A major role for memory CD4 T cells in the control of lymphopenia-induced proliferation of naive CD4 T cells

In a state of lymphopenia, naive and memory CD4 T cells compete with each other for expansion at the expense of naive T cells. This competition prevents the proliferation as well as the phenotypic and functional conversion of naive T cells to "memory-like" T cells and may consequently prevent immune pathology frequently associated with lymphopenia-induced proliferation of naive cells. However, in T cell replete mice, memory T cells do not compete with naive T cells, indicating independent homeostatic control of naive and memory CD4 T cells in conditions that do not involve profound lymphopenia. Moreover, within the memory compartment, subsequent generation of new memory T cells precludes the survival of memory-like T cells. Thus, memory T cells have a major role in the control of lymphopenia-induced proliferation of naive cells because they inhibit both the generation of memory-like T cells and their persistence within the memory compartment.     

Induction of antitumor immune response by homeostatic proliferation and CD28 signaling

Inducing lymphopenia before adoptive cell transfer can improve the antitumor effect of donor immune cells. It was recently reported that lymphopenic conditions can initiate the differentiation of naive T cells into effector cells. Although T cells require a specific "strong" signal via TCR as well as costimulatory signals during Ag-driven differentiation, there has been little evidence to suggest any requirement for costimulatory signaling for the differentiation of naive T cells in a lymphopenic host. In this study, we demonstrate that naive CD8(+) T cells are indispensable for induction of antitumor effect, and, in addition to Ag-driven differentiation, CD28 signaling is essential for the differentiation of naive CD8(+) T cells into functional effector CTLs during homeostatic proliferation (HP). The systemic administration of IL-2 did not restore the antitumor effect induced by HP in the absence of CD28 signaling. These results suggest that homeostatic cytokines enable CD8(+) T cells to expand and survive, and that TCR and the CD28 signal initiate the differentiation of effector functions. A deeper understanding of the mechanisms underlying enhanced induction of the antitumor immune response with accompanying HP may allow us to more precisely induce enhanced immunity with costimulation signaling and the administration of common gamma-chain cytokines.     

Cutting edge: differential self-peptide/MHC requirement for maintaining CD8 T cell function versus homeostatic proliferation

Memory T cells do not require self-peptide/MHC (spMHC) complexes to survive long term in vivo. However, memory CD4 T cells lose the ability to reject skin grafts when transiently placed in an environment in which these low-level TCR stimulations are absent. Whether or not spMHC alters the ability of CD8 T cells to respond to stimulation in vivo remains unknown. Here, we show that memory CD8 T cells retain the ability to respond to dendritic cell-mediated stimulation after adoptive transfer into either TAP(-/-) (MHC class I-deficient) or wild-type mice. Surprisingly, naive CD8 T cells, which fail to undergo homeostatic proliferation and erode in number in the absence of MHC class I, also retain the ability to respond to dendritic cell-mediated antigenic stimulation for at least 1 wk after transfer into TAP(-/-) mice. These findings suggest a differential requirement for spMHC signals for maintenance of CD8 T cell function and homeostatic proliferation.     

Homeostatic proliferation of lymphocytes results in augmented memory-like function and accelerated allograft rejection

Homeostatic proliferation is a normal physiological process triggered by lymphopenia to maintain a constant level of T cells. It becomes the predominant source of new T cells in adulthood after thymus regression. T cells that have undergone homeostatic proliferation acquire the memory phenotype, cause autoimmune disease, and are resistant to tolerance induction protocols. Transplantation is a rare example in which lymphopenia is deliberately induced for its immunosuppressive effect. However, it is not known whether the homeostatic proliferation that follows will have the opposite effect and accelerate rejection. We show that T cells that have undergone homeostatic proliferation acquire a memory phenotype, spontaneously skews toward the Th1 phenotype, even in the absence of antigenic stimulus. Interestingly, in contrast, the percentage of Foxp3(+) regulatory T cells increased by 28-fold following homeostatic proliferation. Using a mouse life-sustaining kidney transplant model, we showed that T cells that have gone through homeostatic proliferation in lymphopenic hosts transformed chronic rejection to acute rejection of a single MHC class II-mismatched kidney allograft. T cells that have undergone homeostatic proliferation consistently cause reliable rejection even when bona fide memory T cells cannot. These functional changes are long-lasting and not restricted to the acute phase of homeostatic proliferation. Our findings have important implications for tolerance induction or graft-prolonging protocols involving leukocyte depletion such as irradiation bone marrow chimera, T cell-depleting Abs, and lymphopenia induced by infections such as CMV and HIV.     

Development and homeostasis of T cell memory in rhesus macaque.

The rhesus macaque (RM) is a critical animal model for studies of viral pathogenesis and immunity, yet fundamental aspects of their cellular immune response remain poorly defined. One such deficiency is the lack of validated phenotypic signatures for their naive and memory T cell subsets, and the resultant unavailability of accurate information on their memory T cell development, homeostasis, and function. In this study, we report a phenotypic paradigm allowing definitive characterization of these subsets and their comprehensive functional analysis. Naive T cells are optimally delineated by their homogeneous CD95(low)CD28(high)beta(7) integrin(int) (CD4+) or CD95(low)CD28(int)CD11a(low) (CD8+) phenotypes. This subset 1) was present in blood and secondary lymph tissues, but not effector sites; 2) vastly predominated in the fetal/neonatal immune system, but rapidly diminished with postnatal age; 3) lacked IFN-gamma production capability, and specific responses to RM CMV; and 4) demonstrated low in vivo proliferative activity. CD4+ and CD8+ memory subsets were CD95(high), but otherwise phenotypically heterogeneous and included all IFN-gamma production, RM CMV-specific responses, effector site T cells, and demonstrated high in vivo proliferative activity ( approximately 10 times the naive subset). These analyses also revealed the RM "effector memory" subset within the overall memory population. This population, best defined by lack of CD28 expression, contained the majority of RM CMV-specific cells, was highly enriched in extralymphoid effector sites, and comprised an increasing proportion of total memory cells with age. The effector memory subset demonstrated similar in vivo proliferative activity and survival as CD28+ "central memory" T cells, consistent with independent homeostatic regulation.     

Effector T cell differentiation and memory T cell maintenance outside secondary lymphoid organs

Naive T cell circulation is restricted to secondary lymphoid organs. Effector and memory T cells, in contrast, acquire the ability to migrate to nonlymphoid tissues. In this study we examined whether nonlymphoid tissues contribute to the differentiation of effector T cells to memory cells and the long-term maintenance of memory T cells. We found that CD4, but not CD8, effector T cell differentiation to memory cells is impaired in adoptive hosts that lack secondary lymphoid organs. In contrast, established CD4 and CD8 memory T cells underwent basal homeostatic proliferation in the liver, lungs, and bone marrow, were maintained long-term, and functioned in the absence of secondary lymphoid organs. CD8 memory T cells found in nonlymphoid tissues expressed both central and effector memory phenotypes, whereas CD4 memory T cells displayed predominantly an effector memory phenotype. These findings indicate that secondary lymphoid organs are not necessary for the maintenance and function of memory T cell populations, whereas the optimal differentiation of CD4 effectors to memory T cells is dependent on these organs. The ability of memory T cells to persist and respond to foreign Ag independently of secondary lymphoid tissues supports the existence of nonlymphoid memory T cell pools that provide essential immune surveillance in the periphery.     

Homeostatic proliferation in the mice with germline FoxP3 mutation and its contribution to fatal autoimmunity

FoxP3 has emerged as a critical regulator for the development and function of regulatory T cells. Recent studies by several groups have demonstrated that FoxP3 is expressed outside T cell lineages. In this context, we have reported that germline mutation of FoxP3 caused defective thymopoiesis, although its potential contribution to autoimmune diseases has not been analyzed. In this study, we report that, during perinatal period, germline mutation of FoxP3 in scurfy mice caused lymphopenia in the spleen and massive homeostatic proliferation, characterized by the independence from cognate Ags and expression of bona fide markers for homeostatic proliferation. The homeostatic proliferation is suppressed by increases in T cell numbers but not by adoptive transfer of regulatory T cells (Treg). Adoptive transfer of Treg-containing bulk T cells was dramatically more effective than transfer of either Treg alone or Treg-depleted CD4 T cells in curing the scurfy mice. Our data demonstrated that FoxP3 mutation not only ablates Treg, but also dramatically increased homeostatic proliferation during the perinatal period. Homeostatic proliferation acts in concert with Treg defects in causing acute and fatal autoimmune diseases in the FoxP3 mutant mice. These results demonstrated that germline mutation of FoxP3 caused two defects that work in concert to cause lethal autoimmunity.     

Accelerated memory cell homeostasis during T cell depletion and approaches to overcome it

Partial T cell depletion is used in solid organ transplantation as a valuable strategy of peritransplant induction immunosuppression. Using a murine cardiac allograft model, we recently demonstrated that this led to lymphopenia-induced (homeostatic) proliferation among the residual nondepleted lymphocytes. Rather than promoting tolerance, peritransplant T cell-depleting Abs actually resulted in resistance to tolerance induction by costimulatory blockade. In this study we show that memory T cells predominate shortly after subtotal lymphodepletion due to two distinct mechanisms: relative resistance to depletion and enhanced homeostatic proliferation. In contrast, regulatory cells (CD4+ CD25+ Foxp3+) are depleted as efficiently as nonregulatory cells and exhibit reduced homeostatic expansion compared with memory cells. The resistance to tolerance induction seen with subtotal T cell depletion can be overcome in two different ways: first, by the adoptive transfer of additional unprimed regulatory cells at the time of transplant, and second, by the adjunctive use of nondepleting anti-CD4 and anti-CD8 mAbs, which effectively block homeostatic expansion. We conclude that the resistance to tolerance induction seen after subtotal lymphocyte depletion can be attributed to alterations in the balance of naive, memory, and regulatory T cells. These data have clinically relevant implications related to the development of novel strategies to overcome resistance to tolerance.     

Generation and growth of CD28nullCD8+ memory T cells mediated by IL-15 and its induced cytokines

Accumulation of CD28(null)CD8+ T cells and the defects of these cells in response to antigenic stimulation are the hallmarks of age-associated decline of T cell function. However, the mechanism of these age-associated changes is not fully understood. In this study, we report an analysis of the growth of human CD28(null) and CD28+CD8+ memory T cells in response to homeostatic cytokine IL-15 in vitro. We showed that 1) there was no proliferative defect of CD28(null)CD8+ memory T cells in response to IL-15 compared with their CD28+ counterparts; 2) stable loss of CD28 expression occurred in those actively dividing CD28+CD8+ memory T cells responding to IL-15; 3) the loss of CD28 was in part mediated by TNF-alpha that was induced by IL-15; and 4) CCL4 (MIP-1beta), also induced by IL-15, had a significant inhibitory effect on the growth of CD28(null) cells, which in turn down-regulated their expression of CCL4 receptor CCR5. Together, these findings demonstrate that CD28(null)CD8+ memory T cells proliferate normally in response to IL-15 and that IL-15 and its induced cytokines regulate the generation and growth of CD28(null)CD8+ T cells, suggesting a possible role of IL-15 in the increase in CD28(null)CD8+ T cells that occurs with aging.     

Dynamics and requirements of T cell clonal expansion in vivo at the single-cell level: effector function is linked to proliferative capacity

The adoptive transfer of TCR-transgenic T cells into syngeneic recipients allows characterization of individual T cells during in vivo immune responses. However, the proliferative behavior of individual T cells and its relationship to effector and memory function has been difficult to define. Here, we used a fluorescent dye to dissect and quantify T cell proliferative dynamics in vivo. We find that the average Ag-specific CD4+ T cell that undergoes division in vivo generates >20 daughter cells. TCR and CD28 signals cooperatively determine the degree of primary clonal expansion by increasing both the proportion of Ag-specific T cells that divide and the number of rounds of division the responding T cells undergo. Nonetheless, despite optimal signaling, up to one-third of Ag-specific cells fail to divide even though they show phenotypic evidence of Ag encounter. Surprisingly, however, transgenic T cells maturing on a RAG-2-/- background exhibit a responder frequency of 95-98% in vivo, suggesting that maximal proliferative potential requires either a naive phenotype or allelic exclusion at the TCRalpha locus. Finally, studies reveal division cycle-dependent expression of markers of T cell differentiation, such as CD44, CD45RB, and CD62L, and show also that expression of the cytokines IFN-gamma and IL-2 depends primarily on cell division rather than on receipt of costimulatory signals. These results provide a quantitative assessment of T cell proliferation in vivo and define the relationship between cell division and other parameters of the immune response including cytokine production, the availability of costimulation, and the capacity for memory.     

Spontaneous and homeostatic proliferation of CD4 T cells are regulated by different mechanisms

Transfer of naive CD4 T cells into lymphopenic mice initiates a proliferative response of the transferred cells, often referred to as homeostatic proliferation. Careful analysis reveals that some of the transferred cells proliferate rapidly and undergo robust differentiation to memory cells, a process we have designated spontaneous proliferation, and other cells proliferate relatively slowly and show more limited evidence of differentiation. In this study we report that spontaneous proliferation is IL-7 independent, whereas the slow proliferation (referred to as homeostatic proliferation) is IL-7 dependent. Administration of IL-7 induces homeostatic proliferation of naive CD4 T cells even within wild-type recipients. Moreover, the activation/differentiation pattern of the two responses are clearly distinguishable, indicating that different activation mechanisms may be involved. Our results reveal the complexity and heterogeneity of lymphopenia-driven T cell proliferation and suggest that they may have fundamentally distinct roles in the maintenance of CD4 T cell homeostasis.     

Induction of CD4 T cell changes in murine AIDS is dependent on costimulation and involves a dysregulation of homeostasis

Strong CD4 T cell activation and proliferation are seen in susceptible mice infected with the murine retroviral inoculum, LP-BM5, which produces an immunodeficiency syndrome called murine AIDS (MAIDS). We developed a short term adoptive transfer model of MAIDS to examine the requirements for the CD4 T cell response. Naive CD4 T cells from uninfected donors responded quickly after adoptive transfer into MAIDS-infected hosts, becoming activated and proliferating within several days. Using blocking mAbs to costimulatory ligands and CD4 T cells deficient in expression of their receptors, we found that the CD4 T cell response requires CD28:B7.1/B7.2 interactions, but not CTLA4 or CD40-CD40 ligand interactions. Naive CD4 T cells did not respond in H-2M-deficient mice with MAIDS, suggesting that disease requires recognition of self peptide-MHC complexes. The self MHC-dependent division and accumulation of large numbers of CD4 T cells suggest that MAIDS involves a disruption of the balance of homeostatic signals. Supporting this hypothesis, CD4 T cells from mice with MAIDS failed to regulate the homeostatic division of naive CD4 T cells in a cotransfer model. Thus, a combination of up-regulation of costimulatory ligands and disruption of homeostatic control may be responsible for CD4 lymphoproliferation in MAIDS.     

The dual role of IL-2 in the generation and maintenance of CD8+ memory T cells

The mechanisms responsible for the generation and maintenance of T cell memory are unclear. In this study, we tested the role of IL-2 in allospecific CD8+ T cell memory by analyzing the long-term survival, phenotype, and functional characteristics of IL-2-replete (IL-2+/+) and IL-2-deficient (IL-2-/-) CD8+ TCR-transgenic lymphocytes in an adoptive transfer model. We found that IL-2 is not essential for the in vivo generation, maintenance, or recall response of CD8+ memory T cells. However, IL-2 increased the size of the CD8+ memory pool if present at the time of initial T cell activation but reduced the size of the pool if present during memory maintenance by inhibiting the proliferation of CD8+ memory T cells. Thus, IL-2-based vaccine strategies or immunosuppressive regimens that target IL-2 should take into account the divergent roles of IL-2 in CD8+ T cell immunity.     

IL-15 is required for sustained lymphopenia-driven proliferation and accumulation of CD8 T cells

Naive T cells undergo slow homeostatic proliferation in response to T cell lymphopenia, which is also called lymphopenia-induced proliferation (LIP). IL-7 is critically required for this process, but previous studies suggested IL-15 was expendable for LIP of naive CD8 T cells. In contrast, we show that IL-15 is important for sustained CD8 T cell proliferation and accumulation in a lymphopenic setting, as revealed by truncated LIP in IL-15(-/-) hosts. At the same time, we find that IL-12 enhances LIP by acting directly on the CD8 T cells and independently of IL-15, suggesting distinct pathways by which cytokines can regulate homeostatic proliferation. Interestingly, the memory-phenotype CD8 T cell generated by LIP in IL-15(-/-) hosts are phenotypically distinct from the rare endogenous memory-phenotype cells found in IL-15(-/-) animals, suggesting these cells are generated by different means. These findings demonstrate that cytokine requirements for LIP change during the process itself, illustrating the need to identify factors that regulate successive stages of lymphopenia-driven proliferation.     

Homeostatic expansion occurs independently of costimulatory signals.

Naive T cells undergo homeostatic proliferation in lymphopenic mice, a process that involves TCR recognition of specific self peptide/MHC complexes. Since costimulation signals regulate the T cell response to foreign Ags, we asked whether they also regulate homeostatic expansion. We report in this study that homeostatic expansion of CD4 and CD8 T cells occurs independently of costimulation signals mediated through CD28/B7, CD40L/CD40, or 4-1BB/4-1BBL interactions. Using DO11.10 TCR transgenic T cells, we confirmed that CD28 expression was dispensable for homeostatic expansion, and showed that the presence of endogenous CD4(+)CD25(+) regulatory cells did not detectably influence homeostatic expansion. The implications of these findings with respect to regulation of T cell homeostasis and autoimmunity are discussed.     

Cutting edge: naive T cells masquerading as memory cells

This study shows that naive CD8 T cells can acquire characteristics of memory T cells in the absence of stimulation with specific Ag simply by the process of homeostatic proliferation under lymphopenic conditions. This Ag-independent T cell differentiation pathway did not result in up-regulation of early activation markers (CD69, CD25, CD71), but expression of several memory markers (CD44, CD122, Ly6C) increased progressively with successive divisions. These markers were then stably expressed, and these cells also became more responsive functionally to specific Ag. Thus, all "memory" phenotype T cells in an individual may not be true Ag-experienced cells and may include naive cells masquerading as memory cells. These findings are specially relevant in cases of disease or treatment-induced lymphopenia such as in HIV-infected individuals or transplant recipients. In addition, this study may have implications for autoimmunity because homeostatic proliferation of naive T cells requires interaction with self peptide plus MHC molecules.     

Phosphodiesterase 7A1 is expressed in human CD4+ naïve T cells at higher levels than in CD4+ memory cells and is not required during their CD3/CD28-dependent activation

PDE7A1 is a cAMP-hydrolyzing phosphodiesterase expressed in lymphoid tissue, where its possible role during T cell activation remains unclear. We have characterized the functional relevance of PDE7A1 in the na?ve (CD4+CD45RA+) and memory (CD4+CD45RO+) subsets of human peripheral CD4+ T cells during CD3/CD28-dependent stimulation. Our results indicate that PDE7A1 is expressed in resting na?ve CD4+ T cells at higher levels than in the corresponding memory cells and that levels of PDE7A1 mRNA are not upregulated upon CD3/CD28 mediated stimulation of these T cell subsets. Treatment with a selective inhibitor of PDE7A1 does not impair CD3/CD28 induced activation of na?ve or memory CD4+ T cells, nor does it increase intracellular cAMP in CD4+ T cells. We conclude that PDE7A1 is not required during CD3/CD28-dependent activation of na?ve and memory CD4+ T cells, but cannot rule out other regulatory roles of PDE7A1 during maturation of CD4+ T cells.     

Role of CD28-B7 interactions in generation and maintenance of CD8 T cell memory.

Although the role of CD28-B7 interaction in the activation of naive T cells is well established, its importance in the generation and maintenance of T cell memory is not well understood. In this study, we examined the requirement for CD28-B7 interactions in primary T cell activation and immune memory. Ag-specific CD8 T cell responses were compared between wild-type (+/+) and CD28-deficient (CD28(-/-)) mice following an acute infection with lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV). During the primary response, there was a substantial activation and expansion of LCMV-specific CD8 T cells in both +/+ and CD28(-/-) mice. However, the magnitude of the primary CD8 T cell response to both dominant and subdominant LCMV CTL epitopes was approximately 2- to 3-fold lower in CD28(-/-) mice compared with +/+ mice; the lack of CD28-mediated costimulation did not lead to preferential suppression of CD8 T cell responses to the weaker subdominant epitopes. As seen in CD28(-/-) mice, blockade of B7-mediated costimulation by CTLA4-Ig treatment of +/+ mice also resulted in a 2-fold reduction in the anti-LCMV CD8 T cell responses. Loss of CD28/B7 interactions did not significantly affect the generation and maintenance of CD8 T cell memory; the magnitude of CD8 T cell memory was approximately 2-fold lower in CD28(-/-) mice as compared with +/+ mice. Further, in CD28(-/-) mice, LCMV-specific memory CD8 T cells showed normal homeostatic proliferation in vivo and also conferred protective immunity. Therefore, CD28 signaling is not necessary for the proliferative renewal and maintenance of memory CD8 T cells.     

Homeostatic proliferation as an isolated variable reverses CD8+ T cell anergy and promotes tumor rejection

Although recent work has suggested that lymphopenia-induced homeostatic proliferation may improve T cell-mediated tumor rejection, there is little direct evidence isolating homeostatic proliferation as an experimental variable, and the mechanism by which improved antitumor immunity occurs via homeostatic proliferation is poorly understood. An adoptive transfer model was developed in which tumor-specific 2C/RAG2(-/-) TCR transgenic CD8+ T cells were introduced either into the lymphopenic environment of RAG2(-/-) mice or into P14/RAG2(-/-) mice containing an irrelevant CD8+ TCR transgenic population. RAG2(-/-), but not P14/RAG2(-/-) recipients supported homeostatic proliferation of transferred T cells as well as tumor rejection. Despite absence of tumor rejection in P14/RAG2(-/-) recipients, 2C cells did become activated, as reflected by CFSE dilution and CD44 up-regulation. However, these cells showed poor IFN-gamma and IL-2 production upon restimulation, consistent with T cell anergy and similar to the hyporesponsiveness induced by administration of soluble peptide Ag. To determine whether homeostatic proliferation could uncouple T cell anergy, anergic 2C cells were transferred into RAG(-/-) recipients, which resulted in vigorous homeostatic proliferation, recovery of IL-2 production, and acquisition of the ability to reject tumors. Taken together, our data suggest that a major mechanism by which homeostatic proliferation supports tumor rejection is by maintaining and/or re-establishing T cell responsiveness.     

CD8+CD28- T cells: certainties and uncertainties of a prevalent human T-cell subset

Human peripheral blood CD8+ T cells comprise cells that are in different states of differentiation and under the control of complex homeostatic processes. In a number of situations ranging from chronic inflammatory conditions and infectious diseases to ageing, immunodeficiency, iron overload and heavy alcohol intake, major phenotypic changes, usually associated with an increase in CD8+ T cells lacking CD28 expression, take place. CD8+CD28- T cells are characterized by a low proliferative capacity to conventional stimulation in vitro and by morphological and functional features of activated/memory T cells. Although the nature of the signals that give origin to this T-cell subset is uncertain, growing evidence argues for the existence of an interplay between epithelial cells, molecules with the MHC-class I fold and CD8+ T cells. The possibility that the generation of CD8+CD28- T cells is the combination of TCR/CD3zeta- and regulatory factor-mediated signals as a result of the sensing of modifications of the internal environment is discussed.