Genetic recombination and the cell cycle: what we have learned from chromosome dimers

Genetic recombination is central to DNA metabolism. It promotes sequence diversity and maintains genome integrity in all organisms. However, it can have perverse effects and profoundly influence the cell cycle. In bacteria harbouring circular chromosomes, recombination frequently has an unwanted outcome, the formation of chromosome dimers. Dimers form by homologous recombination between sister chromosomes and are eventually resolved by the action of two site-specific recombinases, XerC and XerD, at their target site, dif, located in the replication terminus of the chromosome. Studies of the Xer system and of the modalities of dimer formation and resolution have yielded important knowledge on how both homologous and site-specific recombination are controlled and integrated in the cell cycle. Here, we briefly review these advances and highlight the important questions they raise.     

Evidence for a Xer/dif system for chromosome resolution in archaea

Homologous recombination events between circular chromosomes, occurring during or after replication, can generate dimers that need to be converted to monomers prior to their segregation at cell division. In Escherichia coli, chromosome dimers are converted to monomers by two paralogous site-specific tyrosine recombinases of the Xer family (XerC/D). The Xer recombinases act at a specific dif site located in the replication termination region, assisted by the cell division protein FtsK. This chromosome resolution system has been predicted in most Bacteria and further characterized for some species. Archaea have circular chromosomes and an active homologous recombination system and should therefore resolve chromosome dimers. Most archaea harbour a single homologue of bacterial XerC/D proteins (XerA), but not of FtsK. Therefore, the role of XerA in chromosome resolution was unclear. Here, we have identified dif-like sites in archaeal genomes by using a combination of modeling and comparative genomics approaches. These sites are systematically located in replication termination regions. We validated our in silico prediction by showing that the XerA protein of Pyrococcus abyssi specifically recombines plasmids containing the predicted dif site in vitro. In contrast to the bacterial system, XerA can recombine dif sites in the absence of protein partners. Whereas Archaea and Bacteria use a completely different set of proteins for chromosome replication, our data strongly suggest that XerA is most likely used for chromosome resolution in Archaea.     

FtsK-dependent and -independent pathways of Xer site-specific recombination.

Homologous recombination between circular chromosomes generates dimers that cannot be segregated at cell division. Escherichia coli Xer site-specific recombination converts chromosomal and plasmid dimers to monomers. Two recombinases, XerC and XerD, act at the E. coli chromosomal recombination site, dif, and at related sites in plasmids. We demonstrate that Xer recombination at plasmid dif sites occurs efficiently only when FtsK is present and under conditions that allow chromosomal dimer formation, whereas recombination at the plasmid sites cer and psi is independent of these factors. We propose that the chromosome dimer- and FtsK-dependent process that activates Xer recombination at plasmid dif also activates Xer recombination at chromosomal dif. The defects in chromosome segregation that result from mutation of the FtsK C-terminus are attributable to the failure of Xer recombination to resolve chromosome dimers to monomers. Conditions that lead to FtsK-independent Xer recombination support the hypothesis that FtsK acts on Holliday junction Xer recombination intermediates.     

Extent of the activity domain and possible roles of FtsK in the Escherichia coli chromosome terminus

Escherichia coli FtsK protein couples cell division and chromosome segregation. It is a component of the septum essential for cell division. It also acts during chromosome dimer resolution by XerCD-specific recombination at the dif site, with two distinct activities: DNA translocation oriented by skewed sequence elements and direct activation of Xer recombination. Dimer resolution requires that the skewed elements polarize in opposite directions 30-50 kb on either side of dif. This constitutes the DIF domain, approximately coincident with the region where replication terminates. The observation that the ftsK1 mutation increases recombination near dif was exploited to determine whether the chromosome region on which FtsK acts is limited to the DIF domain. A monitoring of recombination activity at multiple loci in a 350 kb region to the left of dif revealed (i) zones of differing activities unconnected to dimer resolution and (ii) a constant 10-fold increase of recombination in the 250 kb region adjacent to dif in the ftsK1 mutant. The latter effect allows definition of an FTSK domain whose total size is at least fourfold that of the DIF domain. Additional analyses revealed that FtsK activity responds to polarization in the whole FTSK domain and that displacement of the region where replication terminates preserves differences between recombination zones. Our interpretation is that translocation by FtsK occurs mostly on DNA belonging to a specifically organized domain of the chromosome, when physical links between either dimeric or still intercatenated chromosomes force this DNA to run across the septum at division.     

An efficient method of selectable marker gene excision by Xer recombination for gene replacement in bacterial chromosomes

A simple, effective method of unlabeled, stable gene insertion into bacterial chromosomes has been developed. This utilizes an insertion cassette consisting of an antibiotic resistance gene flanked by dif sites and regions homologous to the chromosomal target locus. dif is the recognition sequence for the native Xer site-specific recombinases responsible for chromosome and plasmid dimer resolution: XerC/XerD in Escherichia coli and RipX/CodV in Bacillus subtilis. Following integration of the insertion cassette into the chromosomal target locus by homologous recombination, these recombinases act to resolve the two directly repeated dif sites to a single site, thus excising the antibiotic resistance gene. Previous approaches have required the inclusion of exogenous site-specific recombinases or transposases in trans; our strategy demonstrates that this is unnecessary, since an effective recombination system is already present in bacteria. The high recombination frequency makes the inclusion of a counter-selectable marker gene unnecessary.     

The unconventional Xer recombination machinery of Streptococci/Lactococci

Homologous recombination between circular sister chromosomes during DNA replication in bacteria can generate chromosome dimers that must be resolved into monomers prior to cell division. In Escherichia coli, dimer resolution is achieved by site-specific recombination, Xer recombination, involving two paralogous tyrosine recombinases, XerC and XerD, and a 28-bp recombination site (dif) located at the junction of the two replication arms. Xer recombination is tightly controlled by the septal protein FtsK. XerCD recombinases and FtsK are found on most sequenced eubacterial genomes, suggesting that the Xer recombination system as described in E. coli is highly conserved among prokaryotes. We show here that Streptococci and Lactococci carry an alternative Xer recombination machinery, organized in a single recombination module. This corresponds to an atypical 31-bp recombination site (dif_SL) associated with a dedicated tyrosine recombinase (XerS). In contrast to the E. coli Xer system, only a single recombinase is required to recombine dif_SL, suggesting a different mechanism in the recombination process. Despite this important difference, XerS can only perform efficient recombination when dif_SL sites are located on chromosome dimers. Moreover, the XerS/dif_SL recombination requires the streptococcal protein FtsK_SL, probably without the need for direct protein-protein interaction, which we demonstrated to be located at the division septum of Lactococcus lactis. Acquisition of the XerS recombination module can be considered as a landmark of the separation of Streptococci/Lactococci from other firmicutes and support the view that Xer recombination is a conserved cellular function in bacteria, but that can be achieved by functional analogs.     

Termination Structures in the Escherichia coli Chromosome Replication Fork Trap

The Escherichia coli chromosome contains two opposed sets of unidirectional DNA replication pause (Ter) sites that, according to the replication fork trap theory, control the termination of chromosome replication by restricting replication fork fusion to the terminus region. In contrast, a recent hypothesis suggested that termination occurs at the dif locus instead. Using two-dimensional agarose gel electrophoresis, we examined DNA replication intermediates at the Ter sites and at dif in wild-type cells. Two definitive signatures of site-specific termination—specific replication fork arrest and converging replication forks—were clearly detected at Ter sites, but not at dif. We also detected a significant pause during the latter stages of replication fork convergence at Ter sites. Quantification of fork pausing at the Ter sites in both their native chromosomal context and the plasmid context further supported the fork trap model.     

Site-specific recombination at dif by Haemophilus influenzae XerC

Xer site-specific recombination at the Escherichia coli chromosomal site dif converts chromosomal dimers to monomers, thereby allowing chromosome segregation during cell division. dif is located in the replication terminus region and binds the E. coli site-specific recombinases EcoXerC and EcoXerD. The Haemophilus influenzae Xer homologues, HinXerC and HinXerD, bind E. coli dif and exchange strands of dif Holliday junctions in vitro. Supercoiled dif sites are not recombined by EcoXerC and EcoXerD in vitro, possibly as a consequence of a regulatory process, which ensures that in vivo recombination at dif is confined to cells that can initiate cell division and contain dimeric chromosomes. In contrast, the combined action of HinXerC and EcoXerD supports in vitro recombination between supercoiled dif sites, thereby overcoming the barrier to dif recombination exhibited by EcoXerC and EcoXerD. The recombination products are catenated and knotted molecules, consistent with recombination occurring with synaptic complexes that have entrapped variable numbers of negative supercoils. Use of catalytically inactive recombinases provides support for a recombination pathway in which HinXerC-mediated strand exchange between directly repeated duplex dif sites generates a Holliday junction intermediate that is resolved by EcoXerD to catenated products. These can undergo a second recombination reaction to generate odd-noded knots.     

FtsK-dependent dimer resolution on multiple chromosomes in the pathogen Vibrio cholerae

Unlike most bacteria, Vibrio cholerae harbors two distinct, nonhomologous circular chromosomes (chromosome I and II). Many features of chromosome II are plasmid-like, which raised questions concerning its chromosomal nature. Plasmid replication and segregation are generally not coordinated with the bacterial cell cycle, further calling into question the mechanisms ensuring the synchronous management of chromosome I and II. Maintenance of circular replicons requires the resolution of dimers created by homologous recombination events. In Escherichia coli, chromosome dimers are resolved by the addition of a crossover at a specific site, dif, by two tyrosine recombinases, XerC and XerD. The process is coordinated with cell division through the activity of a DNA translocase, FtsK. Many E. coli plasmids also use XerCD for dimer resolution. However, the process is FtsK-independent. The two chromosomes of the V. cholerae N16961 strain carry divergent dimer resolution sites, dif1 and dif2. Here, we show that V. cholerae FtsK controls the addition of a crossover at dif1 and dif2 by a common pair of Xer recombinases. In addition, we show that specific DNA motifs dictate its orientation of translocation, the distribution of these motifs on chromosome I and chromosome II supporting the idea that FtsK translocation serves to bring together the resolution sites carried by a dimer at the time of cell division. Taken together, these results suggest that the same FtsK-dependent mechanism coordinates dimer resolution with cell division for each of the two V. cholerae chromosomes. Chromosome II dimer resolution thus stands as a bona fide chromosomal process.     

Xer recombinase and genome integrity in Helicobacter pylori, a pathogen without topoisomerase IV

In the model organism E. coli, recombination mediated by the related XerC and XerD recombinases complexed with the FtsK translocase at specialized dif sites, resolves dimeric chromosomes into free monomers to allow efficient chromosome segregation at cell division. Computational genome analysis of Helicobacter pylori, a slow growing gastric pathogen, identified just one chromosomal xer gene (xerH) and its cognate dif site (difH). Here we show that recombination between directly repeated difH sites requires XerH, FtsK but not XerT, the TnPZ transposon associated recombinase. xerH inactivation was not lethal, but resulted in increased DNA per cell, suggesting defective chromosome segregation. The xerH mutant also failed to colonize mice, and was more susceptible to UV and ciprofloxacin, which induce DNA breakage, and thereby recombination and chromosome dimer formation. xerH inactivation and overexpression each led to a DNA segregation defect, suggesting a role for Xer recombination in regulation of replication. In addition to chromosome dimer resolution and based on the absence of genes for topoisomerase IV (parC, parE) in H. pylori, we speculate that XerH may contribute to chromosome decatenation, although possible involvement of H. pylori's DNA gyrase and topoisomerase III homologue are also considered. Further analyses of this system should contribute to general understanding of and possibly therapy development for H. pylori, which causes peptic ulcers and gastric cancer; for the closely related, diarrheagenic Campylobacter species; and for unrelated slow growing pathogens that lack topoisomerase IV, such as Mycobacterium tuberculosis.     

Identification and characterization of the dif Site from Bacillus subtilis

Bacteria with circular chromosomes have evolved systems that ensure multimeric chromosomes, formed by homologous recombination between sister chromosomes during DNA replication, are resolved to monomers prior to cell division. The chromosome dimer resolution process in Escherichia coli is mediated by two tyrosine family site-specific recombinases, XerC and XerD, and requires septal localization of the division protein FtsK. The Xer recombinases act near the terminus of chromosome replication at a site known as dif (Ecdif). In Bacillus subtilis the RipX and CodV site-specific recombinases have been implicated in an analogous reaction. We present here genetic and biochemical evidence that a 28-bp sequence of DNA (Bsdif), lying 6 degrees counterclockwise from the B. subtilis terminus of replication (172 degrees ), is the site at which RipX and CodV catalyze site-specific recombination reactions required for normal chromosome partitioning. Bsdif in vivo recombination did not require the B. subtilis FtsK homologues, SpoIIIE and YtpT. We also show that the presence or absence of the B. subtilis SPbeta-bacteriophage, and in particular its yopP gene product, appears to strongly modulate the extent of the partitioning defects seen in codV strains and, to a lesser extent, those seen in ripX and dif strains.     

Archaeal cell cycle progress

The discovery of multiple chromosome replication origins in Sulfolobus species has added yet another eukaryotic trait to the archaea, and brought new levels of complexity to the cell cycle in terms of initiation of chromosome replication, replication termination and chromosome decatenation. Conserved repeated DNA elements--origin recognition boxes--have been identified in the origins of replication, and shown to bind the Orc1/Cdc6 proteins involved in cell cycle control. The origin recognition boxes aid in the identification and characterization of new origins, and their conservation suggests that most archaea have a similar replication initiation mechanism. Cell-cycle-dependent variation in Orc1/Cdc6 levels has been demonstrated, reminiscent of variations in cyclin levels during the eukaryotic cell cycle. Information about archaeal chromosome segregation is also accumulating, including the identification of a protein that binds to short regularly spaced repeats that might constitute centromere-like elements. In addition, studies of cell-cycle-specific gene expression have potential to reveal, in the near future, missing components in crenarchaeal chromosome replication, genome segregation and cell division. Together with an increased number of physiological and cytological investigations of the overall organization of the cell cycle, rapid progress of the archaeal cell cycle field is evident, and archaea, in particular Sulfolobus species, are emerging as simple and powerful models for the eukaryotic cell cycle.     

Two DNA translocases synergistically affect chromosome dimer resolution in Bacillus subtilis

In Bacillus subtilis, chromosome dimers that block complete segregation of sister chromosomes arise in about 15% of exponentially growing cells. Two dedicated recombinases, RipX and CodV, catalyze the resolution of dimers by site-specific recombination at the dif site, which is located close to the terminus region on the chromosome. We show that the two DNA translocases in B. subtilis, SftA and SpoIIIE, synergistically affect dimer resolution, presumably by positioning the dif sites in close proximity, before or after completion of cell division, respectively. Furthermore, we observed that both recombinases, RipX and CodV, assemble on the chromosome at the dif site throughout the cell cycle. The preassembly of recombinases probably ensures that dimer resolution can occur rapidly within a short time window around cell division.     

KOPS-guided DNA translocation by FtsK safeguards Escherichia coli chromosome segregation

The septum-located DNA translocase, FtsK, acts to co-ordinate the late steps of Escherichia coli chromosome segregation with cell division. The FtsK γ regulatory subdomain interacts with 8 bp KOPS DNA sequences, which are oriented from the replication origin to the terminus region ( ter ) in each arm of the chromosome. This interaction directs FtsK translocation towards ter where the final chromosome unlinking by decatenation and chromosome dimer resolution occurs. Chromosome dimer resolution requires FtsK translocation along DNA and its interaction with the XerCD recombinase bound to the recombination site, dif , located within ter . The frequency of chromosome dimer formation is ∼15% per generation in wild-type cells. Here we characterize FtsK alleles that no longer recognize KOPS, yet are proficient for translocation and chromosome dimer resolution. Non-directed FtsK translocation leads to a small reduction in fitness in otherwise normal cell populations, as a consequence of ∼70% of chromosome dimers being resolved to monomers. More serious consequences arise when chromosome dimer formation is increased, or their resolution efficiency is impaired because of defects in chromosome organization and processing. For example, when Cre– loxP recombination replaces XerCD– dif recombination in dimer resolution, when functional MukBEF is absent, or when replication terminates away from ter .     

Validation of bacterial replication termination models using simulation of genomic mutations

In bacterial circular chromosomes and most plasmids, the replication is known to be terminated when either of the following occurs: the forks progressing in opposite directions meet at the distal end of the chromosome or the replication forks become trapped by Tus proteins bound to Ter sites. Most bacterial genomes have various polarities in their genomic structures. The most notable feature is polar genomic compositional asymmetry of the bases G and C in the leading and lagging strands, called GC skew. This asymmetry is caused by replication-associated mutation bias, and this "footprint" of the replication machinery suggests that, in contrast to the two known mechanisms, replication termination occurs near the chromosome dimer resolution site dif. To understand this difference between the known replication machinery and genomic compositional bias, we undertook a simulation study of genomic mutations, and we report here how different replication termination models contribute to the generation of replication-related genomic compositional asymmetry. Contrary to naive expectations, our results show that a single finite termination site at dif or at the GC skew shift point is not sufficient to reconstruct the genomic compositional bias as observed in published sequences. The results also show that the known replication mechanisms are sufficient to explain the position of the GC skew shift point.     

Cell cycle regulation in the hyperthermophilic crenarchaeon Sulfolobus acidocaldarius

The regulation and co-ordination of the cell cycle of the hyperthermophilic crenarchaeon Sulfolobus acidocaldarius was investigated with antibiotics. We provide evidence for a core regulation involving alternating rounds of chromosome replication and genome segregation. In contrast, multiple rounds of replication of the chromosome could occur in the absence of an intervening cell division event. Inhibition of the elongation stage of chromosome replication resulted in cell division arrest, indicating that pathways similar to checkpoint mechanisms in eukaryotes, and the SOS system of bacteria, also exist in archaea. Several antibiotics induced cell cycle arrest in the G2 stage. Analysis of the run-out kinetics of chromosome replication during the treatments allowed estimation of the minimal rate of replication fork movement in vivo to 250 bp s-1. An efficient method for the production of synchronized Sulfolobus populations by transient daunomycin treatment is presented, providing opportunities for studies of cell cycle-specific events. Possible targets for the antibiotics are discussed, including topoisomerases and protein glycosylation.     

XerCD/dif位点特异性重组

大约10%~15%的大肠杆菌在染色体复制过程中会形成染色体二聚体。大肠杆菌染色体编码的重组酶XerC和XerD作用于染色体复制终点区的dif序列,以同源重组的方式将染色体二聚体解离为单体,使细菌得以正常复制分裂。编码霍乱毒素的噬菌体CTXΦ以位点特异的方式整合入霍乱弧菌染色体,但其基因组中不含有任何重组酶基因,其整合过程需要细菌染色体编码的XerC和XerD重组酶,且整合位点与大肠杆菌dif序列相似。XerCD重组酶基因和dif位点在细菌染色体广泛存在,表明其可能是染色体二聚体解离,噬菌体及其他外源基因成分整合入染色体过程中一种广泛存在的途径。文章对XerCD/dif位点特异性重组在细菌染色体二聚体解离、外源基因整合的研究进展进行综述。     

Polarization of the Escherichia coli chromosome. A view from the terminus

The E. coli chromosome replication arms are polarized by motifs such as RRNAGGGS oligomers, found preferentially on leading strands. Their skew increases regularly from the origin to dif (the site in the center of the terminus where chromosome dimer resolution occurs), to reach a value of 90% near dif. Convergent information indicates that polarization in opposite directions from the dif region controls tightly the activity of dif, probably by orienting mobilization of the terminus at cell division. Another example of polarization is the presence, in the region peripheral to the terminus, of small non-divisible zones whose inversion interferes with spatial separation of sister nucleoids. The two phenomena may contribute to the organization of the Ter macrodomain.     

Site-specific recombination in the replication terminus region of Escherichia coli: functional replacement of dif.

The replication terminus region of the Escherichia coli chromosome encodes a locus, dif, that is required for normal chromosome segregation at cell division. dif is a substrate for site-specific recombination catalysed by the related chromosomally encoded recombinases XerC and XerD. It has been proposed that this recombination converts chromosome multimers formed by homologous recombination back to monomers in order that they can be segregated prior to cell division. Strains mutant in dif, xerC or xerD share a characteristic phenotype, containing a variable fraction of filamentous cells with aberrantly positioned and sized nucleoids. We show that the only DNA sequences required for wild-type dif function in the terminus region of the chromosome are contained within 33 bp known to bind XerC and XerD and that putative active site residues of the Xer recombinases are required for normal chromosome segregation. We have also shown that recombination by the loxP/Cre system of bacteriophage P1 will suppress the phenotype of a dif deletion strain when loxP is inserted in the terminus region. Suppression of the dif deletion phenotype did not occur when either dif/Xer or loxP/Cre recombination acted at other positions in the chromosome close to oriC or within lacZ, indicating that site-specific recombination must occur within the replication terminus region in order to allow normal chromosome segregation.     

Prophage lambda induces terminal recombination in Escherichia coli by inhibiting chromosome dimer resolution. An orientation-dependent cis-effect lending support to bipolarization of the terminus

A prophage lambda inserted by homologous recombination near dif, the chromosome dimer resolution site of Escherichia coli, is excised at a frequency that depends on its orientation with respect to dif. In wild-type cells, terminal hyper- (TH) recombination is prophage specific and undetectable by a test involving deletion of chromosomal segments between repeats identical to those used for prophage insertion. TH recombination is, however, detected in both excision and deletion assays when Deltadif, xerC, or ftsK mutations inhibit dimer resolution: lack of specialized resolution apparently results in recombinogenic lesions near dif. We also observed that the presence near dif of the prophage, in the orientation causing TH recombination, inhibits dif resolution activity. By its recombinogenic effect, this inhibition explains the enhanced prophage excision in wild-type cells. The primary effect of the prophage is probably an alteration of the dimer resolution regional control, which requires that dif is flanked by suitably oriented (polarized) stretches of DNA. Our model postulates that the prophage inserted near dif in the deleterious orientation disturbs chromosome polarization on the side of the site where it is integrated, because lambda DNA, like the chromosome, is polarized by sequence elements. Candidate sequences are oligomers that display skewed distributions on each oriC-dif chromosome arm and on lambda DNA.