The distribution of the effects of genes affecting quantitative traits in livestock

Meta-analysis of information from quantitative trait loci (QTL) mapping experiments was used to derive distributions of the effects of genes affecting quantitative traits. The two limitations of such information, that QTL effects as reported include experimental error, and that mapping experiments can only detect QTL above a certain size, were accounted for. Data from pig and dairy mapping experiments were used. Gamma distributions of QTL effects were fitted with maximum likelihood. The derived distributions were moderately leptokurtic, consistent with many genes of small effect and few of large effect. Seventeen percent and 35% of the leading QTL explained 90% of the genetic variance for the dairy and pig distributions respectively. The number of segregating genes affecting a quantitative trait in dairy populations was predicted assuming genes affecting a quantitative trait were neutral with respect to fitness. Between 50 and 100 genes were predicted, depending on the effective population size assumed. As data for the analysis included no QTL of small effect, the ability to estimate the number of QTL of small effect must inevitably be weak. It may be that there are more QTL of small effect than predicted by our gamma distributions. Nevertheless, the distributions have important implications for QTL mapping experiments and Marker Assisted Selection (MAS). Powerful mapping experiments, able to detect QTL of 0.1σ_p, will be required to detect enough QTL to explain 90% the genetic variance for a quantitative trait.     

Linkage between quantitative trait loci and marker loci: resolution power of three statistical approaches in single marker analysis

This paper presents a comparison of three methods of parameter estimation in analysis of linkage between a quantitative trait locus (QTL) and a marker locus: maximum likelihood, mean square for trait cumulative distribution function, and method of moments, employing simulated backcross data. The sensitivity of estimates to violation of assumptions of normality and equal variances were also studied. Some measures of discrepancy between the trait distributions in the QTL groups are considered to evaluate the potential dependence of the resolution capacity of the QTL substitution effect with respect to trait mean value and variance.     

Mapping and Analysis of Dairy Cattle Quantitative Trait Loci by Maximum Likelihood Methodology Using Milk Protein Genes as Genetic Markers

Maximum likelihood methodology was used to estimate effects of both a marker gene and a linked quantitative trait locus (QTL) on quantitative traits in a segregating population. Two alleles were assumed for the QTL. In addition to the effects of genotypes at both loci on the mean of the quantitative trait, recombination frequency between the loci, frequency of the QTL alleles and the residual standard deviation were also estimated. Thus six parameters were estimated in addition to the marker genotype means. The statistical model was tested on simulated data, and used to estimate direct and linked effects of the milk protein genes, β-lactoglobulin, κcasein, and β-casein, on milk, fat, and protein production and fat and protein percent in the Dutch dairy cattle population. β-Lactoglobulin had significant direct effects on milk yield and fat percent. κ-Casein had significant direct effects on milk yield, protein percent and fat yield. β-Casein had significant direct effects on milk yield, fat and protein percent and fat and protein yield. Linked QTL with significant effects on fat percent were found for κ-casein and β-casein. Since the β-casein and κ-casein genes are closely linked, it is likely that the same QTL was detected for those two markers. Further, a QTL with a significant effect on fat yield was found to be linked to κ-casein and a QTL with a significant effect on protein yield was linked to β-lactoglobulin.     

Genetic mapping of QTLs controlling vegetative propagation in Eucalyptus grandis and E. urophylla using a pseudo-testcross strategy and RAPD markers

We have extended the combined use of the “pseudo-testcross” mapping strategy and RAPD markers to map quantitative trait loci (QTLs) controlling traits related to vegetative propagation in Eucalyptus. QTL analyses were performed using two different interval mapping approaches, MAPMAKER-QTL (maximum likelihood) and QTL-STAT (non-linear least squares). A total of ten QTLs were detected for micropropagation response (measured as fresh weight of shoots, FWS), six for stump sprouting ability (measured as # stump sprout cuttings, #Cutt) and four for rooting ability (measured as % rooting of cuttings, %Root). With the exception of three QTLs, both interval-mapping methods yielded similar results in terms of QTL detection. Discrepancies in the most likely QTL location were observed between the two methods. In 75% of the cases the most likely position was in the same, or in an adjacent, interval. Standardized gene substitution effects for the QTLs detected were typically between 0.46 and 2.1 phenotypic standard deviations (σ_p), while differences between the family mean and the favorable QTL genotype were between 0.25 and 1.07 (σ_p). Multipoint estimates of the total genetic variation explained by the QTLs (89.0% for FWS, 67.1 % for#Cutt, 62.7% for %Root) indicate that a large proportion of the variation in these traits is controlled by a relatively small number of major-effect QTLs. In this cross, E. grandis is responsible for most of the inherited variation in the ability to form shoots, while E. urophylla contributes most of the ability in rooting. QTL mapping in the pseudo-testcross configuration relies on withinfamily linkage disequilibrium to establish marker/trait associations. With this approach QTL analysis is possible in any available full-sib family generated from undomesticated and highly heterozygous organisms such as forest trees. QTL mapping on two-generation pedigrees opens the possibility of using already existing families in retrospective QTL analyses to gather the quantitative data necessary for marker-assisted tree breeding.     

Methods for multiple-marker mapping of quantitative trait loci in half-sib populations

In this paper we consider the detection of individual loci controlling quantitative traits of interest (quantitative trait loci or QTLs) in the large half-sib family structure found in some species. Two simple approaches using multiple markers are proposed, one using least squares and the other maximum likelihood. These methods are intended to provide a relatively fast screening of the entire genome to pinpoint regions of interest for further investigation. They are compared with a more traditional single-marker least-squares approach. The use of multiple markers is shown to increase power and has the advantage of providing an estimate for the location of the QTL. The maximum-likelihood and the least-squares approaches using multiple markers give similar power and estimates for the QTL location, although the likelihood approach also provides estimates of the QTL effect and sire heterozygote frequency. A number of assumptions have been made in order to make the likelihood calculations feasible, however, and computationally it is still more demanding than the least-squares approach. The least-squares approach using multiple markers provides a fast method that can easily be extended to include additional effects.     

Methodology and Accuracy of Estimation of Quantitative Trait Loci Parameters in a Half-Sib Design Using Maximum Likelihood

Maximum likelihood methods were developed for estimation of the six parameters relating to a marker-linked quantitative trait locus (QTL) segregating in a half-sib design, namely the QTL additive effect, the QTL dominance effect, the population mean, recombination between the marker and the QTL, the population frequency of the QTL alleles, and the within-family residual variance. The method was tested on simulated stochastic data with various family structures under two genetic models. A method for predicting the expected value of the likelihood was also derived and used to predict the lower bound sampling errors of the parameter estimates and the correlations between them. It was found that standard errors and confidence intervals were smallest for the population mean and variance, intermediate for QTL effects and allele frequency, and highest for recombination rate. Correlations among standard errors of the parameter estimates were generally low except for a strong negative correlation (r = -0.9) between the QTL's dominance effect and the population mean, and medium positive and negative correlations between the QTL's additive effect and, respectively, recombination rate (r = 0.5) and residual variance (r = -0.6). The implications for experimental design and method of analysis on power and accuracy of marker-QTL linkage experiments were discussed.     

Inference of genome-wide mutation rates and distributions of mutation effects for fitness traits: a simulation study.

The properties and limitations of maximum likelihood (ML) inference of genome-wide mutation rates (U) and parameters of distributions of mutation effects are investigated. Mutation parameters are estimated from simulated experiments in which mutations randomly accumulate in inbred lines. ML produces more accurate estimates than the procedure of Bateman and Mukai and is more robust if the data do not conform to the model assumed. Unbiased ML estimates of the mutation effects distribution parameters can be obtained if a value for U can be assumed, but if U is estimated simultaneously with the distribution parameters, likelihood may increase monotonically as a function of U. If the distribution of mutation effects is leptokurtic, the number of mutation events per line is large, or if genotypic values are poorly estimated, only a lower limit for U, an upper limit for the mean mutation effect, and a lower limit for the kurtosis of the distribution can be given. It is argued that such lower (upper) limits are appropriate minima (maxima). Estimates of the mean mutational effect are unbiased but may convey little about the properties of the distribution if it is leptokurtic.     

Maximum likelihood vs. minimum chi-square--a general comparison with applications to the estimation of recombination fractions in two-point linkage analysis.

Some relationships between the estimates of recombination fraction in two-point linkage analysis obtained by maximum likelihood, minimum chi-square, and general least squares are derived. These theoretical results are based on an approximation for the multinomial distribution. Applications (theoretical and experimental) with RFLP (restriction fragment length polymorphism) markers for a segregating F2 population are given. The minimum chi-square estimate is slightly larger than the maximum likelihood estimate. For applications, however, both estimates must be considered to be approximately equal. The least squares estimates are slightly different (larger or smaller) from these estimates.     

Derivation of the shrinkage estimates of quantitative trait locus effects

The shrinkage estimate of a quantitative trait locus (QTL) effect is the posterior mean of the QTL effect when a normal prior distribution is assigned to the QTL. This note gives the derivation of the shrinkage estimate under the multivariate linear model. An important lemma regarding the posterior mean of a normal likelihood combined with a normal prior is introduced. The lemma is then used to derive the Bayesian shrinkage estimates of the QTL effects.     

Interval mapping of quantitative trait loci with selective DNA pooling data

Selective DNA pooling is an efficient method to identify chromosomal regions that harbor quantitative trait loci (QTL) by comparing marker allele frequencies in pooled DNA from phenotypically extreme individuals. Currently used single marker analysis methods can detect linkage of markers to a QTL but do not provide separate estimates of QTL position and effect, nor do they utilize the joint information from multiple markers. In this study, two interval mapping methods for analysis of selective DNA pooling data were developed and evaluated. One was based on least squares regression (LS-pool) and the other on approximate maximum likelihood (ML-pool). Both methods simultaneously utilize information from multiple markers and multiple families and can be applied to different family structures (half-sib, F2 cross and backcross). The results from these two interval mapping methods were compared with results from single marker analysis by simulation. The results indicate that both LS-pool and ML-pool provided greater power to detect the QTL than single marker analysis. They also provide separate estimates of QTL location and effect. With large family sizes, both LS-pool and ML-pool provided similar power and estimates of QTL location and effect as selective genotyping. With small family sizes, however, the LS-pool method resulted in severely biased estimates of QTL location for distal QTL but this bias was reduced with the ML-pool.     

Methods for the detection of multiple linked QTL applied to a mixture of full and half sib families

A new multiple trait strategy based on discriminant analysis was studied for efficient detection of linked QTL in outbred sib families, in comparison with a multivariate likelihood technique. The discriminant analysis technique describes the segregation of a linear combination of the traits in a univariate likelihood. This combination is calculated for each pair of positions depending on the inheritance of the pairs of QTL haplotypes in the progeny. The gains in power and accuracy for position estimations of multiple trait methods in grid searches were evaluated in reference to single trait detections of linked QTL. The methods were applied to simulated designs with two correlated traits submitted to various effects from the linked QTL. Multiple trait strategies were generally more powerful and accurate than the single trait technique. Linked QTL were distinguished when they were separated enough to identify informative recombinations: at least two genetic markers and 25 cM between the QTL under the simulated conditions. Except in a particular case, discriminant analysis was at least as powerful as the multivariate technique and its implementation was five times faster. Combining the advantages from both methodologies, we finally propose a complete strategy for rapid and efficient systematic multivariate detections in outbred populations.     

Modelling epistatic effects of embryo and endosperm QTL on seed quality traits

Coordinated expression of embryo and endosperm tissues is required for proper seed development. The coordination among these two tissues is controlled by the interaction between multiple genes expressed in the embryo and endosperm genomes. In this article, we present a statistical model for testing whether quantitative trait loci (QTL) active in different genomes, diploid embryo and triploid endosperm, epistatically affect a trait expressed on the endosperm tissue. The maximum likelihood approach, implemented with the EM algorithm, was derived to provide the maximum likelihood estimates of the locations of embryo- and endosperm-specific QTL and their main effects and epistatic effects. This model was used in a real example for rice in which two QTL, one from the embryo genome and the other from the endosperm genome, exert a significant interaction effect on gel consistency on the endosperm. Our model has successfully detected Waxy, a candidate gene in the embryo genome known to regulate one of the major steps of amylose biosynthesis in the endosperm. This model will have great implications for agricultural and evolutionary genetic research.     

Statistical optimization of parametric accelerated failure time model for mapping survival trait loci

Most existing statistical methods for mapping quantitative trait loci (QTL) are not suitable for analyzing survival traits with a skewed distribution and censoring mechanism. As a result, researchers incorporate parametric and semi-parametric models of survival analysis into the framework of the interval mapping for QTL controlling survival traits. In survival analysis, accelerated failure time (AFT) model is considered as a de facto standard and fundamental model for data analysis. Based on AFT model, we propose a parametric approach for mapping survival traits using the EM algorithm to obtain the maximum likelihood estimates of the parameters. Also, with Bayesian information criterion (BIC) as a model selection criterion, an optimal mapping model is constructed by choosing specific error distributions with maximum likelihood and parsimonious parameters. Two real datasets were analyzed by our proposed method for illustration. The results show that among the five commonly used survival distributions, Weibull distribution is the optimal survival function for mapping of heading time in rice, while Log-logistic distribution is the optimal one for hyperoxic acute lung injury.     

Comparing analysis methods for mutation-accumulation data: a simulation study

We simulated single-generation data for a fitness trait in mutation-accumulation (MA) experiments, and we compared three methods of analysis. Bateman-Mukai (BM) and maximum likelihood (ML) need information on both the MA lines and control lines, while minimum distance (MD) can be applied with or without the control. Both MD and ML assume gamma-distributed mutational effects. ML estimates of the rate of deleterious mutation had larger mean square error (MSE) than MD or BM had due to large outliers. MD estimates obtained by ignoring the mean decline observed from comparison to a control are often better than those obtained using that information. When effects are simulated using the gamma distribution, reducing the precision with which the trait is assayed increases the probability of obtaining no ML or MD estimates but causes no appreciable increase of the MSE. When the residual errors for the means of the simulated lines are sampled from the empirical distribution in a MA experiment, instead of from a normal one, the MSEs of BM, ML, and MD are practically unaffected. When the simulated gamma distribution accounts for a high rate of mild deleterious mutation, BM detects only approximately 30% of the true deleterious mutation rate, while MD or ML detects substantially larger fractions. To test the robustness of the methods, we also added a high rate of common contaminant mutations with constant mild deleterious effect to a low rate of mutations with gamma-distributed deleterious effects and moderate average. In that case, BM detects roughly the same fraction as before, regardless of the precision of the assay, while ML fails to provide estimates. However, MD estimates are obtained by ignoring the control information, detecting approximately 70% of the total mutation rate when the mean of the lines is assayed with good precision, but only 15% for low-precision assays. Contaminant mutations with only tiny deleterious effects could not be detected with acceptable accuracy by any of the above methods.     

A comparison of bivariate and univariate QTL mapping in livestock populations

This study presents a multivariate, variance component-based QTL mapping model implemented via restricted maximum likelihood (REML). The method was applied to investigate bivariate and univariate QTL mapping analyses, using simulated data. Specifically, we report results on the statistical power to detect a QTL and on the precision of parameter estimates using univariate and bivariate approaches. The model and methodology were also applied to study the effectiveness of partitioning the overall genetic correlation between two traits into a component due to many genes of small effect, and one due to the QTL. It is shown that when the QTL has a pleiotropic effect on two traits, a bivariate analysis leads to a higher statistical power of detecting the QTL and to a more precise estimate of the QTL''s map position, in particular in the case when the QTL has a small effect on the trait. The increase in power is most marked in cases where the contributions of the QTL and of the polygenic components to the genetic correlation have opposite signs. The bivariate REML analysis can successfully partition the two components contributing to the genetic correlation between traits.     

Estimation of Effects of Quantitative Trait Loci in Large Complex Pedigrees

A method was derived to estimate effects of quantitative trait loci (QTL) using incomplete genotype information in large outbreeding populations with complex pedigrees. The method accounts for background genes by estimating polygenic effects. The basic equations used are very similar to the usual linear mixed model equations for polygenic models, and segregation analysis was used to estimate the probabilities of the QTL genotypes for each animal. Method R was used to estimate the polygenic heritability simultaneously with the QTL effects. Also, initial allele frequencies were estimated. The method was tested in a simulated data set of 10,000 animals evenly distributed over 10 generations, where 0, 400 or 10,000 animals were genotyped for a candidate gene. In the absence of selection, the bias of the QTL estimates was <2%. Selection biased the estimate of the Aa genotype slightly, when zero animals were genotyped. Estimates of the polygenic heritability were 0.251 and 0.257, in absence and presence of selection, respectively, while the simulated value was 0.25. Although not tested in this study, marker information could be accommodated by adjusting the transmission probabilities of the genotypes from parent to offspring according to the marker information. This renders a QTL mapping study in large multi-generation pedigrees possible.     

Bayesian QTL mapping using skewed Student-t distributions

In most QTL mapping studies, phenotypes are assumed to follow normal distributions. Deviations from this assumption may lead to detection of false positive QTL. To improve the robustness of Bayesian QTL mapping methods, the normal distribution for residuals is replaced with a skewed Student-t distribution. The latter distribution is able to account for both heavy tails and skewness, and both components are each controlled by a single parameter. The Bayesian QTL mapping method using a skewed Student-t distribution is evaluated with simulated data sets under five different scenarios of residual error distributions and QTL effects.     

Bayesian joint mapping of quantitative trait loci for Gaussian and categorical characters in line crosses

Methodology for joint mapping of quantitative trait loci (QTL) affecting continuous and binary characters in experimental crosses is presented. The procedure consists of a Bayesian Gaussian-threshold model implemented via Markov chain Monte Carlo, which bypasses bottlenecks due to high-dimensional integrals required in maximum likelihood approaches. The method handles multiple binary traits and multiple QTL. Modeling of ordered categorical traits is discussed as well. Features of the method are illustrated using simulated datasets representing a backcross design, and the data are analyzed using mixed-trait and single-trait models. The mixed-trait analysis provides greater detection power of a QTL than a single-trait analysis when the QTL affects two or more traits. The number of QTL inferred in the mixed-trait analysis does not pertain to a specific trait, but the roles of each QTL on specific traits can be assessed from estimates of its effects. The impacts of varying incidence level and sample size on the mixed-trait QTL mapping analysis are investigated as well.     

Estimation of Genotype Distributions and Posterior Genotype Probabilities for β-Mannosidosis in Salers Cattle

β-Mannosidosis is a lethal lysosomal storage disease inherited as an autosomal recessive in man, cattle and goats. Laboratory assay data of plasma β-mannosidase activity represent a mixture of homozygous normal and carrier genotype distributions in a proportion determined by genotype frequency. A maximum likelihood approach employing data transformations for each genotype distribution and assuming a diallelic model of inheritance is described. Estimates of the transformation and genotype distribution parameters, gene frequency, genotype fitness and carrier probability were obtained simultaneously from a sample of 2,812 observations on U.S. purebred Salers cattle with enzyme activity, age, gender, month of pregnancy, month of testing, and parents identified. Transformations to normality were not required, estimated gene and carrier genotype frequencies of 0.074 and 0.148 were high, and the estimated relative fitness of heterozygotes was 1.36. The apparent overdominance in fitness may be due to a nonrandom sampling of progeny genotypes within families. The mean of plasma enzyme activity was higher for males than females, higher in winter months, lower in summer months and decreased with increased age. Estimates of carrier probabilities indicate that the test is most effective when animals are sampled as calves, although effectiveness of the plasma assay was less for males than females. Test effectiveness was enhanced through averaging repeated assays of enzyme activity on each animal. Our approach contributes to medical diagnostics in several ways. Rather than assume underlying normality for the distributions comprising the mixture, we estimate transformations to normality for each genotype distribution simultaneously with all other model parameters. This process also excludes potential biases due to data preadjustment for systematic effects. We also provide a method for partitioning phenotypic variation within each genotypic distribution which allows an assessment of the value of repeat measurements of the predictive variable for genotype assignment.     

Using a mixed effects model to estimate geographic variation in cancer rates

Commonly used methods for depicting geographic variation in cancer rates are based on rankings. They identify where the rates are high and low but do not indicate the magnitude of the rates nor their variability. Yet such measures of variability may be useful in suggesting which types of cancer warrant further analytic studies of localized risk factors. We consider a mixed effects model in which the logarithm of the mean Poisson rate is additive in fixed stratum effects (e.g., age effects) and in logarithms of random relative risk effects associated with geographic areas. These random effects are assumed to follow a gamma distribution with unit mean and variance 1/alpha, similar to Clayton and Kaldor (1987, Biometrics 43, 671-681). We present maximum likelihood and method-of-moments estimates with standard errors for inference on alpha -1/2, the relative risk standard deviation (RRSD). The moment estimates rely on only the first two moments of the Poisson and gamma distributions but have larger standard errors than the maximum likelihood estimates. We compare these estimates with other measures of variability. Several examples suggest that the RRSD estimates have advantages compared to other measures of variability.