B- and C-RAF display essential differences in their binding to Ras: the isotype-specific N terminus of B-RAF facilitates Ras binding

Recruitment of RAF kinases to the plasma membrane was initially proposed to be mediated by Ras proteins via interaction with the RAF Ras binding domain (RBD). Data reporting that RAF kinases possess high affinities for particular membrane lipids support a new model in which Ras-RAF interactions may be spatially restricted to the plane of the membrane. Although the coupling features of Ras binding to the isolated RAF RBD were investigated in great detail, little is known about the interactions of the processed Ras with the functional and full-length RAF kinases. Here we present a quantitative analysis of the binding properties of farnesylated and nonfarnesylated H-Ras to both full-length B- and C-RAF in the presence and absence of lipid environment. Although isolated RBD fragments associate with high affinity to both farnesylated and nonfarnesylated H-Ras, the full-length RAF kinases revealed fundamental differences with respect to Ras binding. In contrast to C-RAF that requires farnesylated H-Ras, cytosolic B-RAF associates effectively and with significantly higher affinity with both farnesylated and nonfarnesylated H-Ras. To investigate the potential farnesyl binding site(s) we prepared several N-terminal fragments of C-RAF and found that in the presence of cysteine-rich domain only the farnesylated form of H-Ras binds with high association rates. The extreme N terminus of B-RAF turned out to be responsible for the facilitation of lipid independent Ras binding to B-RAF, since truncation of this region resulted in a protein that changed its kinase properties and resembles C-RAF. In vivo studies using PC12 and COS7 cells support in vitro results. Co-localization measurements using labeled Ras and RAF documented essential differences between B- and C-RAF with respect to association with Ras. Taken together, these data suggest that the activation of B-RAF, in contrast to C-RAF, may take place both at the plasma membrane and in the cytosolic environment.     

Single substitution within the RKTR motif impairs kinase activity but promotes dimerization of RAF kinase

The serine/threonine kinase RAF is a central component of the MAPK cascade. Regulation of RAF activity is highly complex and involves recruitment to membranes and association with Ras and scaffold proteins as well as multiple phosphorylation and dephosphorylation events. Previously, we identified by molecular modeling an interaction between the N-region and the RKTR motif of the kinase domain in RAF and assigned a new function to this tetrapeptide segment. Here we found that a single substitution of each basic residue within the RKTR motif inhibited catalytic activity of all three RAF isoforms. However, the inhibition and phosphorylation pattern of C-RAF and A-RAF differed from B-RAF. Furthermore, substitution of the first arginine led to hyperphosphorylation and accumulation of A-RAF and C-RAF in plasma membrane fraction, indicating that this residue interferes with the recycling process of A-RAF and C-RAF but not B-RAF. In contrast, all RAF isoforms behave similarly with respect to the RKTR motif-dependent dimerization. The exchange of the second arginine led to exceedingly increased dimerization as long as one of the protomers was not mutated, suggesting that substitution of this residue with alanine may result in similar a structural rearrangement of the RAF kinase domain, as has been found for the C-RAF kinase domain co-crystallized with a dimerization-stabilizing RAF inhibitor. In summary, we provide evidence that each of the basic residues within the RKTR motif is indispensable for correct RAF function.     

Elimination of B-RAF in Oncogenic C-RAF-expressing Alveolar Epithelial Type II Cells Reduces MAPK Signal Intensity and Lung Tumor Growth

Tumors are often greatly dependent on signaling cascades promoting cell growth or survival and may become hypersensitive to inactivation of key components within these signaling pathways. Ras and RAF mutations found in human cancer confer constitutive activity to these signaling molecules thereby converting them into an oncogenic state. RAF dimerization is required for normal Ras-dependent RAF activation and is required for the oncogenic potential of mutant RAFs. Here we describe a new mouse model for lung tumor development to investigate the role of B-RAF in oncogenic C-RAF-mediated adenoma initiation and growth. Conditional elimination of B-RAF in C-RAF BxB-expressing embryonic alveolar epithelial type II cells did not block adenoma formation. However, loss of B-RAF led to significantly reduced tumor growth. The diminished tumor growth upon B-RAF inactivation was due to reduced cell proliferation in absence of senescence and increased apoptosis. Furthermore, B-RAF elimination inhibited C-RAF BxB-mediated activation of the mitogenic cascade. In line with these data, mutation of Ser-621 in C-RAF BxB abrogated in vitro the dimerization with B-RAF and blocked the ability to activate the MAPK cascade. Taken together these data indicate that B-RAF is an important factor in oncogenic C-RAF-mediated tumorigenesis.     

The tumor suppressor DiRas3 forms a complex with H-Ras and C-RAF proteins and regulates localization, dimerization, and kinase activity of C-RAF

The maternally imprinted Ras-related tumor suppressor gene DiRas3 is lost or down-regulated in more than 60% of ovarian and breast cancers. The anti-tumorigenic effect of DiRas3 is achieved through several mechanisms, including inhibition of cell proliferation, motility, and invasion, as well as induction of apoptosis and autophagy. Re-expression of DiRas3 in cancer cells interferes with the signaling through Ras/MAPK and PI3K. Despite intensive research, the mode of interference of DiRas3 with the Ras/RAF/MEK/ERK signal transduction is still a matter of speculation. In this study, we show that DiRas3 associates with the H-Ras oncogene and that activation of H-Ras enforces this interaction. Furthermore, while associated with DiRas3, H-Ras is able to bind to its effector protein C-RAF. The resulting multimeric complex consisting of DiRas3, C-RAF, and active H-Ras is more stable than the two protein complexes H-Ras·C-RAF or H-Ras·DiRas3, respectively. The consequence of this complex formation is a DiRas3-mediated recruitment and anchorage of C-RAF to components of the membrane skeleton, suppression of C-RAF/B-RAF heterodimerization, and inhibition of C-RAF kinase activity.     

Farnesylation of Ras is important for the interaction with phosphoinositide 3-kinase gamma.

The correct functioning of Ras proteins requires post-translational modification of the GTP hydrolases (GTPases). These modifications provide hydrophobic moieties that lead to the attachment of Ras to the inner side of the plasma membrane. In this study we investigated the role of Ras processing in the interaction with various putative Ras-effector proteins. We describe a specific, GTP-independent interaction between post-translationally modified Ha- and Ki-Ras4B and the G-protein responsive phosphoinositide 3-kinase p110gamma. Our data demonstrate that post-translational processing increases markedly the binding of Ras to p110gamma in vitro and in Sf9 cells, whereas the interaction with p110alpha is unaffected under the same conditions. Using in vitro farnesylated Ras, we show that farnesylation of Ras is sufficient to produce this effect. The complex of p110gamma and farnesylated RasGTP exhibits a reduced dissociation rate leading to the efficient shielding of the GTPase from GTPase activating protein (GAP) action. Moreover, Ras processing affects the dissociation rate of the RasGTP complex with the Ras binding domain (RBD) of Raf-1, indicating that processing induces alterations in the conformation of RasGTP. The results suggest a direct interaction between a moiety present only on fully processed or farnesylated Ras and the putative target protein p110gamma.     

Survival signaling by C-RAF: mitochondrial reactive oxygen species and Ca2+ are critical targets

Survival signaling by RAF occurs through largely unknown mechanisms. Here we provide evidence for the first time that RAF controls cell survival by maintaining permissive levels of mitochondrial reactive oxygen species (ROS) and Ca(2+). Interleukin-3 (IL-3) withdrawal from 32D cells resulted in ROS production, which was suppressed by activated C-RAF. Oncogenic C-RAF decreased the percentage of apoptotic cells following treatment with staurosporine or the oxidative stress-inducing agent tert-butyl hydroperoxide. However, it was also the case that in parental 32D cells growing in the presence of IL-3, inhibition of RAF signaling resulted in elevated mitochondrial ROS and Ca(2+) levels. Cell death is preceded by a ROS-dependent increase in mitochondrial Ca(2+), which was absent from cells expressing transforming C-RAF. Prevention of mitochondrial Ca(2+) overload after IL-3 deprivation increased cell viability. MEK was essential for the mitochondrial effects of RAF. In summary, our data show that survival control by C-RAF involves controlling ROS production, which otherwise perturbs mitochondrial Ca(2+) homeostasis.     

Unique N-region determines low basal activity and limited inducibility of A-RAF kinase: the role of N-region in the evolutionary divergence of RAF kinase function in vertebrates

In mammals the RAF family of serine/threonine kinases consists of three members, A-, B-, and C-RAF. A prominent feature of RAF isoforms regards differences in basal and inducible kinase activities. To elucidate the nature of these differences, we studied the role of the nonconserved residues within the N-region (Negative-charge regulatory region). The nonconserved amino acids in positions -3 and +1 relative to the highly conserved serine 299 in A-RAF and serine 338 in C-RAF have so far not been considered as regulatory residues. Here we demonstrate the essential role of these residues in the RAF activation process. Substitution of tyrosine 296 in A-RAF to arginine led to a constitutively active kinase. In contrast, substitution of glycine 300 by serine (mimicking B- and C-RAF) acts in an inhibitory manner. Consistent with these data, the introduction of glycine in the analogous position of C-RAF (S339G mutant) led to a constitutively active C-RAF kinase. Based on the three-dimensional structure of the catalytic domain of B-RAF and using the sequences of the N-regions of A- and C-RAF, we searched by molecular modeling for the putative contact points between these two moieties. A tight interaction between the N-region residue serine 339 of C-RAF and arginine 398 of the catalytic domain was identified and proposed to inhibit the kinase activity of RAF proteins, because abrogation of this interaction contributes to RAF activation. Furthermore, tyrosine 296 in A-RAF favors a spatial orientation of the N-region segment, which enables a tighter contact to the catalytic domain, whereas a glutamine residue at this position in C-RAF abrogates this interaction. Considering this observation, we suggest that tyrosine 296, which is unique for A-RAF, is a major determinant of the low activating potency of this RAF isoform.     

Activation kinetics of RAF protein in the ternary complex of RAF, RAS-GTP, and kinase on the plasma membrane of living cells: single-molecule imaging analysis

RAS is an important cell signaling molecule, regulating the activities of various effector proteins, including the kinase c-RAF (RAF). Despite the critical function of RAS signaling, the activation kinetics have not been analyzed experimentally in living cells for any of the RAS effectors. Here, we analyzed the kinetics of RAF activation on the plasma membrane in living HeLa cells after stimulation with EGF to activate RAS. RAF is recruited by the active form of RAS (RAS-GTP) from the cytoplasm to the plasma membrane through two RAS-binding sites (the RAS-binding domain and the cysteine-rich domain (CRD)) and is activated by its phosphorylation by still undetermined kinases on the plasma membrane. Using single-molecule imaging, we measured the dissociation time courses of GFP-tagged molecules of wild type RAF and fragments or mutants of RAF containing one or two of the three functional domains (the RAS-binding domain, the CRD, and the catalytic domain) to determine their interaction with membrane components. Each molecule showed a unique dissociation time course, indicating that both its interaction with RAS-GTP and its phosphorylation by the kinases are rate-limiting steps in RAF activation. Based on our experimental results, we propose a kinetic model for the activation of RAF. The model suggests the importance of the interaction between RAS-GTP and CRD for the effective activation of RAF, which is triggered by rapid RAS-GTP-induced conformational changes in RAF and the subsequent presentation of RAF to the kinase. The model also suggests necessary properties of the kinases that activate RAF.     

Isoform-specific interaction of C-RAF with mitochondria

The proteins of the RAF family (A-RAF, B-RAF, and C-RAF) are serine/threonine kinases that play important roles in development, mature cell regulation, and cancer. Although it is widely held that their localization on membranes is an important aspect of their function, there are few data that address this aspect of their mode of action. Here, we report that each member of the RAF family exhibits a specific distribution at the level of cellular membranes and that C-RAF is the only isoform that directly targets mitochondria. We found that the RAF kinases exhibit intrinsic differences in terms of mitochondrial affinity and that C-RAF is the only isoform that binds this organelle efficiently. This affinity is conferred by the C-RAF amino-terminal domain and does not depend on the presence of RAS GTPases on the surface of mitochondria. Finally, we analyzed the consequences of C-RAF activation on mitochondria and observed that this event dramatically changes their morphology and their subcellular distribution. Our observations indicate that: (i) RAF kinases exhibit different localizations at the level of cellular membranes; (ii) C-RAF is the only isoform that directly binds mitochondria; and (iii) through its functional coupling with MEK, C-RAF regulates the shape and the cellular distribution of mitochondria.     

Mechanism of activation of the RAF-ERK signaling pathway by oncogenic mutations of B-RAF

Over 30 mutations of the B-RAF gene associated with human cancers have been identified, the majority of which are located within the kinase domain. Here we show that of 22 B-RAF mutants analyzed, 18 have elevated kinase activity and signal to ERK in vivo. Surprisingly, three mutants have reduced kinase activity towards MEK in vitro but, by activating C-RAF in vivo, signal to ERK in cells. The structures of wild type and oncogenic V599EB-RAF kinase domains in complex with the RAF inhibitor BAY43-9006 show that the activation segment is held in an inactive conformation by association with the P loop. The clustering of most mutations to these two regions suggests that disruption of this interaction converts B-RAF into its active conformation. The high activity mutants signal to ERK by directly phosphorylating MEK, whereas the impaired activity mutants stimulate MEK by activating endogenous C-RAF, possibly via an allosteric or transphosphorylation mechanism.     

In-cell single-molecule FRET measurements reveal three conformational state changes in RAF protein

BackgroundThe structures of proteins are intimately related to their functions. Significant efforts have been dedicated to the structural investigation of proteins, mainly those of purified proteins in in vitro environments. Proteins function in living cells and thus protein structures must be regulated by interactions with various molecules, some of which participate in reaction networks, depending on the states, conditions, or actions of the cell. Therefore, it is very important to understand the structural behavior of proteins in living cells.MethodsSingle-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer (smFRET) measurements were conducted using the alternative laser excitation (ALEX) technique. smFRET distributions of cytosolic Rapidly Accelerated Fibrosarcoma (RAF) proteins in living HeLa cells were obtained with exclusion of the negative effects of photobleached fluorophores and incompletely labeled proteins on smFRET.ResultssmFRET histograms of wildtype (wt) RAF in live cells exhibited two major peaks, whereas that of the S621A mutant, which has been thought to have an expanded structure, was almost single-peaked. A population shift involving the peaks for wt RAF was detected upon epidermal growth factor stimulation. Spontaneous transitions between the conformational states corresponding to the two peaks were also detected using the FRET-two-channel kernel-based density distribution estimator method in comparison to static double-stranded DNA samples.ConclusionsCytosolic CRAF has at least three conformational states; in addition to the closed and open forms, the fully-open form was distinctly specified. Based on the results, we propose a speculative structural model for CRAF.General significanceStructural distribution and changes to proteins in live cells as a result of intracellular interactions were successfully identified. smFRET using ALEX is applicable to any other cytosolic proteins.     

RAF protein-serine/threonine kinases: Structure and regulation

A-RAF, B-RAF, and C-RAF are a family of three protein-serine/threonine kinases that participate in the RAS-RAF-MEK-ERK signal transduction cascade. This cascade participates in the regulation of a large variety of processes including apoptosis, cell cycle progression, differentiation, proliferation, and transformation to the cancerous state. RAS mutations occur in 15-30% of all human cancers, and B-RAF mutations occur in 30-60% of melanomas, 30-50% of thyroid cancers, and 5-20% of colorectal cancers. Activation of the RAF kinases requires their interaction with RAS-GTP along with dephosphorylation and also phosphorylation by SRC family protein-tyrosine kinases and other protein-serine/threonine kinases. The formation of unique side-to-side RAF dimers is required for full kinase activity. RAF kinase inhibitors are effective in blocking MEK1/2 and ERK1/2 activation in cells containing the oncogenic B-RAF Val600Glu activating mutation. RAF kinase inhibitors lead to the paradoxical increase in RAF kinase activity in cells containing wild-type B-RAF and wild-type or activated mutant RAS. C-RAF plays a key role in this paradoxical increase in downstream MEK-ERK activation.     

Positive regulation of A-RAF by phosphorylation of isoform-specific hinge segment and identification of novel phosphorylation sites

In mammals the RAF family of serine/threonine kinases consists of three members, A-, B-, and C-RAF. Activation of RAF kinases involves a complex series of phosphorylations. Although the most prominent phosphorylation sites of B- and C-RAF are well characterized, little is known about regulatory phosphorylation of A-RAF. Using mass spectrometry, we identified here a number of novel in vivo phosphorylation sites in A-RAF. In particular, we found that Ser-432 participates in MEK binding and is indispensable for A-RAF signaling. On the other hand, phosphorylation within the activation segment does not contribute to epidermal growth factor-mediated activation. Furthermore, we show that the potential 14-3-3 binding domains in A-RAF are phosphorylated independently of its activation status. Of importance, we identified a novel regulatory domain in A-RAF (referred to as IH-segment) positioned between amino acids 248 and 267 that contains seven putative phosphorylation sites. Three of these sites, serines 257, 262, and 264, regulate A-RAF activation in a stimulatory manner. The spatial model of the A-RAF fragment, including residues between Ser-246 and Glu-277, revealed a switch of charge at the molecular surface of the IH-region upon phosphorylation, suggesting a mechanism in which the high accumulation of negative charges may lead to an electrostatic destabilization of protein-membrane interaction resulting in depletion of A-RAF from the plasma membrane. Together, we provide here for the first time a detailed analysis of in vivo A-RAF phosphorylation status and demonstrate that regulation of A-RAF by phosphorylation exhibits unique features compared with B- and C-RAF.     

Conformational states of ADP ribosylation factor 1 complexed with different guanosine triphosphates as studied by 31P NMR spectroscopy

Guanine nucleotide binding proteins (GNB-proteins) play an essential role in cellular signaling, acting as molecular switches, cycling between the inactive, GDP-bound form and the active, GTP-bound form. It has been shown that conformational equilibria also exist within the active form of GNB-proteins between conformational states with different functional properties. Here we present (31)P NMR data on ADP ribosylation factor 1 (Arf1), a GNB-protein involved in Golgi traffic, promoting the coating of secretory vesicles. To investigate conformational equilibria in active Arf1, the wild type and switch I mutants complexed with GTP and a variety of commonly used GTP analogues, namely, GppCH(2)p, GppNHp, and GTPγS, were analyzed. To gain deeper insight into the conformational state of active Arf1, we titrated with Cu(2+)-cyclen and GdmCl and formed the complex with the Sec7 domain of nucleotide exchange factor ARNO and an effector GAT domain. In contrast to the related proteins Ras, Ral, Cdc42, and Ran, from (31)P NMR spectroscopic view, Arf1 exists predominantly in a single conformation independent of the GTP analogue used. This state seems to correspond to the so-called state 2(T) conformation, according to Ras nomenclature, which is interacting with the effector domain. The exchange of the highly conserved threonine in position 48 with alanine led to a shift of the equilibrium toward a conformational state with typical properties obtained for state 1(T) in Ras, such as interaction with guanine nucleotide exchange factors, a lower affinity for nucleoside triphosphates, and greater sensitivity to chaotropic agents. In active Arf1(wt), the effector interacting conformation is strongly favored. These intrinsic conformational equilibria of active GNB-proteins could be a fine-tuning mechanism of regulation and thereby an interesting target for the modulation of protein activity.     

Assessment of the bioactive conformation of the farnesyltransferase protein binding recognition motif by computational methods.

Ras farnesyltransferase catalyzes the carboxyl-terminal farnesylation of Ras as well as other proteins involved in signal transduction processes. Previous studies demonstrated that its inhibition suppresses the activity of Ras transformed phenotypes in cultured cells, causing tumor regression in animal models. This observation led to the consideration of farnesyltransferase as a target for cancer therapy. In the present work we report the results of a computational study aimed at assessing the bioactive conformation of the peptide Cys-Val-Phe-Met, known to be the minimum peptide sequence that inhibits farnesyltransferase. For this purpose the conformational preferences of four analogs of the peptide were assessed by means of thorough searches of their respective conformational spaces, using a simulated annealing protocol as sampling technique. Specifically, two active analogs: Cys-Val-Tic-Met and Cys-Val-psi(CH2NH)Tic-Met and two inactive analogs: Cys-Val-Tic-psi(CH2NH)Met and Cys-Val-Aic-Met were selected for the present study. Low energy conformations of the four analogs were classified according to their structural motifs. The putative bioactive conformation of the minimum farnesyltransferase recognition motif was assessed by cross-comparison of the different classes of conformations obtained for the two active and the two inactive analogs. The putative bioactive conformation is characterized by two structural motifs: i) a C14 pseudo-ring stabilized by a hydrogen bond between the amino group of Cys1 and the carboxylate group of Met4 and a C11 pseudo-ring involving the residues Cys1 and Tic3. In addition, the thiol group of Cys1 side chain of the bioactive conformation points to the carboxylate moiety of Met4.     

Crystal structure of M-Ras reveals a GTP-bound "off" state conformation of Ras family small GTPases

Although some members of Ras family small GTPases, including M-Ras, share the primary structure of their effector regions with Ras, they exhibit vastly different binding properties to Ras effectors such as c-Raf-1. We have solved the crystal structure of M-Ras in the GDP-bound and guanosine 5'-(beta,gamma-imido)triphosphate (Gpp(NH)p)-bound forms. The overall structure of M-Ras resembles those of H-Ras and Rap2A, except that M-Ras-Gpp(NH)p exhibits a distinctive switch I conformation, which is caused by impaired intramolecular interactions between Thr-45 (corresponding to Thr-35 of H-Ras) of the effector region and the gamma-phosphate of Gpp(NH)p. Previous 31P NMR studies showed that H-Ras-Gpp(NH)p exists in two interconverting conformations, states 1 and 2. Whereas state 2 is a predominant form of H-Ras and corresponds to the "on" conformation found in the complex with effectors, state 1 is thought to represent the "off" conformation, whose tertiary structure remains unknown. 31P NMR analysis shows that free M-Ras-Gpp(NH)p predominantly assumes the state 1 conformation, which undergoes conformational transition to state 2 upon association with c-Raf-1. These results indicate that the solved structure of M-Ras-Gp-p(NH)p corresponds to the state 1 conformation. The predominance of state 1 in M-Ras is likely to account for its weak binding ability to the Ras effectors, suggesting the importance of the tertiary structure factor in small GTPase-effector interaction. Further, the first determination of the state 1 structure provides a molecular basis for developing novel anti-cancer drugs as compounds that hold Ras in the state 1 "off" conformation.     

Kinetic mechanisms for overexpression insensitivity and oncogene cooperation

Minor (5-10 fold) activation of mitogenic signalling cascades typically induces cell division upon extracellular stimulation and is sufficient to support tumourigenesis when permanently triggered by activating mutations. Surprisingly, even strong signalling protein overexpression usually does not trigger deregulated cell proliferation, suggesting that basal state signalling is insensitive to wildtype protein overexpression. Using kinetic modelling of the core Ras cycle, we show that basal RasGTP signalling can be insensitive to Ras overexpression and thus identify a possible tumour suppression mechanism. We further show how phenotypically silent overexpression events within signalling cascades cooperate to bring about carcinogenesis. Our analyses underscore the need for a systems level understanding of tumour formation.