The variation in frequency with which markers are transduced by phage P1 is primarily a result of discrimination during recombination

Summary The efficiency of recovery of P1 transductants is marker dependent and normally varies over a 25-fold range. UV irradiation of either transducing lysates or recipient cells results in a selective stimulation of the transduction of markers which are normally transduced poorly. As a result the range in frequency of transduction is reduced to about 3-fold and resembles the gene frequency distribution expected in the donor cells. We conclude that P1 transducing lysates are likely to contain a random sample of donor DNA but that the recombination system of the recipient cell exhibits a preference for the DNA of some regions over that of others. Damage to DNA presumably overrides this specificity.     

Plasmid marker rescue transformation proceeds by breakage-reunion in Bacillus subtilis.

Bacillus subtilis carrying a plasmid which replicates with a copy number of about 1 was transformed with linearized homologous plasmid DNA labeled with the heavy isotopes 2H and 15N, in the presence of 32Pi and 6-(p-hydroxyphenylazo)-uracil to inhibit DNA replication. Plasmid DNA was isolated from the transformed culture and fractionated in cesium chloride density gradients. The distribution of total and donor plasmid DNA was examined, using specific hybridization probes. The synthesis of new DNA, associated with the integration of donor moiety, was also monitored. Donor-specific sequences were present at a density intermediate between that of light and hybrid DNA. This recombinant DNA represented 1.4% of total plasmid DNA. The latter value corresponded well with the transforming activity (1.7%) obtained for the donor marker. Newly synthesized material associated with plasmid DNA at the recombinant density amounted to a minor portion of the recombinant plasmid DNA. These data suggest that, like chromosomal transformation, plasmid marker rescue transformation does not require replication for the integration of donor markers and, also like chromosomal transformation, proceeds by a breakage-reunion mechanism. The extent of donor DNA replacement of recipient DNA per plasmid molecule of 54 kilobases (27 kilobase pairs) was estimated as 16 kilobases.     

Mismatch correction in pneumococcal transformation: donor length and hex-dependent marker efficiency.

A hypothesis that preferential rejection of donor markers by the hex system of pneumococcus is due to lethal double-strand breaks has been examined in terms of its implications for the extent of the excision required. Experiments reported here were directed at asking whether hex-dependent marker efficiency depends on the length of the donor deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA). In the absence of intracellular competition for hex function, there was no detectable effect of DNA size on hex-dependent marker efficiency as donor DNA was sheared from greater than 1 x 107 daltons to 3.6 x 105 daltons. The latter DNA was purified by two successive velocity fractionations to ensure that the activity seen was representative of DNA of that size. Quantitative examination of the system shows that, for the lethal event hypothesis to be true, the excision step has to remove an average of 7,000 to 10,000 nucleotides. This figure is so much greater than that seen in other excision processes that alternate hypotheses should be considered. The presently known properties of the hex system can be accounted for by a model invoking the migratory features of type I restriction enzymes.     

Competence Mutant of Haemophilus influenzae with Abnormal Ratios of Marker Efficiencies in Transformation

In studies of competence-deficient mutants of Haemophilus influenzae which absorb deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) but fail to produce transformants, it was observed that in some mutants the residual transforming activity for different markers varied widely, i.e., produced a ratio effect. One of these mutants, com⁻⁵⁶, was studied intensively to determine the cause of the residual efficiency of transformation and the reason for the ratio effect. The residual frequency of transformation was higher for markers considered single-site mutations (like naladixic acid resistance), whereas the least efficient markers tested were those conferring resistance to high levels of streptomycin or novobiocin which are more complex than single-site mutations. Measurement of frequencies of cotransformation indicated that overall genetic linkage was reduced. Transfection was fairly efficient with phage S2 DNA, but not prophage DNA. Donor marker activity could be detected in transformed cell lysates, but not linked to recipient markers in recombinant molecules. Sucrose gradient analysis of such lysates revealed that donor material was associated with recipient DNA in at least normal quantities, but lacked detectable genetic activity. Material from donor DNA labeled with heavy isotopes was incorporated into recipient chromosomal fragments having a density indistinguishable from normal density, unlike the hybrid density recombinant material found in normal cells. No excessive solubilization or nicking of unincorporated donor was detected. It is postulated that this strain contains a hyperactive nuclease, which reduces the effective size of the input DNA during the integration process.     

Conjugation in Escherichia coli: Interactions Affecting Recombination Frequencies for Markers Situated at the Leading End of the Donor Chromosome

Experiments have been performed to test the validity of a model which relates low recovery of very early donor markers in recombinants to the presence of sex-factor deoxyribonucleic acid at the leading end of donor deoxyribonucleic acid transferred by conjugation. This model has been found to be incorrect. The results obtained do not rule out the possibility that a piece of sex factor is transferred at the leading end, but indicate, however, that if this occurs it is not the cause of the low recovery of a very early donor marker.     

Fate of transforming bacteriophage HP1 deoxyribonucleic acid in Haemophilus influenzae lysogens.

The biological fate of temperate phage HP1 deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) was followed after uptake by defectively lysogenic competent Haemophilus influenzae cultures. The similar inactivation kinetics of three single phage genetic markers and of their triple combination indicated a complete rather than partial destruction of about half of the adsorbed DNA molecules. Intracellular DNA breakdown products were tentatively identified by hydroxyapatite column chromatography as short single strands and extensively damaged short double strands. Integrated donor DNA (after single-strand insertion?) was still highly efficient for triple-marker co-transformation. This suggests that whole or nearly whole donor DNA molecules were integrated. Some donor DNA was never integrated but remained largely unaltered. This DNA fraction did not contain significant amounts of recipient prophage marker activity. It is concluded that it had not participated in some kind of reciprocal recombination event involving the recipient chromosome. Since very similar phage DNA marker inactivation rates were observed after adsorption by competent nonlysogenic recipients (transfection), the relationship between biological inactivation of adsorbed donor phage DNA and its integration in lysogenic recipients is not clear.     

Recovery of Colony-Forming Ability and Genetic Marker Activity by UV-Damaged Hemophilus influenzae

The rate of recovery of UV-irradiated Hemophilus influenzae from acriflavine-sensitized loss of colony-forming ability was studied at various acriflavine concentrations, UV doses, and temperatures. This rate (as calculated from an equation based upon certain assumptions) was on the order of 0.07 per minute per cell at 37°C. This did not vary greatly with UV dose or acriflavine concentration, but did with temperature, giving a ΔH‡ of about 16 kcal/mole. In another set of experiments, cells bearing two genetic markers (resistance to 2000 μg/ml streptomycin and to 2.5 μg/ml novobiocin) were irradiated and then incubated without acriflavine. DNA extracts made from samples taken after various periods of incubation time were assayed on antibiotic-sensitive cells using acriflavine to inhibit repair during and following transformation. It was found that both in vivo irradiated markers were reactivated in the donor to approximately the same extent (with a rate constant of 0.04 per minute). This result was in contrast to the results obtained when extracted DNA bearing the same markers was irradiated in vitro and used to transform cells. In this latter case the streptomycin marker was much more sensitive than the novobiocin marker. This difference is interpreted as being due to the mechanics of the transformation system.     

Comparison of Deoxyribonucleic Acid Uptake and Marker Integration in Bacilli and Protoplasts of Bacillus subtilis

trp(+)his(-) donor deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) was added to highly competent trp(-)his(+) recipient bacilli and to protoplasts prepared from these bacilli, and the cell-DNA complexes were incubated for 30 min. The complexes were then washed and lysed, and their DNA was analyzed on a trp(-)his(-) strain for the donor marker trp(+), the resident marker his(+), and for the recombinant trp(+)his(+) combination. The extracts of the bacillary complexes contained a normal percentage of donor markers (0.1-0.2%), and the number of trp(+)his(+) doubles (20% of all trp(+) transformants) indicated that the donor DNA had become integrated into the resident genomes. The protoplast complexes contained 10 to 1,000 times fewer donor markers and almost no recombinants. This indicated that, in protoplasts, marker uptake was minimal and recombination was absent. Uptake was also measured with (3)H-labeled DNA. On the average, protoplasts took up one-fiftieth as much DNA as bacilli. It was concluded that, probably, protoplasts took up no DNA at all, that there were no DNA affinity sites on the surface of the protoplasts, and that the residual marker and radioactivity uptake was due to imperfections in the experimental system. The data and conclusions differed sharply from earlier ones of Hirokawa and Ikeda despite the fact that the techniques of these authors were followed in repeat experiments.     

Cell to cell transmission of donor DNA overcomes differential incorporation of non-homologous and homologous markers in Neisseria gonorrhoeae

The neisseriae are naturally competent for DNA transformation. This genetic study examines whether the modification status of chromosomal donor DNA affects transformation of Neisseria gonorrhoeae to drug resistance. When a single modification system was inactivated, unmodified chromosomal donor DNA was not restricted when used to transform the cognate restriction+ host, irrespective of whether the donor DNA carried a point mutation (homologous marker) or a drug-resistance gene cassette (non-homologous marker). These observations contrasted transformations performed with unmodified plasmid donor DNAs, where the incoming DNA was excluded. However, during the study, it became apparent that certain strains of gonococci showed differential incorporation of non-homologous markers when compared with the incorporation of the homologous marker, even when the donor DNAs were prepared from parental strains. Differential incorporation of markers could be rescued either through cell to cell transmission of donor DNA, or by performing in vitro transformations with donor DNA preparations that were obtained from spent culture supernatants. Overall, the data indicate that, in addition to the exclusion of foreign DNA through the requirement for a genus-specific uptake sequence, gonococci appear capable of excluding DNA on the basis of homology.     

Effect of 4,5'',8-trimethylpsoralen interstrand cross-links present in recipient Bacillus subtilis on the integration of transforming DNA.

When recipient Bacillus subtilis carrying chromosomal trimethylpsoralen cross-links were transformed, the donor marker activity decreased with the extent of cross-linking. Additional donor marker activity was lost upon incubation of the reextracted DNA with nuclease S1, particularly at higher levels of cross-linking. Physical analysis of the reextracted DNA showed that the donor DNA was progressively excluded from heteroduplex formation as the frequency of cross-links in the recipient DNA increased. In the donor-recipient complexes still being formed, increasing amounts of donor DNA became susceptible to nuclease S1 digestion under these conditions. These results suggest that resident interstrand cross-links interfere both with initiation of recombination and with the completion of heteroduplex formation.     

Loss of activity of transforming deoxyribonucleic acid after uptake by Haemophilus influenzae

Voll, Mary Jane (University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia), and Sol H. Goodgal. Loss of activity of transforming deoxyribonucleic acid after uptake by Haemophilus influenzae. J. Bacteriol. 90:873-883. 1965.-Transforming deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) which has been irreversibly removed from solution by competent cells undergoes a progressive loss in marker activity when tested by lysis of the cells and exposure to new recipient cells. The loss of activity is limited and marker-specific, with greater inactivation of those markers with lower efficiencies of transformation. Recipient factors or donor factors which have undergone recombination, as measured by the appearance of linked markers, do not undergo inactivation. The efficiency of transformation can be correlated with the sensitivity of a marker to inactivation after DNA uptake. A mutation which affects the efficiency of transformation is found to increase sensitivity to postuptake inactivation. The rate of inactivation is temperature-dependent. At temperatures of 20 and 45 C, marker inactivation can occur without concomitant recombination. During the uptake process, DNA is retained in an acid-insoluble form, indicating that the fate of Haemophilus influenzae DNA differs from the fate of transforming DNA in pneumococcus.     

Molecular mechanism of genetic recombination in bacterial transformation

Summary B. subtilis cells auxotrophic for two linked markers (ind-his, ind-tyr, his-tyr) have been transformed by means of DNA preparations obtained by hybridization of wild type DNA with the DNA of a strain auxotrophic for one of the linked markers. It was established that hybridization does not increase the transforming activity of DNA for the heterozygous marker. A genetic analysis of the progeny of cells transformed by hybrid or wild type DNA was performed. On the basis of the data obtained a model of genetic recombination in transformation is proved. According to this model both strands of the donor DNA interact independently with the chromosome, and either strand can be incorporated into the cell genome with equal probability. According to the estimate made on the basis of this hypothesis, the probability of integration of a single DNA strand carrying a particular genetic marker is 8%.With 3 Figures in the Text     

Transformation and Deoxyribonucleic Acid Size: Extent of Degradation on Entry Varies with Size of Donor

The fate of label introduced as donor deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) into competent cells of Diplococcus pneumoniae was determined immediately after entry at 25 C, as a function of the size of the donor DNA. Part of the label is found to be acid soluble, part has been incorporated into chromosomal DNA, apparently through reincorporation of degraded donor DNA, and part is found in single strands of length smaller than that of the input donor DNA strands. The last fraction apparently constitutes the precursor for integration of intact donor genetic markers and is referred to as the intact fraction. For large donor DNA the intact fraction contains over 80% of the total intracellular label, but the median strand length has been reduced to 2.2 x 10(6) daltons. For small donor molecules (1 x 10(5) to 6 x 10(5) daltons per strand) the fraction intact increases with donor size from 10 to 50% of the total intracellular label, and the median strand length of this fraction is half that of the donor strands. By combining these results with earlier data on the size dependence of the yield of transformants per unit of total intracellular donor label, we have calculated the probability that a marker in the intact fraction will be integrated, as a function of the length of the donor strand after entry. This probability has a linear dependence on strand length for activities below 40% of maximum, and extrapolates to zero activity at 77,000 daltons per strand.     

Construction of DNA Marker Plasmids Based on Taq Tailing Activity and Selective Recovery of Ligation Products

DNA fragments with standard molecular weights (DNA markers, which are usually commercial products) are routinely electrophoresed in conjunction with DNA samples in molecular biology labs to serve as references for DNA molecular weight; this is done by referencing their relative molecular weights. In this study, we present a new technical strategy for constructing super-plasmids for homemade DNA marker production with single restriction enzyme digestion. In this study, two super-plasmids for DNA marker production have been developed, based on tailing activity of Taq polymerase and selective recovery of ligation products following agarose gel electrophoresis.     

Integration and Repair of Ultraviolet-Irradiated Transforming Deoxyribonucleic Acid in Haemophilus influenzae

The extent of association between donor transforming deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) and recipient DNA in Haemophilus influenzae as a function of ultraviolet (UV) dose to the transforming DNA has been measured by isopycnic analysis of lysates of (3)H-labeled recipient cells exposed to DNA labeled with (32)P and heavy isotopes. Except for doses above 15,000 ergs/mm(2), the results of these measurements are in good agreement with previous estimates made by another technique. Experiments with a mutant temperature sensitive for DNA synthesis and another mutant defective in excision of pyrimidine dimers suggest that the discrepancy between the methods of high doses results from DNA synthesis, in which portions of the associated donor DNA containing pyrimidine dimers are excised and broken down, and the components are reutilized for synthesis.Repair of UV-irradiated, transforming DNA during incubation of recipient cells is observed as an increase in transforming ability when fractions from CsCl gradients of cell lysates are assayed on excision-deficient cells. When transforming DNA containing markers of different UV sensitivities is used, repair of the UV-resistant nov marker by excision proficient cells takes place exclusively in the donor DNA that is associated with recipient DNA, and this repair is observed even in the absence of DNA synthesis. However, no repair is observed in the case of the more UV-sensitive str marker, possibly because excision events may remove a large fraction of the integrated str markers in addition to repairing a small fraction of the integrated DNA containing this marker.     

Molecular Events Accompanying the Fixation of Genetic Information in Haemophilus Heterospecific Transformation

Heterospecific transformation between Haemophilus influenzae and H. parainfluenzae was investigated by isopycnic analysis of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) extracts of (3)H-labeled transforming cells that had been exposed to (32)P-labeled, heavy transforming DNA. The density distribution of genetic markers from the resident DNA and from the donor DNA was determined by transformation assay of fractions from CsCl gradients, both species being used as recipients. About 50% of the (32)P atoms in H. parainfluenzae donor DNA taken up by H. influenzae cells were transferred to resident DNA, and only a small amount of the label was lost under conditions of little cell growth. There was less transfer in the reciprocal cross, and almost half of the donor label was lost. In both crosses, the transferred donor material transformed for the donor marker considerably more efficiently when assayed on the donor species than on the recipient species, indicating that at least some of the associated (32)P atoms are contained in relatively long stretches of donor DNA. When the transformed cultures were incubated under growth conditions, the donor marker associated with recipient DNA transformed the donor species with progressively decreasing efficiency. The data indicate that the low heterospecific transformation between H. influenzae and H. parainfluenzae may be due partly to events occurring before association of donor and resident DNA but results mostly from events that occur after the association of the two DNA preparations.     

Heterospecific transformation of Pneumococcus and Streptococcus

Summary Transformations of two linked ribosomal loci (str and ery) were carried out between the SIII-1 strain of pneumococcus and the Challis and SBE strains of group H streptococcus. Transfer of markers between the Challis and SBE strains is as efficient as in the corresponding intrastrain transformations. Transfer between either of these strains and the pneumococcus, however, is less efficient than in the corresponding intrastrain transformation, and is referred to as heterospecific transformation. The inefficiency of the heterospecific transformation is due neither to specific lethality nor reduced uptake of heterologous DNA.When DNA was extracted from the hybrid resulting from a heterospecific cross and used to transform the original donor and recipient species, we found: (a) no donor material in the hybrid DNA responsible for the markedly low efficiency of integration into the recipient species; (b) donor material, in addition to the transforming marker itself, detectable by the higher efficiency with which hybrid DNA transforms the original donor species than does DNA from the original recipient species.DNA was extracted from each of 36 independently derived, doubly marked transformants resulting from the cross: Challis str-s ery-sxSIII-1 str-r53 ery-r2 DNA. Variability was observed between the different hybrid DNAs when the integration efficiency of the str marker in each DNA was compared with that of the ery marker. Variability of as great a magnitude was not observed when the same hybrid DNA was tested in repeated experiments, or when different DNA preparations were extracted from the same hybrid strain, or when several DNA preparations were obtained from a number of independent homospecific transformants. It is concluded that different kinds of donor material are present in the various hybrids, and that the nature of this extra-marker material affects the integration of the marker.Linkage of the str and ery markers was reduced in heterospecific transformations. The kind of donor DNA in the hybrid genome did not affect the linkage reduction observed when the str and ery markers were transferred back to the donor species in which they originated. Indeed, this linkage reduction was the same as that observed when the markers were originally transferred from the SIII-1 to the Challis strain. Specific factors reducing linkage in heterologous crosses must, therefore, be distinct from other factors which affect integration efficiency. The former, however, may be primarily responsible for the inefficiency of heterospecific transformation.One of the hybrid DNAs was used to obtain a second generation of hybrids by passing it through each of the original parental strains. Tests of the DNAs extracted from 24 independently produced, second-generation hybrids showed that hybrid DNA is subject to further alteration by a second integration involving some heterologous confrontation. The probability of such alteration appears to be increased if the second integration is accompanied by linkage reduction.Supported by NIH grant AI-00917.     

A Transforming Marker That Produces Merodiploids with High Efficiency and Stable Transformants with Low Efficiency in Streptococcus

A mutation (ery-r8) conferring a high level of resistance to erythromycin in the Challis strain of Streptoccus sanguis can be transferred to wild-type erythromycin-sensitive recipients via single molecules of donor DNA. The transformants thus produced are of two types: (1) cells slightly more resistant to erythromycin than wild-type and capable of segregating (at a frequency of 2 X 10(-4)/bacterium/generation) either wild-type or highly-resistant cells like the original donor type; (2) cells phenotypically and genotypically identical to the original donor type. The unstable diploids (ery-r8/+) occur with a frequency equivalent to that obtained with high-efficiency (HE) markers, whereas the stable donor-type (ery-r8) transformants occur with about five hundred times lower frequency. Penetration of the wild-type recipient by more than one molecule of DNA bearing the ery-r8 marker increases by as much as seven times the incidence of stable transformants. UV-irradiation of molecules bearing the ery-r8 marker diminishes their ability to cooperate in producing a stable transformant, although the UV sensitivity of stable transformant production by a single DNA molecule is not different from that of diploid production. Hence, stable transformants do not appear to be produced by a process typical of low efficiency (LE) markers, which are generally highly sensitive to ultraviolet irradiation. Moreover, stable ery-r8 transformants are produced with equally low frequencies in strains of S. pneumoniae that discriminate (hex+) and fail to discriminate (hex--) between HE and LE markers. We postulate that all transformations by the ery-r8 marker result in ery-r8/+ diploids, and that segregation results in the infrequent stable transformants of the original donor type. This hypothesis is supported by the observations that rifampin treatment of ery-r8/+ populations increases the frequency of segregation and similar treatment of wild-type recipients under-going transformation by the ery-r8 marker increases the frequency of stable transformants.--In producing the ery-r8/+ transformant the r8 allele is integrated close to the site of its wild-type homolog, since single molecules of DNA from this transformant can be shown to carry both alleles. Segregation of either the ery-r8 or + allele is not detectably enhanced by acridine orange or thymidine deprivation.--The ery-r8 marker occurs close to a site of mutation (ery-r2) which confers erythromycin resistance upon ribosomes. When the r2 and r8 markers are jointly transferred, ery-r2-r8/+ genomes are produced in which the r2 marker is stably integrated but the r8 marker is unstably adjoined to its wild-type homolog. Thus, the duplicated region can be quite short. When the ery-r8 marker is stably integrated, the region of the marker is refractory to subsequent transformation. Markers with properties like ery-r8 are not particularly rare, being found with a frequency of about 4% among spontaneous mutations to erythromycin resistance.     

Characterization of genetic transformation in Streptococcus mutans by using a novel high-efficiency plasmid marker rescue system.

We developed a marker rescue system for study of competence development and genetic transformation in Streptococcus mutans. The system involved the recombinational rescue of a tetracycline resistance (Tcr) determinant by a homologous, inactive locus (Tcs because of a small deletion). Streptococcal cells harboring this in vitro-prepared Tcs construct (pVA1208) were restored to Tcr when plasmid (pVA981) DNA was used as donor material. pVA981 contained the intact streptococcal Tcr locus and was unable to autonomously replicate in streptococci. Marker rescue with this system followed first-order kinetics and occurred at a frequency 8- or 160-fold higher than did transformation with homologous chromosomal or plasmid DNA, respectively. By using the rescue system, we were able to confirm that competence of S. mutans appeared to be inducible. This was indicated by a sequential increase and then decrease in Tcr transformation frequencies during growth in complex medium. Also, donor DNA binding was not sequence specific, since the recovery of Tcr transformants was reduced by increasing the concentrations of heterologous DNA. We investigated the fate of donor DNA and the kinetics of plasmid establishment in the transformation of S. mutans with plasmid DNA. Monomeric plasmid molecules transformed S. mutans as a second-order process, whereas multimeric plasmid DNA and chromosomal markers were recovered as a first-order process. Approximately 50% of the initially bound donor plasmid DNA was found to remain in a trichloroacetic acid-insoluble form. Our results suggested that molecular cloning in S. mutans would be conducted most efficiently by using helper plasmid systems or shuttle vectors and that gene transfer by transformation of S. mutans occurred in a manner similar to that observed in Streptococcus sanguis.     

Fate of Donor Deoxyribonucleic Acid in a Highly Transformation-Deficient Strain of Haemophilus influenzae

A transformation-deficient strain of Haemophilus influenzae (efficiency of transformation 10⁴-fold less than that of the wild type), designated TD24, was isolated by selection for sensitivity to mitomycin C. In its properties the mutant was equivalent to recA type mutants of Escherichia coli. The TD24 mutation was linked with the str-r marker (about 30%) and only weakly linked with the nov-r2.5 marker. The uptake of donor deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) was normal in the TD24 strain, but no molecules with recombinant-type activity (molecules carrying both the donor and the resident marker) were formed. In the mutant the intracellular presynaptic fate of the donor DNA was the same as that in the transformation-proficient (wild-type) strain, and the radioactive label of the donor DNA associated covalently with the recipient chromosome in about the same quantity as in the wild type. However, many fewer donor atoms were associated with segments of the mutant's recipient chromosome as compared with segments of the wild-type chromosome. In the mutant the association was accompanied by complete loss of donor marker activity. The lack of donor marker activity of the donor-recipient complex of DNA isolated from the mutant was not due to lack of uptake of the complex by the second recipient and its inability to associate with the second recipient's chromosome. Because the number of donor-atom-carrying resident molecules was higher than could be accounted for by the lengths of presynaptic donor molecules, we favor the idea that the association of donor DNA atoms with the mutant chromosome results from local DNA synthesis rather than from dispersive integration of donor DNA by recombination.