Automatic analysis of silver-stained comets by CellProfiler software

The comet assay is one of the most widely used methods to evaluate DNA damage and repair in eukaryotic cells. The comets can be measured by software, in a semi-automatic or automatic process. In this paper, we apply the CellProfiler open-source software for automatic analysis of comets from digitized images, reporting the percentage of tail DNA. A side-by-side comparison of CellProfiler with CASP software demonstrated good agreement between the two packages. Our work demonstrates that automatic measurement of silver-stained comets with open-source software is possible, providing significant time savings.     

Comprehensive profiling of radiosensitive human cell lines with DNA damage response assays identifies the neutral comet assay as a potential surrogate for clonogenic survival

In an effort to explore the possible causes of human radiosensitivity and identify more rapid assays for cellular radiosensitivity, we interrogated a set of assays that evaluate cellular functions involved in recognition and repair of DNA double-strand breaks: (1) neutral comet assay, (2) radiation-induced γ-H2AX focus formation, (3) the temporal kinetics of structural maintenance of chromosomes 1 phosphorylation, (4) intra-S-phase checkpoint integrity, and (5) mitochondrial respiration. We characterized a unique panel of 19 "radiosensitive" human lymphoblastoid cell lines from individuals with undiagnosed diseases suggestive of a DNA repair disorder. Radiosensitivity was defined by reduced cellular survival using a clonogenic survival assay. Each assay identified cell lines with defects in DNA damage response functions. The highest concordance rate observed, 89% (17/19), was between an abnormal neutral comet assay and reduced survival by the colony survival assay. Our data also suggested that the neutral comet assay would be a more rapid surrogate for analyzing DNA repair/processing disorders.     

Laser scanning cytometry for comet assay analysis

BACKGROUND: The comet assay (single-cell gel electrophoresis) is a sensitive method for evaluating nuclear DNA damage. Previously used evaluation methods for the comet assay are time consuming and have an inherent risk of biased selection of comets due to manual selection and categorization of comet images. Laser scanning cytometry (LSC), the principle of which is equivalent to flow cytometry, enables quantification of fluorescence emitted from the cells on a microscope slide. In the present study, we explored whether LSC could be used to determine the degree of DNA damage demonstrated by the comet assay. METHODS: DNA damage was induced by ultraviolet A irradiation of keratinocytes and visualized by the comet assay. The evaluation included (a) LSC determination of DNA-specific fluorescence in 1,000 comet heads (undamaged DNA), (b) image acquisition of comets by rescanning of the microscope slide, and (c) digital image analysis and computation of tail moment and DNA content in the comet tails. RESULTS: Cells with damaged DNA were observed in a sub-G(1) area because the comet head loses DNA to the tail. We found a strong inverse correlation between tail moment and DNA content per nucleus. CONCLUSIONS: LSC enables an automated method for cell recognition and evaluation of the comets, thus providing quantitative information about nuclear DNA damage without subjective selection of analyzed comets.     

A modified alkaline comet assay for measuring DNA repair capacity in human populations

Trzeciak, A. R., Barnes, J. and Evans, M. K. A Modified Alkaline Comet Assay for Measuring DNA Repair Capacity in Human Populations. Radiat. Res. 169, 110-121 (2008). Use of the alkaline comet assay to assess DNA repair capacity in human populations has been limited by several factors, including lack of methodology for use of unstimulated cryopreserved peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs), insufficient control of interexperimental variability, and limited analysis of DNA repair kinetics. We show that unstimulated cryopreserved PBMCs can be used in DNA repair studies performed using the comet assay. We have applied data standardization for the analysis of DNA repair capacity using negative and positive internal standards as controls for interexperimental variability. Our standardization procedure also uses negative controls, which provides a way to minimize the interference of interindividual variation in baseline DNA damage levels on DNA repair capacity measurements in populations. DNA repair capacity was assessed in a small human cohort using the parameters described in the literature including initial DNA damage, half-time of DNA repair, and residual DNA damage after 30 and 60 min. We have also introduced new DNA repair capacity parameter, initial rate of DNA repair. There was no difference in DNA repair capacity between fresh and cryopreserved PBMCs when measured by the Olive tail moment and tail DNA. The use of DNA repair capacity parameters in assessment of fast and slow single-strand break repair components is discussed.     

Optimization of the alkaline comet assay for easy repair capacity quantification of oxidative DNA damage in PBMC from human volunteers using aphidicolin block

Assessment of DNA repair capacity (DRC) upon ex vivo challenge of peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) with oxidative damage inducing agents, as evaluated by the comet assay, is widely used as biomarker to assess the antioxidant status in human studies. Here, the alkaline comet assay was now optimized for easy and time saving detection of repair capacity upon oxidative stress-induced DNA damage using the DNA polymerase inhibitor aphidicolin (APC) to block repair of hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) induced DNA damage. Addition of a DMSO-containing DNA damage stop solution was found suitable to replace washing steps for H₂O₂ removal before APC block. Cell treatment with APC at 6 μM did not impact baseline DNA damage but could reliably block DNA repair after H₂O₂ challenge in both fresh and cryopreserved samples thus omitting the use of a starting time point control. Under the conditions used, frozen cells, with or without an additional 4 h rest, showed the same repair capacity as their fresh counterpart. The intra assay coefficient of variation (CV) was 3.3%. To provide proof of principle, the modified assay was applied to cryopreserved PBMC from 19 participants of a short-term Brassica diet intervention study investigating potential health promoting effects of the food intervention. Then, a 33% increase in DRC (p ≤ 0.01) could be shown in samples after intervention (mean ± SD: 5.82 ± 1) as compared to baseline (mean ± SD: 4.38 ± 1.21). Individual samples from baseline and intervention showed an inter-individual CV of 27.65% (baseline) and 17.26% (intervention). Taken together this modified comet assay protocol allows the facilitated detection of DNA repair in fresh or cryopreserved human PBMC samples with a good sensitivity and reliability and could be useful in human studies addressing the antioxidant status and repair capacity of PBMC.     

Assaying DNA Damage in Hippocampal Neurons Using the Comet Assay

A number of drugs target the DNA repair pathways and induce cell kill by creating DNA damage. Thus, processes to directly measure DNA damage have been extensively evaluated. Traditional methods are time consuming, expensive, resource intensive and require replicating cells. In contrast, the comet assay, a single cell gel electrophoresis assay, is a faster, non-invasive, inexpensive, direct and sensitive measure of DNA damage and repair. All forms of DNA damage as well as DNA repair can be visualized at the single cell level using this powerful technique.The principle underlying the comet assay is that intact DNA is highly ordered whereas DNA damage disrupts this organization. The damaged DNA seeps into the agarose matrix and when subjected to an electric field, the negatively charged DNA migrates towards the cathode which is positively charged. The large undamaged DNA strands are not able to migrate far from the nucleus. DNA damage creates smaller DNA fragments which travel farther than the intact DNA. Comet Assay, an image analysis software, measures and compares the overall fluorescent intensity of the DNA in the nucleus with DNA that has migrated out of the nucleus. Fluorescent signal from the migrated DNA is proportional to DNA damage. Longer brighter DNA tail signifies increased DNA damage. Some of the parameters that are measured are tail moment which is a measure of both the amount of DNA and distribution of DNA in the tail, tail length and percentage of DNA in the tail. This assay allows to measure DNA repair as well since resolution of DNA damage signifies repair has taken place. The limit of sensitivity is approximately 50 strand breaks per diploid mammalian cell ^1,2. Cells treated with any DNA damaging agents, such as etoposide, may be used as a positive control. Thus the comet assay is a quick and effective procedure to measure DNA damage.     

DNA damage and repair in lymphocytes of normal individuals and cancer patients: studies by the comet assay and micronucleus tests

A population study is reported in which the DNA damage induced by g-radiation (2 Gy) and the kinetics of the subsequent repair were estimated by the comet and micronucleus assays in isolated lymphocytes of 82 healthy donors and patients with head and neck cancer before radiotherapy. The parameters of background and radiation-induced DNA damage, rate of repair, and residual non-repaired damage were measured by comet assay, and the repair kinetics for every donor were computer-fitted to an exponential curve. The level of background DNA damage before irradiation measured by comet assay as well as the level of micronuclei were significantly higher in the head and neck cancer patient group than in the healthy donors, while the parameters of repair were widely scattered in both groups. Cancer patient group contained significantly more individuals, whose irradiated lymphocytes showed high DNA damage, low repair rate and high non-repaired DNA damage level. Lymphocytes of donors belonging to this subgroup showed significantly lower inhibition of cell cycle after irradiation.     

Investigating oxidative DNA damage and its repair using the comet assay

The comet assay is not the only way to measure oxidative DNA damage, but it is one of the most sensitive and accurate, being relatively free of artefacts. It is a valuable tool in population monitoring, for example in assessing the role of oxidative stress in human disease, and in monitoring the effects of dietary antioxidants. A simple modification allows the measurement of DNA repair. In combination with the analysis of polymorphisms in relevant genes, the comet assay - especially when adapted for analysis of large numbers of samples - can provide important information on the interactions between genetic variation and environmental factors in maintaining genome stability.     

Validation of an automatic comet assay analysis system integrating the curve fitting of combined comet intensity profiles.

In recent years, the single-cell gel electrophoresis (comet) assay has become a reference technique for the assessment of DNA fragmentation both in vitro and in vivo at the cellular level. In order to improve the throughput of genotoxicity screening, development of fully automated systems is clearly a must. This would allow us to increase processing time and to avoid subjectivity brought about by frequent manual settings required for the 'classical' analysis systems. To validate a fully automatic system developed in our laboratory, different experiments were conducted in vitro on murine P388D1 cells with increasing doses of ethyl methanesulfonate (up to 5 mM), thus covering a large range of DNA damage (up to 80% of DNA in the tail). The present study (1) validates our 'in house' fully automatic system versus a widely used semi-automatic commercial system for the image-analysis step, and versus the human eye for the image acquisition step, (2) shows that computing tail DNA a posteriori on the basis of a curve fitting concept that combines intensity profiles [G. Dehon, P. Bogaerts, P. Duez, L. Catoire, J. Dubois, Curve fitting of combined comet intensity profiles: a new global concept to quantify DNA damage by the comet assay, Chemom. Intell. Lab. Syst. 73 (2004) 235-243] gives results not significantly different from the 'classical' approach but is much more accurate and easy to undertake and (3) demonstrates that, with these increased performances, the number of comets to be scored can be reduced to a minimum of 20 comets per slide without sacrificing statistical reliability.     

Comet assay: rapid processing of multiple samples

The present study describes modifications to the basic comet protocol that increase productivity and efficiency without sacrificing assay reliability. A simple technique is described for rapidly preparing up to 96 comet assay samples simultaneously. The sample preparation technique allows thin layers of agarose-embedded cells to be prepared in multiple wells attached to a flexible film of Gelbond, which improves the ease of manipulating and processing samples. To evaluate the effect of these modifications on assay sensitivity, dose-response curves are presented for DNA damage induced by exposure of TK6 cells to low concentrations of hydrogen peroxide (0-10 microM) and for exposure of human lymphocytes to X-irradiation (0-100 cGy). The limit of detection of DNA damage induced by hydrogen peroxide in TK6 cells was observed to be 1 uM for all parameters (tail ratio, tail moment, tail length and comet length) while the limit of detection of DNA damage in human lymphocytes was 10 cGy for tail and comet length parameters, but 50 cGy for tail ratio and tail moment parameters. These results are similar to those previously reported using the conventional alkaline comet assay. The application of SYBR Gold for detection of DNA damage was compared to that of propidium iodide. Measurements of matching samples for tail length and comet length were similar using both stains. However, comets stained with SYBR Gold persisted longer and were much brighter than those obtained with propidium iodide. SYBR Gold was found to be ideal for measuring tail length and comet length but, under present assay conditions, impractical for measuring tail ratio or tail moment due to saturation of staining in the head region of the comets.     

Assessment of DNA damage in peripheral blood of heavy smokers with the comet assay and the micronucleus test

The comet assay (single-cell gel electrophoresis, SCG) is being increasingly used in human biomonitoring for the detection of genotoxic exposures. Cigarette smoking is a well-documented source of a variety of potentially mutagenic and carcinogenic compounds. Therefore, smoking should represent a relevant mutagenic exposure and lead to genotoxic effects in exposed cells. However, our previous investigations as well as several other published studies on human biomonitoring failed to show an effect of smoking on DNA migration in the comet assay, while some other studies did indicate such an effect. Although many factors can contribute to the generation of discrepant results in such studies, clear effects should be obtained after high exposure. We therefore performed a comparative study with healthy male heavy smokers (>20 cigarettes per day) and non-smokers (n=12 in each group). We measured the baseline comet assay effects in fresh whole blood samples and isolated lymphocytes. In addition, the amount of 'formamidopyrimidine DNA-glycosylase (FPG)-sensitive sites' was determined by a combination of the standard comet assay with the bacterial FPG protein. Furthermore, the influence of a repair inhibitor (aphidicolin, APC) on baseline DNA damage was comparatively analysed. Duplicate slides from each sample were processed and analysed separately. In all experiments, a reference standard (untreated V79 cells) was included to correct for assay variability. Finally, to compare the comet assay results with another genetic endpoint, all blood samples were investigated in parallel by the micronucleus test (MNT). Baseline and gamma radiation-induced micronucleus frequencies were determined. None of these approaches revealed a significant difference between heavy smokers and non-smokers with regard to a genotoxic effect in peripheral blood cells.     

Tail profile: a more accurate system for analyzing DNA damage using the Comet assay

The Comet assay (single cell gel electrophoresis assay) measures DNA strand breaks in individual cells. In the assay cells are embedded in agarose, lysed, and electrophoresed under low voltage, allowing migration of damaged DNA. The DNA is stained and subsequently viewed with an epifluorescent microscope. If DNA damage has occurred the electrophoresed DNA fragments appear as a diffuse tail behind the nucleus known as a "comet". Many computer-aided analysis systems are currently in use to quantify the amount of DNA damage that is represented by a comet image. Here, we present a novel method of analysis known as "tail profile". This method of analysis provides several advantages over currently employed methods, which rely primarily on the "tail moment" method of analysis. We compared the amount of DNA damage reported from both the tail profile and tail moment methods of analysis and observed a 26% (P<0.0001) increase in damage detected by tail profile across the 10-25 microm range of tail length, where the majority of the relevant comet data is concentrated. We further report that this increase in sensitivity is not only limited to assessing DNA damage, but also to gathering data from DNA repair assays. Furthermore, we demonstrate increased functionality and extended data analysis capabilities with the use of a compressed collection of images called a "comet chip" and through a visual representation of data called a "profile plot". Use of the custom macros enabled us to detect an unexpected characteristic of the electrophoretic profile, giving us novel insight into the nature of comet analysis. In addition to the increased analytical sensitivity proffered by this system, the tail profile macros are upgradeable and platform independent.     

In vitro detection of indirect-acting genotoxins in the comet assay using Hep G2 cells

The induction of DNA damage by four known promutagens (cyclophosphamide (CP), benzo(a)pyrene (BP), dimethylbenz(a)anthracene and 2-acetylaminofluorene (2AAF) was investigated on Hep G2 using the alkaline single cell electroporesis (SCGE) test, most often referred as the "comet assay". After a 3-day incubation, lysed cells embedded in agarose were electrophoresed under alkaline conditions, dyed with a SYBRgold fluorogen and analysed by the Komet software. Among the comet parameters provided by the image analysis program, statistical analysis did not identify any in particular that could best represent the DNA damages. All promutagens, when compared with the control, caused a statistically significant increase in DNA migration as determined by different parameters such as Olive tail moment, tail extent moment, tail/head or tail length. The data demonstrated the ability and the sensitivity of the comet assay when performed on Hep G2 in the detection of DNA damage induced by promutagens, and its suitability in mutagenicity testing in in vitro short-term assays.     

DNA damage and repair in human peripheral blood lymphocytes following treatment with microcystin-LR

The purpose of this study was to find a possible explanation of the inconsistency of data regarding the genotoxicity of microcystin-LR (MC-LR). We compared the results of the comet assay with the results of the analysis of chromosome aberrations and apoptosis. In order to investigate the influence of MC-LR on DNA damage in human lymphocytes, cells were treated with MC-LR at different concentrations (1, 10 and 25 microg/ml) for 6, 12, 18 and 24 h. Analyses of Olive Tail Moment (OTM) as an indicator of DNA damage showed that MC-LR treatment induced DNA damage in a time-dependent manner, reaching its maximum after 18 h. The lowest values of OTM were observed after 24 h. MC-LR had no effect on the frequency of chromosome aberrations in lymphocytes. Since some data available in the literature indicate that apoptosis may lead to overestimated or false positive results regarding the genotoxicity of mutagens in the comet assay, we measured the frequency of late apoptotic cells by use of the comet assay and the frequency of early apoptotic cells with the TUNEL method. The comet assay results revealed that the highest level of apoptosis was observed after 24 h and the lowest after 18 h. The comparison of the frequency of apoptotic cells determined by the comet assay with DNA damage (OTM) examined by the comet assay revealed a statistically significant, negative correlation. The TUNEL results showed that the frequency of apoptotic cells progressively increased in a dose- and time-dependent manner. The comparison of the frequency of apoptotic cells determined by TUNEL method with DNA damage (OTM) examined by the comet assay showed a significant positive correlation for lymphocytes treated with MC-LR for 6, 12 and 18 h. Therefore, our findings indicate that microcystin-LR-induced DNA damage observed in the comet assay may be related to the early stages of apoptosis due to cytotoxicity but not genotoxicity. In addition, we examined the DNA repair kinetics in lymphocytes following treatment with microcystin-LR and ionizing radiation. Our results indicate that MC-LR has an inhibiting effect on the repair of radiation-induced damage.     

New Application of the Comet Assay: Chromosome�CComet Assay

The comet assay is a well-established, simple, versatile, visual, rapid, and sensitive tool used extensively to assess DNA damage and DNA repair quantitatively and qualitatively in single cells. The comet assay is most frequently used to analyze white blood cells or lymphocytes in human biomonitoring studies, although other cell types have been examined, including buccal, nasal, epithelial, and placental cells and even spermatozoa. This study was conducted to design a protocol that can be used to generate comets in subnuclear units, such as chromosomes. The new technique is based on the chromosome isolation protocols currently used for whole chromosome mounting in electron microscopy, coupled to the alkaline variant of the comet assay, to detect DNA damage. The results show that migrant DNA fragments can be visualized in whole nuclei and isolated chromosomes and that they exhibit patterns of DNA migration that depend on the level of DNA damage produced. This protocol has great potential for the highly reproducible study of DNA damage and repair in specific chromosomal domains.     

The comet assay for DNA damage and repair

The comet assay (single-cell gel electrophoresis) is a simple method for measuring deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) strand breaks in eukaryotic cells. Cells embedded in agarose on a microscope slide are lysed with detergent and high salt to form nucleoids containing supercoiled loops of DNA linked to the nuclear matrix. Electrophoresis at high pH results in structures resembling comets, observed by fluorescence microscopy; the intensity of the comet tail relative to the head reflects the number of DNA breaks. The likely basis for this is that loops containing a break lose their supercoiling and become free to extend toward the anode. The assay has applications in testing novel chemicals for genotoxicity, monitoring environmental contamination with genotoxins, human biomonitoring and molecular epidemiology, and fundamental research in DNA damage and repair. The sensitivity and specificity of the assay are greatly enhanced if the nucleoids are incubated with bacterial repair endonucleases that recognize specific kinds of damage in the DNA and convert lesions to DNA breaks, increasing the amount of DNA in the comet tail. DNA repair can be monitored by incubating cells after treatment with damaging agent and measuring the damage remaining at intervals. Alternatively, the repair activity in a cell extract can be measured by incubating it with nucleoids containing specific damage.     

Validation of an automatic comet assay analysis system integrating the curve fitting of combined comet intensity profiles

In recent years, the single-cell gel electrophoresis (comet) assay has become a reference technique for the assessment of DNA fragmentation both in vitro and in vivo at the cellular level.In order to improve the throughput of genotoxicity screening, development of fully automated systems is clearly a must. This would allow us to increase processing time and to avoid subjectivity brought about by frequent manual settings required for the ‘classical’ analysis systems.To validate a fully automatic system developed in our laboratory, different experiments were conducted in vitro on murine P388D1 cells with increasing doses of ethyl methanesulfonate (up to 5 mM), thus covering a large range of DNA damage (up to 80% of DNA in the tail). The present study (1) validates our ‘in house’ fully automatic system versus a widely used semi-automatic commercial system for the image-analysis step, and versus the human eye for the image acquisition step, (2) shows that computing tail DNA a posteriori on the basis of a curve fitting concept that combines intensity profiles [G. Dehon, P. Bogaerts, P. Duez, L. Catoire, J. Dubois, Curve fitting of combined comet intensity profiles: a new global concept to quantify DNA damage by the comet assay, Chemom. Intell. Lab. Syst. 73 (2004) 235–243] gives results not significantly different from the ‘classical’ approach but is much more accurate and easy to undertake and (3) demonstrates that, with these increased performances, the number of comets to be scored can be reduced to a minimum of 20 comets per slide without sacrificing statistical reliability.     

Assessment of DNA damage in multiple organs of mice after whole body X-irradiation using the comet assay

The comet assay was performed to elucidate the linearity of calibration curves and detection limits for DNA damage in multiple organs of whole body X-irradiated mice, and rates of reduction in DNA damage by DNA repair during the irradiation period were estimated in the respective organs by comparing the rates of increase in DNA damage at different absorbed dose rates of X-rays. Of the assay parameters, tail length and the percentage DNA in the tail showed a higher sensitivity to DNA damage in most organs than Olive tail moment. Data at the higher absorbed dose rates (2.22 or 1.44 Gy/min) showed good correlations between absorbed doses and these two parameters, with correlation coefficients of more than 0.7 in many organs. However, this assay had difficulty detecting DNA damage at the lower absorption dose rate (0.72 Gy/min). The estimated rates of increase in DNA damage and those of DNA repair during the irradiation period in the respective organs suggested differences in the radiosensitivity of nuclear DNA and DNA repair capacity among organs. Our results indicated that absorbed dose rates of 1.0-1.3 Gy/min or greater were needed to induce detectable DNA damages by the comet assay in many organs.     

Assessment of DNA damage in multiple organs of mice after whole body X-irradiation using the comet assay

The comet assay was performed to elucidate the linearity of calibration curves and detection limits for DNA damage in multiple organs of whole body X-irradiated mice, and rates of reduction in DNA damage by DNA repair during the irradiation period were estimated in the respective organs by comparing the rates of increase in DNA damage at different absorbed dose rates of X-rays. Of the assay parameters, tail length and the percentage DNA in the tail showed a higher sensitivity to DNA damage in most organs than Olive tail moment. Data at the higher absorbed dose rates (2.22 or 1.44 Gy/min) showed good correlations between absorbed doses and these two parameters, with correlation coefficients of more than 0.7 in many organs. However, this assay had difficulty detecting DNA damage at the lower absorption dose rate (0.72 Gy/min). The estimated rates of increase in DNA damage and those of DNA repair during the irradiation period in the respective organs suggested differences in the radiosensitivity of nuclear DNA and DNA repair capacity among organs. Our results indicated that absorbed dose rates of 1.0–1.3 Gy/min or greater were needed to induce detectable DNA damages by the comet assay in many organs.