Prebiotic adenine synthesis via HCN oligomerization in ice

Adenine is produced (after hydrolysis) when 0.01 M solutions of HCN are adjusted to pH 9.2 with NH4OH and are frozen at -2 degrees C for 60-100 days. The addition of glycolonitrile (the cyanohydrin of formaldehyde) increases the yield of adenine under these conditions by about five-fold. These results confirm and extend an earlier suggestion that purine synthesis on the prebiotic Earth might have occurred in frozen, dilute solutions of HCN.     

Metabolism and motility in prebiotic structures

Easily accessible, primitive chemical structures produced by self-assembly of hydrophobic substances into oil droplets may result in self-moving agents able to sense their environment and move to avoid equilibrium. These structures would constitute very primitive examples of life on the Earth, even more primitive than simple bilayer vesicle structures. A few examples of simple chemical systems are presented that self-organize to produce oil droplets capable of movement, environment remodelling and primitive chemotaxis. These chemical agents are powered by an internal chemical reaction based on the hydrolysis of an oleic anhydride precursor or on the hydrolysis of hydrogen cyanide (HCN) polymer, a plausible prebiotic chemistry. Results are presented on both the behaviour of such droplets and the surface-active properties of HCN polymer products. Such motile agents would be capable of finding resources while escaping equilibrium and sustaining themselves through an internal metabolism, thus providing a working chemical model for a possible origin of life.     

15 Combinatorial chemistry in the prebiotic environment

The pathway leading to the origin of life presumably included a process by which polymers were synthesized abiotically from simpler compounds on the early Earth, then encapsulated to form protocells. Previous studies have reported that mineral surfaces can concentrate and organize activated mononucleotides, thereby promoting their polymerization into RNA-like molecules. However, a plausible prebiotic activation mechanism has not been established, and minerals cannot form cellular compartments. We are exploring ways in which nonactivated mononucleotides can undergo polymerization and encapsulation. We found that small yields of RNA-like molecules are synthesized by a condensation reaction when mixtures of amphiphilic lipids and mononucleotides are exposed to cycles of dehydration and rehydration. The lipids concentrate and organize the monomers within multilamellar liquid-crystalline matrices that self-assemble in the dry state. The chemical potential driving the polymerization reaction is supplied by the anhydrous conditions in which water becomes a leaving group, with heat providing activation energy. Significantly, the polymeric products are encapsulated in trillions of microscopic compartments upon rehydration. Each compartment is unique in its composition and contents, and can be considered to be an experiment in a natural version of combinatorial chemistry that would be ubiquitous in the prebiotic environment. A successful experiment would be a compartment that captured polymers capable of catalyzing their own replication. If this can be reproduced in the laboratory, it would represent a significant step toward understanding the origin of cellular life.     

Lipid-assisted Synthesis of RNA-like Polymers from Mononucleotides

A fundamental problem in research on the origin of life is the process by which polymers capable of catalysis and replication were produced on the early Earth. Here we show that RNA-like polymers can be synthesized non-enzymatically from mononucleotides in lipid environments. The RNA-like polymers were initially identified by nanopore analysis, a technique with single molecule sensitivity. To our knowledge, this is the first such application of a nanopore instrument to detect RNA synthesis under simulated prebiotic conditions. The synthesis of the RNA-like polymers was confirmed by standard methods of enzymatic end labeling followed by gel electrophoresis. Chemical activation of the mononucleotides is not required. Instead, synthesis of phosphodiester bonds is driven by the chemical potential of fluctuating anhydrous and hydrated conditions, with heat providing activation energy during dehydration. In the final hydration step, the RNA-like polymer is encapsulated within lipid vesicles. This process provides a laboratory model of an early stage of evolution toward an RNA World.     

Addressing the problems of base pairing and strand cyclization in template-directed synthesis: a case for the utility and necessity of 'molecular midwives' and reversible backbone linkages for the origin of proto-RNA

Nucleic acid synthesis is precisely controlled in living organisms by highly evolved protein enzymes. The remarkable fidelity of information transfer realized between template and product strands is the result of both the spatial selectivity of the polymerase active site for Watson-Crick base pairs at the point of nucleotide coupling and subsequent proof-reading mechanisms. In the absence of naturally derived polymerases, in vitro template-directed synthesis by means of chemically activated mononucleotides has proven remarkably inefficient and error-prone. Nevertheless, the spontaneous emergence of RNA polymers and their protein-free replication is frequently taken as a prerequisite for the hypothetical 'RNA world'. We present two specific difficulties that face the de novo synthesis of RNA-like polymers in a prebiotic (enzyme-free) environment: nucleoside base selection and intramolecular strand cyclization. These two problems are inherent to the assumption that RNA formed de novo from pre-existing, chemically-activated mononucleotides in solution. As a possible resolution to these problems, we present arguments and experimental support for our hypothesis that small molecules (referred to as 'molecular midwives') and alternative backbone linkages (under equilibrium control) facilitated the emergence of the first RNA-like polymers of life.     

Detection of Macromolecular Fractions in HCN Polymers Using Electrophoretic and Ultrafiltration Techniques

Elucidating the origin of life involves synthetic as well as analytical challenges. Herein, for the first time, we describe the use of gel electrophoresis and ultrafiltration to fractionate HCN polymers. Since the first prebiotic synthesis of adenine by Oró, HCN polymers have gained much interest in studies on the origins of life due to the identification of biomonomers and related compounds within them. Here, we demonstrate that macromolecular fractions with electrophoretic mobility can also be detected within HCN polymers. The migration of polymers under the influence of an electric field depends not only on their sizes (one‐dimensional electrophoresis) but also their different isoelectric points (two‐dimensional electrophoresis, 2‐DE). The same behaviour was observed for several macromolecular fractions detected in HCN polymers. Macromolecular fractions with apparent molecular weights as high as 250 kDa were detected by tricine‐SDS gel electrophoresis. Cationic macromolecular fractions with apparent molecular weights as high as 140 kDa were also detected by 2‐DE. The HCN polymers synthesized were fractionated by ultrafiltration. As a result, the molecular weight distributions of the macromolecular fractions detected in the HCN polymers directly depended on the synthetic conditions used to produce these polymers. The implications of these results for prebiotic chemistry will be discussed.     

Peptide Amyloids in the Origin of Life

How life can emerge from non-living matter is one of the fundamental mysteries of the universe. A bottom-up approach to this problem focuses on the potential chemical precursors of life, in particular the nature of the first replicative molecules. Such thinking has led to the currently most popular idea: that an RNA-like molecule played a central role as the first replicative and catalytic molecule. Here, we review an alternative hypothesis that has recently gained experimental support, focusing on the role of amyloidogenic peptides rather than nucleic acids, in what has been by some termed “the amyloid-world” hypothesis. Amyloids are well-ordered peptide aggregates that have a fibrillar morphology due to their underlying structure of a one-dimensional crystal-like array of peptides in a β-strand conformation. While they are notorious for their implication in several neurodegenerative diseases including Alzheimer's disease, amyloids also have many biological functions. In this review, we will elaborate on the following properties of amyloids in relation to their fitness as a prebiotic entity: they can be formed by very short peptides with simple amino acids sequences; as aggregates they are more chemically stable than their isolated component peptides; they can possess diverse catalytic activities; they can form spontaneously during the prebiotic condensation of amino acids; they can act as templates in their own chemical replication; they have a structurally repetitive nature that enables them to interact with other structurally repetitive biopolymers like RNA/DNA and polysaccharides, as well as with structurally repetitive surfaces like amphiphilic membranes and minerals.     

Catalysis by a prebiotic nucleotide analog of histidine

A ribosylated derivative of adenine, N6 ribosyl adenine, likely to have formed under prebiotic synthesis conditions, is shown to be as active as histidine in the model reaction of p-nitrophenyl acetate hydrolysis. This property widens the range of reactions accessible to RNA catalysis.     

The improbability of prebiotic nucleic acid synthesis

Many accounts of the origin of life assume that the spontaneous synthesis of a self-replicating nucleic acid could take place readily. Serious chemical obstacles exist, however, which make such an event extremely improbable.Prebiotic syntheses of adenine from HCN, of D, L-ribose from adenosine, and of adenosine from adenine and D-ribose have in fact been demonstrated. However these procedures use pure starting materials, afford poor yields, and are run under conditions which are not compatible with one another.Any nucleic acid components which are formed on the primitive earth would tend to hydrolyze by a number of pathways. Their polymerization would be inhibited by the presence of vast numbers of related substances which would react preferentially with them.It appears likely that nucleic acids were not formed by prebiotic routes, but are later products of evolution.     

The improbability of prebiotic nucleic acid synthesis

Many accounts of the origin of life assume that the spontaneous synthesis of a self-replicating nucleic acid could take place readily. Serious chemical obstacles exist, however, which make such an event extremely improbable. Prebiotic syntheses of adenine from HCN, of D,L-ribose from adenosine, and of adenosine from adenine and D-ribose have in fact been demonstrated. However these procedures use pure starting materials, afford poor yields, and are run under conditions which are not compatible with one another. Any nucleic acid components which were formed on the primitive earth would tend to hydrolyze by a number of pathways. Their polymerization would be inhibited by the presence of vast numbers of related substances which would react preferentially with them. It appears likely that nucleic acids were not formed by prebiotic routes, but are later products of evolution.     

Glyoxylate as a Backbone Linkage for a Prebiotic Ancestor of RNA

The origin of the first RNA polymers is central to most current theories for the origin of life. Difficulties associated with the prebiotic formation of RNA have lead to the general consensus that a simpler polymer preceded RNA. However, polymers proposed as possible ancestors to RNA are not much easier to synthesize than RNA itself. One particular problem with the prebiotic synthesis of RNA is the formation of phosphoester bonds in the absence of chemical activation. Here we demonstrate that glyoxylate (the ionized form of glyoxylic acid), a plausible prebiotic molecule, represents a possible ancestor of the phosphate group in modern RNA. Although in low yields (∼ 1%), acetals are formed from glyoxylate and nucleosides under neutral conditions, provided that metal ions are present (e.g., Mg²⁺), and provided that water is removed by evaporation at moderate temperatures (e.g., 65 ^∘C), i.e. under “drying conditions”. Such acetals are termed ga-dinucleotides and possess a linkage that is analogous to the backbone in RNA in both structure and electrostatic charge. Additionally, an energy-minimized model of a gaRNA duplex predicts a helical structure similar to that of A-form RNA. We propose that glyoxylate-acetal linkages would have had certain advantages over phosphate linkages for early self-replicating polymers, but that the distinct functional properties of phosphoester and phosphodiester bonds would have eventually lead to the replacement of glyoxylate by phosphate.     

Behavior of adenine in Na-montmorillonite exposed to gamma radiation: implications to chemical evolution studies.

Adenine is an important compound in biological systems, such as genetic and energy utilization processes. Adenine is readily formed in prebiotic conditions. Its synthesis and stability in environmental conditions are of paramount importance in chemical evolution processes. Clay minerals might have played an important role in the early Earth. Clays are known to have a high affinity for organic compounds, and they may provide protection to adsorbed molecules against high-energy radiation. The purpose of this work is to testthese assumptions. We study the stability of adenine under irradiation, in aqueous solution and also adsorbed in a clay mineral. The recovery of adenine after a gamma irradiation was higher in the system containing clay in relation to a system without clay. Results show that adenine is readily adsorbed in the clay, and that the clay act as surface protector toward the degradation of adenine by the radiation.     

Exon-intron-like pattern of the first propagating molecule?

Summary A biogeochemical scenario is proposed, according to which prebiotic self-replication of RNA-like molecules evolved gradually from domain propagation to entire strand replication. The hypothetical replicating entities that formed an evolutionary continuity in time, the prebioectons, were characterized by self-structuring, and started their evolution from strands possessing one or more templatable domains. The inherent self-structuring implies a very early coevolution of the replicating molecules with prebiotic peptides, in line with the cassette model of Cedergren and Grosjean (1987). The proposed approach can be partially tested in the laboratory.     

A new hypothesis for the origin of life

This hypothesis suggests that calcium chelating sugars, and especially ribose, have determined the nature of the first molecular systems. The self-organization capacities of these molecules enabled them to form regular arrays with certain salts. These arrays then evolved to form polysaccharides. In this first step, ribose and particularly -D-ribofuranose predominated over other prebiotic components. In a second step, the purines invaded these polysaccharides (3–5-polyribophosphodiester). The purines best suited for this were adenine and deoxyguanine, arising from the polymerization of HCN. Just as the polysaccharides reacted with purines, so the purines reacted with other small molecules and in particular, certain alkylating agents and water. After several methylation and oxidation reactions, adenine and deoxyguanine evolved to adenine, methylguanine, cytosine, uracil and thymine. Slow evolution of the prebiotic components gradually brought about a transition from a ribose world to an RNA world. The environment of this prebiotic RNA was different from that of modern RNA. For example, interaction of prebiotic RNA with water, calcium salts and certain zwitterionic molecules like the amino acids glycine and alanine was unavoidable. The interaction of these two small amino acids with calcium evolved to form transient anhydride bonds that quickly reverted to the initial state, or transformed to a peptide bond or to a more stable activated state, the oxazolone ring. The formation of this ring in double-stranded prebiotic RNA is the critical event that allowed the synthesis of new -L-amino acids. The positioning of the lateral sides of the amino acids inside the RNA suggests a stereochemical relationship that could explain the origin of the genetic code.     

Small molecule interactions were central to the origin of life

Many scientists believe life began with the spontaneous formation of a replicator. This idea has been supported by "prebiotic" syntheses carried out by chemists using modern apparatus and purified reagents. The probability that such reactions would take place spontaneously on the early Earth is minute. These points are illustrated here by considering the often cited oligomerization of activated RNA components by clay minerals. A more likely alternative for the origin of life is one in which a collection of small organic molecules multiply their numbers through catalyzed reaction cycles, driven by a flow of available free energy. Although a number of possible systems of this type have been discussed, no experimental demonstration has been made. The inclusion of a "driver" reaction, directly coupled to the energy source, may lead to a solution.     

Peptide nucleic acids and the origin of life

The possibilities of pseudo-peptide-DNA mimics like PNA (peptide nucleic acid) having a role for the prebiotic origin of life prior to an RNA world is discussed on the basis of literature data showing that this type of molecules might have formed on the primitive earth (or other places in the universe), as well as data indicating the possibilities of template-directed PNA chemical replication and ligation. In particular, the merits of an achiral prebiotic genetic material is discussed.     

The crystal structure of a high affinity RNA stem-loop complexed with the bacteriophage MS2 capsid: further challenges in the modeling of ligand-RNA interactions

We have determined the structure to 2.8 A of an RNA aptamer (F5), containing 2'-deoxy-2-aminopurine (2AP) at the -10 position, complexed with MS2 coat protein by soaking the RNA into precrystallised MS2 capsids. The -10 position of the RNA is an important determinant of binding affinity for coat protein. Adenine at this position in other RNA stem-loops makes three hydrogen bonds to protein functional groups. Substituting 2AP for the -10 adenine in the F5 aptamer yields an RNA with the highest yet reported affinity for coat protein. The refined X-ray structure shows that the 2AP base makes an additional hydrogen bond to the protein compared to adenine that is presumably the principal origin of the increased affinity. There are also slight changes in phosphate backbone positions compared to unmodified F5 that probably also contribute to affinity. Such phosphate movements are common in structures of RNAs bound to the MS2 T = 3 protein shell and highlight problems for de novo design of RNA binding ligands.     

Purine Biosynthetic Intermediate-Containing Ribose-Phosphate Polymers as Evolutionary Precursors to RNA

The RNA world hypothesis proposes that RNA once functioned as the principal genetic material and biological catalyst. However, RNA is a complex molecule made up of phosphate, ribose, and nucleobase moieties, and its evolution is unclear. Yakhnin has proposed a period of prebiotic chemical evolution prior to the advent of replication and Darwinian evolution, in which macromolecules containing polyols joined by phosphodiester linkages underwent spontaneous transesterification reactions with selection for stability. Although he proposes that the nucleobases were obtained during this stage from less stable macromolecules, the ultimate source of the nucleobases is not addressed. We propose that the purine nucleobases arose in situ from simpler precursors attached to a ribose-phosphate backbone, and that the weaker and less specific intra- and interstrand interactions between these precursors were the forerunners to the base pairing and base stacking interactions of the modern RNA nucleobases. Further, in line with Granick’s hypothesis of biosynthetic pathways recapitulating evolution, we propose that these simpler precursors were the same or similar to intermediates of the modern de novo purine biosynthetic pathway. We propose that successive nucleobase precursors formed progressively stronger interactions that stabilized the ribose-phosphate polymer, and that the increased stability of the parent polymer drove the selection and further chemical evolution of the purine nucleobases. Such interactions may have included hydrogen bonding between ribose hydroxyls, hydrogen bonding between carbonyl oxygens and protonated amine side groups, the intra- and interstrand coordination of metal cations, and the stacking of imidazole rings. Five of the eleven steps of the modern de novo purine biosynthetic pathway have previously been shown to have alternative nonenzymatic syntheses, while a sixth step has also been proposed to occur nonenzymatically, supporting a prebiotic origin for the pathway.     

Studies of nucleic acid-like polymers as catalysts

Summary An important issue in the problem of the origins of life is whether or not nucleic acids may exert catalytic activities. In order to study the possible role of the adenine ring in catalysis, we have synthesized polymers containing aliphatic amino groups and the nucleic base adenine linked to macromolecules by its 6-amino group. These polymers exhibit pronounced catalytic activities in the hydrolysis of p-nitrophenylacetate. In mild basic conditions, the strong increase in the activities observed can be related to a cooperative effect between the amino groups and the adenine rings of the polymers. These properties and our previous results on the catalytic activity of N6-ribosyl-adenine are consistent with a possible role for the adenine ring in prebiotic catalysis. Ofprint requests to: M.C. Maurel