Surface active drugs: self-association and interaction with membranes and surfactants. Physicochemical and biological aspects

Many pharmacologically active compounds are of amphiphilic (or hydrophobic) nature. As a result, they tend to self-associate and to interact with biological membranes. This review focuses on the self-aggregation properties of drugs, as well as on their interaction with membranes. It is seen that drug-membrane interactions are analogous to the interactions between membranes and classical detergents. Phenomena such as shape changes, vesiculation, membrane disruption, and solubilization have been observed. At the molecular level, these events seem to be modulated by lipid flip-flop and formation of non-bilayer phases. The modulation of physicochemical properties of drugs by self-association and membrane binding is discussed. Pathological consequences of drug-membrane interaction are described. The mechanisms of drug solubilization by surfactants are reviewed from the physicochemical point of view and in relation to drug carrying and absorption by the organism.     

Thermodynamics and kinetics of joint action of antiviral agent tilorone and DMSO on model lipid membranes

Individual and joint action of two water-soluble drugs, DMSO and tilorone, on model l-α-dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) membranes were studied in equilibrium and kinetic regimes by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). For equilibrium experiments, the drugs were introduced during preparation of the model membrane. In kinetic studies, one of the drugs was added to the DPPC membrane already containing the other drug, and the effects of drug-membrane interactions were monitored in real-time regime. It was found that tilorone and DMSO had opposite effects on the membrane melting temperature, which were non-additive under joint introduction of these drugs. Analysis of kinetics of DSC profiles under drugs introduction allowed us to discriminate two processes in drug-membrane interactions with different characteristic times, i.e., drug sorption onto the membrane (minutes) and drug diffusion through stacks of lipid bilayers (hours). It was established that 0.1?mol% DMSO effectively enhanced membrane penetration for tilorone with the rate of tilorone diffusion being dependent upon the scheme of drugs administration. A model was proposed describing how sorption of a dopant onto lipid membrane could affect the membrane permeability for other dopants. Conditions were determined for enhancement of membrane permeability, as it was observed for DPPC/DMSO/tilorone system.     

Interaction of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs with membranes: In vitro assessment and relevance for their biological actions

Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) are among the most commonly used drugs in the world due to their anti-inflammatory, analgesic and antipyretic properties. Nevertheless, the consumption of these drugs is still associated with the occurrence of a wide spectrum of adverse effects. Regarding the major role of membranes in cellular events, the hypothesis that the biological actions of NSAIDs may be related to their effect at the membrane level has triggered the in vitro assessment of NSAIDs-membrane interactions. The use of membrane mimetic models, cell cultures, a wide range of experimental techniques and molecular dynamics simulations has been providing significant information about drugs partition and location within membranes and also about their effect on diverse membrane properties. These studies have indeed been providing evidences that the effect of NSAIDs at membrane level may be an additional mechanism of action and toxicity of NSAIDs. In fact, the pharmacokinetic properties of NSAIDs are closely related to the ability of these drugs to interact and overcome biological membranes. Moreover, the therapeutic actions of NSAIDs may also result from the indirect inhibition of cyclooxygenase due to the disturbing effect of NSAIDs on membrane properties. Furthermore, increasing evidences suggest that the disordering effects of these drugs on membranes may be in the basis of the NSAIDs-induced toxicity in diverse organ systems. Overall, the study of NSAIDs-membrane interactions has proved to be not only important for the better understanding of their pharmacological actions, but also for the rational development of new approaches to overcome NSAIDs adverse effects.     

Biophysical characterization of mycobacterial model membranes and their interaction with rifabutin: Towards lipid-guided drug screening in tuberculosis

Lipid structure critically dictates the molecular interactions of drugs with membranes influencing passive diffusion, drug partitioning and accumulation, thereby underpinning a lipid-composition specific interplay. Spurring selective passive drug diffusion and uptake through membranes is an obvious solution to combat growing antibiotic resistance with minimized toxicities. However, the spectrum of complex mycobacterial lipids and lack thereof of suitable membrane platforms limits the understanding of mechanisms underlying drug-membrane interactions in tuberculosis. Herein, we developed membrane scaffolds specific to mycobacterial outer membrane and demonstrate them as improvised research platforms for investigating anti-tubercular drug interactions. Combined spectroscopy and microscopy results reveal an enhanced partitioning of model drug Rifabutin in trehalose dimycolate-containing mycobacterial membrane systems. These effects are apportioned to specific changes in membrane structure, order and fluidity leading to enhanced drug interaction. These findings on the membrane biophysical consequences of drug interactions will offer valuable insights for guiding the design of more effective antibiotic drugs coupled with tuned toxicity profiles.     

Affinity of Alkylphosphocholines to Biological Membrane of Prostate Cancer: Studies in Natural and Model Systems

The effectiveness of two alkylphosphocholines (APCs), hexadecylphosphocholine (miltefosine) and erucylphosphocholine to combat prostate cancer has been studied in vitro with artificial cancerous membrane, modelled with the Langmuir monolayer technique, and on cell line (Du-145). Studies performed with the Langmuir method indicate that both the investigated drugs have the affinity to the monolayer mimicking prostate cancer membrane (composed of cholesterol:POPC = 0.428) and the drug-membrane interactions are stronger for erucylphosphocholine as compared to hexadecylphosphocholine. Moreover, both studied drugs were found to fluidize the model membrane, which may lead to apoptosis. Indeed, biological studies confirmed that in Du-145 cell line both investigated alkylphosphocholines cause cell death primarily by apoptosis while necrotic cells constitute only a small percentage of APC-treated cells.     

Model architectures for bacterial membranes

The complex composition of bacterial membranes has a significant impact on the understanding of pathogen function and their development towards antibiotic resistance. In addition to the inherent complexity and biosafety risks of studying biological pathogen membranes, the continual rise of antibiotic resistance and its significant economical and clinical consequences has motivated the development of numerous in vitro model membrane systems with tuneable compositions, geometries, and sizes. Approaches discussed in this review include liposomes, solid-supported bilayers, and computational simulations which have been used to explore various processes including drug-membrane interactions, lipid-protein interactions, host–pathogen interactions, and structure-induced bacterial pathogenesis. The advantages, limitations, and applicable analytical tools of all architectures are summarised with a perspective for future research efforts in architectural improvement and elucidation of resistance development strategies and membrane-targeting antibiotic mechanisms. Supplementary InformationThe online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s12551-021-00913-7.     

Analysis of protein interactions at native chloroplast membranes by ellipsometry

Membrane bound receptors play vital roles in cell signaling, and are the target for many drugs, yet their interactions with ligands are difficult to study by conventional techniques due to the technical difficulty of monitoring these interactions in lipid environments. In particular, the ability to analyse the behaviour of membrane proteins in their native membrane environment is limited. Here, we have developed a quantitative approach to detect specific interactions between low-abundance chaperone receptors within native chloroplast membranes and their soluble chaperone partners. Langmuir-Schaefer film deposition was used to deposit native chloroplasts onto gold-coated glass slides, and interactions between the molecular chaperones Hsp70 and Hsp90 and their receptors in the chloroplast membranes were detected and quantified by total internal reflection ellipsometry (TIRE). We show that native chloroplast membranes deposited on gold-coated glass slides using Langmuir-Schaefer films retain functional receptors capable of binding chaperones with high specificity and affinity. Taking into account the low chaperone receptor abundance in native membranes, these binding properties are consistent with data generated using soluble forms of the chloroplast chaperone receptors, OEP61 and Toc64. Therefore, we conclude that chloroplasts have the capacity to selectively bind chaperones, consistent with the notion that chaperones play an important role in protein targeting to chloroplasts. Importantly, this method of monitoring by TIRE does not require any protein labelling. This novel combination of techniques should be applicable to a wide variety of membranes and membrane protein receptors, thus presenting the opportunity to quantify protein interactions involved in fundamental cellular processes, and to screen for drugs that target membrane proteins.     

Unraveling the mechanism of octenidine and chlorhexidine on membranes: Does electrostatics matter?

The increasing problem of antibiotic resistance in bacteria requires the development of new antimicrobial candidates. There are several well-known substances with commercial use, but their molecular mode of action is not fully understood. In this work, we focus on two commonly used antimicrobial agents from the detergent family—octenidine dichloride (OCT) and chlorhexidine digluconate (CHX). Both of them are reported to be agents selectively attacking the cell membrane through interaction inducing membrane disruption by emulsification. They are believed to present electrostatic selectivity toward charged lipids. In this study, we tested this hypothesis and revised previously proposed molecular mechanisms of action. Employing a variety of techniques such as molecular dynamics, ζ potential with dynamic light scattering, vesicle fluctuation spectroscopy, carboxyfluorescein leakage measurement, and fluorescence trimethylammonium-diphenylhexatriene- and diphenylhexatriene-based studies for determination of OCT and CHX membrane location, we performed experimental studies using two model membrane systems—zwitterionic PC and negatively charged PG (18:1/18:1):PC (16:0/18:1) 3:7, respectively. These studies were extended by molecular dynamics simulations performed on a three-component bacterial membrane model system to further test interactions with another negatively charged lipid, cardiolipin. In summary, our study demonstrated that detergent selectivity is far more complicated than supposed simple electrostatic interactions. Although OCT does disrupt the membrane, our results suggest that its primary selectivity was more linked to mechanical properties of the membrane. On the other hand, CHX did not disrupt membranes as a primary activity, nor did it show any sign of electrostatic selectivity toward negatively charged membranes at any stage of interactions, which suggests membrane disruption by influencing more discrete membrane properties.     

Interaction of the cholesterol reducing agent simvastatin with zwitterionic DPPC and charged DPPG phospholipid membranes

Simvastatin is a lipid-lowering drug in the pharmaceutical group statins. Interaction of a drug with lipids may define its role in the system and be critical for its pharmacological activity. We examined the interactions of simvastatin with zwitterionic dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine (DPPC) and anionic dipalmitoyl phosphatidylglycerol (DPPG) multilamellar vesicles (MLVs) as a function of temperature at different simvastatin concentrations using Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). The FTIR results indicate that the effect of simvastatin on membrane structure and dynamics depends on the type of membrane lipids. In anionic DPPG MLVs, high simvastatin concentrations (12, 18, 24 mol%) change the position of the CH₂ antisymmetric stretching mode to lower wavenumber values, implying an ordering effect. However, in zwitterionic DPPC MLVs, high concentrations of simvastatin disorder systems both in the gel and liquid crystalline phases. Moreover, in DPPG and DPPC MLVs, simvastatin has opposite dual effects on membrane dynamics. The bandwidth of the CH₂ antisymmetric stretching modes increases in DPPG MLVs, implying an increase in the dynamics, whereas it decreases in DPPC MLVs. Simvastatin caused broadening of the phase transition peaks and formation of shoulders on the phase transition peaks in DSC curves, indicating multi-domain formations in the phospholipid membranes. Because physical features of membranes such as lipid order and fluidity may be changed with the bioactivity of drugs, opposing effects of simvastatin on the order and dynamics of neutral and charged phospholipids may be critical to deduce the action mechanism of the drug and estimate drug-membrane interactions.     

Unraveling the mechanism of octenidine and chlorhexidine on membranes: Does electrostatics matter?

The increasing problem of antibiotic resistance in bacteria requires the development of new antimicrobial candidates. There are several well-known substances with commercial use, but their molecular mode of action is not fully understood. In this work, we focus on two commonly used antimicrobial agents from the detergent family—octenidine dichloride (OCT) and chlorhexidine digluconate (CHX). Both of them are reported to be agents selectively attacking the cell membrane through interaction inducing membrane disruption by emulsification. They are believed to present electrostatic selectivity toward charged lipids. In this study, we tested this hypothesis and revised previously proposed molecular mechanisms of action. Employing a variety of techniques such as molecular dynamics, ζ potential with dynamic light scattering, vesicle fluctuation spectroscopy, carboxyfluorescein leakage measurement, and fluorescence trimethylammonium-diphenylhexatriene- and diphenylhexatriene-based studies for determination of OCT and CHX membrane location, we performed experimental studies using two model membrane systems—zwitterionic PC and negatively charged PG (18:1/18:1):PC (16:0/18:1) 3:7, respectively. These studies were extended by molecular dynamics simulations performed on a three-component bacterial membrane model system to further test interactions with another negatively charged lipid, cardiolipin. In summary, our study demonstrated that detergent selectivity is far more complicated than supposed simple electrostatic interactions. Although OCT does disrupt the membrane, our results suggest that its primary selectivity was more linked to mechanical properties of the membrane. On the other hand, CHX did not disrupt membranes as a primary activity, nor did it show any sign of electrostatic selectivity toward negatively charged membranes at any stage of interactions, which suggests membrane disruption by influencing more discrete membrane properties.     

Lipid-induced conformation and lipid-binding properties of cytolytic and antimicrobial peptides: determination and biological specificity

While antimicrobial and cytolytic peptides exert their effects on cells largely by interacting with the lipid bilayers of their membranes, the influence of the cell membrane lipid composition on the specificity of these peptides towards a given organism is not yet understood. The lack of experimental model systems that mimic the complexity of natural cell membranes has hampered efforts to establish a direct correlation between the induced conformation of these peptides upon binding to cell membranes and their biological specificities. Nevertheless, studies using model membranes reconstituted from lipids and a few membrane-associated proteins, combined with spectroscopic techniques (i.e. circular dichroism, fluorescence spectroscopy, Fourier transform infra red spectroscopy, etc.), have provided information on specific structure-function relationships of peptide-membrane interactions at the molecular level. Reversed phase-high performance chromatography (RP-HPLC) and surface plasmon resonance (SPR) are emerging techniques for the study of the dynamics of the interactions between cytolytic and antimicrobial peptides and lipid surfaces. Thus, the immobilization of lipid moieties onto RP-HPLC sorbent now allows the investigation of peptide conformational transition upon interaction with membrane surfaces, while SPR allows the observation of the time course of peptide binding to membrane surfaces. Such studies have clearly demonstrated the complexity of peptide-membrane interactions in terms of the mutual changes in peptide binding, conformation, orientation, and lipid organization, and have, to a certain extent, allowed correlations to be drawn between peptide conformational properties and lytic activity.     

Thermodynamic analysis of an entropically driven,high-affinity nanobody-HIV p24 interaction

Protein-protein interactions are fundamental to life processes. Complementary computational, structural, and biophysical studies of these interactions enable the forces behind their specificity and strength to be understood. Antibody fragments such as single-chain antibodies have the specificity and affinity of full antibodies but a fraction of their size, expediting whole molecule studies and distal effects without exceeding the computational capacity of modeling systems. We previously reported the crystal structure of a high-affinity nanobody 59H10 bound to HIV-1 capsid protein p24 and deduced key interactions using all-atom molecular dynamics simulations. We studied the properties of closely related medium (37E7) and low (48G11) affinity nanobodies, to understand how changes of three (37E7) or one (48G11) amino acids impacted these interactions; however, the contributions of enthalpy and entropy were not quantified. Here, we report the use of qualitative and quantitative experimental and in silico approaches to separate the contributions of enthalpy and entropy. We used complementary circular dichroism spectroscopy and molecular dynamics simulations to qualitatively delineate changes between nanobodies in isolation and complexed with p24. Using quantitative techniques such as isothermal titration calorimetry alongside WaterMap and Free Energy Perturbation protocols, we found the difference between high (59H10) and medium (37E7) affinity nanobodies on binding to HIV-1 p24 is entropically driven, accounted for by the release of unstable waters from the hydrophobic surface of 59H10. Our results provide an exemplar of the utility of parallel in vitro and in silico studies and highlight that differences in entropic interactions between amino acids and water molecules are sufficient to drive orders of magnitude differences in affinity.     

Ionization, lipophilicity, and molecular modeling to investigate permeability and other biological properties of amlodipine

This paper uses a recent approach toward drug discovery, in which in silico tools and experimental data are combined together to study the structural features of amlodipine and their relevance in the peculiar pharmacodynamic and pharmacokinetic profiles of this long acting calcium antagonist. Results reveal for amlodipine two families of conformers (folded and extended) but also demonstrate that protonation is the predominant factor governing amlodipine intermolecular interactions among which ionic forces play a major role.     

The lipid network

Natural cell membranes are composed of a remarkable variety of lipids, which provide specific biophysical properties to support membrane protein function. An improved understanding of this complexity of membrane composition may also allow the design of membrane active drugs. Crafting a relevant model of a cell membrane with controlled composition is becoming an art, with the ability to reveal the molecular mechanisms of biological processes and lead to better treatment of pathologies. By matching physiological observations from in vivo experiments to high-resolution information, more easily obtained from in vitro studies, complex interactions at the lipid interface are determined. The role of the lipid network in biological membranes is, therefore, the subject of increasing attention.     

Molecular dynamics simulation of a phosphatidylglycerol membrane

Although molecular dynamics simulations are an important tool for studying membrane systems, relatively few simulations have used anionic lipids. This paper reports the first simulation of a pure phosphatidylglycerol (PG) bilayer. The properties of this equilibrated palmitoyloleoylphosphatidylglycerol membrane agree with experimental observations of PG membranes and with previous simulations of monolayers and mixed bilayers containing PG lipids. These simulations also provide interesting insights into hydrogen bonding interactions in PG membranes. This equilibrated membrane will be a useful starting point for simulations of membrane proteins interacting with PG lipids.     

Mitoxantrone changes spectrin-aminophospholipid interactions

Understanding drug-membrane and drug-membrane protein interactions would be a crucial step towards understanding the action and biological properties of anthracyclines, as the cell membrane with its integral and peripheral proteins is the first barrier encountered by these drugs. In this paper, we briefly describe mitoxantrone-monolayer and mitoxantrone-bilayer interactions, focusing on the effect of mitoxantrone on the interactions between erythroid or nonerythroid spectrin with phosphatidylethanolamine-enriched mono- and bilayers. We found that mitoxantrone markedly modifies the interaction of erythroid and nonerythroid spectrins with phosphatidylethanolamine/phosphatitydcholine (PE/PC) monolayers. The change in Δπ induced by spectrins is several-fold larger in the presence of 72?nM mitoxantrone than in its absence: spectrin/mitoxantrone complexes induced a strong compression of the monolayer. Spin-labelling experiments showed that spectrin/mitoxantrone complexes caused significant changes in the order parameter measured using a 5′-doxyl stearate probe in the bilayer, but they practically did not affect the mobility of 16′-doxyl stearate. These results indicate close-to-surface interactions/penetrations without significant effect on the mid-region of the hydrophobic core of the bilayer. The obtained apparent equilibrium dissociation constants indicated relatively similar mitoxantrone-phospholipid and mitoxantrone-spectrin (erythroid and nonerythroid) binding affinities. These results might in part, explain the effect of mitoxantrone on spectrin distribution in the living cells.     

Biomimetic membrane systems to study cellular organization

During many cellular processes such as cell division, polarization and motility, the plasma membrane does not only represent a passive physical barrier, but also provides a highly dynamic platform for the interplay between lipids, membrane binding proteins and cytoskeletal elements. Even though many regulators of these interactions are known, their mutual interdependence appears to be highly complex and difficult to study in a living cell. Over the past few years, in vitro studies on membrane–cytoskeleton interactions using biomimetic membranes turned out to be extremely helpful to get better mechanistic insight into the dynamics of these processes. In this review, we discuss some of the recent developments using in vitro assays to dissect the role of the players involved: lipids in the membrane, proteins binding to membranes and proteins binding to membrane proteins. We also summarize advantages and disadvantages of supported lipid bilayers as model membrane.     

Simulation study of interaction mechanism between peptide and asymmetric membrane

Cell-penetrating peptides (CPPs) are widely used as drug carriers, owing to their superior ability to cross cell membrane both alone and with cargos, such as genes and other particles. Understanding the translocation mechanism of CPP is significant for many therapeutic purposes, including targeting drug and gene delivery. In this study, we performed a coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulation to investigate the interaction mechanism between polyarginine peptides and asymmetric membranes. Results showed that peptides can penetrate through the lipid bilayer by inducing a hydrophilic hole formation in the asymmetric membrane. Furthermore, the lengthy peptide chain length (R4–R16 peptides) and high membrane asymmetry positively affect peptide penetration. Our study provides insights into the molecular-level interactions between peptides and asymmetric membranes, as well as suggestions for targeted gene and drug delivery.     

Carotenoids and Environmental Stress in Plants: Significance of Carotenoid-Mediated Modulation of Membrane Physical Properties

Carotenoids, apart of their antenna function in photosynthesis, play an important role in the mechanisms protecting the photosynthetic apparatus against various harmful environmental factors. They protect plants against overexcitation in strong light and dissipate the excess of absorbed energy, they scavenge reactive oxygen species formed during photooxidative stress and moderate the effect of extreme temperatures. One of the important factors involved in the protective action of carotenoids is their influence on the molecular dynamics of membranes. To obtain complex information about interactions between carotenoids and lipids in a membrane, different techniques were used. In this review, the data resulting from EPR–spin label spectrometry, ³¹P- and ¹³C-NMR, differential scanning calorimetry, and computer simulation of the membrane molecular dynamics are presented. The effects of selected, structurally different carotenoid species on various physical parameters of model and natural membranes are described and their relevance to protection against some environmental stresses are discussed.     

Interaction of oxicam NSAIDs with DMPC vesicles: differential partitioning of drugs

Small unilamellar vesicles (SUVs) formed by the dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC), a phospholipid; serve as a membrane mimetic system that can be used to study the effect of absence of net surface charges on drug-membrane interaction. The targets of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) are cyclooxygenases, which are membrane active enzymes. Hence, to approach their targets NSAIDs have to pass different bio-membranes. Different membrane parameters are expected to guide the first level of interaction of these drugs before they are presented to their targets. Our earlier studies have demonstrated the crucial role of surface charges of membrane mimetic systems like micelles and mixed micelles on the interaction of oxicam NSAIDs. In order to see whether net surface charges of membranes are essential for the interaction of oxicam NSAIDs, we have studied the incorporation of two oxicam NSAIDs, viz., piroxicam and meloxicam in DMPC vesicles using the intrinsic fluorescence properties of the drugs. To see whether different prototropic forms of the drugs can interact with DMPC vesicles, studies were carried out under different pH conditions. Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) was used to characterize the SUVs those were formed at different pH values. Steady state fluorescence anisotropy measurements show that both forms of the two drugs, viz., global neutral and anion can be incorporated into the DMPC vesicles. Partition coefficient (KP) between DMPC and the aqueous buffer used has been calculated in all cases from fluorescent intensity measurements. The KP values for the neutral and anionic forms of piroxicam are 219.0 and 25.8, respectively, and that for meloxicam are 896.7 and 110.2, respectively. From the KP values it is evident that irrespective of the nature of the prototropic forms, meloxicam has a higher KP value than piroxicam. This correlates with the previously calculated log KP values between n-octanol and aqueous phase, which demonstrates that in absence of net surface charges of DMPC vesicles the hydrophobic interaction is the principal driving force for incorporation. Our results imply that for bio-membranes having no net surface charges hydrophobic effect plays a principal role to guide these NSAIDs to their targets.