The importance of culling in Johne's disease control

Johne's disease is caused by Mycobacterium avium subsp. paratuberculosis (MAP) infection and results in economic losses in the dairy industry. To control MAP transmission in herds, test-based culling has been recommended and immediate culling of high shedding animals is typically implemented. In this study, we quantified the effects of MAP control in US dairy herds, using the basic reproduction ratio R₀. The effectiveness of culling strategies was evaluated for good and poor herd management (low- and high-transmission rates, respectively) by a phase diagram approach. To establish a quantitative relationship between culling rates and test properties, we defined the average detection times for low and high shedding animals. The effects of various culling strategies and test characteristics, such as test sensitivity, test turnaround time, and testing interval, were analyzed. To understand the overall effect of model parameters on R₀, we performed global uncertainty and sensitivity analyses. We also evaluated the effectiveness of culling only high shedding animals by comparing three test methods (fecal culture, fecal polymerase chain reaction, PCR, and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, ELISA). Our study shows that, in the case of good herd management, culling of only high shedding animals may be effective in controlling MAP transmission. However, in the case of poor management, in addition to immediate culling of high shedding animals, culling of low shedding animals (based on the fecal culture test) will be necessary. Culling of low shedding animals may be delayed 6-12 months, however, if a shorter testing interval is applied. This study suggests that if farmers prefer culling only high shedding animals, faster MAP detection tests (such as the fecal PCR and ELISA) of higher sensitivity should be applied with high testing frequency, particularly on farms with poor management. Culling of infectious animals with a longer testing interval is generally not effective to control MAP.     

Evalution of the “Iceberg Phenomenon” in Johne's Disease through Mathematical Modelling

Johne''s disease (JD) is a chronic, enteric disease in ruminants caused by Mycobacterium avium subsp. paratuberculosis (MAP). Disease progression follows four distinct stages: silent, subclinical, clinical and advanced. Available diagnostic tests have poor sensitivity and cannot detect early stages of the infection; as a result, only animals in the clinical and advanced stages, which represent the tip of the ‘iceberg’, are identified through testing. The Iceberg Phenomenon is then applied to provide estimates for JD prevalence. For one animal in the advanced stage, it is assumed that there are one to two in the clinical stage, four to eight in the subclinical stage, and ten to fourteen in the silent stage. These ratios, however, are based on little evidence. To evaluate the ratios, we developed a deterministic ordinary differential equation model of JD transmission and disease progression dynamics. When duration periods associated with the natural course of the disease progression are used, the above ratios do not hold. The ratios used to estimate JD prevalence need to be further investigated.     

Evaluation of bioelectronics sensor compared to other diagnostic test in diagnosis of Johne's disease in goats

A bioelectronics sensor has been developed and it is evaluated for the diagnosis of paratuberculosis in goats. Initially hematite nanoparticles were prepared and using this nanoparticles as core, electrically active polyaniline coated magnetic (EAPM) nanoparticles are synthesized from aniline monomer (made electrically active by acid doping). These EAPM nanoparticles were fabricated with rabbit anti-goat IgG for the detection of goat antibodies on the capture pad. The protoplasmic antigen of Mycobacterium avium subspecies paratuberculosis (MAP) immobilized onto the capture pad will detect the antibody against MAP in the goat sera samples. This bound goat antibody will be detected by the anti-goat IgG previously bound to EAPM. Upon detection the EAPM nanoparticles bridges an electric circuit between the silver electrodes, flanking the capture membrane. The electrical conductance, caused by EAPM, was measured as direct charge transfer between the electrodes. Testing of the biosensor with known Johne's disease (JD) positive and negative serum samples gave significant difference in the electrical conductance value. Further the efficacy of this biosensor was compared with other serological tests like agar gel immunodiffusion (AGID) and absorbed ELISA using field sera. Out of 265 goat sera tested, positive results recorded were; AGID 36 (13.59%), bioelectronics sensor 49 (19.14%), and absorbed ELISA 51 (19.25%). This biosensor was also compared in live animals using intradermal Johnin test and nested PCR (detecting mycobacterial DNA in feces) in 65 animals. Of which, positive results recorded in animals were; Johnin test 21 (32%), biosensor 26 (40%) and fecal PCR detected mycobacterial DNA in 28 (43%) animals. Though the nanobioelectronics sensor was slightly less sensitive (not statistically significant) compared to absorbed ELISA and fecal nested PCR for mycobacterial DNA but it was simple to perform in field conditions and requires less time. The speed of detection and the equipment involved would support its application toward the various point-of-care opportunities aimed at control and management of Johne's disease in goats.     

The Migration Test on Circulating Bovine Leukocytes and its Possible Application in the Diagnosis of Johne's Disease

The leukocyte migration test for in vitro studies of delayed type hypersensitivity has recently been reviewed (Søborg & Ben-dixen 1967; Bendixen & Søborg 1969). Søborg & Bendixen applied the test to circulating leukocytes in man and thereby widely increased the potentialities of this test. They obtained high leukocyte yields with only moderate erythrocyte admixture by harvesting the supernatant plasma after sedimentation of the erythrocytes for 60 min. at 37°C in the normal gravitational field (1 × g)- Their procedure was unsuitable for the present investigation because bovine erythrocytes sediment so slowly. Sedimentation after clumping at the interphase of aqueous solutions of polymers, dextran and methylcellulose, in combination with metrizoic acid (Böyum 1968) was tried without success because the vast majority of the leukocytes sedimented together with the erythrocytes. Separation of leukocytes from erythrocytes could not be achieved by differential centrifugation.     

Stochastic simulations of a multi-group compartmental model for Johne's disease on US dairy herds with test-based culling intervention

Infection elimination may be an important goal of control programs. Only in stochastic infection models can true infection elimination be observed as a fadeout. The phenomena of fadeout and variable prevalence are important in understanding the transmission dynamics of infectious diseases and these phenomena are essential to evaluate the effectiveness of control measures. To investigate the stochastic dynamics of Mycobacterium avium subsp. paratuberculosis (MAP) infection on US dairy herds with test-based culling intervention, we developed a multi-group stochastic compartmental model (a continuous time Markov chain model) with both horizontal and vertical transmission. The stochastic model predicted fadeout and within-herd prevalence to have a large variance. Although test-based culling intervention generally decreased prevalence over time, it took longer than desired by producers to eliminate the endemic MAP infection from a herd. Uncertainty analysis showed that, using annual culture test and culling of only high shedders or culling of both low and high shedders with a 12-month delay in culling of low shedders, MAP infection persisted in many herds beyond 20 years. While using semi-annual culture test and culling of low and high shedders with a 6-month delay in culling of low shedders, MAP infection in many herds would be extinct within 20 years. Sensitivity analysis of the cumulative density function of fadeout suggested that combining test-based culling intervention and reduction of transmission rates through improved management between susceptible calves and shedding animals may be more effective than either alone in eliminating endemic MAP infection. We also discussed the effects of other factors such as herd size, heifer replacement, and adult cow infection on the probability of fadeout.     

Bovine CLEC7A genetic variants and their association with seropositivity in Johne's disease ELISA

Mycobacterium avium ssp. paratuberculosis (MAP) infection in cattle causes significant economic losses to the dairy and beef industries resulting from reduced productivity, premature culling and mortality. Bovine Dectin-1, an important pattern recognition molecule that is able to generate a proinflammatory response by acting alongside Toll like receptor (TLR) signaling, is known to co-operate with TLR2 to specifically activate a macrophage proinflammatory response against mycobacterial infections. Therefore, the goal of this study was to identify single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in the gene encoding bovine Dectin-1 (CLEC7A) and to assess their association with susceptibility to MAP infection in dairy cattle. Blood and milk samples, collected from commercial dairy operations, were tested for MAP infection using blood and milk ELISAs and a resource population consisting of 197 infected and 242 healthy cattle was constructed. Pooled DNA was used for sequencing and eight single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) were identified. Identified SNPs were genotyped on the resource population using the iPLEX MassARRAY system and statistical analysis was performed using logistic regression fitting the additive and dominance effects of each SNP in the model. Out of a total of eight identified SNPs, five were successfully genotyped, and three out of these five SNPs were found to be in complete linkage. Statistical analysis revealed a strong association between a non-synonymous SNP c.589A>G (p = 0.008), and MAP infection status of the resource population inferred by seropositivity in MAP antibody specific ELISAs. This SNP c.589A>G was located in the geneic region that encodes the carbohydrate recognition domain of bovine Dectin-1. Therefore, further investigation of its functional relevance is warranted.     

Paratuberculosis (Johne's disease) in bighorn sheep and a Rocky Mountain goat in Colorado.

Between May, 1972 and February, 1978, six cases of paratuberculosis (Johne's Disease) caused by Mycobacterium paratuberculosis were diagnosed in free-ranging Rocky Mountain bighorn sheep (Ovis canadensis) and one Rocky Mountain goat (Oreamnos americanus) on or near Mt. Evans in Colorado. Diagnosis of paratuberculosis was based on gross and histopathologic examination of the animals and by isolation of M. paratuberculosis from three sheep and the goat. The clinical signs and pathologic changes seen in the bighorn sheep resembled those described in cattle, while the lesions in the goat were similar to those described for domestic sheep and goats.     

Autoreactive antibodies are present in sheep with Johne's disease and cross-react with Mycobacterium avium subsp. paratuberculosis antigens

Mycobacterial infection has been linked to the generation of autoantibodies, including anti-neutrophil cytoplasmic autoantibodies (ANCA), in clinical studies and small animal models. In an attempt to identify antibodies that react with both self and mycobacterial antigens in naturally infected ruminants, we generated a phage display library comprising single chain antibody fragments (scFv) from sheep with Johne's disease (JD). The library was screened simultaneously against ovine small intestinal tissue and Mycobacterium avium subsp. paratuberculosis (MAP). A clone (termed AutoH1) reacted strongly with host tissue and MAP, recognizing a proteinase-susceptible 32 kDa determinant in ovine gut tissues and lymphatics, and in blood granulocytes but not mononuclear cells. In granulocytes, binding was to cytoplasmic granules and cell membranes; in MAP, AutoH1 bound bacterial cell wall determinants. We further identified a synthetic peptide sequence recognized by AutoH1, using this to generate a carrier:peptide fusion protein (paH1). Sera of normal and JD sheep were screened for AutoH1-like autoantibody activity; 7/11 JD animals showed autoreactivity that could be blocked by paH1, while 0/21 normal animals showed no such serological reactivity. It is possible that the severe pathology observed in ruminant JD may have an autoimmune component, possibly due to ANCA-type binding; this remains to be further investigated.