Assessment of Atmospheric ozone levels in Israel through foliar injury to Bel-W3 tobacco plants

Summary Nicotiana tabacum L. Bel-W3, which is highly sensitive to ozone, was grown in two glass chambers and exposed to the ambient air at the periphery of Tel-Aviv, during winter, spring, summer and autumn 1978. During the exposure time, atmospheric ozone was continuously measured by a chemiluminescent monitor. Throughout the experiments, plants' height was measured and the number of leaves was determined three times weekly. The extent of injury to the tobacco plants was measured by the percentage of injured plants, the percentage of injured leaves and the percentage of leaves' area injured. Necrotic lesions, typical for ozone injury, appeared on the mature leaves of the exposed tobacco plants in three out of four exposures. Appearance of incipient injury and the extent of injury differed among the experiments and depended not only on exposure duration and on ozone concentrations, but also on the exposure conditions. The percentage of injured leaves and the percentage of leaves' area injured, increased with the duration of exposure and with rising cumulative ozone concentrations.This work was partially supported by the Chief Scientist's Office—Israeli Ministry of Health—Contract No. 550     

The response of sensitive and tolerant clones of Populus tremuloides to dynamic ozone exposure under controlled environmental conditions

Both sensitive and tolerant clones of aspen ( Populus tremuloides ) were exposed to ozone using four different exposure regimes under controlled environmental conditions. Based on data on ambient ozone from 10 cities in the USA, three treatments of 4-wk exposure to the same SUM06 (an accumulation of hourly O₃ concentrations greater than 0.06 ml l⁻¹) were constructed. The regimes allowed us to investigate: (a) the importance of long (3 wk, treatment 1) versus short (1 wk, treatment 2) duration of regimes with high peaks; (b) the effect of treatments with variable peak occurrence (treatments 1 and 2) versus uniform peak occurrence (treatment 3) during the exposure period. Nonfumigated control plants were maintained at ozone concentrations <10 nl l⁻¹. Bifacial black necrosis, a typical symptom of ozone injury on aspen leaves, occurred on both clones after 2 wk exposure. Up to 60% of the leaves on the sensitive clone were injured, with an average of 6% of total leaf area injured. In the tolerant clone only 10% of the leaves were injured, with less than 1% of the total leaf area symptomatic. The severity of injury was consistently greatest in treatment 2, followed by treatments 1 and 3, respectively. The interval between peak exposures was less important than the occurrence of peaks versus a stable maximum concentration. Premature leaf abscission occurred in the sensitive clone. Measures of gas exchange demonstrated reduced photosynthesis under ozone fumigation, but exposure regime was not a significant factor. Concentrations of two antioxidants, ascorbic acid and glutathione, were almost always greater in the resistant than in the sensitive clone, but the differences were not statistically significant. The levels of these antioxidants in aspen leaves did not change with ozone fumigation or leaf age.     

烟草气孔特性、抗氧化酶活性与臭氧伤害的关系

 2001～2002连续两年在大田生产条件下研究了10个烤烟基因型气孔密度和气孔导度的变异情况及其与抗臭氧伤害的关系;2002年在控制条件下采用低温加臭氧的方法处理烟草植株,研究分析了烟草叶片遭受臭氧伤害后抗氧化酶活性的变化及其与抗臭氧伤害的关系。结果表明：烤烟不同基因型对臭氧伤害的抗性存在显著的差异。烟草叶片下表皮气孔密度和气孔导度与臭氧伤害引起的气候斑点病具有相关关系,在烟株下部叶中,其相关性分别达到显著（R2001＝0.68,R2002＝0.65）和极显著水平（R2001＝0.87,R2002＝0.80）。因此,下部叶气孔密度和气孔导度可以作为抗病育种的选择指标。在控制条件下的试验结果表明：只有低温加臭氧复合因子才能诱发烟草叶片产生臭氧伤害症状。烟草叶片低温下遭遇臭氧伤害后,超氧化物歧化酶（SOD）活性升高,升幅与气候斑点病病情指数负相关,过氧化氢酶（CAT）活性略有升高,过氧化物酶（POD）活性急剧下降。抗性较差的烟草基因型抗氧化酶反应不敏感,臭氧伤害症状严重,抗性较强的烟草基因型抗氧化酶反应敏感,臭氧伤害症状较轻。低温和臭氧同时作用明显影响了活性氧清除系统,致使系统中酶活性比例失调,POD活性急剧下降,可能是烟草叶片产生臭氧伤害的原因之一,SOD和CAT活性升高对消除臭氧伤害具有一定的防御作用。     

Response of subterranean clover (Trifolium subterraneum) to ozone in relation to plant age and light conditions during exposure

Potted subterranean clover ( Trifolium subterraneum ) plants of different ages were exposed to 70 nl l⁻¹ ozone for 6 h, either during the light or during the dark period in a laboratory-based climate chamber. There was limited visible leaf injury on plants which were 14–20 and 28–34 d old and no significant decrease in biomass after daytime ozone exposure. The oldest leaves of 22–26 d old plants exhibited severe visible injury, which was associated with a significant reduction in biomass in 24–26 d old plants. Thus, ozone-induced visible injury of different magnitude developed in all plants, but was associated with biomass reduction only during a limited period of the plant's life-span. Apart from modifying ozone uptake by plants, climatic conditions are important as growth modifiers. It is suggested that subterranean clover plants of defined developmental stages should be used in bioindication of ozone. Night ozone exposure injured significantly fewer leaves than day exposure. However, some leaves developed visible injury even after night ozone exposure. Night uptake of ozone may be of more importance in northern than in central and southern Europe, because summer nights are short and, for a certain period, never completely dark.     

RESPONSE OF BUSH BEAN EXPOSED TO ACID MIST

Bush bean plants (Phaseolus vulgaris L. cv. Contender) were treated once a week for six weeks with simulated acid mist at five pH levels ranging from 5.5 to 2.0. Leaf injury developed on plants exposed to acid concentrations below pH 3 and many leaves developed a flecking symptom similar to that caused by ozone. An adaxial, interveinal bleached area resembling SO₂ injury also developed on some trifoliate leaves at the low pH treatments. Microscopic observation of injured trifoliates indicated that the palisade cells were plasmolyzed and that the chloroplasts lost structural integrity. Reductions in plant weight and chlorophyll content were detected across the pH gradient. Seed and pod growth were reduced at some intermediate acid depositions even though no visible foliar injury developed. Foliar losses of nitrogen, calcium, magnesium and phosphorous increased with decreases in acid mist pH, whereas foliar potassium concentrations were unaffected by acid mist treatment.     

Water Stress Reduces Ozone Injury via a Stomatal Mechanism

Various studies have shown that water-stressed plants are more tolerant of ozone exposures than are unstressed plants. Two probable explanations for this tolerance are (a) stomatal closure which reduces ozone uptake and (b) biochemical or anatomical changes within the leaves. Phaseolus vulgaris cv Pinto bean plants were established and transferred to membrane systems which controlled the osmotic potential around the roots at −35 or −80 kilopascals for 5 days prior to ozone treatment (0 or 1.0 microliters per liter for 2 hours). Both water-stressed and unstressed plants were sprayed with various concentrations of abscisic acid to close the stomata or with fusicoccin to induce stomata opening. The abaxial stomatal resistances of primary and trifoliate leaves were measured just prior to ozone exposure. Plant response to ozone was determined by stress ethylene production and chlorophyll loss. Both water stress and abscisic acid induced stomatal closure and reduced ozone injury. In water-stressed plants, fusicoccin induced stomatal opening and those plants were as sensitive to ozone as were the non-water-stressed plants. These data suggest that water stress protects plants from ozone injury mainly through its influence on stomatal aperture rather than through biochemical or anatomical changes.     

Species- and age-dependent sensitivity to ozone in young plants of pea,wheat and spinach: Effects on acyl lipid and pigment content and metabolism

Acyl lipids and pigments were analyzed in young plants of garden pea, spring wheat and spinach exposed to < 5 or 65 nl l^?1 ozone 12 h per day for 6 days. In one set of experiments, the plants were exposed to ¹⁴CO₂ for 2 h 3 days prior to ozone exposure. The plants responded differently to the moderately enhanced level of ozone used Spinach was not at all sensitive while in both pea and wheat, leaves of different ages differed in ozone sensitivity. In pea, ozone sensitivity increased with leaf age. In the second and third oldest leaves, the amounts of galactolipids per leaf area and the proportions of 18:3 of the total lipid extract and of phosphatidylglycerol decreased. In the second oldest leaf, ozone also caused a decreased proportion of 18:3 of monogalactosyldiacylglycerol. In the fourth oldest leaf, lipid composition and galactolipid unsaturation was unaffected, but ozone caused decreased leaf expansion resulting in increased acyl lipid content per leaf area. In both the first and second leaves of wheat, ozone fumigation caused a marked decrease in the content of monogalactosyldiacylglycerol and in the first leaf, the contents of phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylethanolamine increased. The proportion of 18:3 in phosphatidylcholine was larger in ozone-fumigated than in control plants, while the reverse applied for phosphatidylglycerol. In the oldest sampled leaves of pea and wheat, ozone caused an increase in the radioactivity associated with β-carotene, indicating increased turnover. Thus, while spinach was unaffected, in both pea and wheat ozone caused a decrease in the proportion of chloroplast membrane lipids to non-chloroplast membrane lipids in older leaves while younger leaves were less sensitive.     

Salicylic acid - a potential biomarker of tobacco Bel-W3 cell death developed as a response to ground level ozone under ambient conditions

Salicylic acid content and benzoic acid 2-hydroxylase (BA2H) activity were investigated in tobacco Bel-W3 and Bel-B leaves after exposure to tropospheric ozone in the conditions of ambient air. Plants were exposed in accordance with a standard methodology for ozone biomonitoring, in a three-year experiment. Free salicylic acid (SA), conjugated with glucose (SAG), and as a product of the BA2H activity was quantified with HPLC. In order to evaluate ozone injuries of leaves, an open source image analysis software was employed. Plants exposure to ambient ozone resulted in enhanced BA2H activity and intensified salicylic acid biosynthesis in leaves of Bel-W3 cultivar showing visible ozone injuries. The BA2H activity significantly correlated with SAG for ozone-exposed Bel-W3 plants. Both injuries and salicylic acid biosynthesis rate depended on the growth phase of leaves and nearly linear correlation between SA content and injuries was found for particular leaves of Bel-W3.     

The effects of ozone on growth and stomatal response in the F<Subscript>2</Subscript> generation of hybrid poplar (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Populus trichocarpa × Populus deltoides</Emphasis>)

Thirty-six F₂ hybrid poplar (Populus trichocarpa × P. deltoides) clones were fumigated with ozone to record its effects on growth, correlate them with stomatal response and screen for ozone sensitivity. Fumigation was applied for 6 to 9 h each day for approximately 3 months at ozone concentrations of 85 to 128 μg g⁻¹ using open-top chambers. Height, diameter, number of leaves, stomatal conductance, transpiration rate, total biomass, biomass components and root/shoot ratios were reduced by ozone stress. Percent of leaf fall in ozone-treated plants was nearly three times higher than in control plants exposed to charcoal-filtered air. Leaf senescence, because of ozone exposure, did not appear to be associated with reduced biomass production. Some clones had a high percentage of leaf-fall with ozone exposure, but were able to maintain total biomass production near that of the control. Their response may be an example of an ability to adjust or compensate for ozone damage. There was no significant or consistent relationship between stomatal conductance and total biomass or the change in stomatal conductance as a result of ozone exposure and the change in total biomass. Taken together, these results suggest that effects of ozone on poplar growth cannot be solely correlated to changes in stomatal conductance, more physiological and biochemical parameters should be examined.     

Isoprene Produced by Leaves Protects the Photosynthetic Apparatus against Ozone Damage, Quenches Ozone Products, and Reduces Lipid Peroxidation of Cellular Membranes

Many plants invest carbon to form isoprene. The role of isoprene in plants is unclear, but many experiments showed that isoprene may have a role in protecting plants from thermal damage. A more general antioxidant action has been recently hypothesized on the basis of the protection offered by exogenous isoprene in nonemitting plants exposed to acute ozone doses. We inhibited the synthesis of endogenous isoprene by feeding fosmidomycin and observed that Phragmites australis leaves became more sensitive to ozone than those leaves forming isoprene. Photosynthesis, stomatal conductance, and fluorescence parameters were significantly affected by ozone only in leaves on which isoprene was not formed. The protective effect of isoprene was more evident when the leaves were exposed for a long time (8 h) to relatively low (100 nL L(-1)) ozone levels than when the exposure was short and acute (3 h at 300 nL L(-1)). Isoprene quenched the amount of H(2)O(2) formed in leaves and reduced lipid peroxidation of cellular membranes caused by ozone. These results indicate that isoprene may exert its protective action at the membrane level, although a similar effect could be obtained if isoprene reacted with ozone before forming active oxygen species. Irrespective of the mechanism, our results suggest that endogenous isoprene has an important antioxidant role in plants.     

Ozone suppresses soil drying- and abscisic acid (ABA)-induced stomatal closure via an ethylene-dependent mechanism

Elevated atmospheric ozone concentrations (70 ppb) reduced the sensitivity of stomatal closure to abscisic acid (ABA) in Leontodon hispidus after at least 24 h exposure (1) when detached leaves were fed ABA, and (2) when intact plants were sprayed or injected with ABA. They also reduced the sensitivity of stomatal closure to soil drying around the roots. Such effects could already be occurring under current northern hemisphere peak ambient ozone concentrations. Leaves detached from plants which had been exposed to elevated ozone concentrations generated higher concentrations of ethylene, although leaf tissue ABA concentrations were unaffected. When intact plants were pretreated with the ethylene receptor binding antagonist 1-methylcyclopropene, the stomatal response to both applied ABA and soil drying was fully restored in the presence of elevated ozone. Implications of ethylene's antagonism of the stomatal response to ABA under oxidative stress are discussed. We suggest that this may be one mechanism whereby elevated ozone induces visible injury in sensitive species. We emphasize that drought linked to climate change and tropospheric ozone pollution, are both escalating problems. Ozone will exacerbate the deleterious effects of drought on the many plant species including valuable crops that respond to this pollutant by emitting more ethylene.     

Influence of ozone on transgenic tobacco plants expressing reduced quantities of Rubisco

RbcS-antisense transformed tobacco plants (Nicotiana tabacum cv. Petit Havana) expressing reduced quantities of Rubisco protein were used to examine the role of Rubisco quantity in determining ozone (O₃) sensitivity. Transformed and wild-type plants were exposed to O₃ in the greenhouse and in the field. Stomatal conductance, net photosynthesis and Rubisco protein quantity were measured at various times. Antisense-transformed genotypes responded to O₃ by exhibiting rapid, severe foliar necrosis. The wild-type plants responded more slowly, exhibiting limited injury. Decreases in stomatal conductance, net photosynthesis or Rubisco quantity in plants exposed to O₃ were not observed in asymptomatic leaves. Total biomass was lower for the transformed genotypes and decreased in both genotypes after exposure to O₃. Shoot–root ratio and specific leaf area were higher in the transformed genotypes and increased in both genotypes with exposure to O₃. Measurements of intercellular airspace demonstrated the presence of larger intercellular spaces in the transformed plants. The indirect effects of the rbcS antisense transformation, including morphological changes in the leaf, probably rendered the transformed plants more sensitive to the oxidant. The decreased quantity of Rubisco is not thought to be directly related to increased O₃ sensitivity in the transformed plants.     

Pre-activating wounding response in tobacco prior to high-level ozone exposure prevents necrotic injury

In tobacco, both wounding and treatment with jasmonates prior to exposure of the tissue to high concentrations of ozone (250 to 500 p.p.b.) produce a dramatic decrease in ozone injury. A systemic pattern of increased ozone tolerance developed within 3–6 h after wounding and also after local application of jasmonates. Ozone treatment of transgenie (NahG) tobacco plants showed that the inability of these plants to accumulate salicylic acid is also accompanied by increased ozone tolerance. Expression of mRNA encoding the anti-oxidant enzyme ascorbate peroxidase is upregulated by ozone challenge, wounding and by methyl jasmonate exposure within 3–4 h, while levels of carbonic anhydrase mRNA are simultaneously depressed following ozone exposure and methyl jasmonate treatment. The pattern of these results shows that the response to ozone challenge in tobacco involves signalling mechanisms similar to those induced in plants by other environmental stresses that generate reactive oxygen species.     

A DIGE analysis of developing poplar leaves subjected to ozone reveals major changes in carbon metabolism

Tropospheric ozone pollution is described as having major negative effects on plants, compromising plant survival. Carbon metabolism is especially affected. In the present work, the effects of chronic ozone exposure were evaluated at the proteomic level in developing leaves of young poplar plants exposed to 120 ppb of ozone for 35 days. Soluble proteins (excluding intrinsic membrane proteins) were extracted from leaves after 3, 14 and 35 days of ozone exposure, as well as 10 days after a recovery period. Proteins (pI 4 to 7) were analyzed by 2-D DIGE experiments, followed by MALDI-TOF-TOF identification. Additional observations were obtained on growth, lesion formation, and leaf pigments analysis. Although treated plants showed large necrotic spots and chlorosis in mature leaves, growth decreased only slightly and plant height was not affected. The number of abscised leaves was higher in treated plants, but new leaf formation was not affected. A decrease in chlorophylls and lutein contents was recorded. A large number of proteins involved in carbon metabolism were identified. In particular, proteins associated with the Calvin cycle and electron transport in the chloroplast were down-regulated. In contrast, proteins associated with glucose catabolism increased in response to ozone exposure. Other identified enzymes are associated with protein folding, nitrogen metabolism and oxidoreductase activity.     

Stomatal Closure During Tobacco Leaf Desiccation as Affected by Ozone

The effect of acute ozone exposure on the stomatal conductance and leaf water content during rapid desiccation was examined in leaves of two tobacco cultivars, ozone sensitive cv. BelW3 and ozone tolerant cv. Samsun. The relative rate of stomatal closure was constant during leaf desiccation in cv. Samsun but decreased in cv. BelW3 in both ozonated and control plants. Ozone exposure increased the relative rate of stomatal closure and transpiration rate (measured on the following day) in cv. Samsun, but reduced the respective parameters in cv. BelW3. As a result, the plants of ozone-sensitive cultivar, treated with ozone, lost more water during desiccation than control plants. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Chlorophyll fluorescence assay for ozone injury in intact plants

A chlorophyll fluorescence induction (Kautsky effect) assay predicted ozone-induced injury in bean leaves (Phaseolus vulgaris) at least 20 hours before any visible sign of leaf necrosis. The extent of injury, which could be predicted during exposure to ozone, depended on concentration, exposure time, and leaf development stage. Much more injury occurred in light than in darkness and long exposures to lower ozone concentrations were more injurious than brief exposures to higher ones. The first detectable effect was on the photosynthetic water-splitting enzyme systems, followed by inhibition of electron transport between the photosystems. The fluorescence assay provides a simple, rapid, nondestructive method for observing effects of ozone on plants.     

Stable free radicals in ozone-damaged wheat leaves

Chlorophyll fluorescence measurements were performed on attached leaves of wheat plants (Triticum aestivum L. cv. Nandu) that were exposed to ambient air and to air supplemented with 80 and 120nmol mol^-1 ozone. Decreases in the “current photochemical capacity” were observed that were dependent on both the ozone concentration and duration of exposure. Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectra on freeze-dried samples from the same batches of plants showed the presence of an unidentified stable free radical, whose spectra had similarities to that of the ubisemiquinone radical. The intensity of this radical signal increased with the duration of ozone exposure in leaves that received an additional 120nmol mol^-1 ozone. In contrast, with exposure to air with 80nmol mol^-1 added ozone, there was little if any change in free radical signal intensity over the 4 week period of the experiment. The increase in intensity of the EPR signal occurred later than the chlorophyll fluorescence changes, which suggests that it is associated with permanent leaf damage.     

EVIDENCE FOR THE REPAIR OF OZONE-INDUCED MEMBRANE INJURY

The increase in [¹⁴C]-2-deoxy-D-glucose uptake by leaf discs 24 hr after fumigation was used as a measure of ozone injury to pinto bean leaves (Phaseolus vulgaris). This method showed that the primary leaves were most affected by ozone when plants were 10 to 12 days old, which coincided with the time of maximum leaf necrosis. However, 8-day-old plants, which had no visible leaf injury, still showed a higher uptake rate than controls, indicating that injury occurred at the cellular level. In these younger plants, uptake was shown to return to normal over a 5 day period. Moreover, the rate of this “repair” was retarded by cold or continuous darkness, enhanced by continuous light, and very markedly increased by glucose applied to the leaves. The timing of the glucose application was not critical, nor did H₂O or mannitol have an effect. The results suggest that ozone injury at the cellular level can be repaired by energy-dependent processes so that necrosis of the leaf tissue does not occur. These experiments also show that conditions and treatments after ozone exposure can alter the degree of ozone injury.     

Exposure of cottonwood plants to ozone alters subsequent leaf decomposition

Summary Cottonwood saplings were exposed to ozone or charcoal-filtered air in a closed chamber. After leaf abscission, decomposition of individual leaf discs was measured in containers of stream water. Exposure of plants to 200 ppb ozone for 5 h caused early leaf abscission and changes in the chemical composition of leaves at time of abscission. Early-abscised leaves from O₃-exposed plants had higher nitrogen, but decomposed more slowly than leaves from control plants. Leaves from O₃-exposed plants that abscised at the normal time had lower nitrogen content and lower specific leaf mass than control leaves, but decomposed at the same rate as leaves from control plants. The results imply that O₃ exposure can alter fundamental processes important to the functioning of detritus-based aquatic ecosystems.     

Ozone effects on the ultrastructure of peatland plants: Sphagnum mosses, Vaccinium oxycoccus, Andromeda polifolia and Eriophorum vaginatum

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Ozone effects on peatland vegetation are poorly understood. Since stress responses are often first visible in cell ultrastructure, electron microscopy was used to assess the sensitivity of common peatland plants to elevated ozone concentrations. METHODS: Three moss species (Sphagnum angustifolium, S. magellanicum and S. papillosum), a graminoid (Eriophorum vaginatum) and two dwarf shrubs (Vaccinium oxycoccus and Andromeda polifolia), all growing within an intact canopy on peat monoliths, were exposed to a concentration of 0, 50, 100 or 150 ppb ozone in two separate growth chamber experiments simulating either summer or autumn conditions in central Finland. After a 4- or 5-week-long exposure, samples were photographed in a transmission electron microscope and analysed quantitatively using image processing software. KEY RESULTS: In the chlorophyllose cells of the Sphagnum moss leaves from the capitulum, ozone exposure led to a decrease in chloroplast area and in granum stack thickness and various changes in plastoglobuli and cell wall thickness, depending on the species and the experiment. In E. vaginatum, ozone exposure significantly reduced chloroplast cross-sectional areas and the amount of starch, whereas there were no clear changes in the plastoglobuli. In the dwarf shrubs, ozone induced thickening of the cell wall and an increase in the size of plastoglobuli under summer conditions. In contrast, under autumn conditions the cell wall thickness remained unchanged but ozone exposure led to a transient increase in the chloroplast and starch areas, and in the number and size of plastoglobuli. CONCLUSIONS: Ozone responses in the Sphagnum mosses were comparable to typical ozone stress symptoms of higher plants, and indicated sensitivity especially in S. angustifolium. The responses in the dwarf shrubs suggest stimulation of photosynthesis by low ozone concentrations and ozone sensitivity only under cool autumn conditions.