Comparison of nucleotide diversity and symbiotic properties of Rhizobium meliloti populations from annual Medicago species

Abstract: Forty-three isolates of Rhizobium meliloti were trapped from soil with five annual species of Medicago (M. polymorpha, M. truncatula, M. rigidula, M. orbicularis and M. minima ) and one perennial species of Medicago (M. sativa) . The annual species were growing naturally near the soil sampling site, and the commonly studied perennial species was used for comparison. Each R. meliloti was characterized by PCR-RFLP methods applied to two DNA regions nested between 16S rRNA and 23S rRNA genes and between nif D and nif K genes. They fell into two highly divergent groups (groups I and II), separated at a genetic distance of 0.024 by rDNA-amplified pattern analysis (profiles R1 and R2) and at 0.029 by nif -amplified pattern analysis (profiles N1-N2 and N3). These two groups were consistent with some cross-nodulation and -fixation results: rhizobia with the R1 genetic background elicited rudimentary nodules and could not fix nitrogen on M. polymorpha , while they were able to nodulate the five other species of Medicago . In contrast, rhizobia with an R2 profile were highly effective on M. polymorpha and poorly nodulated M. rigidula species, but were able to nodulate efficiently the other species. The striking phenotypic traits on M. polymorpha were also shared by reference strains: strains genetically closed to R2 type triggered typical and efficient nodules on M. polymorpha while those close to R1 type elicited rudimentary and non-efficient ones. Our results suggest that the presence of R. meliloti with R2 genetic backgrounds could be favoured by the distribution of M. polymorpha species.     

Localization of symbiotic mutations in Rhizobium meliloti

A total of 5 Nod- and 57 Fix- symbiotic mutants of Rhizobium meliloti strain 41 have been isolated after either nitrosoguanidine or Tn5 transposition mutagenesis. Chromosomal locations of mutations in 1 Nod- and 11 Fix- derivatives were ascertained by transferring the chromosome (mobilized by plasmid R68.45), in eight fragments, into symbiotically effective recipients and testing the recombinants for symbiotic phenotype. Alternatively, the kanamycin resistance marker of Tn5 was mapped. In five mutants the fix alleles were localized on different chromosomal regions, but six other fix mutations and one nod mutation tested did not map onto the chromosome. It was shown that the chromosome-mobilizing ability (Cma+) of R68.45 was not involved in the mobilization of genes located extrachromosomally. Moreover, Cma- derivatives of R68.45 could mobilize regions of the indigenous plasmid pRme41b but not chromosomal genes. Thus, mobilization of a marker by Cma- R68.45 indicates its extrachromosomal location. With a 32P-labeled DNA fragment carrying Tn5 as a hybridization probe, it was shown that in five extrachromosomally located Tn5-induced fix mutants and one nod mutant Tn5 was localized on plasmid pRme41b. This is in agreement with the genetic mapping data.     

Rhizobium meliloti exopolysaccharides: genetic analyses and symbiotic importance.

Genetic experiments have indicated that succinoglycan (EPS I), the acidic Calcofluor-binding exopolysaccharide, of the nitrogen-fixing bacterium Rhizobium meliloti strain Rm1021 is required for nodule invasion and possibly for later events in nodule development on alfalfa and other hosts. Fourteen exo loci on the second megaplasmid have been identified that are required for, or affect, the synthesis of EPS I. Mutations in certain of these loci completely abolish the production of EPS I and result in mutants that form empty Fix- nodules. We have identified two loci, exoR and exoS, that are involved in the regulation of EPS I synthesis in the free-living state. Certain exo mutations which completely abolish EPS I production are lethal in an exoR95 or exoS96 background. Histochemical analyses of the expression of exo genes during nodulation using exo::TnphoA fusions have indicated that the exo genes are expressed most strongly in the invasion zone. In addition, we have discovered that R. meliloti has a latent capacity to synthesize a second exopolysaccharide (EPS II) that can substitute for the role(s) of EPS I in nodulation of alfalfa but not of other hosts. Possible roles for exopolysaccharides in symbiosis are discussed.     

The effect of strA mutation on symbiotic nitrogen fixation by Rhizobium meliloti.

Studies on 3H-dihydrostreptomycin accumulation and binding to ribosomes showed that ineffective strain CMts17 carries strB type mutation changing its membrane permeability to the drug. Introduction of high level streptomycin resistance of strA type into strain CMts17 was correlated with acquisition of effectiveness and membrane permeability to the drug. This suggests that changes in membrane permeability, responsible for ineffectiveness of strain CMts17, can be reversed by strA mutation.     

Genetic mapping of symbiotic loci on the Rhizobium meliloti chromosome.

To facilitate genetic analyses of Rhizobium meliloti genes that are involved in symbiosis, we determined the map positions of 11 symbiotic loci on the R. meliloti chromosome by using a combination of the Tn5-Mob conjugational transfer method described by Klein et al. (S. Klein, K. Lohmann, G. C. Walker, and E. R. Signer. J. Bacteriol. 174:324-326, 1992) and co-transduction of genetic markers by bacteriophage phi M12. Loci involved in effective nodule formation (fix-379, fix-382, fix-383, fix-385, and fix-388), polysaccharide synthesis (exoR, exoS, exoC, and ndvB), nodule invasion (exoD), and nitrogen regulation (ntrA) were ordered with respect to previously mapped markers and each other. The positions of two other loci, degP and pho-1, were also determined.     

Quantitation of cellular deoxyribonucleic acid by flow microfluorometry.

This report characterizes for the first time an easy, reproducible means of standardizing the relative fluorescent units normally reported for flow microfluorometry. Absolute values for deoxyribonucleic acid/cell are obtained by using nucleated red blood cells as references. Cell were selected and characterized for the quantitative analysis of deoxyribonucleic acid per cell over a range from 2 pg/cell to 93 pg/cell using literature values for species having nucleated erythrocytes. Fluorescence staining by either acridine-orange (green wavelength) or propidium iodide (red wavelength) gave linear curves over the entire range investigated only when "gain controls" and current are optimized. The range was equivalent to mammalian cell values from 1 N (=3.5 pg deoxyribonucleic acid/cell) to 28 N (=91 pg deoxyribonucleic acid/cell). The standard curves obtained with nonmammalian erythrocytes were compared to mammalian free-cell preparations of bovine thymus and liver cells which fell at 6.8 and 6.9 pg deoxyribonucleic acid/cell, respectively. The routine use of these easily obtainable red blood cells will allow ready comparisons on the basis of absolute values for deoxyribonucleic acid per cell for work between experiments, work between staining procedures and dye types and work between laboratories.     

Second symbiotic megaplasmid in Rhizobium meliloti carrying exopolysaccharide and thiamine synthesis genes.

Using physical and genetic data, we have demonstrated that Rhizobium meliloti SU47 has a symbiotic megaplasmid, pRmeSU47b, in addition to the previously described nod-nif megaplasmid pRmeSU47a. This plasmid includes four loci involved in exopolysaccharide (exo) synthesis as well as two loci involved in thiamine biosynthesis. Mutations at the exo loci have previously been shown to result in the formation of nodules which lack infection threads (Inf-) and fail to fix nitrogen (Fix-). Thus, both megaplasmids contain genes involved in the formation of nitrogen-fixing root nodules. Mutations at two other exo loci were not located on either megaplasmid. To mobilize the megaplasmids, the oriT of plasmid RK2 was inserted into them. On alfalfa, Agrobacterium tumefaciens strains containing pRmeSU47a induced marked root hair curling with no infection threads and Fix- nodules, as reported by others. This plant phenotype was not observed to change with A. tumefaciens strains containing both pRmeSU47a and pRmeSU47b megaplasmids, and strains containing pRmeSU47b alone failed to curl root hairs or form nodules.     

A phosphate transport system is required for symbiotic nitrogen fixation by Rhizobium meliloti.

The bacterium Rhizobium meliloti forms N2-fixing root nodules on alfalfa plants. The ndvF locus, located on the 1,700-kb pEXO megaplasmid of R. meliloti, is required for nodule invasion and N2 fixation. Here we report that ndvF contains four genes, phoCDET, which encode an ABC-type transport system for the uptake of Pi into the bacteria. The PhoC and PhoD proteins are homologous to the Escherichia coli phosphonate transport proteins PhnC and PhnD. The PhoT and PhoE proteins are homologous to each other and to the E. coli phosphonate transport protein PhnE. We show that the R. meliloti phoD and phoE genes are induced in response to phosphate starvation and that the phoC promoter contains two elements which are similar in sequence to the PHO boxes present in E. coli phosphate-regulated promoters. The R. meliloti ndvF mutants grow poorly at a phosphate concentration of 2 mM, and we hypothesize that their symbiotic phenotype results from their failure to grow during the nodule infection process. Presumably, the PhoCDET transport system is employed by the bacteria in the soil environment, where the concentration of available phosphate is normally 0.1 to 1 microM.     

Exogenous suppression of the symbiotic deficiencies of Rhizobium meliloti exo mutants.

The acidic exopolysaccharide (EPS I) produced by Rhizobium meliloti during symbiosis with Medicago sativa has been shown to be required for the proper development of nitrogen-fixing nodules. Cloned DNA from the exo region of R. meliloti is shown to stimulate production of the low-molecular-weight form of this exopolysaccharide, and in this report we show that the symbiotic deficiencies of two exo mutants of R. meliloti, the exoA and exoH mutants, can be rescued by the addition of this low-molecular-weight material at the time of inoculation. For exoA and exoH mutants, rescue with a preparation containing low-molecular-weight exopolysaccharide induces the formation of nitrogen-fixing nodules which appear somewhat later and at a reduced efficiency compared with wild-type-induced nodules; however, microscopic analysis of these nodules reveals similar nodule morphology and the presence of large numbers of bacteroids in each.     

Comparison between Rhizobium galegae and Rhizobium meliloti plasmid contents

Plasmid profiles of two strains of a newly classified rhizobial species- Rhizobium galegae -were compared with the profiles of several strains of another fast-growing Rhizobium species- Rhizobium meliloti .
The existence of a plasmid DNA band with a lower electrophoretic mobility than the R. meliloti megaplasmid band was demonstrated in the two R. galegae strains by a modified horizontal Eckhardt method. Thus R. galegae species contain giant plasmid(s) larger than the R. meliloti 1000 MD megaplasmids, previously considered to be the largest plasmids in the Rhizobiaceae family.
In one of the R. galegae strains an additional middle-size plasmid only a little smaller than 140 MD pRme41a of R. meliloti 41 was observed.     

Regulation of Rhizobium meliloti exo genes in free-living cells and in planta examined by using TnphoA fusions.

The exo loci of Rhizobium meliloti are necessary for the production of an acidic exopolysaccharide, EPS I, that is needed for alfalfa nodule invasion by strain Rm1021. We have isolated and characterized alkaline phosphatase fusions made with TnphoA in several exo loci of R. meliloti and used these fusions to examine the subcellular localization of exo gene products and the regulation of exo genes in free-living cells and in planta. In the course of this work, we isolated a new exo locus, exoT. We have obtained evidence that several of the exo loci may encode membrane proteins. The activity of TnphoA fusions in several exo loci is increased two- to fivefold in the presence of the regulatory mutations exoR95 and exoS96. While examining the regulation of the exo gens by exoR95 and exoS96, we found that certain classes of exo mutations are lethal in an exoR95 or exoS96 background unless a plasmid complementing the exo mutation is present. This result has possible implications for the role of these exo loci in EPS I biosynthesis. We have developed a method for staining nodules specifically for the alkaline phosphatase activity present in the inducing bacteria and used this method to show that an exoF::TnphoA fusion is expressed mainly in the invasion zone of the nodule.     

The katA catalase gene is regulated by OxyR in both free-living and symbiotic Sinorhizobium meliloti

The characterization of an oxyR insertion mutant provides evidences that katA, which encodes the unique H2O2-inducible HPII catalase, is regulated by OxyR not only in free-living Sinorhizobium meliloti but also in symbiotic S. meliloti. Moreover, oxyR is expressed independently of exogenous H2O2 and downregulates its own expression in S. meliloti.     

Rhizobium meliloti mutants unable to synthesize anthranilate display a novel symbiotic phenotype.

Analyses of Rhizobium meliloti trp auxotrophs suggest that anthranilate biosynthesis by the R. meliloti trpE(G) gene product is necessary during nodule development for establishment of an effective symbiosis. trpE(G) mutants, as well as mutants blocked earlier along this pathway in aromatic amino acid biosynthesis, form nodules on alfalfa that have novel defects. In contrast, R. meliloti trp mutants blocked later in the tryptophan-biosynthetic pathway form normal, pink, nitrogen-fixing nodules. trpE(G) mutants form two types of elongated, defective nodules containing unusually extended invasion zones on alfalfa. One type contains bacteroids in its base and is capable of nitrogen fixation, while the other lacks bacteroids and cannot fix nitrogen. The trpE(G) gene is expressed in normal nodules. Models are discussed to account for these observations, including one in which anthranilate is postulated to act as an in planta siderophore.     

Aromatic aminotransferase activity and indoleacetic acid production in Rhizobium meliloti.

Bacterial indoleacetic acid (IAA) production, which has been proposed to play a role in the Rhizobium-legume symbiosis, is a poorly understood process. Previous data have suggested that IAA biosynthesis in Rhizobium meliloti can occur through an indolepyruvate intermediate derived from tryptophan by an aminotransferase activity. To further examine this biosynthetic pathway, the aromatic aminotransferase (AAT) activity of Rhizobium meliloti 102F34 (F34) was characterized. At least four proteins were detected on nondenaturing gels of F34 protein extracts that exhibited AAT activity. All four of these AATs were constitutively produced and utilized the aromatic amino acids tryptophan, phenylalanine, and tyrosine as amino substrates. Two AATs were also capable of using aspartate. Plasmids from an F34 gene bank were identified that coded for the synthesis of at least three of these proteins, and the respective gene sequences were localized by transposon mutagenesis. Selected transposon insertions were recombined into the F34 genome to produce strains defective in two of these proteins (AAT1 and AAT2). Characterization of the mutants revealed that neither was essential for the biosynthesis of IAA in the absence of exogenous tryptophan, but that both contributed to IAA biosynthesis when high levels of exogenous tryptophan were present. AAT1 and AAT2 were also not required for the production of a minimal level of aromatic amino acids, but both were able to scavenge nitrogen from the aromatic amino acids during nitrogen deprivation. Neither AAT1 nor AAT2 was essential for symbiosis with alfalfa.     

Aspartate aminotransferase activity is required for aspartate catabolism and symbiotic nitrogen fixation in Rhizobium meliloti.

A mutant of Rhizobium meliloti, 4R3, which is unable to grow on aspartate has been isolated. The defect is specific to aspartate utilization, since 4R3 is not an auxotroph and grows as well as its parent strain on other carbon and nitrogen sources. The defect was correlated with an inability to fix nitrogen within nodules formed on alfalfa. Transport of aspartate into the mutant cells was found to be normal. Analysis of enzymes involved in aspartate catabolism showed a significantly lower level of aspartate aminotransferase activity in cell extracts of 4R3 than in the wild type. Two unrelated regions identified from a genomic cosmid bank each complemented the aspartate catabolism and symbiotic defects in 4R3. One of the cosmids was found to encode an aspartate aminotransferase enzyme and resulted in restoration of aspartate aminotransferase activity in the mutant. Analysis of the region cloned in this cosmid by transposon mutagenesis showed that mutations within this region generate the original mutant phenotypes. The second type of cosmid was found to encode an aromatic aminotransferase enzyme and resulted in highly elevated levels of aromatic aminotransferase activity. This enzyme apparently compensated for the mutation by its ability to partially utilize aspartate as a substrate. These findings demonstrate that R. meliloti contains an aspartate aminotransferase activity required for symbiotic nitrogen fixation and implicate aspartate as an essential substrate for bacteria in the nodule.