The effect of superparasitism on development of the solitary parasitoid wasp, Venturia canescens (Hymenoptera: Ichneumonidae)

Abstract.

• 1 The effects of superparasitism on the rate of development, adult size and mortality of Venturia canescens (Hymenoptera: Ichneumonidae) were investigated. Parasitoids were reared from third (L3) and fifth (L5) instars of one of its hosts, Plodia interpunctella (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae) containing one, two or four parasitoid eggs.
• 2 Superparasitism increased the development time of Venturia reared from both instars, but the developmental delay was more evident in wasps from L5 hosts.
• 3 The size of parasitoids from L3 hosts was unaffected by egg number, but wasps from both superparasitized L5 treatments were significantly smaller than those from singly parasitized hosts.
• 4 Parasitoid mortality was significantly higher in L5 than L3, but within instars did not differ significantly with egg number.
• 5 The results confirm that superparasitism may affect the fitness of both the adult female wasp and her progeny, and should therefore be incorporated into models of superparasitism as an adaptive foraging strategy.

     

Self and conspecific superparasitism by the solitary parasitoid Antrocephalus pandens

Abstract.

• 1 The fitness consequences of superparasitism for a solitary parasitoid depend on whether the host was first parasitized by itself (‘self-superparasitism’) or a different individual (‘conspecific superparasitism’). Self superparasitism is usually expected to be avoided.
• 2 A.pandens females showed no difference in their probability of superparasitism between self-parasitized and conspecifically-parasitized hosts. The probability of superparasitism decreased as time from the laying of the first egg in a host increased, from about 0.29–0.46 at a time interval of 1 h to 0.10–0.14 at 72 h.
• 3 The egg distribution of wasps foraging alone on a patch showed significant avoidance of superparasitism, but that of wasps foraging in the presence of conspecifics was not significantly different from a random distribution. This suggests that wasps switch from avoidance of superparasitism when alone to acceptance of all hosts when in a group.
• 4 When wasps foraged in a group, the hosts had many more ovipositor puncture marks than when wasps foraged singly. This suggests that either hosts were attacked several times per encounter, or that the wasps' encounter rate with hosts was much higher when in a group. If the latter is true, it is possible that, although the egg distribution suggested a higher rate of superparasitism when wasps foraged in a group, the ratio of acceptances to contacts of parasitized hosts may in fact have been lower.

     

Phenoloxidase-like activities and the function of virus-like particles in ovaries of the parthenogenetic parasitoid Venturia canescens

The ichneumonid endoparasitoid Venturia canescens successfully develops inside the hemocoel of another insect by using maternal protein secretions, including nucleic acid-free virus-like particles (VLPs), to manipulate host physiology. These VLPs consist of four major proteins, which are produced mainly in the calyx tissue and transferred into the host insect together with the egg. One of the protein-coding genes (vlp1), with similarities to phospholipid-hydroperoxide glutathione peroxidases (PHGPx), exists in allelic forms producing two protein variants with different protein properties. Here, we summarise observations indicating that oocytes and eggs are the source of reactive electrons, which potentially damage the lining and membranes of calyx tissues. We discuss the possible role of VLP1 in counteracting the damaging effects of oxidised phospholipids on membranes surrounding VLPs in the calyx lumen.     

Host behaviour and its influence on foraging and acceptance by the solitary parasitoid wasp,Venturia canescens (Hym: Ichneumonidae)

Behavioural interactions between the solitary koinobiont parasitoid,Venturia canescens, and two of its hosts,Plodia interpunctella andCorcyra cephalonica, were investigated. The response of both hosts to simulated antennation using a two-haired brush was examined over instars 3 (L3) to 5 (L5). YoungP. interpunctella larvae predominantly adopted escape tactics (writhe, trash) whereas L5P. interpunctella usually froze after the stimulus was applied. L3C. cephalonica larvae were more aggressive (headrear, flick) thanP. interpunctella in response to the application of the stimulus, but olderC. cephalonica responded less aggressively than in earlier instars. AlthoughV. canescens readily jabbed its ovipositor at both hosts after antennation,P. interpunctella was considerably more susceptible to parasitoid attack thanC. cephalonica, irrespective of size in the final (L5) instar.C. cephalonica, the larger, more aggressive host, actively resisted parasitism whereasP. interpunctella responded much more passively after parasitoid contact. Parasitoids examined and jabbed their ovipositors at dead hosts, but this behaviour was not sustained, implying that host movement stimulates parasitoid attack. On patches containingV. canescens, L5C. cephalonica andP. interpunctella, mostP. interpunctella larvae responded by freezing after parasitoid contact.P. interpunctella that froze usually avoided parasitism, whereas larvae that attempted to escape by crawling were pursued with vigour byV. canescens and usually parasitized. Irrespective of behaviour after parasitoid contact,C. cephalonia displayed more aggressive behaviour and had much greater success in warding off parasitoid attack. Host acceptance byV. canescens is clearly affected by the size and species of the host it attacks. The influence of host defensive behaviour is discussed in relation to the evolution of parasitoid counter-defences and oviposition strategies.     

Asymmetric larval competition between two species of solitary parasitoid wasps: the influence of superparasitism

Abstract.

• 1 We test the hypothesis that a solitary parasitoid wasp may gain in fitness if she lays more eggs in a host.
• 2 Using heterospecific superparasitism (=multiparasitism) between the solitary aphid parasitoids, Aphidius smithi Sharma & Subba Rao and Ephedrus californicus Baker, we show that (i) a superparasitizing female's chance that her offspring will survive competition is an increasing function of egg density, and (ii) survival among same-aged larvae is independent of the oviposition sequence.
• 3 These findings on asymmetric larval competition provide indirect evidence that supports two fundamental, but untested, assumptions underlying models of adaptive superparasitism between conspecific wasps.

     

The temporal effects of Dufour's gland secretion in host discrimination by Nemeritis canescens

Behavioural experiments with Nemeritis canescens Grav. have demonstrated that the secretions from its Dufour's gland are used as a marker pheromone which can affect the behaviour of other wasps towards host caterpillars bearing it. The external marker is produced within the complex of secretions from the Dufour's gland and has oviposition deterrent effect which lasts approximately 32 h after deposition.The sequence of behaviour patterns shown by individual Nemeritis is described and shows a significant increase in escape and avoidance reactions towards Ephestia caterpillars treated topically with the Dufour's gland contents.This paper presents evidence for the first time to indicate that Nemeritis reacts to an external marker as well as to an internal one. Similar behaviour towards filter paper treated topically with contents of whole Dufour's gland and its component heneicosane contribute evidence for the conclusion that the gland contents influence the wasp's behaviour and hence its avoidance of superparasitism of its host.

---

Effets temporels de la sécrétion de la glande de Dufour sur la sélection des hôtes par Nemeritis canescens grav

Résumé Des expériences sur le comportement de N. canescens ont montré que les sécrétions de la glande de Dufour sont utilisées comme phéromone de marquage pouvant affecter le comportement des autres hyménoptères face aux chenilles contaminées. Ce maqueur externe est produit à partir des sécrétions de la glande de Dufour, il a un effet dissuasif qui dure environ 32 heures après son émission.La séquence des actes comportementaux de Nemeritis montre un accroissement significatif de réactions de fuite et d'évitement face à des chenilles d'Ephestia traitées superficiellement avec du contenu des glandes de Dufour.Cet article prouve pour la première fois que Nemeritis réagit aussi bien à des marqueurs externes qu'internes. Un comportement analogue vis à vis de papier filtre imprégné du contenu des glandes de Dufour et de son constituant hénéicosane constitue une preuve que le contenu de la glande influe sur le comportement de l'hymenoptère et ainsi lui évite de superparasiter ses hôtes.

     

Adaptive self- and conspecific superparasitism in the solitary parasitoid Leptopilina heterotoma (Hymenoptera: Eucoilidae)

One of the foraging decisions facing parasitoids is whetherto accept (superparasitize) or reject hosts that have alreadybeen parasitized. An important distinction is whether the hosthas been parasitized by the female parasitoid herself or bya conspecific. In solitary parasitoids, the pay-off from anegg laid in the latter host type (conspecific superparasitism)is the probability that the second egg wins the competitionfor the host and results in an offspring. The pay-off from anegg laid in the former type (self-superparasitism) increaseswith an increasing probability that another female will superparasitizethe host in the near future. When this probability equals one,self-superparasitism and conspecific superparasitism have thesame payoff. However, conspecific superparasitism will generallyhave a higher pay-off than self-superparasitism. It will thereforebe beneficial for a female parasitoid to be able to distinguishbetween a host she parasitized and one parasitized by a conspecific.The degree of benefit depends on the probability of conspecificsuperparasitism in the near future. Using an optimal diet model,I show that when a parasitoid encounters a patch containinga mixture of unparasitized and already-parasitized hosts, afemale that can distinguish between the two types of parasitizedhosts gains more offspring than a female without this ability.However, when parasitoids search a patch together with conspecifics,it is adaptive to self-superparasitize, and the pay-off fromthis ability may be negligible. It is therefore predicted thatwhen a female parasitoid searches a partially depleted patchalone, it will reject the hosts parasitized by itself more frequentlythan hosts parasitized by conspecifics. In contrast, femaleparasitoids searching together are predicted to accept hoststhat they parasitized themselves much more often. The resultsshow that the solitary parasitoid Leptopilina heterotoma (Hymenoptera:Eucoilidae) is able to distinguish between hosts that it parasitizedand hosts parasitized by conspecifics. The predictions of themodel are met in a second experiment that shows that L. heterotomaself-superparasitizes when the probability of conspecific superparasitismis high.     

Self and conspecific superparasitism by the egg parasitoid Trichogramma evanescens

Superparasitism is a widespread phenomenon in insect parasitoids and may be advantageous in certain circumstances. In this paper, we distinguish two kinds of superparasitism with different adaptive consequences for an ovipositing parasitoid: self superparasitism, where a parasitoid oviposits in a host in which she has previously oviposited, and conspecific superparasitism, where she oviposits in a host containing egg(s) from a previous oviposition by a conspecific. Our studies on Trichogramma evanescens Westwood show that females lay smaller clutches on parasitized than on healthy hosts but make the same overall allocation of males and females, although the sequence of sexes during oviposition differs. No difference was found between allocation in self and conspecific superparasitism. These results are discussed in the light of theories for progeny and sex allocation.

---

Selbst- und konspezifisch-superparasitismus durch die schlupfwespe Trichogramma evanescens

Zusammenfassung Superparasitismus ist ein weitverbreitetes Phänomen in Parasitoiden von Insekten und es kann unter bestimmten Umständen vorteilhaft sein. Diese Arbeit macht Unterschied zwischen zwei Formen von Superparasitismus, jeder mit seiner eigenen adaptiven Konsequenz für die parasitierende Schlupfwespe: Selbst-Superparasitismus, wenn eine Schlupfwespe einen Wirt parasitiert die sie vorher selbst parasitiert hat, und Konspezifisch-Superparasitismus, wenn sie einen Wirt parasitiert die vorher von einem Artgenossen parasitiert worden ist. Unsere Untersuchungen an Trichogramma evanescens zeigen dass die Weibchen auf den belegten Wirten, aber das Gesamtverhältnis von männlichen und weiblichen Brut ist dasselbe, obschon die Reihenfolge in den die Eier der beiden Geschlechte abgelegt werden sich underscheiden. Keinen Unterschied wurde gefunden zwischen die Ablegung während elbst-Superparasitismus und Konspezifisch-Superparasitismus. Diese Ergebnisse werden diskutiert im Rahmen der Theorien für die Belegung des Wirtes in bezug auf die Anzahl und das Geschlecht der Eier.

     

Incidence of superparasitism in the egg parasitoid,Ooencyrtus kuvanae Howard (Hymenoptera: Encyrtidae)

The encyrtid Ooencyrtus kuvanae is a solitary parasitoid of the gypsy moth, Lymantria dispar L. (Lepidoptera-Lymantridae) that is used in biological control programmes and whose mass rearing is influenced by superparasitism. The purpose of this study was to investigate the effect of the self-superparasitism of O. kuvanae at different host densities (5, 10, 15 and 20), female ages (3 and 5 days) and durations of exposure (1 and 5 days) under various laboratory conditions (25°C?±?1°C, RH 60?±?5% and a 16:8?h light:dark photoperiod) as well as in a new laboratory host, Philosamia ricini (Danovan) (Lepidoptera: Saturniidae) of O. kuvanae. In this study, we determined the rate of egg superparasitism and adult emergence and recorded development time, longevity and body weight. Superparasitism increased with female age and the duration of exposure to parasitoids when females had access to five host eggs. Superparasitism increased the number of parasitoid offspring, but it resulted in male-biased (56.90%) progeny. Furthermore, superparasitism caused deleterious effects to the fitness of the progeny by prolonging the developmental process, and decreasing longevity. For example, we found that when four adults can emerge from one superparasitised host egg, the body size of the parasitoid offspring decreases significantly. Hence, superparasitism should be avoided when mass rearing O. kuvanae.     

Geographical distribution and genetic relatedness of sympatrical thelytokous and arrhenotokous populations of the parasitoid Venturia canescens (Hymenoptera)

Theory predicts that asexual reproduction has a competitive advantage over sexual reproduction because of the twofold cost of producing males. Few systems are suitable for directly testing this prediction. In the solitary parasitoid wasp Venturia canescens both arrhenotokously (sexual) and thelytokously (asexual) reproducing individuals occur sympatrically. We sampled 922 wasps from 22 localities along the coast of south‐eastern France. Thelytokous wasps were less abundant (23%) than arrhenotokous wasps and were almost always found in sympatry with arrhenotokous ones. An analysis of genetic relatedness using amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) markers showed the existence of a widespread thelytokous clone. In addition, a few thelytokous individuals were found to be closely related to arrhenotokous ones and vice versa. These data suggest the occurrence of occasional gene flow between both reproductive modes and/or recurrent origin of thelytokous clones from coexisting arrhenotokous populations in the area. The results are discussed in the context of the paradox of sex.     

Fitness consequences of superparasitism and mechanism of host discrimination in the stemborer parasitoid Cotesia flavipes

The fitness consequences of superparasitism and the mechanism of host discrimination in Cotesia flavipes, a larval parasitoid of concealed stemborer larvae was investigated. Naive females readily superparasitized and treated the already parasitized host as an unparasitized host by allocating the same amount of eggs as in an unparasitized host. However, there was no significant increase in the number of emerging parasitoids from superparasitized hosts due to substantial mortality of parasitoid offspring in superparasitized hosts. Furthermore, the developmental time of the parasitoids in a superparasitized host was significantly longer than in a singly parasitized host and the emerging progeny were significantly smaller (body length and head width). Naive females entered a tunnel in which the host was parasitized 4 h previously and accepted it for oviposition. Experienced females (oviposition experience in unparasitized host) refused to enter a tunnel with a host parasitized by herself or by another female. In experiments where the tunnel and/or host was manipulated it was demonstrated that the female leaves a mark in the tunnel when she parasitizes a host. The role of patch marking in C. flavipes is discussed in relation to the ecology of the parasitoid.     

Egg load and adaptive superparasitism in Anaphes nitens, an egg parasitoid of the Eucalyptus snout-beetle Gonipterus scutellatus

We studied egg production and the occurrence of adaptive superparasitism in Anaphes nitens, an egg parasitoid of the Eucalyptus snout beetle Gonipterus scutellatus. First, we determined whether A. nitens females were synovigenic or pro‐ovigenic. Newly emerged females were allowed to lay eggs alone during 3 days on six fresh egg capsules. A first group of females (n = 25) were killed by freezing and the remaining females (n = 21) were maintained during two extra days with food, but without hosts. Their fecundity was measured by dissection of host eggs and females’ ovarioles. We found that the second group of females increased their fecundity by about 20%, suggesting they were weakly synovigenic. To test for the occurrence of adaptive superparasitism in relation to competitors’ density, we compared the oviposition behaviour of females kept alone, in pairs, or in groups of four during patch visit. Results indicated that the females superparasited significantly more often in this last treatment. Synovigeny and the ability to modulate the use of superparasitism could be mentioned as important attributes that allow A. nitens to efficiently control the pest population.     

The effect of egg load on superparasitism by the snowberry fly

In studies conducted with fruits of the host plant, Symphoricarpus albus (L.), we examine the influence of egg load on the oviposition behaviour of Rhagoletis zephyria Snow (Diptera:Tephritidae). By altering the availability of exogenous protein, three classes of females with progressively increasing egg loads were produced, while keeping confounding factors such as age, experience, and mating status constant. Flies from all three classes were randomly presented with either a pheromone marked fruit, or with an unmarked fruit. Results indicate that increased egg load led to a greater propensity to accept, or superparasitize, the pheromone marked fruit. Upon dissection it was revealed that females which superparasitized had a mean egg load of 19.5 eggs (n=22), while females which rejected marked fruit had a mean egg load of 13.5 eggs (n=26). These results are consistent with the theory of adaptive superparasitism.     

The α-amylase inhibitor acarbose does not affect the parasitoid Venturia canescens when incorporated into the diet of its host Ephestia kuehniella

Amylase inhibitors (AIs) are suitable candidates for protecting plants and their products from attacks by herbivorous and granivorous insects. However, detailed studies of the suppressive effects of AIs on target and non‐target insects are necessary before their application in post‐harvest protection. To address this issue, laboratory bioassays were used to test the effect of the non‐proteinaceous inhibitor acarbose on a stored product pest, the flour moth Ephestia kuehniella (Zeller) (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae), and its parasitoid Venturia canescens (Gravenhorst) (Hymenoptera: Ichneumonidae). Two sublethal concentrations (0.001 and 0.0001%, wt/wt) of acarbose were incorporated into the diet of parasitized and unparasitized larvae of E. kuehniella. Development time and fresh body weight of the larvae, together with the size of the wasps, were compared for insects reared on acarbose‐treated and control diets. On the diet containing 0.001% acarbose, the developmental time was longer and relative weight gains of the E. kuehniella larvae were lower, but the weight of the larvae prior to pupation was similar to that of the control. The acarbose did not have a suppressive effect on the parasitoid V. canescens; in fact the wasps that emerged from the hosts reared on a diet containing 0.0001% acarbose were on average larger and heavier than the controls. These results demonstrate that it might be possible to enhance the control of stored product pests by using both biological control and AIs.     

Egg distributions and the information a solitary parasitoid has and uses for its oviposition decisions

Approximately three decades ago the question was first answered whether parasitoids are able to assess the number or origin of eggs in a host for a solitary parasitoid, Leptopilina heterotoma, by fitting theoretically derived distributions to empirical ones. We extend the set of different theoretically postulated distributions of eggs among hosts by combining searching modes and abilities in assessing host quality. In the models, parasitoids search either randomly (Poisson) (1) or by vibrotaxis (Negative Binomial) (2). Parasitoids are: (a) assumed to treat all hosts equally, (b) able to distinguish them in unparasitised and parasitised hosts only, (c) able to distinguish them by the number of eggs they contained, or (d) able to recognise their own eggs. Mathematically tractable combinations of searching mode (1 and 2) and abilities (a,b,c,d) result in seven different models (M1a, M1b, M1c, M1d, M2a, M2b and M2c). These models have been simulated for a varying number of searching parasitoids and various mean numbers of eggs per host. Each resulting distribution is fitted to all theoretical models. The model with the minimum Akaike's information criterion (AIC) is chosen as the best fitting for each simulated distribution. We thus investigate the power of the AIC and for each distribution with a specified mean number of eggs per host we derive a frequency distribution for classification.Firstly, we discuss the simulations of models including random search (M1a, M1b, M1c and M1d). For M1a, M1c and M1d the simulated distributions are correctly classified in at least 70% of all cases. However, in a few cases model M1b is only properly classified for intermediate mean values of eggs per host. The models including vibrotaxis as searching behaviour (M2a, M2b and M2c) cannot be distinguished from those with random search if the mean number of eggs per host is low. Among the models incorporating vibrotaxis the three abilities are detected analogously as in models with random search.Experiments with two species of solitary parasitoids (L. heterotoma and Asobara tabida) are conducted. All theoretically postulated distributions are separately fitted to the resulting experimental egg distributions. The AIC criterion is used to choose the best fitting theoretical distribution. For both parasitoid species the frequency distribution of best fitting models for experimental data is compared to the classification of distributions generated by simulations. This leads to the conclusion that both L. heterotoma and A. tabida are able to distinguish between parasitised and unparasitised hosts. For L. heterotoma the results point to an ability to assess the number of eggs in a host, whereas A. tabida does not seem to have this ability. This difference suggests that an egg is more valuable for L. heterotoma than for A. tabida.     

The effects of host age and superparasitism by the parasitoid, Microplitis rufiventris on the cellular and humoral immune response of Spodoptera littoralis larvae

To study the dynamics of stage-dependent immune responses in Spodoptera littoralis (Boisd.) larvae (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae), single and superparasitism experiments were carried out using the parasitoid Microplitis rufiventris Kok. (Braconidae: Hymenoptera). Compared to younger (preferred) host larvae, the older (non-preferred) host larvae displayed a vigorous humoral response that often damaged and destroyed the single wasp egg or larva. Superparasitism and host age altered both the cellular and humoral immune responses. Younger host larvae showed a stronger encapsulation response compared to older host larvae. Moreover encapsulation rates in younger hosts (e.g., second instar) decreased with increasing numbers of parasitoid eggs deposited/larvae. In older larvae, the encapsulation rate was low in fourth, less in fifth and absent in sixth instar hosts. Conversely, the order and magnitude of the cellular immune response in S. littoralis hosts were highest in second instar larvae with the first instar larvae being a little lower. The immune response steadily decreased from the third through to the fifth instar and was least obvious in the sixth instar. In contrast, the general humoral immune response was most pronounced in sixth instar larvae and diminished towards younger stages. The results suggest that both cellular and humoral responses are stage-dependent. Wasp offspring in younger superparasitized host larvae fought for host supremacy with only one wasp surviving, while supernumerary wasp larvae generally survived in older superparasitized larvae, but were unable to complete development. Older instars seem to have a method for immobilizing/killing wasp larvae that is not operating in the younger instars.     

Descriptions of superparasitism by optimal foraging theory,evolutionarily stable strategies and quantitative genetics

Many parasitoids superparasitize, in which an insect attacks a previously parasitized host, laying an egg in the host even though only one offspring will emerge from the host. In this paper superparasitism is considered from the perspectives of optimal foraging theory, evolutionarily stable strategies, and quantitative genetics. The focal question is: at what point in its life should an individual parasitoid begin attacking previously parasitized hosts? Each of the three theoretical methods can be used to answer the question and by doing so, we see how the three methods are connected. Qualitative, empirical predictions based on the theories are described.