Molecular defects caused by temperature-sensitive mutations in Semliki Forest virus nsP1

Alphavirus replicase protein nsP1 has multiple functions during viral RNA synthesis. It catalyzes methyltransferase and guanylyltransferase activities needed in viral mRNA capping, attaches the viral replication complex to cytoplasmic membranes, and is required for minus-strand RNA synthesis. Two temperature-sensitive (ts) mutations in Semliki Forest virus (SFV) were previously identified within nsP1: ts10 (E529D) and ts14 (D119N). Recombinant viruses containing these individual mutations reproduced the features of the original ts strains. We now find that the capping-associated enzymatic activities of recombinant nsP1, containing ts10 or ts14 lesions, were not ts. The mutant proteins and polyproteins also were membrane bound, mutant nsP1 interacted normally with the other nonstructural proteins, and there was no major defect in nonstructural polyprotein processing in the mutants, although ts14 surprisingly displayed slightly retarded processing. The two mutant viruses were specifically defective in minus-strand RNA synthesis at the restrictive temperature. Integrating data from SFV and Sindbis virus, we discuss the domain structure of nsP1 and the relative positioning of and interactions between the replicase proteins. nsP1 is suggested to contain a specific subdomain involved in minus-strand synthesis and interaction with the polymerase nsP4 and the protease nsP2.     

Specific Sindbis virus-coded function for minus-strand RNA synthesis.

The synthesis of minus-strand RNA was studied in cell cultures infected with the heat-resistant strain of Sindbis virus and with temperature-sensitive (ts) belonging to complementation groups A, B, F, and G, all of which exhibited an RNA-negative (RNA-) phenotype when infection was initiated and maintained at 39 degrees C, the nonpermissive temperature. When infected cultures were shifted from 28 degrees C (the permissive temperature) to 39 degrees C at 3 h postinfection, the synthesis of viral minus-strand RNA ceased in cultures infected with ts mutants of complementation groups B and F, but continued in cultures infected with the parental virus and mutans of complementation groups A and G. In cultures infected with ts11 of complementation group B, the synthesis of viral minus-strand RNA ceased, whereas the synthesis of 42S and 26S plus-strand RNAs continued for at least 5 h after the shift to 39 degrees C. However, when ts11-infected cultures were returned to 28 degrees C 1 h after the shift to 39 degrees C, the synthesis of viral minus-strand RNA resumed, and the rate of viral RNA synthesis increased. The recovery of minus-strand synthesis translation of new proteins. We conclude that at least one viral function is required for alphavirus minus-strand synthesis that is not required for plus-strand synthesis. In cultures infected with ts6 of complementation group F, the syntheses of both viral plus-strand and minus-strand RNAs were drastically reduced after the shift to 39 degrees C. Since ts6 failed to synthesize both plus-strand and minus-strand RNAs after the shift to 39 degrees C, at least one common viral component appears to be required for the synthesis of both minus-strand and plus-strand RNAs.     

BHK cells expressing Sindbis virus-induced homologous interference allow the translation of nonstructural genes of superinfecting virus.

The process by which Sindbis virus excludes superinfecting homologous virus was investigated with the use of temperature-sensitive mutants. Mutants in two RNA-negative complementation groups were found to be defective in their ability to establish interference at the nonpermissive temperature. These mutants were unable to establish interference in a mixed infection (complementation), suggesting that both were defective in a common gene product. Homologous interference was found to block the replication of superinfecting virus after attachment, penetration, and translation of the nonstructural genes encoded in the virus RNA. The production of nonstructural gene products of superinfecting wild-type virus was found to enhance the replication of certain RNA- temperature-sensitive interfering viruses at the permissive and the nonpermissive temperature. The ability of certain RNA- mutants to establish homologous interference and to demonstrate enhanced growth after superinfection with wild-type virus was interpreted to produce a model implicating both virus and host components in the establishment of homologous interference and in the replication of Sindbis virus RNA.     

Functional defects of RNA-negative temperature-sensitive mutants of Sindbis and Semliki Forest viruses.

Defects in RNA and protein synthesis of seven Sindbis virus and seven Semliki Forest virus RNA-negative, temperature-sensitive mutants were studied after shift to the restrictive temperature (39 degrees C) in the middle of the growth cycle. Only one of the mutants, Ts-6 of Sindbis virus, a representative of complementation group F, was clearly unable to continue RNA synthesis at 39 degrees C, apparently due to temperature-sensitive polymerase. The defect was reversible and affected the synthesis of both 42S and 26S RNA equally, suggesting that the same polymerase component(s) is required for the synthesis of both RNA species. One of the three Sindbis virus mutants of complementation group A, Ts-4, and one RNA +/- mutant of Semliki Forest virus, ts-10, showed a polymerase defect even at the permissive temperature. Seven of the 14 RNA-negative mutants showed a preferential reduction in 26S RNA synthesis. The 26S RNA-defective mutants of Sindbis virus were from two different complementation groups, A and G, indicating that functions of two viral nonstructural proteins ("A" and "G") are required in the regulation of the synthesis of 26S RNA. Since the synthesis of 42S RNA continued, these functions of proteins A and G are not needed for the polymerization of RNA late in infection. The RNA-negative phenotype of 26S RNA-deficient mutants implies that proteins regulating the synthesis of this subgenomic RNA must have another function vital for RNA synthesis early in infection or in the assembly of functional polymerase. Several of the mutants having a specific defect in the synthesis of 26S RNA showed an accumulation of a large nonstructural precursor protein with a molecular weight of about 200,000. One even larger protein was demonstrated in both Semliki Forest virus- and Sindbis virus-infected cells which probably represents the entire nonstructural polyprotein.     

A second nonstructural protein functions in the regulation of alphavirus negative-strand RNA synthesis.

Previous studies (D.L. Sawicki, D. B. Barkhimer, S. G. Sawicki, C. M. Rice, and S. Schlesinger, Virology 174:43-52, 1990) identified a temperature-sensitive (ts) defect in Sindbis virus nonstructural protein 4 (nsP4) that reactivated negative-strand synthesis after its normal cessation at the end of the early phase of replication. We now report identification of two different ts alterations in nsP2 of Ala-517 to Thr in ts17 or Asn-700 to Lys in ts133 that also reactivated negative-strand synthesis. These same mutations caused severely reduced protease processing by nsP2 and recognition of the internal promoter for subgenomic mRNA synthesis and were responsible for the conditional lethality and RNA negativity of these mutants. Reactivation of negative-strand synthesis by mutations in nsP2 resembled that in nsP4: it was a reversible property of stable replication complexes and did not require continuation of viral protein synthesis. Recombinant viruses expressing both mutant nsP2 and nsP4 reactivated negative-strand synthesis more efficiently than did either mutant protein alone, consistent with the hypothesis that both nsP2 and nsP4 participate in template recognition. We propose that these alterations cause nsP2 and nsP4 to switch from their normal preference to recognize negative strands as templates to recognize positive strands and thereby mimic the initial formation of a replication complex.     

Regulation of Sindbis virus RNA replication: uncleaved P123 and nsP4 function in minus-strand RNA synthesis, whereas cleaved products from P123 are required for efficient plus-strand RNA synthesis.

Nonstructural proteins of Sindbis virus, nsP1, nsP2, nsP3, and nsP4, as well as intermediate polyproteins, are produced from two precursor polyproteins, P123 and P1234, by a proteolytic enzyme encoded in the C-terminal half of nsP2. We studied the requirements for and the functions of the intermediate and mature processing products for Sindbis virus RNA synthesis by using site-directed mutants which have a defect(s) in processing the 1/2, 2/3, or 3/4 cleavage sites either singly or in various combinations. A mutant defective in cleaving both the 1/2 and 2/3 sites, which makes only uncleavable P123 and mature nsP4 as final products, produced 10(-3) as much virus as did the wild-type virus after 10 h at 30 degrees C and was nonviable at 40 degrees C. A mutant defective in processing the 2/3 site, which makes nsP1, nsP4, and P23 as well as precursor P123, grew 10(-1) as efficiently as wild-type virus at 30 degrees C and 10(-3) as efficiently at 40 degrees C. Early minus-strand RNA synthesis by these mutants was as efficient as that by wild-type virus, whereas plus-strand RNA synthesis was substantially decreased compared with that by wild-type virus. A mutant defective in processing the 3/4 site was nonviable at either 30 or 40 degrees C. The 3/4 site mutant could be complemented by the mutant unable to cleave either the 1/2 or 2/3 site, which can provide mature nsP4. We interpret these results to signify that (i) mature nsP4 is required for RNA replication, (ii) nsP4 and uncleaved P123 function in minus-strand RNA synthesis, and (iii) cleavage of P123 is required for efficient plus-strand RNA synthesis. We propose that Sindbis virus RNA replication is regulated by differential proteolysis of P123. Early in infection, nsP4 and uncleaved P123 form transient minus-strand RNA replication complexes which vanish upon cleavage of P123. Later in infection, an elevated level of viral proteinase activity eliminates de novo synthesis of P123, and no further synthesis of minus-strand RNA is possible. In contrast, nsP4 and cleavage products from P123 form plus-strand RNA replication complexes which are stable and remain active throughout the infection cycle.     

Alphavirus minus-strand RNA synthesis: identification of a role for Arg183 of the nsP4 polymerase

A partially conserved region spanning amino acids 142 to 191 of the Sindbis virus (SIN) nsP4 core polymerase is implicated in host restriction, elongation, and promoter recognition. We extended the analysis of this region by substituting Ser, Ala, or Lys for a highly conserved Arg183 residue immediately preceding its absolutely conserved Ser184-Ala-Val-Pro-Ser188 sequence. In chicken cells, the nsP4 Arg183 mutants had a nonconditionally lethal, temperature-sensitive (ts) growth phenotype caused by a ts defect in minus-strand synthesis whose extent varied with the particular amino acid substituted (Ser>Ala>Lys). Plus-strand synthesis by nsP4 Arg183 mutant polymerases was unaffected when corrected for minus-strand numbers, although 26S mRNA synthesis was enhanced at the elevated temperature compared to wild type. The ts defect was not due to a failure to form or accumulate nsP4 at 40 degrees C. In contrast to their growth in chicken cells, the nsP4 Arg183 mutants replicated equally poorly, if at all, in mosquito cells. We conclude that Arg183 within the Pro180-Asn-Ile-Arg-Ser184 sequence of the SIN nsP4 polymerase contributes to the efficient initiation of minus strands or the formation of its replicase and that a host factor(s) participates in this event.     

Formation of a Sindbis virus nonstructural protein and its relation of 42S mRNA function.

Chicken embryo fibroblasts infected with an RNA- temperature-sensitive mutant (ts24) of Sindbis virus accumulated a large-molecular-weight protein (p200) when cells were shifted from the permissive to nonpermissive temperature. Appearance of p200 was accompanied by a decrease in the synthesis of viral structural proteins, but [35S]methionine tryptic peptides from p200 were different from those derived from a 140,000-molecular-weight polypeptide that contains the amino acid sequences of viral structural proteins. Among three other RNA- ts mutants that were tested for p200 formation, only one (ts21) produced this protein. The accumulation of p200 in ts24- and ts21-infected cells could be correlated with a shift in the formation of 42S and 26S viral RNA that led to an increase in the relative amounts of 42S RNA. These data indicate that p200 is translated from the nonstructural genes of the virion 42S RNA and further suggest that this RNA does not function effectively in vivo as an mRNA for the Sindbis virus structural proteins.     

Requirement for the amino-terminal domain of sindbis virus nsP4 during virus infection

The Sindbis virus RNA-dependent RNA polymerase nsP4 possesses an amino-terminal region that is unique to alphaviruses and is predicted to be disordered. To determine the importance of this region during alphavirus replication, 29 mutations were introduced, and resultant viruses were assessed for growth defects. Three small plaque mutants, D41A, G83L, and the triple mutant GPG((8-10))VAV, had defects in subgenome synthesis, minus-strand synthesis, and overall levels of viral RNA synthesis, respectively. Large plaque viruses were selected following passage in BHK-21 cells, and the genomes of these were sequenced. Suppressor mutations in nsP1, nsP2, and nsP3 that restored viral RNA synthesis were identified. An nsP2 change from M282 to L and an nsP3 change from H99 to N corrected the D41A-induced defect in subgenomic RNA synthesis. Three changes in nsP1, I351 to V, I388 to V, or the previously identified change, N374 to H (C. L. Fata, S. G. Sawicki, and D. L. Sawicki, J. Virol. 76:8641-8649, 2002), suppressed the minus-strand synthetic defect. A direct reversion back to G at position 8 reduced the RNA synthesis defect of the GPG((8-10))VAV virus. These results imply that nsP4's amino-terminal domain participates in distinct interactions with other nsPs in the context of differentially functioning RNA synthetic complexes, and flexibility in this domain is important for viral RNA synthesis. Additionally, the inability of the mutant viruses to efficiently inhibit host protein synthesis suggests a role for nsP4 in the regulation of host cell gene expression.     

Modification of Asn374 of nsP1 suppresses a Sindbis virus nsP4 minus-strand polymerase mutant

Our recent study (C. L. Fata, S. G. Sawicki, and D. L. Sawicki, J. Virol. 76:8632-8640, 2002) found minus-strand synthesis to be temperature sensitive in vertebrate and invertebrate cells when the Arg183 residue of the Sindbis virus nsP4 polymerase was changed to Ser, Ala, or Lys. Here we report the results of studies identifying an interacting partner of the region of the viral polymerase containing Arg183 that suppresses the Ser183 codon mutation. Large-plaque revertants were observed readily following growth of the nsP4 Ser183 mutant at 40 degrees C. Fifteen revertants were characterized, and all had a mutation in the Asn374 codon of nsP1 that changed it to either a His or an Ile codon. When combined with nsP4 Ser183, substitution of either His374 or Ile374 for Asn374 restored wild-type growth in chicken embryo fibroblast (CEF) cells at 40 degrees C. In Aedes albopictus cells at 34.5 degrees C, neither nsP1 substitution suppressed the nsP4 Ser183 defect in minus-strand synthesis. This argued that the nsP4 Arg183 residue itself is needed for minus-strand replicase assembly or function in the mosquito environment. The nsP1 His374 suppressor when combined with the wild-type nsP4 gave greater than wild-type levels of viral RNA synthesis in CEF cells at 40 degrees C ( approximately 140%) and in Aedes cells at 34.5 degrees C (200%). Virus producing nsP1 His374 and wild-type nsP4 Arg183 made more minus strands during the early period of infection and before minus-strand synthesis ceased at about 4 h postinfection. Shirako et al. (Y. Shirako, E. G. Strauss, and J. H. Strauss, Virology 276:148-160, 2000) identified amino acid substitutions in nsP1 and nsP4 that suppressed mutations that changed the N-terminal Tyr of nsP4. The nsP4 N-terminal mutants were defective also in minus-strand synthesis. Our study implicates an interaction between another conserved nsP1 region and an internal region, predicted to be in the finger domain, of nsP4 for the formation or activity of the minus-strand polymerase. Finally, the observation that a single point mutation in nsP1 results in minus-strand synthesis at greater than wild-type levels supports the concept that the wild-type nsP sequences are evolutionary compromises.     

Identification of mutations causing temperature-sensitive defects in Semliki Forest virus RNA synthesis

We have sequenced the nonstructural protein coding region of Semliki Forest virus temperature-sensitive (ts) mutant strains ts1, ts6, ts9, ts10, ts11, ts13, and ts14. In each case, the individual amino acid changes uncovered were transferred to the prototype strain background and thereby identified as the underlying cause of the altered RNA synthesis phenotype. All mutations mapping to the protease domain of nonstructural protein nsP2 caused defects in nonstructural polyprotein processing and subgenomic RNA synthesis, and all mutations in the helicase domain of nsP2 affected subgenomic RNA production. These types of defects were not associated with mutations in other nonstructural proteins.