lactis subsp. cremoris recipient strains. Nip+ Suc+ L. lactis subsp. cremoris transconjugants were obtained at frequencies which ranged from 10(-7) to 10(-8) per donor CFU. DNA-DNA hybridization to transconjugant DNAs, performed with an oligonucleotide probe synthesized to detect the nisin precursor gene, showed that this gene was transferred during conjugation but was not associated with detectable plasmid DNA. Further investigation indicated that L. lactis subsp. cremoris Nip+ Suc+ transconjugants retained the recipient strain phenotype with respect to bacteriophage resistance and acid production in milk. Results suggested that it would be feasible to construct nisin-producing L. lactis subsp. cremoris strains for application as mixed and multiple starter systems. Additionally, the direct-plate conjugation method required less time than filter or milk agar matings and may also be useful for investigations of conjugal mechanisms in these organisms.     

Genetic construction of nisin-producing Lactococcus lactis subsp. cremoris and analysis of a rapid method for conjugation

Conjugation was used to construct nisin-producing Lactococcus lactis subsp. cremoris strains. Recipients were obtained by electroporation of L. lactis subsp. cremoris strains with the drug resistance plasmid pGK13 or pGB301. A method, direct-plate conjugation, was developed in which donor and recipient cells were concentrated and then combined directly on selective media. This method facilitated transfer of the nisin-sucrose (Nip+ Suc+) phenotype from the donor strain, L. lactis subsp. lactis 11454, to three L. lactis subsp. cremoris recipient strains. Nip+ Suc+ L. lactis subsp. cremoris transconjugants were obtained at frequencies which ranged from 10(-7) to 10(-8) per donor CFU. DNA-DNA hybridization to transconjugant DNAs, performed with an oligonucleotide probe synthesized to detect the nisin precursor gene, showed that this gene was transferred during conjugation but was not associated with detectable plasmid DNA. Further investigation indicated that L. lactis subsp. cremoris Nip+ Suc+ transconjugants retained the recipient strain phenotype with respect to bacteriophage resistance and acid production in milk. Results suggested that it would be feasible to construct nisin-producing L. lactis subsp. cremoris strains for application as mixed and multiple starter systems. Additionally, the direct-plate conjugation method required less time than filter or milk agar matings and may also be useful for investigations of conjugal mechanisms in these organisms.     

A microcosm for measuring survival and conjugation of genetically engineered bacteria in rhizosphere environments

A microcosm is described to evaluate and measure bacterial conjugation in the rhizosphere of barley and radish with strains ofPseudomonas cepacia. The purpose was to describe a standard method useful for evaluating the propensity of genetically engineered microorganisms (GEMs) to transfer DNA to recipient bacteria. Results demonstrated the formation of transconjugants from the rhizosphere of each plant 24 h after inoculation. Transconjugant populations peaked at 1.8 × 10² colony forming units (CFU)/g root and associated soil in barley and 2.0×10² CFU/g root and associated soil in radish; they then declined over the next five days of the experiment. No significant differences were found in the survival of transconjugant populations monitored from the two plant species. The microcosm was also used to document the formation of false positive transconjugants, which resulted from donor and recipientP. cepacia mating on the surface of selective agar plates instead of in microcosms. Transconjugants resulting from such plate mating occurred in substantial numbers during the first 5 days of the experiment but declined to undetectable numbers by day 7. The use of nalidixic acid was investigated to determine the magnitude of plate mating. The number of transconjugants detected from radish rhizosphere was reduced by two orders of magnitude by including nalidixic acid in the plating medium; this indicated that 99% of the transconjugants were a result of plate mating.     

Detection and enumeration of viable but non-culturable transconjugants of Escherichia coli during the survival of recipient cells in river water

Viable but non-culturable transconjugant cells were detected by a modification of the direct viable count (DVC) method. This modification involved the addition of parental antimicrobial markers (kanamycin and streptomycin) to the elongation medium in order to promote selective elongation of the transconjugant cells. Presence of viable, other than culturable, transconjugants was demonstrated in matings with parental cells from TSB culture as well as with recipient cells from survival in river water (under illuminated and non-illuminated systems). In matings with a recipient strain from illuminated systems, culturable transconjugants were not detected after the third day of recipient cell survival. In spite of this, viable transconjugants were detected in numbers that exceeded 10⁵cells ml⁻¹. These results clearly show that a fraction of non-culturable recipient cells is able to receive and express plasmids by conjugation processes and form viable but non-culturable transconjugant cells.     

Methods for Detection of Conjugative Plasmid Transfer in Aquatic Environments

Donor and recipient counter selection was evaluated by selecting bacteria that received plasmid RP4 by conjugation on filters and in lake water microcosms. Three counter selection systems were compared; (i) Use of antibiotic-resistant recipients, (ii) use of an auxotrophic donor, and (iii) use of a donor with chromosomal suicide genes. Transfer efficiencies of transconjugants per recipient obtained with the three different counter selection systems in filter-matings were not significantly different. Some nalidixic acid-resistant recipients became partly sensitive to nalidixic acid after receiving the plasmid. Use of an auxotrophic donor was a feasible and easy way to recover indigenous transconjugants. A strain with two copies of the suicide gene gef was successfully eliminated in filter-matings, but elimination of the donor in microcosms by induction of the suicide genes did not succeed. Thus, this counter selection system was not usable in microcosm experiments. Received: 3 March 1998 / Accepted: 15 May 1998     

The Virulence Plasmid of Salmonella typhimurium Is Self-Transmissible

Most isolates of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium contain a 90-kb virulence plasmid. This plasmid is reported to be mobilizable but nonconjugative. However, we have determined that the virulence plasmid of strains LT2, 14028, and SR-11 is indeed self-transmissible. The plasmid of strain SL1344 is not. Optimal conjugation frequency requires filter matings on M9 minimal glucose plates with a recipient strain lacking the virulence plasmid. These conditions result in a frequency of 2.9 × 10⁻⁴ transconjugants/donor. Matings on Luria-Bertani plates, liquid matings, or matings with a recipient strain carrying the virulence plasmid reduce the efficiency by up to 400-fold. Homologs of the F plasmid conjugation genes are physically located on the virulence plasmid and are required for the conjugative phenotype.     

Mechanism of Action of Nalidixic Acid on Conjugating Bacteria

When nalidixic acid, a specific and effective inhibitor of cellular deoxyribonucleic acid synthesis, is added to conjugating bacteria at any time during mating, it stops genetic transfer provided the donor bacterium is sensitive to the drug. When this inhibition is released by the removal of the nalidixic acid, transfer does not resume at the point on the chromosome where it was stopped, but begins again at the transfer origin. Curves relating the effects of various low doses of nalidixic acid to the frequency of recombination reveal that several "hits" are necessary to inhibit recombination for early markers. The number of required "hits" decreases as the distance of the marker from the transfer origin increases. Transfer between drug-resistant cells may also be inhibited by nalidixic acid. The effect of high drug doses on matings between resistant cells is similar to that of low drug doses on matings with a sensitive male.     

Recombinant plasmid associated cell aggregation and high-frequency conjugation of Streptococcus lactis ML3

Lactose-positive (Lac+) transconjugants resulting from matings between Streptococcus lactic ML3 and S. lactis LM2301 possess a single plasmid of approximately 60 megadaltons (Mdal) which is nearly twice the size of the lactose plasmid of the donor. The majority of these Lac+ transconjugants aggregated in broth and were able to transfer lactose-fermenting ability at a frequency higher than 10(-1) per donor on milk agar plates or in broth. Lac+ transconjugants which did not clump conjugated at a much lower frequency. Lactose-negative derivatives of Lac+ clumping transconjugants did not aggregate in broth and were missing the 60-Mdal plasmid. The ability to aggregates in broth was very unstable. Strains could lose the ability to clump but retain lactose-fermenting ability. The majority of these Lac+ nonclumping derivatives of clumping transconjugants contained a plasmid of approximately 33 Mdal, the size of the lactose plasmid of the original donor ML3. These strains transferred lactose-fermenting ability at a frequency of approximately 10(-6) per donor, resulting in both Lac+ clumping transconjugants which contained a 60-Mdal plasmid and Lac+ nonclumping transconjugants which possessed a 33-Mdal plasmid. Our results suggest that the genes responsible for cell aggregation and high-frequency conjugation are on the segment of deoxyribonucleic acid which recombined with the 33-Mdal lactose plasmid in S. lactis ML3.     

Evidence for an active role of donor cells in natural transformation of Pseudomonas stutzeri.

The transfer of chromosomal genes in a cell mat of Pseudomonas stutzeri was ca. 10(3) times more efficient per microgram of DNA if DNA was added as a constituent of intact donor cells rather than as a solution. Such intact cell-mediated transfer appears to depend on cell contact. It is independent of the presence of plasmids in donor strains and is DNase I sensitive, thus fitting the usual definition of transformation. It is bidirectional: cells of either strain in a transformation mixture served as the donor and recipients. The donor function in cell contact transformation was inhibited by nalidixic acid but was unaffected by rifampin and streptomycin at growth-inhibiting concentrations. Concentrations of nalidixic acid sufficient to inhibit donor function completely had no effect on the ability of nalidixic acid-resistant recipients to take up DNA from solution. These experiments suggest that certain cells donate DNA to others in the cell mat: they argue against the hypothesis that the function of donor cells is merely cell lysis.     

Monitoring the spread of broad host and narrow host range plasmids in soil microcosms

Abstract: Escherichia coli recipient and E. coli donor strains carrying streptothricin-resistance genes were inoculated together into different soil microcosms. These genes were localized on the narrow host range plasmids of incompatibility (Inc) groups FII, Il, and on the broad host range plasmids of IncP1, IncN, IncW3, and IncQ. The experiments were intended to study the transfer of these plasmids in sterile and non-sterile soil with and without antibiotic selective pressure and in planted soil microcosms. Transfer of all broad host range plasmids from the introduced E. coli donor into the recipient was observed in all microcosm experiments. These results indicate that broad host range plasmids encoding short and rigid pili might spread in soil environments by conjugative transfer. In contrast, transfer of the narrow host range plasmids of IncFII and IncI1, into E. coli recipients was not found in sterile or non-sterile soil. These plasmids encoded flexible pili or flexible and rigid pili, respectively. In all experiments highest numbers of transconjugants were detected for the IncP1-plasmid (pTH16). There was evidence with plasmids belonging to IncP group transferred by conjugation into a variety of indigenous soil bacteria at detectable frequencies. Significantly higher numbers of indigenous transconjugants were obtained for the IncP-plasmid under antibiotic selection pressure, and a greater diversity of transconjugants was detected. Availability of nutrients and rhizosphere exudates stimulated transfer in soil. Furthermore, transfer of the IncN-plasmid (pIE1037) into indigenous bacteria of the rhizosphere community could be detected. The transconjugants were determined by BIOLOG as Serratia liquefaciens . Despite the known broad host range of IncW3 and IncQ-plasmids, transfer into indigenous soil bacteria could not be detected.     

Conjugal transfer of antibiotic resistances and plasmids from Campylobacter jejuni clinical isolates

Six Campylobacter jejuni clinical isolates were examined for the occurrence of plasmids in association with antibiotic resistances as well as conjugal transfer. All the isolates were found to carry three similar plasmids of 78 kb, 12.6 kb and 3.3 kb in size. Multiple resistance to at least three of the antibiotics tested was observed with resistance to tetracycline most common. En bloc transfer of donor resistances at frequencies ranging from 10(-8) to 10(-4) were seen in all but one of the isolates during conjugation. The conjugal transfer of erythromycin, neomycin and streptomycin were observed to occur at frequencies similar to that of chloramphenicol, kanamycin and tetracycline. In isolate ABA94, three different antibiotic resistance phenotypes of the transconjugants were seen. In addition to en bloc transfer of the donor resistances, in approximately 10% of the transconjugants the streptomycin resistance was lost although these transconjugants carried the donor complement of three plasmids. In a further 1% of the transconjugants, resistance to kanamycin only was detected and these transconjugants did not carry any plasmids.     

High-frequency conjugation system facilitates biofilm formation and pAMbeta1 transmission by Lactococcus lactis

The importance of conjugation as a mechanism to spread biofilm determinants among microbial populations was illustrated with the gram-positive bacterium Lactococcus lactis. Conjugation triggered the enhanced expression of the clumping protein CluA, which is a main biofilm attribute in lactococci. Clumping transconjugants further transmitted the biofilm-forming elements among the lactococcal population at a much higher frequency than the parental non-clumping donor. This cell-clumping-associated high-frequency conjugation system also appeared to serve as an internal enhancer facilitating the dissemination of the broad-host-range drug resistance gene-encoding plasmid pAMbeta1 within L. lactis, at frequencies more than 10,000 times higher than those for the non-clumping parental donor strain. The implications of this finding for antibiotic resistance gene dissemination are discussed.     

pAMbeta1-Associated Mobilization of Proteinase Plasmids from Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis UC317 and L. lactis subsp. cremoris UC205

A combination of plasmid curing and DNA-DNA hybridization data facilitated the identification of proteinase plasmids of 75 (pCI301) and 35 kilobases (pCI203) in the multi-plasmid-containing strains Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis UC317 and L. lactis subsp. cremoris UC205, respectively. Both plasmids were transferred by conjugation to a plasmid-free background only after introduction of the conjugative streptococcal plasmid, pAMbeta1. All Prt transconjugants from matings involving either donor contained enlarged recombinant Prt plasmids. UC317-derived transconjugants were separable into different classes based on the presence of differently sized cointegrate plasmids and on segregation of the pCI301-derived Lac and Prt markers. All UC205-derived transconjugants harbored a single enlarged plasmid that was a cointegrate between pCI203 and pAMbeta1. The identification of prt genes on pCI301 and pCI203 derivatives was achieved by a combination of restriction enzyme and hybridization analyses.     

Effect of entry exclusion on mating aggregates and transconjugants.

Mating aggregates during conjugation directed by an F-like R factor in Escherichia coli were measured as the number of Lac+-Lac- sectored colonies present in a mating mixture. There is a high degree of correlation between the concentration of transconjugants produced in a mating mixture and the concentration of mating aggregates observed at several different concentrations of donor and recipient cells. The mating aggregates are sex pilus specific as demonstrated by the ability of donor-specific ribonucleic acid phage MS-2 to decrease both mating aggregates and transconjugants in a mating mixture. During entry exclusion by either a derepressed or a repressed F-like R factor, isogenic to the superinfecting R factor except for a resistance determinant, the number of transconjugants was markedly reduced, but the number of mating aggregates was not decreased. Entry exclusion by F-Gal toward the donor HfrH resembled that of the F-like R factor in that there was a reduction in the number of recombinants but no significant decrease in mating aggregates. These results suggest that entry exclusion inhibits conjugation at a stage after the formation of mating aggregates.     

Dynamics of drug resistance of Vibrio cholerae isolated from surface water reservoirs in Siberia and the Soviet Far East in 1976-1990]

In the study on antibiotic resistance 1383 strains of El Tor Vibrio cholerae isolated from surface water reservoirs in 12 administrative territories of the Siberia and Far East within a period of 15 years were tested. The following antibiotics were used: ampicillin, streptomycin, monomycin, polymyxin, tetracycline, chloramphenicol, rifampicin and nalidixic acid. The resistance was unstable and its pattern was wave-like according to annual changes in the biological cycle. It was especially evident in regard to ampicillin, streptomycin, monomycin and polymyxin. The highest numbers of the strains were resistant to polymyxin, ampicillin and streptomycin (up to 100 per cent in some years). The lowest numbers of the strains were resistant to chloramphenicol (0.4 per cent) and tetracycline (1.9 per cent). No strains resistant to rifampicin and nalidixic acid were isolated. In some cases the antibiotic resistance level depended on the geographical zone where the strain was isolated. A direct quantitative dependence of the resistance level on the MIC was observed: the lower the MIC of the drug was, the lower the number of the strains resistant to it was. Within the 15-year period there was no general tendency to increase the resistance in V. cholerae to the antibiotics used.     

Anomalies in the enumeration of starved bacteria on culture media containing nalidic acid and tetracycline

Culturable counts of antibiotic resistant, genetically engineeredPseudomonas fluorescens were determined on antibiotic-containing plate count agar during starvation in water. Prior to starvation, colony counts obtained on all media separated into two groups. The mean of the colony counts on plate count agar with or without tetracycline (4.9 × 10⁶ ml⁻¹) was significantly higher than the mean colony counts on plate count agar containing either nalidixic acid or nalidixic acid plus tetraclycline (2.5×10⁶ ml⁻¹). After 20 days of starvation the highest mean colony counts continued to be obtained on plate count agar (7.2 × 10⁶ ml⁻¹) with slightly, but significantly, lower counts obtained on plate count agar containing either nalidixic acid (5.6 × 10⁶ ml⁻¹) or tetraclycline (1.5×10⁶ ml⁻¹). A combination of nalidixic acid and tetracycline in plate count agar, however, dramatically reduced colony counts (8.3 × 10² ml⁻¹) after this starvation period. The addition of catalase to plate count agar containing nalidixic acid and tetracycline negated the effect caused by this combination of antibiotics. When colony counts obtained over the entire 20 day incubation were considered, the addition of MgSO₄ to plate count agar containing nalidixic acid and tetracycline resulted in a significant increase in colony counts. Other combinations of antibiotics, nalidixic acid+carbenicillin, nalidixic acid+kanamycin, streptomycin+tetracycline, streptomycin+carbenicillin, rifampicin+tetracycline, rifampicin+carbenicillin, and rifampicin+kanamycin, did not inhibit colony formation of starved cells. Antibiotic resistant strains ofP. putida andEscherichia coli also displayed sensitivity to the combination of nalidixic acid and tetracycline in plate count agar after starvation.     

Transfer of transposon Tn916 from Bacillus subtilis to Thermus aquaticus

Broad host range conjugating transposon Tn916 has been introduced into the extreme thermophile Thermus by transposon transformation and transposition into the Bacillus subtilis chromosome followed by broth mating with Thermus aquaticus ATCC27634. Tetracycline resistant Thermus transconjugants were obtained at a frequency of 1.4 X 10(-7) per donor and 1.2 X 10(-7) per recipient. Transposon transfer from Thermus to Bacillus subtilis was also demonstrated in similar broth matings. Transfer characteristics were consistent with the conjugation mechanism described for Tn916 in mesophiles.     

A host factor absent from Lactococcus lactis subspecies lactis MG1363 is required for conjugative transposition

In matings between Lactococcus lactis strains, the conjugative transposons Tn916 and Tn919 are found in the chromosome of the transconjugants in the same place as in the chromosome of the donor, indicating that no transposition has occurred. In agreement with this, the frequency of L. lactis transconjugants from intraspecies matings is the same whether the donor contains the wild-type form of the transposon or the mutant Tn916-int1, which has an insertion in the transposon's integrase gene. However, in intergeneric crosses with Bacillus subtilis or Enterococcus faecalis donors, Tn916 and Tn919 transpose to different locations on the chromosome of the L. lactis transconjugants. Moreover, Tn916 and Tn919 could not be transferred by conjugation from L. lactis and B. subtilis, E. faecalis or Streptococcus pyogenes. This suggests that excision of these elements does not occur in L. lactis. When cloned into E. coli with adjacent chromosomal DNA from L. lactis, the conjugative transposons were able to excise, transpose and promote conjugation. Therefore, the inability of these elements to excise in L. lactis is not caused by a permanent structural alteration in the transposon. We conclude that L. lactis lacks a factor required for excision of conjugative transposons.     

Efficiency of the transfer of a pSAM2-derivative plasmid between two strains of Streptomyces lividans in conditions ranging from agar slants to non-sterile soil microcosms

Abstract: The aim of this work was to determine the efficiency of the conjugative plasmid pTS130 to transfer in various environmental conditions between two strains of Streptomyces lividans . This plasmid is a derivative of the conjugative and integrative plasmid pSAM2 isolated originally from Streptomyces ambofaciens and capable of transfer to a large range of bacteria. Our results demonstrate the high frequency of the conjugation mechanism since more than 60% of the recipient cells developed on agar slants harbored the plasmid pTS130 (as evidenced by Southern hybridization with a pSAM2 derivative plasmid probe). When donor and recipient strains were inoculated into sterile and non-sterile soil microcosms, transconjugants were detected after two days of incubation in both cases. However, the number of donor, recipient and transconjugant cells were established at a lower level in the non-sterile soil than in the sterile soil experiments. Moreover, nutrient amendment of the sterile soil was found to increase the population levels of parental strains and transfer frequencies both significantly and simultaneously. On the other hand, modifying water potential of the soil microcosms did not result in affecting the establishment of the Streptomyces lividans cells or the transfer rate.