Electron transfer and protein dynamics in the photosynthetic reaction center.

We have measured the kinetics of electron transfer (ET) from the primary quinone (Q(A)) to the special pair (P) of the reaction center (RC) complex from Rhodobacter sphaeroides as a function of temperature (5-300 K), illumination protocol (cooled in the dark and under illumination from 110, 160, 180, and 280 K), and warming rate (1.3 and 13 mK/s). The nonexponential kinetics are interpreted with a quantum-mechanical ET model (Fermi's golden rule and the spin-boson model), in which heterogeneity of the protein ensemble, relaxations, and fluctuations are cast into a single coordinate that relaxes monotonically and is sensitive to all types of relaxations caused by ET. Our analysis shows that the structural changes that occur in response to ET decrease the free energy gap between donor and acceptor states by 120 meV and decrease the electronic coupling between donor and acceptor states from 2.7 x 10(-4) cm(-1) to 1.8 x 10(-4) cm(-1). At cryogenic temperatures, conformational changes can be slowed or completely arrested, allowing us to monitor relaxations on the annealing time scale (approximately 10(3)-10(4) s) as well as the time scale of ET (approximately 100 ms). The relaxations occur within four broad tiers of conformational substates with average apparent Arrhenius activation enthalpies of 17, 50, 78, and 110 kJ/mol and preexponential factors of 10(13), 10(15), 10(21), and 10(25) s(-1), respectively. The parameterization provides a prediction of the time course of relaxations at all temperatures. At 300 K, relaxations are expected to occur from 1 ps to 1 ms, whereas at lower temperatures, even broader distributions of relaxation times are expected. The weak dependence of the ET rate on both temperature and protein conformation, together with the possibility of modeling heterogeneity and dynamics with a single conformational coordinate, make RC a useful model system for probing the dynamics of conformational changes in proteins.     

A plausible mechanism of electron transfer between quinones in photosynthetic reaction centers

The mechanism of long-range electron transfer between the primary and the secondary quinone of photosynthetic reaction centers has been investigated, with particular attention on the role of the iron-histidine bridge. Computations suggest that in such a system, where the molecular subunits are packed together by H-bonds, a mobile electron, injected on one end of the chain, can be carried to the other end by switching the positions of the H-bonded hydrogens. Energy estimates would suggest that the proposed mechanism is plausible and worthy of further experimental investigations.     

Calculated coupling of electron and proton transfer in the photosynthetic reaction center of Rhodopseudomonas viridis.

Based on new Rhodopseudomonas (Rp.) viridis reaction center (RC) coordinates with a reliable structure of the secondary acceptor quinone (QB) site, a continuum dielectric model and finite difference technique have been used to identify clusters of electrostatically interacting ionizable residues. Twenty-three residues within a distance of 25 A from QB (QB cluster) have been shown to be strongly electrostatically coupled to QB, either directly or indirectly. An analogous cluster of 24 residues is found to interact with QA (QA cluster). Both clusters extend to the cytoplasmic surface in at least two directions. However, the QB cluster differs from the QA cluster in that it has a surplus of acidic residues, more strong electrostatic interactions, is less solvated, and experiences a strong positive electrostatic field arising from the polypeptide backbone. Consequently, upon reduction of QA or QB, it is the QB cluster, and not the QA cluster, which is responsible for substoichiometric proton uptake at neutral pH. The bulk of the changes in the QB cluster are calculated to be due to the protonation of a tightly coupled cluster of the three Glu residues (L212, H177, and M234) within the QB cluster. If the lifetime of the doubly reduced state QB2- is long enough, Asp M43 and Ser L223 are predicted to also become protonated. The calculated complex titration behavior of the strongly interacting residues of the QB cluster and the resulting electrostatic response to electron transfer may be a common feature in proton-transferring membrane protein complexes.     

Proton transfer in the photosynthetic reaction center of Blastochloris viridis

Photosynthetic reaction centers of Blastochloris viridis require two quanta of light to catalyse a two-step reduction of their secondary ubiquinone Q(B) to ubiquinol. We employed capacitive potentiometry to follow the voltage changes that were caused by the accompanying transmembrane proton displacements. At pH 7.5 and 20 degrees C, the Q(B)-related voltage generation after the first flash was contributed by a fast, temperature-independent component with a time constant of approximately 30 micros and a slower component of approximately 200 micros with activation energy (E(a)) of 50 kJ/mol. The kinetics after the second flash featured temperature-independent components of 5 micros and 200 micros followed by a component of 600 micros with E(a) approximately 60 kJ/mol.     

Trapping conformational intermediate states in the reaction center protein from photosynthetic bacteria

In protein, conformational changes are often crucial for function but not easy to observe. Two functionally relevant conformational intermediate states of photosynthetic reaction center protein (RCs) are trapped and characterized at low temperature. RCs frozen in the dark do not allow electron transfer from the reduced primary quinone, Q(A)(-), to the secondary quinone, Q(B). In contrast, RCs frozen under illumination in the product (P(+)Q(A)Q(B)(-)) state, with the oxidized electron donor, P(+), and reduced Q(B)(-), return to the ground state at cryogenic temperature in a conformation that allows a high yield of Q(B) reduction. Thus, RCs frozen under illumination are found to be trapped above the ground state in a conformation that allows product formation. When the temperature is raised above 120 K, the protein relaxes to an inactive conformation which is different from the RCs frozen in the dark. The activation energy for this change is 87 +/- 8 meV, and the active and inactive states differ in energy by only 16 +/- 3 meV. Thus, there are several conformational substates along the reaction coordinate with different transition temperatures. The ground state spectra of the RCs in active and inactive conformations report differences in the intraprotein electrostatic field, demonstrating that the dipole or charge distribution has changed. In addition, the electrochromic shift associated with the Q(A)(-) to Q(B) electron transfer at low temperature was characterized. The electron-transfer rate from Q(B)(-) to P(+) was measured at cryogenic temperature and is similar to the rate at room temperature, as expected for an exothermic, electron tunneling reaction in RCs.     

Electron transfer between exogenous electron donors and reaction center of photosystem 2

Transfer of electrons between artificial electron donors diphenylcarbazide (DPC) and hydroxylamine (NH2OH) and reaction center of manganese-depleted photosystem 2 (PS2) complexes was studied using the direct electrometrical method. For the first time it was shown that reduction of redox-active amino acid tyrosine Y _z ^· by DPC is coupled with generation of transmembrane electric potential difference (δΨ). The amplitude of this phase comprised ～17% of that of the δΨ phase due to electron transfer between Y_Z and the primary quinone acceptor Q_A. This phase is associated with vectorial intraprotein electron transfer between the DPC binding site on the protein-water interface and the tyrosine Y _z ^· . The slowing of ΔΨ decay in the presence of NH₂OH indicates effective electron transfer between the artificial electron donor and reaction center of PS2. It is suggested that NH2OH is able to diffuse through channels with diameter of 2.0–3.0 Å visible in PS2 structure and leading from the protein-water interface to the Mn₄Ca cluster binding site with the concomitant electron donation to Y _z ^· . Because the dielectrically-weighted distance between the NH₂OH binding site and Y _z ^· is not determined, the transfer of electrons from NH₂OH to Y _z ^· could be either electrically silent or contribute negligibly to the observed electrogenicity in comparison with hydrophobic donors.     

Electron transfer reactions between quinols and quinones in aqueous and aprotic media

The pathways of redox equilibration of quinols and quinones have been investigated. The rate-limiting reaction involves the couple QH^?/QH^· of the reducing quinol and the couple Q^?/Q of the oxidising quinone. Three general mechanistic points may be surmised: (i) protonation/deprotonation reactions are not rate-limiting; (ii) all transfers occur in one-equivalent steps; (iii) electron transfers, but not hydrogen atom transfers, are the dominant features. In aprotic media, no rapid route of equilibration is available since the ionic species which are necessary for thermodynamically feasible routes of electron transfer cannot exist to any great extent. The relation of these results to models of biological quinone systems is discussed.     

Electron paramagnetic resonance study of radiation damage in photosynthetic reaction center crystals

Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) was used to simultaneously study radiation-induced cofactor reduction and damaging radical formation in single crystals of the bacterial reaction center (RC). Crystals of Fe-removed/Zn-replaced RC protein from Rhodobacter ( R.) sphaeroides R26 were irradiated with varied radiation doses at cryogenic temperature and analyzed for radiation-induced free radical formation and alteration of light-induced photosynthetic electron transfer activity using high-field (HF) D-band (130 GHz) and X-band (9.5 GHz) EPR spectroscopies. These analyses show that the formation of radiation-induced free radicals saturated at doses 1 order of magnitude smaller than the amount of radiation at which protein crystals lose their diffraction quality, while light-induced RC activity was found to be lost at radiation doses at least 1 order of magnitude lower than the dose at which radiation-induced radicals exhibited saturation. HF D-band EPR spectra provide direct evidence for radiation-induced reduction of the quinones and possibly other cofactors. These results demonstrate that substantial radiation damage is likely to have occurred during X-ray diffraction data collection used for photosynthetic RC structure determination. Thus, both radiation-induced loss of photochemical activity in RC crystals and reduction of the quinones are important factors that must be considered when correlating spectroscopic and crystallographic measurements of quinone site structures.     

Electron transfer kinetics in photosynthetic reaction centers embedded in trehalose glasses: trapping of conformational substates at room temperature.

We report on room temperature electron transfer in the reaction center (RC) complex purified from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. The protein was embedded in trehalose-water systems of different trehalose/water ratios. This enabled us to get new insights on the relationship between RC conformational dynamics and long-range electron transfer. In particular, we measured the kinetics of electron transfer from the primary reduced quinone acceptor (Q(A)(-)) to the primary photo oxidized donor (P(+)), by time-resolved absorption spectroscopy, as a function of the matrix composition. The composition was evaluated either by weighing (liquid samples) or by near infrared spectroscopy (highly viscous or solid glasses). Deconvolution of the observed, nonexponential kinetics required a continuous spectrum of rate constants. The average rate constant ( = 8.7 s(-1) in a 28% (w/w) trehalose solution) increases smoothly by increasing the trehalose/water ratio. In solid glasses, at trehalose/water ratios > or = 97%, an abrupt increase is observed ( = 26.6 s(-1) in the driest solid sample). A dramatic broadening of the rate distribution function parallels the above sudden increase. Both effects fully revert upon rehydration of the glass. We compared the kinetics observed at room temperature in extensively dried water-trehalose matrices with the ones measured in glycerol-water mixtures at cryogenic temperatures and conclude that, in solid trehalose-water glasses, the thermal fluctuations among conformational substates are inhibited. This was inferred from the large broadening of the rate constant distribution for electron transfer obtained in solid glasses, which was due to the free energy distribution barriers having become quasi static. Accordingly, the RC relaxation from dark-adapted to light-adapted conformation, which follows primary charge separation at room temperature, is progressively hindered over the time scale of P(+)Q(A)(-) charge recombination, upon decreasing the water content. In solid trehalose-water glasses the electron transfer process resulted much more affected than in RC dried in the absence of sugar. This indicated a larger hindering of the internal dynamics in trehalose-coated RC, notwithstanding the larger amount of residual water present in comparison with samples dried in the absence of sugar.     

Vibronic coupling to electron transfer and the structure of the R. Viridis reaction center

This paper points out that the orientations of the porphyrins, bacteriochlorophyll and bacteriopheophytin, in the reaction centers of Rhodopseudomonas viridis, as shown by the new X-ray determined structure, have a peculiar orientation towards each other: electron donors are broadside toward the acceptors and acceptors are edgeon toward donors. Vibronic coupling which is the mechanism of converting free-energy loss in electron transport to vibrational energy is examined as a possible explanation. Preliminary calculations do not support this as an explanation of the orientations but suggest strongly that the non-heme iron atom has the function of promoting vibronic coupling in the electron transfer from bacteriopheophytin to menaquinone. It is further suggested that the system of electron transport from the special pair of bacteriochlorophyll to the bacteriopheophytin is arranged to keep virbonic coupling to a minimum to match the very small electronic free-energy loss in this region.Abbreviations BC Bacteriochlorophyll - BP Bacteriopheophytin - BC₂ Bacteriochlorophyll special pair, primary electron donor - Fe Non-heme iron atom - MQ Menaquinone, first quinone acceptor - UQ Ubiquinone, second quinone acceptor     

Tuning electron transfer by ester-group of chlorophylls in bacterial photosynthetic reaction center

Accessory chlorophylls (B(A/B)) in bacterial photosynthetic reaction center play a key role in charge-separation. Although light-exposed and dark-adapted bRC crystal structures are virtually identical, the calculated B(A) redox potentials for one-electron reduction differ. This can be traced back to different orientations of the B(A) ester-group. This tuning ability of chlorophyll redox potentials modulates the electron transfer from SP* to B(A).     

Light-induced conformational changes in photosynthetic reaction centers: redox-regulated proton pathway near the dimer

The influence of the hydrogen bonds on the light-induced structural changes were studied in the wild type and 11 mutants with different hydrogen bonding patterns of the primary electron donor of reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. Previously, using the same set of mutants at pH 8, a marked light-induced change of the local dielectric constant in the vicinity of the dimer was reported in wild type and in mutants retaining Leu L131 that correlated with the recovery kinetics of the charge-separated state [ Deshmukh et al. (2011) Biochemistry, 50, 340-348]. In this work after prolonged illumination the recovery of the oxidized dimer was found to be multiphasic in all mutants. The fraction of the slowest phase, assigned to a recovery from a conformationally altered state, was strongly pH dependent and found to be extremely long at room temperature, at pH 6, with rate constants of ～10(-3) s(-1). In wild type and in mutants with Leu at L131 the very long recovery kinetics was coupled to a large proton release at pH 6 and a decrease of up to 79 mV of the oxidation potential of the dimer. In contrast, in the mutants carrying the Leu to His mutation at the L131 position, only a negligible fraction of the dimer exhibited lowered potential, the large proton release was not observed, the oxidized dimer recovered 1 or 2 orders of magnitude faster depending on the pH, and the very long-lived state was not or barely detectable. These results are modeled as arising from the loss of a proton pathway from the bacteriochlorophyll dimer to the solvent when His is present at the L131 position.     

Protein/lipid interaction in the bacterial photosynthetic reaction center: phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylglycerol modify the free energy levels of the quinones

The role of characteristic phospholipids of native membranes, phosphatidylcholine (PC), phosphatidylglycerol (PG), and cardiolipin (CL), was studied in the energetics of the acceptor quinone side in photosynthetic reaction centers of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. The rates of the first, k(AB)(1), and the second, k(AB)(2), electron transfer and that of the charge recombination, k(BP), the free energy levels of Q(A)(-)Q(B) and Q(A)Q(B)(-) states, and the changes of charge compensating protein relaxation were determined in RCs incorporated into artificial lipid bilayer membranes. In RCs embedded in the PC vesicle, k(AB)(1) and k(AB)(2) increased (from 3100 to 4100 s(-1) and from 740 to 3300 s(-1), respectively) and k(BP) decreased (from 0.77 to 0.39 s(-1)) compared to those measured in detergent at pH 7. In PG, k(AB)(1) and k(BP) decreased (to values of 710 and 0.26 s(-1), respectively), while k(AB)(2) increased to 1506 s(-1) at pH 7. The free energy between the Q(A)(-)Q(B) and Q(A)Q(B)(-) states decreased in PC and PG (DeltaG degrees (Q)A-(Q)B(-->)(Q)A(Q)B- = -76.9 and -88.5 meV, respectively) compared to that measured in detergent (-61.8 meV). The changes of the Q(A)/Q(A)(-) redox potential measured by delayed luminescence showed (1) a differential effect of lipids whether RC incorporated in micelles or vesicles, (2) an altered binding interaction between anionic lipids and RC, (3) a direct influence of PC and PG on the free energy levels of the primary and secondary quinones probably through the intraprotein hydrogen-bonding network, and (4) a larger increase of the Q(A)/Q(A)(-) free energy in PG than in PC both in detergent micelles and in single-component vesicles. On the basis of recent structural data, implications of the binding properties of phospholipids to RC and possible interactions between lipids and electron transfer components will be discussed.     

Light-induced conformational changes in photosynthetic reaction centers: dielectric relaxation in the vicinity of the dimer

Conformational changes near the bacteriochlorophyll dimer induced by continuous illumination were identified in the wild type and 11 different mutants of reaction centers from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. The properties of the bacteriochlorophyll dimer, which has a different hydrogen bonding pattern with the surrounding protein in each mutant, were characterized by steady-state and transient optical spectroscopy. After illumination for 1 min, in the absence of the secondary quinone, the recovery of the charge-separated states was nearly 1 order of magnitude slower in one group of mutants including the wild type than in the mutants carrying the Leu to His mutation at the L131 position. The slower recovery was accompanied by a substantial decrease in the electrochromic absorption changes associated with the Q(y) bands of the nearby monomers during the illumination. The other set of mutants containing the Leu L131 to His substitution exhibited slightly altered electrochromic changes that decreased only half as much during the illumination as in the other family of mutants. The correlation between the recovery of the charge-separated states in the light-induced conformation and the electrochromic absorption changes suggests a dielectric relaxation of the protein that stabilizes the charge on the dimer.     

Electron donation from membrane-bound cytochrome c to the photosynthetic reaction center in whole cells and isolated membranes of Heliobacterium gestii

The reaction between membrane-bound cytochrome c and the reaction center bacteriochlorophyll g dimer P798 was studied in the whole cells and isolated membranes of Heliobacterium gestii. In the whole cells, the flash-oxidized P798⁺ was rereduced in multiple exponential phases with half times (t _1/2s) of 10 s, 300 s and 4 ms in relative amplitudes of 40, 35 and 25%, respectively. The faster two phases were in parallel with the oxidation of cytochrome c. In isolated membranes, a significantly slow oxidation of the membrane-bound cytochrome c was detected with t _1/2 = 3 ms. This slow rate, however, again became faster with the addition of Mg²⁺. The rate showed a high temperature dependency giving apparent activation energies of 88.2 and 58.9 kJ/mol in the whole cells and isolated membranes, respectively. Therefore, membrane-bound cytochrome c donates electrons to the P798⁺ in a collisional reaction mode like the reaction of water-soluble proteins. The rereduction of the oxidized cytochrome c was suppressed by the addition of stigmatellin both in the whole cells and isolated membranes. This indicates that the electron transfer from the cytochrome bc complex to the photooxidized P798⁺ is mediated by the membrane-bound cytochrome c. The multiple flash excitation study showed that 2–3 hemes c were connected to the P798. By the heme staining after the SDS-PAGE analysis of the membraneous proteins, two cytochromes c were detected on the gel indicating apparent molecular masses of 17 and 30 kDa, respectively. The situation resembles the case in green sulfur bacteria, that is, the membrane-bound cyotochrome c _z couples electron transfer between the cytochrome bc complex and the P840 reaction center complex.This revised version was published online in October 2005 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Photophysical properties of quinones and their interaction with the photosynthetic reaction centre

Photophysical properties of tetramethyl-1,4-benzoquinone (TMBQ) and 2,6-dimethoxy-1,4-benzoquinone (DMOBQ) in solution and their interactions with the photosynthetic reaction centre (RC) isolated from the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides have been investigated in this work. For these two benzoquinone derivatives an efficient ISC process which leads to the population of the lowest triplet state of the molecules upon direct excitation was observed. The presence of RC does not alter the properties of the triplet state of DMOBQ suggesting that interactions are negligible; on the other side RC efficiently quenched the T1 state of TMBQ. The behavior is rationalized in terms of redox potentials of quinones and kinetic characteristics of their transients.     

Electron donors and acceptors in photosynthetic reaction centers

Summary A review is given of primary and associated electron transport reactions in various division of photosynthetic bacteria and in the two photosystems of plant photosynthesis. Two types of electron acceptor chains are distinguished: type Q, found in purple bacteria, Chloroflexus and system II of oxygenic photosynthesis and type F, found in green sulfur bacteria, Heliobacterium and photosystem I. Secondary donor reactions are discussed in relation to plant photosystem II.Dedicated to the memory of Warren L. Butler