Impaired endochondral bone development and osteopenia in Gli2-deficient mice

Mice homozygous for targeted disruption of the zinc finger domain of Gli2 (Gli2(zfd/zfd)) die at birth with developmental defects in several organ systems including the skeleton. The current studies were undertaken to define the role of Gli2 in endochondral bone development by characterizing the molecular defects in the limbs and vertebrae of Gli2(zfd/zfd) mice. The bones of mutant mice removed by cesarian section at E16.5 and E18.5 demonstrated delayed endochondral ossification. This was accompanied by an increase in the length of cartilaginous growth plates, reduced bone tissue in the femur and tibia and by failure to develop the primary ossification centre in vertebral bodies. The growth plates of tibiae and vertebrae exhibited increased numbers of proliferating and hypertrophic chondrocytes with no apparent alteration in matrix mineralisation. The changes in growth plate morphology were accompanied by an increase in expression of FGF2 in proliferating chondrocytes and decreased expression of Indian hedgehog (Ihh), patched (Ptc) and parathyroid-hormone-related protein (PTHrP) in prehypertrophic cells. Furthermore, there was a reduction in expression of angiogenic molecules in hypertrophic chondrocytes, which was accompanied by a decrease in chondroclasts at the cartilage bone interface, fewer osteoblasts lining trabecular surfaces and a reduced volume of metaphyseal bone. These results indicate that functional Gli2 is necessary for normal endochondral bone development and that its absence results in increased proliferation of immature chondrocytes and decreased resorption of mineralised cartilage and bone formation.     

Cranial osteogenesis in Monodelphis domestica (Didelphidae) and Macropus eugenii (Macropodidae)

The pattern of onset and general rate of cranial ossification are compared in two marsupials, Monodelphis domestica (Didelphidae) and Macropus eugenii (Macropodidae). In both species a similar suite of bones is present at birth, specifically those surrounding the oral cavity and the exoccipital, and in both postnatal events follow a similar course. The facial skeleton matures more rapidly than the neurocranium, which is characterized by an extended period of ossification. Most dermal bones begin ossification before most endochondral bones. Endochondral bones of the neurocranium are particularly extended in both the period of onset of ossification and the rate of ossification. These data confirm suggestions that morphology at birth is conservative in marsupials and we hypothesize that the pattern of cranial osteogenesis is related to two distinct demands. Bones that are accelerated in marsupials are correlated with a number of functional adaptations including head movements during migration, attachment to the teat, and suckling. However, the very slow osteogenesis of the neurocranium is probably correlated with the very extended period of neurogenesis. Marsupials appear to be derived relative to both monotreme and placental mammals in the precocious ossification of the bones surrounding the oral cavity, but share with monotremes an extended period of neurocranial osteogenesis. © 1993 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Epigenetic mechanical factors in the evolution of long bone epiphyses

In developing vertebrate long bones in which endochondral ossification occurs, it is preceded or accompanied by perichondral ossification. The speed and extent of perichondral apposition relative to endochondral ossification varies in different taxa. Perichondral ossification dominates early long bone development in extinct basal tetrapods and dinosaurs, extant bony fish, amphibians, and birds. In mammals and lizards, perichondral and endochondral ossification proceed more synchronously. One of the most important epigenetic factors in skeletogenesis is mechanical loading caused by muscle contractions which begin in utero or in ovo . It has been previously shown that the stress distributions created perinatally in the chondroepiphysis during human skeletal development can influence the appearance of secondary ossification centres. Using finite element computer models representing bones near birth or hatching, we demonstrate that in vertebrates in which perichondral ossification significantly precedes endochondral ossification, the distribution of mechanical stresses in the ossifying cartilage anlagen tends to inhibit the appearance of secondary ossification centres in the ends of long bones. In models representing vertebrates in which endochondral ossification keeps pace with perichondral apposition, the appearance of secondary centres is promoted. The appearance of secondary centres leads to the formation of bony epiphyses and growth plates, which are most common in mammals and extant lizards. We postulate that genotypic factors influencing the relative speed and extent of perichondral and endochondral ossification interact with mechanical epigenetic factors early in development to account for many of the morphological differences observed in vertebrate skeletons.     

Skeletal development--Wnts are in control

Approximately 200 individual skeletal elements, which differ in shape and size, are the building blocks of the vertebrate skeleton. Various features of the individual skeletal elements, such as their location, shape, growth and differentiation rate, are being determined during embryonic development. A few skeletal elements, such as the lateral halves of the clavicle and parts of the skull are formed by a process called intramembranous ossification, whereby mesenchymal cells differentiate directly into osteoblasts, while the majority of skeletal elements are formed via endochondral ossification. The latter process starts with the formation of a cartilaginous template, which eventually is being replaced by bone. This requires co-regulation of differentiation of the cell-types specific for cartilage and bone, chondrocytes and osteoblasts, respectively. In recent years it has been demonstrated that Wnt family members and their respective intracellular pathways, such as non-canonical and the canonical Wnt/beta-catenin pathway, play important and diverse roles during different steps of vertebrate skeletal development. Based on the recent discoveries modulation of the canonical Wnt-signaling pathway could be an interesting approach to direct stem cells into certain skeletal lineages.     

Sequence of ossification in the skeleton of growing and metamorphosing tadpoles of Rana pipiens

The order of ossification of bones in the skeleton of Rana pipiens during larval growth and metamorphosis has been determined from observations on specimens fixed in 70% alcohol and stained with alizarin red S. The axial skeleton ossifies in a generally cephalo-caudal sequence, beginning with the parasphenoid bone at Taylor-Kollros stages IV-IX, followed by vertebrae (V-IX) and then the urostyle (IX-XIV). Exoccipitals (VII-IX), frontoparietals (XI-XII) and prootics (XIII-XVII) are additional cranial bones which successively ossify before metamorphosis. With the onset of metamorphosis at stage XVIII jawbones and rostral bones of the skull ossify in the following succession: premaxilla, maxilla, septomaxilla, nasal, dentary, angular, squamosal, pterygoid, prevomer, mentomeckelian, quadratojugal, palatine, columella, posteromedial process of “hyoid.” The sphenethmoid does not ossify until after metamorphosis. Ossification of limbbones begins with the femur or humerus at stages X-XII and progresses proximo-distally to the phalanges by stages XIII-XV. Carpals, however, do not ossify until stage XXV or after metamorphosis. The ilium of the pelvic girdle begins to ossify at stages X-XII, but the ischium is delayed until stages XX-XXIII. Scapula and coracoid of the pectoral girdle undergo initial ossification at stages XII-XIV, suprascapula and clavicle at stages XIII-XV. The sternum does not begin to ossify until stage XXIV. The possible role of thyroid hormones in stimulating osteogenesis is discussed.     

Cross-talk between FGF and other cytokine signalling pathways during endochondral bone development

FGF (fibroblast growth factor)/FGFR (FGF receptor) signalling plays an essential role in both endochondral and intramembranous bone development. FGF signalling pathways are important for the earliest stages of limb development and throughout skeletal development. The activity and the outcome of this signalling pathway during bone development are also influenced by many other intracellular and extracellular signals. In this review, we focus on the interplay between FGF signalling and other pathways, which is tightly regulated both spatially and temporally during endochondral skeletal development.     

Comparison of clavicular joints in human and laboratory rat

The human clavicle provides the bony connection between the upper extremity and the axial skeleton and it is reported to be among the first bones ossified and the last bone to fuse. Clavicle development of the studied mammals shows a combination of intramembranous and endochondrial ossification. The covering of its joints in adult humans differs from other joints of long bones. The rat clavicle pattern morphologically appears to be partly different in comparison with the human one. These differences partially restrict the use of the rat as a model for the study of human articular cartilage but on the other hand they can provide some valuable possibilities for application in medical research and practice.     

The development of the clavicle in man

The development of the human clavicle was studied in 50 to 60 d old human embryos. Our findings are summarized as follows: The whole clavicle develops from a cartilaginous anlage. In the middle part of the clavicle, an osseus cuff develops very early by the ossification in the perichondrium. In the lumen of this cuff, a cartilaginous cork persists which is resorbed and replaced by bone and marrow later than in other bones. It is possible that cartilaginous nests may persist in the middle part of the clavicle. In both extremities of the clavicle, the normal enchondral ossification exists as it is described in other anlages. It is difficult to explicate the syndrome of the cleido-facial and cleido-cranial dysostoses only as disturbances of the endesmal ossification.     

Glycogen synthase kinase 3 controls endochondral bone development: contribution of fibroblast growth factor 18

Glycogen synthase kinase 3 (GSK3) inhibits signaling pathways that are essential for bone development. To study the requirement for GSK activity during endochondral bone development, we inhibited GSK3 in cultured metatarsal bones with pharmacological antagonists. Interestingly, we find that inhibition of GSK3 strongly repressed chondrocyte and perichondrial osteoblast differentiation. Moreover, chondrocyte proliferation was inhibited, whereas perichondrial cell proliferation was stimulated. These results mirror the effects of fibroblast growth factor signaling (FGF), suggesting the FGF expression is induced. Indeed, we showed that (1) FGF18 expression is stimulated following inhibition of GSK3 and (2) GSK3 regulates FGF18 expression through the control of beta-catenin levels. Stimulation of cultured metatarsal with FGF18 had similar effects on the differentiation and proliferation of chondrocytes and perichondrial cells as GSK3 repression. This suggests that the regulation of FGF18 expression is a major function of GSK3 during endochondral bone development. Consistent with this, we showed that the effect of GSK3 inhibition on chondrocyte proliferation is repressed in tissues lacking a receptor for FGF18, FGF receptor 3.     

Regulation of skeletogenic differentiation in cranial dermal bone

Although endochondral ossification of the limb and axial skeleton is relatively well-understood, the development of dermal (intramembranous) bone featured by many craniofacial skeletal elements is not nearly as well-characterized. We analyzed the expression domains of a number of markers that have previously been associated with endochondral skeleton development to define the cellular transitions involved in the dermal ossification process in both chick and mouse. This led to the recognition of a series of distinct steps in the dermal differentiation pathways, including a unique cell type characterized by the expression of both osteogenic and chondrogenic markers. Several signaling molecules previously implicated in endochondrial development were found to be expressed during specific stages of dermal bone formation. Three of these were studied functionally using retroviral misexpression. We found that activity of bone morphogenic proteins (BMPs) is required for neural crest-derived mesenchyme to commit to the osteogenic pathway and that both Indian hedgehog (IHH) and parathyroid hormone-related protein (PTHrP, PTHLH) negatively regulate the transition from preosteoblastic progenitors to osteoblasts. These results provide a framework for understanding dermal bone development with an aim of bringing it closer to the molecular and cellular resolution available for the endochondral bone development.     

Matrix remodeling during endochondral ossification

Endochondral ossification, the process by which most of the skeleton is formed, is a powerful system for studying various aspects of the biological response to degraded extracellular matrix (ECM). In addition, the dependence of endochondral ossification upon neovascularization and continuous ECM remodeling provides a good model for studying the role of the matrix metalloproteases (MMPs) not only as simple effectors of ECM degradation but also as regulators of active signal-inducers for the initiation of endochondral ossification. The daunting task of elucidating their specific role during endochondral ossification has been facilitated by the development of mice deficient for various members of this family. Here, we discuss the ECM and its remodeling as one level of molecular regulation for the process of endochondral ossification, with special attention to the MMPs.     

Skeletal development in the Chinese soft‐shelled turtle Pelodiscus sinensis (Testudines: Trionychidae)

We investigated the development of the whole skeleton of the soft‐shelled turtle Pelodiscus sinensis, with particular emphasis on the pattern and sequence of ossification. Ossification starts at late Tokita‐Kuratani stage (TK) 18 with the maxilla, followed by the dentary and prefrontal. The quadrate is the first endoskeletal ossification and appears at TK stage 22. All adult skull elements have started ossification by TK stage 25. Plastral bones are the first postcranial bones to ossify, whereas the nuchal is the first carapacial bone to ossify, appearing as two unstained anlagen. Extensive examination of ossification sequences among autopodial elements reveals much intraspecific variation. Patterns of ossification of cranial dermal elements are more variable than those of endochondral elements, and dermal elements ossify before endochondral ones. Differences in ossification sequences with Apalone spinifera include: in Pelodiscus sinensis the jugal develops relatively early and before the frontal, whereas it appears later in A. spinifera; the frontal appears shortly before the parietal in A. spinifera whereas in P. sinensis the parietal appears several stages before the frontal. Chelydrids exhibit an early development of the postorbital bone and the palatal elements as compared to trionychids. Integration of the onset of ossification data into an analysis of the sequence of skeletal ossification in cryptodirans using the event‐pairing and Parsimov methods reveals heterochronies, some of which reflect the hypothesized phylogeny considered taxa. A functional interpretation of heterochronies is speculative. In the chondrocranium there is no contact between the nasal capsules and planum supraseptale via the sphenethmoid commissurae. The pattern of chondrification of forelimb and hind limb elements is consistent with a primary axis and digital arch. There is no evidence of anterior condensations distal to the radius and tibia. A pattern of quasi‐ simultaneity is seen in the chondrogenesis of the forelimb and the hind limb. J. Morphol. 2009. © 2009 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Cellular and molecular interactions regulating skeletogenesis

Skeletal development involves complex coordination among multiple cell types and tissues. In long bones, a cartilage template surrounded by the perichondrium is first laid down and is subsequently replaced by bone marrow and bone, during a process named endochondral ossification. Cells in the cartilage template and the surrounding perichondrium are derived from mesenchymal cells, which condense locally. In contrast, many cell types that make up mature bone and in particular the bone marrow are brought in by the vasculature. Three tissues appear to be the main players in the initiation of endochondral ossification: the cartilage, the adjacent perichondrium, and the invading vasculature. Interactions among these tissues are synchronized by a large number of secreted and intracellular factors, many of which have been identified in the past 10 years. Some of these factors primarily control cartilage differentiation, while others regulate bone formation and/or angiogenesis. Understanding how these factors operate during skeletal development through the analyses of genetically altered mice depends on being able to distinguish the effect of these molecules on the different cell types that comprise the skeleton. This review will discuss the complexity of skeletal phenotypes, which arises from the tightly regulated, complex interactions among the three tissues involved in bone development. Specific examples illustrate how gene functions may be further assessed using new approaches including genetic and tissue manipulations.     

Regulation of cartilage formation and maturation by mitogen-activated protein kinase signaling

The majority of bones comprising the adult vertebrate skeleton are generated from hyaline cartilage templates that form during embryonic development. A process known as endochondral ossification is responsible for the conversion of these transient cartilage anlagen into mature, calcified bone. Endochondral ossification is a highly regulated, multistep cell specification program involving the initial differentiation of prechondrogenic mesenchymal cells into hyaline chondrocytes, terminal differentiation of hyaline chondrocytes into hypertrophic chondrocytes, and finally, apoptosis of hypertrophic chondrocytes followed by bone matrix deposition. Recently, extensive research has been carried out describing roles for the three major mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) signaling pathways, the extracellular signal-regulated kinase 1/2 (ERK1/2), p38, and c-jun N-terminal kinase (JNK) pathways, in the successive stages of chondrogenic differentiation. In this review, we survey this research examining the involvement of ERK1/2, p38, and JNK pathway signaling in all aspects of the chondrogenic differentiation program from embryonic through postnatal stages of development. In addition, we summarize evidence from in vitro studies examining MAPK function in immortalized chondrogenic cell lines and adult mesenchymal stem cells. We also provide suggestions for future studies that may help ameliorate existing confusion concerning the specific roles of MAPK signaling at different stages of chondrogenesis.     

Skeletal growth and chondroid tissue

Membranous and endochondral ossification processes are insufficient to describe all the aspects observed in the growing skeleton. The presence of chondroid tissue that we have identified by means of all modern histological techniques, including those able to detect the different types of collagen, has also to be explained. Present in the mandibular symphysis of either the human or cat fetuses, chondroid tissue has also been observed in the other parts of the mandible, in the sutural areas of the skull and in all the bones of both axial and appendicular skeleton. The differentiation of the mesenchyme into chondroid tissue could probably be related with mechanical forces exerted simultaneously in opposite directions or with a transient ischemia.     

The origin and early development of the clavicle in the quail (Coturnix c. japonica)

Development of the clavicle in the Japanese quail is described in detail and evidence presented for its development in cartilage. Chondroblast cells and the chondroitin sulphate of the cartilage matrix are identified using a toluidine blue-silver impregnation technique. It was found that the cartilage phase is transitory and is rapidly obliterated by the ossification stage. An initial invasion of the cartilage by osteoblasts is followed by deposition of granules of calcified material scattered randomly in the cartilage in the region of the ramus. In the hypocleideum, however, the calcification is initially perichondral, as seen in the initial ossification of the coracoid, but later resembles that of the clavicular ramus, in being random. The pattern of chondrogenesis and'osteogenesis seen in the clavicle suggests an acceleration of the normal process of endochondral ossification with an abbreviation of the cartilage phase. This study reveals that the development of the clavicle in this bird is not dissimilar (as is generally accepted) to that of other skeletal elements of the primary pectoral girdle.