Inhibition of the reattachment of young adult zebra mussels by single-species biofilms and associated exopolymers

AIMS: To determine the effects of single-species bacterial films and their associated extracellular products on the reattachment of young adult zebra mussels. MATERIALS AND RESULTS: Ten strains of bacteria were isolated from surfaces where adult zebra mussels can be found attached in nature. Single-species biofilms were developed on both glass and polystyrene using these bacteria. The reattachment of zebra mussels (i.e. with byssal threads) was compared between surfaces with and without films. Although no differences were observed in mussel reattachment between glass surfaces with and without films (P > 0.05, anova), a reduction in mussel reattachment between polystyrene surfaces with and without films was observed for seven of the 10 strains (P < or = 0.05 to <0.001, anova). Bacterial extracellular products (BEP) were isolated from five bacterial films and tested for their effects on mussel reattachment. Four of the five sets of isolated extracellular products evoked the same effects as their respective intact biofilms. CONCLUSIONS: We conclude that depending on the substratum, individual strains of bacteria in biofilms can inhibit the reattachment of adult zebra mussels. In some cases, BEP were the source of the inhibitory effects. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: The nature of the substratum on which the biofilms develop affects properties of the biofilm and its extracellular components, which subsequently influences zebra mussel reattachment.     

The effects of natural biofilms on the reattachment of young adult zebra mussels to artificial substrata

This laboratory study examined the effects of natural biofilms on the reattachment of young adult zebra mussels, Dreissena polymorpha, in Petri dishes. Natural biofilms were developed in glass and polystyrene Petri dishes using water samples collected at various times of the year. Biofilms were developed over 1, 3, 8, and 14 d. Controls were clean glass and polystyrene Petri dishes. Zebra mussels collected from the field (< or = 10 mm, ventral length) were placed in the dishes and their reattachment by byssal threads was recorded after 1 d. Zebra mussels reattached to the dish surface or the shells of other mussels in the dish, or remained unattached. The data indicate that reattachment to clean glass was greater than to clean polystyrene (p < or = 0.05, ANOVA), but there were no consistent differences between reattachment to filmed polystyrene and filmed glass dish surfaces. Zebra mussels in control and filmed glass dishes reattached in higher percentages to the dish surface compared to the shells of other mussels (p < or = 0.05, ANOVA). There was no difference in mussel of reattachment between the dish surface and the shells of other mussels in most control polystyrene dishes (p > 0.05, ANOVA), whereas in filmed polystyrene the percentage of reattachment to the dish surface was greater than to the shells of other mussels (p < or = 0.05, ANOVA). These results indicate that substratum wettability and the presence of biofilms on some types of substrata can be factors in the reattachment of young adult zebra mussels.     

Preferential attachment of barnacle larvae to natural multi-species biofilms: Does surface wettability matter?

We tested the hypothesis that surface wettability does not alter the positive effect of natural biofilms on larval attachment in the barnacle Balanus amphitrite. We also answered the question: Does substratum-biofilm interaction affect the larval choice in barnacle? We developed natural multi-species biofilms of different ages on both high (glass) and low (polystyrene) wettability surfaces at mid-intertidal height (native habitat of B. amphitrite). Attachment choice of both young (0-d-old) and old (6-d-old) larvae to biofilms was determined using still water choice bioassay. Irrespective of larval age, cyprid preferred to attach to un-filmed glass than to un-filmed polystyrene. In contrast to aged larvae, young larvae preferred old (6-d-old) biofilms on polystyrene to young (3-d-old) biofilms on glass. In this study, we were also able to examine the interaction between surface wettability, biofilms and larval attachment, by characterizing bacterial community composition in biofilms. Bacterial community composition showed significant differences between biofilms of different ages. Old biofilms positively influenced larval attachment, irrespective of the type of substrata, thereby supporting the hypothesis that surface wettability does not alter the positive effect of natural biofilms on larval attachment.     

Effect of biofilm age on settlement of Mytilus edulis

Biofilm ageing is commonly assumed to improve mussel settlement on artificial substrata, but the structure and taxonomic composition of biofilms remains unclear. In the present study, multi-species biofilms were characterized at different ages (1, 2, and 3 weeks) and their influence on settlement of the blue mussel, Mytilus edulis, was tested in the field. As biofilms can constitute a consistent food resource for larvae, the lipid quality, defined as the proportion of related essential fatty acids, may be a selection criterion for settlement. Overall mussel settlement increased on biofilms older than 1 week, and the enhanced settlement corresponded to the abundance and composition of the biofilm community, rather than to essential fatty acid levels. However, during a pulse of phytoplankton, the positive influence of biofilm was not detected, suggesting that pelagic cues overwhelmed those associated with biofilms. The influence of biofilms on mussel settlement could be more crucial when planktonic resources are limited.     

Monitoring of biofilms grown on differentially structured metallic surfaces using confocal laser scanning microscopy

Imaging of biofilms on opaque surfaces is a challenge presented to researchers especially considering pathogenic bacteria, as those typically grow on living tissue, such as mucosa and bone. However, they can also grow on surfaces used in industrial applications such as food production, acting as a hindrance to the process. Thus, it is important to understand bacteria better in the environment they actually have relevance in. Stainless steel and titanium substrata were line structured and dotted surface topographies for titanium substrata were prepared to analyze their effects on biofilm formation of a constitutively green fluorescent protein (GFP)‐expressing Escherichia coli strain. The strain was batch cultivated in a custom built flow cell initially for 18 h, followed by continuous cultivation for 6 h. Confocal laser scanning microscopy (CLSM) was used to determine the biofilm topography. Biofilm growth of E. coli GFPmut2 was not affected by the type of metal substrate used; rather, attachment and growth were influenced by variable shapes of the microstructured titanium surfaces. In this work, biofilm cultivation in flow cells was coupled with the most widely used biofilm analytical technique (CLSM) to study the time course of growth of a GFP‐expressing biofilm on metallic surfaces without intermittent sampling or disturbing the natural development of the biofilm.     

Effects of different biotic substrata on mussel attachment

Surface colonization by invertebrates can be stimulated or inhibited by cues produced by biofilms, conspecifics or other macroorganisms. To study the effects of living substrata on the attachment of the brown mussel, Perna perna, two different approaches were employed: (1) mussels were distributed in sets of Petri dishes consisting of one sterile set (controls), three sets in which marine biofilms were allowed to develop in aquaria for 1, 7 or 15 days and another set that had been immersed in a natural marine environment for 1-day. There was no significant effect of biofilms on attachment, suggesting that neither age nor the source of the biofilm influenced attachment. (2) Mussels were suspended over PVC panels (controls) and over panels on which Balanus trigonus (Crustacea), Schizoporella errata (Bryozoa), Symplegma rubra or Didemnum speciosum (Ascidiacea) were present. Attachment was significantly higher on the controls and on B. trigonus than on colonial taxa such as S. rubra, S. errata and D. speciosum, probably due to antifouling defenses of these species. The results show that the composition of the biological substratum is an important factor affecting mussel behavior.     

Putative identification of expressed genes associated with attachment of the zebra mussel (Dreissena polymorpha)

Because of its aggressive growth and firm attachment to substrata, the zebra mussel (Dreissena polymorpha) has caused severe economic and ecological problems since its invasion into North America. The nature and details of attachment of this nuisance mollusc remains largely unexplored. Byssus, a special glandular apparatus located at the root of the foot of the mussel produces threads and plates through which firm attachment of the mollusc to underwater objects takes place. In an attempt to better understand the adhesion mechanism of the zebra mussel, the suppression subtractive hybridization (SSH) assay was employed to produce a cDNA library with genes unique to the foot of the mussel. Analysis of the SSH cDNA library revealed the presence of 750 new expressed sequence tags (ESTs) including 304 contigs and 446 singlets. Using BLAST search, 365 zebra mussel ESTs showed homology to other gene sequences with putative functions. The putative functions of the homologues included proteins involved in byssal thread formation in zebra and blue mussels, exocrine gland secretion, host defence, and house keeping. The generated data provide, for the first time, some useful insights into the foot structure of the zebra mussel and its underwater adhesion.     

Bacteria biofilm encourages algal immigration onto substrata in lotic systems

I tested the effect of the density of attached bacteria on the amount of algal immigration in the early development of a periphyton community in an artificial stream by manipulating the density of the attached bacteria. Three densities were prepared by regulation of the incubation time. A suspension of algae was added to the stream, and the degree of algal attachment to substrata was compared among the treatments. Algal immigration was proportional to the density of attached bacteria on all substrata (glass, PVC, and slate), although density differed among substrata. Analysis of covariance (dependent variable, amount of attached algae; covariate, bacterial density) showed significant relationship between amounts of attached algae and bacterial densities, but did not show significant differences in the slopes and adjusted means among substrata. When acrylic beads were added with the suspension of attached algae, significant linear correlation was obtained between the amount of attached algae and the amount of acrylic beads on the substrata. Algal immigration was due to non-selective adsorption by attached bacterial biofilms on substrata, although the extent of bacterial colonization and biofilm formation may be affected by the substrata and other environmental factors (e.g., current conditions and water temperature).     

Putative identification of expressed genes associated with attachment of the zebra mussel (Dreissena polymorpha)

Because of its aggressive growth and firm attachment to substrata, the zebra mussel (Dreissena polymorpha) has caused severe economic and ecological problems since its invasion into North America. The nature and details of attachment of this nuisance mollusc remains largely unexplored. Byssus, a special glandular apparatus located at the root of the foot of the mussel produces threads and plates through which firm attachment of the mollusc to underwater objects takes place. In an attempt to better understand the adhesion mechanism of the zebra mussel, the suppression subtractive hybridization (SSH) assay was employed to produce a cDNA library with genes unique to the foot of the mussel. Analysis of the SSH cDNA library revealed the presence of 750 new expressed sequence tags (ESTs) including 304 contigs and 446 singlets. Using BLAST search, 365 zebra mussel ESTs showed homology to other gene sequences with putative functions. The putative functions of the homologues included proteins involved in byssal thread formation in zebra and blue mussels, exocrine gland secretion, host defence, and house keeping. The generated data provide, for the first time, some useful insights into the foot structure of the zebra mussel and its underwater adhesion.     

Bacterial Community Structure of Biofilms on Artificial Surfaces in an Estuary

This study examined bacterial community structure of biofilms on stainless steel and polycarbonate in seawater from the Delaware Bay. Free-living bacteria in the surrounding seawater were compared to the attached bacteria during the first few weeks of biofilm growth. Surfaces exposed to seawater were analyzed by using 16S rDNA libraries, fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH), and denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE). Community structure of the free-living bacterial community was different from that of the attached bacteria according to FISH and DGGE. In particular, alpha-proteobacteria dominated the attached communities. Libraries of 16S rRNA genes revealed that representatives of the Rhodobacterales clade were the most abundant members of biofilm communities. Changes in community structure during biofilm growth were also examined by DGGE analysis. We hypothesized that bacterial communities on dissimilar surfaces would initially differ and become more similar over time. In contrast, the compositions of stainless steel and polycarbonate biofilms were initially the same, but differed after about 1 week of biofilm growth. These data suggest that the relationship between surface properties and biofilm community structure changes as biofilms grow on surfaces such as stainless steel and polycarbonate in estuarine water.     

Mucin-Pseudomonas aeruginosa interactions promote biofilm formation and antibiotic resistance

Pseudomonas aeruginosa is an opportunistic pathogen that causes chronic lung infections in people suffering from cystic fibrosis (CF). In CF airways, P. aeruginosa forms surface-associated communities called biofilms. Compared with free-swimming cultures, biofilms resist clearance by the host immune system and display increased resistance to antimicrobial agents. In this study we developed a technique to coat surfaces with molecules that are abundant in CF airways in order to investigate their impact on P. aeruginosa biofilm development. We found that P. aeruginosa biofilm development proceeds differently on surfaces coated with the glycoprotein mucin compared with biofilm development on glass and surfaces coated with actin or DNA. Biofilms formed on mucin-coated surfaces developed large cellular aggregates and had increased tolerance to the antibiotic tobramycin compared with biofilms grown on glass. Analysis of selected mutant backgrounds in conjunction with time-lapse microscopy revealed that surface-associated motility was blocked on the mucin surface. Furthermore, our data suggest that a specific adhesin-mucin interaction immobilizes the bacterium on the surface. Together, these experiments suggest that mucin, which may serve as an attachment surface in CF airways, impacts P. aeruginosa biofilm development and function.     

Deposition of bacterial cells onto glass and biofilm surfaces

Deposition rates of Pseudomonas putida and Hyphomicrobium ZV620 onto glass and biofilm surfaces were quantified. Both species deposited to glass at a much slower rate than to biofilm. A definite bias by depositing cells for biofilms of their own species was evident in the highest attachment rates observed in this study.     

Differences in plating efficiency of bacteria from river epilithon sampled from upper and lower surfaces of artificial substrata

The bacterial generic composition of biofilms was investigated by determining colony-forming units on 1/2 PYG (peptone, yeast extract, and glucose medium) agar plates. The biofilms developed on the upper and lower surfaces of artificial substrata submerged in river water at Unazawa in the Tamagawa River in Tokyo, Japan. Greater variation in the number and generic composition in platable colonies was obtained on the upper surface of an artificial substratum than on the lower surface. This variation corresponded to the variation in algal biomass. Accompanying the growth of the algae, specific bacteria commensal with the algae proliferated on the upper surface. The biofilm exfoliated when the surface density of chlorophyll was 11.2 g·cm^–2. When the biofilm exfoliated, the bacterial community accompanying the algae also exfoliated, and the bacterial composition altered. The bacterial composition after exfoliation resembled that observed on the lower surface. The generic composition on the upper surface soon after it was initially submerged resembled that observed in the river water. The bacterial generic composition on the lower surface of the artificial substrata did not change greatly throughout the investigation because of the constant environmental conditions. The difference between the bacterial generic composition on the upper and lower surfaces was due to the fact that bacteria commensal with algae proliferated on the upper surface but not on the lower.     

Space as a limiting resource in freshwater systems: competition between zebra mussels (Dreissena polymorpha) and freshwater sponges (Porifera)

Species interactions between two types of sessile benthic invertebrates, the zebra mussel (Dreissena polymorpha) and freshwater sponges (Porifera), were evaluated in Michigan City IN Harbor in southern Lake Michigan during 1996. The study objective was to define whether competition plays a role in structuring benthic communities using experimental techniques commonly employed in marine systems. Sponges were uninhibited by zebra mussel presence and overgrew zebra mussel shells on hard vertical substrata. In contrast, zebra mussels did not overgrow sponge colonies, but did show an ability to re-capture hard substrata if relinquished by the sponge. The negative affect of sponges on zebra mussels through overgrowth and recruitment suggests interactions that could eventually displace zebra mussels from these benthic communities. However, seasonal reduction of sponge biomass from autumn through winter appears to allow the zebra mussel a periodic respite from overgrowth, preventing exclusion of zebra mussels from the community and allowing these two taxa to co-exist.     

Comparison of fluorinated polymers against stainless steel, glass and polypropylene in microbial biofilm adherence and removal

Biofilm formation is a long-standing problem in ultrapure water and bioprocess fluid transport lines. The standard materials used in these applications (316L stainless steel, polypropylene and glass) have long been known to be good surfaces for the attachment of bacteria and other biological materials. To compare the relative tenacity of biofilms grown on materials used in manufacturing processes, a model system for biofilm attachment was constructed that approximates the conditions in industrial process systems. New fluorinated polymers were compared to the above materials by evaluating the surface area coverage of bacterial populations on materials before and after mild chemical treatment. In addition, contact angle studies compared the relative hydrophobicity of surfaces to suspensions of bacteria in growth media, and scanning electron microscopy and atomic force microscopy studies were used to characterize surface smoothness and surface defects. Biofilm adherence to polymer-based substrata was determined to be a function of both surface finish and surface chemistry. Specifically, materials that are less chemically reactive, as indicated by higher contact angle, can have rougher surface finishes and still be amenable to biofilm removal. Received 20 March 1997/ Accepted in revised form 15 July 1997     

Characterization of monospecies biofilm formation by Helicobacter pylori

As all bacteria studied to date, the gastric pathogen Helicobacter pylori has an alternate lifestyle as a biofilm. H. pylori forms biofilms on glass surfaces at the air-liquid interface in stationary or shaking batch cultures. By light microscopy, we have observed attachment of individual, spiral H. pylori to glass surfaces, followed by division to form microcolonies, merging of individual microcolonies, and growth in the third dimension. Scanning electron micrographs showed H. pylori arranged in a matrix on the glass with channels for nutrient flow, typical of other bacterial biofilms. To understand the importance of biofilms to the H. pylori life cycle, we tested the effect of mucin on biofilm formation. Our results showed that 10% mucin greatly increased the number of planktonic H. pylori while not affecting biofilm bacteria, resulting in a decline in percent adherence to the glass. This suggests that in the mucus-rich stomach, H. pylori planktonic growth is favored over biofilm formation. We also investigated the effect of specific mutations in several genes, including the quorum-sensing gene, luxS, and the cagE type IV secretion gene. Both of these mutants were found to form biofilms approximately twofold more efficiently than the wild type in both assays. These results indicate the relative importance of these genes to the production of biofilms by H. pylori and the selective enhancement of planktonic growth in the presence of gastric mucin.     

Firm but slippery attachment of Deinococcus geothermalis

Bacterial biofilms impair the operation of many industrial processes. Deinococcus geothermalis is efficient primary biofilm former in paper machine water, functioning as an adhesion platform for secondary biofilm bacteria. It produces thick biofilms on various abiotic surfaces, but the mechanism of attachment is not known. High-resolution field-emission scanning electron microscopy and atomic force microscopy (AFM) showed peritrichous adhesion threads mediating the attachment of D. geothermalis E50051 to stainless steel and glass surfaces and cell-to-cell attachment, irrespective of the growth medium. Extensive slime matrix was absent from the D. geothermalis E50051 biofilms. AFM of the attached cells revealed regions on the cell surface with different topography, viscoelasticity, and adhesiveness, possibly representing different surface layers that were patchily exposed. We used oscillating probe techniques to keep the tip-biofilm interactions as small as possible. In spite of this, AFM imaging of living D. geothermalis E50051 biofilms in water resulted in repositioning but not in detachment of the surface-attached cells. The irreversibly attached cells did not detach when pushed with a glass capillary but escaped the mechanical force by sliding along the surface. Air drying eliminated the flexibility of attachment, but it resumed after reimmersion in water. Biofilms were evaluated for their strength of attachment. D. geothermalis E50051 persisted 1 h of washing with 0.2% NaOH or 0.5% sodium dodecyl sulfate, in contrast to biofilms of Burkholderia cepacia F28L1 or the well-characterized biofilm former Staphylococcus epidermidis O-47. Deinococcus radiodurans strain DSM 20539(T) also formed tenacious biofilms. This paper shows that D. geothermalis has firm but laterally slippery attachment not reported before for a nonmotile species.     

Approaches to prevention, removal and killing of biofilms

Biofilms contribute to hygiene problems in the food industry and in the medical field. Biofilms are diverse and due to the development of special phenotypes, biofilm organisms are not as susceptible to biocides as planktonic microorganisms. Biofilms may be prevented by regular disinfection. Since the attachment of microbes to surfaces and the development of biofilm phenotypes is a very fast process, it is, however, almost impossible, to prevent biofilm formation completely. The removal and killing of established biofilms requires harsh treatments, mostly using oxidising biocides. Depending on the nature of the biofilms, different biocides may be useful and the best biocide for a specific biofilm still has to be determined under practical conditions. Another approach is the prevention of biofilm formation by selection of materials that do not support the attachment of microorganisms. Some materials like glass and stainless steel show less biofilm formation than others. The ranking of materials, however, depends on the conditions, under which they are tested. A novel approach is biofilm inhibition by supplementation of systems with nutrients, to inhibit attachment. First results on inhibition of biofouling in reversed osmosis systems are presented.     

Quantitative trends of zebra mussels in Lake Balaton (Hungary) in 2003–2005 at different water levels

During the extremely dry period between 2000 and 2003, the water level of Lake Balaton decreased by 82 cm and 80% of the stony littoral, an important habitat for the zebra mussel (Dreissena polymorpha), became dry. A recovery period started in 2004 due to intense precipitation, which increased water levels in the lake. Seasonal and spatial variations of the relative abundance, population density, population structure and biomass of the zebra mussel and the relative abundance of the amphipod Chelicorophium curvispinum were monitored in the period of 2003–2005 at four different shoreline sections and in two different portions (on the bottom and near the surface portion of the rip-rap) of Lake Balaton. Along with these studies, a quantitative survey of mussel larvae found in the plankton and of the abundance of mussel feeding diving ducks were made. As a consequence of the water level fall, on the dried part of the stony littoral, numerous zebra mussel druses perished. Following the dry period in early 2004, the relative abundance of the mussel on the bottom stones was smaller than in 2003 and the bottom community was dominated by C. curvispinum. By the end of 2004 and during 2005, the water level returned to normal and the surfaces of the reinundated stones were conducive to the successful colonization of zebra mussels. Hence, they returned as the dominant fauna in 2005. The stones near the surface might provide a new substrate for the recruitment of zebra mussels, probably offering more suitable substrata for the settlement in 2005 than in 2003. Therefore, the new substrata available in 2005 may have encouraged better and more rapid zebra mussel colonization than before. Zebra mussels may be better competitors for new space than C. curvispinum. A minor change of water-level fluctuation in 2005 and the reduction in population size of the mussel feeding waterfowl could have contributed to the intensive spread of zebra mussel by 2005.     

Biofilm ecology: On-line methods bring new insights into mic and microbial biofouling

Microbial biofilms were formed on coupons with defined coatings in once-through laminar flow fields of controlled bulk-phase composition and shear. Dilute media were utilized to select for biofilm growth. The formation, succession, and stability of the biofilms were monitored with non-destructive on-line methods (fluorescence, bioluminescence, attenuated total reflectance Fourier transform infrared spectrometry [ATR-FTIR] and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy) and by high resolution destructive analysts (viable and direct counts and phospholipid fatty acid signature methods) at the termination of the experiments. Biofilms of reproducible composition can be formed and the order of inoculation of multi-component biofilms affects their composition at harvest. The corrosion rates of mild steel depended on the biofilm composition but not the attached biomass. Examination of biofilms with the scanning vibrating electrode in a microscope field showed effects of heterogeneity in biofilm structure which promoted localized anodic activity. Pseudomonas stains were engineered to contain the lux gene cassette as a "reporter"; and the formation of the exopolymer alginate was shown not to promote attachment of the strain or secondary colonization by Vibrio. Examination of mutants forming different alginate structures showed differential attachment and biofilm structure. Studies of mutants of lipopolysaccharide structure showed differential attachment to substrata. Specific antifouling and fouling-release coatings showed a wide range of attachment and release properties as well as sublethal toxicity.