An ultra scale-down approach to assess the impact of the choice of recombinant P. pastoris strain on dewatering performance in centrifuges

Pichia pastoris is becoming a desirable host in the biopharmaceutical industry for therapeutics production. It grows on methanol to high cell densities ≥100 g DCW/L and secretes foreign proteins at high titers. However, the culture conditions to reach high cell densities pose a challenge to the processability by primary recovery operations, in particular centrifugation, used for cell removal. This work aims to assess the impact of recombinant P. pastoris strain selection on centrifugal dewatering. Normally, the choice of P. pastoris recombinant strain is based on best target protein expression levels; however, it is unknown whether the choice of strain will have an impact on performance of centrifugation operation. To achieve this aim, a previously developed laboratory ultra‐scale down (USD) methodology that successfully predicted centrifugal dewatering of pilot‐scale disk‐type machines, was used in this work. Two recombinant P. pastoris strains, namely a X‐33 and a glycoengineered Pichia strain, were used to perform fermentations secreting different products. The resulting harvested fermentation culture properties were analyzed and the dewatering performances of a pilot‐ and a large‐scale disk‐type centrifuge were evaluated using the USD methodology. The choice of P. pastoris strain was found to have a considerable impact on dewatering performance, with P. pastoris X‐33 strain reaching better dewatering levels than the glycoengineered strain. The USD method proved to be a useful tool to determine optimal conditions under which the large scale centrifuge needed to be operated, reducing the need for repeated pilot‐scale runs during early stages of process development for therapeutic products. © 2012 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 28: 1029–1036, 2012     

An automated laboratory‐scale methodology for the generation of sheared mammalian cell culture samples

Continuous disk‐stack centrifugation is typically used for the removal of cells and cellular debris from mammalian cell culture broths at manufacturing‐scale. The use of scale‐down methods to characterise disk‐stack centrifugation performance enables substantial reductions in material requirements and allows a much wider design space to be tested than is currently possible at pilot‐scale. The process of scaling down centrifugation has historically been challenging due to the difficulties in mimicking the Energy Dissipation Rates (EDRs) in typical machines. This paper describes an alternative and easy‐to‐assemble automated capillary‐based methodology to generate levels of EDRs consistent with those found in a continuous disk‐stack centrifuge. Variations in EDR were achieved through changes in capillary internal diameter and the flow rate of operation through the capillary. The EDRs found to match the levels of shear in the feed zone of a pilot‐scale centrifuge using the experimental method developed in this paper (2.4×10⁵ W/Kg) are consistent with those obtained through previously published computational fluid dynamic (CFD) studies (2.0×10⁵ W/Kg). Furthermore, this methodology can be incorporated into existing scale‐down methods to model the process performance of continuous disk‐stack centrifuges. This was demonstrated through the characterisation of culture hold time, culture temperature and EDRs on centrate quality.     

Evaluation of a single-use disk stack centrifuge for improved efficiency and sustainability at 1000 L GMP manufacturing scale

Direct depth filtration is an established technology for single-use harvest operation. Advantages of direct depth filtration include familiarity with depth filtration in downstream processes and simplicity of the operation. Drawbacks include low capacity, large footprint, labor-intensive set-up, high water use, and high waste in the form of discarded filters. Single-use centrifugation is emerging as an alternative to depth filtration for the single-use harvest step. Within the single-use centrifugation space, disc stack centrifugation represents the newest entrant. In this study, we evaluated the performance of the GEA kytero single-use disc stack centrifuge to clarify two monoclonal antibody-producing cell culture fluids. The separation performance of the GEA kytero centrifuge varied between the two cell culture fluids, with differences in centrate turbidity and centrate filterability measured. A comparison was then performed to determine resource savings, compared to direct two-stage depth filtration, when using a GEA kytero centrifuge to harvest a 1000 L bioreactor. The analysis concluded that replacement of the first stage of depth filters with a GEA kytero centrifuge has the potential to decrease the required second stage depth filtration area by up to 80%. The decrease in depth filter area resulting from the use of the GEA kytero would result in a decrease in the harvest step footprint, a decrease in buffer volume required to prime and rinse depth filters, and a decrease in the volume of plastic waste. An economic comparison of the GEA kytero single-use centrifuge against a direct depth filtration step found that for a 1000 L harvest step, the GEA kytero centrifuge may reduce costs by up to 20% compared with two-stage direct depth filtration.     

The effect of antiapoptosis genes on clarification performance

Optimal bioreactor harvest time is typically determined based on maximizing product titer without compromising product quality. We suggest that ease of downstream purification should also be considered during harvest. In this view, we studied the effect of antiapoptosis genes on downstream performance. Our hypothesis was that more robust cells would exhibit less cell lysis and thus generate lower levels of cell debris and host‐cell contaminants. We focused on the clarification unit operation, measuring postclarification turbidity and host‐cell protein (HCP) concentration as a function of bioreactor harvest time/cell viability. In order to mimic primary clarification using disk‐stack centrifugation, a scale‐down model consisting of a rotating disk (to simulate shear in the inlet feed zone of the centrifuge) and a swinging‐bucket lab centrifuge was used. Our data suggest that in the absence of shear during primary clarification (typical of depth filters), a 20–50% reduction in HCP levels and 50–65% lower postcentrifugation turbidity was observed for cells with antiapoptosis genes compared to control cells. However, on exposing the cells to shear levels typical in a disk‐stack centrifuge, the reduction in HCP was 10–15% while no difference in postcentrifugation turbidity was observed. The maximum benefit of antiapoptosis genes is, therefore, realized using clarification options that involve low shear, <1 × 10⁶ W/m³ and minimal damage to the cells. © 2013 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 30:100–107, 2014     

Ultra scale‐down prediction using microwell technology of the industrial scale clarification characteristics by centrifugation of mammalian cell broths

This article describes how a combination of an ultra scale‐down (USD) shear device feeding a microwell centrifugation plate may be used to provide a prediction of how mammalian cell broth will clarify at scale. In particular a method is described that is inherently adaptable to a robotic platform and may be used to predict how the flow rate and capacity (equivalent settling area) of a centrifuge and the choice of feed zone configuration may affect the solids carry over in the supernatant. This is an important consideration as the extent of solids carry over will determine the required size and lifetime of a subsequent filtration stage or the passage of fine particulates and colloidal material affecting the performance and lifetime of chromatography stages. The extent of solids removal observed in individual wells of a microwell plate during centrifugation is shown to correlate with the vertical and horizontal location of the well on the plate. Geometric adjustments to the evaluation of the equivalent settling area of individual wells (Σ_M) results in an improved prediction of solids removal as a function of centrifuge capacity. The USD centrifuge settling characteristics need to be as for a range of equivalent flow rates as may be experienced at an industrial scale for a machine of different shear characteristics in the entry feed zone. This was shown to be achievable with two microwell‐plate based measurements and the use of varying fill volumes in the microwells to allow the rapid study of a fivefold range of equivalent flow rates (i.e., at full scale for a particular industrial centrifuge) and the effect of a range of feed configurations. The microwell based USD method was used to examine the recovery of CHO‐S cells, prepared in a 5 L reactor, at different points of growth and for different levels of exposure to shear post reactor. The combination of particle size distribution measurements of the cells before and after shear and the effect of shear on the solids remaining after centrifugation rate provide insight into the state of the cells throughout the fermentation and the ease with which they and accumulated debris may be removed by continuous centrifugation. Hence bioprocess data are more readily available to help better integrate cell culture and cell removal stages and resolve key bioprocess design issues such as choice of time of harvesting and the impact on product yield and contaminant carry over. Operation at microwell scale allows data acquisition and bioprocess understanding over a wide range of operating conditions that might not normally be achieved during bioprocess development. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2009; 104: 321–331 © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Process cost and facility considerations in the selection of primary cell culture clarification technology

The bioreactor volume delineating the selection of primary clarification technology is not always easily defined. Development of a commercial scale process for the manufacture of therapeutic proteins requires scale‐up from a few liters to thousands of liters. While the separation techniques used for protein purification are largely conserved across scales, the separation techniques for primary cell culture clarification vary with scale. Process models were developed to compare monoclonal antibody production costs using two cell culture clarification technologies. One process model was created for cell culture clarification by disc stack centrifugation with depth filtration. A second process model was created for clarification by multi‐stage depth filtration. Analyses were performed to examine the influence of bioreactor volume, product titer, depth filter capacity, and facility utilization on overall operating costs. At bioreactor volumes <1,000 L, clarification using multi‐stage depth filtration offers cost savings compared to clarification using centrifugation. For bioreactor volumes >5,000 L, clarification using centrifugation followed by depth filtration offers significant cost savings. For bioreactor volumes of ～2,000 L, clarification costs are similar between depth filtration and centrifugation. At this scale, factors including facility utilization, available capital, ease of process development, implementation timelines, and process performance characterization play an important role in clarification technology selection. In the case study presented, a multi‐product facility selected multi‐stage depth filtration for cell culture clarification at the 500 and 2,000 L scales of operation. Facility implementation timelines, process development activities, equipment commissioning and validation, scale‐up effects, and process robustness are examined. © 2013 The Authors. American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 29:1239–1245, 2013     

Evaluation of options for harvest of a recombinant E. Coli fermentation producing a domain antibody using ultra scale‐down techniques and pilot‐scale verification

Ultra scale‐down (USD) methods operating at the millilitre scale were used to characterise full‐scale processing of E. coli fermentation broths autolysed to different extents for release of a domain antibody. The focus was on the primary clarification stages involving continuous centrifugation followed by depth filtration. The performance of this sequence was predicted by USD studies to decrease significantly with increased extents of cell lysis. The use of polyethyleneimine reagent was studied to treat the lysed cell broth by precipitation of soluble contaminants such as DNA and flocculation of cell debris material. The USD studies were used to predict the impact of this treatment on the performance and here it was found that the fermentation could be run to maximum productivity using an acceptable clarification process (e.g., a centrifugation stage operating at 0.11 L/m² equivalent gravity settling area per hour followed by a resultant required depth filter area of 0.07 m²/L supernatant). A range of USD predictions was verified at the pilot scale for centrifugation followed by depth filtration. © 2016 The Authors Biotechnology Progress published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc. on behalf of American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 32:382–392, 2016     

An ultra scale‐down characterization of low shear stress primary recovery stages to enhance selectivity of fusion protein recovery from its molecular variants

Fusion proteins offer the prospect of new therapeutic products with multiple functions. The primary recovery is investigated of a fusion protein consisting of modified E2 protein from hepatitis C virus fused to human IgG1 Fc and expressed in a Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell line. Fusion protein products inevitably pose increased challenge in preparation and purification. Of particular concerns are: (i) the impact of shear stress on product integrity and (ii) the presence of product‐related contaminants which could prove challenging to remove during the high resolution purification steps. This paper addresses the use of microwell‐based ultra scale‐down (USD) methods to develop a bioprocess strategy focused on the integration of cell culture and cell removal operations and where the focus is on the use of operations which impart low shear stress levels even when applied at eventual manufacturing scale. An USD shear device was used to demonstrate that cells exposed to high process stresses such as those that occur in the feed zone of a continuous non‐hermetic centrifuge resulted in the reduction of the fusion protein and also the release of glycosylated intracellular variants. In addition, extended cell culture resulted in release of such variants. USD mimics of low shear stress, hydrohermetic feed zone centrifugation and of depth filtration were used to demonstrate little to no release during recovery of these variants with both results verified at pilot scale. Furthermore, the USD studies were used to predict removal of contaminants such as lipids, nucleic acids, and cell debris with, for example, depth filtration delivering greater removal than for centrifugation but a small (～10%) decrease in yield of the fusion protein. These USD observations of product recovery and carryover of contaminants were also confirmed at pilot scale as was also the capacity or throughput achievable for continuous centrifugation or for depth filtration. The advantages are discussed of operating a lower yield cell culture and a low shear stress recovery process in return for a considerably less challenging purification demand. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2013; 110: 1973–1983. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

An ultra scale‐down approach to study the interaction of fermentation,homogenization, and centrifugation for antibody fragment recovery from rec E. coli

Escherichia coli is frequently used as a microbial host to express recombinant proteins but it lacks the ability to secrete proteins into medium. One option for protein release is to use high‐pressure homogenization followed by a centrifugation step to remove cell debris. While this does not give selective release of proteins in the periplasmic space, it does provide a robust process. An ultra scale‐down (USD) approach based on focused acoustics is described to study rec E. coli cell disruption by high‐pressure homogenization for recovery of an antibody fragment (Fab′) and the impact of fermentation harvest time. This approach is followed by microwell‐based USD centrifugation to study the removal of the resultant cell debris. Successful verification of this USD approach is achieved using pilot scale high‐pressure homogenization and pilot scale, continuous flow, disc stack centrifugation comparing performance parameters such as the fraction of Fab′ release, cell debris size distribution and the carryover of cell debris fine particles in the supernatant. The integration of fermentation and primary recovery stages is examined using USD monitoring of different phases of cell growth. Increasing susceptibility of the cells to disruption is observed with time following induction. For a given recovery process this results in a higher fraction of product release and a greater proportion of fine cell debris particles that are difficult to remove by centrifugation. Such observations are confirmed at pilot scale. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2013 9999:XX–XX. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2013; 110: 2150–2160. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Ultra scale‐down characterization of the impact of conditioning methods for harvested cell broths on clarification by continuous centrifugation—Recovery of domain antibodies from rec E. coli

The processing of harvested E. coli cell broths is examined where the expressed protein product has been released into the extracellular space. Pre‐treatment methods such as freeze–thaw, flocculation, and homogenization are studied. The resultant suspensions are characterized in terms of the particle size distribution, sensitivity to shear stress, rheology and solids volume fraction, and, using ultra scale‐down methods, the predicted ability to clarify the material using industrial scale continuous flow centrifugation. A key finding was the potential of flocculation methods both to aid the recovery of the particles and to cause the selective precipitation of soluble contaminants. While the flocculated material is severely affected by process shear stress, the impact on the very fine end of the size distribution is relatively minor and hence the predicted performance was only diminished to a small extent, for example, from 99.9% to 99.7% clarification compared with 95% for autolysate and 65% for homogenate at equivalent centrifugation conditions. The lumped properties as represented by ultra scale‐down centrifugation results were correlated with the basic properties affecting sedimentation including particle size distribution, suspension viscosity, and solids volume fraction. Grade efficiency relationships were used to allow for the particle and flow dynamics affecting capture in the centrifuge. The size distribution below a critical diameter dependant on the broth pre‐treatment type was shown to be the main determining factor affecting the clarification achieved. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2014;111: 913–924. © 2013 The Authors. Biotechnology and Bioengineering Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Ultra scale‐down device to predict dewatering levels of solids recovered in a continuous scroll decanter centrifuge

During centrifugation operation, the major challenge in the recovery of extracellular proteins is the removal of the maximum liquid entrapped within the spaces between the settled solids–dewatering level. The ability of the scroll decanter centrifuge (SDC) to process continuously large amounts of feed material with high concentration of solids without the need for resuspension of feeds, and also to achieve relatively high dewatering, could be of great benefit for future use in the biopharmaceutical industry. However, for reliable prediction of dewatering in such a centrifuge, tests using the same kind of equipment at pilot‐scale are required, which are time consuming and costly. To alleviate the need of pilot‐scale trials, a novel USD device, with reduced amounts of feed (2 mL) and to be used in the laboratory, was developed to predict the dewatering levels of a SDC. To verify USD device, dewatering levels achieved were plotted against equivalent compression (Gt_comp) and decanting (Gt_dec) times, obtained from scroll rates and feed flow rates operated at pilot‐scale, respectively. The USD device was able to successfully match dewatering trends of the pilot‐scale as a function of both Gt_comp and Gt_dec, particularly for high cell density feeds, hence accounting for all key variables that influenced dewatering in a SDC. In addition, it accurately mimicked the maximum dewatering performance of the pilot‐scale equipment. Therefore the USD device has the potential to be a useful tool at early stages of process development to gather performance data in the laboratory thus minimizing lengthy and costly runs with pilot‐scale SDC. © 2013 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 29:1494–1502, 2013     

Modeling industrial centrifugation of mammalian cell culture using a capillary based scale-down system

Continuous-flow centrifugation is widely utilized as the primary clarification step in the recovery of biopharmaceuticals from cell culture. However, it is a challenging operation to develop and characterize due to the lack of easy to use, small-scale, systems that can be used to model industrial processes. As a result, pilot-scale continuous centrifugation is typically employed to model large-scale systems requiring a significant amount of resources. In an effort to reduce resource requirements and create a system which is easy to construct and utilize, a capillary shear device, capable of producing energy dissipation rates equivalent to those present in the feed zones of industrial disk stack centrifuges, was developed and evaluated. When coupled to a bench-top, batch centrifuge, the capillary device reduced centrate turbidity prediction error from 37% to 4% compared to using a bench-top centrifuge alone. Laboratory-scale parameters that are analogous to those routinely varied during industrial-scale continuous centrifugation were identified and evaluated for their utility in emulating disk stack centrifuge performance. The resulting relationships enable bench-scale process modeling of continuous disk stack centrifuges using an easily constructed, scalable, capillary shear device coupled to a typical bench-top centrifuge.     

Screening and assessment of performance and molecule quality attributes of industrial cell lines across different fed‐batch systems

The major challenge in the selection process of recombinant cell lines for the production of biologics is the choice, early in development, of a clonal cell line presenting a high productivity and optimal cell growth. Most importantly, the selected candidate needs to generate a product quality profile which is adequate with respect to safety and efficacy and which is preserved across cell culture scales. We developed a high‐throughput screening and selection strategy of recombinant cell lines, based on their productivity in shaking 96‐deepwell plates operated in fed‐batch mode, which enables the identification of cell lines maintaining their high productivity at larger scales. Twelve recombinant cell lines expressing the same antibody with different productivities were selected out of 470 clonal cell lines in 96‐deepwell plate fed‐batch culture. They were tested under the same conditions in 50 mL vented shake tubes, microscale and lab‐scale bioreactors in order to confirm the maintenance of their performance at larger scales. The use of a feeding protocol and culture conditions which are essentially the same across the different scales was essential to maintain productivity and product quality profiles across scales. Compared to currently used approaches, this strategy has the advantage of speeding up the selection process and increases the number of screened clones for getting high‐producing recombinant cell lines at manufacturing scale with the desired performance and quality. © 2015 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 32:160–170, 2016     

Shear stress analysis of mammalian cell suspensions for prediction of industrial centrifugation and its verification

This article describes the use of ultra scale-down studies requiring milliliter quantities of process material to study the clarification of mammalian cell culture broths using industrial-scale continuous centrifuges during the manufacture of a monoclonal antibody for therapeutic use. Samples were pretreated in a small high-speed rotating-disc device in order to mimic the effect on the cells of shear stresses in the feed zone of the industrial scale centrifuges. The use of this feed mimic was shown to predict a reduction of the clarification efficiency by significantly reducing the particle size distribution of the mammalian cells. The combined use of the rotating-disc device and a laboratory-scale test tube centrifuge successfully predicted the separation characteristics of industrial-scale, disc stack centrifuges operating with different feed zones. A 70% reduction in flow rate in the industrial-scale centrifuge was shown to arise from shear effects. A predicted 2.5-fold increase in throughput for the same clarification performance, achieved by the change to a centrifuge using a feed zone designed to give gentler acceleration of the bioprocess fluid, was also verified at large-scale.     

A methodology for centrifuge selection for the separation of high solids density cell broths by visualisation of performance using windows of operation

Expression systems capable of growing to high cell densities are now readily available and are popular due to the benefits of increased product concentration. However, such high solids density cultures pose a major challenge for bioprocess engineers as choosing the right separation equipment and operating it at optimal conditions is crucial for efficient recovery. This study proposes a methodology for the rapid determination of suitable operating conditions for the centrifugal recovery of high cell density fermentation broths. An ultra scale-down (USD) approach for the prediction of clarification and dewatering levels achieved in a range of typical high-speed centrifuges is presented. Together with a visualisation tool, a Window of Operation, this provides for the rapid analysis of separation performance and evaluation of the available operating conditions, as an aid in the selection of the centrifuge equipment most appropriate for a given process duty. A case study examining centrifuge selection for the processing of a high cell density Pichia pastoris culture demonstrates the method. The study examines semi-continuous disc-stack centrifuges and batch-operated machines such as multi-chamber bowls and Carr Powerfuges. Performance is assessed based on the variables of clarification, dewatering and product yield. Inclusion of limits imposed by the centrifuge type and design, and operation itself, serve to constrain the process and to define the Windows of Operation. The insight gained from the case study provides a useful indication of the utility of the methodology presented and illustrates the challenges of centrifuge selection for the demanding case of high solids concentration feed streams.     

Step change in the efficiency of centrifugation through cell engineering: co‐expression of Staphylococcal nuclease to reduce the viscosity of the bioprocess feedstock

Cell engineering to enable step change improvements in bioprocessing can be directed at targets other than increasing product titer. The physical properties of the process suspension such as viscosity, for example, have a major impact on various downstream processing unit operations. The release of chromosomal DNA during homogenization of Escherichia coli and its influence on viscosity is well‐recognized. In this current article we demonstrate co‐expression of Staphylococcus aureus nuclease in E. coli to reduce viscosity through auto‐hydrolysis of nucleic acids. Viscosity reduction of up to 75% was achieved while the particle size distribution of cell debris was maintained approximately constant (d₅₀ = 0.5–0.6 µm). Critically, resultant step change improvements to the clarification performance under disc‐stack centrifugation conditions are shown. The cell‐engineered nuclease matched or exceeded the viscosity reduction performance seen with the addition of exogenous nuclease removing the expense and validation issues associated with such additions to a bioprocess. The resultant material dramatically altered performance in scale‐down mimics of continuous disc‐stack centrifugation. Laboratory scale data indicated that a fourfold reduction in the settling area of a disc‐stack centrifuge can be expected due to a less viscous process stream achieved through nuclease co‐expression with a recombinant protein. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2009; 104: 134–142 © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Ultra scale-down approach for the prediction of full-scale recovery of ovine polycolonal immunoglobulins used in the manufacture of snake venom-specific Fab fragment

In this article, we describe a new approach that allows the prediction of the performance of a large-scale integrated process for the primary recovery of a therapeutic antibody from an analysis of the individual unit operations and their interactions in an ultra scale-down mimic of the process. The recovery process consisted of four distinct unit operations. Using the new approach we defined the important engineering parameters in each operation that impacted the overall recovery process and in each case verified its effect by a combination of modelling and experimentation. Immunoglobulins were precipitated from large volumes of dilute blood plasma and the precipitated flocs were recovered by centrifugal separation from the liquor containing contaminating proteins, including albumin. The fluid mechanical forces acting on the precipitate and the time of exposure to these forces were used to define a time-integrated fluid stress. This was used as a scaling factor to predict the properties of the precipitated flocs at large scale. In the case of centrifugation, the performance of a full-scale disc stack centrifuge was predicted. This was achieved from a computational fluid dynamics (CFD) analysis of the flow field in the centrifuge coupled with experimental data obtained from the precipitated immunoglobulin flocs using the scale-down precipitation tank, a rotating shear device, and a standard swing-out rotor centrifuge operating under defined conditions. In this way, the performance of the individual unit operations, and their linkage, was successfully analysed from a combination of modelling and experiments. These experiments required only millilitre quantities of the process material. The overall performance of the large-scale process was predicted by tracking the changes in physical and biological properties of the key components in the system, including the size distribution of the antibody precipitates and antibody activity through the individual unit operations in the ultra scale-down process flowsheet.     

Application of multivariate analysis and mass transfer principles for refinement of a 3‐L bioreactor scale‐down model—when shake flasks mimic 15,000‐L bioreactors better

Characterization of manufacturing processes is key to understanding the effects of process parameters on process performance and product quality. These studies are generally conducted using small‐scale model systems. Because of the importance of the results derived from these studies, the small‐scale model should be predictive of large scale. Typically, small‐scale bioreactors, which are considered superior to shake flasks in simulating large‐scale bioreactors, are used as the scale‐down models for characterizing mammalian cell culture processes. In this article, we describe a case study where a cell culture unit operation in bioreactors using one‐sided pH control and their satellites (small‐scale runs conducted using the same post‐inoculation cultures and nutrient feeds) in 3‐L bioreactors and shake flasks indicated that shake flasks mimicked the large‐scale performance better than 3‐L bioreactors. We detail here how multivariate analysis was used to make the pertinent assessment and to generate the hypothesis for refining the existing 3‐L scale‐down model. Relevant statistical techniques such as principal component analysis, partial least square, orthogonal partial least square, and discriminant analysis were used to identify the outliers and to determine the discriminatory variables responsible for performance differences at different scales. The resulting analysis, in combination with mass transfer principles, led to the hypothesis that observed similarities between 15,000‐L and shake flask runs, and differences between 15,000‐L and 3‐L runs, were due to pCO₂ and pH values. This hypothesis was confirmed by changing the aeration strategy at 3‐L scale. By reducing the initial sparge rate in 3‐L bioreactor, process performance and product quality data moved closer to that of large scale. © 2015 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 31:1370–1380, 2015     

Evaluating the toxicity of bDtBPP on CHO‐K1 cells for testing of single‐use bioprocessing systems considering media selection,cell culture volume,mixing, and exposure duration

Single‐use bioprocessing bags are gaining popularity due to ease of use, lower risk of contamination, and ease of process scale‐up. Bis(2,4‐di‐tert‐butylphenyl)phosphate (bDtBPP), a degradant of tris(2,4‐di‐tert‐butylphenyl)phosphite, marketed as Irgafos 168®, which is an antioxidant stabilizer added to resins, has been identified as a potentially toxic leachate which may impact the performance of single‐use, multilayer bioprocessing bags. In this study, the toxicity of bDtBPP was tested on CHO‐K1 cells grown as adherent or suspended cells. The EC50 (effective concentration to cause 50% cell death) for adherent cells was found to be one order of magnitude higher than that for suspended CHO‐K1 cells. While CHO‐K1 cells had good cell viability when exposed to moderate concentrations of bDtBPP, the degradant was shown to impact the viable cell density (VCD) at much lower concentrations. Hence, in developing an industry‐standard assay for testing the cytotoxicity of leachates, suspended cells (as commonly used in the bioprocessing industry) would likely be most sensitive, particularly when reporting EC50 values based on VCD. The effects of mixing, cell culture volume, and exposure duration were also evaluated for suspended CHO‐K1 cells. It was found that the sensitivity of cell culture to leachates from single‐use plastic bags was enhanced for suspended cells cultured for longer exposure times and when the cells were subjected to continuous agitation, both of which are important considerations in the production of biopharmaceuticals. © 2016 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 32:1318–1323, 2016     

Assessment of the manufacturability of Escherichia coli high cell density fermentations

The physical and biological conditions of the host cell obtained at the end of fermentation influences subsequent downstream processing unit operations. The ability to monitor these characteristics is central to the improvement of biopharmaceutical manufacture. In this study, we have used a combination of techniques such as adaptive focus acoustics (AFA) and ultra scale-down (USD) centrifugation that utilize milliliter quantities of sample to obtain an insight into the interaction between cells from the upstream process and initial downstream unit operations. This is achieved primarily through an assessment of cell strength and its impact on large-scale disc stack centrifugation performance, measuring critical attributes such as viscosity and particle size distribution. An Escherichia coli fed-batch fermentation expressing antibody fragments in the periplasm was used as a model system representative of current manufacturing challenges. The weakening of cell strength during cultivation time, detected through increased micronization and viscosity, resulted in a 2.6-fold increase in product release rates from the cell (as measured by AFA) and approximately fourfold decrease in clarification performance (as measured by USD centrifugation). The information obtained allows for informed harvest point decisions accounting for both product leakages during fermentation and potential losses during primary recovery. The clarification performance results were verified at pilot scale. The use of these technologies forms a route to the process understanding needed to tailor the host cell and upstream process to the product and downstream process, critical to the implementation of quality-by-design principles.