Virus-specific T-cell sensitization

Syngeneic, semiallogeneic, or allogeneic spleen lymphocytes were transferred intonu/nu BALB/c mice, which were infected with vaccinia virus. Specific Sensitization of transferred thymus-derived cells was determined in vivo by mean survival time and virus titer in the spleen six days after infection, and in vitro by cell-mediated cytolysis of vaccinia virus-infected syngeneic target cells. Virus-specific Sensitization took place only after transfer of syngeneic or semiallogeneic spleen lymphocytes; allogeneic lymphocytes had no influence on mean survival time or virus titer and showed no virus-specific cytolytic activity in vitro. Infection of mice with vaccinia virus-strain WR, Elstree, DIs, or DIs-infected syngeneic fibroblasts resulted in the generation of virus-specific effector cells, while injection of a high amount of inactivated virus particles caused no Sensitization. These results suggest H-2 homology for production of virus-specific effector cells. Propagation of virus is not necessary, since early surface antigens, combined with syngeneic H-2 antigens, suffice for Sensitization of cytolytic T lymphocytes.Abbreviations used in this paper are as follows CMC cell-mediated cytolysis - CTL cytolytic T lymphocyte - LCM lymphocytic choriomeningitis - MHC major histocompatibility complex - MST mean survival time - T cell thymus-derived cell - TCID₅₀ 50 percent tissue culture infective dose     

Inhibition of T cell-mediated functions by MVM(i), a parvovirus closely related to minute virus of mice

A purified preparation of MVM(i), a murine parvovirus closely related to minute virus of mice (MVM), was found to inhibit various functions mediated by murine T cells in vitro. Addition of MVM(i) virus to secondary allogeneic mixed leukocyte cultures resulted in the inhibition of both lymphocyte proliferation (3H-thymidine incorporation) and the generation of cytolytic T lymphocyte activity but not interferon production. MVM(i) virus also inhibited the growth and cytolytic activity of several cloned, long-term Lyt-2+ cytolytic T cell lines. Furthermore, the antigen-induced proliferative responses of parasite- (Leishmania) specific Lyt-1+ T cells in vitro was abrogated by the addition of MVM(i) virus to the culture. Finally, the suppression of an in vitro antibody response to SRBC by MVM(i) virus was the result of the inhibition of T helper cells required for the B cell response. These suppressive effects were specific for MVM(i); parallel studies in which the prototype MVM parvovirus was used showed no significant inhibition in the various systems tested.     

Functional activity in vivo of effector T cell populations. I. Antitumor activity exhibited by allogeneic mixed leukocyte culture cells

The in vivo activity of murine cytolytic T lymphocyte-containing effector cell populations generated in vitro was studied in a tumor allograft model system by monitoring the elimination of 131I-IUdR-labeled tumor cells with whole-body counting techniques. Mice were irradiated sublethally and 16 hr later 131I-labeled tumor cells were injected either subcutaneously or i.p. Simultaneously, graded doses of various effector cell populations were injected i.v. and the mice were counted daily to assess the potential elimination of the radiolabeled tumor cells. Thus, allogeneic 2 degrees mixed leukocyte culture cells were observed to eliminate allogeneic but not syngeneic tumor cells in a dose-dependent manner, with as few as 0.2 x 10(6) effector cells causing significant destruction of 2 x 10(6) allogeneic tumor cells. The protective effect of the mixed leukocyte culture cells was considerably reduced when Lyt-2+-bearing lymphocytes were eliminated by treatment with monoclonal antibody plus complement. In additional experiments, Lyt-2+ lymphocytes positively selected by enrichment on antibody-coated petri dishes gave efficient protection, in the absence of Lyt-2- cells. Surprisingly, when several different cloned, specific, long-term allogeneic cytolytic T cells lines were injected either i.p. of i.v., tumor cell destruction was observed only after i.p. injection.     

Susceptibility of Friend virus antigen-modulated erythroleukemic cells to lysis by T lymphocytes from mice with dormant Friend virus infections.

Spleen cells from DBA/2 mice with dormant Friend leukemia virus (FLV) infections or from mice immunized with x-irradiated FLC-745 erythroleukemic cells are not cytolytic for FLC-745 cells when tested directly, but acquire cytolytic activity in vitro by cultivation with x-irradiated FLC-745 cells. Spleen cells cultured from normal mice do not acquire such cytolytic activity. Cytolytic activity resides in the T lymphocyte population. Alloantiserum, but not antisera against FLV-virion polypeptides, inhibited the lysis of FLC-745 cells by cytolytic T lymphocytes. To understand further the role of cellular and humoral immune anti-FLV responses in mice with dormant FLV-infections, in vitro experiments were conducted that mimicked the in vivo FLV-specific immune environment of these mice. We found that FLV-immune serum from mice with dormant FLV-infections modulated FLV-antigen expression on the surfaces of FLC-745 cells without affecting their susceptibility to lysis by cytolytic T lymphocytes. These results suggest that cytolytic T lymphocyte restrain the outgrowth of FLV-antigen-modulated erythroleukemic cells in mice with dormant FLV infections and that the targets for cell-mediated lysis may be H-2d-associated antigens.     

Biological effects of activation of human peripheral blood mononuclear cells by mitogenic oxidizing agents. I Alloantigen-independent activation of alloimmune memory cells

Mechanisms of activation of alloimmune memory cells by immunologically nonspecific signals were investigated utilizing the mitogenic oxidizing agents, neuraminidase and galactose oxidase (NAGO) and sodium periodate (IO₄^?). Direct activation of primary long-term human mixed-lymphocyte culture (MLC) cells (memory cells) with either NAGO or IO₄^? resulted in increased specific secondary cytolytic activity. Kinetics of the proliferative and cytotoxic responses resulting from such treatment of memory cells paralleled those resulting from treatment of memory cells with irradiated cells that were the stimulators in the primary MLC. Indirect activation of memory cells by NAGO or IO₄^?-treated and irradiated syngeneic cells also resulted in increased specific secondary cytolytic activity. In contrast, peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBM) activated by the mitogenic oxidizing agents did not develop cytolytic activity toward syngeneic or multiple allogeneic target cells, despite extensive proliferative responses. Cytotoxicity generated by either direct or indirect activation of memory cells by IO₄^? was prevented by treatment of the oxidized cells with the reducing agent, sodium borohydride. Incubation of memory cells in supernatants from 24-hr cultures of PBM activated with either NAGO or IO₄^? resulted in proliferation and in an increase in cytolytic activity in memory cells, but not in PBM. These findings indicate that alloimmune memory cells can be activated by immunologically nonspecific lymphocyte-derived signals that do not depend on alloantigen or lectin.     

Potent CTL induction by a whole cell pertussis vaccine in anti-tumor peptide immunotherapy

Promising yet limited clinical responses have been reported for peptide based immunotherapy against tumors. In order to induce more potent cytolytic CD8 T cell responses, we investigated the use of Bordetella pertussis vaccine as an adjuvant for peptide immunization. A whole cell (Wc) vaccine has been known to induce a Th1 biased immune response while an acellular (Ac) vaccine tends to induce that of the Th2 type. Natural infection by B. pertussis helps to maintain a robust Th1 memory in the host population. To examine the adjuvant activity of the pertussis vaccine, we immunized mice with an ovalbumin peptide as a model tumor antigen, and monitored the development of anti-tumor activities. The addition of either the Ac or the Wc vaccine helped expand the specific CD8 T cells. However, there was a marked difference in the induced cytolytic activity where the Wc vaccine was superior to the Ac. The Wc vaccine was also more effective in inducing in vivo tumor rejection. The adjuvant activity was not only effective against ovalbumin, but was also evident when an endogenous tumor antigen, Wilms' tumor 1 gene product, was targeted. These results indicate that, although the Wc vaccine does not share the same antigen specificity with tumor cells, it can aid in the development of highly cytolytic CD8 T cells as an adjuvant at the site of peptide immunization.     

In vitro expression of secondary antitumor immunity by in vivo tumor-sensitized T cells: Inhibition by tumor-induced suppressor T cells

Summary In vitro cultivation of memory immune cells from P815- or P388-immune mice with corresponding irradiated tumor cells induced generation of cytolytic T cells (CTL). The induction of CTL generation, as well as the cytolytic activity itself, was tumor-specific. The in vitro generation of CTL from P815- or P388-immune cells was suppressed by spleen cells from mice bearing corresponding progressive tumors (tumor size 15 mm). The tumor-induced suppressor cells suppressed the in vitro generation of CTL, but did not affect their cytolytic function. The suppression was tumor-specific and was mediated by Ly1⁺2^–L3T4⁺ T cells. Treatment of suppressor cell donors with cyclophosphamide or sublethal -radiation completely abolished the ability of their spleen cells to inhibit the in vitro CTL generation.     

Induction of graft versus host-associated immunodeficiency by CD4+ T cell clones

Previous studies have shown that the injection of parental T cells into MHC class II mismatched F1 recipient mice can lead to graft-vs-host (GvH) reaction that manifests itself by multiple symptoms. The objective of our study was to analyze GvH reactivity induced by a single T cell clone specific for host I-A or I-E alloantigen. The T cell clones tested for GvH potential were CD4+, with or without cytolytic activity in vitro and with a lymphokine pattern that classifies them as Th1 cells. The inoculation of a single T cell clone induced a severe, but transient immunodeficiency in the host that was independent of its cytolytic activity, as demonstrated by the failure to generate a CTL response to third party allogeneic cells in vitro. Induction of immunodeficiency in the recipients required preactivation of the clones in vitro by rIl-2 and the presence of the stimulator class II alloantigen in the host. Spleen cells from these mice lacked suppressor cells, they were deficient in Il-2 secretion and exhibited a decrease in the number of CD4+ T cells. In addition, I-E expression was reduced, however, without any changes in the macrophage population and an increase in surface Ig and the B cell marker B220. Simultaneous to the immunodeficiency, the clone-injected mice produced elevated antibody titers to ssDNA.     

Effect of anthelminthic treatment on the immune response of mice

Immunologic function was tested both in vivo and in vitro in mice undergoing prophylactic anthelminthic therapy with three agents to assess whether these drugs affected immune responses. This study was performed because investigators often are concerned about the effect of drug treatment on the induction of specific immune responses. While helminthic infestation is recognized as deleterious to the host, it is unclear whether anthelminthic treatment might be immunosuppressive. The effects of piperazine or trichlorphon administered to drinking water or fenbendazole administered in feed were insignificant in BALB/c mice. The induction of allospecific cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTLs) in vitro, influenza specific memory T cells in vivo, influenza specific antibody secretion in vivo, or influenza-specific helper T cells and CTLs in vitro were examined. Results of this study indicate that anthelminthic treatments did not interfere with immune responses.     

Archaeosomes induce long-term CD8+ cytotoxic T cell response to entrapped soluble protein by the exogenous cytosolic pathway, in the absence of CD4+ T cell help

The unique ether glycerolipids of ARCHAEA: can be formulated into vesicles (archaeosomes) with strong adjuvant activity for MHC class II presentation. Herein, we assess the ability of archaeosomes to facilitate MHC class I presentation of entrapped protein Ag. Immunization of mice with OVA entrapped in archaeosomes resulted in a potent Ag-specific CD8(+) T cell response, as measured by IFN-gamma production and cytolytic activity toward the immunodominant CTL epitope OVA(257-264). In contrast, administration of OVA with aluminum hydroxide or entrapped in conventional ester-phospholipid liposomes failed to evoke significant CTL response. The archaeosome-mediated CD8(+) T cell response was primarily perforin dependent because CTL activity was undetectable in perforin-deficient mice. Interestingly, a long-term CTL response was generated with a low Ag dose even in CD4(+) T cell deficient mice, indicating that the archaeosomes could mediate a potent T helper cell-independent CD8(+) T cell response. Macrophages incubated in vitro with OVA archaeosomes strongly stimulated cytokine production by OVA-specific CD8(+) T cells, indicating that archaeosomes efficiently delivered entrapped protein for MHC class I presentation. This processing of Ag was Brefeldin A sensitive, suggesting that the peptides were transported through the endoplasmic reticulum and presented by the cytosolic MHC class I pathway. Finally, archaeosomes induced a potent memory CTL response to OVA even 154 days after immunization. This correlated to strong Ag-specific up-regulation of CD44 on splenic CD8(+) T cells. Thus, delivery of proteins in self-adjuvanting archaeosomes represents a novel strategy for targeting exogenous Ags to the MHC class I pathway for induction of CTL response.     

The immunological role of the thymus in the pathogenesis of virus-induced lymphomas. Suppression of cytolytic T-cell function

Thymectomy of young adult mice has been found to prevent virus-induced lymphomas which develop as the animals age. Thymectomy protects mice by removing a source of suppressor T cells which inhibit the generation of cytolytic T cells against autochthonous tumors. Furthermore, suppression is specific since T cells are regulated in their capacity to respond to syngeneic but not allogeneic tumor cells. To determine if suppression could be adoptively transferred, lethally irradiated, bone-marrow-reconstituted mice were inoculated with T cells from either normal or thymectomized mice. Only T cells from thymectomized animals transferred enhanced T-cell reactivity to syngeneic tumor cells. More importantly, T cells from thymectomized mice injected with virus protected recipients challenged with lethal doses of syngeneic tumor cells. We conclude that thymectomy protects mice from developing virus-induced T-cell lymphomas by removing a source of suppressor T cells which regulates the activity of specific cytolytic T cells directed against autochthonous tumor cells.     

Specific inhibition of cytotoxic memory cells produced against UV-induced tumors in UV-irradiated mice.

Cytotoxic responses of UV-irradiated mice against syngeneic UV-induced tumors were measured by using a 51Cr-release assay to determine if UV treatment induced a specific reduction of cytotoxic activity. The in vivo and in vitro primary responses against syngeneic tumors and allogeneic cells were unaffected, as was the "memory" response (in vivo stimulation, in vitro restimulation) against alloantigens. In contrast, the memory response of UV-treated mice against syngeneic, UV-induced tumors was consistently and significantly depressed. The cytotoxicity generated by tumor cell stimulation in vivo or in vitro was tumor-specific and T cell-dependent. Since the primary response against syngeneic UV-induced tumors produces apparently normal amounts of tumor-specific cytotoxic activity, UV-treated mice may not reject transplanted syngeneic tumors because of too few T effector memory cells. These results imply that, at least in this system, tumor rejection depends mostly on the secondary responses against tumor antigens and that at least one carcinogen can, indirectly, specifically regulate immune responses.     

Induction of feline immunodeficiency virus-specific cytolytic T-cell responses from experimentally infected cats.

We have examined the in vitro induction and activity of feline immunodeficiency virus (FIV)-specific cytolytic T cells obtained from cats experimentally infected for 7 to 17 weeks or 20 to 22 months with the Petaluma isolate of FIV. Normal or FIV-infected autologous and allogeneic T lymphoblastoid cells were used as target cells in chromium-51 or indium-111 release assays. When effector cells consisted of either fresh peripheral blood mononuclear cells or concanavalin A- and interleukin-2-stimulated cells, only low levels of cytotoxicity were observed. However, the levels of FIV-specific cytotoxicity were consistently higher in both groups of cats following in vitro stimulation of the effector cells with irradiated, FIV-infected autologous T lymphoblastoid cells and interleukin-2. The effector cells lysed autologous but not allogeneic FIV-infected target cells and were composed predominantly of CD8+ T cells, indicating that the FIV-specific cytotoxicity measured in this system is mediated by CD8+, major histocompatibility complex class I-restricted T cells. These studies show that FIV-specific cytolytic T cells can be detected as early as 7 to 9 weeks postinfection, and they define a system to identify virus-encoded epitopes important in the induction of protective immunity against lentiviruses.     

The tumoricidal activity of memory CD8+ T cells is hampered by persistent systemic antigen, but full functional capacity is regained in an antigen-free environment

Naive T cells can be tolerized in the periphery by diverse mechanisms. However, the extent to which memory T cells are susceptible to tolerance induction is less well defined. Vaccination of mice with a minimal CTL epitope derived from human adenovirus type 5 E1A in IFA s.c. readily tolerizes naive as well as recently activated CD8(+) T cells due to the overwhelming systemic and persistent presence of the peptide. We have now studied the effect of this peptide on established memory cells, which were induced at least 50 days before by virus vaccination. Memory cells did not undergo peripheral deletion and kept their ability to produce IFN-gamma as well as their cytolytic activity in response to Ag directly ex vivo. However, memory CTL responses in virus vaccinated mice injected with peptide ceased to control tumor outgrowth. Interestingly, functional capacities were regained when T cells were transferred to an Ag-free environment in vivo as determined by their ability to reject an otherwise lethal tumor challenge. Together, these findings indicate that memory CTL responses can be functionally incapacitated, but are not, in contrast to naive or recently activated T cells, irreversibly tolerized by persistent systemic Ag, as memory T cells quickly regain effector function upon disappearance of the Ag.     

Enhanced cytotoxic T cell activity in IL-4-deficient mice

CD8+ effectors are critical components of type 1 responses against viral infections as well as for antiviral vaccines. IL-4 plays a clear role as an inhibitor of CD4+ Th1 cells; however, its role in CD8+ T cell regulation appears to be more complex. Thus, IL-4 may augment CD8+ T cell growth, but also limit effector function. Moreover, abundant IL-4 is inhibitory for viral clearance, but the lack of IL-4 appears not to affect CTL-mediated immunity. This report investigates these disparate roles of IL-4 in CD8+ T lymphocyte regulation by comparing T cell responses specific for a single HIV-IIIIB gp120-derived epitope in BALB/c mice deficient in IL-4 to those in wild-type controls. CTL activation was monitored during the acute and memory phases following immunization with recombinant vaccinia virus. Similar frequencies of gp120-specific CTL precursors in splenocytes from both groups indicated that IL-4 plays no significant role in either CTL priming or the establishment of memory. However, cytolytic activity in cultures derived from IL-4-deficient mice developed earlier and was strikingly enhanced following in vitro restimulation, an effect exhibited by both primary and memory T cells. Secretion of IL-2 and IFN-gamma by CD8+ T cells from IL-4-deficient mice was also elevated, reflecting their enhanced activation. Thus, IL-4 appears to limit the activation, expansion, and differentiation of CD8+ T cells with high cytolytic potential.     

Specifically induced suppression of T cell and NK-like cytolytic activity by ingested soluble antigens

The effect of feeding xenoserum (xs) on cytolytic cell activity induced by parenteral injection was examined in C3H/N mice. Spleen cells were cultured with xs and then assayed for cytolytic activity against a panel of 51Cr-labeled YAC-1, AKR-A, or P815 target cells. Prior feeding resulted in significant suppression of responses stimulated by injection and culture. The induction of these responses was antigen specific for xs whereas the effector stage represented polyclonal activation of cytolytic cells. Some effector cells were lysed by either anti-Lyt 2 or anti-NK- 1.2 and complement and some were blocked by anti-Lyt 2 or anti-T200 in the cytotoxicity assay. Thus, both cytolytic T and NK-like cells were suppressed by antigen feeding. Activity of TH cell-derived factors which enhance cytolytic activity ("promoter" factor, interferon, and interleukin 2) also was diminished in culture supernatants of cells from mice fed soluble antigens. The conclusion that polyclonal cytolytic responses induced by soluble antigen can be regulated by prior enteric stimulation is made.     

Induction of long-term memory CD8(+) T cells for recall of viral clearing responses against influenza virus

Induction of cytotoxic T-cell-mediated virus-clearing responses by influenza virus T cell determinant-containing peptide immunogens was examined. The most potent synthetic immunogens for eliciting pulmonary viral-clearing responses contained peptides representing determinants for CD4 and CD8 T cells (TH and CTL peptides, respectively) together with two or four palmitic acid (Pal) groups. Inoculated in adjuvant, these Pal2- or Pal4-CTL-TH lipopeptides and the nonlipidated CTL peptide induced equivalent levels of cytolytic activity in the primary effector phase of the response. The ability to recall lytic responses, however, diminished much more rapidly in CTL peptide-primed than in lipopeptide-primed mice. By 15 months postpriming, the recalled lytic activity in lipopeptide-inoculated mice remained potent, but the response induced by the CTL peptide was weak. Enumeration of specific gamma interferon-secreting CD8 T cells revealed that a greater number of these T cells had entered or remained in the memory pool in lipopeptide-primed mice, arguing for a quantitative rather than qualitative enhancement of the response on recall. Addition of either the lipid or the TH peptide to the CTL peptide was not sufficient to provide these long-lived antiviral responses, but inclusion of both components augmented the response. CD4 T cells elicited by the lipopeptides did not influence the rate of viral clearance upon challenge and most likely had a role in induction or maintenance of the memory response. It therefore appears that the lipopeptide immunogens, although not significantly superior at inducing primary effector CD8 T cells, elicit a much more effective memory population, the recall of which may account for their superiority in inducing pulmonary protection after viral challenge.     

A helper factor needed for the generation of mouse cytolytic T lymphocytes is made by tumor cell lines, cloned T cells, and spleen cells exposed to a variety of stimuli

A helper factor termed cytolytic T lymphocyte helper factor (CHF) that is needed for the generation of allospecific mouse cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) in vitro was produced by mouse spleen cells 3 to 4 days after the time when interleukin 2 (IL 2) had reached its maximal production. These kinetics were observed by stimulation of immune spleen cells with allogeneic tumor or spleen cells, with Sendai or influenza viral peptides, with virus infected cells, or with concanavalin A (Con A). CHF produced by rat spleen cells was able to help in the generation of mouse CTL, indicating that this cytokine was not restricted genetically. CHF could also be made by WEHI-3 and EL4 cell lines, as well as cloned cytolytic and helper T cells. The production of CHF by WEHI-3 cells argues that CHF is not IL 2. In addition, if CHF was not present early in the in vitro stimulation no CTL were generated, suggesting that CHF participated in the activation of CTL precursors. The addition of IL 2-containing conditioned medium to the CHF assay resulted in no substantial CTL generation, although significant cellular proliferation was observed. In contrast, CHF-containing conditioned medium allowed the generation of CTL in the absence of the same level of proliferation.     

IL-12 priming during in vitro antigenic stimulation changes properties of CD8 T cells and increases generation of effector and memory cells

Antigenic and costimulatory signals trigger a developmental program by which naive CD8 T cells differentiate into effector and memory cells. However, initial cytokine signals that regulate the generation of effector and memory CD8 T cells are not well understood. In this study, we show that IL-12 priming during in vitro antigenic stimulation results in the significant increase of both primary and memory CD8 T cell population in mice after adoptive transfer of activated cells. The effect of IL-12 priming is closely associated with qualitative changes in CD8 T cells, such as reduced MHC I tetramer binding and CD69 expression, altered distribution of lipid rafts, decreased cytolytic activity, and less susceptibility to apoptosis. Furthermore, exogenous IL-12 priming improved the intrinsic survival properties of memory CD8 T cells, leading to better protective immunity and vaccine-induced memory CD8 T cell responses. However, the experiments with IL-12p40- and IL-12Rbeta1-deficient mice showed similar levels of primary and memory CD8 T cell responses compared with wild-type mice, implying that endogenous IL-12 and/or IL-12R signaling in vivo is not critical for CD8 T cell immunity. Together, our results suggest that IL-12 can serve as an important, but dispensable regulatory factor for the development of CD8 T cells, and IL-12 priming could be useful in many medical applications.     

Immunodominance in the T cell response to multiple non-H-2 histocompatibility antigens. III. Single histocompatibility antigens dominate the male antigen

Immunization of mice with multiple non-H-2 histocompatibility antigens results in the generation of cytolytic T lymphocytes that are specific for a limited number of immunodominant antigens. The experiments presented in this communication were designed to reveal immunodominance in pairwise combinations of autosomal and sex-linked non-H-2 histocompatibility (H) antigens. Priming and boosting responders with the male antigen, H-Y, paired with the H-4.2, H-7.1, or H-3.1 antigens, resulted in the generation of cytolytic T cells specific for the autosomal H antigens but not the H-Y antigen. Furthermore, co-immunization and boosting of C57BL/6 female responder spleen cells with BALB.B male cells resulted in the generation of cytolytic T cells specific for the BALB.B immunodominant antigens but not H-Y. No dominance was observed in H-4-plus H-7-incompatible combinations. Co-immunization of three different H-3 congenic strains with H-3.1 plus H-Y demonstrated that an efficient anti-H-3.1 T cell response is required for observing H-3.1 immunodominance over H-Y. Co-expression of H-3.1 and H-Y on the same priming and boosting cells was required for immunodominance. In fact, immunization with H-3.1 and H-Y presented on different cells resulted in normal generation of H-Y-specific cytolytic T cells, but no generation of H-3.1-specific cytolytic T cells resulted unless H-Y-specific cells were stimulated in the mixed lymphocyte cultures. These observations suggest that in vitro T cell responses to paired, non-H-2 H antigens may be independent, competitive, or synergistic, depending on the identity of the antigens and the priming and boosting conditions.